october 25, 2012 | Vol. 113 no. 6 | middleburycampus.com Crime stats expose Email sparks controversy By Bronwyn Oatley faculty members, as well as a se- lection of local media outlets re- TIMELINE OF alcohol citation swell On Oct. 19 the College charged ceived an email from a Gmail ac- EVENTS count associated with the sender By Emilie Munson The Middlebury College Annu- College Handbook policies, re- FRIDAY, OCT. 12 - al Security and Crime Report does lated to their involvement in the On Oct. 1, Public Safety re- tions,” with the subject line “Mid- Original Press Release co-authorship of a mock press leased the Middlebury College dlebury College Divests from War on campus; however, statistics release that was sent to hundreds Annual Security and Crime Re- provided by Facilities Services of students, faculty and staff and a Welcoming Committee” port. This report, emailed to all The mock release stated that suggest that student vandalism number of local media outlets on students in compliance with the “Tim Schornak” of the “Dalai FRIDAY, OCT. 12 Oct. 12. is on the rise. In the 2006-2007 MiddBlog post reports Jeanne Clery Disclosure of Cam- The students, Molly Stuart was to be contacted for further de- pus Security Policy and Campus ’15.5, Jay Saper ’13, Jenny Marks press release of “dubious worth of student damage was ac- - Crime Statistics Act, was a com- origins” crued whereas in the 2010-2011 pilation of statistics about crime and Amitai Ben-Abba ’15.5, have school year, students caused committee. A telephone number at the College in the year 2011 indicated that they will choose was also provided where the of- as compared to the two previous to defend themselves against the SATURDAY, OCT. 13 representing the highest gross- years. charges at an open Judicial Board ing student vandalism year in the When called, the number led to an Middlebury Director of According to the report, in range provided. Furthermore, the Public Affairs Sarah Ray - in recent memory. indicating a non-working number. statistics indicated that last year, The hearing is slated to occur calls email “fraudulent” crease in the number of referrals Throughout the evening, com- Atwater perpetrated the most at 3 p.m. on Nov. 1 at a yet to be for disciplinary action for liquor munity members reacted to the on MiddBlog determined location, and will be law violations in comparison to news — many erroneously believ- and seniors in Atwater were overseen by the Community Ju- SUNDAY, OCT. 14 2010 and 2009. Furthermore, in ing that the communiqué was an found responsible for damage in dicial Board (CJB), comprised 2011, incidents of burglary and re- - Tim Spears calls Press most instances. of trained students, faculty and ferrals for disciplinary action for bury’s actual “College Communi- staff, as is outlined by the College Release a “hoax” liquor law violations occurred on statistics may not accurately re- Handbook policies. TUESDAY, OCT. 16 If the students are convicted, - - Finally, no hate crimes were re- the CJB will decide upon individ- Students “come clean” ism because they are based on the dent for Academic Affairs Timo- ported in 2011 unlike in previous ual sanctions for the group mem- in distributed letter money spent on student vandal- thy Spears sent an email to all stu- years. These statistics, however, bers. Possible repercussions for ism in a given year. dents, staff and faculty explaining only represent reported incidents. nonacademic violations to College WEDNESDAY, OCT. 17 - that the “message was a hoax, Handbook policy, as are alleged “Welcoming Committee” and that neither the email nor the Burchard attributes some of the in this case, range from verbal or as many incidents of vandalism or press release it contained came meets with Deans of changes in the crime statistics to written reprimands to expulsion damage, but it might just be that from Middlebury College or its College and Students new policy and institutions. from the College. there were one or two huge ticket “The increase in alcohol ci- The charges issued to the stu- THURSDAY, OCT. 18 items that created a bloom in the dents relate to alleged violations tations along with other issues posted a “coming clean” letter at - of Middlebury’s Community Stan- resulted in the Task Force on Al- various locations across the cam- on hoax email dards policy and alleged breaches pus and online at go/compassion, related to needless vandalism are to the Responsible Use of Com- THURSDAY, OCT. 18 said Burchard. “It’s very possible identifying themselves by name of great concern to the commons puting and Network Services and Seven Days and that the decrease from one to and class year as the co-authors of deans and the administration. Facilities policy. zero [of hate crimes] is a result of the press release. Assistant Director of Facilities Over the past week, local me- the information and mandatory They co-signed the letter as the reports on the email - dia outlets including Seven Days, training involved with the Anti- - dalism is a concern on campus. Vermont Digger and Vermont SUNDAY, OCT. 21 Harassment Policy.” tee,” a self-described “group of “I do think vandalism is an is- Public Radio have all covered the Burchard also pointed out that students who are concerned that “My Middlebury” action sue when it takes time away from press release incident. crime occurring on public proper- the College embraces practices in front of Proctor the departments that already have ty could be located on the various inconsistent with its own pro- FRIDAY, OCT. 26 a concern about the … care of rou- SEQUENCE OF EVENTS public roads that cross campus. claimed values.” In the letter, the “Welcoming Committee” tine maintenance and operations - Wonnacott Commons Dean - by adding an extra burden to the dowment transparency and urged to host general assembly dents stem from their co-author- work load,” said Ross. the College to divest from arms THURSDAY, NOV. 1 number of students, particularly ship of a self-described “satirical” To reduce crime, Public Safety manufacturers, military contrac- seniors, live off-campus and that press release. Committee to face takes many steps at the begin- tors and fossil fuel companies. this may be a factor in the statis- Over the span of a few hours, Judical Board in tics. hundreds of students, staff and SEE STUDENT, PAGE 4 SEE STUDENTS, PAGE 2 public hearing CHEERS TO ALUMNI WEEKEND FUN. delays concert By Katie Theiss 2]. The FUN. concert that was “Despite our efforts to cir- originally scheduled for Fri- cumvent this scheduling con- day, Nov. 2, has been resched- flict, we were forced to cancel uled until Thursday, Jan. 17. the Nov. 2 show.” The band cannot perform at the After news of the cancella- College in November due to a tion, MCAB worked with FUN.’s scheduling conflict with a Sat- tour management to find an al- ternate date. Middlebury College Activi- “The choices were limited ties Board (MCAB) Concert as FUN.’s tour schedule was Commitee Co-Chairs Molly booked for the remainder of Sprague ’13 and Nick Mallchok the fall, in addition to a Euro- ’15 explained that representa- pean tour in the spring,” wrote tives for FUN. contacted MCAB Sprague and Mallchok. “FUN. just recently to notify them of had only two dates to offer, and the conflict. one of them conflicted with an “MCAB was contacted by the athletic event, leaving Jan. 17 as band the week before fall break our only option.” notifying us that FUN. had been Scheduling concerts re- offered a spot on Saturday Night quires the approval from vari- ous departments across cam- and Mollchok in an email. “Un- pus, which limits the dates the fortunately, the Middlebury MCAB concert committee can Courtesy of luke elder show conflicted with a manda- choose