1 Clathrin-independent pathways do not contribute significantly to endocytic 2 flux
3
4 Vassilis Bitsikas1, Ivan R. Corrêa Jr.2, Benjamin J. Nichols1*
5 1. Medical Research Council Laboratory of Molecular Biology, CB2 0QH, Cambridge, 6 UK.
7 2. New England Biolabs, Inc., 240 County Road, Ipswich, MA 01938, USA.
9
10 Abstract
11 Several different endocytic pathways have been proposed to function in mammalian 12 cells. Clathrin-coated pits are well defined, but the identity, mechanism and function of 13 alternative pathways have been controversial. Here we apply universal chemical labelling 14 of plasma membrane proteins to define all primary endocytic vesicles, and labelling of 15 specific proteins with a reducible SNAP-tag substrate. These approaches provide high 16 temporal resolution and stringent discrimination between surface-connected and 17 intracellular membranes. We find that at least 95% of the earliest detectable endocytic 18 vesicles arise from clathrin-coated pits. GPI-anchored proteins, candidate cargoes for 19 alternate pathways, are also found to enter the cell predominantly via coated pits. 20 Experiments employing a mutated clathrin adaptor reveal distinct mechanisms for sorting 21 into coated pits, and thereby explain differential effects on the uptake of transferrin and 22 GPI-anchored proteins. These data call for a revision of models for the activity and 23 diversity of endocytic pathways in mammalian cells. 24 25 26 27 28 29
30
31
32
33
34
35
1 36 Introduction
37 Endocytosis has central roles in many cell biological processes [1,2]. Since the mid- 38 nineties evidence has accumulated to suggest that mammalian cells utilise additional 39 endocytic mechanisms beyond clathrin-coated pits [3-5]. Whilst the molecular detail of 40 how clathrin-coated pits work is understood in ever-increasing detail [6], similarly complete 41 mechanistic descriptions of how endocytosis may take place outside of clathrin-coated pits 42 are lacking.
43 One central difficulty in defining clathrin-independent endocytic pathways has been the 44 paucity of rigorously validated endocytic markers and pathway-specific cargoes. 45 Dissection of clathrin-mediated endocytosis benefited greatly from signature cargoes such 46 as the transferrin receptor, which are efficiently concentrated in the forming endocytic 47 vesicle, and from the fact that the forming vesicle is marked specifically in space and time 48 by transient assemblies of clathrin, adaptors and associated proteins [7-10]. By contrast, 49 clathrin independent endocytosis has largely been defined by morphological criteria, and 50 by the persistent uptake of cargoes that may utilise multiple pathways following 51 perturbation of the clathrin machinery [11-13].
52 Endocytic structures that can be defined morphologically include macropinosomes, which 53 can readily be resolved by light microscopy [14], and caveolae which are distinctive in 54 electron micrographs [15]. The extent to which caveolae are involved in endocytosis is, 55 however, controversial [16]. Morphology also forms a large part of the definition of more 56 recently characterised endocytic membranes termed CLICs, for clathrin-independent 57 carriers [17,18].
58 GPI-anchored proteins have been extensively studied as potential cargoes for clathrin- 59 independent endocytosis [4,19]. The apparent presence of these proteins in endosomes 60 devoid of transferrin, and uptake in the presence of inhibitors of clathrin-coated pits, 61 provides evidence for GPI-enriched endosomal compartments (GEECs) that are fed from 62 the cell surface independently from coated pits [20-22]. It is not clear, however, that GPI- 63 anchored proteins are ever highly concentrated in nascent endocytic vesicles in a manner 64 analogous to transferrin receptor, so they may enter the cell via multiple mechanisms 65 [19,22-24]. The extent to which other types of cargo associated with clathrin-independent 66 endocytosis, including glycosphingolipid-binding bacterial toxins as well as various viruses, 67 are efficiently sorted during uptake is similarly unclear [11,12,19,25-27].
2 68 In the absence of demonstrably specific cargoes, much of the literature on clathrin- 69 independent endocytosis relies on the use of overexpressed mutant proteins to perturb 70 clathrin function, and observation of differential effects on the uptake of transferrin and 71 potential clathrin-independent cargoes. Dominant negative mutants used in this manner 72 include the C-terminal clathrin-binding domain of AP180/CALM [28], and the K44A mutant 73 of dynamin, which renders this GTPase involved in the scission of clathrin coated pits 74 enzymatically inactive [29,30]. Additionally, differential effects on endocytosis can be 75 observed using overexpression of inactive forms of small GTPases such as ARF6, ARF1 76 or cdc42 [20,21,31-33]). Blocking one type of endocytosis may up-regulate alternative 77 mechanisms, over-expression of mutant proteins may induce non-physiological cellular 78 responses, and small GTPases may, via different sets of effectors, directly or indirectly 79 control the activity of multiple endocytic pathways. Plainly, these types of experiment need 80 to be interpreted carefully.
81 Ideally, different types of endocytosis would be defined by the presence of specific 82 molecular determinants analogous to clathrin or adaptor proteins in the case of clathrin 83 coated pits [6]. Candidates for such determinants include caveolin and cavin proteins 84 which make caveolae [15,34], flotillin proteins which define specific plasma membrane 85 microdomains potentially involved in endocytosis [35], and the protein GRAF1 that may be 86 important for the formation of CLIC / GEEC endosomes [36]. The precise mechanisms by 87 which these proteins are involved in endocytosis remain to be fully understood. Both 88 flotillins and caveolins plus cavins form protein assemblies that are stable over time, and 89 thus can not define endocytic events temporally in the way in which coordinated assembly 90 and disassembly of the clathrin machinery can [34,35,37-39].
