Hearing Report 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12

I hereby give notice that a hearing by commissioners will be held on:

Date: Tuesday 30 July 2019 Wednesday 31 July 2019 Thursday 01 August 2019 Friday 02 August 2019 Tuesday 06 August 2019 Time: 9.30am Meeting Rooms: Reception Lounge (Days 1 – 4) Level 2 Council Chambers (Day 5) Ground Floor Venue: Auckland Town Hall, 301-303 Queen Street, Auckland

HEARING REPORT 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 TAMAKI DRIVE, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 PATTESON AVENUE, 26, 28 & 30 MARAU CRESCENT, MISSION BAY DRIVE HOLDINGS LIMITED

COMMISSIONERS

Chairperson Janine Bell Commissioners David Mead Michael Parsonson

Larissa Rew HEARINGS ADVISOR

Telephone: 09 980 5216 or 021570675 Email: [email protected] Website: www.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz

Note: The reports contained within this agenda are for consideration and should not be construed as a decision of Council. Should Commissioners require further information relating to any reports, please contact the Team Leader Hearings. 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28 & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay Tuesday 30 July 2019, Wednesday 31 July 2019, Thursday 01 August 2019, Friday 02 August 2019 and Tuesday 06 August 2019 WHAT HAPPENS AT A HEARING At the start of the hearing, the Chairperson will introduce the commissioners and council staff and will briefly outline the procedure. The Chairperson may then call upon the parties present to introduce themselves to the panel. The Chairperson is addressed as Mr Chairman or Madam Chair.

Any party intending to give written or spoken evidence in Māori or speak in sign language should advise the hearings advisor at least five working days before the hearing so that a qualified interpreter can be provided.

Catering is not provided at the hearing. Please note that the hearing may be audio recorded.

Scheduling submitters to be heard

A timetable will be prepared approximately one week before the hearing for all submitters who have returned their hearing attendance form. Please note that during the course of the hearing changing circumstances may mean the proposed timetable is delayed or brought forward. Submitters wishing to be heard are requested to ensure they are available to attend the hearing and present their evidence when required. The hearings advisor will advise submitters of any changes to the timetable at the earliest possible opportunity.

The Hearing Procedure

The usual hearing procedure is: • The applicant will be called upon to present his/her case. The applicant may be represented by legal counsel or consultants and may call witnesses in support of the application. After the applicant has presented his/her case, members of the hearing panel may ask questions to clarify the information presented. • The relevant local board may wish to present comments. These comments do not constitute a submission however the Local Government Act allows the local board to make the interests and preferences of the people in its area known to the hearing panel. If present, the local board will speak between the applicant and any submitters. • Submitters (for and against the application) are then called upon to speak. Submitters may also be represented by legal counsel or consultants and may call witnesses on their behalf. The hearing panel may then question each speaker. The council officer’s report will identify any submissions received outside of the submission period. At the hearing, late submitters may be asked to address the panel on why their submission should be accepted. Late submitters can speak only if the hearing panel accepts the late submission. • Should you wish to present written information (evidence) in support of your application or your submission please ensure you provide the number of copies indicated in the notification letter. • Only members of the hearing panel can ask questions about submissions or evidence. Attendees may suggest questions for the panel to ask but it does not have to ask them. No cross-examination - either by the applicant or by those who have lodged submissions – is permitted at the hearing. • After the applicant and submitters have presented their cases, the chairperson may call upon council officers to comment on any matters of fact or clarification. • When those who have lodged submissions and wish to be heard have completed their presentations, the applicant or his/her representative has the right to summarise the application and reply to matters raised by submitters. Hearing panel members may further question the applicant at this stage. • The chairperson then generally closes the hearing and the applicant, submitters and their representatives leave the room. The hearing panel will then deliberate “in committee” and make its decision. • Decisions are usually available within 15 working days of the hearing.

Page 2 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28 & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay Tuesday 30 July 2019, Wednesday 31 July 2019, Thursday 01 August 2019, Friday 02 August 2019 and Tuesday 06 August 2019

SUBMITTERS: VOLUME ONE Page 23 Desmond Hunt 10 Codrington Crescent Mission Bay Page 24 Robert Bree 88a Kurahaupo Street Orakei Page 27 Gary Paykel 44 Arney Road Remuera Page 28 Anthony Edwin Falkenstein 3 Dudley Rd Mission Bay Page 29 Auckland Planning Limited - Nick Culpan 34 Nihill Crescent Mission Bay Page 104 W.A Henderson 125 Selwyn Avenue Mission Bay Page 105 Jill McCarthy 63 Hawera Road Kohimarama Page 107 Winsome Ruth Matches 1/15 Nihill Crescent Mission Bay Page 109 Jo Thompson 1E/80 Aotea Street Orakei Page 112 Liz Pollard 1/22 Speight Road Kohimarama Page 113 William Edward Galpin 116/207 Riddell Road Glendowie Page 115 Donald & Audrey Coster 2/105 Selwyn Avenue Mission Bay Page 116 Antony Guy Jack Brabant 44 Comins Crescent Mission Bay Page 118 Pam Rudelj Apt 9/9 Marau Cres Mission Bay Page 120 Robyn Ballantyne 96 Selwyn Ave Mission Bay Page 122 Manuel Venegas 9A Cliff Road Auckland Page 124 Lisa Moore-Bocarro 63 Ngaio St Orakei Page 126 Jane Martinovich 37 Marau Cres Mission Bay Page 129 German Fernandez 14 William Fraser Cres St Heliers Page 131 Matthew Nant 121B Selwyn Ave Mission Bay Page 133 Robert Murray 132 Kohimarama Road Kohimarama Page 135 Junette Elizabeth Marylyn Wrathall 4/43 Tamaki Drive Mission Bay Page 137 Anthony Goddard 1/19 Selwyn Avenue Mission Bay Page 139 Georgina Sawyer 89 Rukutai Street Orakei Page 141 Chris Wadsworth PO Box 41071 St Lukes Page 143 Kim Michelle Posner 54 Rosepark Crescent St Johns Page 145 Lucy Duncan 148A Selwyn Avenue Mission Bay Page 147 Hadeel Kadir 1/30 Felton Mathew Ave Saint Johns Page 149 Chris von Batenburg 3A Sprott Rd Kohimarama Page 151 Darren Anderson 44 Smythe Rd Henderson Page 153 Mark Herbstein 17 Kempthorne Crescent Mission Bay Page 155 Mangere Elizabeth Wright 16 Andes Avenue Bridge Page 157 Guy Richardson 10 Cowell Place Onehunga Page 159 Margaret Platt 5/84 Kohimarama Road Kohimarama

Page 3 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28 & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay Tuesday 30 July 2019, Wednesday 31 July 2019, Thursday 01 August 2019, Friday 02 August 2019 and Tuesday 06 August 2019 Page 161 Laura Austin 133 West Tamaki Rd Glen Innes Page 163 Andrea Aragon Echano 2/17 Clarendon Road St Heliers Page 165 Megan Burgess 10B Emily Lane Greenhithe Page 167 Tracey Goldstine 38a Ronaki Road Mission Bay Page 169 Nadia de Blaauw 77a Fancourt St Meadowbank Page 171 Michelle Crooks 72 Sprott Road Kohimarama Page 173 Jarrod Kerr 13a Rukutai Street Orakei Page 175 Suzanne Melville 14 William Fraser Cres St Heliers Page 177 Dale Clements 23 Lisburn Ave Glendowie Page 179 Megan Coates 21 Benbow Street St Heliers Page 181 Debbie MacDonald 2/70 Rukutai Street Orakei Page 183 Lijuan Xu PO Box 133168 Eastridge Page 185 Vanessa Hurt 47 Whitehaven Rd Glendowie Page 187 Christine Helen Johnston 44 Codrington Crescent Mission Bay Page 189 Anthony Hurt 32 Waimarie St St Heliers Page 191 Mary-Clare Brownlie 1/24 Hawera Road Kohimarama Page 193 Stuart Clarke 1/24 Hawera road Auckland Page 195 Ian Deynzer 4 Cullwick Road Mission Bay Page 197 Graham French 46D Rawhitiroa Road Kohimarama Page 199 Gillian Cran 2/29 Atkin Avenue Mission Bay Page 201 Carolyn Jean Harrison 5/5 Brookfield Street St Heliers Page 203 John Grant Borrows 15 Marau Cres Mission Bay Page 205 Robyn Fairley 14A Hartland Ave Glendowie Page 207 Junwei Wu 3 Simmental Crescent Somerville Page 209 Angela Dyer 2/123 Riddell Road Glendowie Page 211 Christine Mary Melvilleo 296 Riddell Road Glendowie Page 213 Sam Lawson G03/3 Bluegrey Ave Stonefields Page 215 Elisabeth Stevens 1/95 St Johns Road St Johns Page 217 Briar Dentice 308/4 Bluegrey Ave Stonefields Page 219 Rex Potter 89 Tephra Boulevard Stonefields Page 221 Jan van Deventer 4/17 Nihill Crescent Mission Bay Page 223 Barb Ross 33 Hampton Drive St Heliers Page 225 Toby Gwilym 17 Gerard Way Meadowbank Page 227 Holly Muller 8b Abbotts Way Remuera Page 229 Sally-Anne Forde 645 Remuera Road Remuera Page 231 David Ballantyne 96 Selwyn Ave Mission Bay Page 233 Jayden Grant 23 Comins Crescent Mission Bay

Page 4 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28 & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay Tuesday 30 July 2019, Wednesday 31 July 2019, Thursday 01 August 2019, Friday 02 August 2019 and Tuesday 06 August 2019 Page 235 Michael Shaw 25 Trojan Crescent New Lynn Page 237 Mango Communications - Ian Benet 2/161 Long Drive St Heliers Page 239 Matthew Connolly Riddell Road Auckland Page 241 Kirsty Dale Cowie 93 Selwyn Avenue Mission Bay Page 243 Catherine Anne Woodley 151b St Heliers Bay Rd St Heliers Page 245 Rodrigo Bottieri 31 Speight Road Kohimarama Page 247 Heather Rogers 9 Beere Place Meadowbank Page 249 Carmen Szeto 15b Melling street Glen Innes Page 251 Thais Bottieri 2/31 Speight Rd Kohimarama Page 253 Rhys Mountfort PO Box 17121 Greenlane Page 255 Shareen Smith 41b Roberta Ave Glendowie Page 257 Laureen De Sa 2/91 Long Drive St Heliers Page 259 Colleen Barbarich 8 Codrington Crescent Mission Bay Page 261 Andrea Armishaw 97 Atkin Avenue Mission Bay Page 263 Raewyn Stone 2B Pukeora Ave Auckland Page 265 Rachael Ferris 255 Kohimarama Road Kohimarama Page 267 David Robert Ferris 255 Kohimarama Rd Kohimarama Page 269 Paul Stanfield 104 Godden Crescent Mission Bay Page 271 Rossella Quaranta 231b Marua Road Mt Wellington Page 273 Elena Lezhneva 77 Atkin Avenue Mission Bay Page 275 Curtis Atkinson 7/32 Coates Ave Orakei Page 277 Samantha Caretti 10 Cotter Avenue Remuera Page 279 Yvonne June Joass 76 Whitehaven Rd Auckland Page 281 Janine McKenna-Woodley 2/113 Rukutai St Orakei Page 283 Ross Porter PO Box 99 887 Newmarket Page 285 Brian Retief 25a Awarua Crescent Orakei Page 287 Selena Armstrong 24 Walmsley Road St Heliers Page 289 Mark Strachan 122 Riddell Road Glendowie Page 291 Elizabeth Robinson 73 Patteson Avenue Mission Bay Page 293 Clementine Gardner 10 Towai Street St Heliers Page 295 Empire Capital Limited c/o - David Boersen Auckland Page 297 Naja Urlich 2/23 Coates Avenue Orakei Page 299 William Pott 52 Upland Road Auckland Page 301 Brett Horsfall 64 Lunn Avenue Mt Wellington Page 303 Elena Arduini 86 Aotea Street Orakei Page 305 Elena Arduini 86 Aotea Street Orakei Page 307 Jing Lu and Xuelin Zhou 64 St Andrews Road Auckland

Page 5 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28 & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay Tuesday 30 July 2019, Wednesday 31 July 2019, Thursday 01 August 2019, Friday 02 August 2019 and Tuesday 06 August 2019 Page 309 John Gerty 4/155 Gillies Ave Epsom Page 311 Kris Bainbridge 696A Te Atatu Road Te Atatu Page 313 Sangeeta Desai 33 Norana Ave Remuera Page 315 Jocelyn Whyte 26 Hopkins Crescent Kohimarama Page 317 Lyn Gillanders 529 Riddell Rd Glendowie Page 319 Michael Christie 2/15 Eltham Road Kohimarama Page 321 Jean Cogle 1/2 Thatcher street Mission Bay Page 323 Jonathan Smith 1/28 Eastglen Road Glen Eden Page 325 Liam McKanny 9 Waitara road St Heliers Page 327 Robert and Diane Strevens 2/35 Selwyn Avenue Mission Bay Page 329 TFRD NZ - Andrew Parsons 2c Nihill Cr Auckland Page 331 35A Truro Road, Rita Hunt Camborne Porirua Page 333 Chris de Lautour 46 Garnet Rd Auckland Page 335 Wai o Taiki Gulina Kubanychbekova 18 Clairville Crescent Bay Page 337 Phil Wheeler 33 Hopkins Crescent Kohimarama Page 339 Annette Mary Moody Eastcliffe Retirement Orakei Village Apt 2f, 80 Aotea Street Page 341 Michael Wanless 20 Barrack Road Mt Wellington Page 343 Dr Karen Jones 78 Grampian Road St Heliers Page 345 Saroch Torthienchai 27A Marau Crescent, Mission Bay Page 347 Peter Haarhaus 46D Godden Crescent Mission Bay Page 349 AJHayes and JMWaite Family Trust - Andrew and Jeanette Hayes 51 Ripon Crescent Meadowbank Page 351 Louise Lusty 14 Granada Place Glendowie Page 353 Chen Jiang 52 Comins Crescent Mission Bay Page 355 Allison Willis 65 Kurahaupo St Orakei Page 357 John Service 54 Codrington Cres Mission Bay Page 359 Grahame and Prue Taylor 125D Tamaki Drive Mission Bay Page 361 Gloria Seaman Saint Johns Auckland Page 363 David King 32 Ganley Terrace Stonefields Page 365 Mattie Aspen Queale 19 Patteson Avenue Mission Bay Page 367 Elisa Norah McLennan 3/117 Selwyn Avenue Mission Bay Page 369 Elsie Margaret McKee 92 Aotea St Orakei Page 371 Shona Carle 15B Paunui St St Heliers Bay Page 373 Rex Frye 8 Ronaki Road Mission Bay Page 375 Alan Garny 7/10 Tagalad Rd Mission Bay

Page 6 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28 & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay Tuesday 30 July 2019, Wednesday 31 July 2019, Thursday 01 August 2019, Friday 02 August 2019 and Tuesday 06 August 2019 Page 377 Yan Jiang 11 Bryant Place Glendowie Page 379 Robert John O'Donnell 6/9 Marau Cres Mission Bay Page 381 Paul Lovrich 139 Shore Road Remuera Page 383 Robyn Hoskins 39 Sayegh St St Heliers Page 385 Oksana Alexeichik Rukutai Street Orakei Page 387 Donald Ian Hope 64 Patteson Road Mission Bay Page 389 Eddye Zhang 79 Selwyn Ave Mission Bay Page 391 Jose Franco 4/217 Tamaki Dr Kohimarama Page 393 Malcolm Ewart 27 Geraldine Place Kohimarama Page 395 Phoebe Sarah Dobson 21 Glover Road St Heliers Page 397 Linda Adams 1/89 Kurahaupo St Orakei VOLUME TWO Page 399 Colleen Halkett 125 c Tamaki Drive Mission Bay Page 401 Colleen Christina Halkett 11/36 Marau Cres Mission Bay Page 403 Rebecca O'Shea 3/15 Nihill Crescent Mission Bay Page 405 Craig Wedge 6 Deborah Hatton Lane Otahuhu Page 407 Kip Marks PO Box 25920 St Heliers Page 409 Apt 51, 184 St Heliers Bay Bruce Anderson Road St Heliers Page 411 Susan Gibbs Trust - Susan Diana Bayly Gibbs 9 Dudley Rd Auckland Page 413 Jennifer Gill 59 Bay Road Glendowie Page 415 Carol Janice Frye 8 Ronaki Rd Mission Bay Page 417 Andrea Young 16 Codrington Crescent Mission Bay Page 419 Benjamin Dallimore 59 Southern Cross Road Kohimarama Page 421 Chris Fairbairn 25 Melanesia Road Kohimarama Page 423 Matt Issolah 20 Palmer Crescent Mission Bay Page 425 Ewen Christie 2/8 Taranaki Road Auckland Page 428 Kaye Moxon 15 Codrington Crescent Auckland Page 430 Catherine Mountfort P.O. Box 125052 St Heliers Page 432 Berthine Bruinsma 10 Warwick Ave Titirangi Page 434 Alan Barraclough 9 Corinth Street Remuera Page 436 Amy Ang 2/4 Dinglebank Rd Mt Wellington Page 438 Warren George Whyte 26 Hopkins Crescent Kohimarama Page 440 Craig McLean Fraser 33 Vale Road St Heliers Page 442 Judith Anne Moresby 89 Selwyn Avenue Mission Bay Page 444 Hans Peter Haarhaus 46D Godden Crescent Mission Bay Page 446 Melissa Murphy 8 Hillview Avenue New Windsor

Page 7 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28 & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay Tuesday 30 July 2019, Wednesday 31 July 2019, Thursday 01 August 2019, Friday 02 August 2019 and Tuesday 06 August 2019 Page 448 Tamba Carleton 9 Kenderdine Road Papatoetoe Page 450 Rachel Karen Mason-Thomas 2 Harvey Place St Heliers Page 452 Nigel Merrett 20 Ronaki Road Mission Bay Page 454 Abigail Elizabeth Milnes 47 Rukutai Street Orakei Page 456 Mau Wah Yung 38B John Rymer Place Kohimarama Page 458 Greg and Carolyn Snell 2/31 Marau Cres Mission Bay Page 465 Chris Burnett 8 Colenso Place Mission Bay Page 467 Karin Galle 17 Kinsale Ave Auckland Page 469 Apt 17 Garden Court, 105 Carole Larraine Hutchinson Tamaki Drive Mission Bay Page 471 Karen Mason 46C Rawhitiroa Road Kohimarama Page 473 David Zander 1/32 Patteson Avenue Mission Bay Wai-o-taiki Page 475 Jane Jackson 4 Inglewood St Bay Page 477 Kay Merrett 20 Ronaki Rd Mission Bay Page 479 William Whitburn P O Box 125182 St Heliers Page 481 Maulik Thakkar 24 Parry St Sandringham Page 483 Dorothea Frances Derrick 11a Cullwick Road Mission Bay Page 485 Jeff Meltzer 46C Rawhitiroa Rd Auckland Page 487 Leanne Lowery P O Box 42010 Orakei Page 489 Nick Rees 17 Codrington Crescent Mission Bay Page 491 Robyn Jane Thorn 4 Marau Crescent Mission Bay Page 493 Kaye Muriel Wilson 12a Melanesia Road Kohimarama Page 495 Annette Delugar 1/18 Walmsley Road Saint Heliers Page 497 Frank Douglas Bryson Thompson PO Box 133260 Eastridge Page 499 Richard B Oliphant P O Box 133.080 Mission Bay Page 501 Margaret E Oliphant P O Box 133.080 Mission Bay Page 503 Danita Nel 2/87 Tautari St Orakei Page 505 Rebekah Williams 26a Rukutai St Orakei Page 507 Mr Murray John Willis 65 Kurahaupo Street Orakei Page 509 Russell John Greenwood 32A Atkin Ave Mission Bay Page 511 Megan Jennings 82A Coates Ave Orakei Page 513 Philip Coop 56 Codrington Crescent Mission Bay Page 517 Susan Mary Wood Hansen 4 Ronaki Road Mission Bay Page 521 George and Alison Clark 31 Piccadilly Place Kohimarama Page 523 Kimberly Englert 1 Cyclarama Crescent Massey Page 525 Elaine de la Rossi 2 / 43 Nihill Crescent Mission Bay Page 527 Gerald Fava 2/29 Tamaki Drive Mission Bay

Page 8 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28 & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay Tuesday 30 July 2019, Wednesday 31 July 2019, Thursday 01 August 2019, Friday 02 August 2019 and Tuesday 06 August 2019 Page 529 David Chambers 1/88 Coates Ave Orakei Page 531 Lorraine Anne Seaton 2/12 Piccadilly Place Kohimarama Page 533 Vicky Young 35a, Riddell Road, Glendowie Page 535 Michael Wood 13 Paddington St Glen Innes Page 537 Barbara Foreman 39 The Parade Auckland Page 539 David Cattrall PO Box 25-413 St Heliers Page 541 Jennifer A Rowe 56 Codrington Crescent Mission Bay Page 547 Neil Prestwood 101 Atkin Ave Mission Bay Page 549 Joanne Eldrett 10 Cullwick Road Mission Bay Page 551 Melinda Nolan 12 Bongard Rd Mission Bay Page 553 David and Judith Sheary 1/29 Tamaki Drive Mission Bay Page 555 Di Holland 46 Comins crescent Mission Bay Page 557 Jane Carmichael 201 Riddell Rd Auckland Page 559 Naumai Hughes 11b Te Arawa St Orakei Page 561 Anne Martin 14 Melanesia Rd Kohimarama Page 563 Gared Thomas PO Box 133 1213 Eastridge Page 567 Generation Zero - Malcolm McCracken 35 Tahuhu Road Mt Wellington Page 569 Chris Kinley 125a Long Drive St Heliers Page 571 Daria Murray 132 Kohimarama Road Kohimarama Page 573 Michael Chambers 18/160 Kepa Road Orakei Page 575 Edward Plunkett 16 Tagalad Road Mission Bay Page 577 Richard Thomas Steel 52 Castleton Drive Howick Page 580 Julian Kennedy Mumford 54 Sprott Road Kohimarama Page 582 Yun du 9 Atkin Ave Mission Bay Tech Futures Lab future Masters 35 Liley Place Auckland Page 584 Student - Richard Hugh Cave Page 586 Dinko Martinovich 7 Anne Street Devonport Page 590 Judith Moresby 89 Selwyn Avenue Mission Bay Page 592 Simon and Bridget Tompkins PO Box 55273 Eastridge Page 594 Marcelo Alberto Lardies 61 Meadowbank road Meadowbank Page 596 Ernesto Henriod PO Box 25008 St Heliers Page 598 Rowena Bird 2/20 Patteson Ave Mission Bay Page 600 Ramon Lewis Apart 9i, 156 Vincent St Auckland CBD Page 602 Robert Kohler 110 Coates Avenue Orakei Page 604 Colleen Gene Behrens 14/1-5 Tamaki drive Mission Bay Page 606 Gay Scaniglia 1/13 Speight Road Kohimarama Page 608 Rex Maitland Findlay PO Box 25234 St Heliers Page 610 Ivan Martinovich 37B Marau Cresent Auckland

Page 9 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28 & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay Tuesday 30 July 2019, Wednesday 31 July 2019, Thursday 01 August 2019, Friday 02 August 2019 and Tuesday 06 August 2019 Page 614 Quantock Trust - Desmond and Yukiko 10 Codrington Crescent Mission Bay Hunt Page 616 Marian Beryl Vercoe 17A Goddem Cres Mission Bay Page 618 Victor Manuel Scaniglia 1/13 Speight Road. Kohimarama Page 620 Paul Malcolm Gillard and Anne-Marie Gillard 70 Atkin Avenue Mission Bay Page 622 Rosemary Thomas P O Box 25055 St Heliers Page 624 John Duncan 148A Selwyn Avenue Mission Bay Page 626 Sven Derek Hansen 4 Ronaki Road Mission Bay Page 628 Judy Ranelle Skyrme 104 Atkin Ave Mission Bay Page 630 Blu Steven P.O. Box 9744 Newmarket Page 632 Susan Bowkett 77 Selwyn Ave Mission Bay Page 634 Kenneth Trevor Penniall and Roma 33A Marau Crescent Mission Bay Beatrice Penniall Page 636 Kim Ileene Crow 37C Marau Crescent Mission Bay Page 639 Fairfax Moresby 89 Selwyn Ave Mission Bay Page 645 Joanne Henderson 22 Cullwick Road Mission Bay Page 647 Ralph Lyle Thompson 22 Cullwick Road Mission Bay Page 649 Pippa Styles 4/3 Towai St Auckland Page 651 Sheryl Doonan 291C Tamaki Drive Kohimarama Page 653 Residential Maintenance Services - Eileen Audrey Harris 16 Allum St Kohimarama Page 655 Jane Smart 19b Godden Crescent Mission Bay Page 657 Charles Robert Hadfield 2 Pembroke Crescent Glendowie Page 659 John and Jillian Hickey 2/32 Marau Crescent Mission Bay Page 661 Samantha Jane Becker 57 Rukutai Street Orakei Page 663 Katherine Peat #2-9 Eltham Road Kohimarama Page 665 Lee Clifford 132A Selwyn Avenue Mission Bay Page 667 Felicity Buche 66a Ashby Avenue St Heliers Page 669 Stuart Murphy 8 Hillview Ave New Windsor Page 671 Roy Hawkins 42 Polygon Rd St Heliers Page 673 Don Liggins 51 Atkin Ave Mission Bay Page 675 Adam Hutchinson 25C Eltham Road Kohimarama Page 677 Murray Scott 22 Sayegh St St Heliers Page 679 Support Mission Bay Incorporated PO 106215 Auckland CBD Page 688 Jan Martin 84 Patteson Ave Mission Bay Page 690 Judith Melanie Simpson 16 Rukutai Street Mission Bay Page 692 Spark - Matt Cole 1205/145 Nelson Street Auckland Page 694 Thomas Alan Ryan 2/39A Marau Cres. Mission Bay

Page 10 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28 & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay Tuesday 30 July 2019, Wednesday 31 July 2019, Thursday 01 August 2019, Friday 02 August 2019 and Tuesday 06 August 2019 Page 696 Kaylene Anne Subritzky P O Box 55209 Mission Bay Page 698 Neil Hawkes 14/171 Tamaki Drive Kohimarama Page 700 Warwick and Julie Lewis 4-27 Holgate Road Auckland Page 704 Stephanie Mary Thompson 161 Kohimarama Rd Kohimarama Page 706 Jon Frank Trust - Leslie Peter and Claire Ginette Bruell 36 Auckland Rd St Heliers Page 708 John Gilbert Beckett 9F Taranaki Road Kohimarama Page 711 Solita Ann Lincoln 98A Atkin Avenue Mission Bay Page 713 Robert Everitt P O Box 87070 Meadowbank Page 715 Ecoshield - John Walker 5 Palmer Crescent Mission Bay Page 717 Anne Tinson 57 Pembroke Crescent Glendowie Page 719 Leslee Sinton 87 Kurahaupo St Orakei Page 721 Jane Allen 14 Rukutai Street Orakei Page 723 Philip John Norman 3/37 Tamaki Drive Mission Bay Page 725 Karen Ann Del 55 Coates Ave Orakei Page 727 Wendy Laraman PO Box 133365 Mission Bay Page 729 Eric Simpson G3 217 Kupe Street Orakei Page 731 Peter Kurz 17 Ronaki Rd Mission Bay Page 733 Karen O'Connell 2 Karori Cres Orakei Page 735 Raewyn Bennet 35a Allum Street Auckland Page 737 Harley Ogier 47b Rukutai Street Orakei Page 739 Jacqueline Whalley 47B Rukutai Street Orakei Page 741 Christine Olsen 20 Cullwick Road Mission Bay Page 743 Chris de Lautour 46 Garnet Rd Auckland Page 745 Margaret Armstrong Baker P.O.Box 55-029 Eastridge Page 747 Sharmian Firth 34 Ngake St. Orakei Page 749 Prudence Gay and Christopher Ross 3 Allum Street Kohimarama McConnell Page 751 Rowan Mark Carroll 40 Waimarie Street St Heliers Page 753 Strevens Services Ltd - Walter John 43 Arney Rd Remuera Strevens Page 755 Strand Management Ltd - Barry and 58 Allum St Auckland Rosemary Wallace Page 757 Teresa Mary Davies PO Box 25 262 St Heliers Page 759 Margaret Neill 11 Dudley Rd Mission Bay Page 761 Virginia Reeves 38 Speight Road Kohimarama Page 763 Hilary Mitchell 19 Holgate Road Kohimarama Page 765 Stephen Moore 14c Edmund St St Heliers Page 767 Gerald Avon Davies PO Box 25 262 St Heliers

Page 11 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28 & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay Tuesday 30 July 2019, Wednesday 31 July 2019, Thursday 01 August 2019, Friday 02 August 2019 and Tuesday 06 August 2019 Page 769 Mrs. Deborah Wallis 112 Selwyn Ave Mission Bay Page 771 Barbara Jane Furley 1/26 Patteson Avenue Mission Bay Page 773 Maurice Addy 2/20 Patterson Ave Mission Bay Page 775 Jamie Simmonds 15 Balmoral Road Epsom Page 777 Andrea Geary 83A Kurahaupo Street Orakei Page 779 Annette Faigan 41 Awarua Crescent Orakei Page 781 Janet Vanderwee 37 Grampian Road St Heliers Page 783 Ellen Giles 55 Whytehead Crescent Auckland Page 785 Wendy Norman 3/37 Tamaki Drive Mission Bay Page 787 Dianne Whiteacre 125a Tamaki Drive Mission Bay Page 789 Marina Sunde 3/ 289 Tamaki Drive Kohimarama Page 791 Christine Malaghan 3/29 Tamaki Drive Mission Bay Page 793 Jolene Harrison 60 Divich Ave Te Atatu South Page 795 Elizabeth Eva Collins PO Box 133190 Mission Bay Page 797 Susan Nementzik 6 Sylvia Rd St Heliers Apartment 3 / 29 Tamaki Page 799 Neil Malaghan Drive Mission Bay Page 801 Brian McKay 4/14 Regent St Papatoetoe Page 803 Augusta Amadio 34A Nihill Crescent Mission Bay Page 808 Andrew Edward Reeves 34A Nihill Crescent Mission Bay Page 813 Emma Instone 68 Bay Road Glendowie Page 815 Peter Richard Morton 20 Ashby Ave St Heliers Page 817 David George Whalley 7 Pukenamu Road Rainbow Point Taupo Page 819 John Wardle 74 Melanesia Rd St Heliers Page 821 Teresa Mary Porter 27A Rangitoto Ave Remuera Page 823 Erika Whittome 105 Kupe St Orakei VOLUME THREE Page 827 Matthew Duder 9 Melanesia Rd Kohimarama Page 829 Ian Stewart Morton 59a Melanesia Road Auckland Page 831 Julie Morrison 2/29 Geraldine Place Kohimarama Page 833 Ross Taylor 17 Baddeley Ave Kohimarama Page 835 Peter and Leah Ashton 11 Penrhyn Rd. Mt Eden Page 839 Valerie Robinson 2/137 Tamaki Drive Mission Bay Page 841 Keith George Savory 39 Waimarie St St Heliers Page 843 Michael Peter Joseph 13 Ronaki Road Mission Bay Page 852 Greig Staples 8A Howard Hunter Ave Saint Johns Page 854 Abraham Breetvelt 6/32 Marau Cres Mission Bay

Page 12 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28 & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay Tuesday 30 July 2019, Wednesday 31 July 2019, Thursday 01 August 2019, Friday 02 August 2019 and Tuesday 06 August 2019 Page 856 Wendy Brown 4/35 Marau Crescent Mission Bay Page 858 Maureen Letitia Fletcher 7 Sayegh Street St Heliers Bay Page 860 Naresh Singhal 4/164 St Heliers Bay Rd St Heliers Page 862 Richard Charles Oddy 45 Tarawera Tce St Heliers Page 864 James Johnston 121A Kohimarama Rd Kohimarama Page 866 Louise Elizabeth Northorpe 11 Tautari Street Orakei Page 868 Cherie Cook 47B Nihill Crescent Mission Bay Page 870 Ronald Colin William Hamilton 32b John Rymer Place Kohimarama Page 872 Peter Terence Garner 40 Nihill Cres Mission Bay Page 874 Linda Jean Hall 1 Hopkins Crescent Auckland Page 876 Alison Stenberg 17 Allum Street Kohimarama Page 878 Christine J Malaghan 3/29 Tamaki Drive Mission Bay Page 880 Rene Koome 20 Rautara Street Orakei Page 882 Howard James Small 11 Hawera Rd Kohimarama Page 884 Fiona Mackinnon 1/29 Selwyn Avenue Mission Bay Page 886 Beverley Caroline Verdon 20/105 Tamaki Drive Mission Bay Page 888 Geraldine Simian 35 Nihill Crescent Mission Bay Page 890 Anne Raeburn Willetts Garden Court, Apartment Mission Bay 18, 105 Tamaki Drive Page 892 William Francis Carlin 11 Robley Crescent Auckland Page 894 Alena Molina 105 Patteson Avenue Mission Bay Page 896 Lee Picot 33 Devore St St Heliers Page 898 D A Hopper 50B The Parade Auckland Page 900 Carol James PO Box 55031 Eastridge Page 902 Kathleen Evelyn Mary Ward 30A Jefferson Street Glendowie Page 904 Sue Wilcock 57 Nihill Crescent Mission Bay Page 906 Ian Lester Stenberg 17 Allum Street Kohimarama Page 908 Iain Campbell 1/1 Walmsley Road St Heliers Page 910 Dean Ashley Crow 37C Marau Crescent Mission Bay Page 912 Christine O Arlington 8/36 Marau Crescent Mission Bay Page 914 Mary Craig 111 Kohimarama Road Auckland Page 916 Graeme Frank Reeves 38 Speight Road Kohimarama Page 918 Juliet Yates MNZM 11 Berowald Place St Heliers Page 920 Megan Hirst 6/26 Patteson Ave Mission Bay Page 922 Noel Thompson 14 Codrington Crescent Mission Bay Page 924 Jackie Greenwood 32A Atkin Avenue Mission Bay Page 926 Don and Wendy Stock 12A Ronaki Rd Mission Bay Page 933 Michael Tomlinson 30 Auckland Road St Heliers

Page 13 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28 & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay Tuesday 30 July 2019, Wednesday 31 July 2019, Thursday 01 August 2019, Friday 02 August 2019 and Tuesday 06 August 2019 Page 935 Simon Luke Moriarty 101 Selwyn Avenue Mission Bay Page 937 David Bower PO Box 25141 St Heliers Page 939 Celia Coster 25 Selwyn Avenue Mission Bay Page 941 Gordon Whiteacre 125A Tamaki Drive Mission Bay Page 943 Shona Carol Brown 35 Comins Crescent Mission Bay Page 945 Kate Morgan-Rees 135 Selwyn Avenue Mission Bay Page 947 Philip Henley 81 Godden Cres Auckland Page 949 Hilary Ann Rayner 57 Rukutai Street Orakei Page 951 Mark Vanderwee 37 Grampian Road St Heliers Page 953 Mark Goldstine 38a Ronaki Rd Mission Bay Page 955 Lee Murray 14 Siota Crescent Kohimarama Page 957 Murray Thomas Lockhart and Robyn Patricia Lockhart 29 Marau Crescent Mission Bay Page 959 Nicola Sharyn Baillie 120 Allum St Kohimarama Page 961 Jeanette Thorne 88 Te Kawa Rd Greenlane Page 963 Mervyn and Madelene Strong 7 Palmer Crescent Mission Bay Page 965 Raiza and Stephen Hughes 1/24A Ronaki Road Mission Bay Page 967 Kate Price 7 Cullwick Road Mission Bay Page 969 Carolyn Fougere 6/10 Tagalad Road Mission Bay Page 971 Lucinda Mary Smith P O Box 26897 Remuera Page 973 Christoph Drefers 72 Kohimarama Road Kohimarama Page 975 Neal Lambess Baden Prebble 1/41A Ronaki Road Mission Bay Page 977 Robyn Campbell 7 Rutherford Tce Meadowbank Page 979 Leanne Tattle 97 Rukutai Street Orakei Page 981 Ormond Hall Trusts 1 &2 - Michael Charles Mackenzie Howat 3/36 Marau Crescent Mission Bay Page 983 Mark Timmins 97 Rukutai Street Orakei Page 985 Resident in Orakei - Beverley Anne Goodwin 77 Kurahaupo St Orakei Page 987 Stewart Selwyn Ferguson 18 Ronaki Road Mission Bay Page 989 David Barratt-Boyes 4/171 Tamaki Drive Kohimarama Page 991 Yukari Prebble 1/41A Roanki Road Mission Bay Page 993 Edward Cran 4/3 Towai Street St Heliers Page 995 Gillian Cran 2/29 Atkin Avenue Auckland Page 997 Walter Hart 24 Siota Crescent Kohimarama Page 999 Paul Martin Maskell PO Box 276-069 Manukau City Page 1001 Dave McCrorie 29 Comins Crescent Mission Bay Page 1003 Colin Stephen De Freyne 5 Nihill Crescent Mission Bay

Page 14 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28 & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay Tuesday 30 July 2019, Wednesday 31 July 2019, Thursday 01 August 2019, Friday 02 August 2019 and Tuesday 06 August 2019 Page 1005 Barrister - Anna Nathan care of James PO Box 25-160 Wellington Gardner-Hopkins Page 1011 Roy Bishop 1 / 40 Polygon Rd St. Heliers Page 1013 Helen Stroude Duder 3/19 Selwyn Ave Mission Bay Page 1015 Ivana Goljerova 124b Kohimarama Road Kohimarama Page 1017 Elizabeth Young PO Box 28663 Remuera Page 1019 Rajesh Jeram 10a Ronaki Rd Mission Bay Page 1021 Joanna Boileau 32 Hawera Rd Kohimarama Page 1023 Aruna Jeram 5 Marau Cresent Mission Bay Page 1025 Stephen Sampson 2/ 33 Ronaki Road Auckland Page 1027 Sheryl Anne Beange 15 Tarawera Tce St Heliers Page 1029 John Wilkinson 11 Cheverton Place Kohimarama Page 1031 Peter George Dormon 35a, Riddell Road Glendowie Page 1033 Karen Munro 3/87 Selwyn Avenue Mission Bay Page 1035 Winton Jones 20a Siota Cres Kohimarama Page 1037 Mission Bay Kohimarama Residents P O Box 3320 Shortland St, Association Inc - Gill Chappell (Vulcan Auckland Building Chambers) Page 1046 Lorna Stansfield 335 Tamaki Drive St Heliers Page 1048 Neil Brabant 7 Speight Rd Kohimarama Page 1050 Maria de los Angeles Rodriguez 29 Comins Crescent Mission Bay Gonzalez Page 1052 Peter Williamson 1/103 Tamaki Dr Mission Bay Page 1054 The Stephen Owen Family Trust - Craig Russell McVeagh, Level Auckland Brockliss 30, Vero Centre, 48 Central Shortland Street Page 1062 Julie Thompson 14 Codrington Crescent Mission Bay Page 1064 Sara LaBrooy 10a Long Drive St Heliers Page 1066 9 Reihana Street Orakei Kenneth Palmer - [committee member Tamaki Drive Protection Society] Page 1078 Technology & Security Solutions Ltd- PO Box 25-813 St Heliers Bay Lucia Loy Page 1080 Pamela Eve Hayward 6 Long Drive St Heliers Page 1082 Rita Fay Radley (c/o – Helen Andrews, 34 Ronaki Road Mission Bay Berry Simons Page 1088 John Harper 80 Atkin Ave Mission Bay Page 1090 John Moyes 181 Tamaki Drive Kohimarama Page 1092 John Verdon 20/105 Tamaki Drive Mission Bay Page 1094 Vicki Ohms 87A Selwyn Avenue Auckland Page 1096 Howard Roger Hill 10 Kirkmay Place St Heliers