from. Students played corn hole, drank, ate and enjoyed homecoming festivities at the tailgate outside of Ke- “After a lot of work and co- nyon Arena on Saturday, Oct. 20. Plenty of alumni came back for the weekend, and the football team on the Friday before [on Nov. SEE CONCERT, PAGE 3 VERMONT COLLEGE GOES TO PSYCH DEPT. FARMERS FIGHT GREAT LENGTHS FOR BLENDS SOCIAL GENETICALLY THE DALAI LAMA AND NATURAL MODIFIED CORN PAGE 14 SCIENCES PAGE 6 PAGE 17 inside 2NEWS | october 25, 2012 The Campus was granted exclusive interview access to Dalai Lama calls on young His Holiness the Dalai Lama BEYOND on Saturday, Oct. 13th follow- ing his talk. The full transcript THE generation to enact change and audio of the interview gery elicited laughter from the audience, as can be found on the Campus By Bronwyn Oatley and Kathryn website. Here are some of the DeSutter did his decision to wear a Middlebury visor BUBBLE throughout the lecture. highlights: On Friday Oct. 12 and Saturday Oct. On Saturday Oct. 13, the Dalai Lama BY DANNY ZHANG On mindfulness in the College com- 13, His Holiness the 14th Dalai Lama ad- spoke to the College community on the munity: dressed the College and members of the topic of global ethics. After his opening Middlebury community in two lectures “If one person creates some trouble remarks the Tibetan leader spoke of “one- then the whole community eventu- - in which he discussed themes of morality ness” and the similarities between all peo- ally creates some uneasiness. So there- tween President Bashar al-Assad and rebel in education and the importance of faith, ple before expressing his belief that the lev- fore regarding unity, or harmony or a forces seeking to topple his government peace and cooperation on a global scale. el of violence of the 21st century was “on a peaceful community, the thing is each The two-day event was the third time continued to deepen this past week, with different scale,” than the century prior. He individual has a responsibility. The in- violence seeping into Damascus and ten- that the Dalai Lama has visited the College; called for a reduction of military forces and dividual, you see, develops that kind of sions spilling into neighboring Lebanon as his previous visits were in 1984 and 1990. for a greater emphasis on dialogue. strong conviction and compassion … Friday’s lecture, titled “Educating the After his lecture on Saturday, the Cam- then one hundred percent together.” Beirut bombing on Friday. pus was granted an exclusive interview Many blamed the Beirut explosion, leader’s two-day visit to the College. The with the Dalai Lama, during which the On science: which caused at least eight other deaths Dalai Lama spoke again on Saturday morn- spiritual leader shared his views on culti- “In true investigation, we are trying and dozens of injuries, on the Assad gov- ing in a lecture titled “Finding Common vating mindfulness in a college community ernment taking revenge for the recent ar- Ground: Ethics for a Whole World.” and spirituality in education. He called on rest of a Lebanese ally who helped Syria In Friday’s lecture, the religious leader college students as the next generation of plot terrorist bombings. Assad’s Shiite re- tailored his spiritual wisdom to his col- that — not to accept on the basis of ap- global citizens to embody qualities of open- pearances, but to penetrate reality. gime is closely allied with Hezbollah, the legiate audience, criticizing the modern mindedness and open-heartedness. extremist Shiite group that dominates the education system for its increasingly ma- “I think college students — perhaps I On teaching compassion: Lebanese government. terialistic nature, and called on the largely think, when they enter the area, perhaps “Compassion, sense of caring about The attack on Friday immediately trig- they may feel, this is my home, this is safe,” others, sense of concern for other hu- violence and suffering of the 21st century. gered protests by the Sunni opposition in said the Dalai Lama. “I think that kind of man beings, this must come voluntarily. Lebanon. Opposition forces took to the “You are the people who will shape the spirit you can extend. I think we can do it. You cannot do that by force.” streets to burn tires and blockade roads. new world,” he said, addressing the young- I may not see, in my lifetime, in the next On Sunday, a memorial service was held er members of the audience. “This century 20 years, perhaps, 30 years, but you, this On secularism: for those killed in the attack. Protestors should be the century of the peace.” young student, you have the responsibility “I think that is individual business. used this opportunity to publicly voice While the Dalai Lama’s lecture imparted and you have the opportunity to see this their anger and frustration against the ethical and spiritual wisdom to his audi- happy world. So think this way. So make ef- the people who believe a certain faith, Lebanese regime as well as the Assad re- ence, he maintained a lighthearted sense of fort, tirelessly.” I think we ourselves should make good gime. humor throughout. Jokes about his old age examples to others.” Compiled by Kelsey Collins - and an anecdote about his gall bladder sur- testors and soldiers after the memorial On different faiths: service as the crowd tried to climb a fence “It is useful to know more about similarities or different philosophical surrounding a government compound. views of other traditions — that helps Fortunately, no casualties occurred. None- to enrich your own practice and then theless, ethnic tensions have heightened secondly, that way you can [have] some between Sunnis and Shiites in Lebanon, a mutual respect to other religion. If you country with a history of bloody civil war. remain isolated, without much contact, Prime Minister Mikati, a Sunni Mus- then the reality [is] you can’t remain lim, offered his resignation after the at- that way.” tack, although President Michel Suleiman On future generations Mikati for failing to oppose the Hezbollah I always emphasize the younger gen- government for its support of the Assad eration — college students — you are the regime. In the aftermath of this bombing, generation of the 21st century. So my many fear the outbreak of sectarian vio- generation, our hope [is] on you. Now - our generation, the generation of the try. Opposition groups, such as the March 20th century, as a matter of fact, I think we have a lot of problems, which [we] 14 bloc, have already called for the govern- should solve by coming generation. So ment’s resignation. we create these problems, and then let Within Syria’s borders, signs of the them solve that situation! [laughs] So - now you — you have to solve that, you ous daily in the capital city of Damascus. have to take [this] big mission — not an The city has been, to a large extent, spared Emily White individualistic way. His Holiness the 14th Dalai Lama sported a Middlebury visor at his talk on Friday. few months. However, an increase in the number of soldiers and checkpoints have Students feel safe despite Furthermore, many gas stations have run empty and prices of everyday items have MCAB’s skyrocketed. heightened crime statistics WHAT’S - ing in frequency and intensity. The sense CONTINUED FROM PAGE 1 are similar to peer institutions. HAPPENING AT of danger has made many residents of the “Every NESCAC school has similar con- ning of each year, like testing all emergency city wary of what may unfold in the com- cerns as we do,” said Longman. phones on campus, posting important con- ing weeks. “Soon we will be in the middle tact phone numbers in visible locations and MIDDLEBURY? in a small town in the state of Vermont,” encouraging students to lock their doors. neighborhood