RABIES CASE FOR GLOBAL ELIMINATION
Dr Bernadette ABELA-RIDDER Team Leader, Neglected Zoonotic Diseases Department of the Control of Neglected Tropical Diseases 17 Neglected Tropical Diseases Protozoan Infections ¾ Leishmaniasis Helminth Infections ¾ Human African trypanosomiasis ¾ Chagas disease ¾ Soil-transmitted helminth infections ¾ Ascariasis-Trichuriasis-Hookworm ¾ Lymphatic filariasis ¾ Onchocerciasis ¾ Schistosomiasis ¾ Dracunculiasis (guinea-worm disease) ¾ Cysticercosis ¾ Echinococcosis ¾ Foodborne trematodes infections
Bacterial Infections ¾ Leprosy ¾ Trachoma Viral Infections ¾ Buruli ulcer ¾ Dengue ¾ Endemic treponematoses ¾ RABIES
Dr Bernadette ABELA-RIDDER [email protected] - Webinar on Rabies Prevention and Control Tools in Asia - 30 June 2015 WHO Roadmap for rabies…. Can we commit to go further?
Dr Bernadette ABELA-RIDDER [email protected] - Webinar on Rabies Prevention and Control Tools in Asia - 30 June 2015 Rationale for investment: Freedom from dog- mediated human rabies is a global public good WHO, FAO, OIE, GARC unite to eliminate human rabies and control the disease in animals
1. Rabies disproportionately burdens poor rural communities
2. Dog-mediated human rabies can be eliminated by vaccinating dogs
3. Rabies is preventable yet continues to kill
4. Rabies elimination is feasible
Dr Bernadette ABELA-RIDDER [email protected] - Webinar on Rabies Prevention and Control Tools in Asia - 30 June 2015 Start small: Make the case
KZN Project Success 2007-2014 7 500 2010 473 450 2013 6 BMGF 400 BMGF 23% 4% 5 350 335 4 300 270 Human250 220 KZN KZN 3 Animal200 183 185 77% 96% 2 150 100 1 80 37 50 0 0 7 8 9 1011121314 Philippines, 2007-2015 450 400 410 350 300 250
200 202 150 118 100
50 75 75 80 60 72 21 0 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015
Dr Bernadette ABELA-RIDDER [email protected] - Webinar on Rabies Prevention and Control Tools in Asia - 30 June 2015 Catalysing expansion 3. 4. 1.
1. Swaziland 5. 2. Eastern Cape 3. Mozambique 4. Mpumalanga 5. Orange Free State 6. 6. Lesotho 7. Other Countries –Kenya –Congo –Senegal 2.
Dr Bernadette ABELA-RIDDER [email protected] - Webinar on Rabies Prevention and Control Tools in Asia - 30 June 2015 Rabies Free Zones 9 of the 15 Visayas group of islands declared jointly by DA and DOH rabies free
Region 6: 1. Guimaras 2. Boracay
Region 7: Region 8: 1. Siquijor 1. Biliran 2. Apo Island 2. Limasawa 3. Camotes 4. Malapascua Island 5. Olympia
Dr Bernadette ABELA-RIDDER [email protected] - Webinar on Rabies Prevention and Control Tools in Asia - 30 June 2015 Demonstrate Decrease in bites, decrease in PEP use, decrease in rabies (Tanzania)
Dr Bernadette ABELA-RIDDER [email protected] - Webinar on Rabies Prevention and Control Tools in Asia - 30 June 2015 Surveillance data for planning, monitoring and evaluation • Knowing the extent of the problem and where
• Breaking the transmission in high risk communities and corridors
• Forecasting of vaccine needs (animal and human)
• Monitoring and evaluation of interventions & their impact • ….
Dr Bernadette ABELA-RIDDER [email protected] - Webinar on Rabies Prevention and Control Tools in Asia - 30 June 2015 Lessons learnt: Think big, start small, scale up
• Vaccinate the dogs and break the cycle
• Cross sectorial collaboration - One health • Surveillance (also to show absence of disease) • Awareness and education • Wound cleaning and post-exposure prophylaxis
Dr Bernadette ABELA-RIDDER [email protected] - Webinar on Rabies Prevention and Control Tools in Asia - 30 June 2015
Global conference Global elimination of dog-mediated human rabies - The Time Is Now 10-11 December 2015, WHO Headquarters, Geneva, Switzerland
1. Disseminate results of the proof of concept for the elimination of dog-transmitted rabies in different settings and explore expansion and sustainability in other endemic areas;
2. Build support and case for investment to progress towards rabies elimination from national, regional, global and other stakeholders including the private sector;
3. Promote a One Health inter-sectoral collaboration approach between the human and animal health and other sectors;
4. Shape the forward vision agenda with shared purpose including with donors and stakeholders for the elimination of dog-transmitted human rabies.