91 Thus, although several non-clathrin endocytic pathways have garnered varying degrees of 92 supportive evidence, none has been unambiguously established in molecular and 93 functional terms. Furthermore, the relative contributions of the multiple putative pathways 94 to overall endocytic flux has been unclear. To resolve some of these uncertainties, ideally 95 one would require a means to examine endocytosis in unperturbed cells in a global 96 manner. This would allow simultaneous evaluation of a large number of cargoes and their 97 relationship with clathrin and putative non-clathrin markers. In this study we apply a 98 combination of new and established methods that satisfy these requirements, and thereby 99 provide a systematic and quantitative analysis of total endocytic protein flux in cultured 100 mammalian cells.
3 101
102
4 103 Results
104 Experimental strategy and assay validation
105 We sought to establish endocytic assays and protein labelling strategies to satisfy four 106 main requirements: 1. Achieve very high topological specificity in discrimination between 107 endocytosed and extracellular protein, 2. Provide a means to analyse all, or nearly all, 108 surface proteins simultaneously, 3. Provide high signal to noise, and thereby high temporal 109 resolution for detection of primary endocytic vesicles, and 4. Allow a means to follow 110 uptake of specific cargoes.
111 Biotinylation of extracellular free amine groups with the small, monovalent label sulfo-NHS- 112 SS-biotin offered a way to satisfy the first three of these requirements [40]. The biotin 113 moiety can be removed from labelled proteins by reduction of the disulfide bond with 114 membrane-impermeant sodium 2-mercaptoethanesulfonate (MESNa) at 4°C, so this 115 approach provides a powerful way to detect internalisation of surface proteins [41,42]. We 116 assessed the efficiency of MESNa treatment in removing biotin from sulfo-NHS-SS-biotin- 117 labelled proteins, and compared this with two widely used alternatives, washing at low pH 118 to remove antibodies bound to the outside of the cell and cleavage of extracellular GPI- 119 anchors with PI-PLC [21]. MESNa treatment could remove over 99.9% of biotin from cells 120 labelled at 4°C (Figure 1A). Washes at pH3 to remove bound antibody, or PI-PLC to 121 cleave GPI-anchors, were around 2 orders of magnitude less efficient, removing up to 50% 122 and 90% of antibody bound to the GPI-anchored protein CD59 respectively (Figure 1B) 123 [43]. Reducible biotin and MESNa therefore offer a highly accurate way of assaying 124 protein internalisation.
125 To detect internalised protein in confocal images, we labelled HeLa cells with sulfo-NHS- 126 SS-biotin, allowed internalisation for defined periods of time, removed extracellular biotin 127 by reduction with MESNa, and used fluorescent streptavidin to detect intracellular biotin. 128 All subsequent experiments are also in HeLa cells unless otherwise stated. Control 129 experiments comparing incubation at 4°C with incubation for defined periods at 37°C 130 confirmed that there was no specific signal detected unless internalisation at 37°C was 131 allowed to take place (Figure 1C, Figure 1D). Endocytic vesicles could be observed after 132 as little as 20 seconds of internalisation. This is a significant improvement in time 133 resolution, and hence in our confidence that the detected vesicles have just budded from 134 the plasma membrane [17,21,35].
5 135 In order to interpret uptake of proteins labelled with sulfo-NHS-SS-biotin with confidence it 136 was necessary to confirm that the label reacts with a broad range of representative 137 proteins. Following surface biotinylation, proteins were precipitated using streptavin- 138 agarose beads, and eluted from the beads by reduction with 100mM DTT. Silver staining 139 revealed that biotinylated proteins were precipitated with high specificity (Figure 1E). LC- 140 MS identified the full list of precipitated proteins, and this list was compared with a 141 quantitative analysis of the HeLa cell proteome [44]. Abundant plasma membrane 142 proteins had higher chances of being detected. Nevertheless, a wide range of rare 143 proteins (some with estimated copy number <100 per cell) was detected, assuring us that 144 we achieved good coverage of the total plasma membrane protein complement. (Figure 145 1F, Figure 1-source data 1). Therefore chemical labelling with sulfo-NHS-SS-biotin does 146 indeed provide a way to follow endocytosis of nearly all plasma membrane proteins 147 simultaneously.
148 Reduction of extracellular disulphide bonds with membrane impermeant reducing agents 149 like MESNa evidently provides a good way to discriminate between intra- and extra- 150 cellular substrates. We used the genetically encoded SNAP-tag to apply this approach to 151 specific cargo proteins [45-47]. The SNAP moiety was labelled with a new membrane- 152 impermeant, reducible, fluorescent SNAP-labelling reagent, benzylguanine-SS-fluorophore 153 [where the fluorophore can be either atto-488 (BG-SS-488) or BODIPY (BG-SS-549)]. 154 The disulfide bond linking benzylguanine to a fluorophore can be reduced with MESNa in 155 the same way as that in sulfo-NHS-SS-biotin. Control experiments using a minimal GPI- 156 anchored SNAP-tag construct as a model plasma membrane protein showed that BG-SS- 157 fluorophore allows detection of internalised SNAP tag with very high efficiency and low 158 background, and provides an improved way of discriminating between internal and 159 external pools of tagged protein (Figure 1G, Figure 1-figure supplement 1).