controlled by rebels. added Burchard. “But crime can still oc- Trivia Night Throughout the year, they provide foot and Less than a month ago, the daughter of cur here, and whenever crime occurs, it’s a Join friends for trivia at Crossroads Café! cruiser patrol of campus, respond to emer- problem.” FRIDAY 8 - 10 P.M. a wealthy businessman in Damascus was gencies and offer MiddRides 24 hours a Still, Burchard described the College as kidnapped. She was eventually returned day, seven days a week. “a relatively safe environment.” Commons Creep home, but only after a $395,000 ransom In addition to Public Safety, the College Sam Hage ’16 said he feels safe on cam- A Halloween classic! was paid and the girl was abused and tor- maintains a strong relationship with the pus. go/creepy for more details. tured. Middlebury police. “I don’t really hear about anything bad FRIDAY 8:30 P.M. - 2 A.M. Assad has attempted to shield the city To ameliorate campus security, the key- happening to students,” said Hage. “Not card system was implemented within the that things don’t happen. And also, I think The image of a stable, normal capital city Grooveyard Pub Safe does a good job looking out for was supposed to aid his cling to legiti- Also important in minimizing crime WRMC presents its fall concert: YAWN us.” macy. However, with all signs pointing to and vandalism at the College has been the and Vacationer Longman pointed to students not lock- an approaching showdown between gov- implementation of the commons system. SATURDAY, MCCULLOUGH SOCIAL SPACE ing their doors as an example of students’ ernment and rebel forces in Damascus, Longman described the reduction of crime DOORS OPEN AT 8 P.M. and the increased attention to community Assad’s façade of calm is quickly falling has met a number of students who have concerns as “one of the quieter successes of Zumba apart. said to him that “even if there is theft here, the commons system.” Come dance the calories away at Nightclubs no longer thump until dawn I’m not going to lock my door because I The Middlebury College Annual Secu- McCullough Social Space. hours. Few Western diplomats and report- would rather assert that I view this as a safe rity and Crime Report was emailed to all SUNDAY AT 4 P.M. ers remain. The vibe of the whole town has space.” students. Burchard said the purpose of this Monday Night Football fear — fear for an impending battle that was “to remind everyone crime can and Watch your favorite team and enjoy some promises little certainty for the future. does occur even at [the] College.” A graphic with stats from the crime report The College’s reported crime statistics can be found at middleburycampus.com. free Grille snacks. MONDAY 8:30 P.M. october 25, 2012 | News 3 Rohatyn celebrates 10-year anniversary By Jess Berry really beautifully with what we do in the Of the 11 New England Small College - Athletic Conference [NESCAC] schools, On Thursday, Oct. 18, the Rohatyn Cen- signed name, IGS.” only six offer a major that falls into the ter for International Affairs celebrated its Mayer explained that when she stepped realm of international or global studies. ten year anniversary. In time with this cel- overseas into her position as the director of interna- ebration, the international studies major tional studies, she brought up the sugges- studies major are Amherst, Bates, Bow- was changed to the international and global tion of changing the name to include global doin, Hamilton and Williams. No school briefing studies major (IGS). studies. According to Mayer, this is some- offers an “international and global studies” BY NATHAN LABARBA ’14 Students and professors commemorat- thing she has been thinking about for a long major. ed the anniversary with two panels, one led time. Mayer said that she has received only Buenos Aires, Argentina by professors and one by students, to dis- The new name, she argued, better re- positive feedback on the name change. cuss the role of America as a global power While Mayer feels that the new name I am addressing you from Buenos Ai- really do and how the academic program was necessary, some students are apathetic res, the Paris of South America, a gor- held in Rohatyn and the second in Atwater needs to educate and orient students. to the change. geous city where wine is cheaper than wa- Dining Hall. “IGS faculty ask questions in the courses “I have to say I’m pretty indifferent over ter, the dead get the best real estate and Professor of Geography Tamar Mayer, the addition of ‘global’,” wrote Hudson Ca- the national dance is sexy as hell. I could who was appointed to the directorship of questions that are transnational, that are vanagh ’14 in an email. “Although for what be speaking from anywhere, though. It both the Rohatyn Center and the depart- global, in nature” said Mayer. “It really was is already the wordiest major in existence, does not matter where I am so much as ment of international and global studies it makes writing my actual major on an ap- that I am there. this past summer, gave opening remarks exactly what we do in the program.” plication essentially impossible.” A few weeks ago, some friends and I at the panels, which applauded the work of decided to go skydiving. Some of you may the Rohatyn Center since its establishment have that classic motherly reaction, that in 2002. “oh-you-are-crazy-I-would-never!” gri- “Over the last decade, the Rohatyn Cen- mace of envious appreciation. Others may ter has established itself as the place to go nod and give a “right on;” perhaps you at Middlebury for an in-depth international have experienced the rush of the dive or or global perspective on social, political, similarly seek adrenaline highs. cultural and economic issues,” said Mayer For those of you who have not skydived, in her remarks on Thursday. let me tell you a little about it. First, you In the past 10 years, the Rohatyn Center sit there and decide whether or not it is has hosted over 1,000 speakers, adminis- worth it to you to jump out of an airplane tered over a quarter of a million dollars in with a stranger strapped to your back who Mellon grants in support of undergraduate is solely responsible for making sure that student international research and has em- you do not die. That is the hardest part. ployed over 100 student interns. Resolved, though, you forge onward, and Mayer expressed enthusiasm for her new position as the director of the Rohatyn the great wide world. You strap on a goofy - suit, it squeezes you in weird places, you sition as the head of the international and global studies department. leaving everything behind, contemplating “[Director of the Rohatyn Center] is a a lot of what-ifs, but mostly enjoying an great job and it’s great center,” said Mayer. courtesy of campusexplorer.com unparalleled freedom, the freedom to live, “There’s a lot of great energy here, and I The Rohatyn Center for International Affairs, located in the Robert A. Jones the freedom to die. think that the mission of the center works ’59 house, celebrated its 10-year anniversary last Thursday, Oct. 18. And then, with the world below re- duced to a mere mosaic of farms and lakes and lives, you jump. Absolute sensory Concert date College establishes overload, louder than a thousand freight trains, 35 seconds during which nothing matters, or has ever mattered, other than elicits varied med school alliances your own enjoyment of and appreciation for life. The cold air refreshes your soul, By Nate Sans take the MCAT prior to their commence- and before you have time to process the ment of their senior year. responses On Wednesday, Oct. 17, Director of Stu- fact that the plane you were just in is a Middlebury students and alums ex- tiny speck thousands of feet above