REPORT on the Results of the Work of an External Expert Commission for Assessing the Compliance with the Requirements Of
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
REPORT on the Results of the Work of an External Expert Commission for Assessing the Compliance with the Requirements of Specialized Accreditation Standards of educational programs 5В020300/6В02201 -History, 5В050500/6В03102-Regional Studies, 6М020300/7М02201 -History Kostanay State University named after A. Baytursynov Site-Visit Dates: April 22-25, 2019 Unofficial Translation INDEPENDENT AGENCY FOR ACCREDITATION AND RATING External Expert Commission Addressed to the Accreditation Council of the IAAR REPORT on the Results of the Work of an External Expert Commission for Assessing the Compliance with the Requirements of Specialized Accreditation Standards of educational programs "5В020300/6В02201-History", "5В050500/6В03102-Regional Studies", "6М020300/7М02201-History" A. Baitursynov Kostanay State University from “22” to “25” April 2019 Kostanay, 2019 2 Unofficial Translation TABLE OF CONTENTS (I) DESIGNATIONS AND ABBREVIATIONS ............................................................................. 4 (II) INTRODUCTION ..................................................................................................................... 5 (III) REPRESENTATION OF THE ORGANIZATION OF EDUCATION .................................... 7 (IV) DESCRIPTION OF PREVIOUS ACCREDITATION PROCEDURE ................................. 12 (V) DESCRIPTION OF THE VISIT OF EEC .............................................................................. 12 (VI) CONFORMITY TO SPECIALIZED ACCREDITATION STANDARDS ........................... 15 6.1. Standard “Education program management” ...................................................................................................... 15 6.2. Standard “Information management and reporting” ....................................................................................... 17 6.3. Standard “Working out and confirmation of an educational program”............................................................... 20 6.4. Standard “Ongoing monitoring and periodical assessment of educational programs” ...................................... 22 6.5. Standard “Student-centred education, teaching and performance assessment” .............................................. 24 6.6. Standard “Trainees”............................................................................................................................................ 27 6.7. Standard “Teaching staff” .................................................................................................................................... 30 6.8. Standard “Education resources and student maintenance system” .................................................................... 35 6.9. Standard “Public awareness policy” ..................................................................................................................... 38 6.10. Standard “Standards in the context of individual specialties” ........................................................................... 40 (VII) REVIEW OF STRONG PARTIES / BEST PRACTICES FOR EACH STANDARD ........ 42 (VIII) REVIEW OF RECOMMENDATIONS FOR IMPROVING QUALITY BY EACH STANDARD .................................................................................................................................. 45 Appendix 1. Evaluation table “PARAMETERS OF SPECIALIZED PROFILE” (5В020300 / 6В02201– “History”, 5В050500 / 6В03102– “Regional Studies”, 6М020300 / 7М02201– “History”) ...................................................................................................................................... 47 3 Unofficial Translation (I) DESIGNATIONS AND ABBREVIATIONS АМ - Academic mobility ECTS - European Credit Transfer and Accumulation System (European system of transfer and accumulation of points) KPI - Key Performance Indicator DB - Data base PPP - Public private partnership EPIS - Eurasian Patent Information System ESCC - Education and Science Control Committee MES RK - Ministry of Education and Science of the Republic of Kazakhstan KSU - A. Baitursynov Kostanay state university FE - Final examination SI - State institution UNT - Unified national testing CT - Comprehensive Testing EP - Education program TS - Teaching staff FMC - Faculty Methodical Council МEP - Module of the educational program EDC - Elective disciplines catalogue SAKO - State archive of Kostanay oblast LIET - Laboratory of innovative educational technologies SOES - State obligatory education standard MC - Model curricula ISP - Individual study plans SEG APK - Scientific expert group of the Assembly of the People of Kazakhstan SMC - Special Monitoring Commission under the Agency for Civil Service Affairs and Anti-Corruption