160
161 Biotinylated plasma membrane proteins are predominantly internalised via clathrin coated 162 pits
163 Global labelling of primary endocytic vesicles was achieved by incubation of cells with 164 sulfo-NHS-SS-biotin at 4°C, warming to 37°C by rapid buffer exchange, and allowing 165 uptake for 20 s. Endocytic vesicles detected after MESNa treatment were small puncta 166 (Figure 2A). Approximately 2% of the cells also contained distinctively larger 167 macropinosomes over 500 nm in diameter (Figure 2-figure supplement 1). In order to
6 168 determine the identity of the endocytic vesicles we carried out co-internalisation 169 experiments with the archetypical high-affinity cargo for clathrin-coated pits, transferrin 170 (Figure 2A, Figure 2-figure supplement 2) [41,48]. The great majority of endocytic vesicles 171 contained transferrin, and therefore are likely to have arisen from clathrin-coated pits. 172 Uptake of transferrin was solely due to binding to transferrin receptor, as large, fluid-filled 173 macropinosomes were completely devoid of transferrin (Figure 2-figure supplement 1). 174 Residual surface-bound transferrin was detected as puncta, and co-localised with clathrin, 175 implying concentration in nascent coated pits (Figure 2-figure supplement 2). We used 176 unbiased and semi-automated quantification, involving application of a mask derived from 177 the image of fluorescent transferrin, to determine the proportion of biotin-positive pixels 178 that also contained transferrin in multiple cell images (Figure 2-figure supplement 3). This 179 revealed that over 95% of the total internalised biotin after 20 s uptake was present in 180 transferrin-positive vesicles (Figure 2B). Co-localisation remained constant when times of 181 internalisation up to 150 s were assayed (Figure 2B, Figure 2-figure supplement 4). 182 Additionally, after 20 s uptake over 80% of biotin-positive endocytic vesicles co-localised 183 with clathrin in small puncta, defining them as clathrin-coated vesicles (Figure 2C, Figure 184 2D, Figure 2-figure supplement 5). The proportion co-localising with clathrin fell rapidly 185 with longer periods of uptake, as one would expect due to uncoating of primary vesicles 186 (Figure 2D, Figure 2-figure supplement 5) [6].
187 The experiments described above depended on labelling cells at 4°C before rapid 188 warming to 37°C to permit endocytosis. This improved signal to noise ratio and thereby 189 improved temporal resolution, but at the same time cooling and rapid warming could have 190 an effect on the endocytic machinery [49]. We sought to perform the endocytic assay in 191 unperturbed cells, under more physiological conditions, by omitting the pre-incubation step 192 at 4°C. Cells were labelled with sulfo-NHS-SS-biotin and transferrin at 37°C (Figure 2E). 193 The earliest time after initiation of labelling at which endocytic vesicles could be reliably 194 detected was 90 seconds, presumably because of the time taken for sufficient reaction of 195 the NHS ester with primary amines at the cell surface. Consistent with the results when 196 labelling was carried out at 4°C, nearly all of the internalised protein labelled with biotin 197 was indeed present in transferrin-positive vesicles (Figure 2E, Figure 2F). Another 198 concern was that HeLa cells could be in some way atypical, so we repeated the same 199 experiments in Cos7 and RPE cells. Again, there was near-complete co-localisation 200 between endocytosed sulfo-NHS-SS-biotin and transferrin after 90s uptake at 37°C 201 (Figure 2-figure supplement 6).
7 202 In order to verify that transferrin-negative endocytic vesicles are very rare we used a 203 different labelling approach. We loaded HeLa cells with the amphiphilic styryl membrane
204 dye FM1-43FX [50], and allowed co-internalisation with transferrin for 90 seconds at 37˚C.
205 Extraction of the dye with label-free medium reversed plasma membrane labelling and 206 provided a means of identifying FM1-43FX-positive intracellular vesicles. Although this 207 may not provide such stringent topological discrimination between intracellular vesicles 208 and surface membrane as the sulfo-NHS-SS-biotin plus MESNa approach, there was a 209 very high degree of co-localisation between FM1-43FX-positive puncta and transferrin 210 (Figure 2-figure supplement 7). Quantification revealed that 90% of the FM1-43FX signal 211 present in intracellular vesicles was also present in transferrin-positive pixels (Figure 2- 212 figure supplement 7).
213 Confocal z-stacks and volume rendering were used to allow analysis at the level of 214 individual primary endocytic vesicles. (Figure 3A, Figure 3-figure supplement 1A). Biotin- 215 positive endocytic vesicles were identified as 3D objects using the Imaris software, and the 216 transferrin cargo load was calculated based on the mean transferrin intensity within each 217 vesicle (Figure 3A, Figure 3B, Movie 1). In order to account for background signal 218 generated by experimental noise or random overlap, the transferrin channel was offset by 219 500 nm from its correct register, and transferrin intensity in the same objects was sampled 220 for a second time. (Figure 3B). The 95th percentile of this background intensity distribution 221 was used as a cut-off to define transferrin-negative endocytic vesicles (Figure 3B). 222 Applying this conservative criterion, after 90s continuous labelling and uptake 96% of 2350 223 vesicles contained transferrin, and after labelling at 4°C and uptake for 20s 92% of 2387 224 vesicles contained transferrin (Figure 3B). A single Gaussian curve could describe the 225 transferrin intensity distribution within most identified vesicles, consistent with stochastic 226 incorporation of transferrin receptors into forming clathrin-coated pits [51]. A small 227 population of transferrin-negative objects could be seen as a peak at the lowest end of the 228 intensity distribution, showing that potential transferrin-negative endocytic vesicles, where 229 they exist, can be detected by our method (Figure 3B). We observed no correlation 230 between biotin intensity and the probability of that vesicle not containing transferrin, 231 arguing against the possibility of a morphologically distinctive class of transferrin-negative 232 endocytic vesicle (Figure 3-figure supplement 1B). We also carried out experiments to test 233 the possibility that the glycosphingolipid-binding B-subunit of cholera toxin (CTB), which 234 has been extensively used as a marker for clathrin-independent endocytosis [17,52,53],
8 235 induces the formation of transferrin-negative endocytic vesicles. Biotin-positive vesicles 236 were identified as objects in transferrin-labeled cells as described above, with and without 237 addition of CTB. The transferrin load in vesicles in control and CTB treated cells was the 238 same (Figure 3-Figure Supplement 2).