your dent Fellowships and Health Professions pressed support for the early admission head, the parachute opens and the world CONTINUED FROM PAGE 1 Advising Arlinda Wickland sent an email programs. “Applying early … gives students - becomes silently still, purely peaceful, and ordination, the Concerts Committee was the advantage of avoiding some of the dents announcing that the College has es- stress experienced by upperclassmen pur- able to confirm this date with the approv- tablished an Early Assurance Program with suing admission. I can see how it would be and your understanding rush back into al of Facilities, the Athletic Department Geisel School of Medicine at Dartmouth your body like a deluge, and you are hap- and members of the college administra- College. Pollick ’14 in an email. py, truly happy. The person who comes tion,” wrote Sprague and Mallchok. “This new partnership avails the oppor- Alumnus and current medical school down is never the same as the person who Students are reacting to the resched- tunity for outstanding students at Middle- applicant Samuel Miller ’12 agrees. goes up. uling in a variety of ways. For some, the bury who are clearly commit- “Application to medical If you have never been skydiving, may- rescheduling has no effect. However, oth- ted to a career in medicine “The early school is a very competitive be this description has inspired you to ers who cannot attend the January show to seek acceptance to Geisel process, and pre-med stu- start scrambling together a way to pitch are disappointed. Dartmouth in the sophomore assurance dents are often very concerned “I was really looking forward to seeing year,” wrote Wickland in an program about their GPA,” said Miller. this idea to Mom and Dad. Maybe you email. the band live, but I am going abroad so I “This can sometimes discour- have a sick feeling in the pit of your stom- According to Wickland, should ... allow will not be able to attend the show now,” age students from taking ach and vertigo at the mere thought of it. the aim of the program is to said Hana Kahn ’14. [students] to classes outside of their com- Either way, think about it. No, not about allow students “to take full fort zone, for fear that it will skydiving. I am not here to persuade. Re- On the other hand, some students who advantage of their under- take greater could not attend the November concert negatively impact their GPA. ally think about it. graduate education without The early assurance program are excited about the new date. advantage of Hopefully you will discover what I dis- the pressures of applying should lessen this concern for “When I heard that FUN. was playing covered when my two feet touched the to multiple medical schools the liberal arts some students and allow them ground that sunny afternoon in La Tier- this fall, I was so upset that I couldn’t go. - to take greater advantage of Now, with the rescheduling, I have the lege.” experience that the liberal arts experience that chance to see a great live band play,” said In order to participate in Middlebury Middlebury values so strong- Danielle Hirshberg ’14. the partnership, interested ly.” hurled myself out of a plane into the great Overall, MCAB feels optimistic about students must apply by Feb- values so The Geisel Early Assurance unknown. That is what all this is; college, the rescheduling of the show. ruary of their sophomore Program is one of six similar growing up, studying abroad. Life is a se- year to be considered for strongly.” “If anything, FUN.’s name and reputa- programs at the College, which ries of skydives. nomination by the Middle- tion will be even bigger when they come Samuel miller ’12 also maintains relationships Studying abroad is a risk, just like any. in January, and we are sure that it will bury College Health Profes- with Albany Medical College, sions Committee. The Com- The kid who goes to Buenos Aires and the be a fantastic show,” wrote Sprague and the University of Connecticut School Of kid who comes back are never the same. Mallchok. “While we are obviously upset Medicine, the University at Buffalo School it will provide letters of endorsement nomi- of Medicine, the State University of New You never know if your language is good about the date change, MCAB is plan- nating them for the program. enough, or if your independence is strong ning a live screening of the SNL perfor- York Upstate Medical University and the After receiving an endorsement, nomi- enough, but you try. You never know if mance on Nov. 3rd in Crossroads Café to University of Rochester Medical Center. nees must apply to the Geisel Early As- your parachute will open, either. But you get ready for January.” These relationships allow undergradu- surance Program itself. Students who are ates at Middlebury to apply to these institu- jump. Never be afraid to take the leap of All tickets for the November show will tions during their sophomore or junior year faith, to try something that scares you, to be honored at the January show, and re- the fall of their junior year after the Geisel depending on the institution. The criteria jump into the cold water. funds will be available for those who are School of Medicine at Dartmouth Admis- for applicants are stringent – most require unable to attend. sions Committee makes the decisions Maybe you should give skydiving a a grade point average above 3.5, however shot. You will discover that the only thing The refund period begins Wednes- themselves of whom to admit. some of the programs waive a requirement worse than making a splat is being hot, day, Oct. 17 and ends Wednesday, Nov. The Geisel program also offers accepted for the applicant to take the MCAT exam. 7. There will be a resale period beginning students the opportunity to work at Geisel There will be an information meeting for anxious, cooped up and hovering over on Wednesday, Dec. 5 for students and School of Medicine during the summer af- candidates interested in the Geisel program your future self from 10,000 feet. Wednesday, Dec. 13 for the public. ter their junior year. Participants must also in late October. 4NEWS | october 25, 2012 college shorts CONTINUED FROM PAGE 1 Though many have interpreted the group’s two actions as separate acts — or have interpreted the “coming clean” letter as a response to the pressure exerted by the administration following the press release — the group explained that they crafted both letters simultaneously, and believe the COMPILED BY ANNA CHAMBY two communiqués to be two separate parts of one whole action. Amherst student publishes STATING THEIR BELIEFS account of on-campus rape In their open letter to the community, A former Amherst College student de- the students stated that they believed that tailed her experience of on-campus rape in the school’s investment structure was in- consistent with the College’s values and an op-ed in the Amherst Student on Oct. mission statement. 