Submitter 297 Heritage Inc Provision Sub No/ Position Summary of Submission Decision Request Point No EW / Policies / EW-P4 297.43 Support The Policy EW-P4 (avoids adverse effects on archaeological sites and sites Retain Policy EW-P4 as notified. and areas of significance to Māori) is supported. HC / Strategic Objectives / 297.41 Support Supports Strategic Direction - Historic and Cultural Objective HC-1 Retain Strategic Direction - Historic and Cultural Objective HC-1 as notified. HC-1 (Heritage and cultural values contribute to the district's sense of place and identity and are recognised and protected) as they are appropriate and reasonable. HC / Strategic Objectives / 297.42 Support Supports Strategic Direction - Historic and Cultural Objective HC-2 Retain Strategic Direction - Historic and Cultural Objective HC-2 as notified. HC-2 (Cultural, spiritual and/or historical values associated with historic heritage) as they are appropriate and reasonable. HH / Objectives / HH-O1 297.1a Support Supports HH-O1 (historic heritage is recognised, protected and Retain HH-O1 as notified. maintained) because historic heritage deserves special protection and the objective is appropriate and reasonable. HH / Objectives / HH-O2 297.1b Support Supports HH-O2 (historic heritage is appreciated by the community and is Retain HH-O2 as notified. acknowledged as important to the district's identity) because historic heritage deserves special protection and the objective is appropriate and reasonable. HH / Objectives / HH-O3 297.1c Support Supports HH-O3 (heritage buildings are actively used and maintained) Retain HH-O3 as notified. because historic heritage deserves special protection and the objective is appropriate and reasonable. HH / Policies / HH-P1 297.2 Support Supports HH-P1 (identify, map and schedule significant heritage buildings Retain HH-P1 as notified. and items...) because it is appropriate and reasonable but considers that Note the submitter has also requested that NPDC list further heritage the number listed is too few and far from representative, the new listings buildings, items and archaeological sites, district wide. The submitter has are largely in the CBD, and the delisting of B's and C's increases the prepared more than 90 draft heritage assessments which they consider likelihood that they will be lost. should be treated as a representative sample of a much larger group of unprotected items deserving protection. These matters are addressed in SCHED1. HH / Policies / HH-P2 297.3a Support Supports HH-P2 (identify and map heritage character areas involving Retain HH-P2 as notified. groups of buildings, structures, spaces and other features that collectively have historic heritage values, cultural or social values and/or special Note the submitter has also requested that NPDC revisit the decision not qualities and contribute to the district's identity, character and sense of to schedule the 17 areas (4.1.3.2 Heritage Character Areas) outlined in the place) because it is appropriate and reasonable but considers that heritage Section 32 report and investigate including areas of contiguous character areas should not be limited to the CBD and the 17 previously archaeological sites, such as the Waitara battleground. These matters are recognised heritage character areas should be included as well as some addressed in SCHED1. new ones. HH / Policies / HH-P3 297.4 Support Supports HH-P3 (protect and maintain heritage buildings, items and Retain HH-P3 as notified. character areas from inappropriate activities…) because it is appropriate and reasonable. HH / Policies / HH-P4 297.5 Support in Supports HH-P4 (allow the following activities that involve heritage Retain HH-P4 as notified in conjunction with a review of the scheduled part buildings and items or that are within a heritage character area, provided character areas. they contribute to the long-term viability and retention or ongoing functional use of the building, item or area and do not compromise historic heritage values...) because it is generally appropriate and reasonable but

Submitter 297 Heritage Taranaki Inc │ 335 Provision Sub No/ Position Summary of Submission Decision Request Point No considers that the 17 previously recognised heritage character areas should be reviewed. HH / Policies / HH-P5 297.6 Support Supports HH-P5 (manage activities that occur on or in proximity to Retain HH-P5 as notified. heritage buildings and items which have the potential to adversely impact on the building's or item's historic heritage values) because it is appropriate and reasonable. HH / Policies / HH-P6 297.8 Support Supports HH-P6 (in addition to HH-P5, manage activities that occur within Retain HH-P6 as notified. a heritage character area…) because it is appropriate and reasonable.

HH / Policies / HH-P7 297.7 Support in Supports HH-P7 (avoid total or partial demolition or removal of heritage Retain HH-P7 as notified but clauses 1-3 should be adopted only following part buildings and items and specified interior elements...) but considers that: the establishment of a position on the council (such as a heritage officer) ● Allowing demolion on the grounds for significant public benefit that to ensure that appropriate consideration of heritage values are taken prior could not otherwise be achieved may be used without appropriate care. to demolition. ● NPDC does not employ qualified heritage professionals and there is no- one with suitable institutional knowledge that would guide the planning team in weighing the significant public benefit against the retention of the heritage building or item, or to what extent heritage fabric is damaged beyond repair and would require demolition.

HH / Policies / HH-P8 297.9 Support Supports HH-P8 (ensure that activities adjacent to or affecting heritage Retain HH-P8 as notified. buildings and items avoid adverse effects on the building's or item's historic heritage values…) because it is appropriate and reasonable. HH / Policies / HH-P9 297.11 Support Supports HH-P9 (ensure additions and alterations to heritage buildings and Retain HH-P9 as notified. items are appropriate…) because it is appropriate and reasonable.

HH / Policies / HH-P10 297.10 Support Supports HH-P10 (in addition to HH-P9 ensure that new buildings and/or Retain HH-P10 as notified. that additions and alterations to contributory buildings within a heritage character area are appropriately located and/or that the overall scale, form, composition and design of the structure is appropriate...) because it is appropriate and reasonable.

HH / Policies / HH-P11 297.12 Support Supports HH-P11 (support landowners to manage, maintain and preserve Retain HH-P11 as notified. However, the built heritage and natural heritage buildings, items and character areas by using one or more of the protection grant is woefully underfunded and should be significantly following methods…) because it is appropriate and reasonable. augmented to better provide assistance for owners in maintaining heritage buildings and caring for archaeological sites.

HH / Policies / HH-P12 297.16 Support Supports HH-P12 (map and schedule archaeological sites that have been Retain HH-P12 as notified. identified...) because it is appropriate and reasonable and applauds NPDC for including 31 pre 1900 buildings as archaeological sites but considers Note the submitter has requested that NPDC review the NZAA database, that more archaeological sites should be added. review the list of pre 1900 buildings list supplied by the submitter, make background information publicly accessible and consider scheduling significant archaeological assemblages. These matters are addressed in SCHED3.

Submitter 297 Heritage Taranaki Inc │ 336 Provision Sub No/ Position Summary of Submission Decision Request Point No HH / Policies / HH-P13 297.15 Support Supports HH-P13 (protect and maintain archaeological sites from Retain HH-P13 as notified. inappropriate activities…) because it is appropriate and reasonable.