Dr Bernadette ABELA-RIDDER [email protected] - Webinar on Rabies Prevention and Control Tools in Asia - 30 June 2015 Rationale for investment: Freedom from dog- mediated human rabies is a global public good WHO, FAO, OIE, GARC unite to eliminate human rabies and control the disease in animals
1. Rabies disproportionately burdens poor rural communities
2. Dog-mediated human rabies can be eliminated by vaccinating dogs
3. Rabies is preventable yet continues to kill
4. Rabies elimination is feasible
Dr Bernadette ABELA-RIDDER [email protected] - Webinar on Rabies Prevention and Control Tools in Asia - 30 June 2015
The Blueprint for Rabies Control
Per capita human death rates from canine rabies
Hampson et al., 2015
Rabies • Ancient! • Most Fatal Disease! • Completely Preventable Why Neglected?
Rural communities: -Poverty -Remote location -Poor infrastructure -Negligible health care Who is responsible? 1. Dogs not economically vital 2. Public health impact not appreciated Underreporting: Veterinary neglect Laboratory diagnosis of free roaming non-existent and dogs. misdiagnosis common
Global health agenda: Dog rabies in developing world Less newsworthy than novel strains of influenza or coronaviruses etc. Rabies: - Most Fatal Disease -Completely Preventable Why Neglected?
Who is responsible? Rural communities: -Poverty 1. Dogs not economically vital -Remote location 2. Public health impact not Veterinary appreciated -Poor infrastructure neglect of -Negligiblegg health care free roaminging dogs. Underreporting: Global health agenda: Laboratory Dog rabies in developing diagnosis non- world existent and Less newsworthy than misdiagnosis novel strains of influenza common or coronaviruses etc.
Global Alliance for Rabies Control
2007 World Rabies Day
2008 Partners for Rabies Prevention
2010 2011-2015 2013-2015
Rabiesblueprint.com Burden of rabies HE of rabies www.RabiesBlueprint.org
CanineRabiesBlueprint.org
Very collaborative effort
Online, freely available
Third version completed Sept 2014
Promoted through the networks
Google analytics suggest that usage is increasing Overview of the Site CANINE RABIES BLUEPRINT PAGES 1. Introduction 9 2. Roles and Responsibilities 2 3. Infrastructure, legislative framework, costs and funding 3.1. Infrastructure 11 3.2. Legislation 15 3.3. Costs and Funding 7 4. Communications plan 4.1. Importance of an effective communication plan 1 4.2. Developing a communication plan 8 4.3. Evaluating the campaign and its impact 4 5. Operational activities 5.1. What do we need to know before we start planning a programme? 17 5.2. What do we need to buy? 6 5.3. Who do we need to train and in what? 4 5.4. What are we going to do – dog component? 20 5.5. What are we going to do – human component? 6 5.6 Evaluation 5 5.7. How do we ensure sustainability of the programme? 1 6. A stepwise approach to planning and evaluation 10 LINKS Case studies 22 Documents 112 Navigation Searching and by component Example of a regular page From the Communications section Example of a documents page A Case Study Another Case Study Tools for Advocacy Rabies Educator certificate
South Africa Philippines Rabies Educator Certificate
The Rabies Educator Certificate (REC) program is a free online course for community educators, public health workers and anyone interested in learning how to prevent rabies in their communities.
Pan African Rabies Control Network
We need to stand together
Developing a Stepwise Approach towards (Dog- Transmitted) Rabies Elimination (SARE)
Katinka de Balogh Senior Officer – Veterinary Public Health Animal Health Service Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations 48 Global Rabies Burden: A Public Health Concern
• Neglected and re-emerging zoonotic disease • 50-70,000 estimated human rabies cases per year • Rabies is closely linked to poverty
• Over 95% of all human rabies deaths are observed in Asia and Africa
• Over 99% of the human rabies cases reported are due to dog- bites
49
One Health
• Rabies control best to follow the One Health approach The One Health – Rabies requires coordinated response concept addresses by veterinary and public health health risks at the services animal, human and – It is a human health problem which environmental has social and economic dimensions interface in order to as well as costs in the animal health enhance human and animal sector wellbeing and welfare, and sustainable Human rabies transmitted by dogs management of the can be eliminated! environment.
