TJo+E NEWS-ENTERPRISE 11m SUNDAY, MAY 6, 2012

DEATH S Court: State not liable "" Bobby Carlile Dunaway Mary Catherine Mulhall Willmoth in informant's slaying Bobby Carlile Dunaway, 82, retired engineer. died Mary Catherine Mulhall WilhnOlh, 95, of Elizabeth· By BREIT HARKOUQ.UERE May 4, 2012, at Sljoseph Hospital in Lexington. to ... 'I1, pass<.od away peacefully on Thunday May 3, 2012. The A._.. ,...t I~ Mr. Dunaway WM born May 25, 1929, to the late She was born in SI. john on Sept. 22, 1917. She mar· Albert CMler and Roberta Young Dun­ ried David Lollg Wmmoth Sr. injWle 1939 and for 30 LOUlSVI.ll.E - Police informant Le Bron Gai­ away. I-Ie retired from Nolin RECC after years they owned and operated Hardin County Imple­ ther got into a car for a conlrolled drug buy in j uly 20 years, where he was manager of oper­ ment Co. in Elizabethtown. She was a longtime member 1996 with a man named J ason Noel. Gaither had ations and engi neering and served in the ofSt.james Catholic Chureh and very active in the com· been unaware someone ti pped Noel 10 his role M a U,S. Air Force during the &:>rean War for munitYa! a Realtor. police informant as the two drove from Taylorsville to four yean. Bobby was a lifelong member She was preceded in death by her husband, David Cuey County. of the U K Alumni Association, the AmCf'­ Long WilLnoth Sr.; her parents, Nell French and Albert That's where police laler found Gaither's body at­ ican Legion, Elizabethtown Industrial Mulhall; her sisler, Lucy Thomas; and brothers joseph, ler he was tortured, stabbed, beaten and killed. Foundation, was a Rotary member in \;~~,..U Charles and Lawrence Mulhall. Even though Gaither died while working for Ken­ E1i7.abe!htown and served as a chairman DuNAWAY She ...·as the loying mother of David 1... (Hanni) Will­ tucky State Police, his family cannot collect any dam­ of planning and zoning for eight years. moth jr. of }-:li7.abe!h town, Ann (Roben Stettner) Will· ages from the Kentucky j ustice Wid Public Safety Surviving relativcs includehi~ loving wife of 54 years. moth of Atlanta, Kay Willmolh of Chicago and Mark Cabinet or troopers, the Kenlucky Court of Appeals Sally Martin Dunaway; IWO children. Clay Carlile Dun­ (Lynda Clark) Will moth of Louisville; proud grandmolh· nlled Friday. The Kentucky Board of Claims award­ away of Lexington and Kru-en A l exan d ~r D l~ naway ,of er of David (Carol) Wil hllolh I II of Lexillb'ion. jana ed Gaither's family $168,000. Franklin Circuit judge New Jersey; two sisters, A1lean Blose of ~ve r.llde, CaM., Thomas Wingate overturned Ihal decision in 20\ I. and tilean Classen of Chal!!worth, Calif,; one brother, (David) Bollinger, j ohn (Kru-en) Willmoth of LouisvUle, Marilyn Will molh and Robert Willmoth II; and cher­ The appeals court ruling u~ h?lds Wingate's d~sion . Willianl DWlaway of Glendale, Calif.; a nephew. Henry judge Michelle Keller, JOllied by J udge M.ichael 'Ibompson Nichola! III of Newport Coast, Calif.; an ished great·grandmother of Clay and Cole Bollinger, Caperton. wrote the actions of detectivell involved aunt, Marcella Martin Leach; and cousins. the Il.ev. Al­ Ben, Abbey and Cooper Willmoth and Davis and Kayla were protected by govemmentallmmllnity. ben Gicsler and the Rev. j ohn ThomM Dunaway and Robyn; sistCTJ·in-Iaw, Alice Mulhall of E1 izabethlown ~A1though the choices made by the detectives in Susan Dunaway. and Alice Mulhall of Sun City West, Ariz.; and eight The funeral is 10:30 a.m. Friday at Kerr Il rothers )'-u­ nieces and nephews and their families. Ihis case proved to be tragically nawed, the execution of the undercover operation with leBron was left 10 ncral Home in l..cxington with burial to follow in Ihe The funer.u is 11 a.m. Tuesday at St. james Catholic the discretion and judgment of the delectives. ~ Keller LexinbBeastie Boys were on me ative visionary." Margaret Kelly Shumate, 91, of Vine G~oye , went .to Beastie Boy of his most ramous and so many oth ers.n Adam Nalhanial heaven Th~:~ May 3, 2012, at Hardin Memorial rhymes was a sweet ode Yauch was an integral, Yauch, born in Brooklyn, Hospital in Er thtown. influential to women, which he founding member 10 the formed the