DOCSLIB.ORG

The Effects of Private Military and Security Companies on Local

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
The Effects of Private Military and Security Companies on Local Quaderni di Centro Ricerca Sicurezza e Terrorismo Direttore Ranieri Razzante Michele Turzi The effects of Private Military and Security Companies on local populations in Afghanistan A case-study based analysis on the impact of the large presence of private firms on Afghans Pacini © Copyright 2019 by Pacini Editore Srl Realizzazione editoriale Via A. Gherardesca 56121 Ospedaletto (Pisa) Responsabile di redazione Gloria Giacomelli Le fotocopie per uso personale del lettore possono essere effettuate nei limiti del 15% di ciascun volume /fascicolo di periodico dietro pagamento alla SIAE del compenso previsto dall’art. 68, commi 4 e 5, della legge 22 aprile 1941 n. 633. 31.10.2018 The effects of Private Military and Security Companies on local populations in Afghanistan A case study-based analysis on the impact of the large presence of private firms on Afghans TURZI, Michele Table of contents Table of contents .................................................................................................. i Summary ............................................................................................................. ii List of Abbreviations ......................................................................................... iii 1. Introduction and Background ....................................................................... 1 1.1 Introduction 1 1.2 Structure of the thesis 2 1.3 The Private Military and Security Industry 3 1.4 The Afghan case 8 2. Methodology and Theoretical Framework ................................................ 12 2.1 Methodology 12 2.2 Theoretical Framework 13 3. PMSCs in Afghanistan ................................................................................. 19 3.1 The Private Industry in numbers 19 3.2 A wide variety of PMSCs 22 3.3 The Afghan Affair 26 4. The impact of PMSCs on Afghans .............................................................. 31 4.1 Destabilizing Consequences: direct and indirect effects 31 4.2 Abuses and violations increase the distrust of PMSCs 33 4.3 Concerns for the lack of the governmental presence 37 5. Conclusion ..................................................................................................... 40 References ......................................................................................................... 43 i Summary The purpose of this thesis is to analyze whether the large presence of Private Military and Se- curity Companies (PMSCs) has affected the local populations and how it has impacted on Af- ghans. Becoming major players of the global security structure after the end of the Cold War, these companies have been massively involved in the intervention in Afghanistan for the pro- vision of military-related activities and security services. In this context, most of the PMSCs were hired in support of the coalition military forces that had entered the country in 2001, providing a myriad of different services. From logistical and base support activities to military and operational roles, including even demining and intelli- gence tasks, quickly private companies pervaded Afghanistan not without raising questions. The way in which PMSCs have emerged as crucial players of the security governance in Af- ghanistan show the existence of a hybrid structure where varied actors combine at multiple levels to supply security-related services. What emerges is not just how commercial military and security practices have been genera- ted, but the thesis deals with the consequences of the practices and the impact suffered by the civilian population. Illustrating the cases of incidents and violations involving the personnel of some PMSCs and Afghans, makes it possible to show the direct implications of contractors that have affected the lives of local people with a negative impact on their perception of security. In addition, a sense of destabilization was produced by the apparent impunity of PMSCs, that through a complex system of interlinkages with economic and political elites could challenge the go- vernment of Afghanistan creating a parallel structure of control. Distrust towards both the companies and the state was thus the most noteworthy result of the destabilizing effect of the vast use of PMSCs in Afghanistan. ii List of Abbreviations ANA Afghan National Army ANP Afghan National Police ANSF Afghan National security Forces APPF Afghan Public Protection Force APSC Armed Private Security Company ASG Armed Support Group CIA Central Intelligence Agency DOD Department of Defense GIRoA Government of the Islamic Republic of Afghanistan IR International Relations ISAF International Security Assistance Force MOI Ministry of Interior MPRI Military Professional Resources Inc. NATO North Atlantic Treaty Organization NGO Non-governmental Organization OEF Operation Enduring Freedom PD62 Presidential Decree 62 PMC Private Military Company PMF Private Military Firm PMS Private Security Company PMSC Private Military and Security Company QRF Quick Reaction Force SIGAR Special Inspector General for Afghanistan Reconstruction UNSC United Nations Security Council UNWG United Nations working Group USCENTCOM United States Central Command USPI United States Protection and Investigation iii 1. Introduction and Background 1.1 Introduction 1.2 Structure of the thesis 1.3 The Private Military and Security Industry 1.4 The Afghan case 1.1 Introduction “The end of the Cold War left a huge vacuum and I identified a niche in the market”.1 This quote of EO’s founder Eben Barlow well illustrates the phenomenon of the rise of priva- te military industry in the contemporary context, where private actors have found a great bu- siness