Page 15 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28 & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay Tuesday 30 July 2019, Wednesday 31 July 2019, Thursday 01 August 2019, Friday 02 August 2019 and Tuesday 06 August 2019 Page 1098 Petal and Dave Moran PO Box 42 020 Orakei Page 1100 Andrew Portman 4/121 Riddell Road Glendowie Page 1103 Susan Riddell PO Box 55144 Eastridge Page 1105 Annabel Goodson PO Box 133137 Eastridge Page 1107 Dave Foreman 39 The Parade Auckland Page 1109 K W Bywater 6/14 Marau Cres Mission Bay Page 1111 Dongluo Jiang and Li Guo 52 Comins Crescent Mission Bay Page 1113 Mrs. Christine Mercia Savory 39 Waimarie Street St Heliers Page 1115 Sarah Clayton 15a Dudley Road Mission Bay Page 1117 Brian Keith Clayton 15A Dudley Road Mission Bay Page 1119 Elizabeth Sampson 2/33 Ronaki Road Auckland Page 1121 Lisa McMillan 1/70 Rukutai Street Orakei Page 1123 Bronwen Ray Arlington 8 / 12 Pukerangi Crescent Ellerslie Page 1125 Raewyn Johnson 45 Selwyn Avenue Auckland Page 1127 Richard Bruce Allen 14 Rukutai Street Orakei Page 1129 Michael James Walsh - St 3 Dingle Road St Heliers Heliers/Glendowie Residents Association Page 1133 Michael James Walsh 3 Dingle Road St Heliers

Page 1135 David E J Williams 6 Ronakai Road Mission Bay Page 1137 Andrew Brown 4/35 Marau Cres Mission Bay Page 1139 Joyce Mary Frances Austin 120 Allum Street Kohimarama Page 1141 Anna Spreys 3/103 Tamaki Drive Auckland Page 1143 Bruce Sai Louie 4-34 Marau Cres Auckland Page 1145 John N McCallum 27 Selwyn Avenue Mission Bay Page 1148 John Coutts 59 Te Arawa Street Orakei Page 1153 Henrietta Wilkinson 11 Cheverton Place Kohimarama Page 1155 Rebecca Wu 2/99 Aotea Street Orakei Page 1157 Annette and Vidas Petraska 32a Melanesia Road Kohimarama Page 1159 Mihiri Abeysundara 72 Atkin Avenue Mission Bay Page 1161 Dianne Burgham 57 Te Arawa Street Orakei Page 1163 Mike Booth 28 Palmer Crescent Mission Bay Page 1165 Peter Murray Whyte PO Box 12772 Penrose Page 1167 Alice Skidmore 11 Nihill Cres Mission Bay Page 1169 Victoria Fulford 7 Melanesia Road Kohimarama Page 1171 Dean Fulford 7 Melanesia Road Kohimarama Page 1173 Talia Pua 103 Patteson Ave Mission Bay

Page 16 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28 & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay Tuesday 30 July 2019, Wednesday 31 July 2019, Thursday 01 August 2019, Friday 02 August 2019 and Tuesday 06 August 2019 Page 1175 Julie Zou 15A Utting Street Birkdale Page 1177 Geoffrey Edwin Faithfull 103 Aotea St Mission Bay Page 1179 Kenneth Leroy Norton PO Box 25904 St Heliers Page 1181 Via Kennedy 2 Gorgonzola Wendy Piemonte Milan 2006 Page 1183 Karin Speight 42b Rarangi Road St Heliers Page 1185 Nicola Jill Tollemache 2/10 Tagalad Rd Mission Bay Page 1187 Terry James Gibson 25 Marau Crescent Mission Bay Page 1189 Jill Hadfield 2 Pembroke Crescent Glendowie Page 1191 Jennie Field 1C Thatcher St Mission Bay Page 1193 Jane Boyd and Frank Barrow PO Box 42-144 Orakei Page 1195 David Michael Crown 16 Rukutai Street Mission Bay Page 1197 Robert Paque Benton 32B Rawhitiroa Rd Kohimarama Page 1199 Janne Margaret Pender 43 Bell Road Remuera Page 1201 Hannah Andrew 16 Park Hill Road Birkenhead Page 1203 Abigail Marshall 31A Baddeley Avenue Kohimarama Page 1205 Barbara Joan Poole 4/59 St. Heliers Bay Road St. Heliers Page 1207 Callum Thorpe 31A Baddeley Avenue Kohimarama Page 1209 Michele Jane Williams 59A Melanesia Rd Kohimarama Page 1211 Martin and Diana Sweetapple 3/37 Patteson Ave Mission Bay Page 1213 Mary Pope 2/36 Nihill Cres Mission Bay Page 1215 Catherine Mackenzie 100 Kohimarama Road Auckland Page 1217 Paul Mackenzie 100 Kohimarama Road Auckland Page 1219 Chris and Trish Ward 16 Alfriston Road Manurewa Page 1221 Frederick Ross Duder 3/19 Selwyn Avenue Mission Bay Page 1223 Graham Trevor Mathieson 97 Melanesia Road St Heliers Page 1225 Paul Wood P O Box 55110 Eastridge Mission Bay Page 1227 Adrian David Hynds 30 Selwyn Avenue Mission Bay VOLUME FOUR Page 1229 Joo Boon Phua 103 Patteson Avenue Mission Bay Page 1231 Mary Lynne Scott 3D/18 Cranbrook Place Glendowie Page 1233 John Pearce 276A Victoria Avenue Remuera Page 1235 Robyn Bridget Hynds 30 Selwyn Avenue Mission Bay Page 1237 William Anthony Caughey and Shona E 125B Tamaki Drive Mission Bay R Caughey Page 1241 Jana Wood 34A Hawera Road Auckland Page 1243 David E J Williams 6 Ronaki Rd Mission Bay Page 1245 Elwyn Firth 34 Ngake Street Orakei

Page 17 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28 & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay Tuesday 30 July 2019, Wednesday 31 July 2019, Thursday 01 August 2019, Friday 02 August 2019 and Tuesday 06 August 2019 Page 1247 Nicholas Payton 15 Norman Lesser Dr St Johns Page 1255 Laurel Teklich 13 Godden Cres Orakei Page 1257 Stuart Mackie 97 Atkin Avenue Auckland Page 1259 Louise Mary Davie 13 The Parade St Heliers Page 1261 Felicity Anne McCardle PO Box 133105 Mission Bay Page 1263 Angelika and Thomas Klotz 7 Nihill Crescent Mission Bay Page 1265 Hewitson Hayes Consulting - Mel 7 Codrington Crescent Mission Bay Hewitson Page 1267 Darren Jonathan Sharpe 18 Melanesia Road Kohimarama Page 1269 Peter Moses PO Box 106 419 Auckland Page 1275 Oliver Hay 9/33 Royal Terrace Sandringham Page 1277 Jeff Robertson 20 Whytehead Cres St Heliers Page 1280 Leith Alix Margaret Hamilton 32b John Rymer Place Kohimarama Page 1282 Trevor Alfred Goldschmidt 27 Marau Crescent Mission Bay Page 1284 Janet B McCallum 27 Selwyn Ave Mission Bay Page 1286 Lynn Plom PO Box 25578 St Heliers Page 1288 Kathleen Glass PO Box 25027 St Heliers Page 1290 L Julinda Simons PO Box 74604 Market Rd Greenlane Page 1292 Jane Lucinda Williams 15 Sage Road Kohimarama Page 1294 Douglas Kirby 99 Selwyn Avenue Auckland Page 1296 Sam Chow P O Box 5247 Auckland 1141 Page 1298 Yaqing Li 8a Ronaki Rd Mission Bay Page 1300 Martin Plom 5 Maheke Street St Heliers Page 1302 Paulette Benton-Greig 4/20 Patteson Ave Mission Bay Page 1305 Lyn Walker 17B Rukutai Street Orakei Page 1307 Matija Mira Lovrich and Marin Frank 16 Ronaki Rd Mission Bay Lovrich Page 1309 Peter Riddell 98 Selwyn Avenue Mission Bay Page 1311 Malcolm Walker 17B Rukutai St Orakei Page 1313 William Harrison Furley 73 Glengarry Rd Glen Eden Page 1315 Nicole Paula Pfeifhofer 73 Glengarry Rd Glen Eden Page 1317 Julie C Robson - Julie Robson Consulting 170 St Heliers Bay Road Auckland

Page 1319 Angela Robinson 2/39 Hawera Rd Kohimarama Page 1321 Samuel Goldstine Mission Bay Auckland Page 1323 Mark O'Connell 2 Karori Crescent Orakei Page 1328 Felicity Berry 2/26 Patteson Ave Auckland Page 1330 Roger Seaton 2/12 Piccadilly Place Kohimarama Page 1332 Jillian Ruth Brewis 39 Polygon Road St Heliers

Page 18 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28 & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay Tuesday 30 July 2019, Wednesday 31 July 2019, Thursday 01 August 2019, Friday 02 August 2019 and Tuesday 06 August 2019 Page 1334 Iyanthi Wijayanayake 287A Kepa Road Mission Bay Page 1336 Monica Tattersall 5/36 Marau Crescent Mission Bay Page 1338 Nick Brightwell Atkin Avenue 31, Flat 1 Auckland Page 1340 John Gilbert Beckett 9F Taranaki Road Kohimarama Page 1343 Jim Arnold 3/12 Marau Crescent Mission Bay Page 1345 Paul Robinson 2/39 Hawera Rd Kohimarama Page 1347 Michael Barrie Swift 2/217 Tamaki Drive Kohimarama Page 1349 PO BOX 55071 Eastridge Mission Bay Tennis Club - Huw Beynon Page 1351 Carol Margaret Archie 1/4 Taranaki Road Kohimarama Page 1353 Emeritus Professor Michael Gedye 87A Selwyn Avenue Mission Bay Page 1355 Ian Hall 2 Athol Place Auckland Page 1357 Kicki Hall 2 Athol Place St Heliers Page 1359 April Glenday 53 Prospect Tce Mt Eden Page 1361 Rachel Goldstine 38A Ronaki Road Mission Bay Page 1363 Patricia Ann Bonney 12 Ronaki Rd Mission Bay Page 1365 Jacqueline Francis Everett 2/209 Tamaki Drive Kohimarama Page 1367 Meadowbank and St Johns Residents 48A Meadowbank Road Auckland Association - Tim Duguid Page 1369 Tema Pua 103 Patteson Ave Mission Bay Page 1371 Greg Mikkelsen 106 Long Drive St Heliers Page 1373 Maren Ariane Kracke PO Box 25-022 St Heliers Page 1375 Maryann Hope 90B Kohimarama Rd Auckland Page 1377 Dennis Millard 1-1 Rarangi Rd St Heliers Page 1379 Annette Short c/o Gold Girls 55c Atkin Ave Mission Bay Page 1381 Jacque Lloyd 37 Piccadilly Place Kohimarama Page 1383 Miles Cain 98 Allum St Kohimarama Page 1385 Ronald Macmillan Craig PO Box 47830 Ponsonby Page 1387 Stefano La Cava 90 Aotea St Orakei Page 1389 St Heliers & Glendowie Residents PO Box 25 225 St Heliers Association - Guy King Page 1391 Elizabeth Motion 18B Nihill Crescent Mission Bay Page 1393 Wendy Walker 9 Cullwick Road Mission Bay Page 1395 Harold Frederick Short 55C Atkin Ave Mission Bay Page 1397 Matthew Buer 15B McArthur Avenue St Heliers Page 1399 Lesley Cork 22A West Tamaki Road St Heliers Page 1402 Bruce Harland 90 Rukutai Street Mission Bay Page 1404 Adult Literacy Tamaki Auckland Inc - 25 Mayfair Place Glen Innes Pete Davis

Page 19 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28 & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay Tuesday 30 July 2019, Wednesday 31 July 2019, Thursday 01 August 2019, Friday 02 August 2019 and Tuesday 06 August 2019 Page 1406 Linda Jane Fletcher 39 Dudley Road Mission Bay Page 1408 Colin Douglas Church 24 Dudley Road Mission Bay Page 1410 Kerryanne Tisdall 41 Codrington Crescent Auckland Page 1412 Philip Yock 2/42 Reihana Street Orakei Page 1414 Martina Bohm 10c Holgate Rd Kohimarama Page 1416 Gavin McCardle 3/41A Ronaki Rd Mission Bay Page 1418 Graeme Clark 14 Burrows Avenue Parnell Page 1420 Hazel Mignonne Lanyon 1F /82 Aotea Street Orakei Page 1422 Susan Diana Sim 77A Patteson Avenue Mission Bay Page 1424 Dean Buchanan 35A Rawhitiroa Road Kohimarama Page 1426 Urban Legacy and Partners Limited Level 2, 103 Carlton Gore Newmarket Rd Page 1428 Diana Kassabova 47/c Nihill Cres Mission Bay Page 1430 Raewyn Johnson 45 Selwyn avenue Auckland Page 1432 Henry Leung 12A Cullwick Road Mission Bay Page 1434 Jennifer Duder 9 Melanesia Road Kohimarama Page 1436 Maurice Prendergast 3/35 Marau Cres Mission Bay Page 1438 Kerry Prendergast 3/35 Marau Cres Mission Bay Page 1440 Barbara Kay Clephane 56 Clonbern Road Remuera Page 1442 Jean Lewis 45 Lammermoor Drive St Heliers Bay Page 1444 Diane Robinson Po Box 42067 Orakei Page 1446 Sally Wallis 3/37 Tarawera Terrace St Heliers Page 1448 Anthony Gates Villa 8, Summerset at Mt Wellington Heritage Park, 8 Harrison Road Page 1450 Karen Chretien 22 Bay Road St Heliers Page 1452 John Kenneth MacRae and Julie 78 Selwyn Avenue Mission Bay Elizabeth Kennedy Page 1454 Penelope Jane Coman 19 Palmer Crescent Mission Bay Page 1456 Richard John Leckinger 1/191 Park Road Grafton Page 1459 Allan and Lesa McGilvray 17 Holgate Road Kohimarama Page 1461 Douglas and Denise Edwards 66A Rukutai St Orakei Page 1463 Fleur Heather Nixon 101B Rukutai St Orakei Page 1465 ApiNZ - Jude Earles 73 Melanesai Road Kohimarama Page 1467 Dawn O'Connell-Pfahlert 43 Hanene St St Heliers Page 1469 Joanne Hutchinson 3/101 Kohimarama Road Kohimarama Page 1471 Gillian Clark 41B Selwyn Ave Mission Bay Page 1473 Emma Treadwell 41B Selwyn Ave Mission Bay Page 1475 John Cutler 10 Sage Road Kohimarama

Page 20 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28 & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay Tuesday 30 July 2019, Wednesday 31 July 2019, Thursday 01 August 2019, Friday 02 August 2019 and Tuesday 06 August 2019 Page 1477 Stewart Paul Hawkins 75 Vale Road St Heliers Page 1479 Tony and Sue Knighting 83a Selwyn Avenue Auckland Page 1481 Christine Carroll 40 St Heliers Bay Rd St Heliers Page 1483 Caroline Louise Shepherd 75 Vale Road St Heliers Page 1485 Richard A Mann 38B Atkin Avenue Mission Bay Page 1487 Lisa Martin 14 Melanesia Rd Kohimarama Page 1489 Michael Lawrie 80 Rukutai Street Orakei Page 1491 P O Box 42274 Orakei John David Hole and Susan Janet Hole Page 1493 Robyn Lynette Millar 11 Codrington Crescent Mission Bay Page 1495 Jules Turner 38B Atkin Ave, Mission Auckland Bay Page 1497 Colleen June Turner P O BOX 133278 Auckland Page 1499 Brenda Higgins 301/8 Turua Street St Heliers Page 1501 The Character Coalition Inc - Sally 39 Hawera Road Kohimarama Elizabeth Hughes Page 1505 Brenda Higgins 301/8 Turua Street St Heliers Page 1507 Brett Frank Lornie 237 Tamaki Drive Mission Bay Page 1509 Jacqueline Straffon 4 Emerald St Auckland Page 1511 Hilary Dineen 15D Waimarie St St Heliers Page 1513 Henry Hawkins 75 Vale Road St Heliers Page 1515 Sally Anne Lornie 43A Marau Cresent Mission Bay Page 1517 Sally Anne Lornie 43A Marau Cresent Mission Bay Page 1519 Paul Oei 53 Codrington Cresent Mission Bay Page 1521 Kathleen Siobhan Morrissey 3/59 Ballarat Street Ellerslie Page 1523 Ann Louise Quickenden 45 Nihill Crescent Mission Bay Page 1525 John Mackenzie 49 Baddeley Avenue Kohimarama Page 1527 John Edwin Abbott 51 Codrington Crescent Mission Bay Page 1529 Annabelle Jerram 14 Keswick Crescent Huntington Hamilton Page 1531 Roger John Richardson 56 Godden Crescent Mission Bay Page 1533 Lesley Jacqueline Abbott 51 Coddington Cres Auckland Page 1535 Helen Mackenzie 49 Baddeley Avenue Kohimarama Page 1537 Andy Kilgallon 6 Etherege Place Howick Page 1539 Campbell Waugh 29 Tawa Road Onehunga Page 1541 Melanie Abbott 51 Codrington Crescent Mission Bay Page 1543 Rachel Buer 15B McArthur Avenue St Heliers Page 1545 Andrew John Kilgallon c/o Next Gen 2/58 Elliot street Howick Places Ltd Page 1547 Lisa Allcott and Keryn Kliskey 18 Godden Cres Auckland

Page 21 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28 & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay Tuesday 30 July 2019, Wednesday 31 July 2019, Thursday 01 August 2019, Friday 02 August 2019 and Tuesday 06 August 2019 Page 1549 Carolyn 5 Nihill Crescent Mission Bay Page 1551 Jeffrey Guy Thomson 12 Awaroa Road Helensville Page 1553 Janet Williams 18 Siota Crescent Kohimarama Page 1555 Sarah Jane Travaglia 154 Selwyn Avenue Mission Bay Page 1557 Nigel Hewitson 7 Codrington Crescent Mission Bay Page 1559 City Stays Auckland - Hannah 198A Point Chevalier Road Point Mcquilkan Chevalier Page 1561 Sue Teo 103 Patteson Ave Mission Bay Page 1563 Jan Williams - William Justin Williams 18 Siota Crescent Kohimarama

Page 1565 Philippa Collins 46B Rawhitiroa Rd Kohimarama Page 1567 Estelle Tant PO Box 25601 St Heliers Page 1569 Orakei Community Association PO BOX 9932 Newmarket Page 1571 James Timothy Knox Jerram P O Box 25033 St Heliers Page 1573 Andreas Holdings - Roger Stirling 75 Queen Street Auckland CBD Page 1575 Brian James Shackleton PO Box 25-022 St. Heliers Page 1577 Sam Jerram 249 Mt Pleasant Rd Mt Pleasant Christchurch Page 1579 Roy Clifford Clements 12A Apirana Avenue Glen Innes Page 1581 Alyssa Pua 103 Patteson Avenue Mission Bay Page 1583 Mark Duncan Dwen PO Box 25772 St Heliers Page 1585 Hans Ernst Kracke and Helga Emma PO Box 25 022 St Heliers Kracke Page 1587 L Lawson 10a Puna Street Orakei Page 1589 Margaret King 25 Clarendon Road St Heliers Page 1591 David Michael Byrne 32A Kohimarama Road Kohimarama Page 1593 R Jerram Unit 4/9 Marau Cres Mission Bay Page 1596 Kathryn Ellen Davies PO Box 55 265 Eastridge Page 1606 Civic Trust Auckland - Audrey van Ryn PO Box 74049 Greenlane Page 1608 James Timothy Knox Jerram P. O Box 25033 St Heliers Page 1612 Alexandra Dempsey 33 Te Arawa Street Orakei Page 1616 Christian Giannotti 12a Selwyn Ave Mission Bay Page 1617 Anne Gifford 125 Selwyn Ave Mission Bay Page 1618 Navalneet Anand 10 Calcite Ave Flat Bush

Page 22 Quentin Budd

From: Desmond Hunt Sent: Tuesday, 11 September 2018 9:51 AM To: Premium Submissions Subject: Fwd: BUN60324987,LUC60324989 &WAT60325010

Follow Up Flag: Follow up Flag Status: Completed

Categories: other sources

Forwarded to Achini who is carrying out Notifications for this.

Des

From: Desmond Hunt Subject: BUN60324987,LUC60324989 &WAT60325010 Date: 11 September 2018 at 9:44:37 AM NZST To: [email protected] Cc: [email protected], [email protected]

1)Desmond Hunt, 10 Codrington Crescent, Mission Bay. Ph 021669048. [email protected].

2) 75-79,81-87 &89-97, Tamaki Drive 6. 8-10, 12 &14 Patterson Avenue, 26, 28, 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay.

4) I object to the propose application as it exceeds the current Auckland Unity Plan especially regarding to the hight restriction. After talking to many neighbours this is main complaint. With the number of apartments being planned it would also cause parking issues in the area.

5( Ensure the developer stays within the Auckland Unity Plan.

With kind regards Des

1 23 Quentin Budd

From: Rob Bree Sent: Friday, 14 September 2018 4:02 PM To: Premium Submissions Cc: [email protected] Subject: ID:0002 - Drive Holdings Application Attachments: RE: Drive Holdings Application

Categories: other sources

Dear Mr Budd As an Orakei resident I have been sent the notification for resource consent. I am opposed to the proposed development on Tamaki Drive and Patteseon Ave on the grounds that I do not believe the proposal is well suited to the needs of the area, is not friendly to people who live and work and play in the area and is also destructive to the special character of the precinct. Illustrations I have viewed of the proposal in my humble opinion are ugly and not in keeping with the character of Mission Bay. I am also concerned that there will be a spillover effect with many equally ugly and imposing buildings being built in the area in the future with these buildings being quoted as a precedent. I would not oppose a building only 4 storeys high and in keeping with the current special character of the area. But I do oppose these ones on the grounds of their height and their ugly design. Best regards Robert Bree

PS I have copied in Ellis Gould solicitors per the instructions in your note.

Robert Bree Chief Strategist +64 272 777 832 [email protected]

WWW.BMSW.NZ

At BMSW we help Managers and Marketers create, plan and implement, break‐through growth strategies, targeting the most productive market opportunities, using VENNLI™ our unique, strategic, growth‐finding platform.

1 24 Quentin Budd

From: Rob Bree Sent: Friday, 14 September 2018 4:39 PM To: Premium Submissions Cc: [email protected] Subject: RE: Drive Holdings Application

FYI my address is 88a Kurahaupo Street Orakei and the Resource Consent numbers are BUN60324987 LUC60324989 WAT60325010 Reason. Because I live in Orakei and am concerned about the special character of Mission Bay being preserved. I want the consent authority to not grant the consent.

Robert Bree Chief Strategist +64 272 777 832 [email protected]

WWW.BMSW.NZ

From: Rob Bree Sent: Friday, 14 September 2018 4:02 PM To: '[email protected]' Cc: '[email protected]' Subject: Drive Holdings Application

1 25 PS I have copied in Ellis Gould solicitors per the instructions in your note.

Robert Bree Chief Strategist +64 272 777 832 [email protected]

WWW.BMSW.NZ

2 26 27 Ranjeeta Singh

From: Tony Falkenstein Sent: Friday, 28 September 2018 8:56 PM To: Premium Submissions Subject: Submission re DRive Holdings Ltd

1. Anthony Edwin Falkenstein of 3 Dudley Rd, Mission Bay, Mob: 021 950856 Email: [email protected]

2. Application BUN60324987, LUC60324989,& WAT60325010 Mission Bay

3. I have been a resident of Mission Bay for over 50 years.

4. I am in support of this application. I believe that this is an opportunity to improve the commercial area from a mish mash of retail outlets and restaurants to a very considered modern development. That one organisation own sufficient properties to carry out this development is an opportunity that should not be missed.

5. I wish the Consent Authority to approve this application.

6. I need not appear in person to support this application.

Yours faithfully

Tony falkenstein

1 28 29 30

Auckland Planning Limited Specialists in Resource Consents

T. +64 9 528 9112 M. +64 21 489 494 E. [email protected] W. www.aucklandplanning.co.nz

PO Box 133032 Eastridge Auckland 1146 New Zealand

5th October 2018

Auckland Council Premium Resource Consents 35 Graham Street Auckland CBD

Dear Sir/Madam,

RE: Submission on Proposed Mission Bay Development by Drive Holdings Limited Application Number: LUC60324989 & WAT60325010 ; 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28, & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay, Auckland (hereafter referred to as the ‘proposed development’)

Following notification of the proposed development 12th September 2018, we offer a combined submission on behalf of:

 BLC Limited [Contact - Nick Culpan: 021 489 494]  Barfoot &Thompson Limited [Contact - Teresa Weiss: 0272 868 439]  Unilever New Zealand Limited [Contact - Sean Farrell: 0061 451 643 703]  NZ Water Works LLC Limited [Contact - Nick Turner: 021 458 862]

Collectively we are the owners and tenants of the following property:

Site Address: 99 Tamaki Drive, Mission Bay, Auckland (hereafter referred to as ‘our site’)

Description and Location of 99 Tamaki Drive, Mission Bay, Auckland 99 Tamaki Drive, Mission Bay, Auckland is a north facing cross lease site with a total area of 320m². Under the Auckland Unitary Plan it is zoned Local Centre and directly adjoins the proposed development’s eastern boundary.

The building was constructed during the 1960’s and originally split into 4 shops – 99A, 99B, 99C and 99D Tamaki Drive, Mission Bay. BLC Limited own 99A and 99B and Barfoot & Thompson Limited own 99C and 99D which are now combined. All shops have recently undergone comprehensive renovations and are occupied by the following 3 tenants:

 99A - Ben & Jerry’s Ice Cream Parlour (Unilever New Zealand Limited)  99B - Sals Pizzeria (NZ Water Works LLC Limited)  99C & 99D - Barfoot and Thompson Real Estate Agency (Barfoot &Thompson Limited)

Locality Plan:

Proposed 99 Tamaki Drive, Development Mission Bay

Aerial Photograph:

Sals Pizzeria (99B)

Ben & Jerry’s Barfoot & Thompson Ice Cream Parlour (99A) (99C & 99D)

Proposed Development 99 Tamaki Drive, Mission Bay

Photos:

99 Tamaki Drive, Mission Bay – North Eastern View of Shops

99A Tamaki Drive, Mission Bay – Ben & Jerry’s Ice Cream Parlour

99B Tamaki Drive, Mission Bay – Sals Pizzeria

99C & 99D Tamaki Drive, Mission Bay – Barfoot and Thompson Real Estate Agency

99 Tamaki Drive, Mission Bay – Western Street View of Shop Fronts

REASONS FOR OUR SUBMISSION

We recognize the potential long term benefits of the proposed development however we oppose this application in its current form because:

1.) Construction Risks Our building at 99 Tamaki Drive, Mission Bay is immediately adjacent to the proposed development. Being the closest building we are extremely concerned of construction risks associated with this type of development. These risks include pile deflection, water drawdown, vibration, noise, subsidence, differential settlement, structural damage, internal damage to costly fitouts, public and staff safety inside and outside.

2.) Foundation Removal The proposed development requires all existing buildings onsite are demolished. Council records indicate the building directly adjacent to our western boundary (i.e. 89-97 Tamaki Drive) has footings which are deeper than the footings of our building. Our concern is when the footings of 89-97 Tamaki Drive are removed there is significant risk of partial collapse, unsupported footings and possibly severe differential settlement to our building. Additionally, no details are provided regarding the proposed replacement foundations adjacent to our footings, or what further hazards these may create during construction. We believe the risk of extensive damage is considerable, especially due to the shallow footings below our building.

Earthworks consent [R/LUC/2009/4930] dated 19 April 2010 (Attachment 2), Condition 1, made reference to various plans, reports and letters. Specifically a letter prepared by Tonkin and Taylor dated 17 April 2009 (Attachment 3) outlined methodology for removing the foundations at 89-97 Tamaki Drive while minimising risks to the footings of our building. This information and proposed methodology is omitted from the current application.

3.) Business Interruption and Financial Viability During construction the proposed development will involve building techniques which create noise, vibration and dust. There will be disruption from construction traffic and general construction activities. This will severely restrict pedestrian and vehicular access. For the duration of construction these adverse effects will be exceptionally detrimental to the financial viability of businesses operating from our site. 35

4.) Tamaki Drive Vehicle Crossings and Loading Spaces Included with the application for the proposed development is a Traffic Report prepared by Parlane & Associates. This report outlines intentions to use the Tamaki Drive footpath for vehicle crossings and loading spaces while removing 35,000m³ of earthworks. See figure 25 below (Attachment 4, page 45 of Integrated Transportation Assessment). The red arrows demonstrate the proposed ingress and egress vehicle crossings for large dump trucks and the blue areas demonstrate the proposed loading spaces. Sals Pizzeria

Ben & Jerry’s Barfoot & Ice Cream Parlour Thompson

Bus Stops 99 Tamaki Drive, Mission Bay

Proposed Development

Existing Vehicle Crossing

We believe the proposed use of the Tamaki Drive footpath for vehicle crossings and loading spaces will create substantial adverse effects. Our concerns include:

 Safety Risks for cyclists, pedestrians and patrons will increase considerably - especially children and toddlers seated outside Ben & Jerry’s ice cream parlour at 99A Tamaki Drive, which directly adjoins the proposed ingress point for large dump trucks entering the proposed development.  Public Use of the recently upgraded Tamaki Drive footpath will drop dramatically over a prolonged period of time as the proposed development is estimated to take between 3 to 5 years to complete. Full reinstatement of the public footpath is unlikely until the development is finished.  Traffic Congestion along the arterial road Tamaki Drive will increase markedly causing major traffic delays.  Underground Services renewed along the Tamaki Drive footpath will be damaged, including the ACO drainage channel.  Acoustic Fencing proposed along the Tamaki Drive footpath will have reduced effect.  Unsightly Disruption will result for the highly valued Tamaki Drive scenic way.  Vibration and Noise Levels affecting adjoining properties and businesses will intensify, adding further nuisance to an already difficult situation and escalating potential for structural and cosmetic damage.  Financial Viability of businesses operating nearby will be significantly affected.

5.) Street Verandah The plans submitted by the applicant offer no details as to whether a continuous street verandah is proposed or how this may connect with our street verandah.

CONSENT AUTHORITY DECISION

We request the consent authority decline this application. To address our reasons for the submission and to minimise and mitigate adverse effects on our site, building and businesses, we seek the following:

1) Dilapidation Surveys Appropriate resource consent conditions should be imposed to ensure protection from the construction risks associated with the proposed development. These conditions should include the applicant engaging independent suitably qualified structural engineers to complete ‘Condition Reports’ of our site, building and shop fitouts prior to works commencing, during works, and following completion of the proposed development. Copies of the Condition Reports should be provided to the owners and tenants of 99 Tamaki Drive. If damage is created then compensation should be assured by the applicant.

2) Methodology for Foundation Removal Prior to resource consent being granted, detailed methodology for the removal and replacement of the applicant’s foundations adjacent to our footings should be provided and approved by Councils development engineers. The approved methodology should minimise risks to the footings of our building. Appropriate resource consent conditions should be imposed to ensure the approved methodology for foundation removal and replacement is complied with at all times.

3) Consultation with Owners and Tenants Appropriate resource consent conditions should be imposed to ensure consultation takes place between the applicant’s contractors and the owners and tenants of 99 Tamaki Drive. This consultation should produce agreed time periods when work likely to be excessively disruptive to our site is completed 37

4) Relocation of Proposed Tamaki Drive Vehicle Crossings and Loading Spaces The proposed vehicle crossings and loading spaces along the Tamaki Drive footpath should be relocated to Patteson Avenue – preferably using the existing Patteson Avenue vehicle crossing for all ingress and egress of vehicles and using the Patteson Avenue bus stops for all loading spaces by temporarily moving the bus stops to an approved location. Appropriate resource consent conditions should be imposed to ensure both Tamaki Drive and the recently upgraded Tamaki Drive footpath are not used at any time for vehicle crossings or loading spaces during demolition, construction or following completion of the proposed development.

5) Continuous Street Verandah The plans for the proposed development should be amended to include details of a continuous street verandah providing weather protection for pedestrians and business patrons. Appropriate resource consent conditions should be imposed to ensure the new street verandah connects with the existing street verandah of 99 Tamaki Drive, thereby providing continuous weather protection for pedestrians and patrons while allowing an uninterrupted commercial blend from the proposed development through to our existing commercial shops along Tamaki Drive.

We wish to be heard in support of our submission.

Thank you for considering our submission and if you require any further information please contact me.

Yours faithfully, AUCKLAND PLANNING LIMITED

Nick Culpan (BPlan) Director/Planning Consultant [email protected]

Auckland Planning Limited T. +64 9 528 9112 M. +64 21 489 494 E. [email protected] W. www.aucklandplanning.co.nz PO Box 133032, Eastridge, Auckland 1146, New Zealand 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 PROJECT BEACHSIDE MISSION BAY

INTEGRATED TRANSPORTATION ASSESSMENT

DRIVE HOLDINGS LTD

PO BOX 302-287 NORTH HARBOUR AUCKLAND 1330 PH: 413 7020 August 2018 FAX: 413 7641

51 TABLE OF CONTENTS

1. SUMMARY ...... 1

2. INTRODUCTION AND SCOPE ...... 1

2.1 Subject Site ...... 2

3. LAND USE AND TRANSPORT ENVIRONMENT ...... 3

3.1 Existing Land Use Activities ...... 3

3.2 Existing Transport Network ...... 4 3.2.1 Buses ...... 4 3.2.2 Cycling ...... 5 3.2.3 Walking ...... 7 3.2.4 Roading ...... 8 3.2.5 Traffic Counts...... 10

3.3 Holiday Period Traffic...... 12

3.4 Road Safety...... 13

4. THE PROPOSED PROJECT...... 14

4.1 The Site Layout ...... 14

4.2 Access and Internal Circulation...... 17 4.2.1 Ramp Gradients ...... 19 4.2.2 Vehicle Tracking on Ramps ...... 21 4.2.3 ...... 21 4.2.4 Interface of Driveways and Footpaths...... 22

4.3 Parking Calculations...... 25

4.4 Parking Space Dimensions ...... 26

4.5 Cycle Parking and End of Trip Facilities...... 26

4.6 Loading and servicing...... 27

5. TRIP GENERATION AND EXPECTED MODE SHARE...... 29

52 5.1 Residential Travel Patterns and Mode Share...... 29

5.2 Trip Generation...... 32

6. ASSESSMENT OF EFFECTS...... 35

6.1 Future Traffic Flows...... 35

6.2 Local Network effects and Intersection Capacity...... 35

6.3 Tamaki Drive Traffic Lights ...... 35

6.4 Patteson Avenue Carpark Entrance...... 37

6.5 Patteson Avenue Intersection with Marau Cres and Ronaki Rd...... 38

7. UNITARY PLAN CONSENTS REQUIRED...... 40

7.1 Assessment Against AUP:OP Trip Generation Thresholds ...... 40

7.2 Maximum Ramp Gradient ...... 41

8. CONSTRUCTION EFFECTS...... 41

8.1 Demolition and Excavation ...... 42

8.2 Construction ...... 43

8.3 Temporary Traffic and Pedestrian Effects ...... 44

9. CONCLUSION ...... 46

10. ATTACHMENT 1 – CHANGES TO PARKING CONTROLS...... 47

11. ATTACHMENT 2– PARKING DIMENSIONS...... 48

12. ATTACHMENT 3 – FUTURE TRAFFIC FLOWS...... 49

53 Project Beachside Mission Bay ITA 1

1. SUMMARY

A mixed use residential, commercial (retail and food and beverage) and

entertainment (cinema) project at Mission Bay has been designed to integrate

land use activities with the transport network. The project includes 100

residential apartments and 2,920sqm of commercial/retail space which is most

likely to be used for food and beverage sales, and a cinema with a floor area

of 955sqm. There will also be a balcony associated with the commercial space

which has an area of 51.6sqm within the site and 101.9sqm overhanging the

street. The application will involve demolishing the existing buildings on the

site which include the Berkeley Cinema, shops, restaurants and some

residential units.

The new project is provided for in the Auckland Unitary Plan – Operative in

Part (the “AUP:OP”) through the local centre zoning and the transportation

rules. The project would comply with parking, access and loading rules with

a minor variance on a ramp that complies with the Australian and New

Zealand parking standard.

Modelling of the traffic effects on typical days shows that the expected level

of traffic can be accommodated within the existing road network without

creating adverse traffic congestion or safety effects.

2. INTRODUCTION AND SCOPE

This ITA has been prepared in support of a proposed resource consent

application for a large site at 75 to 97 Tamaki Drive, 6 to 14 Patteson Avenue

and 26 to 30 Marau Crescent in Mission Bay (“the Site”).

The scope of the ITA was defined at a meeting with Auckland Council

Planners and Transport Planners on 19 October 2017. It was agreed that the

485 ITA Report 090818 Parlane & Associates Ltd 54 Project Beachside Mission Bay ITA 2

application is a site-specific project. The ITA follows the Auckland Transport

Guidelines for site-specific applications.

2.1 Subject Site

The subject site has frontage to Tamaki Drive, Patteson Avenue and Marau

Crescent in Mission Bay as shown in Figure 1 below. The site is zoned Local

Centre under the AUP:OP. The total site area is 6530 m².

Figure 1: Locality plan. (Source: Auckland Council GeoMaps).

485 ITA Report 090818 Parlane & Associates Ltd 55 Project Beachside Mission Bay ITA 3

A more detailed description of the site is provided in the Assessment of

Environmental Effects (“AEE”) that accompanies the resource consent

application.

Currently there are shops and restaurants and a cinema on the Tamaki Drive

frontage of the Site and on Patteson Avenue close to Tamaki Drive. The

central part of the Site is used as a loading area and pay and display carpark

serving those commercial activities. Access to the carpark is from Patteson

Avenue.

