DOCSLIB.ORG

Criminological Theory an Introduction to Criminological Theory Third Edition ROGER HOPKINS BURKE

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Criminological Theory an Introduction to Criminological Theory Third Edition ROGER HOPKINS BURKE Crimtheory3edv6.qxd 12/5/09 21:57 Page 1 An Introduction to Theory Criminological to An Introduction Criminological Theory Third edition ROGER HOPKINS BURKE This third edition of An Introduction to Criminological Theory comprises a substantially revised and expanded, comprehensive and up-to-date introduction to criminological theory worldwide. Each chapter has been revised to take account of recent theoretical developments and the enduring validity of established theories has been explored through application to crucial contemporary criminological issues. This edition introduces new themes in a fifth part that An Introduction to addresses crime and criminality in the contemporary age of moral uncertainty. The text is divided into five parts. The first three parts address an identified model of criminal behaviour – the rational actor, the predestined actor and victimised actor models – that have each professed to explain crime and criminal behaviour. The fourth part reviews more recent Criminological attempts to integrate theoretical elements from both within and across models of criminal behaviour. The fifth part addresses a range of contemporary issues including constitutive criminology, anarchist criminology, cultural criminology and the schizophrenia of crime, new modes of governance, the risk society, globalisation theories, terrorism and state violence, and communitarianism. Theory This is an interdisciplinary text that recognises the value of legal, biological, psychological and sociological explanations of crime and criminal behaviour, and the increasingly more sophis- edition ticated attempts to integrate these theories. Theories are placed in the socio-political context Third Third edition in which they arose and the whole text is located in the context of contemporary debates about modernity and postmodernity, now substantially revised at a time when the world is undergoing the seismic shock of perhaps the greatest economic crisis ever encountered and the criminogenic conditions likely to be produced as a consequence. This book covers the entire syllabus for the vast majority of contemporary university crimino- ROGER HOPKINS BURKE logical theory courses at both undergraduate and postgraduate level while continuing to gently expand the parameters of debate. It is nevertheless written in an accessible and non-esoteric fashion and provides an excellent introduction to how crime and criminal behaviour has been variously explained for all students of criminology. The author Roger Hopkins Burke is Criminology Subject Leader, Division of Criminology, Public Health and Policy Studies, Nottingham Trent University. His current research interests are the development of criminological theory and young people and crime. Recent publications include Young People, Crime and Justice (Willan Publishing, 2008). Academic and Professional Publisher of the Year 2008 International Achievement of the Year 2009 www.willanpublishing.co.uk ROGER HOPKINS BURKE An Introduction to Criminological Theory For Kristan, Thomas and Oliver An Introduction to Criminological Theory Third Edition Roger Hopkins Burke Published by Willan Publishing Culmcott House Mill Street, Uffculme Cullompton, Devon EX15 3AT, UK Tel: +44(0)1884 840337 Fax: +44(0)1884 840251 e-mail: [email protected] website: www.willanpublishing.co.uk Published simultaneously in the USA and Canada by Willan Publishing c/o ISBS, 920 NE 58th Ave, Suite 300, Portland, Oregon 97213-3786, USA Tel: +001(0)503 287 3093 Fax: +001(0)503 280 8832 e-mail: [email protected] Website: www.isbs.com © Roger Hopkins Burke 2009 The rights of Roger Hopkins Burke to be identified as author of this book have been asserted by him in accordance with the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act of 1988. All rights reserved; no part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise without the prior written permission of the Publishers or a licence permitting copying in the UK issued by the Copyright Licensing Agency Ltd, Saffron House, 6–10 Kirby Street, London EC1N 8TS. First published 2001 Second Edition 2005 Third Edition 2009 ISBN 978-1-84392-407-4 paperback ISBN 978-1-84392-569-9 hardback British Library