SCOTT E. SUNDBY Washington & Lee School of Law Lexington, Virginia 24450 (540) 458-8016 E-mail: [email protected]

PROFESSIONAL EMPLOYMENT:

1992-present Sydney and Frances Lewis Professor of Law, Washington & Lee University, School of Law, Lexington, Virginia Subjects taught: Criminal Law, Criminal Procedure: Investigation, Criminal Procedure: Prosecution, Comparative Criminal Procedure, Constitutional Law, International Human Rights and Criminal Justice; Seminars on Capital Punishment, Advanced Criminal Procedure, Procedural Due Process, and Fourth Amendment

Director, Frances Lewis Law Center (1997-2001) Faculty member responsible for overseeing research activities at the law school and for organizing enrichment programs.

Fall 2008 Visiting Professor, University of Law School, Coral Gables, FL

Spring 2008 Visiting Fellow, Universitat Jaume I, Castelló de la Plana, Valencia, Spain

Spring 2002 Visiting Fellow, Griffith University, Brisbane, Australia

Fall 1999 Visiting Goldstein Professor of Public Interest Law, State University, School of Law, Tallahassee, Florida

1994-95 Special Assistant Attorney, Southern District of Florida, Miami, Florida

1984-92 University of - Hastings College of the Law, San Francisco, California – Assistant Professor, 1984-87; Associate Professor, 1987-90; Professor, 1990-92

Fall Semesters Visiting Professor, Boalt Law School, University of California- 1986 and 1987 Berkeley, California

1983-84 Judicial clerk to The Honorable Phyllis A. Kravitch, United States Court of Appeals, Eleventh Circuit, Atlanta, Georgia

EDUCATION: Cornell Law School, J.D., summa cum laude, 1983 Editor-in-Chief, Cornell Law Review Order of the Coif

Vanderbilt University, B.A., summa cum laude, 1980 Phi Beta Kappa; English Honors Program-Awarded Highest Honors; Harold Stirling Vanderbilt Honor Scholarship Page Two SCOTT E. SUNDBY

MAJOR PUBLICATIONS:

BOOKS A LIFE AND DEATH DECISION: A JURY WEIGHS THE DEATH PENALTY (Palgrave Macmillan/St. Martin=s Press - April 2005; paperback October 2007) $ Finalist for 2006 A.B.A Silver Gavel Award

ARTICLES/ESSAYS

War and Peace in the Jury Room: How Capital Juries Reach Unanimity, 62 Hastings Law Journal – (2010)

Exclusionary Rule Creation Stories, - Tech Law Review – (2010) (Invited Paper for Symposium on “Fourth Amendment Search and Seizure”) (with Lucy Ricca)

Mapp v. Ohio’s Unsung Hero: The Suppression Hearing as Morality Play, 85 Chicago-Kent Law Review 255 (2010) (Invited Paper for Symposium on “Criminal Procedure and the Roberts Court)

Oyendo Al Jurado A Traves de La Puerta: Una Perspectiva de La Aplicacion de la Pena de Muerte en America, 15 Revista de Derecho Procesal (2008) (with Professor Maria Angeles Cebadera Perez) (“Listening at the Jury Room Door: Understanding America and the Death Penalty”)

Caminando Sobre La Cuerda Floja Constitucional: La USA PATRIOT Act y La “Guerra Contra El Terror,” 15 Revista General de Derecho Procesal (2008) (with Professor Maria Angeles Cebadera Perez) (“Walking the Constitutional Tightrope: The USA PATRIOT Act and the ‘War Against Terror’”)

Competent Capital Representation: The Necessity of Knowing and Heeding What Jurors Tell Us About Mitigation, 36 Hofstra Law Review 1035 (2008) (with John Blume and Sheri Lynn Johnson) (Invited Paper for Symposium on “Guidelines for Mitigation in Death Penalty Cases”)

Why the Downturn in Death Sentences? in THE FUTURE OF AMERICA’S DEATH PENALTY (Carolina Academic Press 2008) (with William Bowers)

