DOCSLIB.ORG

Mathematics Reinforces the Certainty of the Absolute Truth That Is God: Speaks a Mathematical Nobel Catholic.Net

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Mathematics Reinforces the Certainty of the Absolute Truth That Is God: Speaks a Mathematical Nobel Catholic.Net Mathematics reinforces the certainty of the absolute truth that is God: speaks a mathematical Nobel Catholic.net It seems incredible, but nobody knows the most important Italian mathematician. Or at least no one outside the scientific world. His name is Enrico Bombieri, the only Italian to have won the Fields Medal, which corresponds to the Nobel prize of mathematicians. He teaches at Princeton University in the United States. The optimal Francesco Agnoli has recently interviewed the prestigious mathematician, who has pondered extensively on the relationship between science and metaphysics, explaining: "for me mathematics is a model of truth, although it is a pretty model restricted by clear rules of consistency, which tells us that an absolute truth (with capital V) must exist even if we cannot comprehend it". And he adds: "Trying to justify the existence of God with mathematics reminds me of the story of St. Augustine when, walking along the seashore meditating on the mystery of the Trinity, he met a boy who collected the water from the sea with a Spoon and threw it carefully into a pail. St. Augustine asked him: Boy, what are you doing? and the young man replied, "I am counting how much water there is in the sea". "But this is impossible!" retorted St. Augustine. And the boy answered, "Understanding the mystery of the Trinity is more difficult". Mathematics, which is the science of logical truth, certainly helps us to understand things and is therefore natural for a mathematician who believes in God, whatever his denomination, to reconcile the concept of God's existence with the truth that comes from mathematics, although it is limited. "For me", follows Professor Bombieri, is enough what Metastasio says (Italian writer and poet and one of the most important opera writers of the XVIII century): 'Wherever I turn my eyes, there I see immense God". To look at the universe, in our smallness, in the great at the limit of the incomprehensible, and also in the abstract of mathematics, is enough to justify God ». The Big Bang and St. Augustine On the other hand, he adds, "The Big Bang of modern astrophysics does not make página 1 / 3 Mathematics reinforces the certainty of the absolute truth that is God: speaks a mathematical Nobel Catholic.net us think only of biblical creation, but also tells us that time has been created together with the universe, a concept that goes back to the metaphysics of St. Augustine. Mathematics is essential to give consistency to all of this, but alone is not enough to say that this view of the origin of the starry universe of Kant is 100% exact". The famous mathematician also wanted to remind his master, the great mathematician Ennio De Giorgi: Some poor people from Giorgi tried to help assiduously had learned their timetables and when he arrived at Piazza dei Cavalieri, at the foot of the staircase that leads to the entrance to the normal school (of Pisa), they were already there. He always wore something to give them, without making them feel uncomfortable, without ever having a gesture of impatience and even less of annoyance. I was astonished to see these impulses of generosity and it really seemed to me that the goodness of God manifested itself in him in a sublime way". A concrete God, with love. "Pascal and De Giorgi", continues to say Bombieri, "they had understood that God is not only a Platonic God, abstract, geometric, arithmetic or simply creator of an abandoned universe to himself. They had the vision of a god who is more difficult to understand, a god who is made not only of power, but also of infinite love. Only in this way is it possible, humbly, to accept the Christian concept of redemption". The interview is as a whole a great beauty and worth reading (here in Italian PDF). It is interesting, for example, the comment of Professor Bombieri to the verses of Dante, a poet that he loves very much ("Dante is a deep knower of the human soul and shows us how the world of nature, the world of the forces that guide human life and the transcendent world that belongs to God are intertwined with each other", he said), as well as the reflection he makes about good and evil and his existence in the mathematical world. There is also room for a comment to Benedict XVI's speech of April 2006 on mathematics. Bombieri says: "The mathematical consistency of our universe is certainly a reason to see the Creator God of the universe, as Pope Benedict XVI expressed in his speech. However, there is something else. Abstract mathematics, as a coherent science of logical truth, reinforces us in the certainty of the absolute truth that is God. God is creator, infinite love and infinite truth". The small scientific discloser created by the media world, Piergiorgio Odifreddi, (Benedict XVI bothered to write 11 pages of explanations), lamented in his book "Perché Dio non ister" (Aliberti 2010) Writing: Carlo Rubbia I think he's a Catholic. Enrico Bombieri, Fields Medal, is Catholic and goes to mass (p. 122). página 2 / 3 Mathematics reinforces the certainty of the absolute truth that is God: speaks a mathematical Nobel Catholic.net The depth of the reflections of the Italian winner of the Fields Medal, which can be seen in this interview, is certainly the reason why the frivolous media world unfortunately prefers to give space only to pseudo-intellectuals, armed with texts Superficial and banal provocations. This interview has been a very appreciated exception. (Translation of Italian from Uccronline by Helena Faccia Serrano, Alcalá de Henares) In the next video, some phrases from great scientists about the harmony of the universe that brings them closer to God página 3 / 3 Powered by TCPDF (www.tcpdf.org).
