DOCSLIB.ORG

Finance Committee Chair's Action

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Finance Committee Chair's Action Finance Committee – Chair’s Action Date: 12 November 2019 Item: Taxi Fares and Tariffs Update This paper will be published with the papers for the next meeting of the Finance Committee 1 Summary 1.1 The purpose of this paper is to update the Committee on the annual taxi fares and tariffs review and invite it to approve the recommended changes as described in Section 2 below. 1.2 The use of Chair’s Action is considered appropriate as taxi fares and tariffs are normally updated annually in April and any approved changes to fares and tariffs take around six weeks to implement to allow for the taximeter companies to create their taximeter updates, for these to be tested and verified and for arrangements to roll out the update across the taxi fleet to be put in place. A decision is considered to be an urgent matter as delaying the changes to taxi fares and tariffs impacts on the income of taxi drivers, notably during the forthcoming Christmas period. 1.3 The members of the Committee are asked to consider the proposal and provide Ron Kalifa OBE, as Chair, with their views on or before 5.00pm on 14 November 2019. This paper and the Chair’s decision will be reported to the next meeting of the Committee. 2 Recommendations 2.1 The Chair of the Committee (in consultation with its members) is asked to note the paper and: (a) approve increasing the minimum fare from £3.00 to £3.20; (b) approve increasing Tariffs 1 and 2 by 1.9 per cent; (c) approve freezing Tariffs 3 and 4; (d) approve extending the fuel charge arrangements for a further year; (e) approve a change to when Tariff 4 starts so that the distance at which it starts is linked to the distance units for Tariffs 1, 2 and 3; and (f) note that the changes will be implemented by Officers in accordance with TfL’s Standing Orders. 3 Background 3.1 Taxi and private hire services in London are licensed and regulated by TfL. The Licensing, Regulation and Charging Directorate within TfL has day to day responsibility for the delivery of taxi and private hire licensing services. 3.2 We license London taxis (black cabs/hackney carriages) and taxi drivers under the Metropolitan Public Carriage Act 1869. Section 9 of this Act allows us to make regulations which fix the rates or fares to be paid for taxis. The London Cab and Stage Carriage Act 1907 allows us to make regulations to fix the fares to be paid for the hire of taxis fitted with taximeters, on the basis of time or distance or both. The London Cab Order 1934 (as amended), made under these Acts, sets the fares regime that covers most taxi journeys in London. 3.3 Taxi fares are calculated using a taximeter and the meter shows the maximum fare that can be charged at the end of a journey. The fare is based upon the time of day, distance travelled and time taken. Once a journey reaches around six miles, a different tariff rate (sometimes called Tariff 4) applies. 3.4 There are four different taxi tariffs and the times at which these apply plus the current distance and time rates for each tariff are shown below: Tariff 1 Tariff 2 Tariff 3 Tariff 4 Days and Monday to Monday to Friday, Every night For journeys times Friday, 20:00-22:00 and 22:00-05:00 and over six applicable 05:00-20:00 Saturday and Sunday, public holidays miles 05:00-22:00 Minimum fare £3.00 £3.00 £3.00 N/A Distance unit 116.6 94.8 81.2 86.9 (metres) Rate per mile £2.76 £3.40 £3.96 £3.70 Time unit 25.1 20.4 17.5 18.7 (seconds) Rate per hour £28.69 £35.29 £41.14 £38.50 Taxi fare unit 20 pence 20 pence 20 pence 20 pence 3.5 The fare payable increases by 20 pence for each unit of distance travelled or period of time that has passed during the applicable tariff. For example, Tariff 1 will apply to a journey undertaken at 10:00 on a Monday and the fare will increase by 20 pence for each 116.6 metres travelled or every 25.1 seconds. 4 Reviewing taxi fares and tariffs 4.1 When considering proposed changes to taxi fares and tariffs, we try to strike an appropriate balance between drivers being fairly remunerated and taxi users getting fair, reasonable and affordable fares. 