Beastie Boys Mrs. Shumate was a native of Vine Grove, She was a called · Iong overdue": ever·weaving trio: three with high school friend devoted member of St. Brigid Catholic Church in Vine in hip hop ~To all the mothers and l ewish kids from New Diamond. Originally COIl· Grove and the Altar Society. For many years she made sisters and wiveJ and York who fOWld wide· ceived as a hardoore punk rosaries for the miu ioru in Louio;ville, which senl thenl to By JAKE COYLE mends! I want to offer spread respect in a hip" group, they played their missions all over the world. She was retired from the U.S. Arr_...... W"... my love and ~ to hop world \\-1th few credi- first show on Youch's 17th AmlY and Air Force Exchange Servjce at Fon Knox af­ the end." ble white penomlers. bin hday. ter 20 years of service. NEW YORK - When When the news came In a span of more than In the letler read at the She was preceded in death by her husband, Ralph the Beastie BoYI were in­ Friday thai earlier Ihal a quarter century that Rock and Roll Hall of Winfred Shumate; her father and stepmother, Hugh Wid ducted into the Rock and morning, Yauch, 47, had covered four No. 1 al- Fame induction, Yauc h Ollie 'Ibornberry; her mother, Mary Letitia Hamilton; Roll Hall of Fame just died afler a nearly tl l r~'e' bums and more than 40 recalled their early days an d two brothel1l, j ames and William Thornberry. weeks ago, the New York year battle witli cWlcer, million records sold, tJle al his parents' home in Her survivors include three children, Mary Gail Keit h trio Wa! down a man. the words from his letter Beastie Boys played bolh Brookl yn, "where we of Vine Grove. Robert J. Shumate and his wife, Teri, of Michael ~ Mike D~ felt particularly apl The prankster and pioneer- a used to pructitt on hOi l:Jil.O\bethlown and Gary Shumate and his wife, Susie, of Diamond and Adwn "Ad· outpouring of sadness at simultaneously goofy and Brooklyn slimmer days Vine Grove; one sister, Marty Bickett of Florence, S.c.; Rock" Horovil7. lOOk the the lou, and celebration gmundbreaking act that aflef school, windows one brother, Don Thornberry ofLouisvilJe; 10 grandchil· stage with a letter from of the music Yauch helped bring hip-hop to open to disturb Ihe neigh- dren, Dennis Lyons. Ronnie Lyo[U., Tmcy Brown. Karen their miu ing band mate: helped crealed, wa5 im- the mainstream. borhood." Penny,joe Keith, Ryan Shumale, Martin Shumale,j amie Adam "MCA~ Yau ch, mediate and vast, shared T he demure, gray. The group became a Chenault, KwKli Fortune and Andrea Pelley; Wid lever· who was too ill to attend. across social media by haired Yauch wasn't the hip.hop trio soon after aI great.grandchildren and great-great-grandchildren. He .... as suffering from a those close to him, rap· mOSI boastful B.Boy; he Horovitz joined and coo­ A MaJ!I of Christian burial for Mrs. Shumate is at 11 cancerous salivary glwld pers inIluenccd by "Paul's was Ihoughtful and 1\ I~ after Yauch drop­ a.m. Tuesday, May 8, at St. Brigid Catholic Church in first diagnosed in 2009. Boutique- and hip,hop steady source of the trio's plod out of Bard College Vine Grove with the Rev. Daniel Lincoln offi ciating. In the letter, which listeners raised on Beastie ,wo y"_ ·,'uo h·,, ,''' d,·" . Burial follows in St. Brigid Cemetery in Vi ne Groye, Horoyitz "ead, Yauch B0l;,vidcos. innovative spiril A prat- "', ~ _ ~~.I.L ' "h licing Buddhist, he led the They re e~ melr C art- Visitation is from noon to 8 p.m, Monday and at 9 dedicattod the honor to his e rapper Q:l'ip, a gToup in performing con- topping debut "Licensed a.m, l \lesday at Coffey & Chism }-\meral Home in Vine fellow B·Boys. ~who have member of another major certs to benefil Tibet and, to 1Il ~ in 1986, a raucous Grove where there is a prayer service at 7 p.m. Monday, walked the globe wilh n New York hip · h~ group, as a filmmaker, he helped album led by the anthem Condolences can be expressed at www.coffeyand me. A l obe Called QueSl, re- create their imagery. "(you Gotta) Fight for chism.com. "To anyone who has called the Beastie BoY' ~ ~Th e ' m US.IC v~"I .... u ru,h, I~o" nU~ _yL '. ) " . been touched by OUf " h cd h group , band, who our music has &!w "D~d~ ~ e ~bs crossed genres and color It was the ~TSl hi~~ Elvira Marie Yoge meant iIOmethillg to, this called Yauch -a true pio. lines, and helped bring album to top e Bi ~ E1yira Marie Voge, 74, orRadcliff, died Monday, April induction i, as much ours neer and a creative rOTCe rap to a wider audience, ~ chart, and while it re­ 30, 2012, at her home. as it is yours," said Yauch. who paved the ....ay for so said Neil Portnow, presi. mains popular, its irrever­ She was a member of House offuyer LUlheran Chur­ It ....as typical generosi­ many of u s .