17. The 5,000-word piece, which was pub- “Our intent was to bring attention to lished with a “trigger-warning” due to its the unsettling reality that Middlebury has disturbing nature, was written by former millions of dollars invested in industries of member of the class of 2014 Angie Epi- violence, while we appear to stand for uni- fano describing her rape and the distress- versal compassion and peace,” they wrote. ing lack of support she received from the The group also cited the College’s lack- Courtesy of the Dalai Lama Welcoming Committee Amherst administration in dealing with luster grades on endowment transparency Students painted handprints outside of Proctor on a poster that read “Our the aftermath when she sought help on as reported by the College Sustainability Middlebury Divests from Violence” to demonstrate their solidarity with the campus. Report Card, published by the Sustainable Dalai Lama Welcoming Committee on Sunday, Oct. 20 from 11:30 - 2 p.m. Endowments Institute, as another motivat- By Epifano’s account, the school dis- ing factor for their action. they’ve done,” he said. couraged her from reporting her rape to EXAMINING THE POSSIBILITY In the six report cards since the incep- The SRI president explained that the ac- OF DIVESTMENT the police, preventing her from changing tion of the sustainability ranking system in dorms, and questioned her account of the who had seen a number of “big wins” in 2008, the College has received no better The student’s press release has led some their collaborative efforts with the adminis- events. than a C grade with respect to transparency. to question whether divestment is possi- The article subsequently went viral While some other institutions have similar- ble given the College’s current investment Chute described that just weeks before, within a few hours, causing the Amherst ly struggled in this category in recent years model. According to Vice President for Fi- Student website to shut down from the (including Bates College and Williams Col- nance and Treasurer Patrick Norton, forms school’s history, decided that they would - lege) other institutions, including Amherst of divestment have occurred in the past. allow a student liaison from the Advisory College and Brown University, have re- In April 2006, in response to violence in cussion of rape on college campuses and Committee on Socially Responsible Invest- ceived As and Bs for endowment transpar- Darfur, the President of the College Ronald the twitter trending topic #ithappenshere. ing (ACSRI) to act as a liaison for all Board ency. D. Liebowitz announced in a press release - of Trustee’s Investment Committee meet- that the Investment Committee, Board of tional accounts of unreported rape, both at ings “in the foreseeable future”. A CALL FOR TRANSPARENCY Trustees and the College’s external invest- Amherst and other peer institutions. ment consultant had all reviewed the Col- ever ACSRI liaison to a Board Finance President of Amherst College Biddy Chair of the Board of Trustees Marna lege’s direct holdings to identify and cease Committee meeting. Chute was limited in Martin issued a statement regarding the Wittington explained that board members all investment in “any multinational com- his capacity to participate in the meeting, op-ed expressing her regret for the Col- were “disappointed” by the group’s actions. panies that may provide the many factions serving as a non-voting member with no lege’s failure to appropriately respond to “I think that one of our values is integ- that constitute the Sudanese Government the victim’s case. rity, and integrity in communication,” she presentation at the end of the meeting), yet said. “I think we have a lot of tolerance for - “Sexual misconduct and assault are seemed enthusiastic about the creation of disagreement, but I don’t think we have a vestment occurred as a result of the initia- among the toughest and most consequen- the position. lot of tolerance for misrepresenting your- tive, as the College was not invested in any tial problems on college campuses and “The Board seems open to hearing sug- self, and taking someone else’s identity and such companies in their direct holdings in the culture as a whole. Amherst is not gestions from the student body,” he said. using it as your own.” portfolio. alone in its struggles with it. But Amherst, The Dalai Lama Welcoming Committee At the time the College also took steps Lama Welcoming Committee believe that given its values, its commitment to com- members, however, reject the notion that to try to compel Investure to encourage its the recent steps taken by the administra- munity and its size should be a model of they are guilty of impersonation. managers to employ similar screens when - education, prevention and effective re- “We are the Dalai Lama Welcoming investing the pooled funds. tations in the scope of the measures. sponse when violations occur. No student Committee. We sent the letter as the Col- Norton explained in an email, “The Col- - should be discouraged from reporting of- lege sent a letter to Investure with a list of ent tactics, and doing autonomous actions,” fenses or seeking redress,” said President Lama Welcoming Committee … some stu- said Stuart, “as long as it’s not undermining Martin. dents accused us of identity theft, but that’s as prohibited investments.” preposterous. We didn’t violate anything the work of other groups, which we don’t Yet, the College Treasurer acknowledged according to United States law,” said Ben- believe that it was in this case.” — The Amherst Student Abba. over the direct management of the aggre- Koplinka-Loehr explained that the MANAGING THE ENDOWMENT gate funds. Online supplement to group did not use the College’s seal or let- “As an investor in comingled funds for As of June 2012, Middlebury’s endow- terhead. He also stated that the group re- which Investure has full management dis- - peatedly referenced the College Handbook, cretion, we recognized that we couldn’t lion. The vast majority of this sum is man- grades seeking to avoid any action that could be aged by Investure, a company that manages considered a violation of College policy. funds. However, we strongly encouraged the investments of 12 other organizations — - Dean of the College Shirley Collado Investure to divest securities of any type nia’s San Jose State University is testing a and Associate Dean of Judicial Affairs and in these companies that may be part of our new, video lecture-based class in order to Student Life Karen Guttentag spoke to the portfolio, and to avoid them in the future,” billion. ameliorate its student passing rate. Campus for this article, but could not com- he wrote. By using Investure, Middlebury is en- - Norton explained that the College has dowed with a team of professionals who room,” requires students of the Engineer- open investigation being pursued by the provide access to investment possibilities ing Electronics and Circuits class to watch College. to follow the institution’s Environmen- comparable to the opportunities available lecture videos produced by the Massa- tal and Social Responsibility Principles, to institutions with larger endowments. chusetts Institute of Technology on their SOCIALLY RESPONSIBLE which were adopted last spring. Within this Yet, by using an outsourced invest- own time, allowing for a discussion-based INVESTMENT CLUB REACTS framework Investure seeks to maximize re- ment company, the College loses a level of classroom setting during the scheduled turns while managing risk, according to the transparency offered by the in-house man- class times instead. The Socially Responsible Investment Treasurer. agement process. While the Middlebury The class is a pre-requisite course for club (SRI) is recognized by the College com- Investment Committee and Board remain furthering studies in the electrical-engi- munity as another on-campus group seek- companies in which we are invested that actively involved with the decision making neering major, but 40 percent of the stu- ing greater endowment transparency. must remain a focus. It is our endowment process regarding asset allocation, guide- dents in previous semesters received a C Current SRI Co-President, Ben Chute that funds 20 percent of the operating costs lines and strategic changes to the College’s or lower, causing concern among profes- ’13.5, explained that while his group was of Middlebury College,” he said. sors and forcing them to re-think their broadly supportive of the Dalai Lama Wel- endowments, they are unable to instantly method of teaching. coming