50 Surveillance and Human laboratory Health diagnostics Post exposure Sector Public prophylaxis awareness LEGISLATION, Animal bite POLITICAL reporting and wound Animal SUPPORT treatment vaccination AND FUNDING Municipal & community Dog engagement population Surveillance control Animal and laboratory Health diagnostics Sector 51 Rabies is a vaccine preventable disease
Challenges: • Making Post-exposure prophylaxis accessible and affordable
• Increasing vaccination of dogs against rabies
• Importance of animal bite clinics
52 Question for you …
In your country are people more at risk of dying of rabies?
1. In urban areas 2. In rural areas 3. Don’t know
53 Countries/municipalities are often overwhelmed when dealing with (human) rabies outbreaks….
• Fear • Political/social pressure, • Lack of resources • Lack of available and accessible Post-exposure prophlaxis (PEP) • Low vaccination rate of dogs…..
54
Why develop a stepwise approach?
Goal of SARE: I. Provide a structured approach II. Enable countries to define the “Stage” of rabies control they are in III. Provide defined “keys” to move to a next stage (measure progress) IV. Indicated links to relevant sections of the rabiesblueprint
Role of FAO: I. To assist countries in getting started and implement SARE
55
Rabies Stakeholder Consultations Kick-starting integrated rabies control
DRC Kenya Republic of Congo
Cameroun Gabon Cameroun Georgia Regional Meetings Vietnam 56 Stepwise Approach: How does it work?
6 stages to move from endemic to free from human rabies transmitted by dogs
Endemic FREE
List of achievements (keys) essential to move to the next stage
57 FAO-GARC SARE-TOOL (version July 2014) 58 59
COUNTRY ENDEMIC FOR DOG TRANSMITTED RABIES Stage 0
No information on rabies available but rabies 0 suspected to be present
Key to move from Stage 0 to Stage 1: Rabies occurrence in any species is reported to international agencies
60
61
Stage 1
Assessment of the local rabies epidemiology, elaboration of a short term rabies action plan 1
Key to move from Stage 1 to Stage 2: Functional intersectoral rabies task force in place, rabies is a notifiable disease (in humans and animals)
62
63
Direct links to the rabies Stage 1 blueprint
Assessment of the local rabies epidemiology, elaboration of a short term rabies action plan 1
Key to move from Stage 1 to Stage 2: Functional intersectoral rabies task force in place, rabies is a notifiable disease (in humans and animals)
64
Stage 2
Development of the national rabies prevention and control strategy 2
Key to move from Stage 2 to Stage 3: National rabies prevention and control strategy endorsed and funded
65 FAO-GARC SARE-TOOL (version July 2014) 66 Determining the SARE Stage and need
67 WHANT TO LEARN MORE ABOUT SARE? 68 Access SARE Online
http://caninerabiesblueprint.org/The- Stepwise-Approach-towards http://caninerabiesblueprint.org/IMG/pdf /canine_rabies_blueprint_v3_- =_stepwise_approach_to_planning_and _evaluation.pdf
69
Thank You
Questions?
