Flame Spread Behavior Characterization of Discrete Fuel Array Under a Forced Flow
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
ARTICLE IN PRESS JID: PROCI [mNS; July 28, 2020;20:40 ] Available online at www.sciencedirect.com Proceedings of the Combustion Institute 000 (2020) 1–9 www.elsevier.com/locate/proci Flame spread behavior characterization of discrete fuel array under a forced flow a b c Giovanni Di Cristina , Nicholas S. Skowronski , Albert Simeoni , c a, d , ∗ Ali S. Rangwala , Seong-kyun Im a Department of Aerospace and Mechanical Engineering, University of Notre Dame, Notre Dame, IN, United States b USDA Forest Service, Northern Research Station, Morgantown, WV, United States c Department of Fire Protection Engineering, Worcester Polytechnic Institute, Worcester, MA, United States d Department of Mechanical Engineering, Korea University, Seoul, Republic of Korea Received 8 November 2019; accepted 29 May 2020 Available online xxx Abstract The forced flow driven flame spread behavior along an array of discrete wooden fuel elements was ex- perimentally investigated, which could be an important step to understanding the flow-flame interactions that govern fire spread. Fuel arrays with five different spacings (0.75, 0.875. 1.00, 1.125, and 1.25 cm) were subject to flow speeds ranging from 2.2 to 4.3 m/s at approximately 0.2 m/s intervals. For spacing-flow speed conditions tested in the current study, the flame spread behavior was categorized into three different regimes, continuous, discrete, and quenching, and the regimes were presented in a flammability map. Visual analysis of top and side view video data were used to describe the changing flame behavior and increasing discretiza- tion of the overall flame structure as the flow speed increases. An analysis of the fluid mechanics and heat transfer conditions revealed a correlation between the Stanton number ( St ), the Damkohler number ( Da ), and the onset of flame instabilities and quenching. © 2020 Published by Elsevier Inc. on behalf of The Combustion Institute. Keywords: Flame spread; Quenching; Wood combustion; Flow-flame interaction; Wind-driven fire 1. Introduction Small-sized wooden sticks or dowels have been used to represent the initiation and early buildup of a forest fire, where the first vegetation involving ∗ Corresponding author at: Professor Seong-kyun Im, initial ignition processes are the small leaves, pine Department of Mechanical Engineering, Korea Univer- needles, and branches. Early fire spread research sity, 319 Innovation Hall, 145 Anam-ro Seongbuk-gu, by Fons [1] and Emmons [2 , 3] modeled the con- Seoul 02841, Republic of Korea. secutive ignitions of fuel elements in arrays and E-mail addresses: [email protected] , [email protected] simple fuel beds to represent non-homogeneous (S.-k. Im). forest fuel beds. Since then, researchers have used https://doi.org/10.1016/j.proci.2020.05.035 1540-7489 © 2020 Published by Elsevier Inc. on behalf of The Combustion Institute. Please cite this article as: G.D. Cristina, N.S. Skowronski and A. Simeoni et al., Flame spread behavior characterization of discrete fuel array under a forced flow, Proceedings of the Combustion Institute, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.proci.2020. 05.035 ARTICLE IN PRESS JID: PROCI [mNS; July 28, 2020;20:40 ] 2 G.D. Cristina, N.S. Skowronski and A. Simeoni et al. / Proceedings of the Combustion Institute xxx (xxxx) xxx arrays or fuel beds of wooden sticks, paper strips, flow. For example, in an array of dowels, the igni- cardboard or other simple fuels to simplify the tion of the dowel at position n will depend on the study of complex fire scenarios [1 , 3–12] . flame heat transfer of upstream dowels at positions Vogel and Williams [4] examined the spread ( n-1, n-2 , etc.) that further depend on the upward along square dowels mounted on a plate at different and downward spread rates on each dowel based spacing conditions and found that the spread can on the flow velocity, separation distance, and mate- be accurately approximated using a 1-dimensional rial properties. The problem is further complicated conduction model. Prahl and Tien [5] expanded on by the flame-flow instabilities triggered at certain the work of Vogel and Williams [4] by subjecting flow speed-array spacing conditions. The ability to a similar setup to convective flows of up to 0.9 m/s. predict the onset of such flame instabilities due to While Prahl and Tien [5] predicted the spread rate convective conditions could be the first step in ex- of their wind-driven experiments, they could not tending the accuracy of flame spread models. accurately predict the onset of no propagation for the higher wind speed conditions. Beer [11] de- veloped a purely geometric model for fire spread 2. Experimental setup of arrays subject to flow or slope by using similar assumptions from Vogel and