Cataloguing-in-Publication Data A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library Project managed by Deer Park Productions, Tavistock, Devon Typeset by GCS, Leighton Buzzard, Bedfordshire, LU7 1EU Printed and bound by T.J. International, Padstow, Cornwall Contents Acknowledgements xi 1 Introduction: crime and modernity 1 Pre-modern crime and criminal justice 1 The rise of modern society 3 Defining and the extent of crime 5 The structure of the book 7 Suggested further reading 20 Part One: The rational actor model of crime and criminal behaviour 21 2 Classical criminology 27 The Classical theorists 27 The limitations of Classicism 31 The neo-Classical compromise 31 The enduring influence of Classicism 33 Suggested further reading 35 3 Populist conservative criminology 36 The rise of the political new right 36 James Q. Wilson and ‘right realism’ 37 Right realism and social control 41 A critique of right realism 42 Suggested further reading 44 4 Contemporary rational actor theories 46 Contemporary deterrence theories 46 Rational choice theory 49 Routine activities theory 53 The rational actor reconsidered 56 Suggested further reading 59 v An Introduction to Criminological Theory Part Two: The predestined actor model of crime and criminal behaviour 61 5 Biological positivism 65 Early biological theories 65 Inherited criminal characteristics 68 Genetic structure 72 Criminal body types 73 Psychoses and brain injuries 75 Autistic spectrum disorders 77 Biochemical theories 80 Altered biological state theories 82 Treating the offender 87 Conclusions 88 Suggested further reading 90 6 Psychological positivism 92 Psychodynamic theories 92 Behavioural learning theories 97 Cognitive learning theories 103 Conclusions 108 Suggested further reading 108 7 Sociological positivism 110 Emile Durkheim and social disorganisation theory 110 The Chicago school 116 Robert Merton and anomie theory 119 Deviant subculture theories 126 Conclusions 141 Suggested further reading 141 8 Women and positivism 143 Biological positivism and women 143 Psychological positivism and women 146 Sociological positivism and women 152 Conclusions 157 Suggested further reading 157 Part Three: The victimised actor model of crime and criminal behaviour 159 9 Labelling theories 167 The social construction of crime 167 The recipients of deviant labels 170 The consequences of labelling for the recipients 171 vi Contents Moral panics and deviance amplification 173 Criticisms of labelling theories 175 Labelling theories revisited 176 Suggested further reading 179 10 Conflict and radical theories 180 Conflict theories 180 Criticisms of conflict theories 183 Radical theories 184 Criticisms of radical theories 188 Suggested further reading 190 11 The gendered criminal 191 Perspectives in feminist theory 192 The feminist critique of early explanations of female criminality 195 The impact of feminist critiques 197 Feminism and prostitution 200 Is there a feminist criminology? 202 Crime and masculinities 203 Suggested further reading 205 12 Critical criminology 206 The origins of critical criminology 206 Crimes of the powerful 208 Crimes of the less powerful 210 Critical criminology or ‘left idealism’ 211 Critical criminology and the challenge of zemiology 212 Critical criminology revisited 215 Suggested further reading 216 Part Four: Integrated theories of crime and criminal behaviour 219 13 Socio-biological theories 223 Biosocial theory 223 Biosocial theory and the ‘new right’ 225 Sociobiological theories of rape 226 Recent sociobiological explanations of childhood delinquency 228 Conclusions 229 Suggested further reading 230 14 Environmental theories 231 Early environmental theories 231 British environmental theories 232 North American environmental theories 233 Environmental design 238 vii An Introduction to Criminological Theory Environmental management 242 Suggested further reading 243 15 Social control theories 245 The origins of social control theories 245 Early social control theories 247 Later social control theories 249 Integrated theoretical perspectives 251 A general theory of crime 254 Developments in social control theories 256 Conclusions 260 Suggested further reading 261 16 Left realism 262 The origins of left realism 262 A balance of intervention 266 Left realism and ‘New’ Labour 269 Social exclusion and the ‘underclass’: a case study 270 ‘New’ Labour criminal justice policy revisited 272 Left realist theory revisited 275 