The Death Penalty=s Future: Charting the Crosscurrents of Declining Death Sentences and the McVeigh Factor, 84 Texas Law Review 1929 (2006) (Invited Paper for Symposium on APunishment Law and Policy@)

Protecting the Citizen AWhilst He is Quiet@: Suspicionless Searches, ASpecial Needs@ and General Warrants, 74 Mississippi Law Journal 501 (2005) (Invited Paper for Symposium on AThe Tools to Interpret the Fourth Amendment,@ National Center for Justice and the Rule of Law, University of Mississippi)

Page Three

SCOTT E. SUNDBY Moral Accuracy and AWobble@ in Capital Sentencing, 80 Indiana Law Journal 56 (2005) (Invited Comments/Essay for Symposium on AToward a Model Death-Penalty Code: The Massachusetts Governor=s Council Report,@ Indiana University School of Law)

The Capital Jury and Empathy: The Problem of Worthy and Unworthy Victims, 88 Cornell Law Review 343 (2003) (Invited Paper for Symposium on AVictims and the Death Penalty@)

Fallen Superheroes and Constitutional Mirages: The Tale of Brady v. Maryland, 33 McGeorge L.Rev.643 (2002) (Invited Essay/Lecture for McGeorge Law School Distinguished Lecture Series)

Burden of Proof, Encyclopedia of Crime and Justice, 2001 (with Barbara Underwood)

The Limits of Privacy, 570 Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science 202 (2000) (book review of Amitai Etzioni=s The Limits of Privacy)

Mean Justice, 1999 Trial 95 (Sept.issue) (book review of Edward Humes= Mean Justice)

An Ode to Probable Cause, 72 St. John=s Law Review 1133 (1998) (Invited Paper for Symposium on AThe Thirtieth Anniversary of Terry v. Ohio@).

The Jury and Absolution: The Intersection of Trial Strategy, Remorse and the Death Penalty, 83 Cornell Law Review 1557 (1998) (Invited Paper for Symposium on AHow the Death Penalty Works: Empirical Studies of the Modern Capital Sentencing System@).

The Jury as Critic: An Empirical Look at How Capital Juries Perceive Expert Testimony, 83 Virginia Law Review 1109 (1997).

The Education of A Law Professor, 1996 Virginia Lawyer 24 (April issue)

Everyman=s Fourth Amendment: Privacy or Mutual Trust Between Government and Citizen?, 94 Columbia Law Review 1751 (1994).

The Lockett Paradox: Reconciling Guided Discretion and Unguided Mitigation in Capital Sentencing, 38 U.C.L.A..Law Review 1147 (1991).

Is Abandoning State Action Asking Too Much of the Constitution?, 17 Hastings Constitutional Law Quarterly 139 (1990) (Invited Paper for Symposium on the California Constitution).

The Virtues of a Procedural View of Innocence - A Response to Professor Schwartz, 41 Hastings Law Journal 161 (1989).

The Reasonable Doubt Rule and the Meaning of Innocence, 40 Hastings L.J. 457 (1989).

A Return to Fourth Amendment Basics: Undoing the Mischief of Camara and Terry, 72 Minnesota Law Review 383 (1988). Page Four

The Felony-Murder Rule: A Doctrine at Constitutional Crossroads, 70 Cornell Law Review

SCOTT E. SUNDBY 446 (1985) (with Roth).

