Studies in the Buddhist Epistemological Tradition

OSTERREICHISCHE AKADEMIE DER WISSENSCHAFTEN PHILOSOPHISCH-HISTORISCHE KLASSE DENKSCHRIFTEN, 222. BAND

BEITRAGE ZUR KULTUR- UND GEISTESGESCHICHTE ASIENS

Nr.8

Proceedings of the ^ Second International Dharmakirti Conference Vienna, June 11-16, 1989

Edited by

ERNST STEINKELLNER

VERLAG DER OSTERREICHISCHEN AKADEMIE DER WISSENSCHAFTEN WIEN 1991 vu

CONTENTS

Frontispiece: Participants at the Conference v

Contents vii

Preface ix

Y. Kajiyama, Report on the First International Dharmakirti Conference, Ky5to 1982 xi Program xii List of Participants xiii

Account of the Second International Dharmakirti Conference^, Vienna 1989 xiv Program xiv List of Participants xvii

Karunesh Shukla, Subhaiamsanam xviii

PROCEEDINGS

K. Bhattacharya, Marginal Notes on antarvyapti 1 M. R. Chinchore, Post-Udayana Nyaya Reactions to Dharmaklrti's Vadanyaya - An Evaluation 3 G. Dreyfus, Dharmaklrti's Definition of pramana and its Interpreters 19 E. Franco, The Disjunction in Pramanavarttika, Pramanasiddhi Chapter 5c 39 B. S. Gillon, Dharmakirti and the Problem of Induction 53 B. S. Gillon, Word Order in the Svarthanumana Chapter of Dharmaklrti's Pramanavarttika . . 59 M. Inami, On pakfSbhasa 69 T. Iwata, On the Classification of Three Kinds of Reason in Pramanaviniicaya III - Reduction of Reasons to svabhavahetu and kSryahetu 85 D. Jackson, Sources for the Study of Tibetan pramana Traditions Preserved at the Bihar Research Society, Patna 97 Y. Kajiyama, On the Authorship of the Upayahrdaya 107 VU1

K. Kano, On the Background of PV II 12ab - The Origin of Dharmaklrti's Idea of arthaknya 119 Sh. Katsura, Dignaga and Dharmakirti on apoha 129 T. Kimura, Dharmakirtis Sprachtheorie - Eine Synopse 147 Ch. Lindtner, The Initial Verses of the Pramanasiddhi Chapter of the Pramanavarttika .... 155 B. Matilal, Dharmakirti and the Universally Negative Inference 161 T. E. Meindersma, A Brief Reference to apoha Theory in the Section on paralokasiddhi in Pramanavarttika II 169 M. Mejor, On the Date of the Tibetan Translation of the PramOnasamuccaya and the Pramanavarttika 175 S. Moriyama, The Later Madhyamaka and Dharmakirti 199 M. T. Much, Fragments from Dignaga? Traces of a Pre-Dharmaklrti Buddhist Polemic against the Nyaya-nigrahasthana 211 H. Nagasaki, Perception in Pre-Dignaga Buddhist Texts 221 Ch. M. Namai, Two Aspects of paralokasadhana in Dharmaklrtian Tradition 227 C. Oetke, svabhavapratibandha and the Types of Reasons in Dharmaklrti's Theory of Inference 243 O. Pind, Dignaga on §abdasamanya and sabdaviSesa 269 D. Seyfort Ruegg, On pramana Theory in Tsoh kha pa's Madhyamaka Philosophy 281 E. Steinkellner, The Logic of the svabhavahetu in Dharmaklrti's Vadanyaya 311 T. Tani, Logic and Time-ness in Dharmaklrti's Philosophy - Hypothetical Negative Reasoning (prasanga) and Momentary Existence (kfanikatva) 325 T. J. F. Tillemans, Dharmakirti on Some Sophisms 403 A. Wayman, Dharmakirti and the Yogacara Theory of bija 419