Suggested further reading 277 Part Five: Crime and criminal behaviour in the age of moral uncertainty 279 17 Crime and the postmodern condition 287 Constitutive criminology and postmodernity 289 Anarchist criminology 293 Suggested further reading 298 18 Cultural criminology and the schizophrenia of crime 299 The focus of cultural criminology 299 The seductions of crime 302 The carnival of crime 304 The schizophrenia of crime 304 Crime as normal and non pathological 305 One planet under a groove 307 Suggested further reading 311 19 Crime, globalisation and the risk society 312 New modes of governance 312 Crime and the risk society 313 Globalisation and crime 317 Terrorism and state violence 321 Terrorism and postmodernism revisited 327 Suggested further reading 328 viii Contents 20
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Realist Criminology and Its Discontents
    www.crimejusticejournal.com IJCJ&SD 2016 5(3): 80‐94 ISSN 2202–8005 Realist Criminology and its Discontents Simon Winlow Steve Hall Teesside University, United Kingdom Abstract Critical criminology must move beyond twentieth‐century empiricist and idealist paradigms because the concepts and research programmes influenced by these paradigms are falling into obsolescence. Roger Matthews’ recent work firmly advocates this position and helps to set the ball rolling. Here we argue that Matthews’ attempt to use critical realist thought to move Left Realism towards an advanced position can help to put criminology on a sound new footing. However, before this becomes possible numerous philosophical and theoretical issues must be ironed out. Most importantly, critical criminology must avoid political pragmatism and adopt a more critical stance towards consumer culture’s spectacle. A searching analysis of these issues suggests that, ultimately, criminology is weighed down with obsolete thinking to such an extent that to remain intellectually relevant it must move beyond both Left Realism and Critical Realism to construct a new ultra‐realist position. Keywords Critical criminology; harm; consumer culture; Left Realism; Critical Realism; Ultra‐Realism. Please cite this as: Winlow S and Hall S (2016) Realist criminology and its discontents. International Journal for Crime, Justice and Social Democracy 5(3): 80‐94. DOI: 10.5204/ijcjsd.v5i3.247. This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 Licence. As an open access journal, articles are free to use, with proper attribution, in educational and other non‐commercial settings. ISSN: 2202‐8005 © The Author(s) 2016 Simon Winlow, Steve Hall: Realist Criminology and its Discontents Introduction As one of the original architects of Left Realism, Roger Matthews is too well‐known for us to have to outline his many achievements and his influence on the discipline.
    [Show full text]
  • Levitt Sample.Qxd
    Detailed Table of Contents Foreword xviii Preface xx Acknowledgments xxiv Dedication xxv Section I. Introduction and Overview of Crime and Criminology 1 What Is Criminology? 2 What Is Crime? 2 Crime as a Moving Target 2 Crime as a Subcategory of Social Harms 3 Beyond Social Construction: The Stationary Core Crimes 4 Criminality 5 A Short History of Criminology 6 The Role of Theory in Criminology 8 What Is Theory? 9 How to Think About Theories 10 Ideology in Criminological Theory 11 Connecting Criminological Theory and Social Policy 13 A Brief Word About the Section Readings 15 Summary 16 Key Terms 17 Exercises and Discussion Questions 17 Useful Websites 18 How to Read a Research Article 19 The Use and Usefulness of Criminology, 1751–2005: Enlightened Justice and Its Failures 20 READING 23 1. The Use and Usefulness of Criminology, 1751–2005: Enlightened Justice and Its Failures 23 Lawrence W.Sherman A short history of criminology and a cry to make it useful and experimental. Section II. Measuring Crime and Criminal Behavior 32 Categorizing and Measuring Crime and Criminal Behavior 32 The Uniform Crime Reports: Counting Crime Officially 33 Cleared Offenses 36 Problems With the UCR 36 NIBRS: The “New and Improved”UCR 37 Crime Victimization Survey Data and Their Problems 38 Areas of Agreement Between the UCR and NCVS 40 Self-Reported Crime Surveys and Their Problems 40 The Dark Figure of Crime 41 What Can We Conclude About the Three Main Measures of Crime in America? 43 The FBI’s Ten Most Wanted 43 Summary 44 Key Terms 45 Exercises and Discussion Questions 45 Useful Websites 46 READINGS 46 2.
