J Indian Philos https://doi.org/10.1007/s10781-018-9368-0 An Early Modern Account of the Views of the Miśras Christopher Minkowski1 © The Author(s) 2018 Abstract In a doxography of views called the Ṣaṭtantrīsāra, a seventeenth century commentator and Advaitin, Nı¯lakantha Caturdhara, describes the doctrines of a ˙˙ group he calls the Mis´ras. Nı¯lakantha represents the doctrines of the Mis´ras as in ˙˙ most ways distinct from those of the canonical positions that usually appear in such doxographies, both a¯stika and na¯stika. And indeed, some of the doctrines he describes resemble those of the Abrahamic faiths, concerning the creator, a per- manent afterlife in heaven or hell, and the unique births of souls. Other doctriness are difficult to associate with any known South Asian religion, for example the emphasis placed on astrological determinism in the moral economy of the creation. As the Ṣaṭtantrīsāra is unpublished to date, a preliminary edition of those portions that concern the Mis´ras is presented here, together with a translation, notes, and some further discussion. Though the identification is not certain, it seems most likely that the views Nı¯lakantha describes in this text belonged to Vanama¯lı¯ Mis´ra, a ˙˙ North Indian Ma¯dhva who had lived in the Ganges-Yamuna doab in the mid to late seventeenth century. Even if that identification turns out to be correct, many questions remain. Keywords Mis´ra · Nı¯lakantha Caturdhara · Vanama¯limis´ra · Doxography · ˙˙ Advaita · Astrology · Hell · Madhva · Abrahamic religions & Christopher Minkowski
[email protected] 1 The Oriental Institute, University of Oxford, Pusey Lane, Oxford OX1 2LE, UK 123 C.