as being crucial players in the security field. Private Military and Security Companies (henceforth PMSCs), as the South African Executive Outcomes founded in 1989 by Barlow and involved in the conflicts in Angola and Sierra Leo- ne, form a growing industry that since the end of the Cold War has influenced most of the re- cent international conflicts providing military and security commodities on all continents all over the world. The demand for PMSCs’ services has increased incredibly in the last thirty years, reaching the peak with the conflicts in Afghanistan and Iraq. And it is precisely the con- flict that took place in Afghanistan the case study for this dissertation, in which I sought to inquire into the impact of PMSCs on civil population. The process of globalization exploded in the aftermath of the Soviet Union’s collapse, added to the growing influence of economic neoliberal models that inspired most of the governmen- ts, led to a new trend that broadened the classic concept of warfare. The privatization of the military and security profession, that for the last two centuries has been seen as a monopoly in the hands of national states, is now challenging many of the old rules of the warfare. Outsour- cing military and security programs became a priority in the strategies of most of the coun- tries involved in the post-9/11 intervention in Afghanistan, where even the president Hamid Karzai was protected by the personnel of the US private firm DynCorp. 1 Schreier, Fred and Marina Caparini, Privatising Security: Law, Practice and Governance of Private Military and Security Companies, DCAF Occasional Paper 6, 2005, p.19. 1 Previous studies on the emergence of the privatized military industry have focused on a multi- tude of different aspects, but my intention is to explore the consequences of the use of PMSCs on Afghanistan after 2001. The thesis aims to explore how the large use of PMSCs has affec- ted and influenced the life of Afghans, with a special consideration given to the importance of the legitimacy and sovereignty of the Afghan government which is in charge of the control over the territory. The impact of these private actors on the civilians is the main question due to the willingness to clarify their role and implication in the field of security provision in Af- ghanistan. Finding out whether the presence of PMSCs has affected Afghanistan is important in order to deal with the literature of the topic which predominantly focuses on the negative impact of private firms in weak states, eroding state power and diminishing the monopoly on the legitimate use of force. 1.2 Structure of the thesis This chapter offers an introduction and a brief outline of the thesis, with a first definition of PMSCs in a section explaining the phenomenon of the emergence of these actors after the end of the Cold War. Then a paragraph is dedicated to some background informations about Af- ghanistan and its recent history with the US-led intervention of 2001 as part of the new strate- gy of the global war on terror in response to the 9/11 attacks. The brief summary of the recent Afghan history is fundamental to get a better understanding of the current situation of the country, regarded as belonging to that group of fragile, weak or failed states in a process of post-conflict resolution. Chapter 2 explains the methodology applied and the theoretical framework chosen. In the first paragraph the focus is the explication of the case study approach, which has been privileged because the most valid to study a particular situation that needs to be treated following a com- prehensive perspective able to include also the global trend of security and military privatiza- tion. In the second one the theoretical framework is accounted for: a justification of the choice of the Global Security Assemblages is provided after a short overview of the main approaches
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Afghan Instability Has Implications for Pakistan
    Add: V-137, Street-6, Phase, 4, District 6, Add: V-137, Street-6, Phase, 4, District 6, Shahrak Omed Sabz, Kabul Shahrak Omed Sabz, Kabul Email: [email protected] Email: [email protected] Phone: 0093 (799) 005019/777-005019 Phone: 0093 (799) 005019/777-005019 www.outlookafghanistan.net www.thedailyafghanistan.com Back Page August 13, 2016 Ghazni Kandahar Jalalabad Clear Clear Clear Mazar Clear Herat Clear Bamayan Clear Kabul Clear Daily 26°C Outlook 40°C 32°C 41°C 38°C 36°C 33°C Weather 28°C °C °C 27°C 18°C 22°C 19 12 19°C Forcast Land Grabbing on The Afghan Instability has Rise in Nangarhar Implications for Pakistan: US WASHINGTON - The U.S department all terrorists regardless of their back- of state has said that instability in Af- ground and political affiliation, reject- ghanistan has direct repercussions on ing the Afghan officials claims as base- Pakistan, reiterating calls on Islamabad less and far from the truth. to hit all terrorist groups on Pakistani Pakistani government claimed that as soil that continue to wage war against part of its counter-terrorism policy, JALALABAD - Nangarhar Provincial Afghanistan. it has launched the so-called ‘Zarb-e- Council warns that if government author- The U.S has said that terrorism not only Azb’ operation at curbing the terrorist ities do not arrest land grabbers, more impacts the region, but also affects the groups that allegedly continue mis- land will be usurped. peace and security of Pakistan. sions in Pakistan. A number of council members say that The statement comes at a juncture Back in July, the Obama administration government not only banned land grab- where Afghan officials have been urg- mounted fresh pressure on Pakistan to bing, but also the phenomena is increas- ing Pakistan to hit all insurgent groups push Islamabad to act against all insur- ing day by day in the province.