239 Both quantitative analysis of single confocal sections using pixel masks (Figure 2), and 240 object-based quantification of all primary endocytic vesicles in 3D reconstructions (Figure 241 3), argue strongly that around 95% of primary endocytic vesicles are positive for the best 242 characterised cargo of clathrin-coated pits, the transferrin receptor [6]. The simplest 243 hypothesis arising from these observations is that essentially all proteins taken up by the 244 cell are internalised along with transferrin via clathrin-coated pits. If this is the case, then 245 ablation of coated pit activity should effectively block total endocytosis. Overexpression of 246 the C-terminal clathrin-binding domain of AP180/CALM (AP180-C) provides an efficient 247 means of blocking formation of coated pits [28]. In cells overexpressing AP180-C, 248 transferrin uptake and endocytosis of total biotinylated protein were both efficiently 249 blocked, with total protein uptake being reduced to less than 5% of control levels (Figure 250 3C and Figure 3E). Overexpression of the K44A mutant of dynamin blocks budding of 251 clathrin-coated pits [29,30]. In cells overexpressing dynamin 2 K44A there was efficient 252 reduction of both transferrin and total biotinylated protein uptake to less than 5% of control 253 levels (Figure 3D and Figure 3F). Additionally, we noted that expression of very high 254 levels of the dynamin mutant induced endocytosis of total biotinylated protein in both 255 macropinosomes and smaller vesicular structures (see below). We conclude that 256 formation of the primary vesicles that contribute the large majority of endocytic flux in 257 unperturbed cells is blocked by loss of clathrin or dynamin function.
258
259 Quantitative proteomics shows that perturbation of the formation of coated pits alters the 260 protein composition of the plasma membrane
261 If plasma membrane proteins are predominantly endocytosed via clathrin coated pits then 262 one would predict that they should accumulate in the plasma membrane when coated pits 263 are not functional. Proteomic analysis of surface-biotinylated plasma membrane proteins 264 offered a way to test this hypothesis directly. In order to ablate coated pit activity, cells 265 were transfected with siRNA against the alpha adaptin subunit of the clathrin adaptor AP2
266 (‘AP2 siRNA’). This blocked alpha-adaptin expression, and hence AP2 function (Figure 4A,
9 267 Figure 4B) [54,55]. AP2 siRNA blocked both transferrin uptake and uptake of total 268 biotinylated proteins to a similar extent (Figure 4B). SILAC (Stable Isotopic Labelling by 269 Amino-acids in Culture) followed by precipitation of surface biotinylated proteins with 270 streptavidin-agarose provided a quantitative comparison of the relative abundance of 271 plasma membrane proteins in control and AP2 siRNA treated cells. This revealed a clear 272 and pronounced increase in the abundance of most proteins in AP2-siRNA cells (Figure 273 4C and Figure 4-source data 1). Analysis of SILAC ratios of the non-biotinylated cytosolic 274 proteins present in the flow-through provided an internal control and did not reveal similar 275 changes, confirming that the effects of AP2 depletion are largely restricted to the 276 population of plasma membrane proteins (Figure 4C). This is consistent with the majority 277 of plasma membrane proteins entering the cell via clathrin-coated pits.
278 The comparatively small list of proteins that are depleted from the plasma membrane upon 279 AP2 siRNA treatment is heterogeneous (Figure 4-source data 1), and includes proteins 280 thought to be internalised via clathrin-coated pits such as ADAM 10 [56]. The only obvious 281 pattern within the list is the presence of most GPI-anchored proteins detected (Figure 4D). 282 SILAC ratios for GPI-anchored proteins detected in the cytosolic flow-through were all 283 close to 1, so this is likely to reflect a depletion restricted only to the plasma membrane 284 (Figure 4-source data 1). Flow cytometry to assay changes in plasma membrane levels of 285 individual proteins confirmed that AP2 siRNA causes an accumulation of transferrin 286 receptor at the plasma membrane, while levels of the GPI-anchored protein CD59 are 287 reduced (Figure 4-figure supplement 1). As GPI-anchored proteins have been studied as 288 potential cargoes for clathrin-independent endocytic pathways, we decided to focus further 289 on this class of protein [21,24,57].