    [Show full text]
  • Criminology in Europe
    Prague Welcomes the ESC Miroslav Scheinost on Crime and Criminology in the Czech Republic 1 MESSAGE FROM THE PRESIDENT Michael Tonry IS THERE, SHOULD THERE BE, ����| 2 A EUROPEAN CRIMINOLOGY? VOL. �� The question in the title could be Criminology in Europe is published by the European Society of Criminology. interpreted in a number of ways. It could mean, is there and should there Web www.escnewsletter.org be a recognisably European scholarly Editor CSABA GYŐRY community of people interested in Editorial office: crime and the justice system? The Max Planck Institute for Foreign and answers are obvious. Yes and yes. International Criminal Law Günterstalstrasse 73 From the organisation of the Euro- 79100 Freiburg i. Br. pean Steel and Coal Community Phone: +49 (761) 7081-314 under the 1951 Treaty of Paris through Fax: +49 (761) 7081-294 the creation of the Council of Europe Email: [email protected] and the latest contortions of the The European Society of Criminology is a European Union, serious efforts have scientific institution founded under the Literary and Scientific Institutions Act 1854, a statute of been underway to fashion a geopo- the Parliament of the United Kingdom. litical Europe that is greater than the President MICHAEL TONRY sum of its parts. Part of that effort in President-Elect GERBEN BRUINSMA every field has been to foster cross- Past President VESNA NIKOLIĆ-RISTANOVIĆ national interactions and institutions Executive Secretary MARCELO AEBI at the European level. Journal Editor PAUL KNEPPER Except for scholarly communities within countries or language group- Newsletter Editor CSABA GYŐRY Member KLAUS BOERS ings, and relatively small numbers of individuals involved in European expert Member DINA SIEGEL groups, until recently it would have been hard to claim there was a European Member MIKLÓS LÉVAY criminological community.
    [Show full text]
  • Foundations of Criminology Boris Brasol
    Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology Volume 17 Article 2 Issue 1 May Spring 1926 Foundations of Criminology Boris Brasol Follow this and additional works at: https://scholarlycommons.law.northwestern.edu/jclc Part of the Criminal Law Commons, Criminology Commons, and the Criminology and Criminal Justice Commons Recommended Citation Boris Brasol, Foundations of Criminology, 17 Am. Inst. Crim. L. & Criminology 13 (1926-1927) This Article is brought to you for free and open access by Northwestern University School of Law Scholarly Commons. It has been accepted for inclusion in Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology by an authorized editor of Northwestern University School of Law Scholarly Commons. FOUNDATIONS OF CRIMINOLOGY BORis BRASOL1 PREFACE Among the vital problems confronting civilized mankind, the sin- ister phenomenon of criminality occupies a prominent place and engages ever-increasing attention toward its scientific solution on the part of both the jurists and the general public. Modem thought is no longer content with the scholastic inter- pretation of crime based upon abstract legal formulas inscribed in penal codes, but it seeks to explain the complex nature of the criminal deed in the light of the latest discoveries of biology, psychology, anthropology and economics. Positive criminology had departed-and therein lies its great achievement-from the traditional path of the classical school which dealt with crime quite apart from the realities of every-day life; meta- physical conception which reduced the whole study of criminality
    [Show full text]
  • Criminal Man” Distribute Cesare Lombroso 1836–1909 University of Pavia and University of Or Turin, Italy Often Called “The Father of Modern Criminology” Post
    2 The Search for the “Criminal Man” distribute Cesare Lombroso 1836–1909 University of Pavia and University of or Turin, Italy Often called “the father of modern criminology” post, efore we examine the content of this chapter, it is important to remember a few of the B cautionary comments offered in Chapter 1. By keeping these ideas in mind, we more than likely will be successful in accomplishing the goal of introducing you to the context and consequences of criminological theory. We want you to remember that the search for explanations of criminal behavior is not easy because we copy,constantly must guard against our biases, mistaken perceptions, and prej- udices. Unless we maintain our intellectual guard against these problems, our learning will be severely limited. This will become obvious as we study the following chapters and learn that many theories of crime that have experienced popularity with the public and profes- sional criminologists also have been criticized for having serious blind spots. Unfortu- nately,not the blind spots often have contributed to the creation and implementation of official policies that have produced results as undesirable as crime itself. Although it is impossible to develop perfect policies, we must keep in mind the fact that theories do influence the policies and practices found in criminal justice systems. Do It is important to remember that the explanations of crime, whether they are created by the public or by professional criminologists, are influenced by the social context from which they come. This means that the social context will consist of perceptions and inter- pretations of the past as well as the present.