    [Show full text]
  • Afghanistan: Post-Taliban Governance, Security, and U.S
    Afghanistan: Post-Taliban Governance, Security, and U.S. Policy (name redacted) Specialist in Middle Eastern Affairs January 12, 2017 Congressional Research Service 7-.... www.crs.gov RL30588 Afghanistan: Post-Taliban Governance, Security, and U.S. Policy Summary The United States, partner countries, and the Afghan government are attempting to reverse recent gains made by the resilient Taliban-led insurgency since the December 2014 transition to a smaller international mission consisting primarily of training and advising the Afghanistan National Defense and Security Forces (ANDSF). The Afghan government has come under increasing domestic criticism not only for failing to prevent insurgent gains but also for its internal divisions. In September 2014, the United States brokered a compromise to address a dispute over the 2014 presidential election, but a September 2016 deadline was not met for enacting election reforms and deciding whether the Chief Executive Officer (CEO) position might be elevated to a prime ministership in a restructured government. The progress of the Afghan government in reducing corruption and implementing its budgetary and other commitments was assessed by an international meeting on Afghanistan during October 4-5, in Brussels, as sufficient to merit continued international assistance. And, in late 2016, the government adopted the requisite measures to, at the very least, move forward with new parliamentary elections. The number of U.S. forces in Afghanistan, which peaked at about 100,000 in 2011, is about 9,800, of which most are assigned to the 13,000-person NATO-led “Resolute Support Mission” that trains, assists, and advises the ANDSF. About 2,000 of the U.S.
    [Show full text]
  • Page 01 July 30.Indd
    ISO 9001:2008 CERTIFIED NEWSPAPER IMF warns of First doping risks to global case rocks growth Games Business | 15 Sport | 19 Wednesday 30 July 2014 • 3 Shawwal 1435 • Volume 19 Number 6142 www.thepeninsulaqatar.com [email protected] | [email protected] Editorial: 4455 7741 | Advertising: 4455 7837 / 4455 7780 Elderly more vulnerable to cyber crimes Police say most complaints are about blackmailing by women; new law to tackle the problem soon DOHA: Most victims of cyber crimes and would make them public. of the Search and Follow-Up Department crime, so tracking and combating it are crime are admissible as evidence in the in Qatar are people aged 40 and above Sometimes, the person against whom of the Ministry of Interior, was speaking not easy. Sometimes, the other countries local court, the officials added. as they are not quite proficient in use a complaint of a cyber crime has been at a Ramadan symposium organised by refuse to cooperate in solving the crime If the person or persons involved in of electronic gadgets, say the police. made is based out of Qatar. Often, the Al Sharq. and punishing the culprit. a cyber crime are based abroad, help is Younger people are more knowledge- country where the person is based Also present at the symposium was People approach the cyber crime sought from Interpol. able about modern electronic devices refuses to extradite him. Lieutenant Owaida Abdullah Al Nuaimi, combating unit here directly with com- Replying to a question as to what hap- since they have been using them since The mobile phone is a small device investigation officer in the cyber crime plaints, and often the Public Prosecution pens if a cyber criminal has used a fake an early age and are, thus, less vulner- but all conversations and photographic combating unit.