Committee’s message, some SRI access the records that indicate the compa- STUDENTS INVITE DISCUSSION The pilot program is being compared members were critical of the action taken nies in which the College invests. - to two traditionally taught classes through SRI will host a discussion in conjunction rately screen for investment in arms manu- examination scores and overall student “Initially, SRI was pretty shocked [by with the Dalai Lama Welcoming Committee facturers, military contractors or fossil fuel experience. Halfway through a semester of the email.] Many members were not happy and the Divestment Committee (another companies. about it. I think it is not consistent with student group working directly on the issue Koplinka-Loehr believes that it is nearly are already showing positive results: the the strategy that we have been pursuing, of endowment transparency) this evening certain that the College is invested in such median mid-term examination scores of which has been to educate people and have at 8 p.m. in Axinn 219. companies. the 85 students were ten to 11 points high- a thoughtful, reasonable, straight-forward The Dalai Lama Welcoming Committee “There is not only the possibility that we er than those of the other two sections. and honest conversation about the ethics and the “growing contingent” of support- are invested in military contractors, there is Despite some student resistance to its of our endowment and how we can make it ers on campus will also hold a general as- the certainty that we are invested in mili- fast-paced nature, the course will continue better,” Chute said. sembly at 4:00 p.m. on Friday in Warner tary contractors,” he said. “Without screens - “The principles that were expressed by Hemicycle. Both meetings are open to all - aminations. this group are things that many of us largely community members. panies on the market … it is without doubt identify with, and support and sympathize The Community Judicial Board hearing that we are invested in them,” he said. — The Chronicle of Higher Education with … While I would have done it another way, I can’t take anything away from what Nov. 1 at 3 p.m. october 25, 2012 | News 5 community council update Council aims to improve communication From The give them a chance to say this is who we people there.” By Claire Abbadi are and this is our mission, explained Com- In light of the recent editorial published President’s The Community Council met on Mon- munity Council Co-Chair Barret Smith ’13. in the Amherst Student on on-campus rape, day Oct. 22 to outline an ambitious list of “That way we are building an understand- sexual assault was a pertinent topic at Mon- tasks for the 2012-2013 academic year. day’s meeting. The council discussed invit- Desk Issues on the preliminary agenda for the time during the social house review pro- ing staff from Parton Health Center and BY CHARLIE ARNOWITZ council include: communication methods cess.” from the Sexual Assault Overview Commit- between faculty, students and staff; re- The council also discussed campus com- tee (SAOC) to give a presentation of this is- - - munication methods during the Oct. 22 sue to the committee and how to initiate an dent Government Association’s (SGA) cess to health services on campus; sexual meeting. Council members are seeking a ongoing conversation around this issue. bi-weekly column, From the President’s assault on campus; public spaces and dorm way to increase student participation and “The Amherst sexual assault case has Desk with SGA President Charlie Arnow- damage; social house membership; stress attendance of College-sponsored events gotten a lot of attention and so if we are itz ’13. In this column, we will be discuss- culture; student participation in MCAB and through more effective communication. going to work with the SAOC on sexual as- ing issues of importance to the SGA and other college sponsored events; and imple- “There is a stigma on campus to not go sault, we should do it sooner while people the student body. This week I am joined menting recommendations from the Alco- to MCAB events or go to college sponsored are talking about and concerned with the by SGA Treasurer and Finance Committee hol Task Force. events, and a lot of that can be changed issue,” said Isabelle Dietz ’13. Chair Peter Mattson ’14 to talk about the A large part of the meeting was spent just by the way we communicate,” member The council also raised the idea of add- - discussing the relative urgency of each of Zach Marlette ’13 explained. ing residents of Middlebury as members of ation and funding for student organiza- these issues, and their relevancy to the in- In an effort to increase on-campus the College’s Community Council. Opinions tions. terests of students, faculty and staff. communication, the Community Council were divided on this matter — some felt The SGA is responsible for allocating - is working with the Student Government that it was a way to bridge the gap between money to the nearly 175 organizations on ship in social houses. School policy on the Association and the Dean of the College’s the College and the town on certain issues, campus, from the African American Al- issue dictates that students may not join while others felt that the council focused on liance to the Youthful Alliance for Mer- social houses until the second semester of time used to discuss issues on campus. issues that were too unique to the College rymaking, in the form of annual budgets, sophomore year; however the council has “My hope is to create an open time for and would be of little interest to the town. new money requests and loans. Generally, proposed considering more lenient mem- anybody who wants to share something Lastly, the council discussed the forma- bership guidelines. This discussion could student organizations have enjoyed tre- with the student body that there would be tion of a Residential Life Committee whose affect the membership as early as this topics that are of enough interest to stu- mission is to act as an advisory group and In addition to funding student organiza- dents,” said Dean of the College and Coun- discussion forum on residential life, as well for review. tions, we also fund our own initiatives that cil Co-Chair Shirley Collado. “It is really to as review social houses and special interest The Community Council is hoping to serve the student body. Last year, the SGA promote face-to-face dialogue and to re- houses each year. The committee will be initiate an ongoing conversation with the passed a series of exciting initiatives that ally engage one another without relying comprised of one staff member, one faculty social houses on this issue. on email. We just don’t know how to get member and two student members. student life, including a dramatic expan- “I want to bring in the social houses and sion of the MiddView and the YouPower bike room. All of this good work is funded by the Trustees seek student involvement Student Activity Fee, the $380 that ev- ery student pays in addition to the Com- By Kathryn DeSutter cohol front,” added Arnowitz. “They were by the number of students that are apply- prehensive Fee. Collectively, the sum of also strongly opinionated and hearing the ing for small grants to do projects or are these fees makes up the SGA budget. The Trustees of the College met on campus range of reactions was interesting.” interested in internships.” SGA Finance Committee budgets all of this past weekend to discuss and vote on De la Cruz hopes that students will con- The board also voted to establish a new these funds to student organizations each various issues of governance, experiential tinue to be a part of these conversations. C.V. Starr-Middlebury School Abroad in spring. If