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Density of Algebraic Points on Noetherian Varieties 3
    DENSITY OF ALGEBRAIC POINTS ON NOETHERIAN VARIETIES GAL BINYAMINI Abstract. Let Ω ⊂ Rn be a relatively compact domain. A finite collection of real-valued functions on Ω is called a Noetherian chain if the partial derivatives of each function are expressible as polynomials in the functions. A Noether- ian function is a polynomial combination of elements of a Noetherian chain. We introduce Noetherian parameters (degrees, size of the coefficients) which measure the complexity of a Noetherian chain. Our main result is an explicit form of the Pila-Wilkie theorem for sets defined using Noetherian equalities and inequalities: for any ε> 0, the number of points of height H in the tran- scendental part of the set is at most C ·Hε where C can be explicitly estimated from the Noetherian parameters and ε. We show that many functions of interest in arithmetic geometry fall within the Noetherian class, including elliptic and abelian functions, modular func- tions and universal covers of compact Riemann surfaces, Jacobi theta func- tions, periods of algebraic integrals, and the uniformizing map of the Siegel modular variety Ag . We thus effectivize the (geometric side of) Pila-Zannier strategy for unlikely intersections in those instances that involve only compact domains. 1. Introduction 1.1. The (real) Noetherian class. Let ΩR ⊂ Rn be a bounded domain, and n denote by x := (x1,...,xn) a system of coordinates on R . A collection of analytic ℓ functions φ := (φ1,...,φℓ): Ω¯ R → R is called a (complex) real Noetherian chain if it satisfies an overdetermined system of algebraic partial differential equations, i =1,...,ℓ ∂φi = Pi,j (x, φ), (1) ∂xj j =1,...,n where P are polynomials.
    [Show full text]
  • The Top Mathematics Award
    Fields told me and which I later verified in Sweden, namely, that Nobel hated the mathematician Mittag- Leffler and that mathematics would not be one of the do- mains in which the Nobel prizes would The Top Mathematics be available." Award Whatever the reason, Nobel had lit- tle esteem for mathematics. He was Florin Diacuy a practical man who ignored basic re- search. He never understood its impor- tance and long term consequences. But Fields did, and he meant to do his best John Charles Fields to promote it. Fields was born in Hamilton, Ontario in 1863. At the age of 21, he graduated from the University of Toronto Fields Medal with a B.A. in mathematics. Three years later, he fin- ished his Ph.D. at Johns Hopkins University and was then There is no Nobel Prize for mathematics. Its top award, appointed professor at Allegheny College in Pennsylvania, the Fields Medal, bears the name of a Canadian. where he taught from 1889 to 1892. But soon his dream In 1896, the Swedish inventor Al- of pursuing research faded away. North America was not fred Nobel died rich and famous. His ready to fund novel ideas in science. Then, an opportunity will provided for the establishment of to leave for Europe arose. a prize fund. Starting in 1901 the For the next 10 years, Fields studied in Paris and Berlin annual interest was awarded yearly with some of the best mathematicians of his time. Af- for the most important contributions ter feeling accomplished, he returned home|his country to physics, chemistry, physiology or needed him.
