Southern Africa Vol 12 No. 4 Ld) ~ Glljldj@Ld) Glnj ~ ~0 ~ 2__S
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Southern Africa voL 12 No. 4 lD) ~ GllJlDJ@lD) GlnJ ~ ~0 ~ 2__S . September 1997 Neo-Liberalism & AIJl it's Works o· L.an.d D Se~ rvices · o EPZs 0 The S .A. Budget September 1997 Vol. 12 No.4 Contents l Editorial: Of Crime ... and Neo-liberalism . 1 Private Gain, Public Loss? Service Delivery in the New S.A. .. 3 Giving South Africans the GEARs Southern Africa The '97 Budget . .. 7 REPORT is produced quarterly by a collective Regional Mirage: Southern Africa and the EPZ . 11 of TCLSAC, the Toronto Committee for Links between Southern Africa & Canada The Menace of the Market 427 Bloor St. West Land and Labour in Southern Africa 16 Toronto, Ontario M5S 1X7 Tel. (416) 967-5562 email: [email protected] Debating Globalization: Critique of Colin Leys . web site: www.web.n et /~tclsac/ 20 Submissions, suggestions and help in production are welcome and invited ISSN 0820-5582 Going it Alone: Opposition Politics in Zimbabwe . 24 Member: Canadian Magazine Publishers Association Reviews: Indexed in : Canadian Index; Canadian Business & Current Affairs Family Matters 27 A ll rights reversed Whites Only 30 Subscriptions Southern Africa Report subscription & TCLSAC membership rates: SUBSCRIPTION: SAR Collective Individual (per year) $18.00 Institution (per year) $40.00 Margie Adam, Stephen Allen, Carolyn Bassett, Christine Beckermann, Lois Browne, Marlea Clarke, MEMBERSHIP: (includes subscription) Dav id Cooke, Thaddeus Gacii, David Galbraith, David Hartman, Regular . $35.00 John S. Saul, Marit Stiles, Lauren Swenarchuk , Unemployed Joe Vise, Mary Vi se, Student . $18.00 Senior Sustainer . over $100.00 CoveT photo: the Johannesburg Stock Exchange Overseas add $10 .00 Cover design by Art Work Cover pho t o by Philip Schedler- LINK/Impact Visuals Canadian Publications Mail Product Sales Agreement No. 569607 ________________ @@~~@~~~li ________________ World World A cancer of lawlessness afflicts the Rainbow People of God ......-·1!1?1'-. _"' ........ :bd~ ·~ -- • ~ ..-w ,..,_._..._,.._..,.....~==- --bJIII!tf~.tr- - ~..:.. .._ .......... .. --" ..........,..-.,tlltOk- < ~IIW: ~-""""'""·f'alw ....... d•C.. ~:..n.:r.,':"'..:.:._ '- ~.: ;:;::.w..~4oolh~Urol..,.....,.v,... :: = .,..'lo!l ... •dl\11 )1'1~ ~ - 1:"-'1.-• , " ............... _,."'"_, .., ... .,........,...la~Aa"tww• folt.llf}~··----.. ..... _....._..)W!I ..... ~-.~ :hot"'lllf..__ftl'lulitt. ... ~ t.o.n..k ... _flll ............ •""'vfiiiRI..,._..,IWtlf ... .- .,..,. ....., ...... ........ looU,I.l!W'II. ........ ~t.,·...,_ ""'*MIIII""''-•rU,~III...,,A.__......,._.._III""'......, .............. fi.ll w.,....,....,_.m.._...._ _ __ _ - loilooriM-lwllislll_.pk_ ·--~_.,........, ................... __,,..... :::..:::..-=.~..:.~ -~<111.· -fill~ ..... ._.,.. ....,..«d!!l<t .._. .. ........ w, "-·~·"-"'U.II!ilo! ,......,_1>,._..,'1" __ .....,.. _u.,,,...,.,_.,...-tt.•IIIP"'4f litoo! .~ Mri<•'•,..,...._IN4,k·_...,.. ~-(~·-...,._ .................. .._. ... ~e!!:llliill!ol ~ ......... .,.~ _,. •• ........ fll .........-.---.. Jiolll;,·-"'-"'~""..t- ..:.. ..... tlltlo<:NOn._... ... _ •,.:-: A..,.,...,,_-..-, ........ •~t r--------------------------------------------- ----------------------------------------------. c:-~~~=~::=.-~..--· p ~- ~-••!tl1wf>b..._ .... ._.,.._\IOIMicll<• !,.,....,..~._ ....... -l<ii<U""O'III'»d.~<IWf Crime, violence and the nouvelle cuisine of the new South Africa _,. ..:."'1:::::~.:.:::...··-:::.::: """""""'* ........ _..._,_""' _ ~-- ...,. -· ...... ....... - ......... ~~..,....._ _ ..e:J <Js.dl ............................ .. -::..-.:-..:.1::..'='!.'" -~ --_.........,..,__,..~_ JoA.....,.A~ot ... .. ldiii>MIIi ................. _.,... 11!;3;oUO.,-~Ii- ' ...-.~,!<........ !«' {)W .....,..,.l<OI_ ... ~ _,.,....-l ....... ........ ~tlwot..oo(!llf~. ""' l>f ~U...•Oililj1ll<flrl'!L - n...,.,--~•J.ak': oi Uiral -d-~ 4-o .... to•'-"'- I"' ~ P O'llilllfo .........,.,.~ "''-""......_"' ........."'-"' ... ........ ,...,.,.. ~-~-...-...._ ... ... ___ ,.rlf ~~-*11h-*•- ........... "'""'"""' .,.. '""~"'-*"-' --~"'- ... _..,.__--- ""''"··-·loeikn.llfW- ..__.....,;111111.~ ...... • ~ . ,...,.. ..__,....... .._... ...,.,...._... ........... ... lr-*~-~"~~... -- .....,._.. p-. ......-. ,_ .. lulli.wllf................. ... _• _, f\lr~- ............. lilllf;ftl ... ................. ""-' llnlli~-~-·-· ... .......: - ... _. loocltAAM"W;-4..-. ........ -. ... ,........ .... .......,.. ... .--..... ......, ..,_,_~,...._fl'.- ..... ...... _ ............. ~Mk:i .............. \...,.,.,.. .......... ,...... ............... ............ ~~ ............. ...__.. :":.'!::~~.v. .......... ---'---~-n. ~~aA-- w..r- ... ~...,,_.. .• -.. ...... folowkiJ-.,Iooirl:..,._r..i:dtAA'i .o.,o;t·,.,.,._.N!obDI.........,.IIA .... -~-1M~-.. ,.., ... ......,._ .. l_...._ __ ,..,...~ .... - ..hiJW.It*llit'lloow -- -·(~.--~tll,d.U 1-'- . ,... boll~-.,_., ~-,.,....... kl11V !Wo 'l\llltl'-~ j,Oillo<t~l>l"'·ll> ............. '""fi'MM- ...... ... ..•, .. _,._~ ~· h-"'*111 T'lo~-...... ...,~ n ~.-.,...,........_ ~ -'loo'lfdt:tol-,...,._lifl"""'*'-·- .. • ,...tal;.:..._..,... _ _."" ........... ............. ........ l!flillt»~----lbooi¥1 .............................. ... ~....... - (W"""o-~··· <bwa....,.._ .... ....o.."':":..t:.:~ ..... wr .... .. .._...,,...,...._ ..,.. ,. "'"""'.~,.,..... ..... ,.,....... ..... lilllliouT.,~ 'n..- "'-"".._.......,_. -"'~llllu'll-......... 4 !Mid< ......_,...._.,.. ...._ n.llf!lltiiC.WYI.Io :::'"'..:::~~-~ ~~~~~~~----l'mll'o\1 ...................... ~~--- (QI. --- IWtM,............,........,...,.~.... --- ~Jtollcor..-IIW..tw~ ""' ~"'' ""'~-~~~~~ H<qjiA ............... "*'....,..I'InYnto ~~-d\a.,___ ... .,.,.,.._r........ Widl-.. __ - MUI<I._..,_--~·~· .... ~.lo -·__.._....~ .. !lot !leaol, of y.,. lllllllit-~IOW'.,.......W.ku'/1 ..... :ru. ...... a-"tl'r.>-- ......... ....._ ............. Ia. ~ ..... ..._ ... rr.....o.m..ru. ~uruaa---•~-Uol .. ....,,.....ltol __ ~"""'"' "" ._,l, .. .._,.... .......... .,...,.r~- ...,.-.11).,.."'*•--•- ....,.., Nbo,.. b•*'""__ ....... _..,_..___ .. "- -.._ ............. III~Y- Onll'lllllloo-l--l'llo-U... ---~·ltl!mll.olil.ll'ot.. ""0 l!lo.......... IMII ...... kll~• ~1* ... .......,_ _.._ c ~-w-•llr«'llll._ __ .,..., _.,..,.._._~,.~. ro ... --~, ..... --... .... 'lllllt.,-n...Mra.l.,.. .. ---~-"" ..o~- ..... ____ __"-1 .. ..... ·- __ ,.....tlloll_ Q) ... ... ll>lh,.,.,...., hl'bAof_..,. - """""'~ .. ~ ..