290
291 GPI-anchored proteins enter the cell via clathrin-coated pits
292 We produced plasmids for expression of SNAP-tagged versions of CD59, folate receptor 293 and PrP, three different GPI-anchored proteins identified in our mass spectrometry data, 294 as well a minimal SNAP-GPI construct. HeLa cells expressing each of the GPI-anchored 295 proteins were incubated for 90 s at 37°C in the presence of BG-SS-488 to allow labelling 296 and uptake, and extracellular fluorophore was removed by reduction with MESNa (Figure 297 5A). Uptake of BG-SS-488 was detected only in SNAP-expressing cells (Figure 5A). All 298 four GPI-anchored proteins co-localised extensively with transferrin after internalisation 299 (Figure 5A). When quantified, around 90% of all BG-SS-488 labelled, internalised GPI-
10 300 anchored proteins co-localised with transferrin (Figure 5B). To assess the biological 301 significance of the residual 10% we used precisely the same quantification method to 302 analyse co-localisation between transferrin-alexa-647 and transferrin-alexa-546, after 303 mixing and adding to cells for simultaneous internalisation. Again we detected around 304 90% co-localisation, so it is possible that the residual 10% can be accounted for by 305 limitations in quantification rather than a biologically significant pool of GPI-anchored 306 protein internalised separately from transferrin (Figure 5B).
307 Several previous studies, including some from our laboratory, have suggested that GPI- 308 anchored proteins are endocytosed in a clathrin-independent manner [17,21,24,35,57,58]. 309 We sought to explain this apparent discrepancy. In several of these studies CTB has 310 been used as a marker for clathrin-independent endocytosis. As discussed previously, it 311 was possible that CTB induces clathrin-independent uptake of GPI-anchored proteins. 312 Object-based analysis of the transferrin load within BG-SS-488-positive vesicles in cells 313 expressing SNAP-CD59 argues that this is not the case (Figure 5-figure supplement 1).
314 One type of experiment that can be interpreted as evidence for clathrin-independent 315 endocytosis is the presence of endocytosed protein in vesicles separate from those 316 labelled with transferrin [21,22,35]. We did not observe this in the experiments outlined 317 above (Figure 5), so we chose to pursue this further by conjugating a monoclonal antibody 318 against CD59 to both alexa-546, and to SS-atto-488 (Figure 6A). Importantly, the disulfide 319 bond in SS-atto-488 can be reduced with MESNa as previously. This meant we could 320 follow uptake of endogenous CD59, and directly compare two different methods of 321 assaying internalisation. Cells were labelled at 4°C with the doubly labelled antibody and 322 transferrin, and then warmed to 37°C for 90 s. Subsequently cells were treated with 323 MESNa, and then with PI-PLC to cleave GPI-anchors. The SS-atto-488 signal co- 324 localised completely with transferrin. Alexa-546, however, was seen in many punctate 325 structures that lack transferrin (Figure 6A). We interpret these data as strong evidence 326 that the PI-PLC treatment did not remove all external GPI-anchored protein, while 327 reduction with MESNa provided more stringent discrimination between internal and 328 external pools of the antibody (Figure 1A, Figure 1B, Figure 1-figure supplement 1). 329 Therefore, endogenous CD59 is indeed internalised in transferrin-containing vesicles, and 330 apparent internalisation in vesicles lacking transferrin may, at least under the conditions 331 we have employed in this study, be an artifact due to incomplete removal of surface bound 332 antibody.
11 333 A second type of experiment used in many studies to provide evidence for uptake via 334 clathrin-independent endocytosis is to perturb the function of clathrin-coated pits, and then 335 assay continued endocytosis of a specific protein [2,59]. We used overexpression of 336 AP180-C to block formation of coated pits in a HeLa cell line stably expressing SNAP- 337 CD59. In cells expressing AP180-C, endocytosis of SNAP-CD59 was blocked to the same 338 extent as endocytosis of transferrin (Figure 6B and Figure 6D). Endocytosis of SNAP- 339 CD59 was also blocked by moderate expression of dynamin-2-K44A (Figure 6C and 340 Figure 6E). In cells expressing very high levels of the mutant dynamin, abundant 341 macropinosomes could be detected, as well as smaller endocytic structures (Figure 6- 342 figure supplement 1) [29]. These were clearly induced by high levels of dynamin-2-K44A 343 (Figure 6-figure supplement 1). Therefore moderate dynamin-2-K4AA expression does 344 block the physiological mechanism that leads to internalisation of CD59 in unperturbed 345 cells. As loss of both clathrin and dynamin function blocks uptake of CD59, the data imply 346 that GPI-anchored proteins are likely to enter cells predominantly via clathrin-coated 347 vesicles.
348 Labelling of the total population of endocytosed proteins and potential markers for clathrin- 349 independent endocytosis
350 We used surface protein biotinylation with sulfo-NHS-SS-biotin to compare the distribution 351 of total endocytosed protein with markers for possible clathrin-independent endocytic 352 pathways. We examined co-localisation with flotillin 1 [35,60], caveolin 1 [16,61,62], 353 GRAF1-GFP [36], and ARF6-GFP [31,63] after 90 s and 15 min of endocytosis at 37°C 354 (Figure 7, Figure 7-figure supplement 1). Co-localisation was quantified using a mask 355 generated from the streptavidin channel as explained in Figure 2-figure supplement 3. 356 Importantly, as the different markers label abundant structures it was possible that low 357 levels of co-localisation would be detected due to chance overlap rather than specific 358 labelling of the same structures. To control for this, we repeated the co-localisation 359 quantification with the two channels in all images offset from each other by 500nm. This 360 provides an empirical way to estimate the degree of overlap between channels that arises 361 by chance.