    [Show full text]
  • Analyzing the Application of Competing Theories of Justice Into American and Pakistani Policing Strategies James F
    Pakistan Journal of Criminology Vol. 9, Issue 3, July 2017 (1-24) Analyzing the Application of competing Theories of Justice into American and Pakistani Policing Strategies James F. Albrecht* Abstract Law enforcement agencies across the United States have implemented a number of enforcement philosophies since 1960 in an effort to counter rising crime rates, violence, and prolific victimization. The primarily reactive deployment of police resources in the 1960s and 1970s had proved to be ineffective. With drug related violence escalating, frustrated American police administrators opted to implement community policing with its proactive crime reduction and problem solving approaches. Crime control results were limited before showing signs of improved effectiveness in the mid-1990s. Many government and police leaders, as early as 1994, often instituted a ‘zero tolerance’ enforcement mandate, which directed that the police universally address both serious crime and quality of life infractions. Combined with timely crime analysis, the proactive arrest-oriented strategies quickly drew the attention of government and police leadership across the United States and internationally as crime rates in America continued to plummet. As a result, the ‘get tough on crime’ mindset rapidly replaced the neighborhood and public oriented approaches fostered by the traditional models of community policing. American state, regional, and local police agencies had thus shifted their enforcement strategy from one supporting the ‘left realism’ community focused theory of justice to one that has firmly grasped the ‘right realism’ crime and disorder control based ideology. However, with occasional allegations of racial profiling and police brutality following rare but dramatically sensationalized incidents, the reported successes of American crime control tactics may need to be re-evaluated.
    [Show full text]
  • Deviance and Social Control: New Right Realism
    Deviance and Social Control Deviance and Social Control: New Right Realism © Chris.Livesey: www.sociology.org.uk New Right Realism Deviance and Social Control New Right Realism Introduction If New Left Realist approaches to the study of crime and deviance owe some kind of debt to past theories of deviance, the same is true of New Right Realism. In this instance, however, the origins of New Right Realism lie in both Control Theory and, as you might expect, political Conservatism. Unlike the form of "Marxist Realism" of New Left Realism, the "realist" aspect of the neo-conservative theories grouped under the heading of the "New Right Realism" relates more to a "realistic" view about the causes of crime and deviance than to a particular set of methodological principles. In this respect, New Right Realist forms of analysis are, as we shall see, grounded squarely on positivist methodological principles. Thus, the "realistic" assessment of the causes of crime (a concept that’s used very loosely here since it’s probably fair to say that New Right Realism is not unduly concerned with concepts of causality in relation to crime and deviance) and, most importantly, its prevention, proposed by New Right Realists focuses on the idea that the reality of crime is very much a "what you see is what you get" principle. If we look at two of the organizational principles under-pinning New Right Realism, this idea should become a little more clear... 1. Ideologically, New Right Realism is, as I’ve noted, stridently Conservative in its political stance (which is not, of course, to say that this is a "bad thing", any more than the Marxism of Radical Criminology or New Left Realism is a "bad thing".