4.2 To help us achieve this we: (a) use the Cost Index (see Section 5 below) to inform any potential changes to taxi fares and tariffs, but at the same time we do not automatically increase or decrease fares or tariff rates by the total Cost Index figure; (b) consider changes to the costs of being a taxi driver in London along with the need for fares to be fair, reasonable and affordable for users; (c) take into account the need to maintain reasonable and justifiable differences in the tariffs for journeys in the daytime, evening/weekend and late at night or on public holidays; (d) take into account the need to maintain reasonable and justifiable differences in fares as the distance and duration of a taxi journey increases; (e) recognise specific criteria regarding taxi licensing and services in London including the Knowledge of London and taxi vehicles having to meet the standards set out in the Conditions of Fitness; (f) have regard to the impact of changes to fares and tariffs on those sharing characteristics protected under the Equality Act 2010 including those who may use taxis more frequently or place greater reliance on them compared to others; and (g) consider the costs of other modes of passenger transport and the competitiveness of taxi fares. 5 Cost Index 5.1 The Cost Index is maintained and updated by TfL and it provides a way to track changes to: (a) the costs related to being a taxi driver; and (b) average national earnings. 5.2 Different components for the costs related to being a taxi driver (e.g. vehicle costs, parts, tyres, servicing, fuel and insurance) are updated when we review taxi fares and tariffs, and update the Cost Index. 5.3 The Cost Index, and the total figure produced when this is updated, is independent of taxi fares and tariffs. The Cost Index provides us with a way to track changes to the costs associated with being a taxi driver and average national earnings and changes that occur over time. However, there is no obligation for TfL to increase or decrease taxi fares by the Cost Index figure nor to apply this figure directly when considering changes to taxi fares and tariffs. 5.4 The Cost Index was updated in November 2018 and the total Cost Index figure was +3.4 per cent. This figure was used when developing the proposals for consultation for the minimum fare and Tariffs 1, 2, 3 and 4. 5.5 For several years, average fares across Tariffs 1, 2 and 3 were increased by the total Cost Index figure generated when the Cost Index was updated. We consider that the historic use of the total Cost Index figure in this way has contributed to a perception amongst some users that taxi fares are too expensive, especially late at night and for long journeys. 5.6 However, the Cost Index still continues to provide us with a valuable way to track changes to the operating costs associated with being a taxi driver and average national earnings. Although we did not propose increasing taxi fares by the current Cost Index figure (+3.4%), the proposals we consulted on (see Section 6 below) were still informed by this figure. 5.7 Full details of the Cost Index components and change in each component was published as part of the consultation1. 5.8 The Cost Index already includes costs for diesel taxis and diesel but does not currently include costs for the zero emission capable (ZEC) taxis nor charging. Now that there is a significant number of ZEC taxis licensed, these costs will be added to the existing Cost Index components when the Cost Index is next updated. 5.9 We did not propose any changes to the Cost Index but did invite views on this and whether respondents thought changes should be made. A summary of the responses is set out in Section 13 below. 6 Taxi fares and tariffs consultation 2019 Consultation material 6.1 The 2019 taxi fares and tariffs consultation launched on 12 July 2019 and closed on 23 August 2019. The following documents were published on the TfL consultation webpage2: (a) background information about taxi fares and tariffs and taxi driver licensing plus details of the changes to taxi fares and tariffs approved by the Committee in 2018; (b) details of the Cost Index components; (c) results from research which included questions asking what taxi users and taxi drivers think about taxi fares; 1 Cost Index components, https://consultations.tfl.gov.uk/taxis/fares- 2019/supporting_documents/costindexcomponents.pdf 2 Taxi fares review 2019 consultation, https://consultations.tfl.gov.uk/taxis/fares-2019/ (d) information about previous changes to fares and tariffs, options considered and examples of fares for other modes of transport; (e) recent diesel prices; (f) current and proposed fixed fares from Euston station for sharing services; and (g) impact assessments for the consultation proposals. Consultation proposals 6.2 We proposed the following: Area Days and times applicable Proposal Increase by 20 pence Minimum At all times (6.7 per cent) taking fare this from £3.00 to £3.20 Increase by 1.9 per Tariff 1 Monday to Friday, 05:00-20:00 cent Monday to Friday, 20:00-22:00 and Increase by 1.9 per Tariff 2 Saturday and Sunday, 05:00-22:00 cent Tariff 3 Every night 22:00-05:00 and public holidays Freeze Tariff 4 For journeys over six miles Freeze tariff rates 6.3 The minimum fare and tariff proposals were developed as one single package of proposals, which was informed by the total Cost Index figure of +3.4 per cent.