362 In the case of caveolin 1, after both 90 s and 15 min some apparent co-localisation in 363 punctate structures could be observed, and quantification confirmed that around 2% of 364 caveolin 1 was present specifically in biotin-positive endosomes (Figure 7A, Figure 7B, 15 365 min time-point images in Figure 7-figure supplement 1). In the case of flotillin 1, although
12 366 some plausible co-localisation could be observed in confocal images, quantification 367 revealed that this may arise purely by chance as the same degree of pixel overlap was 368 found in offset and original images (Figure 7C, Figure 7D). In the case of GRAF1, 369 internalised biotin was detected in GRAF1-GFP-positive puncta (Figure 7E). 370 Quantification confirmed specific overlap between internalised biotin and GRAF1 (Figure 371 7F). The fact that our previous data show that most internalised biotin / total protein co- 372 localises with transferrin made the strong prediction that these GRAF1-positive 373 endosomes should also contain transferrin. This was indeed the case (Figure 7E). ARF6 374 showed a similar distribution to GRAF1, labelling transferrin-positive endosomes (Figure 375 7G, Figure 7H). We conclude that GRAF1-GFP and ARF6-GFP are present on transferrin- 376 positive endocytic vesicles likely to have arisen from budding of clathrin-coated pits from 377 the plasma membrane, that flotillin 1 is not detected on early endosomes, and that 378 caveolin 1 is present on a very small fraction of endosomes. All of these observations are 379 consistent with our general conclusion, that at least 95% of endocytosed protein enters the 380 cell via clathrin-coated pits.
381
382 Distinct sorting mechanisms for transferrin receptor and GPI-anchored proteins lead to 383 divergent effects on entry into coated pits
384 Our data argue that GPI-anchored proteins enter the cell via coated pits, but, they behave 385 differently from many other clathrin cargoes when AP2 expression is suppressed over 5 386 days. There are several factors potentially involved in this effect, such as rates of 387 synthesis, degradation and endocytic recycling of proteins with GPI anchors. We 388 investigated further the factor most relevant to the focus of this study, sorting during 389 endocytosis. The absence of a cytosolic domain means that GPI-anchored proteins are 390 fundamentally different from high-affinity cargoes such as the transferrin receptor, as they 391 can not be recruited to the nascent pit via direct recognition of endocytic sorting motifs by 392 adaptor proteins. It is likely that GPI-anchored proteins are partially excluded from coated 393 pits by steric crowding effects [22]. We reasoned that perturbing the recognition of 394 endocytic sorting motifs could therefore cause differential effects on uptake of GPI- 395 anchored proteins and transferrin receptor. As an initial test of this hypothesis, we used 396 siRNA to partially reduce AP2 expression. AP2 recognises two major endocytic motifs 397 [6,54,64,65]. We measured transferrin and SNAP-CD59 uptake by flow cytometry, 3 days 398 after siRNA transfection. Cells still endocytosed significant amounts of both cargoes
13 399 (Figure 8-figure supplement 1). We compared the ratio between the two cargoes, on a cell 400 by cell basis, for the populations of control and AP2 siRNA transfected cells (Figure 8A). 401 AP2 siRNA caused a more pronounced reduction of transferrin than CD59 uptake. 402 Confocal imaging confirmed the flow cytometry results. In cells where AP2 levels were 403 reduced, the reduction in transferrin uptake appeared more severe than reduction in 404 SNAP-CD59 uptake (Figure 8B). Using these imaging data, we correlated the amount of 405 AP2 remaining in each cell with the total fluorescence intensity of internalised transferrin 406 and SNAP-CD59 (Figure 8C). The uptake of both cargoes was efficiently blocked when 407 AP2 levels became close to zero, but transferrin uptake was clearly more sensitive to 408 reduction of AP2 levels than uptake of SNAP-CD59. (Figure 8C - see also Figure 4B).
409 Specific amino acid changes in the YXXΦ binding site of the µ2 subunit of AP2 abolish
410 binding of YXXΦ-containing cargoes like transferrin receptor [66,67]. Overexpression of
411 this mutant form of μ2 resulted in incorporation into endogenous AP2 complexes, and 412 thereby provided a tool to further investigate sorting of transferrin and GPI-anchored 413 proteins into coated pits (Figure 8-figure supplement 2). Overexpression of
414 µ2(F174S/D176A), but not wild-type μ2, caused a dramatic differential effect on the uptake
415 of the two cargoes after 90 s of labelling and internalisation. As predicted, transferrin 416 uptake was reduced [67]. Uptake of SNAP-CD59, however, was significantly increased 417 (Figure 8D). Importantly, this divergence did not arise from separate endocytic structures, 418 as internalised SNAP-CD59 still co-localised well with the residual internalised transferrin 419 (Figure 8E). Moreover, when 3D object-based analysis was used to identify transferrin- 420 positive vesicles, and to quantify the amount of SNAP-CD59 present in these vesicles, a 421 clear increase in the SNAP-CD59 load in mutant-expressing cells was observed (Figure 422 8F). This analysis also confirmed the reduced transferrin load in endocytic vesicles in 423 mutant-expressing cells (Figure 8G). These results are in agreement with our initial 424 hypothesis of distinctive sorting of GPI-anchored proteins into clathrin coated pits. They 425 argue that steric exclusion of GPI-anchored proteins from the nascent pit becomes less 426 acute when recruitment of high-affinity cargoes by AP2, or potentially other adaptors is 427 abolished [22]. More generally, the data imply that rates of endocytosis of high affinity 428 cargoes may be more susceptible to a range of perturbations of coated pit function than 429 cargoes like GPI-anchored proteins, which have a lower affinity for the nascent pit.