of the Republic of Kazakhstan STC - Scientific and Technical Council AC - Academic Council 4 Unofficial Translation (II) INTRODUCTION In accordance with the order No. 35-19-ОD dated April 8, 2019, the Independent Agency for Accreditation and Rating (hereinafter - IAAR) from April 22 to April 25, 2019, an external expert committee assessed the compliance of educational programs "5B020300 / 6B02201- History" "5В050500 / 6В03102-Regional Studies", "6М020300 / 7М02201-History" A. Baitursynov Kostanay state university standards of specialized accreditation IAAR (№10-17-ОD dated February 24, 2017, fifth edition). The report of the external expert commission (EEC) contains an assessment of the compliance of A. Baitursynov Kostanay state university (hereinafter KSU) activities within the framework of specialized accreditation with IAAR criteria, and EEC recommendations on further improvement of the specialized profile parameters. EEC members: 1. The chairman of the commission - Bayhan Nurbayevich Ualkhanov, Ph.D., director of Pavlodar Agricultural Experimental Station LLP (Pavlodar); 2. Foreign expert - Milan Paul, professor, PhD, Masaryk University, ENQA expert (Brno, Czech Republic); 3. Foreign expert - Alexey Mikhailovich Gostin, Ph.D., associate professor, Ryazan State Radio Engineering University (RGRTU) (Ryazan); 4. Expert - Zakirova Dilnara Ikramkhanovna, PhD, Turan University (Almaty); 5. Expert - Baytele Darkhan Aytzhanuly, Ph.D., A.Kh. Margulan Institute of Archeology (Nur-Sultan); 6. Expert - Ivashov Arslan Amanbaevich, Ph.D., associate professor, University of UIB (Almaty); 7. Expert - Adilbekova Lyazzat Makhaykyzy, Ph.D., professor, Kazakh State Women's Pedagogical University (Almaty); 8. Expert - Toleubaeva Aknur Mukhitovna, Ph.D, L.N. SImilyov Eurasian National University. (Nur-Sultan); 9. Expert - Ormangali Medeu Shungenuly, Ph.D., Associate Professor, Member of the Kazakhstan Association of International Law, Member of the German-Russian Lawyers Association, University of Narhoz (Almaty); 10. Expert - Zhumabekov Meiram Kenesovich, Ph.D., associate professor, E.A. Buketov Karaganda State University. (Karaganda); 11. Expert - Movkebaeva Zulfiya Akhmetvalievna, Doctor of Pedagogical Sciences, Professor, Abay Kazakh National Pedagogical University (Almaty); 12. Expert - Amirbek Zarlykovich Bekeshev, Candidate of Physical and Mathematical Sciences, Associate Professor, K.Zhubanov Aktobe Regional University (Aktobe); 13. Employer - Ludmila Yuryevna Olkinyan, Head of the Corporate University of SaryarkaAvtoProm LLP of Allure Group of Companies JSC (Kostanay); 14. Employer - Kazin Manarbek Auanovich, head of the human capital department of the Chamber of Entrepreneurs of Kostanay region (Kostanay); 15. Student - Anybekova Anel Tolegenovna, 2nd year student of the EP "5B050500- Regional Studies", L.N. SImilyov Eurasian National University (Nur-Sultan); 16. Student - Zhanibek UTkelbaev Kabdullaevich, 4th year student of EP "5B011900- Foreign Language: two foreign languages", U.Sultangazin Kostanay State Pedagogical University. (Kostanay); 17. Student - Lutsenko Olga Sergeevna, 3rd year student of EP "5B060100-Mathematics", U.Sultangazin Kostanay State Pedagogical University (Kostanay); 18. Student - Doribay Aruzhan Temirbaykyzy, 3-year student of the EP "5B050400- Journalism", L.N. SImilyov Eurasian National University (Nur-Sultan); 19. Student - Elena Ivanovna Studenkina, 3rd year student of EP "5B050300-Psychology", U.Sultangazina Kostanay State Pedagogical University (Kostanay); 5 Unofficial Translation 20. Agency’s Observer - Timur Kanapyanov, PhD, International Projects and PR Manager, IAAR (Nur-Sultan). 6 Unofficial Translation (III) REPRESENTATION OF THE ORGANIZATION OF EDUCATION Republican state enterprise on the right of economic management “A. Baitursynov Kostanay state university” (hereinafter - KSU or University) is a subject of higher and postgraduate education (hereinafter - HPE) of the Republic of Kazakhstan (hereinafter - RK). KSU is a regional institution of higher education in Kostanay oblast that provides training in a wide range of specialties. Currently, the university has about 5,000 students, there are 31 departments, including the military. The University operates in accordance with the Constitution of the Republic of Kazakhstan, the Law of the Republic of Kazakhstan “On Education”, the Law of the Republic of Kazakhstan “On Science”, the Law of the Republic of Kazakhstan “On the Commercialization of Scientific and Scientific-Technical Activities”, regulatory and legal acts governing educational and scientific activities, Model Rules activities of organizations of entities implementing programs of higher and postgraduate education (Appendix 5 to the order of MES RK No. 595 of 10.30.2018) and the Charter of the University. The University has a state license (No. 12020851