Contact: [email protected] 70 RABIES The International Standards
Dr Gregorio Torres - [email protected]
LinkTADs webinar on rabies prevention and control tools in Asia
71 World Organisation for Animal Health
Established in 1924 5 regions 180 countries http://www.oie.int
Mandate of the OIE “to improve animal health and animal welfare world-wide”
72 Our mandate
• Transparency (WAHIS)
• Veterinary scientific information (disease control)
• Safe Trade (WTO)
73 Outline
• Standard setting procedures
• Terrestrial animal health code • Rabies • Stray dog population control
• Manual of diagnostics and vaccines
• One Health and vaccine banks
74 OIE terrestrial animals standards
• Terrestrial Code: Standards for disease control and safe international trade
• Terrestrial Manual: Standards for laboratory diagnostic methods and requirements for the production and control of vaccines
http://www.oie.int/en/international-standard-setting/overview/ 75 OIE standard setting procedure
Member participation
Democratic Transparent
Science based Rapid & flexible
International collaboration
Well-established
76 Commissions, Request OIE delegates, stakeholders Specialist Commissions (Scientific & Code)
Development of Support (Expert Advice: international Ad hoc Groups) standards Specialist Commissions (Scientific & Code)
Draft text Member Countries OIE Comments ASSEMBLY INTERNATIONAL STANDARD Adoption 77 OIE international standards on rabies
• Terrestrial Animal Health Code
• Manual of Diagnostic tests and Vaccines for Terrestrial Animals
78 OIE international standards on rabies
Vertical Horizontal
Chapter 7.7 Chapter 8.12 Stray dogs Infection with population Rabies virus control
Chapter 5.11 Chapter 1.1 Certificate Notification
Chapter 2.1.13 Chapter 1.4 Rabies (Manual) Surveillance
79 Cap. 8.12. Infection with Rabies virus
• General provisions • Case definition, hosts, incubation period • Control rabies in dogs • Notifiable, surveillance, diagnostic, stray dog management • Rabies Free Country (self-declaration) • Surveillance, notification, preventive measures • No indigenous case in the last 2 years • Recommendation for importation • Certification Chapter 5.11 • Dogs, cats, ferrets, ruminants, equids, camelids, suids, rodents, wildlife
AIM: Mitigate the risk of rabies transmision to human and to prevent the international spread of the disease
80 Cap. 7.7 Stray dog population control
• Within the OIE animal welfare section
• It addresses humane methods for the control of dog populations and the prevention of zoonotic diseases
• It is not exclusively for rabies
• Outline: Dog ecology, programme components, control measures
Responsible Ownership it is key in rabies control 81 Cap. 2.1.13. Rabies
• Summary
• Section A. Introduction (aetiology)
• Section B. Diagnostic techniques • Sample Collection and shipment • Identification of the agent • Serological test
• Section C. Requirement for vaccines • For injectable use • For oral use
82 Rabies - One Health Concept
… rabies control is a Public Good to “ be considered a priority model to apply the One Health concept...” The OIE is committed to supporting the efforts of the international community to achieve worldwide elimination of dog mediated rabies in humans
83 Vaccine banks
• Benefits : quality (OIE Manual), costs vs benefits, speed and logistics, better coordination
• Asia. Afghanistan, Bangladesh, Bhutan, Indonesia, Lao PDR, Myanmar, Nepal, Philippines*, Singapore, Sri Lanka and Vietnam.
• Africa. Mali, South Africa*, Togo
• Cooperation (*) WHO Global Procurement and Logistics
84 Conclusions
• International Standards agreed by Member Countries
• Technical texts for international trade (WTO)
• Provide guidance and support on disease control measures and surveillance
• Dynamic and adjusting to new circumstances
85 Thank you for your attention!
86 Principles and Practices for Rapid Rabies Control
30 June, 2015
Eric Brum, DVM, MSc Team Leader – FAO ECTAD Bangladesh
FAO Bangladesh Principles and Practices for Rapid Rabies Control
FAO Bangladesh Epidemiological foundation of disease control • To control an infectious disease, must decrease the rate of new infections • R0 = basic reproductive number = the expected number of secondary infections resulting from one single infection in a completely susceptible population • Example: 1 person with measles spreads the disease to 10 other people Æ R0 = 10
• R0 > 1 Æ number of new infections will increase over time • R0 = 1 Æ number of new infections will remain stable over time • R0 < 1 Æ number of new infections will decrease over time
FAO Bangladesh What’s the Ro of rabies in humans?
Zero. Humans are a dead-end host! -
Thus, the R0 of rabies cannot be decreased by dealing only with humans /
Dogs are the virus reservoir and source of 99% of the infections to humans and other “non-flying” mammals.
FAO Bangladesh Why is the rabies virus different in dogs? Why is the rabies Ro > 1 in dogs?
1. Dogs are social animals.
FAO Bangladesh FAO Bangladesh FAO Bangladesh FAO Bangladesh FAO Bangladesh FAO Bangladesh Why is the rabies virus different in dogs? Why is the rabies Ro > 1 in dogs?
1. Dogs are social animals.
2. Dogs interact with the world through their teeth.
FAO Bangladesh What are ways to decrease R0?
• R0 is directly proportional to 3 factors:
*
transmissibility contact rate duration of infection Tools
no change no change Stamping out
no change Vaccination
no change no change Sterilization
Rapid response to no change no change suspect dogs (if you’re fast!) *from J.H. Jones 2007 FAO Bangladesh Why is it so challenging to rely on case detection to control rabies in dogs?
1. The incubation period can be very long.
FAO Bangladesh FAO Bangladesh FAO Bangladesh FAO Bangladesh FAO Bangladesh Why is it so challenging to rely on case detection to control rabies in dogs?