Load more

Recommended publications
  • EUR 34.149 Aangeboden Door: GBP 29.950
    Exposé of vehicle-ID: 95842 www.classic-trader.com/ad/95842 Austin FX 3 London Taxi (1955) EUR 34.149 Aangeboden door: GBP 29.950 Beschrijving Comments A Hire Car version, the FL1 was also made, which had four full doors, a bench front seat, column gear-change and an umbrella-type handbrake handle. The two occasional seats faced forward. A 'driveaway' chassis-cab was also supplied to outside coachbuilders. Several shooting brake ('woodie') bodies were made, as well as newspaper vans for the three London evening papers, the Star, News and Standard. Built in 1955, this FLI was professionally restored and converted to a Shooting Car, by specialist trimmer Northumbrian Leather of Newcastle on Tyne, based on the FL1 the shooting car has received a full restoration, and a period of recent recommissioning in our workshops. Interior Fully restored in the style of an Estate / Shooting Car, the interior being trimmed in Ostrich skin and buffalo hide, with contrasting tartan interior, History The Austin FX3 is a taxicab that was sold in the United Kingdom by Austin from 1948 to 1958. It was designed to comply with the Metropolitan Police Conditions of Fitness for London taxicabs, but was used in other towns and cities in the UK. It was commissioned from Austin by taxi dealers Mann & Overton and built by Carbodies of Coventry on a chassis supplied by Austin. The first prototype, the FX had a 1.8-litre sidevalve engine that proved inadequate for the job. The second prototype, the FX2 had a 1.8-litre petrol engine, but this was replaced by the third version, the FX3, which had a 2.2-litre ohv petrol engine.
    [Show full text]
  • Onroute-Issue-4.Pdf
    ISSUE 4 / APRIL-MAY 2016 Brought to you by Transport for London Above and beyond for charity Identity Uptown All DBS parade: top ranking: a-Twitter: update: wear your badge/ out with the FAQs from the cutting the DBS photo ID with pride night taxi marshals TPH Twitter feed check backlog CONTENTS 3 Welcome. As spring hits the city we are celebrating Contents the wonderful contribution taxi and private hire make to life in London. Friday and Saturday nights in the Capital are usually busy times for the trades. With so many people out and 8 18 about enjoying themselves the taxi marshals on our late night ranks do You wear it well Checking up a great job getting everyone home safely. Find out what a typical night Wear your badge or Helping the DBS process is like for them on p16. photo ID with pride to go smoothly Not only do drivers provide an essential service for the Capital, but many are also doing great things for good causes – from putting smiles on London’s taxis are seen as the gold 11 20 sick children’s faces, to feeding the Celebrating The full force of the law homeless. On p11 we celebrate some of standard across the world. They are a charity heroes the charity heroes who have gone above We talk to Anand and beyond to help communities. vital part of our transport system and We meet the drivers Nandha, the new head Wearing your badge or photo ID going that extra of compliance at TPH reassures the public that you are play an essential role in keeping London mile for those in need legitimate and shows them the pride you have in your trade.