    [Show full text]
  • Calculus Redux
    THE NEWSLETTER OF THE MATHEMATICAL ASSOCIATION OF AMERICA VOLUME 6 NUMBER 2 MARCH-APRIL 1986 Calculus Redux Paul Zorn hould calculus be taught differently? Can it? Common labus to match, little or no feedback on regular assignments, wisdom says "no"-which topics are taught, and when, and worst of all, a rich and powerful subject reduced to Sare dictated by the logic of the subject and by client mechanical drills. departments. The surprising answer from a four-day Sloan Client department's demands are sometimes blamed for Foundation-sponsored conference on calculus instruction, calculus's overcrowded and rigid syllabus. The conference's chaired by Ronald Douglas, SUNY at Stony Brook, is that first surprise was a general agreement that there is room for significant change is possible, desirable, and necessary. change. What is needed, for further mathematics as well as Meeting at Tulane University in New Orleans in January, a for client disciplines, is a deep and sure understanding of diverse and sometimes contentious group of twenty-five fac­ the central ideas and uses of calculus. Mac Van Valkenberg, ulty, university and foundation administrators, and scientists Dean of Engineering at the University of Illinois, James Ste­ from client departments, put aside their differences to call venson, a physicist from Georgia Tech, and Robert van der for a leaner, livelier, more contemporary course, more sharply Vaart, in biomathematics at North Carolina State, all stressed focused on calculus's central ideas and on its role as the that while their departments want to be consulted, they are language of science. less concerned that all the standard topics be covered than That calculus instruction was found to be ailing came as that students learn to use concepts to attack problems in a no surprise.
    [Show full text]
  • How a Mathematician Started Making Movies 185
    statements pioneers and pathbreakers How a Mathematician Started Making Movies M i ch e l e e M M e R The author’s father, Luciano Emmer, was an Italian filmmaker who made essentially two—possibly three—reasons. The first: In 1976 I feature movies and documentaries on art from the 1930s through was at the University of Trento in northern Italy. I was work- 2008, one year before his death. Although the author’s interest in films ing in an area called the calculus of variations, in particular, inspired him to write many books and articles on cinema, he knew he ABSTRACT would be a mathematician from a young age. After graduating in 1970 minimal surfaces and capillarity problems [4]. I had gradu- and fortuitously working on minimal surfaces—soap bubbles—he had ated from the University of Rome in 1970 and started my the idea of making a film. It was the start of a film series on art and career at the University of Ferrara, where I was very lucky mathematics, produced by his father and Italian state television. This to start working with Mario Miranda, the favorite student of article tells of the author’s professional life as a mathematician and a Ennio De Giorgi. At that time, I also met Enrico Giusti and filmmaker. Enrico Bombieri. It was the period of the investigations of partial differential equations, the calculus of variations and My father, Luciano Emmer, was a famous Italian filmmaker. the perimeter theory—which Renato Caccioppoli first intro- He made not only movies but also many documentaries on duced in the 1950s and De Giorgi and Miranda then devel- art, for example, a documentary about Picasso in 1954 [1] oped [5–7]—at the Italian school Scuola Normale Superiore and one about Leonardo da Vinci [2] that won a Silver Lion of Pisa.
    [Show full text]
  • The Mathematical Truth
    THE MATHEMATICAL TRUTH Enrico Bombieri IAS, Princeton THE MATHEMATICAL TRUTH Enrico Bombieri IAS, Princeton For angling may be said to be so like the mathematics, that it can never be fully learnt; at least not so fully, but that there will still be more new experiments left for the trial of other men that succeed us. Izaak Walton, The Compleat Angler, To the Reader of this Discourse. WHAT IS MATHEMATICAL TRUTH? WHAT IS MATHEMATICAL TRUTH? 1) An absolute. WHAT IS MATHEMATICAL TRUTH? 1) An absolute. 2) A relative notion. WHAT IS MATHEMATICAL TRUTH? 1) An absolute. 2) A relative notion. 3) A tautology. WHAT IS MATHEMATICAL TRUTH? 1) An absolute. 2) A relative notion. 3) A tautology. 4) Does not exist. WHAT IS MATHEMATICAL TRUTH? 1) An absolute. 2) A relative notion. 3) A tautology. 4) Does not exist. 5) A product of culture. Platonic Realism: The view that numbers, geometry, hence mathe- matics, exist in the platonic world of ideas as absolutes. Plentiful Platonism: It allows for the existence of an objective set of distinct mathematics. Platonic Realism: The view that numbers, geometry, hence mathe- matics, exist in the platonic world of ideas as absolutes. Plentiful Platonism: It allows for the existence of an objective set of distinct mathematics. Formalism: The view that mathematics is only a construction of the mind (or the collective mind). The role of the mathematician is analogous to that of an architect, rather than of an explorer. One has different types of mathematics according to which constructions and rules are allowed. A serious difficulty: Freewheeling infinite constructions quickly lead to antinomies and paradoxes, as in early models of set theory.