The southern part of the Site is all residential with a number of flats and

houses that have access to Marau Crescent via two very wide vehicle

crossings.

3. LAND USE AND TRANSPORT ENVIRONMENT

3.1 Existing Land Use Activities

Figure 2 below shows the AUP:OP map of the local area with the bright pink

showing the Local Centre zone.

Immediately to the east of the site on Tamaki Drive is a pizza restaurant and

a real estate agents’ office. These two activities mark the eastern end of the

Mission Bay commercial area. Beyond this the sites fronting Tamaki Drive are

all residential.

On the opposite side of Tamaki Drive there is a public carpark and reserve

and the Mission Bay Beach.

All of the neighbouring sites on Marau Crescent are residential. These homes

have a range of types including a block of flats or apartments at 32 Marau

Crescent and larger stand-alone houses on the southern side of Marau

Crescent.

485 ITA Report 090818 Parlane & Associates Ltd 56 Project Beachside Mission Bay ITA 4

Figure 2: Subject site (blue outline) and surrounding zoning. (Source: Auckland Council Unitary Plan Map Viewer).

3.2 Existing Transport Network

3.2.1 Buses

From 8 July 2018 bus services on the Auckland Isthmus changed through the

implementation of Auckland Transport’s New Network. Figure 3 below

shows the new services in the Mission Bay area.

485 ITA Report 090818 Parlane & Associates Ltd 57 Project Beachside Mission Bay ITA 5

Figure 3: New Network

The biggest change is the introduction of the Tamaki Link service from

Britomart to Glen Innes via Mission Bay and St Heliers. This new service

forms part of the Frequent Network with services in each direction every 15

minutes. This represents a substantial improvement in public transport to and

from Mission Bay and, given the success of other frequent services such as the

Inner Link and Outer Link, is expected to significantly change how people

will choose to travel.

The new 782 service travels on Patteson Avenue providing a link between

Mission Bay and the rail network at Orakei and on to Remuera, Newmarket

and the Museum.

3.2.2 Cycling

As shown in Figure 4 below, there are some dedicated cycle lanes and shared

lanes in the vicinity of the site which form part of an overall network,

including dedicated cycle lanes along parts of Tamaki Drive. However the

485 ITA Report 090818 Parlane & Associates Ltd 58 Project Beachside Mission Bay ITA 6

westbound cycle lane on Tamaki Drive currently comes to an abrupt stop just

west of the Marau Crescent intersection and cyclists have to share the road

space with general traffic. There is a cycle lane on the footpath on the beach

side of Tamaki Drive although there are places where signs and car doors pose

a problem. A short length of on-street cycle lane exists on the carriageway of

Tamaki Drive just prior to the Patteson Avenue intersection. However, that

cycle lane does not really connect to anything else so again cyclists share road

space with general traffic.

Figure 4: Regional cycle network map around subject site (red star). (Source: AT website).

485 ITA Report 090818 Parlane & Associates Ltd 59 Project Beachside Mission Bay ITA 7

The area that can be accessed in 10 minutes by bike is shown in Figure 5 below.

Figure 5 – Ten Minute Cycle Ride from the Site 3.2.3 Walking

Pedestrian linkages within the vicinity of the site are provided by way of

footpaths along roads and along the beachfront within a ten-minute walk of

the site, as shown in Figure 6 below.

The footpaths generally directly adjoin the carriageway without a green berm

between. The footpath width is reasonably generous on Patteson Avenue and

Tamaki Drive.

485 ITA Report 090818 Parlane & Associates Ltd 60 Project Beachside Mission Bay ITA 8

Figure 6: Ten-minute (blue) walking catchments from the subject site (red star).

3.2.4 Roading

Tamaki Drive is classified by the AUP:OP as an Arterial Road while Patteson

Avenue and Marau Crescent are not classified. However Patteson Avenue is

a bus route and was previously classified as a collector road.

The most recent count on Tamaki Drive at the site frontage was in 2015 when

the road carried 16,8001 vehicles on an average weekday, 17,800 on a Saturday

and 13,400 on a Sunday.

Tamaki Drive operates with a single traffic lane in each direction with a central

flush median. At the signalised intersection with Patteson Avenue the flush

median transitions to an extra turning lane for traffic turning into Patteson

Avenue as shown in Figure 7 below.

1 AT Traffic Counts between Marau Cres and Patteson Ave 12 November 2015.

485 ITA Report 090818 Parlane & Associates Ltd 61 Project Beachside Mission Bay ITA 9

Figure 7: Aerial Photograph of the Frontage Road (Source: Auckland Council Geomaps)

Parking along the site frontage on Tamaki Drive and in front of 99 Tamaki

Drive has been removed to provide for a wider footpath and landscape strip.

Parking on the opposite side and in the carpark opposite is all restricted to

P180. The current layout is shown in the photograph in Figure 8.

485 ITA Report 090818 Parlane & Associates Ltd 62 Project Beachside Mission Bay ITA 10

Figure 8: Tamaki Drive

Patteson Avenue in front of the site has a bus stop, a vehicle crossing serving

the site and eleven P120 parking spaces including one space reserved for

people with an accessible parking permit. These spaces are all at 90-degrees

to the traffic.

Marau Crescent is a narrow residential street where cars can be parked either

side of a carriageway that does not have a centreline. Comparatively wide

landscaped berms separate the street from the footpath on either side. It is a

street that is not really suitable for access to shops or restaurant parking.

3.2.5 Traffic Counts Turning movements have been counted at the intersection of Tamaki Drive

with Patteson Avenue, at the intersection of Ronaki Road with Patteson

Avenue and at the intersection of Marau Crescent with Ronaki Road. Traffic

turning into and out of the existing carpark entrance has also been counted.

485 ITA Report 090818 Parlane & Associates Ltd 63 Project Beachside Mission Bay ITA 11

Summaries of the evening peak hour are shown in Figure 9 below.

Figure 9: Evening Peak Hour Car Traffic

Mission Bay traffic is also regularly busy on Saturdays, so a summary of the

busiest Saturday hour is also provided in Figure 10.

485 ITA Report 090818 Parlane & Associates Ltd 64 Project Beachside Mission Bay ITA 12

Figure 10: Saturday Car Turning Flows

3.3 Holiday Period Traffic

Mission Bay and Tamaki Drive experience very high traffic flows and

associated congestion during summer weekends and on public holidays.

These high flows are in part due to sightseers driving along the length of

Tamaki Drive and in part due to the popularity of the beach.

485 ITA Report 090818 Parlane & Associates Ltd 65 Project Beachside Mission Bay ITA 13

3.4 Road Safety

A search of reported crashes for the five year period 2013 to 2017 shows there

have been eight crashes that have resulted in minor injuries and no serious

crashes or fatalities in the vicinity of the site. None of the reported injury

crashes have occurred at the existing carpark entrance, although one

pedestrian was struck by a van on the opposite side of Patteson Avenue. Five

of the crashes occurred at or near to the Tamaki Drive traffic signals, two of

these involved cyclists. Two crashes occurred east of the site on Tamaki Drive.

One involved a car parking and the other involved one driver losing control.

Figure 11: Reported Injury Crashes 2013 to 2017

There have been 25 non-injury crashes reported on roads near the site. Most

of these occurred at the traffic signals or on one of the approaches to the traffic

signals. None of the non-injury crashes occurred at the existing entrance to

the carpark or on Marau Crescent where the new entrance will be. One of the

non-injury crashes involved a vehicle turning into the parking area on the

opposite side of Patteson Avenue.

485 ITA Report 090818 Parlane & Associates Ltd 66 Project Beachside Mission Bay ITA 14

Figure 12: Reported Non-Injury Crashes 2013 to 2017 (each number is a reported crash)

The main pattern to the crashes seems to be due to drivers following too

closely or having their attention diverted. Unfortunately this type of pattern

is common within town centres. There are no obvious changes that can be

made to address these crashes but the recent removal of parking on the

southern side of Tamaki Drive near the site should result in a reduction in

crashes along that frontage.

4. THE PROPOSED PROJECT

4.1 The Site Layout

The proposed project will require the demolition of all of the existing

buildings on the site and the construction of parking at the ground level and

485 ITA Report 090818 Parlane & Associates Ltd 67 Project Beachside Mission Bay ITA 15

two basement floors. New buildings will then be constructed to provide for

the following activities:

 100 residential dwellings;

 2920 sqm of retail space including shops and food and beverage

retail (“f & b”);

 154 sqm of balcony areas which will most likely be used for

outdoor areas for f & b;

 A five screen cinema building with 322 to 400 seats (subject to

detailed design) and a total floor area of 955sqm;

 265 car parking spaces including 4 accessible spaces.

The layout of the ground floor of the proposed project is shown in the site

plan prepared by The Buchan Group architects (“Buchan”) as shown in Figure

13.

A minor change is proposed to the existing on-street parking on the Patteson

Avenue frontage to the site. Where there are currently a small number of 90-

degree parking spaces it is proposed that a small drop-off bay will be

provided. This would be marked as a P10 area if approved by AT.

Similarly, it is also proposed to mark a no stopping restriction on the northern

side of Marau Crescent along the site frontage. This would extend from

Ronaki Road to the entrance to the underground basement. Both of these

changes require approval of a resolution by AT and are proposed to ensure

that visitor parking does not become a nuisance to other road users. These

changes within the road reserve are shown in Attachment 1.

485 ITA Report 090818 Parlane & Associates Ltd 68 Project Beachside Mission Bay ITA 16

Figure 13: The Proposed Project (Source Buchan Plans)

The 154sqm balcony on Level 1 is likely to be used as part of food and

beverage retail activities as it overlooks the water and is located adjacent to a

retail and kitchen area. Because the building is angled to the street boundary,

52sqm of the balcony is within the site and a further 102sqm overhangs the

street and is located outside of the site boundary. This balcony area is shown

in Figure 14 below.

485 ITA Report 090818 Parlane & Associates Ltd 69 Project Beachside Mission Bay ITA 17

Figure 14: Level 1 showing the extent of balcony overhanging Tamaki Drive. (Source Buchan Plans)

4.2 Access and Internal Circulation

Two access points are proposed for the parking areas. The main access would

be via a vehicle crossing on Patteson Avenue that would provide access to all

of the parking associated with the commercial aspects of the project as well as

the loading area. An internal ramp system would provide connection

between the ground level and Basement 1 level of parking.

The second site access would be located on Marau Crescent. This new vehicle

crossing would provide access directly to the Basement 2 level, which would

all be used for parking associated with the residential components of the

project.

485 ITA Report 090818 Parlane & Associates Ltd 70 Project Beachside Mission Bay ITA 18

The two accesses and vehicle crossings have been assessed against the

AUP:OP rules as discussed below.

Rule Requirement Assessment

E27.6.4.1 No restrictions apply. Neither of the two proposed

Vehicle accesses are within areas

Access where a vehicle access

Restrictions restriction applies.

E27.6.4.2 The site can have 1 vehicle Only two crossings are

Width and crossing per 25m of frontage proposed. They will be more

number of which in this case means 9 than 95 metres apart and 20

vehicle crossings would be permitted. metres from the nearest

crossings There must be at least 6m of vehicle crossing on Marau

separation between them and Crescent.

they must be at least 2m from

accesses to other sites.

E27.6.4.3 The minimum width of vehicle The Marau Crescent vehicle

Width of crossings at the boundary is 5.5m crossings will be 6.0 metres

vehicle access with a maximum of 6.0m. The wide at the boundary and will

and queuing minimum formed access width is connect to a 6.0 metre wide

requirements 5.5m. two-way driveway. The

Patteson Avenue Access will

be 5.8metres wide.

E27.6.4.4. The residential access ramp can The Marau Crescent ramp will Gradient of vehicle access have a maximum grade of 1 in 5 be for residential traffic only

485 ITA Report 090818 Parlane & Associates Ltd 71 Project Beachside Mission Bay ITA 19

or 20%. The visitor ramp can be and can be 1 in 5. The internal

up to 1 in 6 or 16.7%. curved ramp will have a

maximum gradient of 1 in 5 at

the inside radius so a consent

is required.

Transitions are required for grade Transitions will be included at

changes of more than 12.5% the top and bottom of each

ramp to avoid vehicles

scraping.

A 4m long platform of no steeper A 7.0-metre-long flat platform

than 1 in 20 is required for the will be provided at the top of

Residential ramp. the residential ramp.

Table 1 – AUP:OP Access Assessment

4.2.1 Ramp Gradients

As noted above the AUP:OP sets a maximum ramp gradient of 1 in 6 for non-

residential parking. The internal curved up-ramp will exceed that gradient at

the extreme inside radius where the gradient will be 1 in 5. This means a

consent is required and the effects need to be assessed. Curved ramps by their

nature have steeper grades at the inside radius as that part of the ramp is

shorter. The up-ramp has been designed to have an average grade of 1 in 7.1

(measured in the centre of the vehicle track) and when measured at the inside

radius it has an average grade (including transitions) of 1 in 6.6.

While it has a maximum gradient of 1 in 5 at the inside radius it can be

approved on the basis that it complies with the requirements of the Australian

and New Zealand Standard for Off Street Parking Facilities AS/NZ2890.1

485 ITA Report 090818 Parlane & Associates Ltd 72 Project Beachside Mission Bay ITA 20

(2004). That code permits gradients of up to 1 in 5 in public carparks where

the ramp length is less than 20 metres, as long as transition grades are

provided2. The down ramp has a gradient of 1 in 9.5 at the inner radius and 1

in 11.4 at the centre.

Figure 15: Ramp Gradients

The ramp to Marau Crescent complies with the rules of the AUP:OP. The

gradient is 1 in 5 which meets the rules for access to residential parking.

Transitions will be provided at the top and the bottom and a flat area is

provided adjacent to the footpath.

2 AS/NZ2890.1(2004), 2.5.3a(ii).

485 ITA Report 090818 Parlane & Associates Ltd 73 Project Beachside Mission Bay ITA 21

4.2.2 Vehicle Tracking on Ramps

The internal ramps have been designed to accommodate the 85th percentile car

tracking curve set out in the AUP:OP. Despite its name this design vehicle is

actually slightly larger than the old 99-percentile vehicle defined in the legacy

District Plans. Figure 15 below shows the tracking requirements of the vehicle

going up and down the curved ramp.

Figure 16: Tracking for the 85th-Percentile Car on the Curved Ramp

4.2.3

Similarly tracking has been checked at the bottom of the straight ramp to the

residential parking in Basement 2. This is shown in Figure 17.

485 ITA Report 090818 Parlane & Associates Ltd 74 Project Beachside Mission Bay ITA 22

Figure 17: Tracking for the 85th-Percentile Car on the Straight Ramp

4.2.4 Interface of Driveways and Footpaths

Although not a requirement of the AUP:OP, both vehicle accesses have been

designed to provide a sight triangle to ensure existing traffic has good views

of pedestrians using the footpath. Both access points comply with the

recommended visibility triangle set out in AS/NZ2890.1 shown in Figure 18

below.

485 ITA Report 090818 Parlane & Associates Ltd 75 Project Beachside Mission Bay ITA 23

Figure 18: Required Pedestrian Sight Lines (Source AS/NZ2890.1:2004)

The proposed access onto Patteson Avenue has been designed to have a width

of 5.8 metres with a kerb to ensure that there will be a 2-metre visibility offset

for vehicles leaving the carpark as shown below. No offset is required on the

entering side of the access as sight triangles are not required on that side when

the driveway is designed for two-way traffic.

485 ITA Report 090818 Parlane & Associates Ltd 76 Project Beachside Mission Bay ITA 24

Figure 19: The Patteson Avenue Entrance showing a 2 metre by 5 metre Visibility Area

The proposed access to Marau Crescent will have a 6-metre wide access which

again has a 2.0m visibility offset to the footpath.

Figure 20: The Marau Crescent Entrance Showing a 2m by 2.5m Visibility Triangle

485 ITA Report 090818 Parlane & Associates Ltd 77 Project Beachside Mission Bay ITA 25

4.3 Parking Calculations

The project would have a total of 265 parking spaces located as follows:

Location Casual Regular Total Parking Parking Spaces Ground Level 42 0 42 Basement 1 58 36 94 Basement 2 0 129 129 Total 100 165 265 Table 2 – Proposed Parking Provision

NZS 4121 requires accessible parking at a rate of 2 accessible spaces for the

first 21 to 50 casual spaces and an additional 1 space per 50 spaces thereafter.

For this project there would need to be 3 accessible spaces. Four are provided

on the Ground Floor level. Residential tenants’ spaces are not included in the

calculations in NZS4121.

The AUP:OP sets out minimum and maximum parking rules for sites located

in a Local Centre as shown in Table 3 below.

Activity Scale Units Minimum Parking Maximum Parking Parking Rate Spaces Parking Rate Residential 100 Dwellings no minimum 0 no maximum Retail including 2920 sqm 1 space per 30sqm 97 no maximum food & beverage Balcony (inside 52 sqm 1 space per 30sqm 2 no maximum the site) Balcony 102 sqm No requirement 0 no maximum (outside the site) Cinema 955 sqm no minimum 0 no maximum Total 99 No limit on parking Table 3 – AUP:OP Parking Calculations

So, the AUP:OP requires that the project has at least 99 parking spaces but

imposes no upper limit on the amount of parking that can be provided for this

project mix. In calculating this I have assumed that all of the retail areas are

485 ITA Report 090818 Parlane & Associates Ltd 78 Project Beachside Mission Bay ITA 26

either used for food and beverage or as general retail as the rates for parking

are 1 per 30 sqm for both categories. I have assumed that the balcony area

would be used in the same way. The balcony areas outside the site do not

have any parking requirement under the AUP:OP as this area is not part of

the site and is treated in the same way as footpath trading.

The parking spaces have all been assessed against the AUP:OP requirements

and this assessment is shown in Attachment 2.

4.4 Parking Space Dimensions

All of the public parking spaces have been designed to meet the casual user

requirements of Table E27.6.3.1.1 of the AUP:OP. The plan by Buchan shows

in detail that each of the spaces will be 2.6 metres wide with a manoeuvring

area of 7.0 metres.

The basement 2 level has a range of space sizes in order to fit them around the

structure of the building and ramps. The spaces comply with the regular user

rules of E27.6.3.1.1.

Attachment 2 shows the details of the three proposed parking levels together

with compliance with the AUP:OP rules.

4.5 Cycle Parking and End of Trip Facilities

Table E27.6.2.5 of the AUP:OP requires both short stay and long stay cycle

parking as set out below.

Activity Scale Visitors Secure or Long stay Rule Spaces Rule Spaces Residential 100 1 space per 20 units 5.0 1 space per unit 100.0 dwellings

485 ITA Report 090818 Parlane & Associates Ltd 79 Project Beachside Mission Bay ITA 27

Food 2920 sqm 1space per 350 sqm 8.3 1space per 300 sqm 9.7 Balcony 52 sqm 1space per 350 sqm 0.1 1space per 300 sqm 0.2 (inside the site) Balcony 102 No requirement 0 0 (outside the site) Cinema 400 seats 1space per 50 seats 8 1 space per 15 full 1.0 time equivalent Employees Total 21 111 Table 4 Cycle Parking

It is proposed that 24 cycle spaces will be provided within the ground floor

parking area.

The secure or long stay cycle parking will be provided within a bike room

located in Basement 2.

No end of trip facilities are required.

4.6 Loading and servicing

One loading space is required as the area of retail activities is less than

5,000sqm. The AUP:OP requires a loading space that is at least 8 metres long

and 3.5 metres wide with 3.8 metres of headroom.

A loading space has been designed to be used by a medium rigid truck as

required by the AUP:OP. The plot below shows how the truck would access

the loading space.

485 ITA Report 090818 Parlane & Associates Ltd 80 Project Beachside Mission Bay ITA 28

Figure 21: Truck Tracking Showing the Medium Rigid Truck and 300mm Clearance

A generous goods loading area will be provided adjacent to the marked

loading space.

485 ITA Report 090818 Parlane & Associates Ltd 81 Project Beachside Mission Bay ITA 29

5. TRIP GENERATION AND EXPECTED MODE SHARE

5.1 Residential Travel Patterns and Mode Share

Peak traffic levels generated by residential activities in Mission Bay can be

assessed by reference to the existing Journey to Work data from the 2013

Census of Population and Dwellings complied by Statistics New Zealand.

(The sites are located in the Mission Bay Census Area Unit). On Census day

in 2013 a total of 951 people commuted into the Mission Bay area to work and

2127 people commuted out of that area to work elsewhere. In addition, 4831

people both live and work in the area. The specific commuting patterns are

shown in the diagram below.

Figure 22: Journeys to Work CAU (Source Statistics NZ CommuterView)

485 ITA Report 090818 Parlane & Associates Ltd 82 Project Beachside Mission Bay ITA 30

The data shows that the destinations that attracted more than 20 commuters

are as follows:

Mission Bay, (516500) Area unit code Area unit name Type of flow 2006 2013 514102 Auckland Central West out 237 207 514103 Auckland Central East out 219 171 514101 Auckland Harbourside out 132 162 515902 Parnell West out 87 96 517400 Newmarket out 114 81 520500 Mt Wellington South out 72 69 520202 Ellerslie South out 45 54 519500 Penrose out 57 54 514302 Grafton East out 48 48 524200 Mangere South out 42 42 516400 Orakei North in 39 42 516900 Glen Innes North in 54 39 523112 Highbrook out 30 39 514301 Grafton West out 21 36 514000 Freemans Bay out 27 33 516700 St Heliers in 48 33 516700 St Heliers out 30 30 517001 Glen Innes West in 24 27 516601 Kohimarama West in 33 27 516301 Meadowbank North in 39 27 518101 Mt Eden North out 21 27 516001 Mt Hobson out 21 27 520301 Mt Wellington Domain out 42 27 514102 Auckland Central West in 9 24 517001 Glen Innes West out 15 24 516602 Kohimarama East in 30 24 524604 Manukau Central out 33 24 519200 Mt St John out 24 24 507900 Westlake out 30 24 523113 Greenmount out 12 21 520302 Mt Wellington West out 18 21 517201 St Johns in 27 21 Table 5 – Major Commuter Destinations (Source Statistics NZ

CommuterView)

Almost all of these destinations are either located on the Rapid Transit

Network or Frequent Network or within walking and cycling distance of the

485 ITA Report 090818 Parlane & Associates Ltd 83 Project Beachside Mission Bay ITA 31

site. The new Tamaki Link service that will connect Britomart with Glen Innes

will provide access to all of the city and waterfront locations while the 782

service will allow for a rail interconnection.

Looking at the mode share for people commuting to this area we see that the

private car is the predominant mode of transport with 53.2% driving a private

vehicle, 10.8% driving a company vehicle and a further 2.5% travelling as a

passenger. All together that makes two-thirds of people travelling from the

area reliant on cars. However, that could likely change as the public transport

improvements are rolled out and as traffic congestion in other parts of

Auckland increases.

Mission Bay, (516500) Travel 2006 2013 2013 Share Note: Confidentiality rules have been applied to all cells in this table, including randomly rounding to base 3. Worked at home 243 297 10.5% Did not go to work today 237 243 8.6% Drove a private car, truck, or van 1632 1506 53.2% Drove a company car, truck, or van 309 303 10.7% Passenger in a car, truck, van, or company bus 102 72 2.5% Public bus 192 177 6.3% Train 21 45 1.6% Motorbike or powercycle 15 42 1.5% Bicycle 192 63 2.2% Walked or jogged 63 57 2.0% Other 24 21 0.7% Not elsewhere included 87 66 Totals stated 2889 2829 100% Total people who went to work on census day 2412 2289 Totals 2979 2898

Table 6 – Mode Share (Statistics NZ Journey to Work 2013)

485 ITA Report 090818 Parlane & Associates Ltd 84 Project Beachside Mission Bay ITA 32

Motorbike or 2013 powercycle Bicycle Walked or Other Train jogged

Public bus Worked at home

Passenger in a Did not go to car, truck, van, work today or company bus

Drove a company car, Drove a private truck, or van car, truck, or van

Figure 23: Mission Bay Mode share (Source: Statistics NZ Census of Population and Dwellings 2013)

Mode share for trips to Mission Bay is more difficult to assess. In the past the

majority of people would have driven to the Mission Bay centre or they would

have been local people who were able to walk there. However, we know that

changes have been occurring across Auckland for the last two decades as

more people use public transport to go out for dinner to avoid drink driving

and as people choose to dine locally. We would expect that pattern to

continue for evening dining.

During the day on Saturdays, Sundays and Public holidays we can expect a

heavy reliance on private cars.

5.2 Trip Generation

Traffic generation for the project has been estimated from standard data. The

residential apartments are a mix of sizes so a rate of 0.5 trips per unit has been

assumed for the morning and evening peak and 0.4 for the Saturday peak

485 ITA Report 090818 Parlane & Associates Ltd 85 Project Beachside Mission Bay ITA 33

hour. The retail areas have all been assumed to be a mix of shops and food

and beverage retailers including bars and restaurants. An evening peak rate

of 5 trips per 100sqm has been used which has been increased to 8.0 for the

Saturday hour. The retail areas are not likely to generate much traffic during

the morning peak.

The cinema has been assumed to attract trips at a higher level than the current

cinema does. The NZ Trips Database Bureau shows a rate of 0.15 trips per

seat for a weekday evening peak and 0.17 trips per seat for the Saturday peak.

Activity Scale Units Trip Rate Trips Residential 100 Dwellings 0.5 per household 50 Shops including f & b 2920 sqm 2 per 100sqm 58 Balcony (within the site) 52 sqm 2 per 100sqm 1 Balcony (above the street) 102 sqm 2 per 100sqm 1 Cinema 400 seats 0 per seat 0 Total 110 Table 7 – Morning Peak Traffic Generation

The evening peak is estimated below.

Activity Scale Units Trip Rate Trips Residential 100 Dwellings 0.5 per household 50 Shops including f & b 2920 sqm 5 per 100sqm 146 Balcony (within the site) 52 sqm 5 per 100sqm 3 Balcony (above the street) 102 sqm 5 per 100sqm 5 Cinema 400 seats 0.15 per seat 60 Total 264 Table 8 – Evening Peak Traffic Generation

The Saturday midday rates have been calculated as follows:

Activity Scale Units Trip Rate Trips Residential 100 Dwellings 0.4 per household 40 Shops including f & b 2920 sqm 8 per 100 sqm 234 Balcony (within the site) 52 sqm 8 per 100 sqm 4 Balcony (above the street) 102 sqm 8 per 100 sqm 8 Cinema 400 seats 0.17 per seat 68 Total 354 Table 9 – Saturday Traffic Generation

485 ITA Report 090818 Parlane & Associates Ltd 86 Project Beachside Mission Bay ITA 34

While the number of seats within the cinema is not known at this time a study

has shown that it will be within the range of 322 to 400. For traffic assessment

purposes I have used the higher figure.

As expected for retail projects the critical traffic periods will be the evening

peak and Saturday midday periods. Retail projects tend to generate very little

traffic during the morning commuter peak. During the morning peak hour

the project is likely to only generate 38 vehicles out on Marau Crescent and 13

vehicles in. The commercial entrance on Patteson Avenue could generate 30

vehicles in and 30 vehicles out. These are very minor additional traffic flows

that are unlikely to have any noticeable effect on the safety or capacity of these

roads

Both the evening peak and Saturday peak have been used as the design cases

for testing traffic capacity.

New traffic has been assigned to the road network based on the following

assumptions:

 All residential traffic will use the Marau Crescent access.

 All other traffic will use the Patteson Avenue access.

 The evening peak residential traffic will be split with 75% entering and

25% leaving.

 All other traffic and time periods will have 50% arriving and 50%

leaving.

No reduction in trips due to pass-by traffic or diverted linked trips has been

assumed. Similarly, no reduction has been made on the basis that many of

the visitors will already be in Mission Bay anyway.

485 ITA Report 090818 Parlane & Associates Ltd 87 Project Beachside Mission Bay ITA 35

6. ASSESSMENT OF EFFECTS

6.1 Future Traffic Flows

Future traffic flows for the project option have been estimated based on the

traffic generations noted above. Future traffic flows have been estimated as

shown in Attachment 3.

6.2 Local Network effects and Intersection Capacity

The likely effects of the project have been tested using SIDRA models of the

adjacent intersection for both the evening peak hour and the Saturday design

hour. These models have been built for the Tamaki Drive traffic lights, the

Patteson Avenue gateway and the Marau/Ronaki/Patteson Intersection. The

SIDRA models were then run as both standalone intersections and as linked

intersections using SIDRA Network.

6.3 Tamaki Drive Traffic Lights

Model results from the evening peak Sidra models are shown in Tables 10 and

11 below. The results show that the signalised intersection can easily handle

the additional traffic without significant changes in vehicle delay.

485 ITA Report 090818 Parlane & Associates Ltd 88 Project Beachside Mission Bay ITA 36

Table 10 – Evening Peak Sidra Comparison at Tamaki Drive

Table 11 – Saturday Peak Sidra Comparison at Tamaki Drive

The degree of saturation is a ratio of traffic volume to capacity. The usual

limit for planning exercises is around 0.9. None of the tested options get above

0.87 indicating traffic flows are only 87% of available capacity. We have

adopted the delay (Sidra) definition of Level of Service and as shown in the

tables none of the intersection turns tested exceed Level of Service ‘D’. Level

of Service E is the usual limit for planning.

LANE LEVEL OF SERVICE

Lane Level of Service

Site: 101 [PM Dev Tamaki Dr Patteson Ave] Project Beachside Mission Bay Site Category: (None) Signals - Fixed Time Isolated Cycle Time = 80 seconds (Site Practical Cycle Time) Variable Sequence Analysis applied. The results are given for the selected output sequence.

Approaches Intersection South East West LOS D C C C

485 ITA Report 090818 Parlane & Associates Ltd 89 Project Beachside Mission Bay ITA 37

Site Level of Service (LOS) Method: Delay (SIDRA). Site LOS Method is specified in the Parameter Settings dialog (Site tab). Lane LOS values are based on average delay per lane. Intersection and Approach LOS values are based on average delay for all lanes. SIDRA Standard Delay Model is used. Control Delay includes Geometric Delay.

Figure 24: Levels of Service with Project Beachside during the Evening Peak

6.4 Patteson Avenue Carpark Entrance

The model of the Patteson Avenue carpark entrance is based on standard gap

acceptance criteria. Even with the additional traffic the carpark entrance is

likely to operate well. The model results in Tables 12 and 13 show that the

carpark entrance will operate at level of service ‘A’.

485 ITA Report 090818 Parlane & Associates Ltd 90 Project Beachside Mission Bay ITA 38

Table 12 – Evening Peak Sidra Comparison at Patteson Ave Entrance

Table 13 – Saturday Peak Sidra Comparison at Patteson Ave Entrance

6.5 Patteson Avenue Intersection with Marau Cres and Ronaki Rd

For completeness I have also modelled the intersection of Patteson Avenue

with Marau Crescent and Ronaki Road. The results show no significant

change in delay or the degree of saturation at that intersection.

485 ITA Report 090818 Parlane & Associates Ltd 91 Project Beachside Mission Bay ITA 39

Table 14 – Evening Peak Sidra Comparison at Patteson Ave Marau Cres

Table 15 – Evening Peak Sidra Comparison at Patteson Ave Marau Cres

485 ITA Report 090818 Parlane & Associates Ltd 92 Project Beachside Mission Bay ITA 40

7. UNITARY PLAN CONSENTS REQUIRED

7.1 Assessment Against AUP:OP Trip Generation Thresholds

The AUP:OP includes trip generation limits to define what level of

transportation assessment is required in rule E26.7.1. Specifically, the rule

requires an assessment where there are more than 100 dwellings3 or where

there is more than 1,667 sqm of retail activity4. The project triggers both of

these thresholds so it requires an assessment under section E27.8.2(3) of the

AUP:OP.

E27.8.2 Criterion Assessment

(3) any activity or subdivision which exceeds the trip generation thresholds under Standard E27.6.1: (a) the effects on the function (a) A full assessment of traffic effects using and the safe and efficient capacity modelling has shown no operation of the transport network including pedestrian significant changes to delay or congestion movement, particularly at peak at peak times. Wide footpaths and traffic times; visibility splays will ensure a high level of pedestrian amenity and safety. b) the implementation of (b) The project includes a mix of activities mitigation measures proposed that generate traffic at different times and to address adverse effects which may include measures in different peak directions. The site now such as travel planning, fronts a high frequency bus service. The providing alternatives to private project complies with cycle parking rules vehicle trips including accessibility to public transport, and has access to a high quality cycling staging development, or environment. contributing to improvements to the local transport network; or (c) the trip characteristics of the (c) Trip generation has been fully assessed. proposed activity on the site. The combination of both residential and commercial activities on one site will have significant benefits. The site has great connectivity to local streets and amenities.

3 AUP:OP Table E27.6.1.1 (Line T1). 4 Ibid Line T8 as modified by Plan Change 4.

485 ITA Report 090818 Parlane & Associates Ltd 93 Project Beachside Mission Bay ITA 41

Table 16 Assessment in Terms of Trip Generation Thresholds

In my view the project meets the assessment criteria and can be approved.

7.2 Maximum Ramp Gradient

The inside radius of the curved ramp down from the Ground level to

Basement 1 has a maximum gradient of 1 in 5. This exceeds the maximum

gradient of 1 in 6 for ‘other’ activities as set out in E27.6.4.4 of the AUP:OP.

The ramp also provides access to residential parking on the Basement 1 level

and it complies with the requirements of a gradient of 1 in 5 specified for

access to residential parking.

The AUP:OP does not contain any specific assessment criteria dealing with

this issue however it does refer in section E27.9(1)(b) to the

AS/NZS2890.1:2004 standard. I have assessed the proposed ramp against that

standard and found that it complies. Section 2.5.3(a)(ii) of AS/NZS2890.1:2004

allows for gradients of up to 1 in 5 where ramps serving commercial activities

are less than 20 metres long.

In my view the ramp will work well, and a consent can be granted.

8. CONSTRUCTION EFFECTS

A detailed Construction Traffic Management Plan (“TMP”) will be required

for this project to ensure that the works can be carried out without creating

safety or capacity problems. That plan should be required as a condition of

consent with approval required from Auckland Transport (“AT”) prior to the

start of demolition of the existing buildings. While it is not possible to set out

specific details at this time we can assess likely construction traffic issues to

ensure temporary traffic effects are avoided, remedied or mitigated.

485 ITA Report 090818 Parlane & Associates Ltd 94 Project Beachside Mission Bay ITA 42

An earlier resource consent for a major excavation of the site was issued by

the Auckland Council. This consent allowed for the removal of 30,000 cubic

metres of material from the site with approximately 7800 to 8000 truck

movements. The current application requires the removal of a greater amount

of material, however the use of trucks with trailers and direct access from

Tamaki Drive will allow the effects of the truck traffic to be reduced. A bulk

Earthworks Report has been prepared by Dodds Civil Consultants detailing

the quantities and programme for excavation.

8.1 Demolition and Excavation

Demolition of the existing buildings will require closure of the footpaths.

Demolition is not expected to take long, but during that period the footpaths

will need to be closed to protect public safety. The existing bus stop on

Patteson Avenue will need to be relocated temporarily while the existing

building is deconstructed. The best place to locate the temporary bus stop is

further south on Patteson Avenue on the site frontage.

The excavation of two basement levels will require a significant number of

trucks with trailers to visit the site to be loaded, and to exit the site to dispose

of the material. Dodds Civil Consultants have estimated that earthworks will

require the removal of 35,000 cubic metres of material generating 50 truck and

trailer units per day for approximately 90 days of operations.

Marau Crescent is not a suitable place for large trucks and Patteson Avenue

has a bus stop that will need to be maintained, so it is anticipated that the

Tamaki Drive frontage will be the best place to provide access for heavy

vehicles. It is sensible to make provision for two loading bays on the Tamaki

Drive frontage and to also allow for trucks to completely enter the site from

485 ITA Report 090818 Parlane & Associates Ltd 95 Project Beachside Mission Bay ITA 43

Tamaki Drive right up to the point where the excavation no longer makes

access possible.

This means there will be an entrance from Tamaki Drive, two loading spaces

and an exit.

As the footpath will need to be kept open to serve the neighbouring businesses

and to allow access to the centre from the east an overhead gantry will be

required over the footpath.

An additional loading space should also be provided on Patteson Avenue

south of the bus stop to provide for deliveries to the southern part of the site.

The peak number of trucks is likely to occur during the excavation phase.

However, the use of trucks with trailers will minimise the number of vehicle

movements and provided the loading spaces and access points are controlled

by site traffic management supervisors or flag marshals, then pedestrian

safety can be maintained.

While the current proposal requires the excavation of more material than the

previous consent for earthworks granted by the Council, the use of truck and

trailer units and the ability to use Tamaki Drive for loading means the actual

traffic effects will be reduced.

8.2 Construction

During the construction phase it is anticipated that one loading space on

Patteson Avenue and two on Tamaki Drive will be more than enough to

service the site. The overhead gantries will be maintained to protect

pedestrians.

485 ITA Report 090818 Parlane & Associates Ltd 96 Project Beachside Mission Bay ITA 44

8.3 Temporary Traffic and Pedestrian Effects

The most important aspect of ensuring a safe pedestrian and traffic

environment is that a detailed TMP should be prepared once the detailed

design of the site is completed.

A 2.4-metre-high hoarding has been recommended by the acoustic engineers

to mitigate noise. This hoarding will also limit access to the site to the

managed site access points where traffic safety supervisors can ensure trucks

do not pose a safety issue to pedestrians.

Specific applications will be required to AT for the following:

 the TMP;

 an application in advance of the temporary relocation of the bus stop

 an application prior to closure of the footpaths for demolition

 an application to remove parking associated with the Patteson

Avenue loading space.

485 ITA Report 090818 Parlane & Associates Ltd 97 Project Beachside Mission Bay ITA 45

Legend Loading Spaces and Access Public Protection Gantry Acoustic 2.4m Fence

Figure 25: Temporary Traffic Management

485 ITA Report 090818 Parlane & Associates Ltd 98 Project Beachside Mission Bay ITA 46

9. CONCLUSION

The project is not expected to result in any noticeable adverse traffic

congestion or safety effects. The project is designed to have a large carpark

with separate access points for the visitor traffic and the residential traffic.

The Marau Crescent access would only serve residential users.

Computer modelling has shown there would be no significant capacity effects

during typical design periods. Of course the nature of Tamaki Drive and

Mission Bay is that there are times of the year that are particularly busy. At

those times there can be significant queues and delays on

Tamaki Drive through Mission Bay. That is already the baseline and the

project is unlikely to make that noticeably worse.

The project has a significant basement excavation and there are likely to be

many truck loads of waste material over a reasonable period. The effects of

this activity cannot be avoided but they can be mitigated by limiting most

trucks to using only Tamaki Drive. The footpaths will need to be kept open

to the public at all times except when demolition is occurring to the facades of

the buildings.