    [Show full text]
  • Call Sign JAN 13
    3 1 0 2 y r a u n a J Call Sign asks drivers the unaskable… Should we dump the Conditions of Fitness??? Call Sign January 2013 Page 2 NASH’S NUMBERS From Alan Nash (A95) Need to know where the work is? New Eurostar timetable operates from 9 December to 1 June 2013 Note 1 Runs 09/12/2012 till 05/01/2013 and from 10/02/2013 till 01/06/2013 Note 2 Runs 31/03/2013 till 01/06/2013 Nash's Numbers would like to wish you all a very merry Christmas and a prosperous New Year. Don' t forget to visit www.nashsnumbers.co.uk which not only has all the back issues but direct access to the MyFav website designed as your ideal "Home Page", combine this with the unlock code of taxi and this will be your best launch pad to everything you will ever need on the internet. Personalise with your favourite search engine, retailer, gadgets, your own bookmarks and 100’s of icons to launch all the most popular websites. Call Sign January 2013 Page 3 from the editor’s desk Well, that’s the first part of the holidays fin - leaving your driver a tip easy and optional. ished and we are just days away from the The Hailo Fee in Chicago is as follows. Non-Peak annual fight for fares. But if I’ve learned one Fee $1.50 with the Peak Fee (6-10am and 3-6pm, thing in my almost 42 years in this business, it Mon-Fri) $2.75.
    [Show full text]
  • November Badge:July Badge.Qxd.Qxd
    The voice of the taxi trade’s only independent organisation Issue 204 November 2012 INSIDE DELOITTES INVESTIGATES LT&PH DRIVERS PAGE 2 IN LIMBO NEWS AIRPORT MATTERS PAGE 13 Manganese Bronze go NEWS into administration. What next? LIVES AT RISK ON FULL STORY ON PAGES 4&5 EURO DISNEY TRIP PAGE 14 2 Issue 204 - November 2012 Deloittes To Undertake A Top To Bottom Review Of LT&PH Published by EXCLUSIVE The London Cab Driver’s Club Ltd. After John Griffin Complains To TFL Unit A 303.2, Tower Bridge Business Complex Tower Point, 100 Clements Road The LCDC were shocked to learn that Southwark, London SE16 4DG after a letter of complaint sent by Mr John Griffin of Addison Lee to The Telephone: 020 7232 0676 Mayor Of London about his deep E-mail for membership enquiries: dissatisfaction with John Mason and E-mail: [email protected] the Directorate at LT&PH. Web: lcdcorg.wordpress.com As a result of this letter Leon Daniels of TFL has now commissioned Deloittes Editor: Grant Davis to undertake a full top to bottom review of the Directorate of LT&PH. The letter The Badge is distributed free to the Licenced London Cab Trade. from Mr Griffin expressed his deep dissatisfaction with the way LT&PH For advertising enquiries please contact the office on were treating the Private Hire in the Leon Daniels - TFL 020 7394 5553 or E-mail: [email protected] Capital, and that not enough is being All advertising in The Badge is accepted under done to support their wishes.
    [Show full text]
  • Ceredigion County Council's Response To: the Law
    CEREDIGION COUNTY COUNCIL’S RESPONSE TO: THE LAW COMMISSION - REFORMING THE LAW OF TAXI AND PRIVATE HIRE SERVICES Background In July 2011 the Law Commission agreed to undertake a law reform project on the law of taxis and Private Hire Vehicles (PHVs). The Department for Transport (DfT) proposed the project, but in such cases the Law Commission is independent of Government. Consultation On 10 May 2012 the Law Commission published its provisional proposals along with associated Questions. All parties have until 10 August 2012 to submit responses. Proposals and Questions What follows is a summary of the Law Commission’s proposals. Proposed future action The Law Commission intends that its consultation will be its main information- gathering exercise. After the consultation, the Commission will analyse responses and reconsider this document’s proposals. The Commission aims to produce a report containing its final proposals and a draft Bill by November 2013. PROVISIONAL PROPOSAL 1 Regulation should continue to distinguish between taxis, which can accept pre-booked fares, be hailed on the street and wait at ranks, and PHVs, which can only accept pre-booked fares. This, in effect, represents the retention of the current, “two-tier” system. The main alternative would be a one-tier system in which a single category of vehicle would be able to take pre-bookings, to hail and to rank. A one-tier system would be simpler because it would avoid the distinction between regulation of taxis and PHVs. However, the Law Commission’s view is that it would require additional regulatory distinctions to be devised to accommodate the different range of services regulated.