HH / Policies / HH-P14 297.14 Support in Considers that clause 2 and 3 of HH-P14 (allow the following activities on Amend HH-P14 as follows: part or adjacent to an archaeological site provided they do not compromise the Allow the following activities on or adjacent to an archaeological site site's historic heritage values) should be clarified. The submitter questions provided they do not compromise the site's historic heritage values: what happens when the archaeological site IS a built archaeological 1. land disturbance; site/building and the alteration or demolition allowed in these clauses may 2. demolition or removal of existing buildings and structures, except where allow the site to be adversely affected or destroyed. the archaeological site is the building or structure; 3. alterations to existing buildings and structures, except where the archaeological site is the building or structure; 4. maintenance and repair or upgrading of existing network utility structures; and 5. erection of signs.

HH / Policies / HH-P15 297.19 Support Supports HH-P15 (manage activities that occur on or adjacent to scheduled Retain HH-P15 as notified. archaeological sites…) because it is appropriate and reasonable. HH / Policies / HH-P16 297.13 Support Supports HH-P16 (ensure that activities on, adjacent to or affecting Retain HH-P6 as notified. archaeological sites or on land where there is reasonable cause to suspect an archaeological site may exist avoid adverse effects on the site...) because it is appropriate and reasonable.

HH / Policies / HH-P17 297.17 Support Supports HH-P17 (ensure that any structure that exceeds permitted Retain HH-P17 as notified. structure height limits on or adjacent to an archaeological site is appropriately located…) because it is appropriate and reasonable. HH / Policies / HH-P18 297.18 Support Supports HH-P18 (support landowners to manage, maintain and preserve Retain HH-P18 as notified. archaeological sites by using one or more of the following methods…) because it is appropriate and reasonable. HH / Rules / HH-R1 297.20 Support Supports HH-R1 (maintenance and repair to the exterior of a scheduled Retain HH-R1 as notified [inferred]. heritage building or item and/or to any scheduled interior elements listed in SCHED2) because is it appropriate and reasonable. HH / Rules / HH-R2 297.21 Support Supports HH-R2 (erection of a structure on a site containing a scheduled Retain HH-R2 as notified [inferred]. heritage building or item) because it is appropriate and reasonable. HH / Rules / HH-R3 297.22 Support Supports HH-R3 (installation of an impervious surface … on a site Retain HH-R3 as notified [inferred]. containing a scheduled heritage building or item) because it is appropriate and reasonable. HH / Rules / HH-R4 297.23 Support Supports HH-R4 (relocation of a structure onto a site containing a Retain HH-R4 as notified [inferred]. scheduled heritage building or item) because it is appropriate and reasonable. HH / Rules / HH-R5 297.25 Oppose Opposes HH-R5 (relocation of a specified scheduled heritage building or Delete HH-R5, and HH-R9 should apply making their removal and item) because there is no reason that these items are treated differently to demolition a NC activity. others in the heritage schedule. HH / Rules / HH-R6 297.26 Support Supports HH-R6 (demolition or removal of a scheduled contributory Retain HH-R6 as notified [inferred]. building) because it is appropriate and reasonable.

Submitter 297 Heritage Taranaki Inc │ 337 Provision Sub No/ Position Summary of Submission Decision Request Point No HH / Rules / HH-R10 297.32 Support in Supports HH-R10 (land disturbance on a scheduled archaeological site) Amend HH-R10 as follows (or similar): part because it is appropriate and reasonable but considers that: Activity status: PER ● Grazing can cause significant damage to fragile archaeological sites. Where: ● NPDC has been contacted about this, e.g. Rewarewa Pā, . 1. the land disturbance is for: ● Heritage has taken acon about this, e.g. overgrazing of Te a. …; Ruaki Pā/Hawera, resulting in a heritage covenant limiting the number of b. sustainable grazing of suitable livestock. cattle that can be grazed. HH / Rules / HH-R11 297.33 Support in Supports HH-R11 (demolition or removal of a structure on a scheduled Amend HH-R11 as follows (or similar): part archaeological site) because it is appropriate and reasonable but considers Activity status: PER it may cause confusion in cases of built archaeological sites, where the Where: archaeological site is in fact the structure or building that is to be 1. the works do not involve earthworks; demolished or removed. 2. for alterations, there is no change to the size, location or design of the structure's foundation or building footprint occupied by the existing structure; and 3a. the building to be demolished is not the archaeological site; and 3. all underlying Zone Effects Standards are complied with. HH / Rules / HH-R12 297.34 Support in The submitter refers to comments made to HH-R11 in respect to HH-R12 Amend HH-R12 as follows (or similar): part (alterations to a structure on a scheduled archaeological site). Activity status: PER Where: 1. the works do not involve earthworks; 2. for alterations, there is no change to the size, location or design of the structure's foundation or building footprint occupied by the existing structure; and 3a. the building to be demolished is not the archaeological site; and 3. all underlying Zone Effects Standards are complied with. HH / Rules / HH-R14 297.36 Support Supports HH-R14 (erection of a structure on or within 50m of a scheduled Retain HH-R14 as notified [inferred]. archaeological site) because it is appropriate and reasonable. HH / Rules / HH-R17 297.40a Support in Considers that HH-R17 (earthworks on or within 50m of a scheduled Clarify the intent of HH-R17 [inferred]. part archaeological site...) should be clarified because: ● Does discreon include consideraon of Heritage New Zealand's response to earthworks and subdivision and the requirements of the HNZPTA 2014 for the granting of an archaeological authority prior to commencing earthworks? ● Subdivisions should not result in further subdivision of archaeological sites and multiple ownership of single archaeological sites, resulting in fencing of sites and difficulties for site care and conservation, i.e. access issues, different land use resulting in affected appearance, differential site damage and reduced amenity value. HH / Rules / HH-R18 297.40b Support in Considers that HH-R18 (subdivision of land containing any part of a Clarify the intent of HH-R18 [inferred]. part scheduled archaeological site) should be clarified because: ● Does discreon include consideraon of Heritage New Zealand's response to earthworks and subdivision and the requirements of the HNZPTA 2014 for the granting of an archaeological authority prior to commencing earthworks? ● Subdivisions should not result in further subdivision of archaeological