    [Show full text]
  • 2008 Doob Prize
    2008 Doob Prize The 2008 Joseph Doob Prize was awarded at the The book also develops the extraordi- 114th Annual Meeting of the AMS in San Diego in nary work of Zhang and others on the January 2008. Bogomolov conjecture, puts forward an This prize was established by the AMS in elegant approach to Hilbert irreducibil- 2003 and endowed in 2005 by Paul and Virginia ity, and includes a detailed discussion Halmos in honor of Joseph L. Doob (1910–2004). of the Nevanlinna-Vojta theory. There Paul Halmos (1916–2006) was Doob’s first Ph.D is a lovely exposition of the important student. Doob received his Ph.D. from Harvard theory of unit equations and a most in 1932 and three years later joined the faculty brilliant discussion of the Subspace at the University of Illinois, where he remained Theorem of Schmidt and Schlickewei, until his retirement in 1978. He worked in prob- as well as the possibilities afforded by ability theory and measure theory, served as AMS the abc-conjecture and further develop- president in 1963–1964, and received the Steele ments along these lines. Enrico Bombieri Prize in 1984. The Doob Prize recognizes a single, The book is self-contained, yet sur- relatively recent, outstanding research book that prisingly accessible given the depth of makes a seminal contribution to the research lit- the material. Links between classical erature, reflects the highest standards of research Diophantine arithmetic and modern exposition, and promises to have a deep and long- arithmetic geometry are emphasized term impact in its area. The book must have been throughout the text in an appealing published within the six calendar years preceding way.
    [Show full text]
  • CURRICULUM VITAE Giacomo Zanella Phd Candidate Department of Statistics, University of Warwick Coventry, CV4 7AL, United Kingdom Education
    CURRICULUM VITAE Giacomo Zanella PhD candidate Department of Statistics, University of Warwick Coventry, CV4 7AL, United Kingdom Education 2012 Oct.- PhD in Statistics at the University of Warwick. Supervisor: Wilfrid Kendall. 2012 Feb.-June Visiting student at Chalmers University of Technology, Goteborg, Sweden. 2010 - 2012 Laurea Magistrale (Master degree) in Mathematics, Universit`adegli Studi di Milano (University of Milan), Italy, 110/110 cum laude, July 2012. Grade Average: 29.7/30. Master Thesis: Branching-Stable Point Processes. Supervisors: Vincenzo Capasso, and Sergei Zuyev. 2007 - 2010 Laurea Triennale (Bachelor degree) in Mathematics, Universit`adegli Studi di Milano (University of Milan), Italy, 110/110 cum laude, Oct. 2010. Grade Average: 29.0/30. Thesis: Maps and plans in optimal transportation theory. Supervisor: Giacomo Aletti. 2005 - 2006 Exchange year (4th year of High School) at St. Dominic's High School, London, UK. 2002 - 2007 Scientific High School (Liceo Sacro Cuore), Milan, Italy. Final score (Diploma): 100/100. Awards and Scholarships 2014 July Junior Travel Award, ISBA 2014 conference. 2013 - 2014 Nomination for the Warwick Awards for Teaching Excellence for PhD Students, based on senior teaching fellows observations and students feedback. 2014 January Honourable mention for poster, MCMSki IV conference. 2012 - 2015 Center for Research in Statistical Methodology (CRiSM) studentship. 2007 - 2009 Merit scolarship holder at INdAM (National Institute of High Mathematics). Award assigned through national examination to 40 students across all Italy. 2008 - 2010 \Incentives for students enrolled in Chemistry, Physics and Mathematics degree", award assigned by the University of Milan. Research Interests Generally speaking I'm interested in Statistics and Probability Theory.