1. The incubation period can be very long.
2. Clinical rabies is actually quite difficult to detect. Biting may be the only obvious sign.
FAO Bangladesh Ok, so why not just cull dogs to control rabies?
1. Only temporary decrease in contact rate achieved (e.g. only temporary decease in R0). 2. Dogs are social animals so contact rate does not decrease in direct proportion to decreased density. 3. Decreases community support for rabies control activities, making disease eradication difficult.
FAO Bangladesh So how can we decrease the R0?
• R0 is directly proportional to 3 factors:
*
transmissibility contact rate duration of infection Tools
no change no change Stamping out
no change Vaccination
no change no change Sterilization
Rapid response to no change no change suspect dogs (if you’re fast!) *from J.H. Jones 2007 FAO Bangladesh Effective dog vaccination
1. Efficacious vaccine
2. Long-lasting immunity
3. Herd immunity • = vaccination threshold • Sufficient immune animals within the target population to protect even those individuals that are not immune (e.g. maintain R0 < 1) • Percentage of immunity required to achieve herd immunity is based on the R0
4. Access to target population
FAO Bangladesh So what’s the R0 of rabies in dogs?
The R0 is between 1 – 2 in dogs.
FAO Bangladesh What percentage of the herd needs to be immune to decrease R0 < 1?
% immune = 1 – (1/R0)
If R0 = 1.5, then % of immune dogs = 1 – (1/1.5) = 33%
The lower the R0, the lower the herd immunity required.
FAO Bangladesh Rabies in comparison to other diseases
Measles R = 10-15 Measles R00 = 10-15
Smallpox FMD R0= ~10 R0= 3-5 Polio R0= 5-7 Rinderpest R0= ~5
Canine Rabies
R0=1-2
FAO Bangladesh If the R0 of rabies is so low, why has it not been eliminated yet like the other diseases?
Good question! -
Simply not enough focus on dog vaccination
FAO Bangladesh So once the vaccination coverage is high, what else can be done?
Keep the vaccinated dogs alive!
The lower the population turnover, the slower the decline in vaccination coverage over time.
FAO Bangladesh And how do we decrease population turnover?
•Decrease death rate •Provide better care (e.g. food, water) •Do not intentionally kill dogs •Decrease birth rate •Surgical sterilization (permanent) •Chemical sterilization (temporary)
FAO Bangladesh Effective vaccination
1. Efficacious vaccine
2. Long-lasting immunity
3. Herd immunity • = vaccination threshold • Sufficient immune animals within the target population to protect even those individuals that are not immune (e.g. maintain R0 < 1) • Percentage of immunity required to achieve herd immunity is based on the R0
4. Access to target population
FAO Bangladesh Which dogs are the most important to vaccinate in order to have the greatest impact on R0?
Dogs with the highest likelihood of encountering the rabies virus.
FAO Bangladesh Which dogs have the highest likelihood of encountering the rabies virus?
Dogs that are not kept in enclosed areas. •Roaming owned dogs •Stray dogs
FAO Bangladesh FAO Bangladesh What’s the best way to vaccinate these outside dogs?
1. Vaccinate them when they’re still puppies! 2. Use collars
FAO Bangladesh FAO Bangladesh FAO Bangladesh What’s the best way to vaccinate these dogs?
1. Vaccinate them when they’re still puppies! 2. Use collars 3. Use nets 4. Work hard and work together!
FAO Bangladesh The power of teamwork
AnjingDogs vaccinateddi vaksinasi
350 300 250 200 DayHari 1 150 100 50 0 Jayo Satri Elang Singa Lapar Gudig Gebar Agam Kincing Garuda Kuning Harimau Nyo-dog Lancang Mabuhai OK Team Klampitan
Day 1: 50 dogs per team
FAO Bangladesh The power of teamwork
AnjingDogs vaccinateddi vaksinasi
350 300 250 200 DayHari 1 150 DayHari 2 100 50 0 Satri Jayo Elang Singa Lapar Gudig Gebar Agam Kincing Garuda Kuning Nyo-dog Harimau Lancang Mabuhai OK Team OK Klampitan
Day 1: 50 dogs per team
FAO Bangladesh The power of teamwork
AnjingDogs vaccinateddi vaksinasi
350 300 250 Hari 1 200 Day 1 DayHari 2 150 DayHari 3 100 50 0 Satri Jayo Elang Singa Lapar Gudig Gebar Agam Kincing Garuda Kuning Nyo-dog Harimau Lancang Mabuhai OK Team OK Klampitan
Day 1: 50 dogs per team Last day: 210 dogs per team
FAO Bangladesh Effective vaccination
1. Efficacious vaccine
2. Long-lasting immunity
3. Herd immunity • = vaccination threshold • Sufficient immune animals within the target population to protect even those individuals that are not immune (e.g. maintain R0 < 1) • Percentage of immunity required to achieve herd immunity is based on the R0 • Reduce population turnover via sterilization and no dog culling to maintain herd immunity as long as possible.