student organizations do not learning and student life, among other “I think the trustees really see how India. spend the entirety of their budgets, those topics. much they need student input in order to “It is great that we will be able to pro- funds come back to the SGA as reserves. The board heard from several students make any kind of informed decision on vide opportunities for our students to If the SGA chooses, these reserves can be during their time at the College. student affairs,” wrote de la Cruz in an study in and learn about India,” wrote spent on projects like the ones mentioned Student Government Association email. “Fortunately, they have plans to President of the College Ronald D. Li- above. (SGA) President Charlie Arnowitz ’13, create more dialogue with students out- ebowitz in an email. “Students have been As a result of the SGA’s allocation of Lauren Greer ’13 and Chris de la Cruz ’13 side of the meetings so they may all come requesting this for more than a decade.” generous budgets to student organiza- sat in on the meeting of the Student Af- The Buildings and Grounds Committee tions and legislative agendas over the fairs Committee. think student involvement really is some- also received an update on fundraising for past two years, the Student Government Arnowitz gave a brief presentation to thing they lack yet something they are the Field House. The board approved con- Reserve Fund fell from $413,000 in the the trustees to outline the duties and goals pushing to work on.” struction of the Field House last fall. fall of 2011 to $121,000 today. Demand of the SGA. After Arnowitz’s presentation, De la Cruz described how the trustees “The Field House is a much-needed for funding is booming like never before the committee was present- directly addressed the project,” wrote Liebowitz. “The tempo- and this year will likely bring a further ed with the results of the students. rary ‘Bubble’ has given us more years that drop in the reserves. alcohol survey conducted “I think student “Right at the end, the it was intended to give us. The new facility These reserve levels are problemati- among nine of the 11 New involvement really meeting was directed will be used by the entire community.” England Small College Ath- is something at the three students as Before the weekend’s meetings, the that we keep a small amount of liquid capi- letic Conference (NESCAC) they asked, ‘What kind trustees met on Thursday, Oct. 18 for a re- tal on hand for emergencies, and in such schools in March. they lack yet are of issues should we be treat that took place at the Jackson Prop- cases the SGA is committed to ensuring Dean of the College pushing to work talking about?’” added erty, 377 acres of land along Route 125 and we can adequately serve student organiza- Shirley Collado serves as a de la Cruz. Cider Mill Road that the College received tions. liaison to the Student Af- on.” Student involvement from Trustee Emeritus Will Jackson ’51 in fairs Committee. Collado Chris de la Cruz ’13 was not limited to the December 2011. The board spent the day therefore ask for your patience. Student explained that the trustees Student Affairs Commit- discussing issues of governance, and took organizations should keep a few guiding were encouraged by the ac- a mid-day break to enjoy the fall weather. - tions of the Alcohol Task Force, a group member of the Socially Responsible In- Whittington spoke positively of the re- nancial planning for the coming year. Plan that engaged in a year-long investigation vestment club (SRI), Ben Chute ’13.5, sat treat. ahead — programs planned far in advance of alcohol use on campus and its effects in on the Investment Committee proceed- “We’re stepping back and looking at that attract students will likely receive on the community and concluded their ings to offer an additional perspective on our own governance — making sure it’s more funding. Spend responsibly, and research with a list of recommendations, the investment of the endowment. tight and we have the policies and the keep your spending focused on the mis- Board Chair Marna Whittington ex- processes we need to have, both to sup- sion of your organization. Collaborate with President for consideration last May. pressed enthusiasm for increased student port the Middlebury of today [and] the other clubs to take advantage of shared “[The trustees] feel very good and very involvement. Middlebury we think is coming in the fu- resources. If the College Democrats and “If the students are interested in a par- ture,” said Whittington. Republicans can plan a successful election happy to see that some of the recommen- ticular form of interaction, I think they “The reason we can have these con- night at the Grille together, then we know dations — like some of the positions and just need to request it,” said Whittington. versations is we’re coming from a posi- valuable collaboration between other some of the [issues] around residential During a meeting of an ad-hoc commit- tion of strength,” she added. “I would say groups on this campus is also possible. life — had been tackled,” said Collado. tee on education in action, board mem- if we could keep this level of collegiality, Planning well, spending responsibly Greer explained that the trustees and bers discussed the importance of students cooperation, hard work and commitment and collaborating are key ways to help students reached the conclusion that the connecting their education with opportu- going between and among the Board of program effectively for the year, but it’s community needs to address the issue col- nities outside of the classroom. According Trustees and the administration into the also important to realize that funding will lectively. to Whittington, the board members are foreseeable future, it would clearly be a be tight. Nonetheless, we are fully dedi- “It came down to the agreement that committed to fundraising for an endowed strategic advantage for us.” cated to ensuring that student organiza- we can use those statistics as a reminder fund in order to increase the opportuni- Liebowitz echoed Whittington’s enthu- tions have adequate resources to fund that we need to improve behavior with ties available to students. siasm for the progress made. creative and effective student ideas, ini- regard to alcohol on campus, and take “It’s part of our vision for Middlebury; “The trustee retreat was excellent,” tiatives and programming. more ownership as a student body,” wrote it’s part of our belief about the undergrad- wrote Liebowitz. “It allowed the board to If learning more about the SGA inter- Greer in an email. “They were very sup- uate education,” said Whittington. “One work together to consider major issues ests you, come to our open Senate meet- portive in helping this effort.” of the things that’s been very interesting on how to be responsible stewards of the ings at 7 p.m. on Sundays in the Crest - to us is the students’ reception to it. We’ve College. The board looks forward to con- Room, and check us out at go/sga, on ested in hearing how things played with had a lot of interest and demand … We’ve tinue working on this issue throughout Facebook and on Twitter. the student body, particularly on the al- been pleasantly surprised and challenged the year.” local Vermont farmers lead GMO movement By Devin MacDonald The available corn came from hybrid Vermont is one of the leading states seed. Hybrid corn seed is made from two in organic agriculture and progressive genetically very different parents, and movements; the people of this state are because of their genetic differences if often trailblazers of nationwide trends. the seed from the corn crop is used again The movement of the moment is the la- the next year, there