    [Show full text]
  • Bombieri and Tao Receive King Faisal Prize
    Bombieri and Tao Receive King Faisal Prize The King Faisal Foundation annu- functions and the local Bieberbach conjecture, in ally presents the King Faisal Inter- theory of functions of several complex variables, national Prize to reward dedicated and in theory of partial differential equations and men and women whose contribu- minimal surfaces—in particular, to the solution of tions make a positive difference, Bernstein’s problem in higher dimensions. including to scientists and scholars In the past decade, his main contributions whose research results in signifi- have been in the active area of Diophantine ap- cant advances in specific areas that proximation and Diophantine geometry, exploring benefit humanity. The prize carries questions of how to solve equations and inequali- a cash award of approximately ties in integers and rational numbers. Many topics US$200,000. related to prime number theory have potential Photo by Cliff Moore. Two mathematicians shared practical applications to cryptography and security Enrico Bombieri the 2010 prize in science: Enrico of data transmission and identification. Bombieri and Terence Tao. The Bombieri received the 2008 AMS Doob Prize for science prize is given alternately in the book Heights in Diophantine Geometry, writ- mathematics, chemistry, physics, ten with Walter Gubler. The citation read, in part: and biology. “The book is a research monograph on all aspects Enrico Bombieri is IBM Von Neu- of Diophantine geometry, both from the perspec- mann Professor at the Institute for tive of arithmetic geometry and of transcendental Advanced Study, Princeton Uni- number theory.… One gets the sense that every versity. He has made pioneering lemma, every theorem, every remark has been care- contributions to various branches fully considered, and every proof has been thought of mathematics.
    [Show full text]
  • Alessio Figalli: Magic, Method, Mission
    Feature Alessio Figalli: Magic, Method, Mission Sebastià Xambó-Descamps (Universitat Politècnica de Catalunya (UPC), Barcelona, Catalonia, Spain) This paper is based on [49], which chronicled for the ness, and his aptitude for solving them, as well as the joy Catalan mathematical community the Doctorate Honoris such magic insights brought him, were a truly revelatory Causa conferred to Alessio Figalli by the UPC on 22nd experience. In the aforementioned interview [45], Figalli November 2019, and also on [48], which focussed on the describes this experience: aspects of Figalli’s scientific biography that seemed more appropriate for a society of applied mathematicians. Part At the Mathematical Olympiad, I met other teens of the Catalan notes were adapted to Spanish in [10]. It is a who loved math. All of them dreamed of studying at pleasure to acknowledge with gratitude the courtesy of the the Scuola Normale Superiore in Pisa (SNSP), which Societat Catalana de Matemàtiques (SCM), the Sociedad offers a high level of education. Those who get one of Española de Matemática Aplicada (SEMA) and the Real the coveted scholarships do not have to pay anything. Sociedad Matemática Española (RSME) their permission Living, eating and studying are free. I also wanted that. to freely draw from those pieces for assembling this paper. I concentrated on mathematics and physics on my own and managed to pass the entrance exam. The first year at Scuola Normale (SN) was tough. I didn’t Origins, childhood, youth, plenitude even know how to calculate a derivative, while my col- Alessio Figalli was born in Rome leagues were much more advanced than me, since they on 2 April 1984.
    [Show full text]
  • Entropy of Quantum Limits
    ENTROPY OF QUANTUM LIMITS JEAN BOURGAIN AND ELON LINDENSTRAUSS 1. Introduction In this paper we report some progress towards a conjecture of Rud- nick and Sarnak regarding eigenfunctions of the Laplacian ∆ on a com- pact manifold M for certain special arithmetic surfaces M of constant curvature (see below for definitions): Conjecture 1.1 (QUE [5]). If M has negative curvature, then for any 2 sequence of eigenfunctions φi of the Laplacian, normalized to have L - norm 1, such that the eigenvalues λi tend to −∞, the probability mea- 2 ∗ sures |φi(x)| d vol(x) converge in the weak topology to the Riemannian volume vol(M)−1d vol. ∗ (Recall that µi converge weak to µ if for every continuous function with compact support, Z Z fd µi −→ fd µ as i → ∞.) A similar conjecture can be stated also in the finite volume case [6]. Of particular number theoretic interest are manifolds of the form Γ\H with Γ a congruence arithmetic lattice, in which case it is natu- ral to assume that the eigenfunctions are Hecke-Maas forms, i.e. also eigenfunctions of all Hecke operators. We shall refer to this special case of Conjecture 1.1 as the Arithmetic Quantum Unique Ergodicity Conjecture. While most of our methods are quite general, the number theoretic argument used to prove Theorem 3.4 is specific to lattices coming from quaternion algebras over the rationals or to congruence sublattices of SL2(Z). We plan to address the general case using a different technique in a future paper. It is well known (see [2], [7], [11]) that any weak∗ limit as in the above 2 conjecture of |φi(x)| d vol(x) is a projection of a measure on Γ\ SL(2, R) invariant under the geodesic flow; our main result is that if we assume that φi are all Hecke-Maas forms, then all ergodic components of this Date: August 4, 2002.