    [Show full text]
  • The Afghan Government's Relationship with the Pashtun Community and Its Effect on Stability; a Comparative Approach
    American University in Cairo AUC Knowledge Fountain Theses and Dissertations 6-1-2012 The Afghan government's relationship with the Pashtun community and its effect on stability; a comparative approach Alfred Jasins Follow this and additional works at: https://fount.aucegypt.edu/etds Recommended Citation APA Citation Jasins, A. (2012).The Afghan government's relationship with the Pashtun community and its effect on stability; a comparative approach [Master’s thesis, the American University in Cairo]. AUC Knowledge Fountain. https://fount.aucegypt.edu/etds/1066 MLA Citation Jasins, Alfred. The Afghan government's relationship with the Pashtun community and its effect on stability; a comparative approach. 2012. American University in Cairo, Master's thesis. AUC Knowledge Fountain. https://fount.aucegypt.edu/etds/1066 This Thesis is brought to you for free and open access by AUC Knowledge Fountain. It has been accepted for inclusion in Theses and Dissertations by an authorized administrator of AUC Knowledge Fountain. For more information, please contact [email protected]. The American University in Cairo School of Humanities and Social Sciences The Afghan Government’s Relationship with the Pashtun Community and its effect on Stability; a Comparative Approach A Thesis Submitted to The Department of Political Science In Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements For the Degree of Master of Arts By Alfred Jasins Under the supervision of Dr. Ivekovic May/ 2012 1 TABLE OF CONTENTS CHAPTER 1 - INTRODUCTION 1 1. Research Topic 1 2. Research Questions 7 3. Hypothesis 7 4. Alternative Hypothesis 8 5. Conceptual Framework and Methodology 12 6. Literature Review 17 CHAPTER 2 – DEMOGRAPHICS/HISTROICAL BACKGROUND 21 1.
    [Show full text]
  • Internacionals CIDOB 96 the CONSEQUENCES of SEPTEMBER AFGHANISTAN’S 2014 PRESIDENTIAL 2014 ELECTION IMPASSE
    CIDOB • Barcelona Centre for International for Affairs Centre CIDOB • Barcelona notesISSN: 2013-4428 internacionals CIDOB 96 THE CONSEQUENCES OF SEPTEMBER AFGHANISTAN’S 2014 PRESIDENTIAL 2014 ELECTION IMPASSE Malaiz Daud, Associate Senior Researcher, CIDOB s Afghanistan’s elec- The Afghan polity is in tatters, as fraudulent elections since 2004 3.1 percent in 2013 from 14.4 tion saga dragged have progressively polarized the leadership. This year’s presidential percent in 20121; the country is on, the international election could not have come at a worse time, with the security transi- expected to lose USD 5 billion tion taking place and foreign aid dwindling. Acommunity was desperate in revenue this year. The gov- to have the new president Internally, the past three months have been the bloodiest. Taliban ernment has run out of cash to in place in time to attend the have re-launched frontal wars in several provinces in the south and pay salaries of its employees. NATO summit in Wales on east, even north. The country is expected to lose USD 5 billion in Afghans are increasingly look- revenue this year. September 4th of this year. That ing to move out of the country did not happen. Because of Afghans are increasingly looking to move out of the country in search in search of better job oppor- the inconclusive presidential of better job opportunities as well as to avoid an uncertain securi- tunities as well as to avoid an election, there is uncertainty ty situation in the aftermath of the expected full withdrawal of the uncertain security situation in NATO forces.
    [Show full text]
  • Afghanistan: Post-Taliban Governance, Security, and U.S
    Afghanistan: Post-Taliban Governance, Security, and U.S. Policy Kenneth Katzman Specialist in Middle Eastern Affairs February 24, 2015 Congressional Research Service 7-5700 www.crs.gov RL30588 Afghanistan: Post-Taliban Governance, Security, and U.S. Policy Summary As of January 1, 2015, the United States and its partner countries have completed a transition to a smaller post-2014 mission consisting mostly, but not exclusively, of training the Afghanistan National Security Forces (ANSF). The number of U.S. forces in Afghanistan, which peaked at about 100,000 in June 2011, has been reduced to about 10,500, of which most are trainers and advisers as part of a 13,000-person NATO-led “Resolute Support Mission.” About 1,000 of the U.S. contingent are counter-terrorism forces that continue to conduct combat, operating under a new U.S. “Operation Freedom’s Sentinel” that replaces the post-September 11 “Operation Enduring Freedom.” President Obama directed in May 2014 that the U.S. force will shrink during 2015 to about 5,000 by the end of this year, and their presence after 2015 will be exclusively in Kabul and at Bagram Airfield. The post-2016 U.S. force is to be several hundred military personnel, under U.S. Embassy authority. However, doubts about the ability of the ANSF to operate without substantial international backing have led to recent U.S. alterations of the post- 2014 U.S. rules of engagement and to U.S. command statements that the 2015-16 drawdown plan might be altered. Deploying a post-2014 international force was contingent on Afghanistan’s signing a Bilateral Security Agreement (BSA) with the United States and a similar document with NATO.