    [Show full text]
  • The Role of LS-DYNA® in the Design of the New London Electric Taxi
    15th International LS-DYNA® Users Conference Automotive The Role of LS-DYNA® in the Design of the New London Electric Taxi Jamie Dennis1, Simon Hart1 1Arup (Advanced Technology and Research), Solihull, UK Abstract The iconic London taxi is known worldwide. The London Taxi Company (LTC) has produced this much loved vehicle for many years with few radical changes. Recently, zero-emission legislation in London and the global demand for cleaner vehicles has prompted an evolution in its design. With investment from owner Geely, the newly branded London EV Company (LEVC) will produce several thousand electric taxis per year from its new headquarters in Coventry, UK. The designers, Emerald Automotive Design (EAD), engaged Arup to analyse all structural and safety load cases. This paper discusses how the versatility of LS-DYNA and the modularity of the keyword file enabled Arup to use a single-model approach for all analysis - from full vehicle crashworthiness through to component- level durability checks - and how this facilitated an efficient division of activity between remote teams in the UK and China. The application of both explicit and implicit LS-DYNA to the various load cases is considered, together with the correlation against physical testing. Special challenges were posed by the requirement to comply with Transport for London’s (TfL) Conditions of Fitness and the need to protect the high-voltage components. Reliance on the LS-DYNA predictions was high, with few prototype stages afforded by the accelerated programme. Successful progression directly from simulation to legislative testing sign-off was achieved for cases including pedestrian protection. Arup’s use of LS-DYNA was key in bringing this lightweight bonded aluminium taxi to market, whilst minimising energy consumption and delivering a solution to the issue of sustainable city transport.
    [Show full text]
  • The Low Emission Taxi Guide
    The Low Emission Taxi Guide Helping Local Authorities implement low emission taxi and private hire vehicle schemes This report is published by the Low Carbon Vehicle Partnership and Energy Saving Trust Low Carbon Vehicle Partnership 3 Birdcage Walk, London, SW1H 9JJ Tel: +44 (0)20 7304 6880 Energy Saving Trust 30 North Colonnade London E14 5GP Tel: 020 7222 0101 Project Team: Gloria Esposito LowCVP, Maria Siakovelli and Ian Featherstone EST Date of Report: 1st September 2018 Acknowledgments The production of the Low Emission Taxi Guide has been sponsored by the Department for Transport and Autogas Limited. 4 The Low Emission Taxi Guide The Low Emission Taxi Guide 5 Contents 1 1 Introduction 6 1.1 What does this guide cover? 6 1.2 Impacts of TPH vehicles on road transport emissions 6 1.3 Defining low and ultra-low emission TPH vehicles 7 1.3 Why adopt low emission TPH vehicles? 7 1.4 The taxi and private hire market and fleet profile 8 1.5 An overview of taxi and private hire licensing 9 2 2 National measures to reduce road transport emissions 10 2.1 Air quality 10 2.2 Climate change 12 2.3 Government grants and incentives for low emission vehicles 12 3 3 Best practice guidance for local authorities 16 3.1 What to consider before making any policy changes 16 3.2 Local policy measures and initiatives 16 3.3 Policy case studies 19 3.4 Guidance for installation of EV charging infrastructure 22 4 4 Technology chapters 26 4.1 Battery electric taxi and private hire vehicles 26 4.2 Extended range and plug-in hybrid taxi and private hire vehicles
    [Show full text]
  • Call Sign Feb 10:Call Sign Feb 10
