Sociology of Crime and Deviance Unit Four: SCLY4
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Name:________________________ Sociology of Crime and Deviance Unit Four: SCLY4 Miss Sakine Koc Advance A Level Miss Sakine Koc Published 2015 © Course Outline 1 Different theories of crime, deviance, social order and social control o Different definitions of crime, deviance, social order and social control o The distinction between sociological theories of crime and other theories (eg biological, psychological); crime and deviance as socially constructed o Functionalist theories of crime: Durkheim, anomie, collective conscience; Merton’s strain theory; manifest and latent functions; functionalist subcultural theories o Marxist and neo-Marxist theories of crime: classical Marxism, laws reflecting class interests; Neo-Marxism, hegemony, the CCCS studies, critical and new criminology o Interactionist theories of crime: labelling theory, the self-fulfilling prophecy o Feminist theories of crime: patriarchy, male control of women’s lives o Control theory and other contemporary approaches to crime: social bonds, communitarianism, situational prevention; postmodern theories; Foucault on individualisation and surveillance o Realist theories: New Left Realism and Right Realism o The relevance of the various theories to understanding different types of crime, and their implications for social policy. 2 The social distribution of crime and deviance by age, ethnicity, gender, locality and social class, including recent patterns and trends in crime o Study of statistics and other evidence on the social distribution of crime by age, ethnicity, gender, locality and social class, including recent patterns and trends o Issues related to and explanations of the social distribution of crime and deviance by age: juvenile delinquency and youth crime o Issues related to and explanations of the social distribution of crime and deviance and ethnicity: explanations from different theories, racism in the criminal justice system o Issues related to and explanations of the social distribution of crime and deviance and gender: explanations of the rates of male and female crime, the gendering of crime, chivalry thesis, the gender deal o Issues related to and explanations of the social distribution of crime and deviance and locality: rural and urban crime o Issues related to and explanations of the social distribution of crime and deviance and social class: explanations from different theories; white collar crime; occupational crime. 3 Globalisation and crime in contemporary society; the mass media and crime; green crime; human rights and state crimes o Globalisation and crime: examples and explanations of globalised crimes such as web- based crimes, global trades in drugs, weapons and people; global corporate crime o Mass media and crime: media’s role in social construction of crime including moral panics and amplification; crime and news values and agenda setting; representations of crime (both fact and fiction) o Green crime: definitions, criminalisation of environmental offences; extent, enforcement of green crimes: environmental laws, corporate and state environmental crimes, crimes 1 Advance A Level Miss Sakine Koc Published 2015 © against non-human species o Human rights and state crimes: international rules and norms and examples of violations of them; human rights violations; state crimes. 4 Crime control, prevention and punishment, victims, and the role of the criminal justice system and other agencies o Crime control, prevention and punishment: contemporary policies, linked to the theories studied under point 1; surveillance, zero tolerance, anti-social behaviour orders, expansion of imprisonment o Victims of crime: statistics and other evidence on victims of crime; ethnicity, age and gender; different theoretical accounts, e.g. positivist and radical victimology o Role of the criminal justice system and other agencies. 5 The sociological study of suicide and its theoretical and methodological implications o Durkheim’s classic study of suicide, including typologies o Interpretivist responses to Durkheim, e.g. Atkinson, Douglas o Realist approaches, e.g. Taylor’s ‘people under trains’ o The theoretical and methodological implications of the different approaches of the study of suicide. 2 Advance A Level Miss Sakine Koc Published 2015 © Functionalism on Crime and Deviance o Functionalism was one of the first theories of crime that sought to explain deviance by the nature of society rather than the biology and psychology of the individual. Durkheim – positive view of crime - thinks crime is functional for society! o Durkheim believed modern societies are made up of collective conscience based on moral individualism since ‘uniformity so universal and absolute’ was impossible. Thus, unlike Marxism, he believed crime can never be eradicated since it’s normal and appears in all societies but in different forms. o Crime is an ‘integral part of all healthy societies’. This is because individuals are exposed to different influences and will all not be committed to the shared values/beliefs of society. Thus, crime acts as a moral dichotomy providing us with what is good/bad behaviour and in effects binds together society. o Crime can be functional since all societies need to progress and social change begins with some form of deviance. E.g. homosexuality was once illegal, but today its normal. Thus, yesterday’s deviance must become tomorrow’s normality for change to occur according to Durkheim. Moreover, this suggests crime doesn’t disappear but change it form. o However, Societies need both crime and punishment because without punishment the rate of criminality would become dysfunctional. Thus, laws must be stricter than before and must be experienced throughout society to justify the need for control. o Durkheim noted that too much and too little crime reflected social pathology (dysfunctional). Thus balance is needed: Too much crime - not enough collective conscience, society in a state of anomie (normlessness) Too little crime – too strong collective conscience, totalitarian state. o Lastly, the criminal was not an unsociable being but one that ‘plays a definite role in social life’. Evaluation of Durkheim’s theory: 3 Advance A Level Miss Sakine Koc Published 2015 © Cohen (1966) 2 additional functions of crime: 1. Deviance as a ‘safety valve’, providing a harmless expression of discontent. E.g. prostitution enables men to escape from family life without undermining the family as an institution. (synoptic link to the functions of the family) 2. Deviant acts can warn society that an aspect is not working properly – e.g. widespread truanting from school. (synoptic link to education – Paul Willis’s study of the lads) Evaluation of Cohen’s theory: Merton’s (1938) strain theory suggests crime arises from the culture and structure of society. o He begins form the functionalist position of value consensus – idea that all members of society share the same values. In the USA, for example, individuals strived for the same goal of success, largely measured in terms of wealth and material possessions. o However, while great emphasis is placed on the ‘American dream’, little significance is given to the means of achieving it. This results in an unbalanced society where success is about ‘winning the game’ rather than ‘wining though circumscribed modes of activity’. o Once rules cease to operate, a situation of anomie occurs in which deviance is encouraged. Individuals respond to this in five ways: 1. Conformity - most common response. Members strive to success though accepted channels. 2. Innovation - adopted by those that are denied the opportunities to succeed via conventional means. E.g. working class – thus, greater pressure to deviate for ‘success’. 3. Ritualists - lower middle-class where goal of wealth is abandoned but they continue to conform to conventional standards of respectability (e.g. education). Thus, deviant for rejecting mainstream goal. 4. Retreatism - embraced by ‘drop-outs’ e.g. tramps/drug addicts. Deviate in 2 ways by rejecting shared values of success and means to achieve it. 5. Rebellion - both goals and means are rejected and replace with an alternative society. o Crime is therefore a result of the culture and structure of society which overemphasises cultural goals at the expense of institutionalised means to achieve it, creating a tendency towards anomie. This increases need for deviance but level varies according to people’s social position. 4 Advance A Level Miss Sakine Koc Published 2015 © Evaluation of Merton theory: Merton assumes American culture is homogenous while others reject idea of common value hierarchy fixed by culture or structure. Problematic to suggest individuals shape their goal by society when they interact in multi- values with the different groups they participate in. Exaggerates the level of working class crime as he ignores more undercover crimes like corporate crime which is committed by the ruling class. However, some argue Merton’s theory is still applicable today. E.g. Thatcherism placed great emphasis on individual success during the 70s and 80s which contributed to a rise in property crime according to some sociologists. Evaluation of Functionalism: Strength Limitation Unlike Marxism, Functionalism fails to consider wider power functionalists are correct in relations in society like who make the laws? and suggesting that crime cannot who it benefits? be eradicated since it existed in communist countries like Assumes society is based on value consensus. China and the Former Soviet Premises