Submitter 297 Heritage Taranaki Inc │ 338 Provision Sub No/ Position Summary of Submission Decision Request Point No sites and multiple ownership of single archaeological sites, resulting in fencing of sites and difficulties for site care and conservation, i.e. access issues, different land use resulting in affected appearance, differential site damage and reduced amenity value. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.44 Support Considers that under SCHED1: Research and list further heritage buildings and items district wide. and Items ● Protecng 143 sites, mostly within the CBD, is too few and far from The submitter has prepared more than 90 draft heritage assessments (see representative across the district. attachments to submission) covering a diverse range of buildings and ● NPDC has been pragmac with its budget and concentrated new listings structures from across the district, which they consider should be treated in the CBD, largely ignoring the smaller centres meaning that buildings as a representative sample of a much larger group of unprotected items outside of the CBD will more likely be lost and may not have access to deserving protection. These assessments are dealt with as individual funding sources. submission points. ● Despite an increase in listed buildings (formerly A), the delisng of hundreds of B and C's amounts to a loss of public visibility and increases the likelihood that they will be lost. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.45 Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be listed in Add 1 Hau Lane, Ōākura to SCHED1. and Items SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.46 Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be listed in Add 25 Standish Street, to SCHED1. and Items SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.47 Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be listed in Add 240 Devon Street West, New Plymouth to SCHED1. and Items SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.48 Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be listed in Add 242 Devon Street West, New Plymouth to SCHED1. and Items SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.49 Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be listed in Add 294 Devon Street West, New Plymouth to SCHED1. and Items SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.50 Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be listed in Add Airlie House (161 Powderham Street, New Plymouth) to SCHED1. and Items SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.51 Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be listed in Add Alsop's Workers' Dwelling (25 Paynters Avenue, New Plymouth) to and Items SCHED1. SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.52 Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be listed in Add Ambury Residence (Former) (98 Liardet Street, New Plymouth) to and Items SCHED1. SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.53 Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be listed in Add Amoore Residence (Former) (25 Vivian Street/73 Brougham Street, and Items SCHED1. New Plymouth) to SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.54 Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be listed in Add Arnold's Cottage No. 1 (129 Lemon Street, New Plymouth) to SCHED1. and Items SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.55 Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be listed in Add Arnold's Cottage No. 2 (31 Lemon Street, New Plymouth) to SCHED1. and Items SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.56 Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be listed in Add Barron's Cottage (4 Hempton Street, New Plymouth) to SCHED1. and Items SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.57 Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be listed in Add Bridger Residence (Former) (96 Lemon Street, New Plymouth) to and Items SCHED1. SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.58 Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be listed in Add Captain Rogers Cottage No. 3 (75 Eliot Street, New Plymouth) to and Items SCHED1. SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.59 Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be listed in Add Captain Rogers Residence/Scrimgeour's Store (Former) (77 Eliot and Items SCHED1. Street, New Plymouth) to SCHED1.

Submitter 297 Heritage Taranaki Inc │ 339 Provision Sub No/ Position Summary of Submission Decision Request Point No SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.60 Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be listed in Add Carr Residence (17 Barrett Street, New Plymouth) to SCHED1. and Items SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.61 Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be listed in Add Carrington Street Horse Trough (Lower Carrington Street, New and Items SCHED1. Plymouth) to SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.62 Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be listed in Add Cassell's Cottage (99 Lemon Street, New Plymouth) to SCHED1. and Items SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.63 Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be listed in Add Charteris' Workers' Dwelling (27 Paynters Avenue, New Plymouth) to and Items SCHED1. SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.64 Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be listed in Add Chew Chong's Villa (Former) (272 Courtenay Street, New Plymouth) to and Items SCHED1. SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.65 Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be listed in Add David Teed Residence (Former) (12 Weymouth Street, New Plymouth) and Items SCHED1. to SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.66 Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be listed in Add Davie House (19 Robe Street, New Plymouth) to SCHED1. and Items SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.67 Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be listed in Add Douglass Residence (Former) (51 Dawson Street, New Plymouth) to and Items SCHED1. SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.68 Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be listed in Add F T Bellringer Residence (Former) (363 Devon Street East, New and Items SCHED1. Plymouth) to SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.69 Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be listed in Add First Church of Christ, Scientist (81 Courtenay Street, New Plymouth) and Items SCHED1. to SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.70 Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be listed in Add Fitzroy Post Office (Former) (512 Devon Street East, New Plymouth) to and Items SCHED1. SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.71 Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be listed in Add Frankley Road School (Former) (419 Frankley Road, New Plymouth) to and Items SCHED1. SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.72 Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be listed in Add Frankley Road School Teachers' Residence (Former) (407 Frankley and Items SCHED1. Road, New Plymouth) to SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.73 Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be listed in Add Hall-McCaul House (181 Kairau Road East, Brixton) to SCHED1. and Items SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.74 Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be listed in Add Harlin's Cottage (63 Lemon Street, New Plymouth) to SCHED1. and Items SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.75 Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be listed in Add Heard Residence (Former) (23 Hine Street, New Plymouth) to SCHED1. and Items SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.76 Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be listed in Add Hinemoa Private Maternity Hospital (Former) (240 Courtenay Street, and Items SCHED1. New Plymouth) to SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.77 Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be listed in Add Inglewood BNZ (Former) (22 Matai Street, Inglewood) to SCHED1. and Items SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.78 Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be listed in Add Inglewood Railway Hotel (Former) (23 Rata Street, Inglewood) to and Items SCHED1. SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.79 Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be listed in Add Issey Manor (32 Carrington Street, New Plymouth) to SCHED1. and Items SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.80 Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be listed in Add Kebbell-Quilliam Residence (Former) (59 Vivian Street, New Plymouth) and Items SCHED1. to SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.81 Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be listed in Add Kerr Residence (Former) (84 Brougham Street, New Plymouth) to and Items SCHED1. SCHED1.

