Hearing Report 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
I hereby give notice that a hearing by commissioners will be held on: Date: Tuesday 30 July 2019 Wednesday 31 July 2019 Thursday 01 August 2019 Friday 02 August 2019 Tuesday 06 August 2019 Time: 9.30am Meeting Rooms: Reception Lounge (Days 1 – 4) Level 2 Council Chambers (Day 5) Ground Floor Venue: Auckland Town Hall, 301-303 Queen Street, Auckland HEARING REPORT 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 TAMAKI DRIVE, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 PATTESON AVENUE, 26, 28 & 30 MARAU CRESCENT, MISSION BAY DRIVE HOLDINGS LIMITED COMMISSIONERS Chairperson Janine Bell Commissioners David Mead Michael Parsonson Larissa Rew HEARINGS ADVISOR Telephone: 09 980 5216 or 021570675 Email: [email protected] Website: www.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz Note: The reports contained within this agenda are for consideration and should not be construed as a decision of Council. Should Commissioners require further information relating to any reports, please contact the Team Leader Hearings. 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28 & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay Tuesday 30 July 2019, Wednesday 31 July 2019, Thursday 01 August 2019, Friday 02 August 2019 and Tuesday 06 August 2019 WHAT HAPPENS AT A HEARING At the start of the hearing, the Chairperson will introduce the commissioners and council staff and will briefly outline the procedure. The Chairperson may then call upon the parties present to introduce themselves to the panel. The Chairperson is addressed as Mr Chairman or Madam Chair. Any party intending to give written or spoken evidence in Māori or speak in sign language should advise the hearings advisor at least five working days before the hearing so that a qualified interpreter can be provided. Catering is not provided at the hearing. Please note that the hearing may be audio recorded. Scheduling submitters to be heard A timetable will be prepared approximately one week before the hearing for all submitters who have returned their hearing attendance form. Please note that during the course of the hearing changing circumstances may mean the proposed timetable is delayed or brought forward. Submitters wishing to be heard are requested to ensure they are available to attend the hearing and present their evidence when required. The hearings advisor will advise submitters of any changes to the timetable at the earliest possible opportunity. The Hearing Procedure The usual hearing procedure is: • The applicant will be called upon to present his/her case. The applicant may be represented by legal counsel or consultants and may call witnesses in support of the application. After the applicant has presented his/her case, members of the hearing panel may ask questions to clarify the information presented. • The relevant local board may wish to present comments. These comments do not constitute a submission however the Local Government Act allows the local board to make the interests and preferences of the people in its area known to the hearing panel. If present, the local board will speak between the applicant and any submitters. • Submitters (for and against the application) are then called upon to speak. Submitters may also be represented by legal counsel or consultants and may call witnesses on their behalf. The hearing panel may then question each speaker. The council officer’s report will identify any submissions received outside of the submission period. At the hearing, late submitters may be asked to address the panel on why their submission should be accepted. Late submitters can speak only if the hearing panel accepts the late submission. • Should you wish to present written information (evidence) in support of your application or your submission please ensure you provide the number of copies indicated in the notification letter. • Only members of the hearing panel can ask questions about submissions or evidence. Attendees may suggest questions for the panel to ask but it does not have to ask them. No cross-examination - either by the applicant or by those who have lodged submissions – is permitted at the hearing. • After the applicant and submitters have presented their cases, the chairperson may call upon council officers to comment on any matters of fact or clarification. • When those who have lodged submissions and wish to be heard have completed their presentations, the applicant or his/her representative has the right to summarise the application and reply to matters raised by submitters. Hearing panel members may further question the applicant at this stage. • The chairperson then generally closes the hearing and the applicant, submitters and their representatives leave the room. The hearing panel will then deliberate “in