RESEARCH PROJECTS FUNDED BY GRANTS:

Co-Investigator, National Science Foundation Capital Jury Research Projects II & III, 2002-present (Supervising the interviewing of capital jurors)

Co-Principal Investigator, National Science Foundation Study: Judging Capital Murder Cases, 1997- 2002 (Interviewing of judges who have conducted capital trials to develop an empirical understanding of different statutory frameworks)

Director, California Segment of National Science Foundation Capital Jury Research Project I, 1991-93 (Supervised the interviewing of over 150 jurors who served on juries where the death penalty was sought)

SELECTED LECTURES, PRESENTATIONS AND WORKSHOPS 2007-10: [Full list of presentations available upon request]  Vanderbilt University, Criminal Justice Scholarship Roundtable, December 2010  University of Louisville, Symposium on the Roberts Court, December 2010, “Justice Scalia: Hopeless Constitutional Romantic?”  Federal Death Penalty Strategy Session, Austin, TX, November 2010, “Protecting Your Mitigation Evidence in the Jury Room”  Los Angeles Public Defenders, Los Angeles, CA, October 2010, “The Messenger Matters: Communicating the Case for Life to the Jury”  Virginia Trial Lawyers Association, Norfolk, VA, September 2010, “Thinking Like a Juror: What Empirical Research Tells Us”  Southeastern Association of Law Schools (SEALS), West Palm Beach, FL, August 2010, “Is the Exclusionary Rule Broken? Should It be Fixed?”  National Judicial College, Reno, NV, July 2010, “Death Penalty Jurisprudence”  Webcast (sponsored by National Judicial College), June 2010, “The Supreme Court and the Death Penalty”  Florida Advanced Judicial Studies, Sanibel, FL, June 2010, “Constitutional Limits on the Death Penalty”  Texas Tech School of Law, Lubbock, TX, April 2009, “The Majestic Conception of the Exclusionary Rule” (Symposium on the Fourth Amendment)  California Attorneys for Criminal Justice, Capital Case Defense Seminar, Monterey, CA, February 2010, “War and Peace in the Jury Room: How Capital Juries Reach Unanimity”  National Judicial College, Fort Myers, FL, October 2009, “The Supreme Court and the Death Penalty”  Supreme Court Preview, October 2009, “Life Without Parole for Juveniles: Line Drawing and the Eighth Amendment”  State of Washington Capital Defenders, Seattle, WA, October 2009, “Making the Case for Life” Page Five  William & Mary School of Law, Williamsburg, VA, September 2009, “Reconciling Discretion and the Death Penalty”

SCOTT E. SUNDBY  Virginia Judicial Education, Florida Virginia Beach, VA,September 2009, “The Supreme Court and the Death Penalty”  Southeastern Association of Law Schools (SEALS), West Palm Beach, FL, June 2009, “Juries and Discretion in the Criminal Justice System”  Georgia Capital Defenders, Atlanta, GA, June 2009, “Thinking About Holdouts”  Florida Advanced Judicial Studies, Sanibel, FL, June 2009, “Constitutional Limits on the Death Penalty”  Washington & Lee School of Law, March 2009, General Lecture, “Moral Wobble and the Death Penalty”  Keynote, Florida Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers, “Death is Different Conference,” Orlando, FL, March 2009, “Understanding Jurors in Making the Case for Life”  DePaul University, School of Law, Workshop, Chicago, IL, March 2009, “War and Peace in the Jury Room”  National Judicial College, San Francisco, CA, March 2009, “Death Penalty Developments”  California Attorneys for Criminal Justice, Capital Case Defense Seminar, Monterey, CA, February 2009, “Lessons from the Capital Jury Project”  Emory University, School of Law, Atlanta, GA, Criminal Procedure Discussion Forum, December 2008, “Suppression Hearings As Morality Plays”  Department of Psychology, Florida International University, Faculty Workshop, Miami, FL, December 2008, “The Psychology of Juror Interactions”  Washington University – St. Louis, School of Law, Faculty Workshop, St. Louis, MO, October 2008, “Group Think and Capital Juries”  Capital Improvement Litigation Grant Lecture, Richmond, Virginia, November 2008 – AThe Supreme Court and the Death Penalty”  Florida International University, School of Law, Faculty Workshop, Miami, FL November 2008, “Group Think and Capital Juries”  Washington University – St. Louis, School of Law, Faculty Workshop, St. Louis, MO, October 2008, “Group Think and Capital Juries”  University of Miami School of Law, Miami, FL, Faculty Workshop, September 2008, “War and Peace in the Jury Room”  NACDL Seminar on Mitigation in Capital Cases, Biloxi, MS, September 2008, “Lessons From the Capital Jury Project”  Southeastern Association of Law Schools (SEALS), Palm Beach, FL, August 2008, Panel, “The Death Penalty: New Age Questions in an Age Old Debate”  Universitat Jaume I, Castello de la Plana, Spain, May 2008, Lecture, “Caminando Sobre La Cuerda Floja Constitucional: La USA PATRIOT Act y La “Guerra Contra El Terror” (“Walking the Constitutional Tightrope: The USA PATRIOT Act and the ‘War On Terror’”)  Universidad de Castilla – Cuenca, Cuenca, Spain, April 2008, “Oyendo Al Jurado A Traves de La Puerta: Una Perspectiva de La Aplicacion de la Pena de Muerte en America” (“Listening at the Jury Room Door: Understanding America and the Death Penalty”) Page Six  Universitat Jaume I, Castello de la Plana, Valencia, Spain, March 2008, General Lecture, “Oyendo Al Jurado A Traves de La Puerta: Una Perspectiva de La Aplicacion de la Pena de Muerte en America”