Submitter 297 Heritage Taranaki Inc │ 340 Provision Sub No/ Position Summary of Submission Decision Request Point No SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.82 Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be listed in Add Kibby's Cottage (15 Clemow Road, New Plymouth) to SCHED1. and Items SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.83 Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be listed in Add Kincora Private Maternity Home (Former) (23 Mt Edgecumbe Street, and Items SCHED1. New Plymouth) to SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.84 Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be listed in Add Knox Church and Hall (Former) (27 Cutfield Street, Inglewood) to and Items SCHED1. SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.85 Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be listed in Add L. A. Nolan Hide Store (15 Liardet Street, New Plymouth) to SCHED1. and Items SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.86 Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be listed in Add Lacey's Cottage (94 Lemon Street, New Plymouth) to SCHED1. and Items SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.87 Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be listed in Add Langman's Cottage (105 Molesworth Street, New Plymouth) to and Items SCHED1. SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.88 Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be listed in Add Lawson's Cottage No. 2 (92 Lemon Street, New Plymouth) to SCHED1. and Items SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.89 Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be listed in Add Llantwit Cottage (35 Gilbert Street, New Plymouth) to SCHED1. and Items SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.90 Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be listed in Add Lock's Cottage (23 Standish Street, New Plymouth) to SCHED1. and Items SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.91 Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be listed in Add Lomas Residence (Former) (83 Brougham Street, New Plymouth) to and Items SCHED1. SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.92 Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be listed in Add Mannix Villa (Former) (284 Devon Street West, New Plymouth) to and Items SCHED1. SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.93 Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be listed in Add McAllum Residence (Former) and Retaining Wall (17 Vivian Street, and Items SCHED1. New Plymouth) to SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.94 Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be listed in Add Messenger House (219 Gill Street, New Plymouth) to SCHED1. and Items SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.95 Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be listed in Add Miss Lane's Cottage (105 Pendarves Street, New Plymouth) to and Items SCHED1. SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.96 Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be listed in Add Morley Street Tram Shelter (NPDC Road Reserve, Morley Street, New and Items SCHED1. Plymouth) to SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.97 Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be listed in Add Mrs Cooper's Cottage (49 Gilbert Street, New Plymouth) to SCHED1. and Items SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.98 Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be listed in Add Neal Residence (Former) (162 St Aubyn Street, New Plymouth) to and Items SCHED1. SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.99 Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be listed in Add New Plymouth Railway Bridges (Pari, Eliot, Hobson and Devon Street and Items SCHED1. East, New Plymouth) to SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.100 Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be listed in Add New Plymouth Technical School Technical Engineering Building and Items SCHED1. (Former) (99 Liardet Street, New Plymouth) to SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.101 Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be listed in Add Overdale (1/130-6/130 Carrington Street, New Plymouth) to SCHED1. and Items SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.102 Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be listed in Add Pahitere Blockhouse (Former) (16 Koru Road, Ōākura) to SCHED1. and Items SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.103 Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be listed in Add Parsons Cool Store (5 Hakirau Street, New Plymouth) to SCHED1. and Items SCHED1.

Submitter 297 Heritage Taranaki Inc │ 341 Provision Sub No/ Position Summary of Submission Decision Request Point No SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.104 Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be listed in Add Superintendents' Residence (Former) (25 Victoria Road, and Items SCHED1. New Plymouth) to SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.105 Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be listed in Add Pukekura Park Ticket Boxes (2) (Pukekura Park Sports Ground, Liardet and Items SCHED1. Street, New Plymouth) to SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.106 Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be listed in Add Pukekura Park Victoria Road Entrance Gates (Victoria Road/Pukekura and Items SCHED1. Park, New Plymouth) to SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.107 Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be listed in Add Queen Street Takeaways (34 Queen Street, Waitara) to SCHED1. and Items SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.108 Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be listed in Add Rahui Boarding House/Seaspray House (Former) (13 Weymouth and Items SCHED1. Street, New Plymouth) to SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.109 Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be listed in Add Regina Place/Victoria Esplanade Retaining Wall (Regina Place, New and Items SCHED1. Plymouth) to SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.110 Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be listed in Add Reid Residence/Mulberry Cottage (139 Powderham Street, New and Items SCHED1. Plymouth) to SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.111 Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be listed in Add Rennell's Villa (46 Vivian Street, New Plymouth) to SCHED1. and Items SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.112 Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be listed in Add Reo Moana Flats (10 Weymouth Street, New Plymouth) to SCHED1. and Items SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.113 Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be listed in Add Rev. Drew's Villa (Former) (7 Pendarves Street, New Plymouth) to and Items SCHED1. SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.114 Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be listed in Add Robertson Residence (Former) (14 Wakefield Street, New Plymouth) and Items SCHED1. to SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.115 Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be listed in Add Soffe House (99 Inland North Road, ) to SCHED1. and Items SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.116 Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be listed in Add Retaining Wall and Wrought Iron Fence (11 Vivian Street, New and Items SCHED1. Plymouth) to SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.117 Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be listed in Add T. S. Weston Residence (Former) (26 Weymouth Street, New and Items SCHED1. Plymouth) to SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.118 Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be listed in Add Taranaki Producers' Freezing Works Butter Store (5 Hakirau Street, and Items SCHED1. New Plymouth) to SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.119 Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be listed in Add Taranaki Producers' Freezing Works Produce Store (5 Hakirau Street, and Items SCHED1. New Plymouth) to SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.120 Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be listed in Add Taranaki Producers' Freezing Works Engine Room (5 Hakirau Street, and Items SCHED1. New Plymouth) to SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.121 Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be listed in Add 'Tea-pot' Roberts Store (Former) (70 Eliot Street, New Plymouth) to and Items SCHED1. SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.122 Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be listed in Add Thomas Sole's Cottage No. 1 (251 Courtenay Street, New Plymouth) to and Items SCHED1. SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.123 Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be listed in Add Thomas Sole's Cottage No. 2 (253 Courtenay Street, New Plymouth) to and Items SCHED1. SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.124 Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be listed in Add Tiromoana (68 Whiteley Street, New Plymouth) to SCHED1. and Items SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.125 Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be listed in Add Taranaki Jockey Club Caretakers Residence (Former) (130 Coronation and Items SCHED1. Avenue, New Plymouth) to SCHED1.

Submitter 297 Heritage Taranaki Inc │ 342 Provision Sub No/ Position Summary of Submission Decision Request Point No SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.126 Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be listed in Add Taranaki Jockey Club Sand Roll (131 Coronation Avenue, New and Items SCHED1. Plymouth) to SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.127 Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be listed in Add Urenui Post Office (Former) (24 Ngakoti Street, Urenui) to SCHED1. and Items SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.128 Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be listed in Add W. J. Shaw Residence (Former) (3 Rogan Street, New Plymouth) to and Items SCHED1. SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.129 Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be listed in Add Waitara Lock-Up (1875) (Memorial Place, Waitara) to SCHED1. and Items SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.130 Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be listed in Add Waitara Lock-Up (1911) (Memorial Place, Waitara) to SCHED1. and Items SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.131 Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be listed in Add Waldyve King Residence (Former) (30 Brooklands Park Drive, New and Items SCHED1. Plymouth) to SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.132 Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be listed in Add Walker's Workers' Dwelling (23 Paynters Avenue, New Plymouth) to and Items SCHED1. SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.133 Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be listed in Add Wareham-Morris Homestead (Former) (976 South Road, Ōākura) to and Items SCHED1. SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.134 Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be listed in Add White's Workers' Dwelling (29 Paynters Avenue, New Plymouth) to and Items SCHED1. SCHED1. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.135 Support Considers that more heritage buildings and items should be listed in Add Woon House (149 Vivian Street, New Plymouth) to SCHED1. and Items SCHED1. SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.136 Support Considers that under SCHED3: Review the NZAA database and update the plan to better reflect the Sites or Sites and Areas of ● Built archaeological sites on the NZAA site recording scheme are not current archaeological record. Significance to Māori / New included. Review and schedule as built archaeological sites the pre 1900 buildings ● The submier has a list of pre 1900 built archaeological sites on which list supplied by the submitter (these are listed as individual submission research has been carried out and the construction date is confirmed (see points). submission for list). Make background information publicly accessible so the submitter can ● The archaeological site/Waahi taonga project is ongoing and updated comment on the veracity of the built heritage and archaeological site site locations and extents are still required. Further plan changes are recording completed to date. expected which is positive and advances the heritage status of other Consider scheduling significant archaeological assemblages (contiguous places. archaeological sites) as heritage precincts or special heritage areas. ● There are issues accessing informaon pertaining to scheduled heritage building/items and archaeological sites. The basis for identification can't be gained from the e plan, which makes it almost impossible to make meaningful evaluation of the quality of this process. ● Consideraon should be given to scheduling significant archaeological assemblages (contiguous archaeological sites) as heritage precincts or special heritage areas, e.g. Waitara Road battlefield from Kairoa to Pukerangiora. SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.137 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add Airlie House (161 Powderham Street, New Plymouth) to SCHED3. Sites or Sites and Areas of Significance to Māori / New SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.138 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add Woon House (149 Vivian Street, New Plymouth) to SCHED3. Sites or Sites and Areas of Significance to Māori / New