    February 2010 WhyWhy isis thisthis DaCDaC dispatcherdispatcher onon thethe frontfront cover?cover? AA clue?…clue?… NotNot justjust becausebecause she’sshe’s gorgeous!gorgeous! WhatWhat hashas DaC’sDaC’s SidSid NathanNathan gotgot againstagainst thisthis bus?bus? Call Sign February 2010 Page 2 NASH’S NUMBERS From Alan Nash (A95) London City Airport ‘Arrivals’ timetable, somewhat cramped but all flights are on one page. For a larger format - including flight numbers and originating airports - sign up for the UID. Simply go to www.nashsnumbers.co.uk and click on “Free 70+ page info.” For the What’s On guide, go to www.nashsnumbers.co.uk and just click on What’s On... Call Sign February 2010 Page 3 from the editor’s desk Camberwell Road. He seems like a responsible Views of the police? businessman, a nice guy and I’m sure that he I recently had a very interesting chat about pri- would be just as annoyed at his drivers
    [Show full text]
  • Response to Law Co Taxi and Private Hi
    Response to Law Commission's Consultation on Taxi and Private Hire Services London Taxi Branch National Union of Rail, Maritime and Transport Workers September 2012 1 Table of Contents 1LIST OF ACRONYMS ...................................................................................................................... 4 2GLOSSARY OF TERMS .................................................................................................................. 4 3INTRODUCTION ............................................................................................................................. 5 4OVERVIEW OF PROVISIONAL REFORM PROPOSALS .............................................................. 6 Proposal 1. Regulation should distinguish between taxis & PHV's .................................................... Vehicle Distinction & Colour ............................................................................................................... 6 Vehicle Distinction & London Conditions of Fitness ........................................................................... 7 Vehicle Identification ........................................................................................................................... 8 Legislation v TfL Satellite Office Policy ............................................................................................... 8 Legislation v TfL Private Hire Ranks Policy ...................................................................................... 10 Legislation v TfL Terminology ..........................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Call Sign July 08
    Call Sign July 2008 Page 2 NASH’S NUMBERS By Alan Nash (A95) Continuing with nightclubs – this month N to R. Some are really just pubs but list themselves as nightclubs. Postcodes for SatNavs included. Concludes next month… “What’s On” at O2, ExCel, Olympia and Earls Court For lots more information, email [email protected] with subject as ‘UID’ with the body of the text containing just your name, email address, callsign, badge number and contact telephone number (only used if email address is rejected) for a free - yes free - link to over 50 pages of printable, every day useful information. Don’t delay… do it now! Call Sign July 2008 Page 3 from the editor’s desk Back again… mile and it was filled with limousines of all It’s nice to be back after my month off and to shapes, sizes and indeed lengths. begin my twelfth year in the Call Sign hot It’s fair to say that the number of taxis in that seat! But I have to say that it does seem to be queue was minimal compared to the car num- ever-harder getting back into the swing of bers – although it’s probably equally fair to things – this year more than most after spend- also say that there were very few people car- ing time in magnificent Snowdonia with prob- riers either. ably the best weather the UK had seen this As we inched forward towards the house, we year. watched the posh equivalent of street enter- Returning also has its problems in that there tainers designed to keep us amused.