committee” and make its decision. • Decisions are usually available within 15 working days of the hearing. Page 2 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28 & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay Tuesday 30 July 2019, Wednesday 31 July 2019, Thursday 01 August 2019, Friday 02 August 2019 and Tuesday 06 August 2019 SUBMITTERS: VOLUME ONE Page 23 Desmond Hunt 10 Codrington Crescent Mission Bay Page 24 Robert Bree 88a Kurahaupo Street Orakei Page 27 Gary Paykel 44 Arney Road Remuera Page 28 Anthony Edwin Falkenstein 3 Dudley Rd Mission Bay Page 29 Auckland Planning Limited - Nick Culpan 34 Nihill Crescent Mission Bay Page 104 W.A Henderson 125 Selwyn Avenue Mission Bay Page 105 Jill McCarthy 63 Hawera Road Kohimarama Page 107 Winsome Ruth Matches 1/15 Nihill Crescent Mission Bay Page 109 Jo Thompson 1E/80 Aotea Street Orakei Page 112 Liz Pollard 1/22 Speight Road Kohimarama Page 113 William Edward Galpin 116/207 Riddell Road Glendowie Page 115 Donald & Audrey Coster 2/105 Selwyn Avenue Mission Bay Page 116 Antony Guy Jack Brabant 44 Comins Crescent Mission Bay Page 118 Pam Rudelj Apt 9/9 Marau Cres Mission Bay Page 120 Robyn Ballantyne 96 Selwyn Ave Mission Bay Page 122 Manuel Venegas 9A Cliff Road Auckland Page 124 Lisa Moore-Bocarro 63 Ngaio St Orakei Page 126 Jane Martinovich 37 Marau Cres Mission Bay Page 129 German Fernandez 14 William Fraser Cres St Heliers Page 131 Matthew Nant 121B Selwyn Ave Mission Bay Page 133 Robert Murray 132 Kohimarama Road Kohimarama Page 135 Junette Elizabeth Marylyn Wrathall 4/43 Tamaki Drive Mission Bay Page 137 Anthony Goddard 1/19 Selwyn Avenue Mission Bay Page 139 Georgina Sawyer 89 Rukutai Street Orakei Page 141 Chris Wadsworth PO Box 41071 St Lukes Page 143 Kim Michelle Posner 54 Rosepark Crescent St Johns Page 145 Lucy Duncan 148A Selwyn Avenue Mission Bay Page 147 Hadeel Kadir 1/30 Felton Mathew Ave Saint Johns Page 149 Chris von Batenburg 3A Sprott Rd Kohimarama Page 151 Darren Anderson 44 Smythe Rd Henderson Page 153 Mark Herbstein 17 Kempthorne Crescent Mission Bay Page 155 Mangere Elizabeth Wright 16 Andes Avenue Bridge Page 157 Guy Richardson 10 Cowell Place Onehunga Page 159 Margaret Platt 5/84 Kohimarama Road Kohimarama Page 3 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28 & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay Tuesday 30 July 2019, Wednesday 31 July 2019, Thursday 01 August 2019, Friday 02 August 2019 and Tuesday 06 August 2019 Page 161 Laura Austin 133 West Tamaki Rd Glen Innes Page 163 Andrea Aragon Echano 2/17 Clarendon Road St Heliers Page 165 Megan Burgess 10B Emily Lane Greenhithe Page 167 Tracey Goldstine 38a Ronaki Road Mission Bay Page 169 Nadia de Blaauw 77a Fancourt St Meadowbank Page 171 Michelle Crooks 72 Sprott Road Kohimarama Page 173 Jarrod Kerr 13a Rukutai Street Orakei Page 175 Suzanne Melville 14 William Fraser Cres St Heliers Page 177 Dale Clements 23 Lisburn Ave Glendowie Page 179 Megan Coates 21 Benbow Street St Heliers Page 181 Debbie MacDonald 2/70 Rukutai Street Orakei Page 183 Lijuan Xu PO Box 133168 Eastridge Page 185 Vanessa Hurt 47 Whitehaven Rd Glendowie Page 187 Christine Helen Johnston 44 Codrington Crescent Mission Bay Page 189 Anthony Hurt 32 Waimarie St St Heliers Page 191 Mary-Clare Brownlie 1/24 Hawera Road Kohimarama Page 193 Stuart Clarke 1/24 Hawera road Auckland Page 195 Ian Deynzer 4 Cullwick Road Mission Bay Page 197 Graham French 46D Rawhitiroa Road Kohimarama Page 199 Gillian Cran 2/29 Atkin Avenue Mission Bay Page 201 Carolyn Jean Harrison 5/5 Brookfield Street St Heliers Page 203 John Grant Borrows 15 Marau Cres Mission Bay Page 205 Robyn Fairley 14A Hartland Ave Glendowie Page 207 Junwei Wu 3 Simmental Crescent Somerville Page 209 Angela Dyer 2/123 Riddell Road Glendowie Page 211 Christine Mary Melvilleo 296 Riddell Road Glendowie Page 213 Sam Lawson G03/3 Bluegrey Ave Stonefields Page 215 Elisabeth Stevens 1/95 St Johns Road St Johns Page 217 Briar Dentice 308/4 Bluegrey Ave Stonefields Page 219 Rex Potter 89 Tephra Boulevard Stonefields Page 221 Jan van Deventer 4/17 Nihill Crescent Mission Bay Page 223 Barb Ross 33 Hampton Drive St Heliers Page 225 Toby Gwilym 17 Gerard Way Meadowbank Page 227 Holly Muller 8b Abbotts Way Remuera Page 229 Sally-Anne Forde 645 Remuera Road Remuera Page 231 David Ballantyne 96 Selwyn Ave Mission Bay Page 233 Jayden Grant 23 Comins Crescent Mission Bay Page 4 75-79, 81-87, & 89-97 Tamaki Drive, 6, 8-10, 12 & 14 Patteson Avenue, 26, 28 & 30 Marau Crescent, Mission Bay Tuesday 30 July 2019, Wednesday 31 July 2019, Thursday 01 August 2019, Friday 02 August 2019 and Tuesday 06 August 2019 Page 235 Michael Shaw 25 Trojan Crescent New Lynn Page 237 Mango Communications - Ian Benet 2/161 Long Drive St Heliers Page 239 Matthew Connolly Riddell Road Auckland Page 241 Kirsty Dale Cowie 93 Selwyn Avenue Mission Bay Page 243