430
14 431 Discussion
432 An imaging approach to studying endocytosis in unperturbed cells, where all surface 433 proteins are labelled, is intrinsically easier to interpret than experiments where mutant 434 proteins, siRNA, or chemical inhibitors cause loss of function, and potentially indirect or 435 off-target effects, over days. The use of small, monovalent reducible chemical labels 436 provides high temporal resolution, signal-to-noise ratio and efficiency of topological 437 discrimination between intracellular and extracellular protein. This has allowed us to follow 438 endocytosis of effectively all proteins, and thereby to observe all endocytic intermediates 439 formed by the cell at specific time-points, starting with as little as 20s of internalisation. 440 Our results are at some variance with previous studies from our own and other 441 laboratories, and with our preconceptions before being confronted with the data [59].
442 Our data support the conclusions that the predominant pathway for endocytosis in 443 mammalian cells, accounting for at least 95% of total protein endocytic flux, is uptake via 444 the clathrin-coated pit. Other mechanisms are not likely to make a significant contribution. 445 Primary endocytic vesicles involved in clathrin-independent endocytosis should not contain 446 significant amounts of transferrin receptor, and while we can detect a class of such 447 vesicles they account for less than 5% of total endocytosis. Further data, including 448 perturbations of clathrin-coated pit function, assay of the endocytosis of GPI-anchored 449 proteins, and co-localisation experiments looking at candidate markers for clathrin- 450 independent endocytic pathways are all consistent with this conclusion. A recent 451 systematic analysis of multiple assays for endocytosis using siRNA screens also provides 452 indirect support, in that it reveals extensive functional and regulatory links between uptake 453 of cargoes previously thought to enter the cell via different mechanisms [68]. In addition, 454 this study conspicuously does not detect new linked sets of proteins likely to act together 455 in a concerted fashion to make novel types of endocytic vesicle. Some cargoes for clathrin 456 coated pits have been reported to be present in sub-populations of early endocytic 457 vesicles, most likely through mechanisms related to cargo-dependent recruitment of 458 specific adaptors [69-71]. However, there is good evidence that transferrin receptor does 459 not behave in this way [6,70], and our analysis of transferrin load in primary endocytic 460 vesicles confirms this. In the light of these observations, it is difficult to reconcile our data 461 with reports of abundant clathrin-independent endocytic carriers or CLICs. We note that 462 the ultrastructure of CLICs, although clearly different from clathrin-generated vesicles, is 463 not dissimilar to that of the early endosomes that receive cargoes taken up via coated pits 464 [72-76].
15 465 Much of the literature on clathrin-independent endocytosis is based on perturbations with 466 differential effects on the uptake of transferrin and putative clathrin-independent cargoes 467 [2,5,21,25,59,77]. Our data suggest a possible re-interpretation of this type of experiment. 468 We demonstrate that GPI-anchored proteins enter mammalian cells via clathrin coated 469 pits, and that this is fully compatible with the differential effects on endocytic uptake 470 between transferrin receptor and GPI-anchored proteins reported here and observed in 471 previous studies [20,21,31,57]. The coated pit is a crowded environment, and GPI- 472 anchored proteins will have to compete for a place inside the nascent pit with cargo 473 proteins possessing high affinity sorting signals recognised directly by adaptor proteins [6]. 474 When the protein levels of adaptors such as AP2 are reduced, or when the ability to bind 475 and recruit certain cargoes is lost, it is likely that the pit becomes less crowded, thereby 476 becomes more populated with low affinity or passive cargoes like GPI-anchored proteins, 477 and yet retains some ability to bud. This leads to the differential effects on transferrin and 478 CD59 uptake that we observed experimentally. Divergent effects of coated pit perturbation 479 on cargoes which all demonstrably enter the cell via coated pits, means that such effects 480 need no longer be interpreted as evidence for clathrin-independent endocytosis.
481 Our data place important constraints on models of endocytic flux. Additional endocytic 482 mechanisms, like the still poorly understood set of protein machinery responsible for 483 macropinocytosis, and the budding of caveolae, contribute very little to total protein uptake 484 but can be detected by our assays. Such clathrin-independent pathways could still be 485 functionally important when uptake of specific cargoes, and the variety of cell types and 486 functions in vivo are considered [78,79]. Nevertheless, we conclude that clathrin- 487 independent pathways do not make a significant contribution to total endocytic flux in 488 cultured cells.
489
16 490 Acknowledgements
491 We thank Mark Skehel and the LMB Mass Spec. team for analysis of SILAC experiments. 492 Sean Munro and Ramanujan Hegde provided insightful comments on the manuscript.
493 Competing interests
494 Ivan Correa is an employee of New England Biolabs Inc. New England Biolabs may in the 495 future provide reagents used in this study as commercial products.
496
497
498 Materials and Methods
499 Cell culture and DNA transfections
500 HeLa, RPE and Cos7 cells where cultured at 37°C, 10% CO2, in DMEM supplemented 501 with 10% FBS. When required, cells were transfected with FugeneHD (Promega), 14–20 502 hours before imaging.