Williams [4] . In Beer’s Wooden dowels with a diameter (d) of 3.2 mm model, the flow (or slope) only serves to tilt the and a length of 14 cm were arranged into in-line flame but does not account for other effects of the arrays. Mounting plates with drilled holes at the flow, such as quenching from high wind speeds. desired spacings were manufactured, and the Although the previous works have demon- dowels were press-fit to the holes. The mounting strated predictions and modeling of fire spread plate was then placed in a small wind tunnel with behaviors under a flow with a relatively low speed a test section that has a cross-sectional area of (below 1.5 m/s), studies for the fire spread behaviors 15.25 cm by 15.24 cm and length of 81.28 cm, as were relatively rare for the flow conditions above schematically illustrated in Fig. 1 a. Flow condi- 1.5 m/s, where the buoyancy effects on the flame tioning screens were utilized to achieve a uniform are still comparable to the effects of momentum flow profile across the height of the wind tunnel from the imposed flow. Furthermore, it has been and minimize fluctuations to less than 5% of the reported that fire spread around the 2.5 mm diam- mean flow. A pilot ignition using a small cotton eter scale becomes unsteady and highly variable wick soaked in 0.1 ml of dodecane initiated the at relatively high flow speeds (around 3 m/s) [13] . fire 1 cm ahead of the first dowel as shown in The propagation and flame behavior changes at Fig. 1 b. The pilot was ignited after turning the flow extinction conditions in fuel arrays have not been on in order to avoid flow unsteadiness from the fan studied previously. Studies for unsteady flames startup. Because the pilot ignition could affect the near extinction have been conducted for single flame propagation, the ignition method was kept cylinders [14] and tandem spheres [15] but not consistent for all experiments. for cylinder arrays. Extensive studies on fluid Flame propagation was measured with two mechanics of single cylinders, tandem cylinders cameras, a GoPro camera facing the dowel array [16–18] , and cylinder arrays and banks [19 , 20] and a Sony DSCIII facing downward. The side inform how the convective flow may interact with camera visualized the flame propagation behavior the cylinders. Such interactions alter the convective while the downward-facing camera captured the heat transfer depending on the separation distance flame wake. The flame propagation behavior was and flow speed. For a reacting flow, the flame-flow studied for 5 spacings ( s = 0.75, 0.875, 1.00, 1.125, coupling can cause unique flame dynamics and and 1.25 cm) under freestream flows of 2.2 to spread behaviors. Finney et al. [21] suggested that 4.3 m/s at approximately 0.2 m/s increments. The unsteady flame convection is strongly dictated by smallest spacing (0.75 cm) was selected based on buoyant and inertial interaction, and the find- the flame size without wind, at which the flame ings could contribute to advancing physics-based barely touches the next dowel. The buoyancy modeling. currents exit the test section before they impact The current study seeks to provide further dis- the ceiling with the flow speeds chosen in the cussion on the flame-flow coupling, arguing that current study, minimizing ceiling effects. For each the common assumptions of continuous increase in spacing-velocity combination, the experiments flame contact or convective heat transfer with an in- were repeated 3 times. In addition to the flame creasing freestream flow speed should be adjusted spread experiments, a hot-wire anemometer was if the flow and fuel setting lead to discretized flame utilized to measure the mean flow speed and tur- behavior. The flame-spread behavior of discrete bulent intensity behind dowel 5 of the array in cold solid fuels was characterized at flow speeds above flows. Measurements were taken approximately 2 m/s for multiple spacing conditions. The system- 6 cm above the base of the tunnel at the centerline atic classification and corresponding analysis of the of the cylinder longitudinal axis. Flow data was flow conditions are used to generate a flammability collected at a half-spacing distance away from map for flame spread on discrete fuels under forced dowel 5 at all spacing conditions. Please cite this article as: G.D. Cristina, N.S. Skowronski and A. Simeoni et al., Flame spread behavior characterization of discrete fuel array under a forced flow, Proceedings of the Combustion Institute, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.proci.2020. 05.035 ARTICLE IN PRESS JID: PROCI [mNS; July 28, 2020;20:40 ] G.D. Cristina, N.S. Skowronski and A. Simeoni et al. / Proceedings of the Combustion Institute xxx (xxxx) xxx 3 3. Results 3.1. Flame propagation behavior characterization From the time the pilot is ignited, the very first dowel is in contact with the flame.