John Parlane BE(Civil), BApplEcon, CMEngNZ Consulting Traffic Engineer

14 August 2018

485 ITA Report 090818 Parlane & Associates Ltd 99 Project Beachside Mission Bay ITA 47

10. ATTACHMENT 1 – CHANGES TO PARKING CONTROLS

Figure 26: Proposed Parking Controls (Subject to Auckland Transport Approvals and Resolutions)

485 ITA Report 090818 Parlane & Associates Ltd 100 Project Beachside Mission Bay ITA 48

11. ATTACHMENT 2– PARKING DIMENSIONS

All parking spaces comply with the rules of the AUP:OP as set out below.

Aisles have been designed to be 7.0 metres wide. Casual spaces are 2.6 metres

wide while residents parking is 2.5 metres wide.

Location Number of Width Aisle Required Standard

Spaces of width Aisle Table

Spaces E27.6.3.1.1

Ground 38 Visitor 2.6m 7.0m 7.0m Complies with Casual

Floor Spaces Parking (T122)

4 Accessible 3.5m 7.0m 6.7m Complies with

Spaces NZ4121

Basement 1 58 Retail 2.6m 7.0m 7.0m Complies with Casual

Spaces Parking (T122)

36 Residents’ 2.5m 7.0m 6.7m Complies with

Spaces Regular Parking

(T118)

Basement 2 108 Residents’ 2.5 7.0m 6.7m Complies with

Spaces Regular Parking

(T118)

21 Stacked 2.5m Stacked Stacked Complies with

Spaces E27.6.3.3(3)

485 ITA Report 090818 Parlane & Associates Ltd 101 Project Beachside Mission Bay ITA 49

12. ATTACHMENT 3 – FUTURE TRAFFIC FLOWS

Figure 27: Future Evening Peak Car Traffic

485 ITA Report 090818 Parlane & Associates Ltd 102 Project Beachside Mission Bay ITA 50

Figure 28: Future Saturday Peak Car Traffic

485 ITA Report 090818 Parlane & Associates Ltd 103 104 105 106 107 108 109 110 111 112 113 114 115 Linda Butler

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz Sent: Wednesday, 12 September 2018 10:15 AM To: Central RC Submissions Cc: [email protected] & Subject: [ID:1531] Submission received on notified resource consent

Follow Up Flag: Follow up Flag Status: Completed

We have received a submission on the notified resource consent for 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28, & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay.. Details of submission

Notified resource consent application details

Property address: 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28, & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay.

Application number: BUN60324987

Applicant name: Drive Holdings Limited

Applicant email: [email protected] & [email protected]

Application description: Drive Holdings Limited has applied for resource consent to demolish all existing buildings on the land, construct seven new multi-level buildings extending across the entire area, providing for retail, food & beverage, entertainment (cinema) and residential activities. Land use consent and a ground-water diversion permit is required and assessed together as a discretionary activity under the Auckland Unitary Plan (OIP). Closing date for submissions: Midnight, 10 October 2018.

Submitter contact details

Full name: Antony Guy Jack Brabant

Organisation name:

Contact phone number: 0212214746

Email address: [email protected]

Postal address: 44 Comins Crescent Mission Bay Auckland 1071

Submission details

This submission: supports the application in whole or in part

Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: The entire application my wife and I are in support of.

What are the reasons for your submission? We believe that this part of Mission Bay is extremely tired and in need of a full upgrade to realise its full potential.

1 116 What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? I would like the Council to look favourably at the submission.

Are you a trade competitor of the applicant? I am not a trade competitor of the applicant.

Do you want to attend a hearing and speak in support of your submission? Yes

If other people make a similar submission I will consider making a joint case with them at the hearing: Yes

Supporting information:

2 117 Linda Butler

From: Robyn Pilkington on behalf of Central RC Submissions Sent: Wednesday, 12 September 2018 12:56 PM To: Premium Submissions Subject: SUB3 - FW: [ID:1534] Submission received on notified resource consent

Follow Up Flag: Follow up Flag Status: Completed

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz [mailto:NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz] Sent: Wednesday, 12 September 2018 12:30 p.m. To: Central RC Submissions Cc: [email protected] & Subject: [ID:1534] Submission received on notified resource consent

Notified resource consent application details

Property address: 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28, & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay.

Application number: BUN60324987

Applicant name: Drive Holdings Limited

Applicant email: [email protected] & [email protected]

Submitter contact details

Full name: Pam Rudelj

Organisation name:

Contact phone number: 021665503

Email address: [email protected]

Postal address: Apt9/9 Marau Cres Mission Bay Auckland 1071

Submission details 1 118 This submission: opposes the application in whole or in part

Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Height of Building Number of Apartments

What are the reasons for your submission? As a local resident, I am aware that progress is inevitable in Mission Bay. It has the ambiance of being more than 10 minutes away from the Central City, making it attractive to tourists and locals. The amount of residential dwellings is unrealistic. Unless radical changes are made to roading and parking. The surrounding narrow streets are unrealistic now, this will become a major problem. The properties in Ronaki Rd would lose sunlight due to the building’s height. Effort should be made to keep the existing iconic feel of the area. Let’s not make it another Surfers Paradise or Waikiki where all character is lost!

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Building Height reduced. Iconic buildings integrated( realise these are not original Art Deco) Less residential dwellings. Unrealistic. Upgrade of surrounding footpaths and traffic which unfortunately are already a disgrace.

Are you a trade competitor of the applicant? I am not a trade competitor of the applicant.

Do you want to attend a hearing and speak in support of your submission? No

If other people make a similar submission I will consider making a joint case with them at the hearing: Yes

Supporting information:

2 119 Linda Butler

From: Robyn Pilkington on behalf of Central RC Submissions Sent: Thursday, 13 September 2018 8:21 AM To: Premium Submissions Subject: Sub4 - FW: [ID:1539] Submission received on notified resource consent

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz [mailto:NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz] Sent: Wednesday, 12 September 2018 2:30 p.m. To: Central RC Submissions Cc: [email protected] & Subject: [ID:1539] Submission received on notified resource consent

Notified resource consent application details

Property address: 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28, & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay.

Application number: BUN60324987

Applicant name: Drive Holdings Limited

Applicant email: [email protected] & [email protected]

Submitter contact details

Full name: Robyn Ballantyne

Organisation name:

Contact phone number: 0274404652

Email address: [email protected]

Postal address: 96 Selwyn Ave Mission Bay Auckland 1071

Submission details

This submission: opposes the application in whole or in part

1 120 Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: The height and style of development.

What are the reasons for your submission? The intended height is well beyond and above what is allowable under the Unitary Plan. I don't think the development should predominately be for a few wealthy apartment dwellers. It should be predominately as it is now - for all to enjoy the amenities, shops and parking. The design is very "Gold Coast", not at all in keeping with the iconic current style and incorporates no beach or pacifika elements. I agree the current buildings need updating but the development design could be so much more attractive and iconic and representative of the area.The houses behind on Marua Cres will most certainly be affected in their outlook and sea views.

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Enforce the height restrictions strictly. Make sure at least two levels are shops, restaurants, cinema. Make sure the incorporated parking spaces will be available to the public and not just apartment residents, and at a fair price. Request that they come up with a more attractive design. Have some influence over the lease rates that will be charged - there are already too many empty spaces in current buildings in Mission Bay because this developer owns most of the area and charges far too much rent and it drives business out which is detrimental to the public's enjoyment of the area.

Are you a trade competitor of the applicant? I am not a trade competitor of the applicant.

Do you want to attend a hearing and speak in support of your submission? No

If other people make a similar submission I will consider making a joint case with them at the hearing: No

Supporting information:

2 121 Linda Butler

From: Robyn Pilkington on behalf of Central RC Submissions Sent: Thursday, 13 September 2018 8:21 AM To: Premium Submissions Subject: Sub5 - FW: [ID:1541] Submission received on notified resource consent

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz [mailto:NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz] Sent: Wednesday, 12 September 2018 3:30 p.m. To: Central RC Submissions Cc: [email protected] & Subject: [ID:1541] Submission received on notified resource consent

Notified resource consent application details

Property address: 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28, & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay.

Application number: BUN60324987

Applicant name: Drive Holdings Limited

Applicant email: [email protected] & [email protected]

Submitter contact details

Full name: Manuel Venegas

Organisation name:

Contact phone number: +64274062922

Email address: [email protected]

Postal address: 9A Cliff Road Auckland Auckland 1071

Submission details

This submission: opposes the application in whole or in part

1 122 Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Don't want to see more carparks and lots of more building bringing more people to an already over populated beach throughout the year

What are the reasons for your submission? Before it was only during the summer months that Mission Bay was busy, now it's all year round. Don't mess with the classical look, that's what attracts lots of people today, and considering the space it's quite messy. If you bring more people, it would be unmanageable and Tamaki Drive will collapse. You will also be killing a classic view that represents Auckland and overall, New Zealand. Leave the green and the looks!

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Cancel this and any other so called "Improvement" project to Mission Bay that considers bringing down beautiful buildings and change our landscape.

Are you a trade competitor of the applicant? I am not a trade competitor of the applicant.

Do you want to attend a hearing and speak in support of your submission? Yes

If other people make a similar submission I will consider making a joint case with them at the hearing: Yes

Supporting information:

2 123 Linda Butler

From: Robyn Pilkington on behalf of Central RC Submissions Sent: Thursday, 13 September 2018 8:23 AM To: Premium Submissions Subject: Sub7 - FW: [ID:1551] Submission received on notified resource consent

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz [mailto:NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz] Sent: Wednesday, 12 September 2018 7:15 p.m. To: Central RC Submissions Cc: [email protected] & Subject: [ID:1551] Submission received on notified resource consent

Notified resource consent application details

Property address: 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28, & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay.

Application number: BUN60324987

Applicant name: Drive Holdings Limited

Applicant email: [email protected] & [email protected]

Submitter contact details

Full name: Lisa Moore-Bocarro

Organisation name:

Contact phone number: 0272889048

Email address: [email protected]

Postal address: 63 Ngaio St Orakei Auckland 1071

Submission details

This submission: opposes the application in whole or in part

1 124 Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: The overall design, including the height.

What are the reasons for your submission? The design should be in at least in keeping with the heritage of the area and the existing buildings. The area will lose all its soul, and part of the reason Misson Bay is a tourist attraction. Replacing the existing buildings with such a generic and modern style, especially at the proposed height completely changes the area, and not for the better.

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Not allow the application to proceed in its current form and design

Are you a trade competitor of the applicant? I am not a trade competitor of the applicant.

Do you want to attend a hearing and speak in support of your submission? No

If other people make a similar submission I will consider making a joint case with them at the hearing: Yes

Supporting information:

2 125 Linda Butler

From: Robyn Pilkington on behalf of Central RC Submissions Sent: Thursday, 13 September 2018 8:23 AM To: Premium Submissions Subject: Sub8 - FW: [ID:1552] Submission received on notified resource consent

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz [mailto:NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz] Sent: Wednesday, 12 September 2018 7:45 p.m. To: Central RC Submissions Cc: [email protected] & Subject: [ID:1552] Submission received on notified resource consent

Notified resource consent application details

Property address: 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28, & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay.

Application number: BUN60324987

Applicant name: Drive Holdings Limited

Applicant email: [email protected] & [email protected]

Submitter contact details

Full name: Jane Martinovich

Organisation name:

Contact phone number: 0212553990

Email address: [email protected]

Postal address: 37 Marau Cres mission bay Auckland 1071

Submission details

This submission: opposes the application in whole or in part

1 126 Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: I oppose the development of a building over 2 stories high

What are the reasons for your submission?

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Apply a height restriction

Are you a trade competitor of the applicant? I am not a trade competitor of the applicant.

Do you want to attend a hearing and speak in support of your submission? No

If other people make a similar submission I will consider making a joint case with them at the hearing: Yes

Supporting information:

2 127 128 Linda Butler

From: Robyn Pilkington on behalf of Central RC Submissions Sent: Thursday, 13 September 2018 8:24 AM To: Premium Submissions Subject: Sub10 - FW: [ID:1559] Submission received on notified resource consent

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz [mailto:NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz] Sent: Wednesday, 12 September 2018 11:15 p.m. To: Central RC Submissions Cc: [email protected] & Subject: [ID:1559] Submission received on notified resource consent

Notified resource consent application details

Property address: 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28, & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay.

Application number: BUN60324987

Applicant name: Drive Holdings Limited

Applicant email: [email protected] & [email protected]

Submitter contact details

Full name: German Fernandez

Organisation name:

Contact phone number: 0226461263

Email address: [email protected]

Postal address: 14 WILLIAM FRASER CRESCENT ST HELIERS AUCKLAND 1071

Submission details

This submission: opposes the application in whole or in part

1 129 Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: The scale of the project in an place that could be in the near future a heritage area.

What are the reasons for your submission? Impact in the communities sorrounding this project.

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Not to allow this project.

Are you a trade competitor of the applicant? I am not a trade competitor of the applicant.

Do you want to attend a hearing and speak in support of your submission? Yes

If other people make a similar submission I will consider making a joint case with them at the hearing: Yes

Supporting information:

2 130 Linda Butler

From: Robyn Pilkington on behalf of Central RC Submissions Sent: Thursday, 13 September 2018 8:24 AM To: Premium Submissions Subject: Sub11 - FW: [ID:1563] Submission received on notified resource consent

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz [mailto:NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz] Sent: Thursday, 13 September 2018 8:15 a.m. To: Central RC Submissions Cc: [email protected] & Subject: [ID:1563] Submission received on notified resource consent

Notified resource consent application details

Property address: 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28, & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay.

Application number: BUN60324987

Applicant name: Drive Holdings Limited

Applicant email: [email protected] & [email protected]

Submitter contact details

Full name: matthew nant

Organisation name:

Contact phone number: +6421879087

Email address: [email protected]

Postal address: 121B Selwyn Ave Mission Bay Auckland 1071

Submission details

This submission: opposes the application in whole or in part

1 131 Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Construction of commercial and residential activities

What are the reasons for your submission? Loss of character, architecture and aesthetic skyline.

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? To decline the application. If unsuccessful, prohibit real estate companies and banks from occupying commercial spaces. These premises should be for dining and entertainment purposes only encouraging nightlife.

Are you a trade competitor of the applicant? I am not a trade competitor of the applicant.

Do you want to attend a hearing and speak in support of your submission? Yes

If other people make a similar submission I will consider making a joint case with them at the hearing: Yes

Supporting information:

2 132 Linda Butler

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz Sent: Thursday, 13 September 2018 10:15 AM To: Central RC Submissions Cc: [email protected] & Subject: Sub12 - [ID:1566] Submission received on notified resource consent

Notified resource consent application details

Property address: 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28, & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay.

Application number: BUN60324987

Applicant name: Drive Holdings Limited

Applicant email: [email protected] & [email protected]

Submitter contact details

Full name: Robert Murray

Organisation name:

Contact phone number: 0273087578

Email address: [email protected]

Postal address: 132 Kohimarama Road Kohimarama Auckland 1071

Submission details

This submission: opposes the application in whole or in part

Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: I am strongly protesting against this development. In particular I am against the development given the "Assessment of Landscape and Visual Effects."

What are the reasons for your submission? I am a local resident and feel very passionately that what little heritage and history Auckland has should be maintained. You are taking a beautiful and peaceful sea side suburb and turning it into another gold coast or Dubai. You are destroying what little heritage is left in Auckland. Finally, you are ignoring your own law. You are showing all of Auckland that rules and regulations do not apply to the rich. You are weakening your own authority and ignoring a long consent process. What was the purpose of a series of town hall meetings, back and forth's only to then ignore 1 133 completely the specifications you agreed to? This plan is a law. What is the purpose of laws and rules if they are not upheld and the rich can subvert them. Why shouldn't I build a block of flats in my 60m garden? If a developer is able to ignore guidelines then why shouldn't I? Put a line in the sand and enforce your own laws!

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? I firmly believe the council should do their job and enforce the unitary plan regarding the height of this proposed development and should force the developer to retain these heritage buildings. If permitted you will make a mockery of any development law and permit the destruction of some of the most character filled buildings in Auckland.

Are you a trade competitor of the applicant? I am not a trade competitor of the applicant.

Do you want to attend a hearing and speak in support of your submission? Yes

If other people make a similar submission I will consider making a joint case with them at the hearing: Yes

Supporting information:

2 134 Linda Butler

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz Sent: Thursday, 13 September 2018 11:45 AM To: Central RC Submissions Cc: [email protected] & Subject: Sub13 - [ID:1570] Submission received on notified resource consent

Notified resource consent application details

Property address: 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28, & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay.

Application number: BUN60324987

Applicant name: Drive Holdings Limited

Applicant email: [email protected] & [email protected]

Submitter contact details

Full name: Junette Elizabeth Marylyn Wrathall

Organisation name:

Contact phone number: 09 521 6184

Email address: [email protected]

Postal address: 4/43 Tamaki Drive, Mission Bay Auckland 1071

Submission details

This submission: supports the application in whole or in part

Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: All aspects

What are the reasons for your submission? I support the whole of the application

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Nil

1 135 Are you a trade competitor of the applicant? I am not a trade competitor of the applicant.

Do you want to attend a hearing and speak in support of your submission? No

If other people make a similar submission I will consider making a joint case with them at the hearing: Yes

Supporting information:

2 136 Linda Butler

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz Sent: Thursday, 13 September 2018 1:30 PM To: Central RC Submissions Cc: [email protected] & Subject: Sub14 - [ID:1572] Submission received on notified resource consent

Notified resource consent application details

Property address: 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28, & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay.

Application number: BUN60324987

Applicant name: Drive Holdings Limited

Applicant email: [email protected] & [email protected]

Submitter contact details

Full name: Anthony Goddard

Organisation name:

Contact phone number: 0225225856

Email address: [email protected]

Postal address: 1/19 Selwyn Avenue Mission Bay Auckland 1071

Submission details

This submission: opposes the application in whole or in part

Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Demolition of existing buildings, construction of seven new buildings

What are the reasons for your submission? 1. Certain of the existing buildings have special character and should be preserved. 2. Traffic flow and parking in Mission Bay is already overloaded on sunny weekends. Intensification of residences, retail and F&B will cause massive traffic and parking problems that can't be solved on the waterfront.

1 137 What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Reject the proposal in full.

Are you a trade competitor of the applicant? I am not a trade competitor of the applicant.

Do you want to attend a hearing and speak in support of your submission? No

If other people make a similar submission I will consider making a joint case with them at the hearing: No

Supporting information:

2 138 Linda Butler

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz Sent: Thursday, 13 September 2018 3:15 PM To: Central RC Submissions Cc: [email protected] & Subject: Sub15 - [ID:1575] Submission received on notified resource consent

Follow Up Flag: Follow up Flag Status: Completed

Notified resource consent application details

Property address: 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28, & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay.

Application number: BUN60324987

Applicant name: Drive Holdings Limited

Applicant email: [email protected] & [email protected]

Submitter contact details

Full name: Georgina Sawyer

Organisation name:

Contact phone number: 0212729229

Email address: [email protected]

Postal address: 89 Rukutai Street Orakei Auckland 1071

Submission details

This submission: supports the application in whole or in part

Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Building height Architecture Cinema

What are the reasons for your submission? I live in the neighbourhood and am in the immediate area daily

1 139 What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Reduce the height to max of 3 stories Make cinema an essential element Change architecture to something more modern - like teh new Pavillion. Current drawings look like an Australian shopping mall and will look like Surfers Paradise in a few years. Ugly.

Are you a trade competitor of the applicant? I am not a trade competitor of the applicant.

Do you want to attend a hearing and speak in support of your submission? No

If other people make a similar submission I will consider making a joint case with them at the hearing: Yes

Supporting information:

2 140 Linda Butler

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz Sent: Thursday, 13 September 2018 4:30 PM To: Central RC Submissions Cc: [email protected] & Subject: Sub16 - [ID:1577] Submission received on notified resource consent

Follow Up Flag: Follow up Flag Status: Completed

Notified resource consent application details

Property address: 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28, & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay.

Application number: BUN60324987

Applicant name: Drive Holdings Limited

Applicant email: [email protected] & [email protected]

Submitter contact details

Full name: Chris Wadsworth

Organisation name:

Contact phone number: 0211602901

Email address: [email protected]

Postal address: Po Box 41071 St Lukes Auckland 1346

Submission details

This submission: opposes the application in whole or in part

Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Loss of existing character heritage

What are the reasons for your submission?

1 141 What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? ;'k"

Are you a trade competitor of the applicant? I am not a trade competitor of the applicant.

Do you want to attend a hearing and speak in support of your submission? No

If other people make a similar submission I will consider making a joint case with them at the hearing: Yes

Supporting information:

2 142 Linda Butler

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz Sent: Thursday, 13 September 2018 5:00 PM To: Central RC Submissions Cc: [email protected] & Subject: Sub17 - [ID:1578] Submission received on notified resource consent

Follow Up Flag: Follow up Flag Status: Completed

Notified resource consent application details

Property address: 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28, & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay.

Application number: BUN60324987

Applicant name: Drive Holdings Limited

Applicant email: [email protected] & [email protected]

Submitter contact details

Full name: KIm Michelle Posner

Organisation name:

Contact phone number: 0274188520

Email address: [email protected]

Postal address: 54 Rosepark Crescent St Johns Auckland 1050

Submission details

This submission: opposes the application in whole or in part

Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Height of the development.

What are the reasons for your submission?

1 143 What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? It is my understanding that the proposed development is not within the height restrictions of the unitary plan. I don't think my money should be wasted on a plan that doesn't mean anything if developers can just do as they please. The development is too high and will spoil the special character of the area. I would like to see revised plans that are in keeping with the unitary plan. I also don't like the "building block" style of the bulidings. Can't the designers come up with a more attractive, cohesive design? It looks cheap.

Are you a trade competitor of the applicant? I am not a trade competitor of the applicant.

Do you want to attend a hearing and speak in support of your submission? No

If other people make a similar submission I will consider making a joint case with them at the hearing: Yes

Supporting information:

2 144 Linda Butler

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz Sent: Thursday, 13 September 2018 5:15 PM To: Central RC Submissions Cc: [email protected] & Subject: Sub18 - [ID:1579] Submission received on notified resource consent

Follow Up Flag: Follow up Flag Status: Completed

Notified resource consent application details

Property address: 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28, & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay.

Application number: BUN60324987

Applicant name: Drive Holdings Limited

Applicant email: [email protected] & [email protected]

Submitter contact details

Full name: Lucy Duncan

Organisation name:

Contact phone number: 09 5284331

Email address: [email protected]

Postal address: 148A Selwyn Avenue Mission Bay Auckland 1071

Submission details

This submission: opposes the application in whole or in part

Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Under the Unitary Plan the maximum allowable occupied height is 16m. This application prosposes nearly double this height. The height is in contravention of this.

1 145 What are the reasons for your submission? This application flies in the face of the Unitary Plan and would create a precedent for further such development and also does not fit in with its environs.

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? The development of this site is necessary but should be within the constricts of the Unitary Plan. It needs to be of good quality construction, in keeping with the locality and definitely needs a substantial reduction in height.

Are you a trade competitor of the applicant? I am not a trade competitor of the applicant.

Do you want to attend a hearing and speak in support of your submission? No

If other people make a similar submission I will consider making a joint case with them at the hearing: Yes

Supporting information:

2 146 Linda Butler

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz Sent: Thursday, 13 September 2018 5:45 PM To: Central RC Submissions Cc: [email protected] & Subject: Sub19 - [ID:1580] Submission received on notified resource consent

Follow Up Flag: Follow up Flag Status: Completed

Notified resource consent application details

Property address: 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28, & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay.

Application number: BUN60324987

Applicant name: Drive Holdings Limited

Applicant email: [email protected] & [email protected]

Submitter contact details

Full name: Hadeel Kadir

Organisation name:

Contact phone number: 0276920709

Email address: [email protected]

Postal address: 1/30 Felton Mathew Avenue Saint Johns AUCKLAND 1072

Submission details

This submission: is neutral regarding the application in whole or in part

Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: NA

What are the reasons for your submission?

1 147 What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Keep as is

Are you a trade competitor of the applicant? I am not a trade competitor of the applicant.

Do you want to attend a hearing and speak in support of your submission? Yes

If other people make a similar submission I will consider making a joint case with them at the hearing: No

Supporting information:

2 148 Linda Butler

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz Sent: Thursday, 13 September 2018 6:15 PM To: Central RC Submissions Cc: [email protected] & Subject: Sub20 - [ID:1583] Submission received on notified resource consent

Notified resource consent application details

Property address: 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28, & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay.

Application number: BUN60324987

Applicant name: Drive Holdings Limited

Applicant email: [email protected] & [email protected]

Submitter contact details

Full name: Chris von Batenburg

Organisation name:

Contact phone number: 021828521

Email address: [email protected]

Postal address: 3A Sprott Rd Kohimarama Auckland 1071

Submission details

This submission: opposes the application in whole or in part

Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: The building is too high, and is ugly

What are the reasons for your submission? Local resident

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Make the applicant reapply with a better designed option

1 149 Are you a trade competitor of the applicant? I am not a trade competitor of the applicant.

Do you want to attend a hearing and speak in support of your submission? No

If other people make a similar submission I will consider making a joint case with them at the hearing: Yes

Supporting information:

2 150 Linda Butler

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz Sent: Thursday, 13 September 2018 6:45 PM To: Central RC Submissions Cc: [email protected] & Subject: Sub21 - [ID:1584] Submission received on notified resource consent

Notified resource consent application details

Property address: 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28, & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay.

Application number: BUN60324987

Applicant name: Drive Holdings Limited

Applicant email: [email protected] & [email protected]

Submitter contact details

Full name: Darren Anderson

Organisation name:

Contact phone number: 0226571744

Email address: [email protected]

Postal address: 44 Smythe Rd Henderson Auckland 0612

Submission details

This submission: opposes the application in whole or in part

Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Changing the character and not retaining historic buildings

What are the reasons for your submission? The buildings and character of the buildings are what makes the area. Replacing classic historic building with low cost boring designs lower the class of what is beautiful

1 151 What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? I would like to see the buildings strengthened to modern earth quake standards and added to with extensions if required. Some times a classic modern combination looks cool and retains the character of the area. A compromise.

Are you a trade competitor of the applicant? I am not a trade competitor of the applicant.

Do you want to attend a hearing and speak in support of your submission? No

If other people make a similar submission I will consider making a joint case with them at the hearing: No

Supporting information:

2 152 Linda Butler

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz Sent: Thursday, 13 September 2018 8:00 PM To: Central RC Submissions Cc: [email protected] & Subject: Sub22 - [ID:1587] Submission received on notified resource consent

Notified resource consent application details

Property address: 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28, & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay.

Application number: BUN60324987

Applicant name: Drive Holdings Limited

Applicant email: [email protected] & [email protected]

Submitter contact details

Full name: Mark Herbstein

Organisation name:

Contact phone number: 0212888027

Email address: [email protected]

Postal address: 17 Kempthorne crescent Mission Bay Auckland 1071

Submission details

This submission: opposes the application in whole or in part

Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Generally I'd like to preserve the classic Mission Bay look that I know and love. I don't want to see Mission Bay turned into a commercial place with no parking and too many people.

What are the reasons for your submission? I don't want to see Mission Bay all fancy and commercial I love it the way it is now.

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Don't approve this development. Mission Bay is perfect the way it is.

1 153 Are you a trade competitor of the applicant? I am not a trade competitor of the applicant.

Do you want to attend a hearing and speak in support of your submission? No

If other people make a similar submission I will consider making a joint case with them at the hearing: Yes

Supporting information:

2 154 Linda Butler

From: Robyn Pilkington on behalf of Central RC Submissions Sent: Friday, 14 September 2018 12:06 PM To: Premium Submissions Subject: Sub23 - FW: [ID:1599] Submission received on notified resource consent

Follow Up Flag: Follow up Flag Status: Completed

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz [mailto:NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz] Sent: Friday, 14 September 2018 11:31 a.m. To: Central RC Submissions Cc: [email protected] & Subject: [ID:1599] Submission received on notified resource consent

Notified resource consent application details

Property address: 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28, & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay.

Application number: BUN60324987

Applicant name: Drive Holdings Limited

Applicant email: [email protected] & [email protected]

Submitter contact details

Full name: Elizabeth Wright

Organisation name:

Contact phone number: 0274820081

Email address: [email protected]

Postal address: 16 Andes Avenue Mangere Bridge Auckland 2022

Submission details 1 155 This submission: supports the application in whole or in part

Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: I am submitting in favour of the proposal to rejuvenate the eastern side of Mission Bay’s centre. Mission Bay has long been in need of improvement and I am in support of the proposed project, and believe it will bring a much-needed upgrade to the area, while retaining its identity and purpose. I am pleased to see that the project has retained a focus on food and beverage outlets, ensuring the area will remain a popular destination for locals and visitors alike. The decision to keep the theatre in the new proposal has my full support. The current theatre is a much-loved aspect of the Mission Bay centre and it is pleasing to see it included in the proposal. The introduction of new accommodation delivers new value to the area and the replacement accommodation on Marau Street is a significant improvement on what is currently there. It is time for an upgrade at Mission Bay and I believe the proposal will transform Mission Bay for the better.

What are the reasons for your submission? I would like to see a positive outcome for this project. Mission Bay plays such a big part of many Aucklanders lives and to see it enhanced would be fantastic.

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Support for this project.

Are you a trade competitor of the applicant? I am not a trade competitor of the applicant.

Do you want to attend a hearing and speak in support of your submission? No

If other people make a similar submission I will consider making a joint case with them at the hearing: No

Supporting information:

2 156 Linda Butler

From: Robyn Pilkington on behalf of Central RC Submissions Sent: Friday, 14 September 2018 12:06 PM To: Premium Submissions Subject: Sub24 - FW: [ID:1600] Submission received on notified resource consent

Follow Up Flag: Follow up Flag Status: Completed

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz [mailto:NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz] Sent: Friday, 14 September 2018 11:31 a.m. To: Central RC Submissions Cc: [email protected] & Subject: [ID:1600] Submission received on notified resource consent

Notified resource consent application details

Property address: 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28, & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay.

Application number: BUN60324987

Applicant name: Drive Holdings Limited

Applicant email: [email protected] & [email protected]

Submitter contact details

Full name: Guy Richardson

Organisation name:

Contact phone number: 0273151015

Email address: [email protected]

Postal address: 10 Cowell place Onehunga Auckland 1061

Submission details 1 157 This submission: supports the application in whole or in part

Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Height

What are the reasons for your submission? Fully support the height of the new buildings

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? None

Are you a trade competitor of the applicant? I am not a trade competitor of the applicant.

Do you want to attend a hearing and speak in support of your submission? No

If other people make a similar submission I will consider making a joint case with them at the hearing: No

Supporting information:

2 158 Linda Butler

From: Robyn Pilkington on behalf of Central RC Submissions Sent: Friday, 14 September 2018 2:59 PM To: Premium Submissions Subject: Sub 25 - FW: [ID:1602] Submission received on notified resource consent

Follow Up Flag: Follow up Flag Status: Completed

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz [mailto:NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz] Sent: Friday, 14 September 2018 12:46 p.m. To: Central RC Submissions Cc: [email protected] & Subject: [ID:1602] Submission received on notified resource consent

Notified resource consent application details

Property address: 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28, & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay.

Application number: BUN60324987

Applicant name: Drive Holdings Limited

Applicant email: [email protected] & [email protected]

Submitter contact details

Full name: Margaret Platt

Organisation name:

Contact phone number: 095207698

Email address: [email protected]

Postal address: 5/84 Kohimarama Road Kohimarama Auckland 1071

Submission details 1 159 This submission: opposes the application in whole or in part

Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: The proposed building is too high

What are the reasons for your submission? I would like the height restrictions down to what is allowed in the Council Unitary Plan. Mission Bay is beautiful beach we do not want it destroyed with huge high buildings, which will not benefit the local community at all. Lets keep the Iconic look as it is.

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Make the new proposed buildings inline with the Unitary Plan.

Are you a trade competitor of the applicant? I am not a trade competitor of the applicant.

Do you want to attend a hearing and speak in support of your submission? No

If other people make a similar submission I will consider making a joint case with them at the hearing: No

Supporting information:

2 160 Linda Butler

From: Robyn Pilkington on behalf of Central RC Submissions Sent: Friday, 14 September 2018 3:00 PM To: Premium Submissions Subject: Sub 26 - FW: [ID:1603] Submission received on notified resource consent

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz [mailto:NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz] Sent: Friday, 14 September 2018 1:31 p.m. To: Central RC Submissions Cc: [email protected] & Subject: [ID:1603] Submission received on notified resource consent

Notified resource consent application details

Property address: 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28, & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay.

Application number: BUN60324987

Applicant name: Drive Holdings Limited

Applicant email: [email protected] & [email protected]

Submitter contact details

Full name: Laura Austin

Organisation name:

Contact phone number: 0226505772

Email address: [email protected]

Postal address: 133 West Tamaki Rd Glen Innes Auckland 1072

Submission details

This submission: opposes the application in whole or in part

1 161 Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: The height of the development

What are the reasons for your submission? The plans show that the developers plan to go to 8 LEVELS which is nearly DOUBLE the height allowed under the Unitary plan. Not only will this block many people's views, but it will also completely visually dominate the area.

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Restrict the height

Are you a trade competitor of the applicant? I am not a trade competitor of the applicant.

Do you want to attend a hearing and speak in support of your submission? No

If other people make a similar submission I will consider making a joint case with them at the hearing: No

Supporting information:

2 162 Linda Butler

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz Sent: Friday, 14 September 2018 3:01 PM To: Central RC Submissions Cc: [email protected] & Subject: Sub 27 - [ID:1604] Submission received on notified resource consent

Notified resource consent application details

Property address: 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28, & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay.

Application number: BUN60324987

Applicant name: Drive Holdings Limited

Applicant email: [email protected] & [email protected]

Submitter contact details

Full name: Andrea Aragon Echano

Organisation name:

Contact phone number: 0225012008

Email address: [email protected]

Postal address: 2/17 Clarendon Road St. Heliers Auckland 1071

Submission details

This submission: opposes the application in whole or in part

Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: The demolition of the block of existing buildings.

What are the reasons for your submission? These buildings are as iconic to Mission Bay as its beach & fountain & the views of Rangitoto. If these buildings are demolished (especially the deFontein corner building & the Berkley cinema building), an irreplaceable part of Mission Bay will be lost. The new building design they have proposed does not at all reflect the spirit of Mission Bay. In my opinion, a big part of Mission Bay's soul will be lost if these buildings are demolished. Why can't they do something like what Singapore has been doing with their buildings? The Cathay on Orchard Road

1 163 (https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q779865) for example is a prime example of adaptive reuse that still preserves the beauty if the original building.

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Do not allow the destruction of the iconic Mission Bay art deco buildings. Look instead at adaptive reuse.

Are you a trade competitor of the applicant? I am not a trade competitor of the applicant.

Do you want to attend a hearing and speak in support of your submission? No

If other people make a similar submission I will consider making a joint case with them at the hearing: Yes

Supporting information:

2 164 Linda Butler

From: Robyn Pilkington on behalf of Central RC Submissions Sent: Friday, 14 September 2018 3:27 PM To: Premium Submissions Subject: Sub 28 - FW: [ID:1605] Submission received on notified resource consent

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz [mailto:NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz] Sent: Friday, 14 September 2018 3:16 p.m. To: Central RC Submissions Cc: [email protected] & Subject: [ID:1605] Submission received on notified resource consent

Notified resource consent application details

Property address: 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28, & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay.

Application number: BUN60324987

Applicant name: Drive Holdings Limited

Applicant email: [email protected] & [email protected]

Submitter contact details

Full name: Megan Burgess

Organisation name:

Contact phone number: +64211904609

Email address: [email protected]

Postal address: 10B Emily Lane Greenhithe Greenhithe 0632

Submission details

This submission: supports the application in whole or in part

1 165 Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: I am submitting in favour of the proposal to rejuvenate the eastern side of Mission Bay’s centre. Mission Bay has long been in need of improvement and I am in support of the proposed project, and believe it will bring a much-needed upgrade to the area, while retaining its identity and purpose. I am pleased to see that the project has retained a focus on food and beverage outlets, ensuring the area will remain a popular destination for locals and visitors alike. The decision to keep the theatre in the new proposal has my full support. The current theatre is a much-loved aspect of the Mission Bay centre and it is pleasing to see it included in the proposal. The introduction of new accommodation delivers new value to the area and the replacement accommodation on Marau Crescent is a significant improvement on what is currently there. It is time for an upgrade at Mission Bay and I believe the proposal will transform Mission Bay for the better.

What are the reasons for your submission?

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? I would like council to approve the project in its entirety.

Are you a trade competitor of the applicant? I am not a trade competitor of the applicant.

Do you want to attend a hearing and speak in support of your submission? No

If other people make a similar submission I will consider making a joint case with them at the hearing: No

Supporting information:

2 166 Linda Butler

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz Sent: Friday, 14 September 2018 3:31 PM To: Central RC Submissions Cc: [email protected] & Subject: Sub 29 - [ID:1606] Submission received on notified resource consent

Notified resource consent application details

Property address: 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28, & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay.

Application number: BUN60324987

Applicant name: Drive Holdings Limited

Applicant email: [email protected] & [email protected]

Submitter contact details

Full name: Tracey Goldstine

Organisation name:

Contact phone number: +64274865422

Email address: [email protected]

Postal address: 38a Ronaki Road Mission Bay Auckland 1071

Submission details

This submission: opposes the application in whole or in part

Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: I oppose the height proposed in this application

What are the reasons for your submission? Aesthetically this will to imposing on the Mission Bay suburb - not only blocking views from neighbours but from the street and beach it will look imposing and completely out of place. I am concerned with the shadows the height will cast and most of all the potential dangerous precedence this will set if approved. Not only for the rest of Mission Bay but the other seaside suburbs and in fact all of the Auckland City.

1 167 What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Whilst personally I feel that the height approved under the unitary plan is still too high - i think that this is more acceptable than the proposed height - four levels would be far more in keeping with aesthetics and being reasonable.

Are you a trade competitor of the applicant? I am not a trade competitor of the applicant.

Do you want to attend a hearing and speak in support of your submission? No

If other people make a similar submission I will consider making a joint case with them at the hearing: Yes

Supporting information:

2 168 Linda Butler

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz Sent: Friday, 14 September 2018 4:31 PM To: Central RC Submissions Cc: [email protected] & Subject: 31 - [ID:1607] Submission received on notified resource consent

Notified resource consent application details

Property address: 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28, & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay.

Application number: BUN60324987

Applicant name: Drive Holdings Limited

Applicant email: [email protected] & [email protected]

Submitter contact details

Full name: Nadia de Blaauw

Organisation name: -

Contact phone number: 021580057

Email address: [email protected]

Postal address: 77a Fancourt St Meadowbank Auckland 1072

Submission details

This submission: opposes the application in whole or in part

Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: demolition of existing art deco buildings /unsympathetic development of the area

What are the reasons for your submission?