is no way to predict beling of genetically modified products which genes will be expressed or not. It is (GMOs). Last year a bill was introduced technically possible to save the seed, but to the Vermont House Committee on is not an effective practice for farmers. Agriculture that proposed requiring all What Lazor decided to do, however, products that included genetically modi- to make himself more self-sufficient, was fied ingredients be labeled as such. use seed that grew through open pollina- Will Stevens, an agriculture commit- tion. Instead of forcing two very differ- tee representative from Shoreham, Vt. ent types of corn together as with hybrid who has worked closely on the develop- seeds, open pollination takes genetically ment of this bill, explained the main pur- similar corn and allows them to combine pose of the bill. in a natural way. The idea was to “plant “It’s basically a consumer awareness them all together in a patch and allow bill,” said Stevens. “Consumers are ask- them to all cross on each other,” said ing for information on the ingredients of Lazor. Courtesy of High-Mowing Organic Seeds processed products and this is how the This practice led him not only to have Tom Stearns, the founder of High-Mowing Organic Seeds, stands in his greenhouse. bill was proposed.” seed again for the next year through open tion system with water-soluble nitrogen when everything costs more, that’s just Ingredients are important to people pollination, but to experiment with which infusing the plants with the necessary nu- how it goes.” all over Vermont, especially farmers breed of corn functioned best for the cold trients. The soil plays no larger role than Stearns and his team at High Mead- themselves. Jack Lazor, of Butterworks Vermont climate. He now has seeds that just keeping the plants where they are. ow Seeds have been aggressively fighting Farm in Westfield, Vt. has been working he produces for himself and farmers all “On an organic farm,” explained genetically modified foods for 15 years. to be as self sufficient as possible since over the state. The open pollination seeds Stearns, “the health of the soil is every- Two years after genetically engineered the mid-1970s. Lazor started out as a produce corn that “tastes better, has thing. Seeds that are selected and adapt- corn was first introduced, they published homesteader who wanted to grow all his more minerals in it and picks up more ed to organic farms have a different way the Safe Seed Pledge in protest. Over 200 own food. stuff from the soil” said Lazor, as com- of relating to the soil so they can go get seed companies all over the United States “We started with wheat and barley in pared with genetically engineered corn. the nutrients.” have since signed the pledge. 1977,” said Lazor. “After that we got more Lazor open-pollinates his corn Stearns focuses on breeding new Because of the activity of Lazor, Stea- and more cows and started our little yo- through a lengthy process of guess and types of organic seed, which can take any- rns and other farmers all over the state, gurt business. We got our license from check that has proved fruitful for him. where from two to six years to produce. government officials have been moved to the state of Vermont in 1984.” Tom Stearns of High Mowing Seeds is The pressure to have successful crops propose a bill that would require every Butterworks Farm is principally a focused much more specifically on the has led to experimentation with new seed producer to label foods with genetically dairy farm, but also features its own corn genetics and science of seed production. varieties. While open pollination and hy- modified ingredients. meal. Lazor wanted to create a self-suf- “I wanted to focus on seeds specifi- bridization are natural processes, scien- Will Stevens, an Agriculture Com- ficient environment, and consequently cally, the genetics and breeding was stim- tists have reached new levels with geneti- mittee representative in support of the began growing his own corn to feed to his ulating. Providing seeds to people helps cally modified seeds. bill, explained that the House Agriculture cows in order to produce the best dairy. people grow their own food. I have a be- “[Genetic modification] is something Committee received the bill late in the He did not start out with his own seed, hind-the-scenes role of helping farmers.” that would not happen in nature,” ex- session last year, and due to its late in- but purchased it from various seed com- High Mowing Seeds sells to garden- plained Stearns. “It happens in a lab, and troduction the bill died at the end of the panies and used hybrid seeds. ers in all 50 states and all over Canada. is a process of inserting genes from one session. “As time went on, I decided I wanted Stearns caters his company to organic species into another species.” “My hunch is that the bill will come to grow all my own seed as well as my own farmers in general. Organic farmers all A good example of genetic modifica- back to the legislature,” said Stevens. grain,” said Lazor. “It was harder with over the country have unique challenges tion and its implications is an ongoing Unfortunately nothing is that simple. corn because all the corn that was avail- and conditions to deal with. Generally, experiment in which scientists produce If Vermont were to be the only state to able, you couldn’t save your own seed.” fertilization is done through an irriga- a strain of corn that is toxic to insects adopt this kind of legislation, many other by cross-breeding corn and a bacterium farmers would be disadvantaged. Ideally toxic to insects. Unfortunately, this bac- this type of bill would be introduced na- terial insertion has also produced a host tionally so that worrying about state lines of problems. Benign insects have been would cease to be a concern. killed while worms have built up a resis- Debates about the problems posed by tance to the bacteria over the course of GMOs continue. On one side, it has never the past decade, throwing off the natural been proved that genetically modified balance. foods are bad for human beings. On the “The EPA actually considers this other side, there have yet to be any long- corn to be a pesticide,” said Stearns. “It term studies on possible effects to human needed to go through all the licensing and health. regulations, just like Round-Up.” “For me, it comes back to the fact that Genetically modified seeds give a all the countries in Europe are complying higher yield, but also raise a lot of con- with it,” said Stevens. “So why not? As cerns among farmers and consumers. In Ben and Jerry say, ‘what’s the dough boy Stearns’ opinion, there are four main rea- afraid of?’” sons why someone would be against ge- Almost all of Europe has instituted netically engineering produce: religious a highly successful labeling program, and ethical issues (people not wanting to which may serve as a model for states in “play God”), environmental issues, hu- the U.S. man health issues and economic issues. Right now all eyes are on California, There are a dwindling number of non-ge- where similar legislation is being exam- netically engineered seeds, which limits ined. Proposition 37 would require one of farmers’ output possibilities. the nations most agriculturally produc- Courtesy of VPR “It absolutely costs more,” said Stea- tive states to label their genetically modi- Strains of corn that are genetically engineered to kill pests often kill benign species. rns. “But farmers need corn to plant, so fied food.
Wild Game Feast in Brandon Haunted Hayride and Spook Walk in Heliand Consort in concert in Brandon Local Ferrisburgh Carnivores rejoice! Come and enjoy Ver- 24 lowdown Halloween Celebration in Middlebury ç - - -