    [Show full text]
  • Abel Prize 2016 and Fermat’S Last Theorem
    Asia Pacific Mathematics Newsletter Abel Prize 2016 and Fermat’s Last Theorem Y K Leong The Abel Prize 2016 has been awarded to Sir Andrew Wiles of Oxford University “for his stunning proof of Fermat’s Last Theorem by way of the modu- larity conjecture for semistable elliptic curves, opening a new era in number theory”. The Abel Prize is generally regarded as the mathe- matics Nobel Prize (the Swedish Nobel Prize Committee does not allocate any prize to mathematics). It was established by the Norwegian Academy of Science and Letters in memory of the Norwegian mathematician Niels Henrik Abel (1802–1829) on the occasion of the bicentenary of his birth. It is funded by the Norwegian government and carries with it a monetary award of 6 million Norwegian krone (about US$700,000). It is awarded annually, the first time in 2003 to the French mathematician Jean-Pierre Serre. It is interesting to know that more than 100 years ago, a German industrialist Paul Friedrich Wolfskehl (1856–1906), who had an interest in mathematics, Photo copyright C J Mozzochi, Princeton NJ bequeathed a sum of 100,000 Deutsch marks (equiva- lent to one million pounds in 1997 British currency) to be awarded for the solution of Fermat’s Last Theorem Andrew Wiles was at Princeton University between (FLT). By the time it was finally awarded to Andrew 1982 and 2010, except for a short period from 1988– Wiles in 1997, the value of the prize had dwindled to 1990 when he was Royal Society Research Professor at 30,000 pounds because of the hyperinflation Germany Oxford University.
    [Show full text]
  • G. Zanella: CV
    Curriculum Vitae - Giacomo Zanella Personal Information Name Giacomo Zanella Date & Place of Birth November, 28th 1988, Milano (MI), Italy Citizenship Italian Current address Mejerigatan 2A, 41276 Goteborg, Sweden Permanent address Via Val di Sole 22, 20141 Milano, Italy E-Mail [email protected] Telephone +39 3351402614 Education February 2012 - present At current I'm developing my master thesis project on a generalization of the notion of discrete stability for point processes at Chalmers University of Technology (Goteborg, Sweden) under the supervision of prof. Sergei Zuyev, Chalmers University of Tech- nology, and prof. Vincenzo Capasso, Universit`adegli Studi di Milano (University of Milan), Italy. 2010 - present Laurea Magistrale (Master's degree) in Mathematics, Universit`adegli Studi di Milano (University of Milan), Italy. Current GPA: 29.7/30. 2007-2010 Laurea Triennale (Bachelor's degree) in Mathematics, Universit`adegli Studi di Milano (University of Milan), Italy, 110/110 cum laude, October 2010. Thesis: Mappe e Piani nella teoria del trasporto ottimale (Maps and plans in theory of optimal transport) with the supervision of Prof. Giacomo Aletti (University of Milan, Italy). 2005-2006 Fourth year of High School attended at St. Dominic's High School, London, UK. 2002-2007 Liceo Scientifico \Istituto Sacro Cuore" (\Istituto Sacro Cuore" Scientific High School), Maturit`aScientifica (High school Diploma) in a course with one foreign language (En- glish) with 100/100 final score. Honors and Awards 2007 & 2008 I receive a merit scolarship assigned by \Istituto Nazionale di Alta Matematica" (National Institute of High Mathematics) through national examination. 2008 & 2009 \Incentives for students enrolled in degree courses in Chemistry, Physics, Mathematics", award assigned by the University of Milan for the best students of the first two years of the scientific degree courses, earned both years.
    [Show full text]