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Require the submitter to keep or incorporate elements of the existing art deco buildings into the scheme - these are integral to the look, feel and history of Mission Bay.

1 169 Are you a trade competitor of the applicant? I am not a trade competitor of the applicant.

Do you want to attend a hearing and speak in support of your submission? No

If other people make a similar submission I will consider making a joint case with them at the hearing: No

Supporting information:

2 170 Linda Butler

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz Sent: Friday, 14 September 2018 5:01 PM To: Central RC Submissions Cc: [email protected] & Subject: 32 - [ID:1609] Submission received on notified resource consent

Notified resource consent application details

Property address: 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28, & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay.

Application number: BUN60324987

Applicant name: Drive Holdings Limited

Applicant email: [email protected] & [email protected]

Submitter contact details

Full name: Michelle Crooks

Organisation name:

Contact phone number: 0210360481

Email address: [email protected]

Postal address: 72 Sprott Road Kohimarma Auckland 1071

Submission details

This submission: opposes the application in whole or in part

Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Over height restrictions on the building Roads out of mission bay at peak hour are already at its peak What structures will be put in place to cover the increase in cars due to the apartments Over all look of the buildings

What are the reasons for your submission?

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Look into increase traffic coming and going from mission bay during peak hours Overall height of buildings above height restrictions Mission bay is a tourist stop due to how it looks now

1 171 Are you a trade competitor of the applicant? I am not a trade competitor of the applicant.

Do you want to attend a hearing and speak in support of your submission? No

If other people make a similar submission I will consider making a joint case with them at the hearing: No

Supporting information:

2 172 Linda Butler

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz Sent: Friday, 14 September 2018 11:01 PM To: Central RC Submissions Cc: [email protected] & Subject: 33 - [ID:1617] Submission received on notified resource consent

Notified resource consent application details

Property address: 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28, & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay.

Application number: BUN60324987

Applicant name: Drive Holdings Limited

Applicant email: [email protected] & [email protected]

Submitter contact details

Full name: Jarrod Kerr

Organisation name:

Contact phone number: 0212721328

Email address: [email protected]

Postal address: 13a Rukutai Street Orakei Auckland 1071

Submission details

This submission: opposes the application in whole or in part

Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Demolition of iconic buildings and overdevelopment

What are the reasons for your submission? We must ensure the development of our city and beaches does not destroy the value we hold close

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Reduce the density and ensure character of building(s) reflects the area

1 173 Are you a trade competitor of the applicant? I am not a trade competitor of the applicant.

Do you want to attend a hearing and speak in support of your submission? Yes

If other people make a similar submission I will consider making a joint case with them at the hearing: Yes

Supporting information:

2 174 Linda Butler

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz Sent: Saturday, 15 September 2018 8:16 AM To: Central RC Submissions Cc: [email protected] & Subject: 34 - [ID:1619] Submission received on notified resource consent

Notified resource consent application details

Property address: 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28, & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay.

Application number: BUN60324987

Applicant name: Drive Holdings Limited

Applicant email: [email protected] & [email protected]

Submitter contact details

Full name: Suzanne Melville

Organisation name:

Contact phone number: +64210458644

Email address: [email protected]

Postal address: 14 William Fraser Crescent, St Heliers Auckland Auckland 1071

Submission details

This submission: opposes the application in whole or in part

Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Compounding already present traffic problems on Tamaki Drive especially in the weekends Commericalisation of a suburban area Housing

What are the reasons for your submission? I live in the area, I am supportive of change but this change seems extreme for a suburban area that already has plenty of restaurants and a cinema. The change in landscape will have a significant impact on the area. It isn't clear from the documents I looked at, but I assume that the apartments/ townhouses being built are not going to provide for any housing options for lower incomes. I also don't think that they should be allowed to build above what is allowed for in the unitary plan. Also what provisions are being made for the increasing traffic that will occur with increasing 1 175 commercialisation of the area? Tamaki Drive around Mission Bay is extremely busy especially on summer weekends and these changes will only increase that. Provisions need to be made for the roads and for parking.

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Affordable housing should be provided for. Traffic provisions Heights of the buildings

Are you a trade competitor of the applicant? I am not a trade competitor of the applicant.

Do you want to attend a hearing and speak in support of your submission? No

If other people make a similar submission I will consider making a joint case with them at the hearing: Yes

Supporting information:

2 176 Linda Butler

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz Sent: Saturday, 15 September 2018 9:46 AM To: Central RC Submissions Cc: [email protected] & Subject: 35 - [ID:1620] Submission received on notified resource consent

Notified resource consent application details

Property address: 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28, & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay.

Application number: BUN60324987

Applicant name: Drive Holdings Limited

Applicant email: [email protected] & [email protected]

Submitter contact details

Full name: Dale Clements

Organisation name:

Contact phone number: 0212752590

Email address: [email protected]

Postal address: 23 Lisburn Ave Glendowie Auckland 1071

Submission details

This submission: opposes the application in whole or in part

Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: 8 storey height

What are the reasons for your submission? If you give consent to this height then what is the point of having a Unitary Plan if you are just going to ignore its rules. It renders the Plan useless, a waste of everyone's time and we may as well revert to everyone doing what they like. I am all for 8 stories or more, but in the places designated by the plan

1 177 What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Allow the development to proceed but within the Unitary Plan's height restriction for that area.

Are you a trade competitor of the applicant? I am not a trade competitor of the applicant.

Do you want to attend a hearing and speak in support of your submission? Yes

If other people make a similar submission I will consider making a joint case with them at the hearing: Yes

Supporting information:

2 178 Linda Butler

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz Sent: Saturday, 15 September 2018 12:01 PM To: Central RC Submissions Cc: [email protected] & Subject: 36 - [ID:1624] Submission received on notified resource consent

Notified resource consent application details

Property address: 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28, & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay.

Application number: BUN60324987

Applicant name: Drive Holdings Limited

Applicant email: [email protected] & [email protected]

Submitter contact details

Full name: Megan Coates

Organisation name:

Contact phone number: 021632326

Email address: [email protected]

Postal address: 21 Benbow street, St Heliers St Heliers Auckland 1071

Submission details

This submission: opposes the application in whole or in part

Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Height and character of the area We don’t Auckland to look like the horror story the Gold Coast is 4 stories is enough!!! PS we don’t live in mission bay

What are the reasons for your submission? As above Height and character

1 179 What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Control height and character of the development so it doesn’t look like a towering monstrosity ( not vision domineering) on the water front

Are you a trade competitor of the applicant? I am not a trade competitor of the applicant.

Do you want to attend a hearing and speak in support of your submission? No

If other people make a similar submission I will consider making a joint case with them at the hearing: No

Supporting information:

2 180 Linda Butler

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz Sent: Saturday, 15 September 2018 3:16 PM To: Central RC Submissions Cc: [email protected] & Subject: 37 - [ID:1631] Submission received on notified resource consent

Notified resource consent application details

Property address: 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28, & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay.

Application number: BUN60324987

Applicant name: Drive Holdings Limited

Applicant email: [email protected] & [email protected]

Submitter contact details

Full name: Debbie MacDonald

Organisation name:

Contact phone number: 021834585

Email address: [email protected]

Postal address: 2/70 Rukutai st Orakei Auckland 1071

Submission details

This submission: opposes the application in whole or in part

Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: The height of the buildings is unacceptable for the area. All buildings should be less than 4 stories, which maintains the character of Mission bay.

What are the reasons for your submission?

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Restrict any building to 4 stories high.

1 181 Are you a trade competitor of the applicant? I am not a trade competitor of the applicant.

Do you want to attend a hearing and speak in support of your submission? No

If other people make a similar submission I will consider making a joint case with them at the hearing: Yes

Supporting information:

2 182 Linda Butler

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz Sent: Saturday, 15 September 2018 8:31 PM To: Central RC Submissions Cc: [email protected] & Subject: 38 - [ID:1635] Submission received on notified resource consent

Notified resource consent application details

Property address: 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28, & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay.

Application number: BUN60324987

Applicant name: Drive Holdings Limited

Applicant email: [email protected] & [email protected]

Submitter contact details

Full name: lijuan xu

Organisation name:

Contact phone number: 021416789

Email address: [email protected]

Postal address: PO BOX133168 eastridge auckland 1148

Submission details

This submission: supports the application in whole or in part

Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: the facility needs to be upgraded in mission bay. the building is too old, and that cinemas is very small. location is perfect but building is not good enough.

What are the reasons for your submission?

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? accept this proposal and ask them to make mission bay much better.

1 183 Are you a trade competitor of the applicant? I am not a trade competitor of the applicant.

Do you want to attend a hearing and speak in support of your submission? Yes

If other people make a similar submission I will consider making a joint case with them at the hearing: Yes

Supporting information:

2 184 Linda Butler

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz Sent: Sunday, 16 September 2018 3:01 PM To: Central RC Submissions Cc: [email protected] & Subject: 39 - [ID:1650] Submission received on notified resource consent

Notified resource consent application details

Property address: 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28, & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay.

Application number: BUN60324987

Applicant name: Drive Holdings Limited

Applicant email: [email protected] & [email protected]

Submitter contact details

Full name: Vanessa Hurt

Organisation name: - None -

Contact phone number: 021967720

Email address: [email protected]

Postal address: 47 Whitehaven Rd Glendowie Auckland 1071

Submission details

This submission: opposes the application in whole or in part

Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Building design and height

What are the reasons for your submission?

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Whilst I understand that Auckland needs to move with the times and I am in favour of improving Mission Bay in terms of amenities, I disagree with the proposed building height and design of this project. I have lived in the eastern suburbs my entire life and Mission Bay is an iconic destination that I have enjoyed visiting regularly. Mission Bay has

1 185 always had a quaint 'village' feel to it and the current height and style of the buildings adds to this. Aucklanders and visitors alike flock to Mission Bay to enjoy this village vibe. In particular the art deco buildings speak to the history of Auckland and given that Auckland is still very young in terms of age, it would be a travesty to destroy these buildings. I am all for a new retail development and restaurants but I think they should have to maintain the same building frontage - the art deco feel could be furthered developed somehow to make the look more uniform than it is now. As to the height of the buildings - going any higher than they do today would once again detract from the village feel. Please don't let developers destroy the Mission Bay that Aucklanders know and love!

Are you a trade competitor of the applicant? I am not a trade competitor of the applicant.

Do you want to attend a hearing and speak in support of your submission? No

If other people make a similar submission I will consider making a joint case with them at the hearing: Yes

Supporting information:

2 186 Linda Butler

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz Sent: Sunday, 16 September 2018 4:01 PM To: Central RC Submissions Cc: [email protected] & Subject: 40 - [ID:1656] Submission received on notified resource consent

Notified resource consent application details

Property address: 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28, & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay.

Application number: BUN60324987

Applicant name: Drive Holdings Limited

Applicant email: [email protected] & [email protected]

Submitter contact details

Full name: Christine Helen Johnston

Organisation name:

Contact phone number: 095289622

Email address: [email protected]

Postal address: 44 Codrington Crescent Mission Bay Auckland 1071

Submission details

This submission: opposes the application in whole or in part

Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: The main issue is the height and visual dominance of the proposed development . It is up to 8 stories in a zone intended for 4 stories. There is nothing of any benefit to the local community with the over height sections. This will set a precedence if the development is approved of excess height as the same developer owns the shops on the opposite side of Mission Bay. Put in context the tallest building is higher than those on the ridge of Ronaki Road

What are the reasons for your submission? I do not want Mission Bay to turn into a high rise area like Surfers Paradise. Look at the expense that went into restoring the Mission House beautifully . I want Mission Bay to be an attractive area, not a high rise one.

1 187 What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Reduce the height of the buildings allowed from 8 stories to 4 stories Maximum

Are you a trade competitor of the applicant? I am not a trade competitor of the applicant.

Do you want to attend a hearing and speak in support of your submission? No

If other people make a similar submission I will consider making a joint case with them at the hearing: Yes

Supporting information:

2 188 Linda Butler

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz Sent: Sunday, 16 September 2018 6:01 PM To: Central RC Submissions Cc: [email protected] & Subject: 41 - [ID:1665] Submission received on notified resource consent

Notified resource consent application details

Property address: 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28, & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay.

Application number: BUN60324987

Applicant name: Drive Holdings Limited

Applicant email: [email protected] & [email protected]

Submitter contact details

Full name: anthony hurt

Organisation name:

Contact phone number: 021921300

Email address: [email protected]

Postal address: 32 Waimarie St St Heliers Ak 1071

Submission details

This submission: opposes the application in whole or in part

Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: building heights and changes

What are the reasons for your submission? the changes to the existing building arrangements which will change the village aspect of the present business community. This is a typical example of big business exploiting the weakness of the Auckland Council to observe local requirements

1 189 What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? any changes should retain the profile of the existing structures and maintain the village atmosphere of the area.

Are you a trade competitor of the applicant? I am not a trade competitor of the applicant.

Do you want to attend a hearing and speak in support of your submission? No

If other people make a similar submission I will consider making a joint case with them at the hearing: Yes

Supporting information:

2 190 Linda Butler

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz Sent: Sunday, 16 September 2018 9:31 PM To: Central RC Submissions Cc: [email protected] & Subject: 42 - [ID:1677] Submission received on notified resource consent

Notified resource consent application details

Property address: 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28, & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay.

Application number: BUN60324987

Applicant name: Drive Holdings Limited

Applicant email: [email protected] & [email protected]

Submitter contact details

Full name: Mary-Clare Brownlie

Organisation name:

Contact phone number: 021520859

Email address: [email protected]

Postal address: 1/24 Hawera Road Kohimarama Kohimarama 1071

Submission details

This submission: opposes the application in whole or in part

Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: The block should be no taller than 4 stories as is other buildings in Mission Bay. We have no need for such a massive structure in this pretty residential suburb. This will also reduce the values of the surrounding residences. Reserve those heady buildings for the business centres around the city.

What are the reasons for your submission? It will be too imposing and block out views for a lot of the residences and also block out the sun and views for the residences on the south side during the cooler winer months.

1 191 What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? High rises to be no more than 4 stories high.

Are you a trade competitor of the applicant? I am not a trade competitor of the applicant.

Do you want to attend a hearing and speak in support of your submission? No

If other people make a similar submission I will consider making a joint case with them at the hearing: No

Supporting information:

2 192 Linda Butler

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz Sent: Sunday, 16 September 2018 10:01 PM To: Central RC Submissions Cc: [email protected] & Subject: 43 - [ID:1678] Submission received on notified resource consent

Notified resource consent application details

Property address: 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28, & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay.

Application number: BUN60324987

Applicant name: Drive Holdings Limited

Applicant email: [email protected] & [email protected]

Submitter contact details

Full name: stuart clarke

Organisation name:

Contact phone number: 021 993627

Email address: [email protected]

Postal address: 1/24 hawera road auckland auckland 1071

Submission details

This submission: opposes the application in whole or in part

Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Height of new buildings

What are the reasons for your submission? i believe there is no need to ruin the outlook of mission bay and the suburbs behind with buildings that block the view of the harbour from behind the mission bay/tamaki drive frontage by being over 4 floors high

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? restrict height of new buildings to 4 floors (including the ground floor) at the most

1 193 Are you a trade competitor of the applicant? I am not a trade competitor of the applicant.

Do you want to attend a hearing and speak in support of your submission? Yes

If other people make a similar submission I will consider making a joint case with them at the hearing: Yes

Supporting information:

2 194 Ranjeeta Singh

From: Robyn Pilkington on behalf of Central RC Submissions Sent: Monday, 17 September 2018 11:16 AM To: Premium Submissions Subject: FW: [ID:1684] Submission received on notified resource consent

Categories: Achini

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz [mailto:NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz] Sent: Monday, 17 September 2018 9:30 a.m. To: Central RC Submissions Cc: [email protected] & Subject: [ID:1684] Submission received on notified resource consent

Notified resource consent application details

Property address: 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28, & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay.

Application number: BUN60324987

Applicant name: Drive Holdings Limited

Applicant email: [email protected] & [email protected]

Submitter contact details

Full name: Ian Deynzer

Organisation name:

Contact phone number: 021689974

Email address: [email protected]

Postal address: 4 Cullwick Road Mission Bay Auxckland 1071

Submission details

1 195 This submission: opposes the application in whole or in part

Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: The proposed development is out of character for both Mission Bay and the Eastern Bays in general.

What are the reasons for your submission? To protect the character of the area for the future, and retain its seaside village charm that encourages visitors to use the outdoors.

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Best case to renovate the existing structures and retain their character. Worst case, downscale the proposed development , reduce the height, and reconsider the out of character design.

Are you a trade competitor of the applicant? I am not a trade competitor of the applicant.

Do you want to attend a hearing and speak in support of your submission? No

If other people make a similar submission I will consider making a joint case with them at the hearing: Yes

Supporting information:

2 196 Ranjeeta Singh

From: Robyn Pilkington on behalf of Central RC Submissions Sent: Monday, 17 September 2018 12:47 PM To: Premium Submissions Subject: FW: [ID:1692] Submission received on notified resource consent

Categories: Achini

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz [mailto:NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz] Sent: Monday, 17 September 2018 11:30 a.m. To: Central RC Submissions Cc: [email protected] & Subject: [ID:1692] Submission received on notified resource consent

Notified resource consent application details

Property address: 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28, & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay.

Application number: BUN60324987

Applicant name: Drive Holdings Limited

Applicant email: [email protected] & [email protected]

Submitter contact details

Full name: Graham French

Organisation name:

Contact phone number: 02108381194

Email address: [email protected]

Postal address: 46D Rawhitiroa Road Kohimarama Auckland 1071

Submission details

1 197 This submission: opposes the application in whole or in part

Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: The plans show that the developers plan to go to 8 LEVELS which is nearly DOUBLE the height allowed under the Unitary plan. Not only will this block many people's views, but it will also completely visually dominate the area.

What are the reasons for your submission?

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Keep to the rules of the Unitary plan.

Are you a trade competitor of the applicant? I am not a trade competitor of the applicant.

Do you want to attend a hearing and speak in support of your submission? No

If other people make a similar submission I will consider making a joint case with them at the hearing: Yes

Supporting information:

2 198 Ranjeeta Singh

From: Robyn Pilkington on behalf of Central RC Submissions Sent: Monday, 17 September 2018 12:47 PM To: Premium Submissions Subject: FW: [ID:1694] Submission received on notified resource consent

Categories: Achini

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz [mailto:NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz] Sent: Monday, 17 September 2018 11:45 a.m. To: Central RC Submissions Cc: [email protected] & Subject: [ID:1694] Submission received on notified resource consent

Notified resource consent application details

Property address: 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28, & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay.

Application number: BUN60324987

Applicant name: Drive Holdings Limited

Applicant email: [email protected] & [email protected]

Submitter contact details

Full name: Gillian Cran

Organisation name:

Contact phone number: 0224298270

Email address: [email protected]

Postal address: 2/29 Atkin Avenue Mission Bay Auckland 1071

Submission details

1 199 This submission: supports the application in whole or in part

Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: l approve of the development in all aspects

What are the reasons for your submission? The area needs upgrading and re-vitalising

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? To approve the development as is or slightly modified in height if necessary

Are you a trade competitor of the applicant? I am not a trade competitor of the applicant.

Do you want to attend a hearing and speak in support of your submission? No

If other people make a similar submission I will consider making a joint case with them at the hearing: No

Supporting information:

2 200 Linda Butler

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz Sent: Monday, 17 September 2018 2:45 PM To: Central RC Submissions Cc: [email protected] & Subject: [ID:1704] Submission received on notified resource consent

Categories: Achini

Notified resource consent application details

Property address: 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28, & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay.

Application number: BUN60324987

Applicant name: Drive Holdings Limited

Applicant email: [email protected] & [email protected]

Submitter contact details

Full name: Carolyn Jean Harrison

Organisation name:

Contact phone number: 0212201121

Email address: [email protected]

Postal address: 5/5 Brookfield Street St Heliers Auckland 1071

Submission details

This submission: opposes the application in whole or in part

Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: I totally oppose this building project to be allowed. It is way above the unitary plan height restrictions. It will block views and sunlight and will be a total eyesore. There will be bigger traffic and parking problems than ever before. Keep Mission Bay as was intended when built, a relaxed seaside area, not a great big concrete jungle!!!

1 201 What are the reasons for your submission? This is not within the Unitary Plan Heights. There have already been footpath and restaurant upgrades to this lovely area. The roads are not wide enough o take more traffic and the parking is already congested.

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Keep Mission bay as it is now.

Are you a trade competitor of the applicant? I am not a trade competitor of the applicant.

Do you want to attend a hearing and speak in support of your submission? No

If other people make a similar submission I will consider making a joint case with them at the hearing: No

Supporting information:

2 202 Linda Butler

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz Sent: Monday, 17 September 2018 3:15 PM To: Central RC Submissions Cc: [email protected] & Subject: [ID:1708] Submission received on notified resource consent

Categories: Achini

Notified resource consent application details

Property address: 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28, & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay.

Application number: BUN60324987

Applicant name: Drive Holdings Limited

Applicant email: [email protected] & [email protected]

Submitter contact details

Full name: John Grant Borrows

Organisation name:

Contact phone number: 095280009

Email address: [email protected]

Postal address: 15 Marau Cres Auckland Auckland 1071

Submission details

This submission: supports the application in whole or in part

Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Existing buildings are derelict and unsafe and need to be demolished - the submitted plans would make a huge improvement to the whole block.

What are the reasons for your submission? As above

1 203 What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? None

Are you a trade competitor of the applicant? I am not a trade competitor of the applicant.

Do you want to attend a hearing and speak in support of your submission? No

If other people make a similar submission I will consider making a joint case with them at the hearing: Yes

Supporting information:

2 204 Linda Butler

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz Sent: Monday, 17 September 2018 3:45 PM To: Central RC Submissions Cc: [email protected] & Subject: [ID:1709] Submission received on notified resource consent

Categories: Achini

Notified resource consent application details

Property address: 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28, & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay.

Application number: BUN60324987

Applicant name: Drive Holdings Limited

Applicant email: [email protected] & [email protected]

Submitter contact details

Full name: Robyn Fairley

Organisation name:

Contact phone number: 0292007891

Email address: [email protected]

Postal address: 14 A HARTLAND Ave Glendowie Auckland 1071

Submission details

This submission: opposes the application in whole or in part

Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Height Car parks

What are the reasons for your submission? This seems to be a huge developement over the height restrictions laid out in the unitary plan. Have the developers submitted their plans knowing full well it will meet resistance but will have gains in the due process. Mission Bay is desperately short of car park spaces as it is. This development is in increasing people in unimaginable numbers with

1 205 a proposed 265 car parks which I assume will be used by apartment dwellers. Disruption to the area will be a nightmare as residents from St Heliers Kohimarama and Glendowie seek other ways to commute to the city. Kepa Rd is already under stress from 2 large developments, schools and commuters from GI St John's and Orakei.

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Its all very well to have this unitary plan but my concern is how strict is council adherring to it. There needs to be substantially more Car parks and public toilets How do you know that when you buy a property that developers can come and build multi level apartments because they have power to do so.

Are you a trade competitor of the applicant? I am not a trade competitor of the applicant.

Do you want to attend a hearing and speak in support of your submission? No

If other people make a similar submission I will consider making a joint case with them at the hearing: No

Supporting information:

2 206 Ranjeeta Singh

From: Robyn Pilkington on behalf of Central RC Submissions Sent: Tuesday, 18 September 2018 7:24 AM To: Premium Submissions Subject: FW: [ID:1712] Submission received on notified resource consent

Categories: Achini

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz [mailto:NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz] Sent: Monday, 17 September 2018 4:00 p.m. To: Central RC Submissions Cc: [email protected] & Subject: [ID:1712] Submission received on notified resource consent

Notified resource consent application details

Property address: 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28, & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay.

Application number: BUN60324987

Applicant name: Drive Holdings Limited

Applicant email: [email protected] & [email protected]

Submitter contact details

Full name: Junwei WU

Organisation name:

Contact phone number: 0212627647

Email address: [email protected]

Postal address: 3 Simmental Crescent,Somerville Auckland Auckland 2014

Submission details

1 207 This submission: supports the application in whole or in part

Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: I support the whole resource consent application.

What are the reasons for your submission?

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? approval

Are you a trade competitor of the applicant? I am not a trade competitor of the applicant.

Do you want to attend a hearing and speak in support of your submission? No

If other people make a similar submission I will consider making a joint case with them at the hearing: No

Supporting information:

2 208 Ranjeeta Singh

From: Robyn Pilkington on behalf of Central RC Submissions Sent: Tuesday, 18 September 2018 7:25 AM To: Premium Submissions Subject: FW: [ID:1725] Submission received on notified resource consent

Categories: Achini

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz [mailto:NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz] Sent: Monday, 17 September 2018 8:15 p.m. To: Central RC Submissions Cc: [email protected] & Subject: [ID:1725] Submission received on notified resource consent

Notified resource consent application details

Property address: 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28, & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay.

Application number: BUN60324987

Applicant name: Drive Holdings Limited

Applicant email: [email protected] & [email protected]

Submitter contact details

Full name: Angela Dyer

Organisation name:

Contact phone number: 021399506

Email address: [email protected]

Postal address: 2/123 Riddell Road Glendowie Auckland 1071

Submission details

1 209 This submission: opposes the application in whole or in part

Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: My thoughts on the mission bay promonade are that the buildings there now are iconic and historical, to loose them would change the whole feeling down there. I’m not opposed to development but to retain some of the history, mainly the Berkeley movie theatre and De Fontein. Most of the restaurants down there aren’t great! Not like St Heliers which is next level compared to mission bay. Too many chain restaurants etc at MB.

What are the reasons for your submission? My reasons are the iconic look and feel of the architecture being changed completely would be a great loss. A design that mimicked or included the original buildings would be a lot more attractive and respectful.

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Re look at designs! Make this area a true reflection of what is there now! Colours and style of Art Deco design like Miami for example, that’s what’s there now. A glass building is not in keeping with the beautiful promenade.

Are you a trade competitor of the applicant? I am not a trade competitor of the applicant.

Do you want to attend a hearing and speak in support of your submission? Yes

If other people make a similar submission I will consider making a joint case with them at the hearing: Yes

Supporting information:

2 210 Ranjeeta Singh

From: Robyn Pilkington on behalf of Central RC Submissions Sent: Tuesday, 18 September 2018 7:25 AM To: Premium Submissions Subject: FW: [ID:1727] Submission received on notified resource consent

Categories: Achini

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz [mailto:NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz] Sent: Monday, 17 September 2018 8:15 p.m. To: Central RC Submissions Cc: [email protected] & Subject: [ID:1727] Submission received on notified resource consent

Notified resource consent application details

Property address: 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28, & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay.

Application number: BUN60324987

Applicant name: Drive Holdings Limited

Applicant email: [email protected] & [email protected]

Submitter contact details

Full name: Christine Mary Melvilleo

Organisation name:

Contact phone number: 0272102696

Email address: [email protected]

Postal address: 296 Riddell Road Glendowie Auckland 1071

Submission details

1 211 This submission: opposes the application in whole or in part

Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: NA

What are the reasons for your submission?

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? NA

Are you a trade competitor of the applicant? I am not a trade competitor of the applicant.

Do you want to attend a hearing and speak in support of your submission? No

If other people make a similar submission I will consider making a joint case with them at the hearing: No

Supporting information:

2 212 Ranjeeta Singh

From: Robyn Pilkington on behalf of Central RC Submissions Sent: Tuesday, 18 September 2018 7:26 AM To: Premium Submissions Subject: FW: [ID:1733] Submission received on notified resource consent

Categories: Achini

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz [mailto:NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz] Sent: Monday, 17 September 2018 8:45 p.m. To: Central RC Submissions Cc: [email protected] & Subject: [ID:1733] Submission received on notified resource consent

Notified resource consent application details

Property address: 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28, & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay.

Application number: BUN60324987

Applicant name: Drive Holdings Limited

Applicant email: [email protected] & [email protected]

Submitter contact details

Full name: Sam lawson

Organisation name:

Contact phone number: 0211341619

Email address: [email protected]

Postal address: G03/3 Bluegrey Stonefields Auckland 1072

Submission details

1 213 This submission: opposes the application in whole or in part

Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: This is an unecessary and over the top request. 7 story buildings on existing sites of mission bay will completely ruin exisiting views, increase shade and increase traffic flows. There is already extremely poor car parking in mission bay. This isn’t going to help.

What are the reasons for your submission?

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Completely stop the submission.

Are you a trade competitor of the applicant? I am not a trade competitor of the applicant.

Do you want to attend a hearing and speak in support of your submission? No

If other people make a similar submission I will consider making a joint case with them at the hearing: No

Supporting information:

2 214 Ranjeeta Singh

From: Robyn Pilkington on behalf of Central RC Submissions Sent: Tuesday, 18 September 2018 7:26 AM To: Premium Submissions Subject: FW: [ID:1749] Submission received on notified resource consent

Categories: Achini

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz [mailto:NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz] Sent: Monday, 17 September 2018 11:45 p.m. To: Central RC Submissions Cc: [email protected] & Subject: [ID:1749] Submission received on notified resource consent

Notified resource consent application details

Property address: 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28, & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay.

Application number: BUN60324987

Applicant name: Drive Holdings Limited

Applicant email: [email protected] & [email protected]

Submitter contact details

Full name: Elisabeth Stevens

Organisation name:

Contact phone number: 0060173262995

Email address: [email protected]

Postal address: 1/95 St Johns Road St Johns Auckland 1072

Submission details

1 215 This submission: opposes the application in whole or in part

Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: This proposals plan shows the developer intends to go nearly double the height permitted under the Unitary Plan. They need to stay within the limit of permitted activity (approximately 4 levels). Also, prominent buildings that people associate with Mission Bay will be removed. The building on the corner that currently houses the Belgium Beer Bar has been in many pictures, and is iconic in the Mission Bay area. It would a shame for a part of history to be removed.

What are the reasons for your submission?

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Restrict the developer to 4 levels, the height within the Unitary Plan. Work out a way to keep the building currently housing the Belgium Beer Bar, or at least the facade.

Are you a trade competitor of the applicant? I am not a trade competitor of the applicant.

Do you want to attend a hearing and speak in support of your submission? No

If other people make a similar submission I will consider making a joint case with them at the hearing: Yes

Supporting information:

2 216 Ranjeeta Singh

From: Robyn Pilkington on behalf of Central RC Submissions Sent: Tuesday, 18 September 2018 7:26 AM To: Premium Submissions Subject: FW: [ID:1750] Submission received on notified resource consent

Categories: Achini

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz [mailto:NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz] Sent: Tuesday, 18 September 2018 12:30 a.m. To: Central RC Submissions Cc: [email protected] & Subject: [ID:1750] Submission received on notified resource consent

Notified resource consent application details

Property address: 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28, & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay.

Application number: BUN60324987

Applicant name: Drive Holdings Limited

Applicant email: [email protected] & [email protected]

Submitter contact details

Full name: Briar Dentice

Organisation name:

Contact phone number: 0212237450

Email address: [email protected]

Postal address: 308/4 Bluegrey Ave Stonefields Auckland 1072

Submission details

1 217 This submission: opposes the application in whole or in part

Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: The demolition of existing buildings

What are the reasons for your submission? This was done at St. Heliers, and the retail, public areas lost their appeal. The area lost its vibrancy, and character. This would also happen to Mission Bay.

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Not to demolish existing buildings.

Are you a trade competitor of the applicant? I am not a trade competitor of the applicant.

Do you want to attend a hearing and speak in support of your submission? No

If other people make a similar submission I will consider making a joint case with them at the hearing: Yes

Supporting information:

2 218 Ranjeeta Singh

From: Robyn Pilkington on behalf of Central RC Submissions Sent: Tuesday, 18 September 2018 9:06 AM To: Premium Submissions Subject: FW: [ID:1756] Submission received on notified resource consent

Categories: Achini

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz [mailto:NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz] Sent: Tuesday, 18 September 2018 9:00 a.m. To: Central RC Submissions Cc: [email protected] & Subject: [ID:1756] Submission received on notified resource consent

Notified resource consent application details

Property address: 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28, & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay.

Application number: BUN60324987

Applicant name: Drive Holdings Limited

Applicant email: [email protected] & [email protected]

Submitter contact details

Full name: Rex Potter

Organisation name:

Contact phone number: 02102478043

Email address: [email protected]

Postal address: 89 tephra boulevard Stonefields Auckland 1072

Submission details

1 219 This submission: supports the application in whole or in part

Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Would be a great development for the area.

What are the reasons for your submission?

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? None don't hold up the process.

Are you a trade competitor of the applicant? I am not a trade competitor of the applicant.

Do you want to attend a hearing and speak in support of your submission? No

If other people make a similar submission I will consider making a joint case with them at the hearing: No

Supporting information:

2 220 Linda Butler

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz Sent: Tuesday, 18 September 2018 10:15 AM To: Central RC Submissions Cc: [email protected] & Subject: [ID:1763] Submission received on notified resource consent

Categories: Achini

Notified resource consent application details

Property address: 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28, & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay.

Application number: BUN60324987

Applicant name: Drive Holdings Limited

Applicant email: [email protected] & [email protected]

Submitter contact details

Full name: Jan van Deventer

Organisation name:

Contact phone number: 021315575

Email address: [email protected]

Postal address: 4/17 Nihill Crescent Mission Bay Auckland 1071

Submission details

This submission: supports the application in whole or in part

Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: I would like to see this area improved to great something special in our neighborhood.

What are the reasons for your submission? To give support for this development.

1 221 What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? To allow the project to proceed with instruction to make the project stand out.

Are you a trade competitor of the applicant? I am not a trade competitor of the applicant.

Do you want to attend a hearing and speak in support of your submission? No

If other people make a similar submission I will consider making a joint case with them at the hearing: Yes

Supporting information:

2 222 Ranjeeta Singh

From: Robyn Pilkington on behalf of Central RC Submissions Sent: Tuesday, 18 September 2018 12:10 PM To: Premium Submissions Subject: FW: [ID:1771] Submission received on notified resource consent

Categories: Achini

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz [mailto:NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz] Sent: Tuesday, 18 September 2018 11:45 a.m. To: Central RC Submissions Cc: [email protected] & Subject: [ID:1771] Submission received on notified resource consent

Notified resource consent application details

Property address: 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28, & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay.

Application number: BUN60324987

Applicant name: Drive Holdings Limited

Applicant email: [email protected] & [email protected]

Submitter contact details

Full name: Barb Ross

Organisation name:

Contact phone number: 021925910

Email address: [email protected]

Postal address: 33 Hampton Drive St Heliers Auckland 1071

Submission details

1 223 This submission: opposes the application in whole or in part

Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: I would very much prefer to see the height remain at 4 stories not 8 as proposed. Look at the monstrosity in St Heliers - it's a concrete eyesore.

What are the reasons for your submission? You will be destroying the views of so many residents in the area. It's just not necessary.

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Leave the height restriction at 4 levels please.

Are you a trade competitor of the applicant? I am not a trade competitor of the applicant.

Do you want to attend a hearing and speak in support of your submission? No

If other people make a similar submission I will consider making a joint case with them at the hearing: Yes

Supporting information:

2 224 Linda Butler

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz Sent: Tuesday, 18 September 2018 12:15 PM To: Central RC Submissions Cc: [email protected] & Subject: [ID:1773] Submission received on notified resource consent

Categories: Achini

Notified resource consent application details

Property address: 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28, & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay.

Application number: BUN60324987

Applicant name: Drive Holdings Limited

Applicant email: [email protected] & [email protected]

Submitter contact details

Full name: Toby Gwilym

Organisation name:

Contact phone number: 0272722880

Email address: [email protected]

Postal address: 17 Gerard Way Meadowbank Auckland 1072

Submission details

This submission: opposes the application in whole or in part

Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Demolition of classic buildings

What are the reasons for your submission?

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Move the main road behind the shops so that it is possible to have water front dining

1 225 Are you a trade competitor of the applicant? I am not a trade competitor of the applicant.

Do you want to attend a hearing and speak in support of your submission? No

If other people make a similar submission I will consider making a joint case with them at the hearing: Yes

Supporting information:

2 226 Ranjeeta Singh

From: Robyn Pilkington on behalf of Central RC Submissions Sent: Tuesday, 18 September 2018 1:58 PM To: Premium Submissions Subject: FW: [ID:1775] Submission received on notified resource consent

Categories: Achini

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz [mailto:NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz] Sent: Tuesday, 18 September 2018 1:30 p.m. To: Central RC Submissions Cc: [email protected] & Subject: [ID:1775] Submission received on notified resource consent

Notified resource consent application details

Property address: 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28, & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay.

Application number: BUN60324987

Applicant name: Drive Holdings Limited

Applicant email: [email protected] & [email protected]

Submitter contact details

Full name: Holly Muller

Organisation name:

Contact phone number: 0212586125

Email address: [email protected]

Postal address: 8b Abbotts Way Remuera Auckland 1050

Submission details

1 227 This submission: opposes the application in whole or in part

Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Development of Mission Bay, taking away all of it's character and turning it in to a wannabe Gold Coast

What are the reasons for your submission? Auckland is terrible at not keeping any history or anything for ourselves to cherish. We don't actually HAVE to overly develop everything. Some things are ok being left as a beautiful, characteristic, well-loved piece of our history.

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Do not overly develop our beautiful Mission Bay! Don't let private buyers turn it in to yet another commercialised area that has no character to it. Try not to be greedy.

Are you a trade competitor of the applicant? I am not a trade competitor of the applicant.

Do you want to attend a hearing and speak in support of your submission? No

If other people make a similar submission I will consider making a joint case with them at the hearing: Yes

Supporting information:

2 228 Ranjeeta Singh

From: Robyn Pilkington on behalf of Central RC Submissions Sent: Tuesday, 18 September 2018 1:58 PM To: Premium Submissions Subject: FW: [ID:1777] Submission received on notified resource consent

Categories: Achini

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz [mailto:NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz] Sent: Tuesday, 18 September 2018 1:45 p.m. To: Central RC Submissions Cc: [email protected] & Subject: [ID:1777] Submission received on notified resource consent

Notified resource consent application details

Property address: 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28, & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay.

Application number: BUN60324987

Applicant name: Drive Holdings Limited

Applicant email: [email protected] & [email protected]

Submitter contact details

Full name: Sally-Anne Forde

Organisation name:

Contact phone number: 021831175

Email address: [email protected]

Postal address: 645 Remuera Road Remuera Auckland 1050

Submission details

1 229 This submission: opposes the application in whole or in part

Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: The height and look of the buildings which do not suit the area.

What are the reasons for your submission?

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Decline it completely, it does not suit the character of the neighbourhood.

Are you a trade competitor of the applicant? I am not a trade competitor of the applicant.

Do you want to attend a hearing and speak in support of your submission? Yes

If other people make a similar submission I will consider making a joint case with them at the hearing: Yes

Supporting information:

2 230 Linda Butler

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz Sent: Tuesday, 18 September 2018 2:30 PM To: Central RC Submissions Cc: [email protected] & Subject: [ID:1781] Submission received on notified resource consent

Categories: Achini

Notified resource consent application details

Property address: 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28, & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay.