Submitter 297 Heritage Taranaki Inc │ 343 Provision Sub No/ Position Summary of Submission Decision Request Point No SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.139 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add Fleetwood Cottage (38 Carrington Street, New Plymouth) to SCHED3. Sites or Sites and Areas of Significance to Māori / New SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.140 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add Belgrave Cottage (85 Gover Street, New Plymouth) to SCHED3. Sites or Sites and Areas of Significance to Māori / New SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.141 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add Arnold's Cottage no.1 (129 Lemon Street, New Plymouth) to SCHED3. Sites or Sites and Areas of Significance to Māori / New SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.142 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add Arnold's Cottage no.2 (131 Lemon Street, New Plymouth) to SCHED3. Sites or Sites and Areas of Significance to Māori / New SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.143 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add Langman's Cottage (105 Molesworth Street/11 Eliot Street, New Sites or Sites and Areas of Plymouth) to SCHED3. Significance to Māori / New SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.144 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add New Plymouth Prison (Robe Street, New Plymouth) to SCHED3. Sites or Sites and Areas of Significance to Māori / New SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.145 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add 4 Aubrey Street, New Plymouth to SCHED3. Sites or Sites and Areas of Significance to Māori / New SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.146 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add 6 Aubrey Street, New Plymouth to SCHED3. Sites or Sites and Areas of Significance to Māori / New SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.147 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add Fishleigh Cottage (20 Aubrey Street, New Plymouth) to SCHED3. Sites or Sites and Areas of Significance to Māori / New SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.148 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add 246 Devon Street West, New Plymouth to SCHED3. Sites or Sites and Areas of Significance to Māori / New SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.149 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add Richard Cock Jnr's "West End Store" (229 Devon Street West, New Sites or Sites and Areas of Plymouth) to SCHED3. Significance to Māori / New SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.150 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add McNaughton's Cottage (161 Molesworth Street, New Plymouth) to Sites or Sites and Areas of SCHED3. Significance to Māori / New SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.151 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add Mrs Cooper's Cottage (49 Gilbert Street, New Plymouth) to SCHED3. Sites or Sites and Areas of Significance to Māori / New SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.152 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add Cassell’s Cottage (99 Lemon Street, New Plymouth) to SCHED3. Sites or Sites and Areas of Significance to Māori / New

Submitter 297 Heritage Taranaki Inc │ 344 Provision Sub No/ Position Summary of Submission Decision Request Point No SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.153 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add Harlin's Cottage (63 Lemon Street, New Plymouth) to SCHED3. Sites or Sites and Areas of Significance to Māori / New SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.154 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add Captain Roger's Cottage no.3 (75 Eliot Street, New Plymouth) to Sites or Sites and Areas of SCHED3. Significance to Māori / New SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.155 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add Allen's Cottage (89 Pendarves Street, New Plymouth) to SCHED3. Sites or Sites and Areas of Significance to Māori / New SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.156 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add 84 Pendarves Street, New Plymouth to SCHED3. Sites or Sites and Areas of Significance to Māori / New SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.157 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add 90 Pendarves Street, New Plymouth to SCHED3. Sites or Sites and Areas of Significance to Māori / New SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.158 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add 94 Pendarves Street, New Plymouth to SCHED3. Sites or Sites and Areas of Significance to Māori / New SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.159 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add 98 Pendarves Street, New Plymouth to SCHED3. Sites or Sites and Areas of Significance to Māori / New SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.160 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add 102 Pendarves Street, New Plymouth to SCHED3. Sites or Sites and Areas of Significance to Māori / New SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.161 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add Willowfield (37 Cameron Street, New Plymouth) to SCHED3. Sites or Sites and Areas of Significance to Māori / New SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.162 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add French's Cottage (98 Gover Street, New Plymouth) to SCHED3. Sites or Sites and Areas of Significance to Māori / New SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.163 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add Wells Cottage (37 Gilbert Street, New Plymouth) to SCHED3. Sites or Sites and Areas of Significance to Māori / New SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.164 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add Llantwit Cottage (35 Gilbert Street, New Plymouth) to SCHED3. Sites or Sites and Areas of Significance to Māori / New SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.165 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add Issey Manor (32 Carrington Street, New Plymouth) to SCHED3. Sites or Sites and Areas of Significance to Māori / New SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.166 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add 11 Pendarves Street, New Plymouth to SCHED3. Sites or Sites and Areas of Significance to Māori / New