~ The rapper dent of the Recording enl rock-rap fusion bore ch in Elizabethtown. ty from Yauch, the gravel· NM lamented the loss of a Academy. ~Yauch 1'"<13 an few hints of an act with Survivors include her husband of 54 years, Donald D. Iy-voiced rapper who "brother": - MCA was Immense talent and cre- staying power. Voge of Ra dcliff; two sons, Donald D. Vogc II of Radcliff hclpo:.-cl make the Beastie so cool,n he said. r-----~=~~~::-:~~::_----., an d Ed win j oseph Voge of Louisvi lle; a grandson, Boy, one of the seminal For Eminem, Yauch NOTIct: Of PUUUC II£AlUNG NOIIc. 10 I>o ....y fi"u lb., lb. Ilardi" County l'l ... u'i"ll ..,d Donald D. Voge TIl of Radcliff; and two sbters. groups ill hip.hop (tnd was an undeniah Ie l)t,.. lopmoD' com...... lon wllll>oId I public IMooslnl" 5:3(1 p.m, (>0 The funeraf bat 11 a. m. Monday. May 7, al Neoon­ touchstone: "I think it's -n-ioy IS MIY WI ~ . In ,110 Itn f110 eounM.... , Third f1 _I''lI"ool whose good-hearted na­ ...... n Bulldi,.. c..iden.tIoo will bo III"'" to ~ ...... ,..i"ll .....p Edelen-Bennett Funeral Home in Radcliff with I'astor rure led him to humanis­ obvious to anyone how "- .... Con~ Commert:W ...... (t-I) 10 ,ho Iuno! Roo;d" .nial 7...... (1·2) lor .11 __ 10 be ~ lor MMld... uol Pu~ Tbo Pamda Thorson oiflciating. Burial follows in North Har­ tic causes and made him b ig an in nuenee t he l"rnpo<1y lfl_ooI .. 645ZS. I>I .... H!p_y.GI-=IoIo. KeIolod:y. di n Memorial Gardens in Radcliff. Visitation is from 6 to 8 p.m, today and at 10 a.m. Monday at the funeral home. ~==:::::::::=; Condolences lIlay be expressed at www.nebfu.com. Keith Monument Kathleen Walker ~ [1!J - Serving Kentucky's families since 1867 -- Kathleen Walker, 73, of San Diego, formerly of Eliza­ Mault.-" M, ..-..· a.... '" bethtown, died Tuesday, May 1,20\2, at San Diego Hos­ NIW ..N'" _ , I'M MM _wIoe- ·...... - Nt.nt. pice. Survivors include two daughters, Leslie Ayers and 2091 Loitt:~fi.1d lid. Elillblilhll'wn Toni Ayers; and a son,j ohn C. Ayers. 210-769-6341 ChI"I, IIbo mSO<1O" & UPlon The funeral is alii a.m. Monday at Pe rcell & Sons 21G-369,l444 Funeral Home in Elizabethtown with buri.1.I in Eliza­ bethtown Cily Cemetery". Visitation begins at 6 p.m. today at the fWlerai home, CjJt~~-;Z;e • SERVICE S FUNERAL HOME AftOldablo tunoml!> for every faml f, . Ylvlan MarIe GreenIg EIlutls, 2012. The funeral is at 11 89. died Tuesday. May 1. a.m. today at Ramse~ fl)­ 2012. The fur.eral Is at 11 ne ral Home In lancaster with "But I've already Tim Thomas, Roxmm King, a.m. Monday at Seatonville oorial ln Paint lick ceme t er~. Derek Keith, Tim Dixoll Congregational Church in Fra,* CIIarIes IMt Jr~ 66. prearranged. " Sprir'C Valley. III. Burial fol­ of Eastview. died Thursday. lows in valley Memorial Pm April 19. 2012. A memorial It hu been an honor and privilege In Sprln& Valley. Visitation Is 1f)'GII1Ine flm'llllII aI,.PI."II'Il service Is from 5 to 8 p.m. from 5 to 8 p.m. tQday at 11M cIqId 'flU pref...:t iI MnI ror our ramily to have helped your Ba(\o funeral Home in Wednesday al Pritchard 1Ion, )GI' be hippy IG PlIw Ihal IIIese ramily theae put 142 yean. Sprirc Valley. Community Center In Eliza. .'."I.ib ... ~CiIIII&, f1'anc:ts I\endIrson lamb. bethtown, M!WlBkee Funeral II'Il "', be ..1G east 'flU n*d. 83. of Crescent View in Paint Home Is In charge of ar· Lick, died Monday. April 30. rangements. D LXON· ATWOOD Tradition, Quality, Service," ~~ TROWB R I DGE Today's community !-un"nol Hom" 1407 N. Dixi e l lighw:ty Eliz:tbet.htown, KY 42701 t1ij{K\ calendar can be found :tt the Entr:tnce to Freeman Lake .. on page D5. (270) 169-5925 • (800) 513-3539 ~w