----- .0 .. ... ........,, ,..... ~ ...... .,,........ .,.,.._ ---~lillll ,.. __ .... .,.. .. ~ ... ....., .2 ... ~.x- .......-~-~--~ .,._...-~c--.~ (.:J ~...::=-~.::.-- ..... Q) ftPio<>lollltMlklt _,. ........--.-11- ··-..........· ....... ..r £ It- --~ ~- 1- Of Crime • • • and Nee-liberalism Michael Valpy, once the Toronto even m its own terms. Thus we day South African society, "Crime" Globe and Mail's correspondent in find , to take merely one example, with, precisely, a capital "C." Crime Africa, t has written recently in the ANC as liberation movement became, in fact, the very heart of the that same new&paper of his return blandly presented as being in some darkness that Valpy seemed content visit to South Africa earlier this way as responsible for the culture to place at the centre of his portrait year. His central piece, granted of crime and violence perceived by of the country. a remarkable three full pages at Valpy as has been the ex-apartheid True, Valpy did make some the front of the "Focus" section state or Chief Buthelezi's dreaded reference in his mega-article to the m the Saturday edition of May Inkatha movement! stark inequalities of wealth and 17, was an all too sensationalist social condition that are present presentation of the crime problem Yet such is the saliency, as day South Africa's chief inheritance that he encountered there - not least "Canada's national newspaper," of from its past as a grimly racist in the conversation of middle class the Globe and Mail in "informed society and as an almost-parodically friends with whom, as Valpy informs circles" that, for a week or two, exploitative capitalist one. In these us at some length, he dined. The everybody with whom one spoke was inequalities lie, self-evidently, the account was bumptious, misleading suddenly an expert on South Africa roots of the cnme problem that ... and what they knew about was does indeed stalk South Africa t On his previous sojourn in southern Crime. Not "how much crime?" today even if the "culture of Africa see "The Education of Michael really, not even "why crime?" but violence" which has also been Valpy" and "Valpy on Valpy," SAR, 3 , rather, as if it defined some kind of carried over from that past also has no. 5 (1988). almost existential essence of present- a complementary role to play. Southern Africa REPORT s ept ember 1997 1 But what to do about these And yet not for Valpy the possi Steve Greenberg and Samuel Bonti inequalities? Is it merely because bility that a very different kind of Ankomah, of a range of menacing members of the SAR editorial "macroeconomic policy," one based developments on the land right collective dine with different folks not on supply-side calculations but across the southern African region. when we visit South Africa that on the democratically-willed direc discussion of such inequalities seems tion of productive activities towards There is room, to be sure, for to be more prominent conversational the meeting of such social needs, further debate about the costs and fare than is the C-word fixation might be far more worthy of a benefits (and indeed the very feasi encountered by Valpy - and to be high mark