SCOTT E. SUNDBY  Lecturer in “Cursos de Postgrado en Derecho,” (Continuing Education Program for Spanish and South Amercian Judges), Universidad de Castilla – La Mancha, Toledo, Spain, January 2008, “Caminando Sobre La Cuerda Floja Constitucional: La USA PATRIOT Act y La ‘Guerra Contra El Terror’”  Federal Capital Defense Strategy Session, Baltimore, Maryland, November 2007, “Stories for Life”  Law & Literature Conference, Washington & Lee Univ., November 2007, “The Yin and Yang of Willie Stark,” (using All the King's Men as primary text)  University of Richmond, Roundtable, “Deciding Death: The Supreme Court, Culture, and the Limits of Legal Decision-making,” Richmond, VA, October 2007 (with Professors Paul Marcus and Corinna Lain)  University of California – Hastings, Faculty Workshop, San Francisco, CA, September 2007, “War and Peace in the Jury Room”  University of California – Hastings, Public Lecture, San Francisco, California, September 2007, “Crystal Ball Gazing and the Death Penalty”  Washington University – St. Louis & St. Louis University, St. Louis, Missouri, March 2007, Symposium, “Life and Death Decisions: Prosecutorial Discretion and Capital Punishment”  National Mitigation Conference, Washington, D.C., March 2007,“The ‘Science’ of Jury Decision-making”

PROFESSIONAL ACTIVITIES AND DISTINCTIONS:  Visiting Fellow, Universitat Jaume I, Castelló de la Plana, Valencia, Spain  Guest Faculty, Cursos de Postgrado en Derecho, Universidad de Castilla-La Mancha, Toledo, Spain (Continuing education program for Latin American and Spanish judges)  Parsons Fellow, Faculty of Law, University of Sydney, Sydney, Australia  Visiting Fellow, Griffith University, Brisbane, Australia  Distinguished Scholar in Residence, Institute of Bill of Rights Law, College of William & Mary, Marshall-Wythe School of Law, Williamsburg, Virginia  Distinguished Lecture Series, McGeorge School of Law, Sacramento, California  Faculty, National Judicial College, 1990 - present (instructing judges, prosecutors and defense attorneys on capital punishment and criminal procedure issues)  Board of Editors, University of Dublin Law Journal, Trinity College, Dublin, Ireland  Chair (former), Criminal Justice Section, American Association of Law Schools (AALS)  Member, American Law Institute  Member, California Bar  Board Member (former), American Judicature Society (1995-2002)  Consultant and expert witness testimony in cases involving capital punishment, prosecutorial discovery, and fourth amendment issues  Media interviews on the death penalty and other criminal procedure issues  Teacher of the Year Awards, Hastings College of the Law and Washington & Lee Law School