Application number: BUN60324987

Applicant name: Drive Holdings Limited

Applicant email: [email protected] & [email protected]

Submitter contact details

Full name: David Ballantyne

Organisation name:

Contact phone number: 0272747586

Email address: [email protected]

Postal address: 96 Selwyn Ave Mission Bay Auckland 1071

Submission details

This submission: supports the application in whole or in part

Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Height of proposed project

What are the reasons for your submission?

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Keep the development within the existing height restrictions

1 231 Are you a trade competitor of the applicant? I am not a trade competitor of the applicant.

Do you want to attend a hearing and speak in support of your submission? No

If other people make a similar submission I will consider making a joint case with them at the hearing: No

Supporting information:

2 232 Linda Butler

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz Sent: Tuesday, 18 September 2018 9:30 PM To: Central RC Submissions Cc: [email protected] & Subject: [ID:1807] Submission received on notified resource consent

Categories: Achini

Notified resource consent application details

Property address: 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28, & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay.

Application number: BUN60324987

Applicant name: Drive Holdings Limited

Applicant email: [email protected] & [email protected]

Submitter contact details

Full name: Jayden Grant

Organisation name:

Contact phone number: 02108161600

Email address: [email protected]

Postal address: 23 Comins Crescent Mission Bay Auckland 1071

Submission details

This submission: opposes the application in whole or in part

Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Height of proposed scheme

What are the reasons for your submission?

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? I appose the height of the scheme

1 233 Are you a trade competitor of the applicant? I am not a trade competitor of the applicant.

Do you want to attend a hearing and speak in support of your submission? No

If other people make a similar submission I will consider making a joint case with them at the hearing: Yes

Supporting information:

2 234 Ranjeeta Singh

From: Robyn Pilkington on behalf of Central RC Submissions Sent: Wednesday, 19 September 2018 9:13 AM To: Premium Submissions Subject: FW: [ID:1826] Submission received on notified resource consent

Categories: Achini

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz [mailto:NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz] Sent: Wednesday, 19 September 2018 8:45 a.m. To: Central RC Submissions Cc: [email protected] & Subject: [ID:1826] Submission received on notified resource consent

Notified resource consent application details

Property address: 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28, & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay.

Application number: BUN60324987

Applicant name: Drive Holdings Limited

Applicant email: [email protected] & [email protected]

Submitter contact details

Full name: Michael Shaw

Organisation name:

Contact phone number: 0276828961

Email address: [email protected]

Postal address: 25 Trojan Crescent New Lynn Auckland 0600

Submission details

1 235 This submission: supports the application in whole or in part

Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Design and land use

What are the reasons for your submission? I am passionate about creating a city where Aucklanders are proud to live and play

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? I absolutely support developing the land into the intended land use of the development. I think the design is poor and will turn Mission Bay into the Docklands equivalent of Melbourne. There is no charm, no character, and Aucklanders want that. This is a great opportunity to develop a stunning piece of character that suits the nature and history of Mission Bay. Make the architects think outside the box. This development as is will turn Mission Bay into a place where only tourists go (and they won’t be that impressed). Aucklanders will turn their backs on a soulless development like this. Also the designs do not allow for bars and restaurants on balconies like the current land use. This is a major draw card for visitors to have a meal in the sun and enjoy the views (away from sitting on the footpath by the road).

Are you a trade competitor of the applicant? I am not a trade competitor of the applicant.

Do you want to attend a hearing and speak in support of your submission? No

If other people make a similar submission I will consider making a joint case with them at the hearing: Yes

Supporting information:

2 236 Linda Butler

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz Sent: Wednesday, 19 September 2018 9:30 AM To: Central RC Submissions Cc: [email protected] & Subject: [ID:1829] Submission received on notified resource consent

Categories: Achini

Notified resource consent application details

Property address: 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28, & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay.

Application number: BUN60324987

Applicant name: Drive Holdings Limited

Applicant email: [email protected] & [email protected]

Submitter contact details

Full name: Ian Benet

Organisation name: Mango Communications

Contact phone number: 0221695443

Email address: [email protected]

Postal address: 2/161 Long Drive ST HELIERS Auckland 1071

Submission details

This submission: opposes the application in whole or in part

Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: The imposing height, the additional traffic it would create, the destruction of some quite beautiful buildings along the water front

What are the reasons for your submission?

1 237 What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Reduce the height, save the facade of the building on the corner.

Are you a trade competitor of the applicant? I am not a trade competitor of the applicant.

Do you want to attend a hearing and speak in support of your submission? No

If other people make a similar submission I will consider making a joint case with them at the hearing: No

Supporting information:

2 238 Ranjeeta Singh

From: Robyn Pilkington on behalf of Central RC Submissions Sent: Wednesday, 19 September 2018 11:10 AM To: Premium Submissions Subject: FW: [ID:1833] Submission received on notified resource consent

Categories: Achini

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz [mailto:NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz] Sent: Wednesday, 19 September 2018 10:28 a.m. To: Central RC Submissions Cc: [email protected] & Subject: [ID:1833] Submission received on notified resource consent

Notified resource consent application details

Property address: 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28, & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay.

Application number: BUN60324987

Applicant name: Drive Holdings Limited

Applicant email: [email protected] & [email protected]

Submitter contact details

Full name: Matthew Connolly

Organisation name:

Contact phone number: 0211178385

Email address: [email protected]

Postal address: Riddell Road Auckland Auckland 1071

Submission details

1 239 This submission: supports the application in whole or in part

Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: I support the idea to develop Mission Bay as a way of future proofing and attracting more people to the area. It is in definite need of a face lift. I do although have a huge problem with the proposed design. It screams overseas style which will age very quickly and look awful. I see it as a missed opportunity to create something very "New Zealand" as it is the perfect beachfront site. I look across the road about how well the new Stone House building has been done it would be criminal to waste this opportunity to create an Auckland icon rather than trying to be the Gold Coast or Miami.

What are the reasons for your submission? My reasons for this submission is that the current plan is a whole hearted missed opportunity to create a New Zealand icon, Instead the design is just trying to be someone else. As I am heavily involved in Architecture, it breaks me to see Buildings like this being proposed rather than celebrating the New Zealand Vernacular Architecture

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Overhaul the breif and design, Set a competition for only New Zealand Architects to create a New Zealand and Auckland building. It will achieve a far better end result putting Mission bay on the map not just for Auckland but has the possibility to be a world wide icon. Why not think out of the box

Are you a trade competitor of the applicant? I am not a trade competitor of the applicant.

Do you want to attend a hearing and speak in support of your submission? No

If other people make a similar submission I will consider making a joint case with them at the hearing: No

Supporting information:

2 240 Linda Butler

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz Sent: Wednesday, 19 September 2018 12:31 PM To: Central RC Submissions Cc: [email protected] & Subject: [ID:1845] Submission received on notified resource consent

Categories: Achini

Notified resource consent application details

Property address: 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28, & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay.

Application number: BUN60324987

Applicant name: Drive Holdings Limited

Applicant email: [email protected] & [email protected]

Submitter contact details

Full name: Kirsty Dale Cowie

Organisation name:

Contact phone number: 0274987337

Email address: [email protected]

Postal address: 93 Selwyn Avenue Mission Bay Auckland 1071

Submission details

This submission: opposes the application in whole or in part

Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: the height the design traffic congestion

What are the reasons for your submission?

1 241 What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? adhere to the unitary plan re height maintain a high standard of design for the new look of mission bay - contemporary, by the beach,

Are you a trade competitor of the applicant? I am not a trade competitor of the applicant.

Do you want to attend a hearing and speak in support of your submission? No

If other people make a similar submission I will consider making a joint case with them at the hearing: Yes

Supporting information:

2 242 Linda Butler

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz Sent: Wednesday, 19 September 2018 1:16 PM To: Central RC Submissions Cc: [email protected] & Subject: [ID:1849] Submission received on notified resource consent

Categories: Achini

Notified resource consent application details

Property address: 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28, & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay.

Application number: BUN60324987

Applicant name: Drive Holdings Limited

Applicant email: [email protected] & [email protected]

Submitter contact details

Full name: Catherine Anne Woodley

Organisation name:

Contact phone number: 021545169

Email address: [email protected]

Postal address: 151b St Heliers Bay Rd St Heliers Auckland 1071

Submission details

This submission: opposes the application in whole or in part

Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: 1/ Height of proposed development 2/ Number of carparks proposed 3/ Proposed retail space usage (specifically the cinema) 4/ Design of proposed development

What are the reasons for your submission? Whilst I support the regeneration of the Mission Bay Area this proposed development is not in keeping with the relaxed, beachside feel of the neighbourhood and will be too intrusive and block the view and light of the neighbouring

1 243 houses. The proposed development is too high, the design proposed is ugly and intrusive and the number of carparks proposed will increase an already congested road in/out of Mission Bay and the Eastern Suburbs

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? 1/ Reduce the overall height to half 2/ Reduce the number of proposed carparks to half and remove the carpark across the road to remove cars and congestion from the beach area (turn old carpark into green space) 3/ Limit the number of retail spaces and proposed size of multiplex cinema (keep cinema as it is) 4/ Reject the proposed design aesthetic to something less intrusive, more contemporary and in keeping with the beachside feel of the neighbouring area (i.e not concrete 'Miami' style Art Deco look )

Are you a trade competitor of the applicant? I am not a trade competitor of the applicant.

Do you want to attend a hearing and speak in support of your submission? No

If other people make a similar submission I will consider making a joint case with them at the hearing: No

Supporting information:

2 244 Linda Butler

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz Sent: Wednesday, 19 September 2018 2:16 PM To: Central RC Submissions Cc: [email protected] & Subject: [ID:1857] Submission received on notified resource consent

Categories: Achini

Notified resource consent application details

Property address: 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28, & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay.

Application number: BUN60324987

Applicant name: Drive Holdings Limited

Applicant email: [email protected] & [email protected]

Submitter contact details

Full name: Rodrigo Bottieri

Organisation name:

Contact phone number: 0221330185

Email address: [email protected]

Postal address: 31 Speight Road Kohimarama Auckland 1071

Submission details

This submission: opposes the application in whole or in part

Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: I think it won't add any value for most of the community, being beneficial only for the people who is proposing it, that'll probably have great profit, and for the few wealth fortunates that'll be able to spend millions to secure a property or new business

What are the reasons for your submission?

1 245 What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Reject the whole submission. Or at least make it only for new businesses, with buildings no higher than actual ones

Are you a trade competitor of the applicant? I am not a trade competitor of the applicant.

Do you want to attend a hearing and speak in support of your submission? No

If other people make a similar submission I will consider making a joint case with them at the hearing: No

Supporting information:

2 246 Linda Butler

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz Sent: Wednesday, 19 September 2018 2:31 PM To: Central RC Submissions Cc: [email protected] & Subject: [ID:1861] Submission received on notified resource consent

Categories: Achini

Notified resource consent application details

Property address: 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28, & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay.

Application number: BUN60324987

Applicant name: Drive Holdings Limited

Applicant email: [email protected] & [email protected]

Submitter contact details

Full name: Heather Rogers

Organisation name:

Contact phone number: 095285242

Email address: [email protected]

Postal address: 9 Beere Place Meadowbank Auckland 1072

Submission details

This submission: opposes the application in whole or in part

Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Noooooo to 8 stories

What are the reasons for your submission? The developer should keep to the regulated 4 levels and NO MORE

1 247 What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? 4 Levels max. Keep to the unitary plan!

Are you a trade competitor of the applicant? I am not a trade competitor of the applicant.

Do you want to attend a hearing and speak in support of your submission? Yes

If other people make a similar submission I will consider making a joint case with them at the hearing: Yes

Supporting information:

2 248 Linda Butler

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz Sent: Wednesday, 19 September 2018 3:01 PM To: Central RC Submissions Cc: [email protected] & Subject: [ID:1864] Submission received on notified resource consent

Categories: Achini

Notified resource consent application details

Property address: 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28, & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay.

Application number: BUN60324987

Applicant name: Drive Holdings Limited

Applicant email: [email protected] & [email protected]

Submitter contact details

Full name: Carmen Szeto

Organisation name:

Contact phone number: 0210687146

Email address: [email protected]

Postal address: 15b Melling street Glen Innes Auckland 1072

Submission details

This submission: supports the application in whole or in part

Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Density is needed

What are the reasons for your submission?

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Approve

1 249 Are you a trade competitor of the applicant? I am not a trade competitor of the applicant.

Do you want to attend a hearing and speak in support of your submission? No

If other people make a similar submission I will consider making a joint case with them at the hearing: No

Supporting information:

2 250 Linda Butler

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz Sent: Wednesday, 19 September 2018 3:16 PM To: Central RC Submissions Cc: [email protected] & Subject: [ID:1866] Submission received on notified resource consent

Categories: Achini

Notified resource consent application details

Property address: 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28, & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay.

Application number: BUN60324987

Applicant name: Drive Holdings Limited

Applicant email: [email protected] & [email protected]

Submitter contact details

Full name: Thais Bottieri

Organisation name:

Contact phone number: 02041093247

Email address: [email protected]

Postal address: 2/31 Speight Rd Kohimarama Auckland 1071

Submission details

This submission: opposes the application in whole or in part

Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Against the application to rejuvenate Mission Bay’s centre

What are the reasons for your submission? I dont think it will add any value for most of the community, being beneficial only for the people who is proposing it, that'll probably have great profit. Also the walking path was just renovated, so it will be a waste of money changing it

1 251 again. The new building will also block see views and raise the house and business prices even more. Mission Bay is perfect as it's

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Leave as it's

Are you a trade competitor of the applicant? I am not a trade competitor of the applicant.

Do you want to attend a hearing and speak in support of your submission? No

If other people make a similar submission I will consider making a joint case with them at the hearing: No

Supporting information:

2 252 Linda Butler

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz Sent: Wednesday, 19 September 2018 4:01 PM To: Central RC Submissions Cc: [email protected] & Subject: [ID:1869] Submission received on notified resource consent

Categories: Achini

Notified resource consent application details

Property address: 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28, & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay.

Application number: BUN60324987

Applicant name: Drive Holdings Limited

Applicant email: [email protected] & [email protected]

Submitter contact details

Full name: Rhys Mountfort

Organisation name:

Contact phone number: 021749077

Email address: [email protected]

Postal address: PO Box 17121 Greenlane Auckland 1546

Submission details

This submission: opposes the application in whole or in part

Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Specifically the proposed height which is outside the rules of the Unitary Plan

What are the reasons for your submission? It is not in keeping with the Unitary Plan or the Special Character of the area.

1 253 What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? The Council spend a great deal of time and a large amount of ratepayers money to design the Unitary Plan. The Unitary Plan is more than generous in allowing a 4 storey development on this area. Please respect the residents and ratepayers who live in this area and be fair, by standing firm on the 4 storey limit designated.

Are you a trade competitor of the applicant? I am not a trade competitor of the applicant.

Do you want to attend a hearing and speak in support of your submission? Yes

If other people make a similar submission I will consider making a joint case with them at the hearing: Yes

Supporting information:

2 254 Linda Butler

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz Sent: Wednesday, 19 September 2018 4:01 PM To: Central RC Submissions Cc: [email protected] & Subject: [ID:1873] Submission received on notified resource consent

Categories: Achini

Notified resource consent application details

Property address: 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28, & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay.

Application number: BUN60324987

Applicant name: Drive Holdings Limited

Applicant email: [email protected] & [email protected]

Submitter contact details

Full name: Shareen Smith

Organisation name:

Contact phone number: 0226700340

Email address: [email protected]

Postal address: 41b Roberta Ave Glendowie Auckland 1071

Submission details

This submission: opposes the application in whole or in part

Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: The demolition of the character buildings in Mission Bay. The redevelopment is not sensitive or takes into consideration the current character of Mission Bay. The supposed nod to the art deco period in the new design is tokenistic.

1 255 What are the reasons for your submission? Destruction of Mission Bay's character by demolishing the art deco buildings. The destruction of the village feel and the heart of Mission Bay.

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? To keep all the character buildings - the Berkeley cinema, De Fontein etc.. The character buildings remaining. Also I oppose the height the new redevelopment is proposing to build up to.

Are you a trade competitor of the applicant? I am not a trade competitor of the applicant.

Do you want to attend a hearing and speak in support of your submission? No

If other people make a similar submission I will consider making a joint case with them at the hearing: No

Supporting information:

2 256 Ranjeeta Singh

From: Robyn Pilkington on behalf of Central RC Submissions Sent: Thursday, 20 September 2018 7:22 AM To: Premium Submissions Subject: FW: [ID:1875] Submission received on notified resource consent

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz [mailto:NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz] Sent: Wednesday, 19 September 2018 4:31 p.m. To: Central RC Submissions Cc: [email protected] & Subject: [ID:1875] Submission received on notified resource consent

Notified resource consent application details

Property address: 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28, & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay.

Application number: BUN60324987

Applicant name: Drive Holdings Limited

Applicant email: [email protected] & [email protected]

Submitter contact details

Full name: laureen de sa

Organisation name:

Contact phone number: 0274234899

Email address: [email protected]

Postal address: 2/91 long drive st heliers auckland 1071

Submission details

This submission: opposes the application in whole or in part

1 257 Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: the demolition of heritage buildings and replacing with an oversized concrete monolithic eyesore

What are the reasons for your submission? Concerned property owner and eastern bays dweller. Have the council not learnt from what was done in st heliers with that eyesore Maheke development

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? to keep the existing buildings and not allow greedy developers defacing the eastern bays waterfront with concrete monoliths like was done in st heliers maheke development.

Are you a trade competitor of the applicant? I am not a trade competitor of the applicant.

Do you want to attend a hearing and speak in support of your submission? No

If other people make a similar submission I will consider making a joint case with them at the hearing: No

Supporting information:

2 258 Ranjeeta Singh

From: Robyn Pilkington on behalf of Central RC Submissions Sent: Thursday, 20 September 2018 7:38 AM To: Premium Submissions Subject: FW: [ID:1876] Submission received on notified resource consent

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz [mailto:NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz] Sent: Wednesday, 19 September 2018 4:31 p.m. To: Central RC Submissions Cc: [email protected] & Subject: [ID:1876] Submission received on notified resource consent

Notified resource consent application details

Property address: 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28, & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay.

Application number: BUN60324987

Applicant name: Drive Holdings Limited

Applicant email: [email protected] & [email protected]

Submitter contact details

Full name: Colleen Barbarich

Organisation name:

Contact phone number: 5289141

Email address: [email protected]

Postal address: 8 Codrington Crescent Mission Bay Auckland 1071

Submission details

This submission: opposes the application in whole or in part

1 259 Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Height of construction

What are the reasons for your submission? Exceeds the Unitary Plan.

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? The height of the construction must not exceed what is allowed for in the current unitary plan.

Are you a trade competitor of the applicant? I am not a trade competitor of the applicant.

Do you want to attend a hearing and speak in support of your submission? No

If other people make a similar submission I will consider making a joint case with them at the hearing: Yes

Supporting information:

2 260 Ranjeeta Singh

From: Robyn Pilkington on behalf of Central RC Submissions Sent: Thursday, 20 September 2018 7:42 AM To: Premium Submissions Subject: FW: [ID:1889] Submission received on notified resource consent

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz [mailto:NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz] Sent: Wednesday, 19 September 2018 7:16 p.m. To: Central RC Submissions Cc: [email protected] & Subject: [ID:1889] Submission received on notified resource consent

Notified resource consent application details

Property address: 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28, & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay.

Application number: BUN60324987

Applicant name: Drive Holdings Limited

Applicant email: [email protected] & [email protected]

Submitter contact details

Full name: Andrea Armishaw

Organisation name:

Contact phone number: 095783344

Email address: [email protected]

Postal address: 97 Atkin Avenue Mission Bay Auckland 1071

Submission details

This submission: opposes the application in whole or in part

1 261 Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: The height of the proposed development is 4 levels too high. It will feel very oppressive and will dominate the area and create huge shadows and obstruct neighbouring views. Unitary plan says 4 levels for a reason. The development should have great urban planning and landscape design.

What are the reasons for your submission? The development should also have shops on the street level with living above. There are too many restaurants (not to a high standard) in Mission Bay without much else here now. I have lived here since 1990 on and off and there use to be a proper village with a bank, stationary shop, butchers.... now over run with restaurants that feel like they are stuck in a 1980s Gold Coast time warp!

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Change the height.

Are you a trade competitor of the applicant? I am not a trade competitor of the applicant.

Do you want to attend a hearing and speak in support of your submission? Yes

If other people make a similar submission I will consider making a joint case with them at the hearing: Yes

Supporting information:

2 262 Ranjeeta Singh

From: Robyn Pilkington on behalf of Central RC Submissions Sent: Thursday, 20 September 2018 7:42 AM To: Premium Submissions Subject: FW: [ID:1891] Submission received on notified resource consent

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz [mailto:NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz] Sent: Wednesday, 19 September 2018 7:31 p.m. To: Central RC Submissions Cc: [email protected] & Subject: [ID:1891] Submission received on notified resource consent

Notified resource consent application details

Property address: 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28, & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay.

Application number: BUN60324987

Applicant name: Drive Holdings Limited

Applicant email: [email protected] & [email protected]

Submitter contact details

Full name: Raewyn Stone

Organisation name:

Contact phone number: 0274642919

Email address: [email protected]

Postal address: 2B Pukeora Ave Auckland Auckland 1050

Submission details

This submission: opposes the application in whole or in part

1 263 Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: design, impact

What are the reasons for your submission? Have visited Mission Bay for decades with family, friends and overseas visitors, enjoying its unique qualities. I have seen ghastly commercialisation of lovely seaside towns overseas with apartments dominating the views. It is great to go to a place which is just about the beach and foreshore, eating and the movies. Why on earth do we need retail here? And what on earth will it do to the traffic?

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Retain existing facade, tidy up street front, limited 4 story, unobtrusive residential and no retail

Are you a trade competitor of the applicant? I am not a trade competitor of the applicant.

Do you want to attend a hearing and speak in support of your submission? No

If other people make a similar submission I will consider making a joint case with them at the hearing: Yes

Supporting information:

2 264 Ranjeeta Singh

From: Robyn Pilkington on behalf of Central RC Submissions Sent: Thursday, 20 September 2018 7:43 AM To: Premium Submissions Subject: FW: [ID:1912] Submission received on notified resource consent

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz [mailto:NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz] Sent: Wednesday, 19 September 2018 9:31 p.m. To: Central RC Submissions Cc: [email protected] & Subject: [ID:1912] Submission received on notified resource consent

Notified resource consent application details

Property address: 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28, & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay.

Application number: BUN60324987

Applicant name: Drive Holdings Limited

Applicant email: [email protected] & [email protected]

Submitter contact details

Full name: Rachael Ferris

Organisation name:

Contact phone number: 0211347015

Email address: [email protected]

Postal address: 255 Kohimarama Road Kohimarama Auckland 1071

Submission details

This submission: opposes the application in whole or in part

1 265 Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: The height of the proposed buildings

What are the reasons for your submission? Too high

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Restrict to 4 levels as per unitary plan

Are you a trade competitor of the applicant? I am not a trade competitor of the applicant.

Do you want to attend a hearing and speak in support of your submission? No

If other people make a similar submission I will consider making a joint case with them at the hearing: Yes

Supporting information:

2 266 Ranjeeta Singh

From: Robyn Pilkington on behalf of Central RC Submissions Sent: Thursday, 20 September 2018 7:43 AM To: Premium Submissions Subject: FW: [ID:1917] Submission received on notified resource consent

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz [mailto:NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz] Sent: Wednesday, 19 September 2018 9:31 p.m. To: Central RC Submissions Cc: [email protected] & Subject: [ID:1917] Submission received on notified resource consent

Notified resource consent application details

Property address: 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28, & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay.

Application number: BUN60324987

Applicant name: Drive Holdings Limited

Applicant email: [email protected] & [email protected]

Submitter contact details

Full name: David Robert ferris

Organisation name:

Contact phone number: 021339795

Email address: [email protected]

Postal address: 255 Kohimarama rd Kohimarama Auckland 1071

Submission details

This submission: opposes the application in whole or in part

1 267 Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: The height of the proposed building

What are the reasons for your submission?

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Review the height of the proposed building.

Are you a trade competitor of the applicant? I am not a trade competitor of the applicant.

Do you want to attend a hearing and speak in support of your submission? No

If other people make a similar submission I will consider making a joint case with them at the hearing: No

Supporting information:

2 268 Ranjeeta Singh

From: Robyn Pilkington on behalf of Central RC Submissions Sent: Thursday, 20 September 2018 7:43 AM To: Premium Submissions Subject: FW: [ID:1939] Submission received on notified resource consent

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz [mailto:NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz] Sent: Wednesday, 19 September 2018 11:16 p.m. To: Central RC Submissions Cc: [email protected] & Subject: [ID:1939] Submission received on notified resource consent

Notified resource consent application details

Property address: 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28, & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay.

Application number: BUN60324987

Applicant name: Drive Holdings Limited

Applicant email: [email protected] & [email protected]

Submitter contact details

Full name: Paul Stanfield

Organisation name:

Contact phone number: 021736084

Email address: [email protected]

Postal address: 104 Godden Crescent Mission Bay Auckland 1071

Submission details

This submission: supports the application in whole or in part

1 269 Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: All of it

What are the reasons for your submission?

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? None

Are you a trade competitor of the applicant? I am not a trade competitor of the applicant.

Do you want to attend a hearing and speak in support of your submission? No

If other people make a similar submission I will consider making a joint case with them at the hearing: No

Supporting information:

2 270 Ranjeeta Singh

From: Robyn Pilkington on behalf of Central RC Submissions Sent: Thursday, 20 September 2018 7:43 AM To: Premium Submissions Subject: FW: [ID:1945] Submission received on notified resource consent

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz [mailto:NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz] Sent: Wednesday, 19 September 2018 11:46 p.m. To: Central RC Submissions Cc: [email protected] & Subject: [ID:1945] Submission received on notified resource consent

Notified resource consent application details

Property address: 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28, & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay.

Application number: BUN60324987

Applicant name: Drive Holdings Limited

Applicant email: [email protected] & [email protected]

Submitter contact details

Full name: Rossella Quaranta

Organisation name:

Contact phone number: 0223112349

Email address: [email protected]

Postal address: 231b Marua Road Mount Wellington Auckland 1051

Submission details

This submission: opposes the application in whole or in part

1 271 Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Architectural design and project as a whole

What are the reasons for your submission?

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? I strongly disagree with the project as it was presented and conceived. The proposed multi-level buildings look like a '70s pseudo sci-fi concept. I'm OK with giving the existing building a facelift, but not if that means replacing them with five-story condos that look like something out of The Jetsons.

Are you a trade competitor of the applicant? I am not a trade competitor of the applicant.

Do you want to attend a hearing and speak in support of your submission? No

If other people make a similar submission I will consider making a joint case with them at the hearing: Yes

Supporting information:

2 272 Linda Butler

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz Sent: Thursday, 20 September 2018 6:31 PM To: Central RC Submissions Cc: [email protected] & Subject: [ID:2049] Submission received on notified resource consent

Notified resource consent application details

Property address: 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28, & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay.

Application number: BUN60324987

Applicant name: Drive Holdings Limited

Applicant email: [email protected] & [email protected]

Submitter contact details

Full name: Elena Lezhneva

Organisation name:

Contact phone number: 0210571770

Email address: [email protected]

Postal address: 77 Atkin Avenue Mission Bay Auckland 1071

Submission details

This submission: opposes the application in whole or in part

Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Demolishing of current historic buildings and building the multistorey block.

What are the reasons for your submission? It's destroying the atmosphere and the peaceful area. The area is over populated already too, and Tamaki drive is too busy.

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? To keep the old buildings and built the multistorey buildings away from the front line.

1 273 Are you a trade competitor of the applicant? I am not a trade competitor of the applicant.

Do you want to attend a hearing and speak in support of your submission? Yes

If other people make a similar submission I will consider making a joint case with them at the hearing: Yes

Supporting information:

2 274 Linda Butler

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz Sent: Friday, 21 September 2018 6:30 AM To: Central RC Submissions Cc: [email protected] & Subject: [ID:2050] Submission received on notified resource consent

Notified resource consent application details

Property address: 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28, & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay.

Application number: BUN60324987

Applicant name: Drive Holdings Limited

Applicant email: [email protected] & [email protected]

Submitter contact details

Full name: Curtis Atkinson

Organisation name:

Contact phone number: 0273923504

Email address: [email protected]

Postal address: 7/32 Coates Ave Orakei Auckland 1071

Submission details

This submission: opposes the application in whole or in part

Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Design

What are the reasons for your submission? Design and company in question are of poor quality

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Deny request

1 275 Are you a trade competitor of the applicant? I am not a trade competitor of the applicant.

Do you want to attend a hearing and speak in support of your submission? No

If other people make a similar submission I will consider making a joint case with them at the hearing: No

Supporting information:

2 276 Linda Butler

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz Sent: Friday, 21 September 2018 8:30 AM To: Central RC Submissions Cc: [email protected] & Subject: [ID:2051] Submission received on notified resource consent

Notified resource consent application details

Property address: 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28, & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay.

Application number: BUN60324987

Applicant name: Drive Holdings Limited

Applicant email: [email protected] & [email protected]

Submitter contact details

Full name: Samantha Caretti

Organisation name:

Contact phone number: 021 174 3222

Email address: [email protected]

Postal address: 10 Cotter Avenue Remuera auckland 1050

Submission details

This submission: opposes the application in whole or in part

Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: I would hope Auckland Council would support an application to redevelop Mission bay beach front that keeps in consideration its beautiful landscape and heritage feel in the existing buildings. Sadly, the current proposal does not seem to keep these two very basic and simple requirements in mind. The proposed building has no reference to the current Art Deco style which gives to Mission Bay its unique character. The proposed rounded corner cube building seems more fit for a Las Vegas or Miami landscape and has no resemblance whatsoever with the natural character of the New Zealand landscape even in the proposed use of material (concrete and glass). The proposed development appears impersonal and unnatural for that beach front location, the high of this building is a concern not just for the building behind it but how it is going to look like when viewed from the sea? Like another high-rise eye sore building. It will be just a complete shame to destroy with no attempt to recover all if not part of the current De Fontein frontage 1 277 that is such a landmark of this area. The increase number of population and cars in such a high-density area with already heavy traffic on Tamaki drive during key time of the day seems not to have been considered either.

What are the reasons for your submission?

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Please, Auckland Council, send back the proposal to the drawing table of the developers and architects and demand them to come up with something more in line with the ‘100% New Zealand’ vision you should have in mind in each new development in this country to avoid the monstrosities created in Spain, Hawaii and other areas of the world in the recent years. Look at them and learn from the mistakes made to those natural landscapes now ruined forever. We can do better.

Are you a trade competitor of the applicant? I am not a trade competitor of the applicant.

Do you want to attend a hearing and speak in support of your submission? Yes

If other people make a similar submission I will consider making a joint case with them at the hearing: Yes

Supporting information:

2 278 Ranjeeta Singh

From: Robyn Pilkington on behalf of Central RC Submissions Sent: Friday, 21 September 2018 12:00 PM To: Premium Submissions Subject: FW: [ID:2054] Submission received on notified resource consent

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz [mailto:NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz] Sent: Friday, 21 September 2018 10:45 a.m. To: Central RC Submissions Cc: [email protected] & Subject: [ID:2054] Submission received on notified resource consent

Notified resource consent application details

Property address: 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28, & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay.

Application number: BUN60324987

Applicant name: Drive Holdings Limited

Applicant email: [email protected] & [email protected]

Submitter contact details

Full name: Yvonne June Joass

Organisation name:

Contact phone number: 0211124171

Email address: [email protected]

Postal address: 76 Whitehaven Rd Auckland Auckland 1071

Submission details

This submission: opposes the application in whole or in part

1 279 Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Intention of development to fall outside the rules of the Unitary Plan

What are the reasons for your submission? Whilst not against redevelopment of this block of Mission Bay, I strongly oppose allowing the development to construct buildings taller than the 4 storeys allowed by the Unitary Plan. I believe constructing such large, imposing structures would ruin the character of Mission Bay. Furthermore, I Consider allowing this development to go ahead outside the rules of the Unitary Plan would set a precedent for breaking these rules anywhere in Auckland, opening a clear path for future developments to also make a mockery of the Unitary Plan

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Allow development but do not allow deviation from the Unitary Plan

Are you a trade competitor of the applicant? I am not a trade competitor of the applicant.

Do you want to attend a hearing and speak in support of your submission? No

If other people make a similar submission I will consider making a joint case with them at the hearing: Yes

Supporting information:

2 280 Ranjeeta Singh

From: Robyn Pilkington on behalf of Central RC Submissions Sent: Friday, 21 September 2018 12:01 PM To: Premium Submissions Subject: FW: [ID:2056] Submission received on notified resource consent

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz [mailto:NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz] Sent: Friday, 21 September 2018 11:15 a.m. To: Central RC Submissions Cc: [email protected] & Subject: [ID:2056] Submission received on notified resource consent

Notified resource consent application details

Property address: 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28, & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay.

Application number: BUN60324987

Applicant name: Drive Holdings Limited

Applicant email: [email protected] & [email protected]

Submitter contact details

Full name: JANINE MCKENNA-WOODLEY

Organisation name:

Contact phone number: 0274462690

Email address: [email protected]

Postal address: 2/113 RUKUTAI ST Orakei AUCKLAND 1071

Submission details

This submission: opposes the application in whole or in part

1 281 Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: The height should definitely not exceed 2-4 stories. Preferably 2.

What are the reasons for your submission? Mission Bay slopes steadily up to Kepa Rd. It is abhorrent to block the views of the beach to half the population of Mission Bay and visitors. The only people who would benefit are wealthy developers and the very few wealthy people who could afford the apartments, many of whom probably wouldn't even live in them, nor be 2nd -generation New Zealanders. The majority would be disadvantaged for the wealthy few. All 4 + storey buildings should only be allowed at the TOP of the hill on Kepa Rd. It is the only fair and sensible option.

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Height restrictions on all buildings below Kepa Rd.

Are you a trade competitor of the applicant? I am not a trade competitor of the applicant.

Do you want to attend a hearing and speak in support of your submission? No

If other people make a similar submission I will consider making a joint case with them at the hearing: No

Supporting information:

2 282 Ranjeeta Singh

From: Robyn Pilkington on behalf of Central RC Submissions Sent: Friday, 21 September 2018 12:01 PM To: Premium Submissions Subject: FW: [ID:2057] Submission received on notified resource consent

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz [mailto:NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz] Sent: Friday, 21 September 2018 12:00 p.m. To: Central RC Submissions Cc: [email protected] & Subject: [ID:2057] Submission received on notified resource consent

Notified resource consent application details

Property address: 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28, & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay.

Application number: BUN60324987

Applicant name: Drive Holdings Limited

Applicant email: [email protected] & [email protected]

Submitter contact details

Full name: Ross Porter

Organisation name:

Contact phone number: 021644150

Email address: [email protected]

Postal address: PO Box 99 887 Newmarket Auckland 1149

Submission details

This submission: supports the application in whole or in part

1 283 Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: The whole application.

What are the reasons for your submission? I am submitting in favour of the proposal to rejuvenate the eastern side of Mission Bay’s centre. Mission Bay has long been in need of improvement and I am in support of the proposed project, and believe it will bring a much-needed upgrade to the area, while retaining its identity and purpose. I am pleased to see that the project has retained a focus on food and beverage outlets, ensuring the area will remain a popular destination for locals and visitors alike. The introduction of new accommodation delivers new value to the area and the replacement accommodation on Marau Street is a significant improvement on what is currently there. It is time for an upgrade at Mission Bay and I believe the proposal will transform Mission Bay for the better.

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Approve the application

Are you a trade competitor of the applicant? I am not a trade competitor of the applicant.

Do you want to attend a hearing and speak in support of your submission? Yes

If other people make a similar submission I will consider making a joint case with them at the hearing: Yes

Supporting information:

2 284 Linda Butler

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz Sent: Friday, 21 September 2018 2:00 PM To: Central RC Submissions Cc: [email protected] & Subject: [ID:2058] Submission received on notified resource consent

Notified resource consent application details

Property address: 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28, & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay.

Application number: BUN60324987

Applicant name: Drive Holdings Limited

Applicant email: [email protected] & [email protected]

Submitter contact details

Full name: Brian Retief

Organisation name:

Contact phone number: 021833938

Email address: [email protected]

Postal address: 25a Awarua Cresecent Orakei Auckland 1071

Submission details

This submission: opposes the application in whole or in part

Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: The height of the 8 storey proposed building that goes outside of the councils proposed unitary plans. The look and design of the building which just does not support the look and feel of Mission Bay which is a small but iconic area with its retro facade and coastal holiday feel enjoyed year-round by people from around Auckland and tourists who are taken to Mission Bay and recommended to visit by for example cruise ships as an place to visit because its quaint seaside look and feel

What are the reasons for your submission? Because if the council does not uphold the unitary plan it devised and allows this 8 story concrete development to go

1 285 ahead they should tear up the unitary plan rules Also, the developer has little or no respect for the plan or the look and feel of the area and Auckland will lose another coastal seaside site that people enjoy

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? That any development should respect the height limitations of the unitary plan and the planned development height be reduced to that specified by the unitary plan. That they should be made to respect the feel, look and ambience of this iconic area with the design of any development they propose and not the huge concrete and glass monstrosity they are proposing That the council should discount the images they have submitted as they have used a wide angle lens which will distort the impact the development will have on the area.

Are you a trade competitor of the applicant? I am not a trade competitor of the applicant.

Do you want to attend a hearing and speak in support of your submission? No

If other people make a similar submission I will consider making a joint case with them at the hearing: Yes

Supporting information:

2 286 Linda Butler

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz Sent: Friday, 21 September 2018 2:45 PM To: Central RC Submissions Cc: [email protected] & Subject: [ID:2059] Submission received on notified resource consent

Notified resource consent application details

Property address: 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28, & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay.

Application number: BUN60324987

Applicant name: Drive Holdings Limited

Applicant email: [email protected] & [email protected]

Submitter contact details

Full name: Selena Armstrong

Organisation name:

Contact phone number: 0220290313

Email address: [email protected]

Postal address: 24 Walmsley Road St Heliers Auckland 1071

Submission details

This submission: opposes the application in whole or in part

Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: I do not believe that the art deco buildings that currently exist should be taken down.

What are the reasons for your submission? I do not oppose the development but believe the facade of the existing buildings which have historical value must remain and be incorporated into the development plans.

1 287 What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? ENsure the current art deco facade of the buildings that exist remain and are incorported into the design of the development.

Are you a trade competitor of the applicant? I am not a trade competitor of the applicant.