    [Show full text]
  • The Impact of COVID-19 on Youth Offending
    THE UNIVERSITY OF HULL DEPARTMENT OF CRIMINOLOGY AND SOCIOLOGY The impact of COVID-19 on youth offending Being a dissertation submitted in partial fulfilment of the requirements for the degree of BA (Hons) Criminology with Psychology May 2021 LEANNE JADE KNOWLES Abstract When estimating the potential impacts of the COVID-19 crisis on youth offending, it is important to consider traditional theories of crime. This literature review aims to determine which of the secondary impacts of the pandemic have influenced crime during the crisis and can predict changes to crime rates in the future. Existing theories of crime such as ‘anomie’, control theories and the right realist perspective of offending can identify crime predictors and risk factors that may be aggravated by the COVID-19 pandemic. The following review contains secondary research of personal accounts from individuals based on their experiences throughout the pandemic, literature on traditional theories of crime can be compared with the main issues raised by this research. The focus of the review is youth offending in the UK. Several theories have been used to explain the impacts of COVID-19 on criminal activity, for example, routine activities theory can help to explain reductions in crime following the national lockdown. Routine activities theory may be able to explain rises in crime when government restrictions are lifted, as opportunities for offending are to increase. Theories surrounding social disorganisation can be used to draw links between unemployment and youth crime. Disruptions in the structure of society are expected to increase criminal activity due to an increase in anomic frustration.
    [Show full text]
  • UNIT 3 THEORIES of CRIME Criminal Behaviour
    Causes Underlying UNIT 3 THEORIES OF CRIME Criminal Behaviour Structure 3.0 Introduction 3.1 Objectives 3.2 Definition of Crime 3.3 When an Act is Considered a Crime 3.3.1 Harm 3.3.2 Illegal 3.3.3 Malafide Intention 3.3.4 Criminal Intention 3.3.5 Concurrence of Intention and Conduct 3.3.6 Casual Relationship 3.3.7 Prescription of Punishment 3.4 Schools of Thought 3.4.1 Pre-Scientific or Demonological School 3.4.2 Free-Will School 3.4.3 Classical School 3.4.4 Ecological School 3.4.5 Geographical School 3.4.6 Typological School 3.4.7 Socialistic School 3.4.8 Sociological School 3.4.9 Positivist School 3.4.10 Italian School 3.4.11 Lacassagne School 3.4.12 Chicago School 3.5 Traditional and Modern Theories of Crime 3.5.1 Social Structure Theories 3.5.2 Social Disorganisation (Neighbourhoods) 3.5.3 Social Ecology 3.5.4 Strain Theory (Social Class) 3.5.5 Sub Cultural Theory 3.6 Individual Theories 3.6.1 Trait Theories 3.6.2 Control Theories 3.6.3 Symbolic Interactionism 3.6.4 Rational Choice Theory 3.6.5 Routine activity Theory 3.6.6 Neo-Classical School 3.6.7 Social Control Theory 3.6.8 Drift Theory 3.6.9 Rational Choice Theory 3.7 Complexity of Crime in Modern Times 3.8 Let Us Sum Up 3.9 Unit End Questions 3.10 Glossary 3.11 Suggested Readings 45 Approaches to Understanding Criminal 3.0 INTRODUCTION Behaviour Crime is an anti-social behaviour which a society rejects and to which it attaches penalties.
    [Show full text]
  • Encyclopedia of Criminological Theory
    Encyclopedia of Criminological Theory Garofalo, Raffaele: Positivist School Contributors: Francesca Patuelli Editors: Francis T. Cullen & Pamela Wilcox Book Title: Encyclopedia of Criminological Theory Chapter Title: "Garofalo, Raffaele: Positivist School" Pub. Date: 2010 Access Date: September 12, 2014 Publishing Company: SAGE Publications, Inc. City: Thousand Oaks Print ISBN: 9781412959186 Online ISBN: 9781412959193 DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.4135/9781412959193.n97 Print pages: 353-356 ©2010 SAGE Publications, Inc. All Rights Reserved. This PDF has been generated from SAGE knowledge. Please note that the pagination of the online version will vary from the pagination of the print book. SAGE ©2010 SAGE Publications, Inc. All Rights Reserved. SAGE knowledge http://dx.doi.org/10.4135/9781412959193.n97 Raffaele Garofalo was born November 18, 1851, in Naples into a noble family of Catalan origin and is considered one of the main exponents of the Positivist School of Criminology. He enjoyed a rich and successful career as a lawyer, with prestigious Bench and Ministry of Justice assignments and was active until his death on April 18, 1934. Garofalo was Cesare Lombroso's disciple with whom he collaborated on the Archives of Psychiatry, Anthropology and Penal Sciences together with the third representative of the “glorious triad” (as Grispigni wrote of the three founders of the new school in the Dictionary of Criminology in 1943, p. 398), the lawyer Enrico Ferri. In his work, Garofalo systemized the theories of his teacher and tried to give a juridical position to the new criminal theories. One of the characteristics of Garofalo's work, which stemmed from his professional background, was the strong attention given to the practical aspects of the reform.