    [Show full text]
  • Afghanistan: Post-Taliban Governance, Security, and U.S. Policy
    Afghanistan: Post-Taliban Governance, Security, and U.S. Policy Kenneth Katzman Specialist in Middle Eastern Affairs October 15, 2015 Congressional Research Service 7-5700 www.crs.gov RL30588 Afghanistan: Post-Taliban Governance, Security, and U.S. Policy Summary At the end of 2014, the United States and partner countries completed a transition to a smaller mission consisting primarily of training and advising the Afghanistan National Defense and Security Forces (ANDSF). The number of U.S. forces in Afghanistan, which peaked at about 100,000 in June 2011, stands at about 9,800, of which about 1,000 continue to conduct combat under U.S. “Operation Freedom’s Sentinel” that replaced the post-September 11 “Operation Enduring Freedom.” U.S. forces constitute the bulk of the 13,000-person NATO-led “Resolute Support Mission.” Amid assessments that the ANDSF is having difficulty preventing gains by the Taliban and other militant groups (exemplified by the insurgent overrunning of the northern city of city of Konduz in late September 2015) President Obama announced on October 15, 2015, that about 10,000 U.S. military personnel would remain in Afghanistan through almost all of 2016, and subsequently fall to 5,500. The 5,500 person post-2016 force is significantly larger than the U.S. force of about 1,000 personnel that was previously announced for that timeframe. Prior to the Konduz takeover, U.S. officials asserted that insurgents did not pose a threat to the stability of the government, and U.S. officials have not subsequently altered that assessment publicly. The insurgency benefits, in some measure, from weak governance in Afghanistan.
    [Show full text]
  • Afghanistan: Post-Taliban Governance, Security, and U.S
    Afghanistan: Post-Taliban Governance, Security, and U.S. Policy Kenneth Katzman Specialist in Middle Eastern Affairs December 22, 2015 Congressional Research Service 7-5700 www.crs.gov RL30588 Afghanistan: Post-Taliban Governance, Security, and U.S. Policy Summary The United States, partner countries, and the Afghan government are coping with a resilient Taliban-led insurgency after the December 2014 transition to a smaller international mission consisting primarily of training and advising the Afghanistan National Defense and Security Forces (ANDSF). The number of U.S. forces in Afghanistan, which peaked at about 100,000 in June 2011, stands at about 9,800, of which most are assigned to the 13,000-person NATO-led “Resolute Support Mission” to train, assist, and advise the ANDSF. About 1,000 of the U.S. contingent conduct combat against Al Qaeda and associated terrorist groups under U.S. “Operation Freedom’s Sentinel” that replaced the post-September 11 “Operation Enduring Freedom.” Amid assessments that the ANDSF is having difficulty preventing gains by the Taliban and other militant groups—exemplified by the insurgent overrunning of the northern city of city of Konduz in late September 2015 and major insurgent gains in Helmand Province—President Obama announced on October 15, 2015, that about 10,000 U.S. military personnel would remain in Afghanistan through almost all of 2016, and subsequently fall to 5,500. The post-2016 force, which will remain at 5,500 for an undetermined time, is significantly larger than the U.S. force of about 1,000 personnel that was previously announced. U.S.
    [Show full text]
  • Pajhwok Afghan News (PAN) Weekly Election Coverage Newsletter, July 30-Aug 5
    Pajhwok Afghan News (PAN) Weekly Election Coverage Newsletter, July 30-Aug 5 “I've worked closely with him, and I know that one of his lasting legacies will be how Afghanistan makes its first democratic, peaceful transfer of power.” Kerry wrote Afghans took an enormous step on the road toward a stronger democracy in April and June when millions of people went to the polls to choose the country’s next president. “Every vote was a courageous endorsement of democracy, and an expression of hope for the future.” Kerry rules out parliamentary system in Afghanistan The United States, the United Nations and the international By Javed Hamim Kakar Jul 30, 2014 - 22:26 community were engaged in the post-election process solely to help the Afghan election institutions restore KABUL (Pajhwok): US Secretary of State John Kerry has credibility to the voting, he said. said it was not for outsiders to describe the contents of the “Experts tell me that the audit under way in Kabul is the political framework both Afghan presidential candidates largest and most complicated election audit ever accepted a few days ago. undertaken anywhere. Few countries could meet this “It does not violate the Afghan constitution – it respects challenge alone.” Afghan institutions. It does not establish a parliamentary He continued specialists from the UN were working side system – it creates a new position of chief executive who by side with their Afghan colleagues to ensure that the will report to the president until the president convenes a audit met the laws of Afghanistan, the highest international Loya Jirga to determine whether a permanent change is in standards and, most importantly, the expectations of the best interests of the country,” Kerry wrote in his latest Afghans.
    [Show full text]