Do you want to attend a hearing and speak in support of your submission? No

If other people make a similar submission I will consider making a joint case with them at the hearing: No

Supporting information:

2 288 Linda Butler

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz Sent: Friday, 21 September 2018 4:30 PM To: Central RC Submissions Cc: [email protected] & Subject: [ID:2061] Submission received on notified resource consent

Notified resource consent application details

Property address: 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28, & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay.

Application number: BUN60324987

Applicant name: Drive Holdings Limited

Applicant email: [email protected] & [email protected]

Submitter contact details

Full name: Mark Strachan

Organisation name:

Contact phone number: 0211802419

Email address: [email protected]

Postal address: 122 Riddell Road Glendowie Auckland 1071

Submission details

This submission: opposes the application in whole or in part

Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: The scale of the development. The impact on the traffic. The current lack of parking with existing traffic. The potential disruption caused by increase visitors and increased licensed premises. The impact on the reserve across from the development.

What are the reasons for your submission?

1 289 What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? To scale back the size of the development to only increase to a size that the exiting infrastructure can comfortably accommodate.

Are you a trade competitor of the applicant? I am not a trade competitor of the applicant.

Do you want to attend a hearing and speak in support of your submission? Yes

If other people make a similar submission I will consider making a joint case with them at the hearing: Yes

Supporting information:

2 290 Linda Butler

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz Sent: Friday, 21 September 2018 4:45 PM To: Central RC Submissions Cc: [email protected] & Subject: [ID:2063] Submission received on notified resource consent

Notified resource consent application details

Property address: 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28, & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay.

Application number: BUN60324987

Applicant name: Drive Holdings Limited

Applicant email: [email protected] & [email protected]

Submitter contact details

Full name: Elizabeth Robinson

Organisation name:

Contact phone number: 095280933

Email address: [email protected]

Postal address: 73 Patteson Avenue Mission Bay Auckland 1071

Submission details

This submission: opposes the application in whole or in part

Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Height of proposed development Safety issues arising from increased traffic

What are the reasons for your submission? The unitary plan states that in Local Centre Zones " Provisions allow for buildings up to four storeys high, enabling residential use at upper floors" The 7 stories proposed in this application is excessive and will be totally out of character in Mission Bay It will be aesthetically offensive. The size of the proposed development will seriously impact on the volume of traffic in the Mission Bay area. Currently there are extremely long traffic queues along Tamaki Drive at peak traffic times and at the weekends . Mission Bay is a popular destination for many families and increased traffic poses increased safety risks . It is is naive to state as this proposal does " Modelling of the traffic effects on typical 1 291 days shows that the expected level of traffic can be accommodated within the existing road network without creating adverse traffic congestion or safety effects. " We are concerned that no mention is made of the effect of increased traffic on Patteson Ave. This is a relatively narrow residential road which is used to reach Mission Bay by cars ,heavy vehicles and buses. There are already problems with volumes and drivers using excessive speed.

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Restrict the height of any development to 4 stories Make sure adequate consideration is given to the implications to public safety caused by the increased traffic volumes

Are you a trade competitor of the applicant? I am not a trade competitor of the applicant.

Do you want to attend a hearing and speak in support of your submission? No

If other people make a similar submission I will consider making a joint case with them at the hearing: No

Supporting information:

2 292 Linda Butler

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz Sent: Friday, 21 September 2018 4:46 PM To: Central RC Submissions Cc: [email protected] & Subject: [ID:2064] Submission received on notified resource consent

Notified resource consent application details

Property address: 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28, & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay.

Application number: BUN60324987

Applicant name: Drive Holdings Limited

Applicant email: [email protected] & [email protected]

Submitter contact details

Full name: Clementine Gardner

Organisation name:

Contact phone number: 0211253160

Email address: [email protected]

Postal address: 10 Towai Street St Heliers Auckland 1071

Submission details

This submission: opposes the application in whole or in part

Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: I oppose the whole plan to demolish and rebuild on these sites in Mission Bay

What are the reasons for your submission? My reasons are that what exists now defines Mission Bay, it gives it it’s character, history and quirkiness. Every time I drive through Mission Bay (which is almost daily) I love it as it is now... it makes me smile and think how lucky I am to live nearby. The proposed monolith has no place in the area and will destroy the character we love so very much.

1 293 What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Do not allow it to happen

Are you a trade competitor of the applicant? I am not a trade competitor of the applicant.

Do you want to attend a hearing and speak in support of your submission? No

If other people make a similar submission I will consider making a joint case with them at the hearing: No

Supporting information:

2 294 Linda Butler

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz Sent: Friday, 21 September 2018 5:00 PM To: Central RC Submissions Cc: [email protected] & Subject: [ID:2066] Submission received on notified resource consent

Notified resource consent application details

Property address: 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28, & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay.

Application number: BUN60324987

Applicant name: Drive Holdings Limited

Applicant email: [email protected] & [email protected]

Submitter contact details

Full name: David Boersen

Organisation name: Empire Capital Limited

Contact phone number: 0276890586

Email address: [email protected]

Postal address: Level 4 Auckland Auckland 1010

Submission details

This submission: supports the application in whole or in part

Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Whole application - support in full.

What are the reasons for your submission? Good use of land. Appropriate urban form proposed. Site suitable for intensive and visually interesting development.

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Grant consent as sought

1 295 Are you a trade competitor of the applicant? I am not a trade competitor of the applicant.

Do you want to attend a hearing and speak in support of your submission? No

If other people make a similar submission I will consider making a joint case with them at the hearing: No

Supporting information:

2 296 Linda Butler

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz Sent: Friday, 21 September 2018 5:31 PM To: Central RC Submissions Cc: [email protected] & Subject: [ID:2067] Submission received on notified resource consent

Notified resource consent application details

Property address: 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28, & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay.

Application number: BUN60324987

Applicant name: Drive Holdings Limited

Applicant email: [email protected] & [email protected]

Submitter contact details

Full name: Naja urlich

Organisation name:

Contact phone number: 0211648424

Email address: [email protected]

Postal address: 2/23coates ave Orakei Auckland 1071

Submission details

This submission: supports the application in whole or in part

Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: It would improve the bays

What are the reasons for your submission? It’s a part of Auckland future growth

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Positiv

1 297 Are you a trade competitor of the applicant? I am not a trade competitor of the applicant.

Do you want to attend a hearing and speak in support of your submission? No

If other people make a similar submission I will consider making a joint case with them at the hearing: Yes

Supporting information:

2 298 Linda Butler

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz Sent: Friday, 21 September 2018 6:00 PM To: Central RC Submissions Cc: [email protected] & Subject: [ID:2068] Submission received on notified resource consent

Notified resource consent application details

Property address: 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28, & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay.

Application number: BUN60324987

Applicant name: Drive Holdings Limited

Applicant email: [email protected] & [email protected]

Submitter contact details

Full name: William Pott

Organisation name:

Contact phone number: 0210379438

Email address: [email protected]

Postal address: 52 Upland Road Auckland Auckland 1050

Submission details

This submission: opposes the application in whole or in part

Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: The proposed development is out of scale for Mission Bay and will open the floodgates to future low quality development which will negatively impact the local economy & vibrancy of one of Auckland most iconic landmark tourist destinations.

What are the reasons for your submission? The historic Art Deco buildings at Mission Bay should be preserved as they contribute to the heritage of the community. Sensitive and sensible development should be encouraged which emphasizes the quality and heritage of Auckland's seaside villages which along Tamaki Drive were predominantly developed during the 1920's & 1930's. The clock, cinemas & building housing Movenpick/Belgian Beer cafe are local landmarks which help set the tone for this 1 299 village. A historic district like those created around South Beach, Florida would be a more logical solution to driving tourism & stimulating redevelopment of Mission Bay.

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Designate the Art Deco buildings in Mission Bay as protected heritage buildings & ensure that future development complies with the character of Mission Bay.

Are you a trade competitor of the applicant? I am not a trade competitor of the applicant.

Do you want to attend a hearing and speak in support of your submission? No

If other people make a similar submission I will consider making a joint case with them at the hearing: Yes

Supporting information:

2 300 Linda Butler

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz Sent: Friday, 21 September 2018 7:45 PM To: Central RC Submissions Cc: [email protected] & Subject: [ID:2069] Submission received on notified resource consent

Notified resource consent application details

Property address: 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28, & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay.

Application number: BUN60324987

Applicant name: Drive Holdings Limited

Applicant email: [email protected] & [email protected]

Submitter contact details

Full name: Brett

Organisation name: Horsfall

Contact phone number: 0225624748

Email address: [email protected]

Postal address: 64 Lunn Avenue Mt Welington Auckland 1072

Submission details

This submission: supports the application in whole or in part

Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: The mission bay upgrade

What are the reasons for your submission?

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Better with more parking, built up retail eating strip with better water views

Are you a trade competitor of the applicant? I am not a trade competitor of the applicant.

1 301 Do you want to attend a hearing and speak in support of your submission? No

If other people make a similar submission I will consider making a joint case with them at the hearing: No

Supporting information:

2 302 Linda Butler

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz Sent: Friday, 21 September 2018 10:30 PM To: Central RC Submissions Cc: [email protected] & Subject: [ID:2070] Submission received on notified resource consent

Notified resource consent application details

Property address: 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28, & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay.

Application number: BUN60324987

Applicant name: Drive Holdings Limited

Applicant email: [email protected] & [email protected]

Submitter contact details

Full name: Elena Arduini

Organisation name:

Contact phone number: +642108996984

Email address: [email protected]

Postal address: 86 aotea Street Orakei Auckland 1071

Submission details

This submission: opposes the application in whole or in part

Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: The plan of 8 stories high buildings goes against the current unitary plan, it will completely dwarf the mission bay suburb.

What are the reasons for your submission? It will completely obscure our view of the bay

1 303 What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Would like to see a Plan for a renovation of the block in question but maintaining the Art Deco feel and keeping the height of the buildings to max 3 stories high

Are you a trade competitor of the applicant? I am not a trade competitor of the applicant.

Do you want to attend a hearing and speak in support of your submission? No

If other people make a similar submission I will consider making a joint case with them at the hearing: Yes

Supporting information:

2 304 Linda Butler

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz Sent: Friday, 21 September 2018 10:30 PM To: Central RC Submissions Cc: [email protected] & Subject: [ID:2071] Submission received on notified resource consent

Notified resource consent application details

Property address: 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28, & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay.

Application number: BUN60324987

Applicant name: Drive Holdings Limited

Applicant email: [email protected] & [email protected]

Submitter contact details

Full name: Elena Arduini

Organisation name:

Contact phone number: +642108996984

Email address: [email protected]

Postal address: 86 aotea Street Orakei Auckland 1071

Submission details

This submission: opposes the application in whole or in part

Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: The height of the submission is against the current unitary plan and it goes against the whole feel of mission bay Another greed driven project without considering environmental impact /

What are the reasons for your submission?

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Oppose the new build

1 305 Are you a trade competitor of the applicant? I am not a trade competitor of the applicant.

Do you want to attend a hearing and speak in support of your submission? Yes

If other people make a similar submission I will consider making a joint case with them at the hearing: Yes

Supporting information:

2 306 Linda Butler

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz Sent: Friday, 21 September 2018 11:00 PM To: Central RC Submissions Cc: [email protected] & Subject: [ID:2072] Submission received on notified resource consent

Notified resource consent application details

Property address: 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28, & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay.

Application number: BUN60324987

Applicant name: Drive Holdings Limited

Applicant email: [email protected] & [email protected]

Submitter contact details

Full name: Jing Lu and Xuelin Zhou

Organisation name:

Contact phone number: 021665589

Email address: [email protected]

Postal address: 64 St Andrews Road Auckland Auckland 1023

Submission details

This submission: supports the application in whole or in part

Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: This submission is to endorse the application of above numbers in all aspects.

What are the reasons for your submission? The proposed construction of seven multi-level buildings will greatly enhance the physical outlook as well as the cultural values of Mission Bay as a world-class tourist spot. The proposed project will also benefit people of the neighborhood and those across Auckland through providing dining, retail and entertainment facilities.

1 307 What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? We'd like Auckland Council to consider the proposed construction from a holistic perspective and grant consent to the application.

Are you a trade competitor of the applicant? I am not a trade competitor of the applicant.

Do you want to attend a hearing and speak in support of your submission? Yes

If other people make a similar submission I will consider making a joint case with them at the hearing: Yes

Supporting information:

2 308 Linda Butler

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz Sent: Saturday, 22 September 2018 7:15 AM To: Central RC Submissions Cc: [email protected] & Subject: [ID:2073] Submission received on notified resource consent

Notified resource consent application details

Property address: 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28, & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay.

Application number: BUN60324987

Applicant name: Drive Holdings Limited

Applicant email: [email protected] & [email protected]

Submitter contact details

Full name: john Gerty

Organisation name:

Contact phone number: 0291287725

Email address: [email protected]

Postal address: 4/155 Gillies Ave Epsom Epsom 1023

Submission details

This submission: supports the application in whole or in part

Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: The general design is good and I support the height of the buildings.

What are the reasons for your submission? I feel the need to help Auckland to grow and develop especially around the under developed and utilised waterfront areas and I am aware people will be against this so I may be able to help by supporting good new progressive development.

1 309 What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? to grant full consent as is.

Are you a trade competitor of the applicant? I am not a trade competitor of the applicant.

Do you want to attend a hearing and speak in support of your submission? No

If other people make a similar submission I will consider making a joint case with them at the hearing: No

Supporting information:

2 310 Linda Butler

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz Sent: Saturday, 22 September 2018 8:30 AM To: Central RC Submissions Cc: [email protected] & Subject: [ID:2074] Submission received on notified resource consent

Notified resource consent application details

Property address: 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28, & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay.

Application number: BUN60324987

Applicant name: Drive Holdings Limited

Applicant email: [email protected] & [email protected]

Submitter contact details

Full name: Kris Bainbridge

Organisation name:

Contact phone number: 0211221843

Email address: [email protected]

Postal address: 696A Te Atatu Road Te Atatu Peninsula Auckland 0610

Submission details

This submission: supports the application in whole or in part

Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: The entire application.

What are the reasons for your submission? Interest in seeing Auckland develop to cater for future housing needs. It’s important that modern developments like this don’t get held back by loud vocal minorities complaining about losing views they are not entititled to. The maximum height is not particularly overbearing at all.

1 311 What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Consider strongly the recommendations of the Urban Design Panel on exemplary design, but otherwise approve the application.

Are you a trade competitor of the applicant? I am not a trade competitor of the applicant.

Do you want to attend a hearing and speak in support of your submission? No

If other people make a similar submission I will consider making a joint case with them at the hearing: No

Supporting information:

2 312 Linda Butler

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz Sent: Saturday, 22 September 2018 9:15 AM To: Central RC Submissions Cc: [email protected] & Subject: [ID:2075] Submission received on notified resource consent

Notified resource consent application details

Property address: 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28, & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay.

Application number: BUN60324987

Applicant name: Drive Holdings Limited

Applicant email: [email protected] & [email protected]

Submitter contact details

Full name: Sangeeta Desai

Organisation name:

Contact phone number: 02102989104

Email address: [email protected]

Postal address: 33 Norana Ave, Remuera Auckland 1050

Submission details

This submission: supports the application in whole or in part

Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: I would like to see the location to be developed, modernised. I would like to see the area receives the investment it deserves.

What are the reasons for your submission?

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? I would like to see the company invests in public places such as building skate parks, plant palm trees, fountains, boardwalks etc. and make the area easily accessible for public enjoyment.

1 313 Are you a trade competitor of the applicant? I am not a trade competitor of the applicant.

Do you want to attend a hearing and speak in support of your submission? No

If other people make a similar submission I will consider making a joint case with them at the hearing: No

Supporting information:

2 314 Linda Butler

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz Sent: Saturday, 22 September 2018 10:30 AM To: Central RC Submissions Cc: [email protected] & Subject: [ID:2076] Submission received on notified resource consent

Notified resource consent application details

Property address: 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28, & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay.

Application number: BUN60324987

Applicant name: Drive Holdings Limited

Applicant email: [email protected] & [email protected]

Submitter contact details

Full name: Jocelyn Whyte

Organisation name:

Contact phone number: 09 5284824

Email address: [email protected]

Postal address: 26 Hopkins Crescent Kohimarama Auckland 1070

Submission details

This submission: opposes the application in whole or in part

Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: The height

What are the reasons for your submission? I appreciate the time, thought and effort that has gone into planning this development. I like the overall concept which has the potential to refresh Mission Bay which, by virtue of the Selwyn Reserve beach frontage is probably the most visited and used of the waterfront beaches in Auckland. However, I consider 8 storeys is too high on the beachfront. There is a natural connection between the beaches and the ridges behind which is broken by tall buildings on the waterfront.

1 315 What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? I would like to see the height reduced to maximum 6 storeys if possible.

Are you a trade competitor of the applicant? I am not a trade competitor of the applicant.

Do you want to attend a hearing and speak in support of your submission? No

If other people make a similar submission I will consider making a joint case with them at the hearing: No

Supporting information:

2 316 Linda Butler

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz Sent: Saturday, 22 September 2018 11:15 AM To: Central RC Submissions Cc: [email protected] & Subject: [ID:2077] Submission received on notified resource consent

Notified resource consent application details

Property address: 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28, & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay.

Application number: BUN60324987

Applicant name: Drive Holdings Limited

Applicant email: [email protected] & [email protected]

Submitter contact details

Full name: Lyn Gillanders

Organisation name:

Contact phone number: 9-5757334

Email address: [email protected]

Postal address: 529 Riddell Rd Glendowie Auckland 1071

Submission details

This submission: supports the application in whole or in part

Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Height needs modification to be less monumental and out of keeping with lovely historic seaside settlement. The design features could be strengthened to more in keeping with the art deco character of existing waterfront homes including the immediately adjacent apartments. Overall this development is welcome.

What are the reasons for your submission? As a local family we use Mission Bay frequently for recreation and entertainment including cafes and the movie theatre.

1 317 What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Give planning permission after the developers have bought the height down to 4 stories maximum on Tamaki Drive and redesign of the buildings to a more sympathetic art deco character.

Are you a trade competitor of the applicant? I am not a trade competitor of the applicant.

Do you want to attend a hearing and speak in support of your submission? No

If other people make a similar submission I will consider making a joint case with them at the hearing: Yes

Supporting information:

2 318 Linda Butler

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz Sent: Saturday, 22 September 2018 11:30 AM To: Central RC Submissions Cc: [email protected] & Subject: [ID:2078] Submission received on notified resource consent

Notified resource consent application details

Property address: 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28, & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay.

Application number: BUN60324987

Applicant name: Drive Holdings Limited

Applicant email: [email protected] & [email protected]

Submitter contact details

Full name: Michael Christie

Organisation name:

Contact phone number: 0223287067

Email address: [email protected]

Postal address: 2/15 Eltham road Kohimarama Auckland 1071

Submission details

This submission: opposes the application in whole or in part

Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: I object to the removal of the Art Deco buildings (cinema and de fontein) and the style of the new development.

What are the reasons for your submission? The proposed architecture style is tasteless. The removal of the original buildings will leave mission bay a charmless place.

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Maintain the cinema building. The lovely brick behind has so much character. Keep the facade of defontein and tidy

1 319 up the shops. I am not against the removal of the building which starts at dis amigos towards sals pizza. I suggest a style that isn’t trying to be a replica of a bygone era. This look dated and naff immediately and look even worse in time when the buildings and materials lose their sheen.

Are you a trade competitor of the applicant? I am not a trade competitor of the applicant.

Do you want to attend a hearing and speak in support of your submission? Yes

If other people make a similar submission I will consider making a joint case with them at the hearing: Yes

Supporting information:

2 320 Linda Butler

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz Sent: Saturday, 22 September 2018 12:00 PM To: Central RC Submissions Cc: [email protected] & Subject: [ID:2079] Submission received on notified resource consent

Notified resource consent application details

Property address: 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28, & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay.

Application number: BUN60324987

Applicant name: Drive Holdings Limited

Applicant email: [email protected] & [email protected]

Submitter contact details

Full name: Jean Cogle

Organisation name:

Contact phone number: 0225418446

Email address: [email protected]

Postal address: 1/2 Thatcher street Mission bay Auckland 1071

Submission details

This submission: supports the application in whole or in part

Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: I just want to state i am for the proposed changes in its current form. I believe Mission bay is long overdue for an upgrade and this submission will push the area in the right direction

What are the reasons for your submission?

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? No amendments

1 321 Are you a trade competitor of the applicant? I am not a trade competitor of the applicant.

Do you want to attend a hearing and speak in support of your submission? No

If other people make a similar submission I will consider making a joint case with them at the hearing: No

Supporting information:

2 322 Linda Butler

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz Sent: Saturday, 22 September 2018 2:00 PM To: Central RC Submissions Cc: [email protected] & Subject: [ID:2080] Submission received on notified resource consent

Notified resource consent application details

Property address: 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28, & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay.

Application number: BUN60324987

Applicant name: Drive Holdings Limited

Applicant email: [email protected] & [email protected]

Submitter contact details

Full name: Jonathan Smith

Organisation name:

Contact phone number: 021704316

Email address: [email protected]

Postal address: 1/28 Eastglen Road Glen Eden Auckland 0602

Submission details

This submission: supports the application in whole or in part

Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: I would like to give my full backing to the application to develop the area around Mission Bay.

What are the reasons for your submission? In my mind Mission Bay is a great part of Auckland. I think as our city grows, and has grown, it needs great places for it's people to enjoy their evenings and weekends. A high quality destination would be a great addition to the city. I find the idea that a handful of home owners in the vicinity of the development could stop it is highly frustrating. I ask myself 'Why should a few hundred people in Mission Bay, and even fewer particular home owners, limit what could be used by tens of thousands of other Aucklanders every year.'

1 323 What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? I would like the council to decide in favour of the development at Mission Bay.

Are you a trade competitor of the applicant? I am not a trade competitor of the applicant.

Do you want to attend a hearing and speak in support of your submission? No

If other people make a similar submission I will consider making a joint case with them at the hearing: No

Supporting information:

2 324 Linda Butler

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz Sent: Saturday, 22 September 2018 2:30 PM To: Central RC Submissions Cc: [email protected] & Subject: [ID:2081] Submission received on notified resource consent

Notified resource consent application details

Property address: 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28, & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay.

Application number: BUN60324987

Applicant name: Drive Holdings Limited

Applicant email: [email protected] & [email protected]

Submitter contact details

Full name: Liam McKanny

Organisation name:

Contact phone number: 02102722874

Email address: [email protected]

Postal address: 9 waitara road St Heliers Auckland 1071

Submission details

This submission: supports the application in whole or in part

Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: all of it

What are the reasons for your submission? Absolutely think mission bay should be developed as it is such a busy area and a big tourist spot. This development will generate more income for local businesses and turn mission bay into a must visit place! The proposed application excites me as a local and will enhance mission bay and the whole Bay Area for the future.

1 325 What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? To approve this

Are you a trade competitor of the applicant? I am not a trade competitor of the applicant.

Do you want to attend a hearing and speak in support of your submission? Yes

If other people make a similar submission I will consider making a joint case with them at the hearing: Yes

Supporting information:

2 326 Linda Butler

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz Sent: Saturday, 22 September 2018 3:45 PM To: Central RC Submissions Cc: [email protected] & Subject: [ID:2082] Submission received on notified resource consent

Notified resource consent application details

Property address: 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28, & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay.

Application number: BUN60324987

Applicant name: Drive Holdings Limited

Applicant email: [email protected] & [email protected]

Submitter contact details

Full name: Robert and Diane Strevens

Organisation name:

Contact phone number: 5287980

Email address: [email protected]

Postal address: 2/35 Selwyn Avenue Mission Bay Auckland 1071

Submission details

This submission: opposes the application in whole or in part

Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: The height of the proposed development .

What are the reasons for your submission? The height of the proposed development will create an over-powering aspect to the area and so will spoil the character of a relaxed beach-side water front.

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? We would like the Council to keep to the height limitations required by the Unitary Plan.

1 327 Are you a trade competitor of the applicant? I am not a trade competitor of the applicant.

Do you want to attend a hearing and speak in support of your submission? No

If other people make a similar submission I will consider making a joint case with them at the hearing: No

Supporting information:

2 328 Linda Butler

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz Sent: Saturday, 22 September 2018 4:15 PM To: Central RC Submissions Cc: [email protected] & Subject: [ID:2083] Submission received on notified resource consent

Notified resource consent application details

Property address: 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28, & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay.

Application number: BUN60324987

Applicant name: Drive Holdings Limited

Applicant email: [email protected] & [email protected]

Submitter contact details

Full name: Andrew Parsons

Organisation name: tfrd nz

Contact phone number: 0211649110

Email address: [email protected]

Postal address: 2c nihill Cr auckland auckland 1071

Submission details

This submission: opposes the application in whole or in part

Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: The application as a whole

What are the reasons for your submission? As a local resident,

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? I would like the council to reject the proposal in its entirety due to its excessive size. Furthermore, the tikanga of the

1 329 area is Art Deco architecture. This design "references" the tikanga like a dog "references" a lamp post as the design is a stark brutalist monocoloured schema in the vein of Bauhaus design which is totally inappropriate

Are you a trade competitor of the applicant? I am not a trade competitor of the applicant.

Do you want to attend a hearing and speak in support of your submission? No

If other people make a similar submission I will consider making a joint case with them at the hearing: Yes

Supporting information:

2 330 Linda Butler

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz Sent: Saturday, 22 September 2018 4:45 PM To: Central RC Submissions Cc: [email protected] & Subject: [ID:2084] Submission received on notified resource consent

Notified resource consent application details

Property address: 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28, & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay.

Application number: BUN60324987

Applicant name: Drive Holdings Limited

Applicant email: [email protected] & [email protected]

Submitter contact details

Full name: Rita Hunt

Organisation name:

Contact phone number: 0211081960

Email address: [email protected]

Postal address: 35A Truro Road Camborne Porirua 5026

Submission details

This submission: supports the application in whole or in part

Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: The height of the buildings, and to some extent the style.

What are the reasons for your submission? Start Mission Bay - higher buildings? No, PLEASE don’t https://www.nzherald.co.nz/business/news/article.cfm?c_id=3&objectid=12129250 Battle lines drawn in fight for Mission Bay's future as developer lodges consent application for housing and retail complex Hi All I don’t even live in Auckland but even I am horrified by this proposal. For frequent visitors like me (and probably locals alike) Mission Bay is a refuge from the madness that is now Auckland and a jewel in the crown of the city. If more housing and retail is wanted by all means upgrade what there is now but most definitely do not go much higher than it is now. It will end up 1 331 similar to a horrible Gold Coast conglomerate and totally ruin the beachy balmy feel the area has now. People don’t want to feel overlooked on the grassy and beach areas and have a sense of freedom there which would be impeded by higher developments. Why is Auckland so bent on destroying itself with ever more concrete? The CBD is fairly horrible now with every square inch being taken up by a high rise building. It has become a city of greed. At least leave the horribleness to limited locations only, but hands off Mission Bay, please. End.

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Restrict the height of all buildings to the level of the tallest one now. Style the buildings in a soft style, not blandly urban.

Are you a trade competitor of the applicant? I am not a trade competitor of the applicant.

Do you want to attend a hearing and speak in support of your submission? No

If other people make a similar submission I will consider making a joint case with them at the hearing: No

Supporting information:

2 332 Linda Butler

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz Sent: Saturday, 22 September 2018 4:45 PM To: Central RC Submissions Cc: [email protected] & Subject: [ID:2085] Submission received on notified resource consent

Notified resource consent application details

Property address: 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28, & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay.

Application number: BUN60324987

Applicant name: Drive Holdings Limited

Applicant email: [email protected] & [email protected]

Submitter contact details

Full name: Chris de Lautour

Organisation name:

Contact phone number: +6421933770

Email address: [email protected]

Postal address: 46 Garnet Rd Auckland Auckland 1022

Submission details

This submission: opposes the application in whole or in part

Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: The height of the development

What are the reasons for your submission? This is a character suburb. Height should be restricted as per the Unitary Plan. Srongly object to the height restrictions in the Unitary Plan being disregarded. This will set a precedent for all other developments across the city. Aucklanders do not want Mission Bay looking like the trashy aspects of the Gold Coast. Keep it tasteful by keeping all parts of the development with in the Unitary Plan height restrictions.

1 333 What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? The height should be as specified in the Unitary Plan.

Are you a trade competitor of the applicant? I am not a trade competitor of the applicant.

Do you want to attend a hearing and speak in support of your submission? No

If other people make a similar submission I will consider making a joint case with them at the hearing: No

Supporting information:

2 334 Linda Butler

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz Sent: Saturday, 22 September 2018 7:15 PM To: Central RC Submissions Cc: [email protected] & Subject: [ID:2087] Submission received on notified resource consent

Notified resource consent application details

Property address: 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28, & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay.

Application number: BUN60324987

Applicant name: Drive Holdings Limited

Applicant email: [email protected] & [email protected]

Submitter contact details

Full name: Gulina Kubanychbekova

Organisation name:

Contact phone number: 0211399451

Email address: [email protected]

Postal address: 18 Clairville crescent Wai o Taiki Bay Auckland 1072

Submission details

This submission: supports the application in whole or in part

Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: I love the whole concept of developing Mission Bay.

What are the reasons for your submission? I live nearby this area and we visit regularly with family. It is a great place and this development will only enhance this area.

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? To support this development in full.

1 335 Are you a trade competitor of the applicant? I am not a trade competitor of the applicant.

Do you want to attend a hearing and speak in support of your submission? No

If other people make a similar submission I will consider making a joint case with them at the hearing: No

Supporting information:

2 336 Linda Butler

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz Sent: Sunday, 23 September 2018 12:15 AM To: Central RC Submissions Cc: [email protected] & Subject: [ID:2088] Submission received on notified resource consent

Notified resource consent application details

Property address: 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28, & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay.

Application number: BUN60324987

Applicant name: Drive Holdings Limited

Applicant email: [email protected] & [email protected]

Submitter contact details

Full name: Phil Wheeler

Organisation name:

Contact phone number: 021779166

Email address: [email protected]

Postal address: 33 Hopkins Crescent Kohimarama Auckland 1071

Submission details

This submission: opposes the application in whole or in part

Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: As a resident and home owner in Kohimarama, I’m grateful for the opportunity to respond to the proposed development from Urban Partners for the Mission Bay precinct. While I am fully supportive of regeneration in the area, anything that harms the underlying spirit of the area, or ignores its history and artefacts, is a concern for me. In particular I would respond to: 1) the underlying need for regeneration 2) the timing of the submission with respect to other regeneration in the area 3) the destruction of the existing Art Deco architecture 4) the proposed height of the development compared to the Unitary Plan regulations 5) the impact on local infrastructure 6) the lack of non- commercial community facilities included in the proposal

1 337 What are the reasons for your submission? 1) I think that a renewal of Mission Bay, bringing a mix of housing, retail, food and bev, is a positive for the area. It looks tired with a mix of food and bev offerings that is a little vanilla in feel given that many of the older, family run places have been replaced by major chains 2) I question how this proposal is submitted only 12 months after the council renewed the road and footpath infrastructure and hope that this investment would be recouped from the proponents who have been beneficiaries of this renewed infrastructure since its completion 3) I’m particularly opposed to the destruction of the Art Deco architecture (eg, the external parts of the De Fontein corner building, and the Berkeley Cinemas facade). There are many ways in which to allow a development such as this without impacting some of the unique features of the existing buildings The similarly Art Deco styled “Ritz Cinema” in Randwick was redeveloped in the 1990s, in many ways retaining the original styling and feel, yet expanding the number of cinemas and surrounding food and beverage outlets. In fact, the entire area of the “The Spot” in Randwick is an excellent example of developing a high value restaurant precinct without destroying the local feel. 4) I am opposed to the maximum height of the buildings. It is simply too high. It will not be in any way respectful of the existing surroundings, and the submissions made to Council (as shown for instance in Plans and Visuals Parts 8, 9, 12, and 14) show clearly that it exceeds the regulations of the Unitary Plan. 5) the proposal does not appear to sufficiently acknowledge the impact on existing infrastructure from increase residents and visitors. While the Traffic Report references existing bus routes in the submission, and the number of parking space provided, I would consider the review to be cursory at best. It seems only logical that additional buses would be required to service the area's residents and visitors, which would have a flow on affect to bus parking/access, which is not considered in the report. In addition, as there are no details with respect to the payment expected for parking, then it can only be assumed that the proponent would take a commercial view and charge for parking. The consequence being the significant increase in the demand for free parking in the vicinity, including on local surrounding roads. A commitment from the proponents to supporting the community through free parking should be required. 6) while the proposal includes a new cinema complex, it fails to acknowledge the non-commercial needs of the community in any way. Our community, across the entire eastern bays from Orakei to Glendowie, has a very broad socio-economic base which is not accommodated in the proposal. There are no new features that would support the local community such as a community centre, library, children's play area, etc . Mission Bay is a wonderful places for families of all incomes to spend time. With the numbers of families like to increase as part of this development, I would expect the proponents to deliver additional facilities to cater for the continued enjoyment of the area, as well as to "pay back" to the community in some manner As a final word, one has only to look across to Sydney to see how developments such as this have impacted local communities and the beaches that are at their centre. Bondi Beach is no longer is an area with a family feel, but is instead filled with high rise buildings valued at equally high prices, suffering from lack of access and transport, and with most families driven out by high tourist numbers and the wealthy. Development of the Bondi Beach area has had a severely negative impact on the culture of the suburb and I would be disappointed to see this become the future for Mission Bay. I feel that the proponents of this development should take a much broader view of the opportunity than is currently incorporated into its commercially focused proposal.

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? In my view, council should encourage the following amendments 2) the proponent to repay council in full for the upgrades made in the last two years to the pedestrian area on the south side of Tamaki drive 3) council to encourage the developer to consider the retention of the existing Art Deco architecture into the design of the buildings 4) council to impose, in the strictest terms, the limits included in the Unitary Plan on building heights 5) council to request a more detailed submission from the proponents on its commitments for parking, including a commitment from the proponent to support of free parking. Also, a more detailed submission on the impact of the development on pubic transport including bus frequency and bus parking infrastructure 6) council to request the developer to consider the incorporation of non-commercial community facilities in the development

Are you a trade competitor of the applicant? I am not a trade competitor of the applicant.

Do you want to attend a hearing and speak in support of your submission? No

If other people make a similar submission I will consider making a joint case with them at the hearing: Yes

Supporting information:

2 338 Linda Butler

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz Sent: Sunday, 23 September 2018 8:16 AM To: Central RC Submissions Cc: [email protected] & Subject: [ID:2089] Submission received on notified resource consent

Notified resource consent application details

Property address: 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28, & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay.

Application number: BUN60324987

Applicant name: Drive Holdings Limited

Applicant email: [email protected] & [email protected]

Submitter contact details

Full name: Annette Mary Moody

Organisation name:

Contact phone number: 0275643225

Email address: [email protected]

Postal address: Eastcliffe Retirement Village Apt2f 80 Aotea Street Orakei Auckland 1071

Submission details

This submission: supports the application in whole or in part

Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: The height should only be as much as specified for residential buildings. And not more than 3 stories. Parking is a great need.

What are the reasons for your submission? Height proposed it too much.

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? As above. You can't one two different rules for same situation.

1 339 Are you a trade competitor of the applicant? I am not a trade competitor of the applicant.

Do you want to attend a hearing and speak in support of your submission? No

If other people make a similar submission I will consider making a joint case with them at the hearing: Yes

Supporting information:

2 340 Linda Butler

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz Sent: Sunday, 23 September 2018 9:46 AM To: Central RC Submissions Cc: [email protected] & Subject: [ID:2090] Submission received on notified resource consent

Notified resource consent application details

Property address: 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28, & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay.

Application number: BUN60324987

Applicant name: Drive Holdings Limited

Applicant email: [email protected] & [email protected]

Submitter contact details

Full name: Michael Wanless

Organisation name:

Contact phone number: 021737487

Email address: [email protected]

Postal address: 20 Barrack Road Mt Wellington Auckland 1060

Submission details

This submission: opposes the application in whole or in part

Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: All

What are the reasons for your submission? This proposal will detrimentally affect the character of the area. 7 storeys is not in keeping with the current stock of existing buildings. Reduce to 3 storeys maximum

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Decline consent until new plans are submitted for a 3 storey building at maximum

1 341 Are you a trade competitor of the applicant? I am not a trade competitor of the applicant.

Do you want to attend a hearing and speak in support of your submission? No

If other people make a similar submission I will consider making a joint case with them at the hearing: Yes

Supporting information:

2 342 Linda Butler

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz Sent: Monday, 24 September 2018 7:30 AM To: Central RC Submissions Cc: [email protected] & Subject: [ID:2091] Submission received on notified resource consent

Notified resource consent application details

Property address: 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28, & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay.

Application number: BUN60324987

Applicant name: Drive Holdings Limited

Applicant email: [email protected] & [email protected]

Submitter contact details

Full name: Dr Karen Jones

Organisation name:

Contact phone number: 0274526966

Email address: [email protected]

Postal address: 78 Grampian Road St Heliers Auckland’s 1061

Submission details

This submission: opposes the application in whole or in part

Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Building height exceeds Unitary Plan restrictions

What are the reasons for your submission? There is a reason the Unitary Plan allows for 4 levels. This height is a reasonable balance between the need to provide additional housing and facilities, and the needs of local residents and visitors to enjoy views, open spaces and environments without feeling dominated and overshadowed by tower blocks. It also reduces the impact of an already increasing population into the area on both the infrastructure and environment as a whole.

1 343 What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Restrict height and ensure sustainability of the area.

Are you a trade competitor of the applicant? I am not a trade competitor of the applicant.

Do you want to attend a hearing and speak in support of your submission? No

If other people make a similar submission I will consider making a joint case with them at the hearing: Yes

Supporting information:

2 344 Linda Butler

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz Sent: Monday, 24 September 2018 8:30 AM To: Central RC Submissions Cc: [email protected] & Subject: [ID:2092] Submission received on notified resource consent

Notified resource consent application details

Property address: 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28, & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay.

Application number: BUN60324987

Applicant name: Drive Holdings Limited

Applicant email: [email protected] & [email protected]

Submitter contact details

Full name: Saroch Torthienchai

Organisation name:

Contact phone number: 021-02053333

Email address: [email protected]

Postal address: 27A Marau Crescent, mission bay auckland Auckland City 1071

Submission details

This submission: supports the application in whole or in part

Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: I am supporting the development in my community because there are actually a lot of people visit Mission bay all year round and If we could offer them more activities and facilities in the area, this would generate more attraction points in Mission Bay.

What are the reasons for your submission? Like to see the community growing

1 345 What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Please proceed fast within the planned time frame as If possible

Are you a trade competitor of the applicant? I am not a trade competitor of the applicant.

Do you want to attend a hearing and speak in support of your submission? No

If other people make a similar submission I will consider making a joint case with them at the hearing: Yes

Supporting information:

2 346 Linda Butler

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz Sent: Monday, 24 September 2018 10:30 AM To: Central RC Submissions Cc: [email protected] & Subject: [ID:2093] Submission received on notified resource consent

Notified resource consent application details

Property address: 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28, & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay.