Submitter 297 Heritage Taranaki Inc │ 345 Provision Sub No/ Position Summary of Submission Decision Request Point No SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.167 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add 12 Pendarves Street, New Plymouth (1/21A- 5/21A Bulteel Street, Sites or Sites and Areas of New Plymouth) to SCHED3. Significance to Māori / New SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.168 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add Andrew Morton's Residence (1/21A- 5/21A Bulteel Street, New Sites or Sites and Areas of Plymouth) to SCHED3. Significance to Māori / New SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.169 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add Egmont Steam Flour Mill (Courtenay Street, New Plymouth) to Sites or Sites and Areas of SCHED3. Significance to Māori / New SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.170 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add 149 St Aubyn Street, New Plymouth to SCHED3. Sites or Sites and Areas of Significance to Māori / New SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.171 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add 35 Hine Street, New Plymouth to SCHED3. Sites or Sites and Areas of Significance to Māori / New SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.172 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add Crown Dairy Company Building (26 Queen Street, New Plymouth) to Sites or Sites and Areas of SCHED3. Significance to Māori / New SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.173 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add Hancock's Cottage (298 Devon Street West, New Plymouth) to Sites or Sites and Areas of SCHED3. Significance to Māori / New SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.174 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add McManus-Bond Residence (294 Devon Street West, New Plymouth) to Sites or Sites and Areas of SCHED3. Significance to Māori / New SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.175 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add St Mary's Cathedral (Vivian Street, New Plymouth) to SCHED3. Sites or Sites and Areas of Significance to Māori / New SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.176 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add Te Henui Vicarage (Courtenay Street, New Plymouth) to SCHED3. Sites or Sites and Areas of Significance to Māori / New SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.177 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add 59 Pendarves Street, New Plymouth to SCHED3. Sites or Sites and Areas of Significance to Māori / New SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.178 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add Kirkby-Medley Residence (31 Waipapa Road, Waitara) to SCHED3. Sites or Sites and Areas of Significance to Māori / New SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.179 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add Allen Residence (961 Main North Road, ) to SCHED3. Sites or Sites and Areas of Significance to Māori / New SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.180 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add Mace/Foxglove Cottage (55D Karina Road, New Plymouth) to SCHED3. Sites or Sites and Areas of Significance to Māori / New

Submitter 297 Heritage Taranaki Inc │ 346 Provision Sub No/ Position Summary of Submission Decision Request Point No SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.181 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add Richmond/Beach Cottage (Ariki Street, New Plymouth) to SCHED3. Sites or Sites and Areas of Significance to Māori / New SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.182 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add Devonport Cottage (564 Road, New Plymouth) to SCHED3. Sites or Sites and Areas of Significance to Māori / New SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.183 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add Portion of Marsland Hill Barracks (North Egmont) to SCHED3. Sites or Sites and Areas of Significance to Māori / New SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.184 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add Flight House (NPGHS, New Plymouth) to SCHED3. Sites or Sites and Areas of Significance to Māori / New SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.185 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add Curtis Homestead (198 Pheney Road, New Plymouth) to SCHED3. Sites or Sites and Areas of Significance to Māori / New SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.186 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add Gordon Residence/Iona Hospital Extension (385 Lower Weld Road, Sites or Sites and Areas of New Plymouth) to SCHED3. Significance to Māori / New SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.187 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add William Pellew’s Villa (58 Pendarves Street, New Plymouth) to Sites or Sites and Areas of SCHED3. Significance to Māori / New SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.188 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add Taranaki Club (Former) (28 Egmont Street, New Plymouth) to SCHED3. Sites or Sites and Areas of Significance to Māori / New SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.189 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add 139 Powderham Street, New Plymouth to SCHED3. Sites or Sites and Areas of Significance to Māori / New SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.190 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add Frankley Road School Teachers Residence (407 Frankley Road, New Sites or Sites and Areas of Plymouth) to SCHED3. Significance to Māori / New SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.191 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add Roy Building (48 Brougham Street, New Plymouth) to SCHED3. Sites or Sites and Areas of Significance to Māori / New SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.192 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add Nice Hotel (71 Brougham Street, New Plymouth) to SCHED3. Sites or Sites and Areas of Significance to Māori / New SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.193 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add (29 Wallace Place, New Plymouth) to SCHED3. Sites or Sites and Areas of Significance to Māori / New SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.194 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add Mount Hardy/Rossiter Residence (100 Belt Road, New Plymouth) to Sites or Sites and Areas of SCHED3. Significance to Māori / New

Submitter 297 Heritage Taranaki Inc │ 347 Provision Sub No/ Position Summary of Submission Decision Request Point No SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.195 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add Whiteley Mission House (St Aubyn Street, New Plymouth) to SCHED3. Sites or Sites and Areas of Significance to Māori / New SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.196 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add 245 St Aubyn Street, New Plymouth to SCHED3. Sites or Sites and Areas of Significance to Māori / New SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.197 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add 251 St Aubyn Street, New Plymouth to SCHED3. Sites or Sites and Areas of Significance to Māori / New SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.198 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add W. H. Skinner's Buildings (93 & 95 Devon Street West, New Plymouth) Sites or Sites and Areas of to SCHED3. Significance to Māori / New SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.199 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add Mannix Villa (284 Devon Street West, New Plymouth) to SCHED3. Sites or Sites and Areas of Significance to Māori / New SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.200 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add Lawson's Cottage no.2 (92 Lemon Street, New Plymouth) to SCHED3. Sites or Sites and Areas of Significance to Māori / New SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.201 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add Lawson's Cottage no.1 (107 Pendarves Street, New Plymouth) to Sites or Sites and Areas of SCHED3. Significance to Māori / New SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.202 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add Lacey's Cottage (94 Lemon Street, New Plymouth) to SCHED3. Sites or Sites and Areas of Significance to Māori / New SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.203 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add 3 Rogan Street, New Plymouth to SCHED3. Sites or Sites and Areas of Significance to Māori / New SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.204 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add St Kilda/Charles Burgess Residence (7 Ridge Lane, New Plymouth) to Sites or Sites and Areas of SCHED3. Significance to Māori / New SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.205 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add Hosking House/Holmwood (1 Victoria Road, New Plymouth) to Sites or Sites and Areas of SCHED3. Significance to Māori / New SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.206 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add Charles Gledhill’s Building (17 Devon Street West, New Plymouth) to Sites or Sites and Areas of SCHED3. Significance to Māori / New SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.207 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add Ward's Cottage (14 Morley Street, New Plymouth) to SCHED3. Sites or Sites and Areas of Significance to Māori / New SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.208 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add 18 Morley Street, New Plymouth to SCHED3. Sites or Sites and Areas of Significance to Māori / New