503 Constructs and cell lines
504 CD59 and FOLR1 were cloned from human cDNA. PrP was a gift from Manu Hegde. The 505 N-terminal tagging of SNAP-CD59, SNAP-FOLR1 and SNAP-PrP was obtained by 506 inserting the SNAPtag domain following the N-terminal signal peptide of each protein. The 507 minimal SNAP-GPI was constructed by inserting a SNAPtag domain between the N- 508 terminal signal peptide and the ω-2 site of human CD59. To obtain AP180C-IRES-GFP, 509 AP180-C (A gift from H. McMahon) was inserted into the multiple cloning site of IRES2- 510 AcGFP1, using the XhoI and SacII sites. DynII (aa) K44A-dsRed was a gift from M.Frick. 511 GRAF1-GFP was a gift from H. McMahon. AP2 µ2 and µ2(F174S/D176A) (Gifts from 512 M.Robinson) were cloned in IRES2-AcGFP1, using the XhoI and SacII sites. A typographic 513 error for the YXXΦ binding mutant is present in previous publications [54,65,67]. The 514 mutant used and characterised in those studies was as described here (David Owen, 515 personal communication).
516 Following transfection, G418 (400µg/ml) was used to select cells stably expressing SNAP- 517 CD59. Resistant cells were sorted twice by flow cytometry to ensure retention of the 518 construct and uniform expression levels.
519 Antibodies and other reagents
17 520 antiCD59-546-ss488 was generated by conjugating anti-CD59 (MEM43) (Abcam) 521 simultaneously to NHS-ss-ATTO488 (ATTO-TEC) and NHS-AlexaFluor546 (Molecular 522 probes). Following conjugation the antibody was separated from unreacted reagents using 523 size-exclusion chromatography. Antibodies and reagents were obtained from the following 524 sources; AntiCD59-AlexaFluor647 (MEM43) (AbD Serotec), mouse monoclonal (AP.6) 525 against alpha adaptin used for immunofluorescence and immunoprecipitation (Abcam), 526 mouse monoclonal against alpha adaptin used for western blots (BD), rabbit polyclonal 527 anti-caveolin 1 (BD), mouse monoclonal anti-flotillin 2 (BD), rabbit polyclonal against 528 clathrin heavy chain (Abcam), Streptavidin-HRP (Pierce), PI-PLC from Bacillus cereus 529 (Life technologies), Streptavidin-488, -546 or -647 (Molecular probes), Transferrin-546 or - 530 647 (Molecular probes), Cholera toxin subunit B (CTB) -647 (Molecular probes), FM1- 531 43FX (Molecular probes), SNAP-surface 549 (NEB), BG-SS-488 and BG-SS-549 were 532 kindly provided by our collaborators in NEB
533 siRNA transfection
534 Typically, non-targeting siRNA (Dharmacon) or alpha-adaptin siRNA (Dharmacon) were 535 delivered to the cells at a final concentration of 100 nM, using oligofectamine (Invitrogen). 536 Transfections took place on days 1 and 3, while assays were carried out on day 5. For 537 partial depletion of AP-2, one round of siRNA transfection took place and assays were 538 performed at different timepoints up to 72 hours later. The siRNA targeting the alpha- 539 subunit of AP-2, has been described previously[80] [5’-GAG CAU GUG CAC GCU GGC 540 CAdT dT-3’]
541 Immunoprecipitation
542 AP2 complexes were immunoprecipitated with an anti-alpha adaptin antibody (AP.6) and 543 protein G-sepharose after lysis with immunoprecipitation buffer (25mM Tris-HCl pH 7.4, 544 150mM NaCl, 1mM EDTA, 1% Triton X-100 and 5% glycerol). To test for incorporation of 545 the overexpressed mutant subunit into endogenous AP2 complexes, HeLa cells were 546 transfected with μ2(F174S/D176A)-IRES-GFP and maintained in culture for the indicated 547 periods.
548 SILAC and mass spectrometry
549 HeLa cells were cultured for 7 days in R0K0 or R10K8 DMEM (Dundee cell products) 550 supplemented with dialysed fetal bovine serum (MWCO 10kDa - Dundee cell products).
18 551 Following surface biotinylation, cells were lysed in 1% Triton X-100, 1% Octyl glucoside 552 (Sigma) in TBSE buffer (50mM Tris pH 7.4, 150mM NaCl, 5mM EDTA) in the presence of 553 protease inhibitors (Roche). The lysates were left to rotate in the coldroom for 30 minutes, 554 and then spun at 20.000rcf for 20min. The supernatant was transferred to a clean 555 eppendorf tube and incubated for 1 hour with high capacity streptavidin-agarose resin 556 (Pierce). Every sample was then transferred to a chromatography column (Bio-Rad) and 557 washed with 25ml 1%Triton in TBSE. To elute biotinylated proteins the resin was 558 incubated for 5 minutes with 100mM DTT in TBS (50mM Tris pH 7.4, 150mM NaCl). SDS- 559 PAGE gels were stained with Sypro Ruby (Lonza) or silver stain (Pierce). Peptide 560 identification from each sample was done using LTQ Orbitrap XL (Thermo). Calculation of 561 SILAC ratios and further data analysis were performed using MaxQuant [81] and Prism 562 (GraphPad) respectively. The AP2 siRNA SILAC experiment was repeated 3 times, data 563 shown are from one experiment. The same overall trend in terms of accumulation of most 564 plasma membrane proteins in the AP2 siRNA treated cells and depletion of GPI-anchored 565 proteins, were observed in all 3 experiments.
566 Bioinformatic analysis of labelled plasma membrane proteins
567 A recently published estimate for protein copy numbers in HeLa cells [44] was correlated 568 with a list of human plasma membrane proteins [GO:0005886]. Plasma membrane 569 abundance (PMA) for a protein x was calculated as shown;