Application number: BUN60324987

Applicant name: Drive Holdings Limited

Applicant email: [email protected] & [email protected]

Submitter contact details

Full name: Peter Haarhaus

Organisation name:

Contact phone number: 0210358654

Email address: [email protected]

Postal address: 46D Godden Crescent Mission Bay Auckland 1071

Submission details

This submission: opposes the application in whole or in part

Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: The set (building) rules should be followed. No exception.

What are the reasons for your submission? I do not agree that a Auckland council accepts building applications outside of the set rules. Council should accept building applications to look at only if they are within the rules.

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Stick within the (building) rules. No exception.

1 347 Are you a trade competitor of the applicant? I am not a trade competitor of the applicant.

Do you want to attend a hearing and speak in support of your submission? No

If other people make a similar submission I will consider making a joint case with them at the hearing: Yes

Supporting information:

2 348 Ranjeeta Singh

From: Robyn Pilkington on behalf of Central RC Submissions Sent: Monday, 24 September 2018 2:18 PM To: Premium Submissions Subject: FW: [ID:2094] Submission received on notified resource consent

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz [mailto:NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz] Sent: Monday, 24 September 2018 1:15 p.m. To: Central RC Submissions Cc: [email protected] & Subject: [ID:2094] Submission received on notified resource consent

Notified resource consent application details

Property address: 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28, & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay.

Application number: BUN60324987

Applicant name: Drive Holdings Limited

Applicant email: [email protected] & [email protected]

Submitter contact details

Full name: Andrew and Jeanette Hayes

Organisation name: AJHayes and JMWaite Family Trust

Contact phone number: 09 5217412

Email address: [email protected]

Postal address: 51 Ripon Crescent, Meadowbank Auckland 1072

Submission details

This submission: opposes the application in whole or in part

1 349 Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: The development should be restricted to the height and boundary limits imposed by the new unitary plan without any discretionary uplift. As proposed, the buildings are too dominant in their cumulative and individual bulk, design and positioning, for the anticipated future character of the surrounding neighbourhood.

What are the reasons for your submission?

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Refusal of the application in total and invitation to submit a new compliant plan for a fresh denovo consideration.

Are you a trade competitor of the applicant? I am not a trade competitor of the applicant.

Do you want to attend a hearing and speak in support of your submission? Yes

If other people make a similar submission I will consider making a joint case with them at the hearing: Yes

Supporting information:

2 350 Ranjeeta Singh

From: Robyn Pilkington on behalf of Central RC Submissions Sent: Monday, 24 September 2018 2:18 PM To: Premium Submissions Subject: FW: [ID:2095] Submission received on notified resource consent

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz [mailto:NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz] Sent: Monday, 24 September 2018 2:15 p.m. To: Central RC Submissions Cc: [email protected] & Subject: [ID:2095] Submission received on notified resource consent

Notified resource consent application details

Property address: 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28, & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay.

Application number: BUN60324987

Applicant name: Drive Holdings Limited

Applicant email: [email protected] & [email protected]

Submitter contact details

Full name: Louise Lusty

Organisation name:

Contact phone number: 021734742

Email address: [email protected]

Postal address: 14 Granada Place Glendowie Auckland 1071

Submission details

This submission: opposes the application in whole or in part

1 351 Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Height

What are the reasons for your submission? Should be max 4 stories

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Stick to 4 stories

Are you a trade competitor of the applicant? I am not a trade competitor of the applicant.

Do you want to attend a hearing and speak in support of your submission? No

If other people make a similar submission I will consider making a joint case with them at the hearing: Yes

Supporting information:

2 352 Linda Butler

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz Sent: Monday, 24 September 2018 4:45 PM To: Central RC Submissions Cc: [email protected] & Subject: [ID:2097] Submission received on notified resource consent

Notified resource consent application details

Property address: 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28, & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay.

Application number: BUN60324987

Applicant name: Drive Holdings Limited

Applicant email: [email protected] & [email protected]

Submitter contact details

Full name: Chen Jiang

Organisation name:

Contact phone number: 021945059

Email address: [email protected]

Postal address: 52 Comins Crescent Mission Bay Auckland 1071

Submission details

This submission: opposes the application in whole or in part

Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Height and design

What are the reasons for your submission? In relation to height, the proposed apartments should be limited to 4 storeys (not 8 as proposed). This would make it consistent visually with the surrounding area. Mission Bay is a family friendly and suburban beach - I don't want it to turn into the Gold Coast. In relation to the design, the proposed development lacks respect for the existing character of the area and is uninspiring in general. It is bland and tacky and reflects nothing about our unique New Zealand landscape and culture. I would prefer to keep the art deco facade but for the apartments to rise behind it. I am in support of development, but they should be of the appropriate height and design. 1 353 What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? 1. To limit the height to four storeys. 2. To have the design to be amended to something that is unique and inspiring.

Are you a trade competitor of the applicant? I am not a trade competitor of the applicant.

Do you want to attend a hearing and speak in support of your submission? Yes

If other people make a similar submission I will consider making a joint case with them at the hearing: Yes

Supporting information:

2 354 Linda Butler

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz Sent: Monday, 24 September 2018 5:30 PM To: Central RC Submissions Cc: [email protected] & Subject: [ID:2098] Submission received on notified resource consent

Notified resource consent application details

Property address: 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28, & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay.

Application number: BUN60324987

Applicant name: Drive Holdings Limited

Applicant email: [email protected] & [email protected]

Submitter contact details

Full name: Allison Willis

Organisation name:

Contact phone number: 5288392

Email address: [email protected]

Postal address: 65 Kurahaupo St Orakei Auckland 1071

Submission details

This submission: opposes the application in whole or in part

Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: The height should not be allowed to exceed the 18m maximum under the unitary plan. It would be preferable if the cinema entrance and courtyard were at ground level.

What are the reasons for your submission? Mission Bay main attraction is as a seaside suburb. Overheight buildings will dominate the bay and detract from the general atmosphere. We should learn from the Sunshine Coast where with height restrictions in Noosa they have maintained a seaside feel in their main street, whereas other nearby beaches are dominated with high rise buildings and have little atmosphere. This proposal is at least 3 times higher than the building currently on the corner of Patteson Ave and Tamaki Drive, and will change the feeling at that intersection significantly. 1 355 What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Ensure that the height restrictions are strictly adhered. They should also ensure a feeling of openness is maintained with the separate buildings as shown in the proposals and if possible bring the courtyard and cinema entrance to ground level.

Are you a trade competitor of the applicant? I am not a trade competitor of the applicant.

Do you want to attend a hearing and speak in support of your submission? No

If other people make a similar submission I will consider making a joint case with them at the hearing: No

Supporting information:

2 356 Linda Butler

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz Sent: Tuesday, 25 September 2018 7:01 AM To: Central RC Submissions Cc: [email protected] & Subject: [ID:2102] Submission received on notified resource consent

Notified resource consent application details

Property address: 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28, & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay.

Application number: BUN60324987

Applicant name: Drive Holdings Limited

Applicant email: [email protected] & [email protected]

Submitter contact details

Full name: John Service

Organisation name:

Contact phone number: 0275284849

Email address: [email protected]

Postal address: 54 Codrington cres Mission Bay Auckland 1071

Submission details

This submission: supports the application in whole or in part

Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Whole

What are the reasons for your submission? Revamp a very run down area

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Past and support the development

1 357 Are you a trade competitor of the applicant? I am not a trade competitor of the applicant.

Do you want to attend a hearing and speak in support of your submission? Yes

If other people make a similar submission I will consider making a joint case with them at the hearing: Yes

Supporting information:

2 358 Linda Butler

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz Sent: Tuesday, 25 September 2018 7:46 AM To: Central RC Submissions Cc: [email protected] & Subject: [ID:2103] Submission received on notified resource consent

Notified resource consent application details

Property address: 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28, & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay.

Application number: BUN60324987

Applicant name: Drive Holdings Limited

Applicant email: [email protected] & [email protected]

Submitter contact details

Full name: Grahame and Prue Taylor

Organisation name:

Contact phone number: 021985869

Email address: [email protected]

Postal address: 125D Tamaki Drive Mission Bay Auckland 1071

Submission details

This submission: opposes the application in whole or in part

Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Height of buildings

What are the reasons for your submission? Mission Bay does not need to have eight story buildings along its waterfront. If allowed, they will create a precedent for all beach side developments in New Zealand. We do not want to be overbuilt like Surface Paradise or similar, with high rise developments. A lower profile, more like Nice in France, would be more appropriate. Four story buildings should be the maximum allowed as this would not create shadowing, wind tunnels and over powering, visual dominance. This will also allow everyone in the area to enjoy the ambiance and views over Auckland Harbour that they have paid dearly to enjoy. Mission Bay has always enjoyed a village atmosphere, and while upgrades and 1 359 progress are important, destroying this village vibe is not good for the community. Unfortunately a project as big as is proposed, will also destroy the tourist and local community usage and enjoyment of Mission Bay, as it will disrupt the area for several years while rebuilding takes place. This will take years to recover. We have lived in Mission Bay for nearly 50 years and acknowledge progressive upgrades are needed to keep a neighbourhood alive and moving forward, but not to the detriment of ambiance, community living and business. At present tourist visitors and locals enjoy the unique Mission Bay beach, cafe, theatre, fresh air, walks and open, low rise, Art Deco atmosphere. Hopefully this will not be destroyed. Please think carefully!

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Please reduce height of buildings to a four story maximum on Tamaki Drive and only two or three story buildings on Marau Cresent and Patterson Avenue.

Are you a trade competitor of the applicant? I am not a trade competitor of the applicant.

Do you want to attend a hearing and speak in support of your submission? No

If other people make a similar submission I will consider making a joint case with them at the hearing: No

Supporting information:

2 360 Linda Butler

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz Sent: Tuesday, 25 September 2018 1:16 PM To: Central RC Submissions Cc: [email protected] & Subject: [ID:2104] Submission received on notified resource consent

Notified resource consent application details

Property address: 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28, & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay.

Application number: BUN60324987

Applicant name: Drive Holdings Limited

Applicant email: [email protected] & [email protected]

Submitter contact details

Full name: Gloria Seaman

Organisation name:

Contact phone number: 02102218085

Email address: [email protected]

Postal address: 6 Saint Johns Auckland 1072

Submission details

This submission: opposes the application in whole or in part

Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Demolition of the existing structures like the original iconic buildings along mission bay and the fabulous stylish little cinema

What are the reasons for your submission? To keep the iconic look and charm of Mission Bay and stop high rise appartment and retail buildings destroying the stylish heritage buildings. We don’t need another heart less modern high rise area especially not so close to the beach and in Misdion bay which is a first go to for most tourists that come to Auckland as well as New Zealand residents.

1 361 What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? See above Stop the exploitation for money and keep the charm of Much loved Mission Bay

Are you a trade competitor of the applicant? I am not a trade competitor of the applicant.

Do you want to attend a hearing and speak in support of your submission? No

If other people make a similar submission I will consider making a joint case with them at the hearing: No

Supporting information:

2 362 Ranjeeta Singh

From: Robyn Pilkington on behalf of Central RC Submissions Sent: Wednesday, 26 September 2018 7:47 AM To: Premium Submissions Subject: FW: [ID:2105] Submission received on notified resource consent

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz [mailto:NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz] Sent: Tuesday, 25 September 2018 2:16 p.m. To: Central RC Submissions Cc: [email protected] & Subject: [ID:2105] Submission received on notified resource consent

Notified resource consent application details

Property address: 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28, & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay.

Application number: BUN60324987

Applicant name: Drive Holdings Limited

Applicant email: [email protected] & [email protected]

Submitter contact details

Full name: David King

Organisation name:

Contact phone number: 0275745125

Email address: [email protected]

Postal address: 32 Ganley tce Stonefields Auckland 1072

Submission details

This submission: opposes the application in whole or in part

1 363 Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Change to existing building height allowance

What are the reasons for your submission? Will change the existing character and ambiance which is todays drawcard.

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Don't change existing height restrictions

Are you a trade competitor of the applicant? I am not a trade competitor of the applicant.

Do you want to attend a hearing and speak in support of your submission? No

If other people make a similar submission I will consider making a joint case with them at the hearing: No

Supporting information:

2 364 Ranjeeta Singh

From: Robyn Pilkington on behalf of Central RC Submissions Sent: Wednesday, 26 September 2018 7:48 AM To: Premium Submissions Subject: FW: [ID:2106] Submission received on notified resource consent

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz [mailto:NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz] Sent: Tuesday, 25 September 2018 2:31 p.m. To: Central RC Submissions Cc: [email protected] & Subject: [ID:2106] Submission received on notified resource consent

Notified resource consent application details

Property address: 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28, & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay.

Application number: BUN60324987

Applicant name: Drive Holdings Limited

Applicant email: [email protected] & [email protected]

Submitter contact details

Full name: Mattie Aspen Queale

Organisation name:

Contact phone number: 0212154360

Email address: [email protected]

Postal address: 19 patteson avenue Mission Bay Auckland 1071

Submission details

This submission: opposes the application in whole or in part

1 365 Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Building height, density and parking

What are the reasons for your submission? I own and live at 19 Patteson Avenue. While I support the redevelopment of the property in question, I have serious concerns about the height, scale and density of the development proposed. While some buildings in the area are more then four storeys in height, they are stand alone structures, generally surrounded by gardens and spread through the neighbourhood. The scale, density and in particular height of the buildings proposed on the site is not in keeping with the residential area which surrounds it. I also have serious councerns about parking if the proposal goes ahead as contemplated. The proposal provides for the removal of existing street parking on patteson ave and the existing car park behind the Berkeley cinema. It provides for only 250 new car parks - only 58 of which will be for visitors to the site. This falls well short of what is required. Mission Bay is already short of parking and every weekend we have problems with people parking on the grass verge in front of our house, parking across our driveway and jamming local streets. Cars parked between 19 patteson ave and the corner of Patteson Ave and Marau Crescent (including on the grass verge) limit visibility and make turning in and out of our driveway very dangerous. Marau crescent also becomes very congested as it becomes a one lane road when cars are parked along both sides.

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? I would like the council to limit the height of the entire development to 4 storeys. I believe more open/green space is required within the development - in keeping with the surrounding neighbourhood. A better thought out parking plan for the development - taking account of the issues already facing mission bay, is required. 58 car parks is simply not enough. If the development goes ahead street parking should only be allowed on one side of Marau Crescent so the road can maintain 2 way traffic - and their should be no road side parking between 19 patteson ave and the corner of patteson and Marau Crescent. Signs should go up prohibiting parking on the grass verges in the area.

Are you a trade competitor of the applicant? I am not a trade competitor of the applicant.

Do you want to attend a hearing and speak in support of your submission? Yes

If other people make a similar submission I will consider making a joint case with them at the hearing: Yes

Supporting information:

2 366 Ranjeeta Singh

From: Robyn Pilkington on behalf of Central RC Submissions Sent: Wednesday, 26 September 2018 7:48 AM To: Premium Submissions Subject: FW: [ID:2107] Submission received on notified resource consent

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz [mailto:NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz] Sent: Tuesday, 25 September 2018 3:16 p.m. To: Central RC Submissions Cc: [email protected] & Subject: [ID:2107] Submission received on notified resource consent

Notified resource consent application details

Property address: 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28, & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay.

Application number: BUN60324987

Applicant name: Drive Holdings Limited

Applicant email: [email protected] & [email protected]

Submitter contact details

Full name: Elisa Norah McLennan

Organisation name:

Contact phone number: 0211300890

Email address: [email protected]

Postal address: 3/117 Selwyn Avenue Mission Bay Auckland 1071

Submission details

This submission: opposes the application in whole or in part

1 367 Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: it changes the landscape of Mission Bay dramatically to the detriment of the bay.

What are the reasons for your submission?

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Do not give consent.

Are you a trade competitor of the applicant? I am not a trade competitor of the applicant.

Do you want to attend a hearing and speak in support of your submission? No

If other people make a similar submission I will consider making a joint case with them at the hearing: No

Supporting information:

2 368 Ranjeeta Singh

From: Robyn Pilkington on behalf of Central RC Submissions Sent: Wednesday, 26 September 2018 8:04 AM To: Premium Submissions Subject: FW: [ID:2108] Submission received on notified resource consent

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz [mailto:NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz] Sent: Tuesday, 25 September 2018 4:01 p.m. To: Central RC Submissions Cc: [email protected] & Subject: [ID:2108] Submission received on notified resource consent

Notified resource consent application details

Property address: 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28, & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay.

Application number: BUN60324987

Applicant name: Drive Holdings Limited

Applicant email: [email protected] & [email protected]

Submitter contact details

Full name: Elsie Margaret McKee

Organisation name:

Contact phone number: 0274345767

Email address: [email protected]

Postal address: 92 Aotea ST Orakei Auckland 1071

Submission details

This submission: opposes the application in whole or in part

1 369 Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Not complying with unitary plan regarding height limits on the flat land in Mission Bay. If this was to proceed sets a precedent for other coastal development on flat land in Kohimarama and St Heliers. Visually awful looking... like a tacky Australian coastal development and lacking any unique New Zealand/Auckland character. Too much concrete in the landscape. Development should be of a 'human scale' and no higher than the highest tree.

What are the reasons for your submission? Unacceptably change the character of Mission Bay dwarfing the park, beach, pohutukawas, norfolk pines and the people. Awful architecture lacking any NZ character and too high. Any development should be of 'human scale' and no higher than a tall tree. Important not to set a precedent than may allow more high development on the flat land along Tamaki Drive.

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Height of buildings limited to 3 stories so building is of a human scale. Style and architecture to be sympathetic to the landscape, seascape and New Zealand's unique natural and cultural heritage

Are you a trade competitor of the applicant? I am not a trade competitor of the applicant.

Do you want to attend a hearing and speak in support of your submission? No

If other people make a similar submission I will consider making a joint case with them at the hearing: No

Supporting information:

2 370 Linda Butler

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz Sent: Wednesday, 26 September 2018 4:15 PM To: Central RC Submissions Cc: [email protected] & Subject: [ID:2111] Submission received on notified resource consent

Notified resource consent application details

Property address: 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28, & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay.

Application number: BUN60324987

Applicant name: Drive Holdings Limited

Applicant email: [email protected] & [email protected]

Submitter contact details

Full name: Shona Carle

Organisation name:

Contact phone number: 09 5285132 022 0200

Email address: [email protected]

Postal address: 15B Paunui St St Heliers Bay Auckland 1071

Submission details

This submission: opposes the application in whole or in part

Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: The proposed buildings are too high and would ruin the special character of Mission Bay. Once this is lost we will never get it back. The proposed plans are ugly and have no quality or character at all. Please do not allow this development to go ahead in it's present state.

What are the reasons for your submission? As above

1 371 What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Lower the height. Have a building and development which retains the art deco history of Mission Bay

Are you a trade competitor of the applicant? I am not a trade competitor of the applicant.

Do you want to attend a hearing and speak in support of your submission? No

If other people make a similar submission I will consider making a joint case with them at the hearing: Yes

Supporting information:

2 372 Ranjeeta Singh

From: Robyn Pilkington on behalf of Central RC Submissions Sent: Thursday, 27 September 2018 7:37 AM To: Premium Submissions Subject: FW: [ID:2112] Submission received on notified resource consent

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz [mailto:NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz] Sent: Wednesday, 26 September 2018 4:45 p.m. To: Central RC Submissions Cc: [email protected] & Subject: [ID:2112] Submission received on notified resource consent

Notified resource consent application details

Property address: 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28, & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay.

Application number: BUN60324987

Applicant name: Drive Holdings Limited

Applicant email: [email protected] & [email protected]

Submitter contact details

Full name: Rex Frye

Organisation name:

Contact phone number: 09 5218601

Email address: [email protected]

Postal address: 8 Ronaki Road Mission Bay Auckland 1071

Submission details

This submission: opposes the application in whole or in part

1 373 Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Height of development excessive and totally out of keeping with area.

What are the reasons for your submission? Extremely ugly. Will take away the appearance of family friendliness from the area and diminish thereby the natural attractiveness of the reserve.It destroys Mission Bay’s uniqueness, and renders the area the same as all overdeveloped high rise sea fronts everywhere in the world. Tourists like Mission Bay because the style is understated and not artificial. We must not destroy what is unique, but add to it carefully.

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? The council has a new Unitary Plan. I would think this cost millions of dollars and many hours of contributions and consideration. It would seem ludicrous, to disregard its provisions, and permit this development which exceeds by about twofold the height limits of the Plan. The height limits set out by the plan are generous enough and do not spoil the general look and feeling of the area, provided the architectural detail is sympathetic.

Are you a trade competitor of the applicant? I am not a trade competitor of the applicant.

Do you want to attend a hearing and speak in support of your submission? No

If other people make a similar submission I will consider making a joint case with them at the hearing: No

Supporting information:

2 374 Ranjeeta Singh

From: Robyn Pilkington on behalf of Central RC Submissions Sent: Thursday, 27 September 2018 7:37 AM To: Premium Submissions Subject: FW: [ID:2114] Submission received on notified resource consent

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz [mailto:NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz] Sent: Wednesday, 26 September 2018 8:45 p.m. To: Central RC Submissions Cc: [email protected] & Subject: [ID:2114] Submission received on notified resource consent

Notified resource consent application details

Property address: 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28, & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay.

Application number: BUN60324987

Applicant name: Drive Holdings Limited

Applicant email: [email protected] & [email protected]

Submitter contact details

Full name: Alan Garny

Organisation name:

Contact phone number: 0272449673

Email address: [email protected]

Postal address: 7/10 Tagalad Rd Mission Bay Auckland 1071

Submission details

This submission: opposes the application in whole or in part

1 375 Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: I am opposing the planned height of the proposed development on Tamaki Drive. It will just be too high compared with the rest of Mission Bay's waterfront.

What are the reasons for your submission?

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? I would ask for the height to be, at most, the same as the rest of Mission Bay's waterfront.

Are you a trade competitor of the applicant? I am not a trade competitor of the applicant.

Do you want to attend a hearing and speak in support of your submission? No

If other people make a similar submission I will consider making a joint case with them at the hearing: Yes

Supporting information:

2 376 Ranjeeta Singh

From: Robyn Pilkington on behalf of Central RC Submissions Sent: Thursday, 27 September 2018 7:38 AM To: Premium Submissions Subject: FW: [ID:2115] Submission received on notified resource consent

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz [mailto:NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz] Sent: Wednesday, 26 September 2018 8:45 p.m. To: Central RC Submissions Cc: [email protected] & Subject: [ID:2115] Submission received on notified resource consent

Notified resource consent application details

Property address: 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28, & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay.

Application number: BUN60324987

Applicant name: Drive Holdings Limited

Applicant email: [email protected] & [email protected]

Submitter contact details

Full name: YAN JIANG

Organisation name:

Contact phone number: 02108203495

Email address: [email protected]

Postal address: 11 bryant place Glendowie Auckland 1071

Submission details

This submission: opposes the application in whole or in part

1 377 Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: 8 stories is very much higher than the 16m inhabitable height allowed

What are the reasons for your submission?

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? 3 or 4 stories is enough height in Mission Bay beach.

Are you a trade competitor of the applicant? I am not a trade competitor of the applicant.

Do you want to attend a hearing and speak in support of your submission? Yes

If other people make a similar submission I will consider making a joint case with them at the hearing: Yes

Supporting information:

2 378 Ranjeeta Singh

From: Robyn Pilkington on behalf of Central RC Submissions Sent: Friday, 28 September 2018 8:40 AM To: Premium Submissions Subject: FW: [ID:2122] Submission received on notified resource consent

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz [mailto:NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz] Sent: Thursday, 27 September 2018 2:30 p.m. To: Central RC Submissions Cc: [email protected] & Subject: [ID:2122] Submission received on notified resource consent

Notified resource consent application details

Property address: 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28, & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay.

Application number: BUN60324987

Applicant name: Drive Holdings Limited

Applicant email: [email protected] & [email protected]

Submitter contact details

Full name: Robert John O'Donnell

Organisation name:

Contact phone number: 021 2789275

Email address: [email protected]

Postal address: 6/9 Marau Cres Mission Bay Auckland 1071

Submission details

This submission: supports the application in whole or in part

1 379 Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: I support the new Mission Bay Project and do not object to the proposed redevelopment plans for the Mission Bay area. The new proposal would be a welcome upgrade to this popular Auckland tourist leisuretime and recreational hub.

What are the reasons for your submission? Regarding the development being double the height of the Unitary Plan: I see no reason for any objections. This will not detract from the charm of the area once completed. The design elements have taken into consideration the best use of visual aesthetics and modern design. I don't see any logical reason why the height of the proposed development would be a problem. Realistically the proposed minor height increase for 22m to 28m is miniscule. This will have no impact visually or realistically on the final impression of the finished project. Regarding the Auckland Unitary Plan argument; You will be aware the recently released Unitary Plan is already under threat and being challenged by the Government because it is unweildy. https://www.nzherald.co.nz/nz/news/article.cfm?c_id=1&objectid=12116466)

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? I am in full support of the project and believe it should proceed. The short term pain of the redevelopment phase will ensure long term gain for the area.

Are you a trade competitor of the applicant? I am not a trade competitor of the applicant.

Do you want to attend a hearing and speak in support of your submission? No

If other people make a similar submission I will consider making a joint case with them at the hearing: No

Supporting information:

2 380 Ranjeeta Singh

From: Robyn Pilkington on behalf of Central RC Submissions Sent: Friday, 28 September 2018 8:40 AM To: Premium Submissions Subject: FW: [ID:2124] Submission received on notified resource consent

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz [mailto:NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz] Sent: Thursday, 27 September 2018 8:00 p.m. To: Central RC Submissions Cc: [email protected] & Subject: [ID:2124] Submission received on notified resource consent

Notified resource consent application details

Property address: 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28, & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay.

Application number: BUN60324987

Applicant name: Drive Holdings Limited

Applicant email: [email protected] & [email protected]

Submitter contact details

Full name: Paul Lovrich

Organisation name:

Contact phone number: 0274 944888

Email address: [email protected]

Postal address: 139 shore road Remurea Auckland 1050

Submission details

This submission: supports the application in whole or in part

1 381 Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: not happy with the height and look off buildings

What are the reasons for your submission?

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Reduce the height and look off the buildings

Are you a trade competitor of the applicant? I am not a trade competitor of the applicant.

Do you want to attend a hearing and speak in support of your submission? No

If other people make a similar submission I will consider making a joint case with them at the hearing: Yes

Supporting information:

2 382 Ranjeeta Singh

From: Robyn Pilkington on behalf of Central RC Submissions Sent: Monday, 1 October 2018 7:22 AM To: Premium Submissions Subject: FW: [ID:2132] Submission received on notified resource consent

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz [mailto:NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz] Sent: Friday, 28 September 2018 5:16 p.m. To: Central RC Submissions Cc: [email protected] & Subject: [ID:2132] Submission received on notified resource consent

Notified resource consent application details

Property address: 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28, & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay.

Application number: BUN60324987

Applicant name: Drive Holdings Limited

Applicant email: [email protected] & [email protected]

Submitter contact details

Full name: Robyn Hoskins

Organisation name:

Contact phone number: 0274892915

Email address: [email protected]

Postal address: 39 Sayegh St St Heliers Auckland 1071

Submission details

This submission: opposes the application in whole or in part

1 383 Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: I object to the size of the development.

What are the reasons for your submission? I think the proposed development will ruin the appeal of Mission Bay as a friendly local area and make it another modern featureless area. Parking, which is bad now in the summer, will be much worse and the families and groups who come to the beach to swim and play games will be pushed out by the eaters, drinkers, shoppers and cinema goers so we end up with another Queen Street. The natural-ness of a beach suburb will be gone.

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Buildings must be low and in keeping with the older style of the area. Parking must be an absolute priority as well as no more obstruction to the roads. Above all, however, Mission Bay must remain a place that families want to spend the day at as they do now. It can't become somewhere that is too busy, noisy and featureless to attract only shoppers and diners and shut out the locals. This is not a great big long beach like the Gold Coast, this is a beach & area with character & history and any development should treasure this.

Are you a trade competitor of the applicant? I am not a trade competitor of the applicant.

Do you want to attend a hearing and speak in support of your submission? No

If other people make a similar submission I will consider making a joint case with them at the hearing: No

Supporting information:

2 384 Ranjeeta Singh

From: Robyn Pilkington on behalf of Central RC Submissions Sent: Monday, 1 October 2018 7:22 AM To: Premium Submissions Subject: FW: [ID:2133] Submission received on notified resource consent

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz [mailto:NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz] Sent: Saturday, 29 September 2018 6:45 a.m. To: Central RC Submissions Cc: [email protected] & Subject: [ID:2133] Submission received on notified resource consent

Notified resource consent application details

Property address: 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28, & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay.

Application number: BUN60324987

Applicant name: Drive Holdings Limited

Applicant email: [email protected] & [email protected]

Submitter contact details

Full name: Oksana alexeichik

Organisation name:

Contact phone number: 0210796639

Email address: [email protected]

Postal address: Rukutai street Orakei Auckland 1071

Submission details

This submission: opposes the application in whole or in part

1 385 Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: See below

What are the reasons for your submission? This is not appropriate for mission bay and it will not suit the bays. The design is horrible. The nature of the bays needs to be preserved, it can’t accommodate so much residential space, and will only be bad for the environment and transportation. No thanks

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Focus on making sure that the beaches are clean and look after the waterfront instead of building more dwellings...

Are you a trade competitor of the applicant? I am not a trade competitor of the applicant.

Do you want to attend a hearing and speak in support of your submission? No

If other people make a similar submission I will consider making a joint case with them at the hearing: No

Supporting information:

2 386 Ranjeeta Singh

From: Robyn Pilkington on behalf of Central RC Submissions Sent: Monday, 1 October 2018 7:24 AM To: Premium Submissions Subject: FW: [ID:2142] Submission received on notified resource consent

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz [mailto:NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz] Sent: Saturday, 29 September 2018 6:00 p.m. To: Central RC Submissions Cc: [email protected] & Subject: [ID:2142] Submission received on notified resource consent

Notified resource consent application details

Property address: 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28, & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay.

Application number: BUN60324987

Applicant name: Drive Holdings Limited

Applicant email: [email protected] & [email protected]

Submitter contact details

Full name: Donald Ian Hope

Organisation name:

Contact phone number: 0211757877

Email address: [email protected]

Postal address: 64 Patteson Road Mission Bay Auckland 1071

Submission details

This submission: opposes the application in whole or in part

1 387 Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Height, scale and mass of the proposed development

What are the reasons for your submission? I believe the height of the proposed development, with its consequential impact on the overall mass and scale, is such that it will have a High Impact on Mission Bay that would adversely affect, and change, the character of Mission Bay. I also understand that the proposal is not compliant with the most recent Unitary Plan and that permitting a development that departs significantly from the plan is not in the best interests of the local community.

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? I believe that a development that more closely aligns with the current height of the existing buildings would be acceptable and would add value to the area, as well as generating an adequate return for the developers.

Are you a trade competitor of the applicant? I am not a trade competitor of the applicant.

Do you want to attend a hearing and speak in support of your submission? No

If other people make a similar submission I will consider making a joint case with them at the hearing: No

Supporting information:

2 388 Ranjeeta Singh

From: Robyn Pilkington on behalf of Central RC Submissions Sent: Monday, 1 October 2018 7:27 AM To: Premium Submissions Subject: FW: [ID:2146] Submission received on notified resource consent

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz [mailto:NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz] Sent: Saturday, 29 September 2018 10:30 p.m. To: Central RC Submissions Cc: [email protected] & Subject: [ID:2146] Submission received on notified resource consent

Notified resource consent application details

Property address: 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28, & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay.

Application number: BUN60324987

Applicant name: Drive Holdings Limited

Applicant email: [email protected] & [email protected]

Submitter contact details

Full name: Eddye Zhang

Organisation name:

Contact phone number: 022 0355995

Email address: [email protected]

Postal address: 79 Selwyn Ave Mission Bay Auckland City 1071

Submission details

This submission: supports the application in whole or in part

1 389 Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Modern design, will improve the lifestyle in Mission Bay

What are the reasons for your submission?

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? approval

Are you a trade competitor of the applicant? I am not a trade competitor of the applicant.

Do you want to attend a hearing and speak in support of your submission? Yes

If other people make a similar submission I will consider making a joint case with them at the hearing: Yes

Supporting information:

2 390 Ranjeeta Singh

From: Robyn Pilkington on behalf of Central RC Submissions Sent: Monday, 1 October 2018 8:42 AM To: Premium Submissions Subject: FW: [ID:2150] Submission received on notified resource consent

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz [mailto:NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz] Sent: Sunday, 30 September 2018 11:45 a.m. To: Central RC Submissions Cc: [email protected] & Subject: [ID:2150] Submission received on notified resource consent

Notified resource consent application details

Property address: 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28, & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay.

Application number: BUN60324987

Applicant name: Drive Holdings Limited

Applicant email: [email protected] & [email protected]

Submitter contact details

Full name: Jose Franco

Organisation name:

Contact phone number: 0212233088

Email address: [email protected]

Postal address: 4/217 Tamaki Dr Kohimarama Auckland 1071

Submission details

This submission: supports the application in whole or in part

1 391 Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: All, I fully support the proposal, we have a world class beach which is totally under utilised and is let down by sub standard shopping and entertainment.

What are the reasons for your submission?

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? None.

Are you a trade competitor of the applicant? I am not a trade competitor of the applicant.

Do you want to attend a hearing and speak in support of your submission? No

If other people make a similar submission I will consider making a joint case with them at the hearing: No

Supporting information:

2 392 Ranjeeta Singh

From: Robyn Pilkington on behalf of Central RC Submissions Sent: Monday, 1 October 2018 8:42 AM To: Premium Submissions Subject: FW: [ID:2151] Submission received on notified resource consent

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz [mailto:NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz] Sent: Sunday, 30 September 2018 1:00 p.m. To: Central RC Submissions Cc: [email protected] & Subject: [ID:2151] Submission received on notified resource consent

Notified resource consent application details

Property address: 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28, & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay.

Application number: BUN60324987

Applicant name: Drive Holdings Limited

Applicant email: [email protected] & [email protected]

Submitter contact details

Full name: malcolm ewart

Organisation name:

Contact phone number: 02102469481

Email address: [email protected]

Postal address: 27 Geraldine Place Kohimarama Auckland 1071

Submission details

This submission: supports the application in whole or in part

1 393 Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Redevelopment of a key piece of land in an appropriate location that is suitable for the type of development being proposed. This north facing site is an ideal location for additional building height as it is south of Tamaki Drive and the public area and beach to the north, over-shading of public areas is therefore not a concern.

What are the reasons for your submission? Auckland needs to keep evolving and developing in order to meet the needs of the general population. The interests of the many outweigh the few who are concerned about losing some of their view.

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? To grant Resource Consent

Are you a trade competitor of the applicant? I am not a trade competitor of the applicant.

Do you want to attend a hearing and speak in support of your submission? No

If other people make a similar submission I will consider making a joint case with them at the hearing: No

Supporting information:

2 394 Ranjeeta Singh

From: Robyn Pilkington on behalf of Central RC Submissions Sent: Monday, 1 October 2018 8:42 AM To: Premium Submissions Subject: FW: [ID:2152] Submission received on notified resource consent

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz [mailto:NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz] Sent: Sunday, 30 September 2018 3:00 p.m. To: Central RC Submissions Cc: [email protected] & Subject: [ID:2152] Submission received on notified resource consent

Notified resource consent application details

Property address: 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28, & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay.

Application number: BUN60324987

Applicant name: Drive Holdings Limited

Applicant email: [email protected] & [email protected]

Submitter contact details

Full name: Phoebe Sarah Dobson

Organisation name:

Contact phone number: 021456748

Email address: [email protected]

Postal address: 21 Glover Road St Heliers Auckland 1071

Submission details

This submission: opposes the application in whole or in part

1 395 Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Height of proposed building, loss of character / architectural approach of proposed buildings, impact on parking and traffic

What are the reasons for your submission? The proposed height of this design is completely out of scale for the area and the local landscape (and exceeds the recommended height of the Unitary Plan by several stories plus goes against the recommendations in the submitted Urban Design Panel recommendations). There is limited architectural merit in the proposed design. The proposed height differences and rounded corners although make it slightly better than a big box really don't provide anything other than what will be a future eyesore. As a regular commuter along Tamaki Drive, I find the report that this development will not have a significant impact on the current - already bad - congestion hard to believe. This report also does not seem to have considered the impact of the demolition and building phase on this key commuter route.

What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? Ensure that the height of any development at this site does not exceed 4 stories high at any point (and consider limiting to 3 stories). Consider if the existing art deco facades at the corner of Tamaki Drive & Patterson Ave (existing Movenpick location) and Berkeley Cinema should gain heritage protection. If not, ensure that the chosen design for this site has architectural merit and fits with the surroundings and history of the area (which the current design with a few rounded corners does not). Assess the impact of the building phase (several months if not years) on the traffic congestion along Tamaki Drive and repeat the assessment of the projected future traffic congestion as the current report appears to take an optimistic viewpoint. Ensure that any future design retains the local cinema and the proposed trees & landscaping of the proposed design.

Are you a trade competitor of the applicant? I am not a trade competitor of the applicant.

Do you want to attend a hearing and speak in support of your submission? No

If other people make a similar submission I will consider making a joint case with them at the hearing: Yes

Supporting information:

2 396 Linda Butler

From: NotifiedResourceConsentSubmissionOnlineForm@donotreply.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz Sent: Monday, 1 October 2018 10:45 AM To: Central RC Submissions Cc: [email protected] & Subject: [ID:2165] Submission received on notified resource consent

Notified resource consent application details

Property address: 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28, & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay.

Application number: BUN60324987

Applicant name: Drive Holdings Limited

Applicant email: [email protected] & [email protected]

Submitter contact details

Full name: Linda Adams

Organisation name:

Contact phone number: 0220983080

Email address: [email protected]

Postal address: 1/89 Kurahaupo St Orakei Auckland 1071

Submission details

This submission: opposes the application in whole or in part

Specify the aspects of the application you are submitting on: Height of buildings over the district plan heights

What are the reasons for your submission? The area behind Tamaki Drive is a rough flat horseshoe shape before rising up to the surrounding ridges. The highest (if necessary) buildings should be at the base of these natural rises in the land with building height decreasing towards the shore. This would minimise shading and preserve a note pleasing aspect to any future development. The waterfront is Auckland's most valuable asset and we need to learn from the mistakes of the city centre where high buildings on the waterfront have blocked the harbour from behind.

1 397 What decisions and amendments would you like the council to make? I would like the council to rule against the over height buildings in line with the district plan.

Are you a trade competitor of the applicant? I am not a trade competitor of the applicant.

Do you want to attend a hearing and speak in support of your submission? No

If other people make a similar submission I will consider making a joint case with them at the hearing: Yes

Supporting information:

2 398