    [Show full text]
  • 1 WORKING DRAFT NOT YET COPYEDITED This Article Will
    WORKING DRAFT_NOT YET COPYEDITED This Article will appear on Vol. 18, Issue 3 of the New Criminal Law Review (July 2015) THE 100-plus YEAR OLD CASE FOR A MINIMALIST CRIMINAL LAW (Sketch of a General Theory of Substantive Criminal Law) Mike C. Materni* ABSTRACT Criminal law defines the system of government of which it is the political expression; thus having a normative theory of substantive criminal law is paramount. U.S. criminal law has developed in the absence of such overarching theory, and is now plagued by overcriminalization. This article advances a model of a minimalist criminal law grounded on strong normative principles that are presented and defended not from the perspective of metaphysics or moral philosophy; but rather, in a historical and comparative perspective, as a matter of political choice. Core among those principles is the idea that in a liberal democracy the criminal law should be seen as the extrema ratio, or option of the last resort. After laying out and defending the model, the article deals with issues related to its implementation, advancing an argument for the constitutionalization of substantive criminal law. The article argues that, on the basis of existing yet overlooked constitutional doctrine, criminal laws should be subject to strict scrutiny. I. INTRODUCTION: WHAT TYPE OF CRIMINAL LAW? ................................................................ 2 II. FROM THE ANCIEN RÉGIME TO THE CLASSICAL MODEL OF LIBERAL CRIMINAL LAW: FRANCESCO CARRARA AND THE CLASSICAL SCHOOL. .................................................. 8 I) CARRARA’S GENERAL PRINCIPLES OF CRIMINAL LAW ............................................................................... 10 II) THE “CLASSICAL MODEL” OF LIBERAL CRIMINAL LAW ............................................................................ 14 III. THE CASE FOR THE “CLASSICAL MODEL”: A LESSON FROM HISTORY ........................
    [Show full text]
  • Predisposition and Positivism: the Orf Gotten Foundations of the Entrapment Doctrine T
    Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology Volume 103 | Issue 1 Article 3 Winter 2013 Predisposition and Positivism: The orF gotten Foundations of the Entrapment Doctrine T. Ward Frampton Follow this and additional works at: https://scholarlycommons.law.northwestern.edu/jclc Part of the Criminal Law Commons Recommended Citation T. Ward Frampton, Predisposition and Positivism: The Forgotten Foundations of the Entrapment Doctrine, 103 J. Crim. L. & Criminology 111 (2013). https://scholarlycommons.law.northwestern.edu/jclc/vol103/iss1/3 This Criminal Law is brought to you for free and open access by Northwestern University School of Law Scholarly Commons. It has been accepted for inclusion in Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology by an authorized editor of Northwestern University School of Law Scholarly Commons. 0091-4169/13/10301-0111 THE JOURNAL OF CRIMINAL LAW & CRIMINOLOGY Vol. 103, No. 1 Copyright © 2013 by Northwestern University School of Law Printed in U.S.A. PREDISPOSITION AND POSITIVISM: THE FORGOTTEN FOUNDATIONS OF THE ENTRAPMENT DOCTRINE T. WARD FRAMPTON* For the past eighty years, the entrapment doctrine has provided a legal defense for defendants facing federal prosecution, but only for those lacking criminal “predisposition” prior to the government’s inducement. The peculiar contours of this doctrine have generated significant academic debate, yet this scholarship has failed to explain why the entrapment doctrine developed as it did in the first instance. This Article addresses this gap by examining competing views on criminality and punishment in America during the doctrine’s emergence, highlighting the significant, though largely forgotten, impact of positivist criminology on the early twentieth-century legal imagination.
    [Show full text]