Submitter 297 Heritage Taranaki Inc │ 348 Provision Sub No/ Position Summary of Submission Decision Request Point No SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.209 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add 94 Hine Street, New Plymouth to SCHED3. Sites or Sites and Areas of Significance to Māori / New SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.210 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add Scotland Cottage (NPGHS, New Plymouth) to SCHED3. Sites or Sites and Areas of Significance to Māori / New SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.211 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add St Mary’s Community Centre (Vivian Street, New Plymouth) to Sites or Sites and Areas of SCHED3. Significance to Māori / New SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.212 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add St Mary’s Vicarage (Vivian Street, New Plymouth) to SCHED3. Sites or Sites and Areas of Significance to Māori / New SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.213 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add White Hart Hotel (124 Devon Street West, New Plymouth) to SCHED3. Sites or Sites and Areas of Significance to Māori / New SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.214 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add Teeds Building (56 Devon Street West, New Plymouth) to SCHED3. Sites or Sites and Areas of Significance to Māori / New SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.215 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add W. F. Brooking Residence (115 Vivian Street, New Plymouth) to Sites or Sites and Areas of SCHED3. Significance to Māori / New SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.216 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add 813 Mangorei Road, New Plymouth to SCHED3. Sites or Sites and Areas of Significance to Māori / New SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.217 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add Shuttleworth Residence (15 Lismore Street, New Plymouth) to Sites or Sites and Areas of SCHED3. Significance to Māori / New SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.218 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add ‘Donnybrook’/Newman Residence (7 Kapu Grove, New Plymouth) to Sites or Sites and Areas of SCHED3. Significance to Māori / New SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.219 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add William Kerr Residence (84 Brougham Street, New Plymouth) to Sites or Sites and Areas of SCHED3. Significance to Māori / New SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.220 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add Rev Drew's Villa (7 Pendarves Street, New Plymouth) to SCHED3. Sites or Sites and Areas of Significance to Māori / New SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.221 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add Maranui (25 Maranui Street, New Plymouth) to SCHED3. Sites or Sites and Areas of Significance to Māori / New SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.222 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add 37-43 Brougham Street, New Plymouth to SCHED3. Sites or Sites and Areas of Significance to Māori / New

Submitter 297 Heritage Taranaki Inc │ 349 Provision Sub No/ Position Summary of Submission Decision Request Point No SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.223 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add Holy Trinity Church (Henui Street, New Plymouth) to SCHED3. Sites or Sites and Areas of Significance to Māori / New SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.224 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add St John the Evangelist (SH45, ) to SCHED3. Sites or Sites and Areas of Significance to Māori / New SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.225 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add Clare Homestead (229 Parklands Avenue, Bell Block) to SCHED3. Sites or Sites and Areas of Significance to Māori / New SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.226 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add Francis Residence/FDMC Agricultural Classroom (Francis Douglas Sites or Sites and Areas of Memorial College, Tukapa Street, New Plymouth) to SCHED3. Significance to Māori / New SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.227 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add Newell's Villa (53 Morley Street, New Plymouth) to SCHED3. Sites or Sites and Areas of Significance to Māori / New SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.228 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add Webber’s Cottage (37 Lemon Street, New Plymouth) to SCHED3. Sites or Sites and Areas of Significance to Māori / New SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.229 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add 44 Hine Street, New Plymouth to SCHED3. Sites or Sites and Areas of Significance to Māori / New SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.230 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add Glen Almond House (18C Glen Almond Street, New Plymouth) to Sites or Sites and Areas of SCHED3. Significance to Māori / New SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.231 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add 162 Mangorei Road, New Plymouth to SCHED3. Sites or Sites and Areas of Significance to Māori / New SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.232 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add Wood Residence (334 Devon Street West, New Plymouth) to SCHED3. Sites or Sites and Areas of Significance to Māori / New SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.233 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add Belt Road Dairy (334 Devon Street West, New Plymouth) to SCHED3. Sites or Sites and Areas of Significance to Māori / New SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.234 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add Thomas Sole’s Cottage no.1 (251 Courtenay Street, New Plymouth) to Sites or Sites and Areas of SCHED3. Significance to Māori / New SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.235 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add Thomas Sole’s Cottage no.2 (253 Courtenay Street, New Plymouth) to Sites or Sites and Areas of SCHED3. Significance to Māori / New SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.236 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add Foyle Hills (67 Parrs Road, New Plymouth) to SCHED3. Sites or Sites and Areas of Significance to Māori / New

Submitter 297 Heritage Taranaki Inc │ 350 Provision Sub No/ Position Summary of Submission Decision Request Point No SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.237 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add Henwood House (314 Henwood Road, New Plymouth) to SCHED3. Sites or Sites and Areas of Significance to Māori / New SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.238 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add 688 Junction Road, New Plymouth to SCHED3. Sites or Sites and Areas of Significance to Māori / New SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.239 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add 4 Broadway to SCHED3. Sites or Sites and Areas of Significance to Māori / New SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.240 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add Waitara Foresters Hall (former) (43 Domett Street, Waitara) to Sites or Sites and Areas of SCHED3. Significance to Māori / New SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.241 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add 79 Queen Street, Waitara to SCHED3. Sites or Sites and Areas of Significance to Māori / New SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.242 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add 32 Memorial Place, Waitara to SCHED3. Sites or Sites and Areas of Significance to Māori / New SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.243 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add 24 Princess Street, Waitara to SCHED3. Sites or Sites and Areas of Significance to Māori / New SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.244 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add 45 Grey Street, Waitara to SCHED3. Sites or Sites and Areas of Significance to Māori / New SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.245 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add 55 Grey Street, Waitara to SCHED3. Sites or Sites and Areas of Significance to Māori / New SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.246 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add 40A Queen Street, Waitara to SCHED3. Sites or Sites and Areas of Significance to Māori / New SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.247 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add Masonic Hotel (cnr McLean and Warre Streets, Waitara) to SCHED3. Sites or Sites and Areas of Significance to Māori / New SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.248 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add St John the Baptist Church Hall (35 Domett Street, Waitara) to Sites or Sites and Areas of SCHED3. Significance to Māori / New SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.249 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add 59 Domett Street, Waitara to SCHED3. Sites or Sites and Areas of Significance to Māori / New SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.250 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add John Cameron's Cottage (93 Domett Street, Waitara) to SCHED3. Sites or Sites and Areas of Significance to Māori / New

Submitter 297 Heritage Taranaki Inc │ 351 Provision Sub No/ Position Summary of Submission Decision Request Point No SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.251 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add 9 Pratt Street, Waitara to SCHED3. Sites or Sites and Areas of Significance to Māori / New SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.252 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add 15 Cracroft Street, Waitara to SCHED3. Sites or Sites and Areas of Significance to Māori / New SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.253 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add 45 Cracroft Street, Waitara to SCHED3. Sites or Sites and Areas of Significance to Māori / New SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.254 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add 91 Centennial Avenue, Waitara to SCHED3. Sites or Sites and Areas of Significance to Māori / New SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.255 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add 127 Centennial Avenue, Waitara to SCHED3. Sites or Sites and Areas of Significance to Māori / New SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.256 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add 63 Queen Street, Waitara to SCHED3. Sites or Sites and Areas of Significance to Māori / New SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.257 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add Madden's Cottage and Bakery (65 Queen Street, Waitara) to SCHED3. Sites or Sites and Areas of Significance to Māori / New SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.258 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add 65A Queen Street, Waitara to SCHED3. Sites or Sites and Areas of Significance to Māori / New SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.259 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add 39 Blake Street, Waitara to SCHED3. Sites or Sites and Areas of Significance to Māori / New SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.260 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add 7 Warre Street, Waitara to SCHED3. Sites or Sites and Areas of Significance to Māori / New SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.261 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add 6 Harris Street, Waitara to SCHED3. Sites or Sites and Areas of Significance to Māori / New SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.262 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add Methodist Parsonage (former) (46 Princess Street, Waitara) to Sites or Sites and Areas of SCHED3. Significance to Māori / New SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.263 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add Wood House (70 Waipapa Road, Waitara) to SCHED3. Sites or Sites and Areas of Significance to Māori / New SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.264 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add Hicks' Family Homestead (208 Ngatimaru Road, Tikorangi) to SCHED3. Sites or Sites and Areas of Significance to Māori / New

