<<

Vowel Raising in the Dialect of Mandarin Hai Hu† ([email protected]), Aini ‡, Yiwen Zhang†, Phillip Weirich† † Indiana University Bloomington, ‡ Jiao Tong University

Introduction Results: age and gender Results: age and gender Discussion

Previously documented /an/ in the Chengdu dialect: • Raising: /ian/, /yan/, /uan/, /Can/ in younger groups all • Females raise more than males → females lead the change • Confirms results in previous studies, e.g. He and Rao (2013); higher than the oldest age group • Possible sequence for raising: Hu and Zhang (2017) Year of 1941 1956 1956 1982 1983 2006 2016 • Similar realizations for 2 younger age groups /ian/ (assimilation) → /yan/ → /uan/ and /Can/ • Found an effect from not only age and gender, but also lan- Analysis guage attitude and vowel context Published Zhen Zhen He and Hu and in (1984) (1958) et al. (1982) (1983) Rao Zhang • Variation among age and gender groups Apparent-time track of change allows us to observe the (1960) (2013) (2017) stages in the phonologization of an innovative pattern with /iai/ a E E E NA E NA phonetic origins /ian/ e æ E E E˜ æ / E E /yan/ e æ E E E˜ æ / E E • Whether it should be understood as a regular sound change, /Can/ a A æ NA ã æ / E æ / E i.e. a gradual transformation of a single phonetic feature, or a /uan/ a A æ NA ã NA æ / E change triggered by lexical diffusion remains to be answered • Recent studies: elicited data (Hu and Zhang, 2017), no • Next: extend to include even younger speakers (< 15 years acoustic analysis (He and Rao, 2013). old) • This study: the influence of age, gender, language attitude and vowel context on the realization of /an/. Conclusion • This study: natural speech of 18 native Chengdu speakers from Li (2018). • Raising attested in natural speech of two young age groups Methods • Female speakers leading the sound change (c.f. Labov (2001)) Vowel context (target tokens): /(C)ian/, /(C)yan/, /(C)uan/, • Possibly started from assimilation and then spread to other /(C)an/. conditions: /ian/ → /yan/ → /uan/ and /Can/ Reference vowels: /a/, /i/, /u/, /o/ as anchors in vowel chart. • Older, male speakers: more positive language attitude Speakers: 3 age groups: 15-20 yrs, 20-30 yrs, >40 yrs; 3 male and 3 female speakers per age group. References Results: vowel contexts Results: linear model Annotation: Annotation starts at 10 minutes, ends with 50 tar- get tokens. F1 and F2 values extracted using Praat (Boersma Bates, D., Mächler, M., Bolker, B., and Walker, S. (2015). Fitting linear mixed-effects models using lme4. Journal of Statistical Software, 67(1):1–48. et al., 2002), Nearey normalized (Nearey, 1977). Praat settings: Boersma, P. et al. (2002). Praat, a system for doing phonetics by computer. Glot interna- male: 5000 Hz, 5 formants; female: 5500 Hz, 5 formants; Our reference vowels are tional, 5(9/10):341–345. closer under Nearey normalization. Compared with other normalization procedures, it He, W. and Rao, D. (2013). Sichuan Chengduhua yinxi cihui diaocha yanjiu (A survey of preserves effectively phonemic and sociolinguistic variation while at the same time mini- Sichuan Chengdu dialect). Press. Hu, H. and Zhang, Y. (2017). Path of vowel raising in Chengdu dialect of Mandarin. In mize physiological variation. Proceedings of 29th North American Conference on Chinese Linguistics. Language attitude questionnaire: Labov, W. (2001). Principles of linguistic change Volume 2: Social factors. Blackwell. • 30 multiple choice ques- Li, A. (2018). A variationist analysis of locative markers in Chengdu dialect. In New tions to examine participants’ Ways of Analyzing Variation 47. Liang, D. (1982). Sichuan fangyan yu putonghua (Sichuan dialect and Mandarin). language attitude towards the Sichuan People’s Press. Chengdu dialect and their lo- Nakagawa, S. and Schielzeth, H. (2013). A general and simple method for obtaining cal identity after the interview. R2 from generalized linear mixed-effects models. Methods in Ecology and Evolution, • 5-level Likert scale. 4(2):133–142. Nearey, T. M. (1977). Phonetic feature systems for vowels. PhD thesis, University of 2 • Total score as language atti- model AIC BIC LogLik R Alberta. Reprinted 1978 by the Indiana University Linguistics Club. tude index for each informant. F 1 ∼ age + context + randEff -846.5 -798.2 433.2 0.300 Yang, S. (1984). Sichuan fangyan diaocha baogao (A report on Sichuan Dialect). Institute (For example: Question: Which language F 1 ∼ gender + context + randEff -847.2 -803.7 432.6 0.295 of Linguistics Academia Sinica. F 1 ∼ lg.att. + context + randEff -847.9 -804.4 432.9 0.303 do you prefer to use on daily occasions? Zhen, S. (1958). Chengdu yuyin de chubu yanjiu (A preliminary phonological analysis of F 1 ∼ age ∗ gender + context + randEff -854.9 -792.1 440.5 0.367 chengdu dialect). Journal of Sichuan University, (1):5–34. Scoring of the response: Chengdu dialect-5; more Chengdu dialect-4; Both-3; more stan- • /ian/ and /Can/: most extreme environments F 1 ∼ age ∗ gender ∗ lg.att. + context + randEff -862.6 -770.8 450.3 0.410 Zhen, S. (1983). Sichuan fangyan de biweiyun (Nasal codas in Sichuan dialect). dard Mandarin-2; standard Mandarin-1). (Li, 2018) • Wider range for /ian/ within the oldest age group b/c females Table: Models and their fit, by lme4 (Bates et al., 2015), w/ max Fangyan(Dialect), (4):241–243. 2 Linear mixed effects model: more advanced in raising → similar to the younger age groups likelihood. R for fixed effects (Nakagawa and Schielzeth, 2013). Zhen, S., Hao, X., and Chen, S. (1960). Sichuan fangyan yinxi (Phonlogy of Sichuan dialect). Journal of Sichuan University, 3. Fixed effects: → evidence for /ian/ raising first • Likelihood ratio test of lg.att.-only model vs. full model: • Age: 15-20, 20-30, >40 • 2 younger age groups very similar We thank Prof. Ken de Jong for helpful discussions and Prof. Mark Aronoff for • Gender: male, female p = 0.00014 → prefers full model (so does AIC, but not BIC) invaluable suggestions. Hai Hu is supported by Scholarship Council. • Language attitude: scores from the above questionnaire • In the full model, all four predictors significant (age**, • Vowel context: /ian/, /yan/, /uan/, /(C)an/ gender**, lg.att.***, context***) • Note: lg.att. ∼ age ∗ gender: R2 = 0.2471 → lg.att. not Random effects: subject, word, annotator completely predictable from age and gender → could be in- cluded in the model