4. Access to target population • Roaming and stray dogs are most important population to target • Dog catching with nets • Permanent collars for vaccinated dogs • Puppy vaccination • Teamwork!
FAO Bangladesh Principles and Practices for Rapid Rabies Control
FAO Bangladesh Impact indicator
Human cases on Bali, 2008-2013
90 80 70 60 50 40 30 20 Human rabies cases rabies Human 10 0 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 Year
Human cases in 2013 decreased by 98% compared to 2010.
FAO Bangladesh Dog vaccination and human cases
Dogs Vaccinated and Human Rabies Cases
140000 10 120000 100000 8 80000 6 60000 4 40000
number of dogs number of 2 20000 cases number of 0 0 Jul-10 Jul-11 Jul-12 Jul-13 Oct-10 Oct-11 Oct-12 Jan-10 Jan-11 Jan-12 Jan-13 Feb-10 Apr-10 Jun-10 Nov-10 Dec-10 Feb-11 Apr-11 Jun-11 Nov-11 Dec-11 Feb-12 Apr-12 Jun-12 Nov-12 Dec-12 Feb-13 Apr-13 Jun-13 Mar-10 Sep-10 Mar-11 Sep-11 Mar-12 Sep-12 Mar-13 May-10 Aug-10 May-11 Aug-11 May-12 Aug-12 May-13
Total Dog Vax Human Cases
FAO Bangladesh FAO Bangladesh Impact of systematic mass dog vaccination
MexicoMexico
Mexico cases 30 years g Number of do Number of Number of dog cases dog Number of Number of human caseshuman cases Number of Number of
Human and Animal Rabies Cases, Bali
1122 80
7700 1100 Bali 60 8 50 6 3 years! - 4400 30 4 2200
numbernumber of of human human cases cases 2 numbernumber of of animal animal cases cases 1100
0 0 1 1 1 1 3 1 3 1 1 3 3 1 1 3 1 1 3 1 3 -10 -1 -12 -10 -1 -12 -1 -10 -1 -12 r-10 r-1 r-12 r-1 y y y y g g g p p p ar-10 ar-1 ar-12 ar-1 p ec-10 p ec-1 p ec-12 p a a a a Jul-13 Jul-12 Jul-11 Jul-10 Jul-10 Jul-1 Jul-12 Jul-1 Oct-12 Oct-11 Oct-10 Oct-10 Oct-1 Oct-12 Jan-13 Jan-12 Jan-11 Jan-10Jan-10 Jan-1 Jan-12 Jan-1 Feb-10 A Jun-10 Nov-10 D Feb-1 A Jun-1 Nov-1 D Feb-12 A Jun-12 Nov-12 D Feb-1 A Jun-1 Apr-13 Jun-13 Feb-13 Nov-12 Dec-12 Apr-12 Jun-12 Feb-12 Nov-11 Dec-11 Apr-11 Jun-11 Feb-11 Nov-10 Dec-10 Apr-10 Jun-10 Feb-10 M Se M Se M Se M Mar-13 Sep-12 Mar-12 Sep-11 Mar-11 Sep-10 Mar-10 M Au M Au M Au M Aug-12 Aug-11 Aug-10 May-13 May-12 May-11 May-10 The “bitter pill” of One Health
Animal health Human health services services
Projected cost to $3,139,221 0 eliminate rabies from Bali
Projected 5-year $-2,899,785 / $11,180,796 - savings as a result of successful elimination
• Internal rate of return = 98%
FAO Bangladesh And what do we do globally?
Of the US$ 583.5 million spent annually: •83% is spent on post-exposure treatment •10% is spent on dog vaccination
Source: Knobel et al. 2005 FAO Bangladesh The persistence of rabies is not due to our neglect. It’s due to our collective ignorance, an ignorance now entrenched within our separated health systems.