Submitter 297 Heritage Taranaki Inc │ 351a Provision Sub No/ Position Summary of Submission Decision Request Point No SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.265 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add 99 Inland North Road, Urenui to SCHED3. Sites or Sites and Areas of Significance to Māori / New SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.266 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add Tikorangi Playcentre/Original Albert Road School (356 Ngatimaru Sites or Sites and Areas of Road, Tikorangi) to SCHED3. Significance to Māori / New SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.267 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add Huirangi Hall (8 Bayley Street, Huirangi) to SCHED3. Sites or Sites and Areas of Significance to Māori / New SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.268 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add McTaggart Residence (372 Mountain Road, Waitara District) to Sites or Sites and Areas of SCHED3. Significance to Māori / New SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.269 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add Hall-McCaul House (177 Kairau Road East, Waitara) to SCHED3. Sites or Sites and Areas of Significance to Māori / New SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.270 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add 39 Whakapaki Street, Urenui to SCHED3. Sites or Sites and Areas of Significance to Māori / New SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.271 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add Urenui Town Hall (former) (23 Ngakoti Street, Urenui) to SCHED3. Sites or Sites and Areas of Significance to Māori / New SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.272 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add St Paul's Church (25 Ngakoti Street, Urenui) to SCHED3. Sites or Sites and Areas of Significance to Māori / New SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.273 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add Sacred Heart Church (21 Standish Street, Inglewood) to SCHED3. Sites or Sites and Areas of Significance to Māori / New SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.274 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add Becklands (9 Becklands Place, Inglewood) to SCHED3. Sites or Sites and Areas of Significance to Māori / New SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.275 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add Railway Hotel (23 Rata Street, Inglewood) to SCHED 3. Sites or Sites and Areas of Significance to Māori / New SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.276 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add 5-9 Moa Street, Inglewood to SCHED3. Sites or Sites and Areas of Significance to Māori / New SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.277 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add Moa Farmers Union Inglewood Bakery (11 Moa Street, Inglewood) to Sites or Sites and Areas of SCHED3. Significance to Māori / New SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.278 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add North End Farm/Drake Homestead (1365 Mountain Road, Inglewood) Sites or Sites and Areas of to SCHED3. Significance to Māori / New

Submitter 297 Heritage Taranaki Inc │ 351b Provision Sub No/ Position Summary of Submission Decision Request Point No SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.279 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add Inglewood Railway Station (Matai Street, Inglewood) to SCHED3. Sites or Sites and Areas of Significance to Māori / New SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.280 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add Deem and Shearer Building (1 Kelly Street, Inglewood) to SCHED3. Sites or Sites and Areas of Significance to Māori / New SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.281 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add Somerset Boarding House (former) (41 Moa Street, Inglewood) to Sites or Sites and Areas of SCHED3. Significance to Māori / New SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.282 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add 32 Matai Street, Inglewood to SCHED3. Sites or Sites and Areas of Significance to Māori / New SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.283 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add Dr Hutchinson's House (2211 Tarata Road, Tarata) to SCHED3. Sites or Sites and Areas of Significance to Māori / New SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.284 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add 1441 Egmont Road, to SCHED3. Sites or Sites and Areas of Significance to Māori / New SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.285 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add Oakura Hall (1160A South Road, Oakura) to SCHED3. Sites or Sites and Areas of Significance to Māori / New SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.286 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add 1 Hau Lane, Oakura to SCHED3. Sites or Sites and Areas of Significance to Māori / New SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.287 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add Pahitere Blockhouse (16 Koru Road, Omata) to SCHED3. Sites or Sites and Areas of Significance to Māori / New SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.288 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add Greenwood-Honeyfield House (269 Lower Timaru Road, Tataramaika) Sites or Sites and Areas of to SCHED3. Significance to Māori / New SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.289 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add Wareham-Morris Homestead (976 South Road, Omata) to SCHED3. Sites or Sites and Areas of Significance to Māori / New SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.290 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add Ashdown Park (1671 South Road, Tataraimaka) to SCHED3. Sites or Sites and Areas of Significance to Māori / New SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.291 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add Okato Parsonage (former) (96 Oxford Road, Okato) to SCHED3. Sites or Sites and Areas of Significance to Māori / New SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.292 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add 33 Old South Road, Okato to SCHED3. Sites or Sites and Areas of Significance to Māori / New

Submitter 297 Heritage Taranaki Inc │ 351c Provision Sub No/ Position Summary of Submission Decision Request Point No SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.293 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add Stony River Hotel (2502 South Road, Okato) to SCHED3. Sites or Sites and Areas of Significance to Māori / New SCHED3 / Archaeological 297.294 Support Considers that more archaeological sites should be listed in SCHED3. Add 2333 South Road, Okato to SCHED3. Sites or Sites and Areas of Significance to Māori / New SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.3b Support Considers that: Revisit the decision to not schedule the 17 areas (4.1.3.2 Heritage and Items / New Heritage ● Heritage character areas should not be limited to the CBD. Character Areas) outlined in the Section 32. Character Areas ● The 17 previously recognised heritage character areas should be included. It is not accepted that their site loss is so extensive that smaller areas of contiguous heritage buildings couldn't be considered. The site loss described in the section 32 report only addresses residential areas and the reasons for not including the commercial and bach areas are not addressed. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.3c Support Considers that: Add those heritage areas recognised by Heritage New Zealand Pouhere and Items / New Heritage ● Heritage character areas should not be limited to the CBD. Taonga, such as the Tongaporutu bach area and the Hen and Chicken Character Areas ● At a minimum, those heritage areas recognised by HNZPT should be houses historic area [inferred]. included, such as the Tongaporutu bach area and the Hen and Chicken houses historic area. SCHED1 / Heritage Buildings 297.3d Support Considers that: Investigate including areas of contiguous archaeological sites, such as the and Items / New Heritage ● Heritage character areas should not be limited to the CBD. Waitara battleground. Character Areas ● No consideraon appears to have been given to archaeological heritage, such as the Waitara Road battleground from Kairau to Pukerangiora.

Submitter 297 Heritage Taranaki Inc │ 351d