    [Show full text]
  • Hackney Carriage and Private Hire Handbook Index
    Swindon Borough Council Hackney Carriage & Private Hire Handbook ¯¯¯¯¯¯¯ March 2017 Delivery Services Wat Tyler House Beckhampton Street Swindon SN1 2JH HACKNEY CARRIAGE AND PRIVATE HIRE HANDBOOK INDEX Page General Matters 1 Drivers Guide for Applicants for Hackney Carriage and Private Hire Drivers Licence 3 Special Licensing Arrangements for Drivers working solely for Chauffeur Companies or solely engaged on Education Transport Contracts 7 Determining your Application 8 Disclosure and Barring Service-A Guide to completing the DBS form 10 Standards to be met by licence applicants 12 Driving Assessments 13 Knowledge Test procedure 14 Guidelines relating to the Relevance of Convictions 15 Conditions applying to Hackney Carriage (Driver) Licences 18 Hackney Carriage Byelaws 21 Conditions applying to Private Hire (Driver) Licences 25 Vehicles Hackney Carriage Vehicle Licensing 29 Conditions applying to Hackney Carriage (Vehicle) Licences 30 Advertising on Hackney Carriages 34 Hackney Carriage Vehicle Signage 34 Conditions Applying to Hackney Carriage licences first issued prior to May 1989 35 Private Hire Vehicle Licensing 37 Private Hire Vehicle Conditions of Licence 38 Vehicle Fitness Spot Checks 45 Operators Procedure for Applicants for Private Hire Operators Licence 46 Notes for Guidance of Applicants for Private Hire Operators Licence 47 Private Hire Operator Licence Conditions 49 The Law relating to Private Hire vehicles 53 Applicants for an Operator or Driver Licence who declare a conviction involving dishonesty, indecency, violence or disqualification from driving 58 Complaints Procedure 59 Hackney Carriage and Private Hire Code of Conduct 61 Private Hire Queries Answered 62 Hackney Carriage Fares 63 Annual Licence Fees 64 Location of Taxi Ranks 65 Disability Awareness 66 Child Sexual Exploitation (CSE) 70 GENERAL MATTERS Introduction Section 38 of the Town Police Clauses Act 1847, defines a Hackney Carriage as "Every wheeled carriage, whatever its form or construction, used in standing or plying for hire in any street ......".
    [Show full text]
  • Judgment Lord Justice Floyd
    Case No: A3/2016/0867 Neutral Citation Number: [2017] EWCA Civ 1729 IN THE COURT OF APPEAL (CIVIL DIVISION) ON APPEAL FROM THE HIGH COURT OF JUSTICE CHANCERY DIVISION MR JUSTICE ARNOLD [2016] EWHC 52 (Ch) Royal Courts of Justice Strand, London, WC2A 2LL Date: 01/11/2017 Before: LORD JUSTICE KITCHIN and LORD JUSTICE FLOYD - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - Between : THE LONDON TAXI CORPORATION LIMITED Appellant trading as THE LONDON TAXI COMPANY - and - (1) FRAZER-NASH RESEARCH LIMITED Respondents (2) ECOTIVE LIMITED - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - Douglas Campbell QC (instructed by Browne Jacobson LLP) for the Appellant Mark Platts-Mills QC and Maxwell Keay (instructed by Berwin Leighton Paisner LLP) for the Respondents Hearing dates: 18th-20th July 2017 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - Judgment Lord Justice Floyd: 1. Is the shape of a London taxi a valid registered trade mark? The claimant and appellant The London Taxi Corporation Limited (“LTC”) contends that it can be. It further contends that the defendants and respondents Frazer-Nash Research Limited (“FNR”) and Ecotive Limited (“Ecotive”) threaten to infringe two of its registered trade marks (“the LTC marks”) which depict models of its taxis, by launching a new London taxi, the new Metrocab. After a trial, Arnold J held that both of the LTC marks were invalid on a number of grounds, and that one of them should be revoked for non-use. Further, even if the LTC marks had been valid, he held that they would not be infringed by the new Metrocab. He also dismissed a claim founded on the common law tort of passing off. LTC’s taxis 2. LTC is the successor in title to the manufacturer of the Fairway, TX1, TXII and TX4 models of London taxi and claims to be the owner of the goodwill in the shapes of all four models.
    [Show full text]