DOCSLIB.ORG

Terminal Evaluation of the UNEP/GEF Project “Continued Institutional Strengthening Support for Ceits to Meet the Obligations of the Montreal Protocol”

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Terminal Evaluation of the UNEP/GEF Project “Continued Institutional Strengthening Support for Ceits to Meet the Obligations of the Montreal Protocol” 2014 Terminal Evaluation of the UNEP/GEF project “Continued Institutional Strengthening Support for CEITs to meet the obligations of the Montreal Protocol” Valery Smirnov Evaluation Office 15 September 2014 1 TABLE OF CONTENTS Page Acknowledgements ............................................................................................................................. 4 List of acronyms .................................................................................................................................. 5 Project Profile ..................................................................................................................................... 6 Pезюме на русском языке ................................................................................................................ 7 Executive summary ............................................................................................................................. 17 I. Introduction ..................................................................................................................................... 23 II. The Evaluation .............................................................................................................................. 24 A. Objectives of the evaluation ......................................................................................................... 24 B. Overall approach and methods ..................................................................................................... 24 C. Limitations ................................................................................................................................... 26 III. The Project ................................................................................................................................... 26 A. Context ......................................................................................................................................... 26 1. Historical overview .................................................................................................................. 26 2. Other GEF funded activities in CEITs 30 3. Status of NOUs at the starting point of the project 32 B. Objectives and components .......................................................................................................... 32 C. Target areas/groups ...................................................................................................................... 34 D. Milestones/key dates in project design and implementation ........................................................ 35 E. Implementation arrangements ...................................................................................................... 35 1. Implementation approaches and management framework ....................................................... 35 2. The interaction of NOU with members of national steering committee and higher level authorities ....................................................................................................................... 37 3. Response to directives and guidance ........................................................................................ 38 4. Operational and political / institutional problems and constraints ........................................... 38 5. GEF environmental and social safeguards and requirements .................................................. 39 F. Project financing ........................................................................................................................... 39 G. Project partners ............................................................................................................................ 40 H. Changes in design during implementation ................................................................................... 40 I. Reconstructed Theory of Change of the project ............................................................................ 41 IV. Evaluation Findings ..................................................................................................................... 42 A. Strategic relevance ....................................................................................................................... 42 B. Achievement of outputs................................................................................................................ 43 1. Results by categories of outputs ............................................................................................... 43 2. Rating of achievement of output .............................................................................................. 51 C. Effectiveness: Attainment of project objectives and results ......................................................... 52 1. Direct outcomes from reconstructed TOC ............................................................................... 52 2. Likelihood of impact using RoTI and based on reconstructed TOC ........................................ 59 3. Achievement of project goal and planned objectives............................................................... 62 D. Sustainability and replication ....................................................................................................... 63 1. Socio-political sustainability .................................................................................................... 63 2. Financial resources ................................................................................................................... 64 3. Institutional framework ............................................................................................................ 65 4. Environmental sustainability .................................................................................................... 66 5. Catalytic role and replication ................................................................................................... 67 2 Page E. Efficiency ..................................................................................................................................... 67 F. Factors affecting performance ...................................................................................................... 68 1. Preparation and readiness ......................................................................................................... 68 2. Project implementation and management ................................................................................ 69 3. Stakeholder participation and awareness ................................................................................. 69 4. Country ownership and motivation .......................................................................................... 70 5. Evaluation of financial planning .............................................................................................. 71 6. UNEP supervision and backstopping ....................................................................................... 74 7. Monitoring and evaluation ....................................................................................................... 74 8. Use of GEF tracking tolls ......................................................................................................... 75 G. Complementarity with UNEP strategies and programmes........................................................... 75 V. Conclusions and Lessons Learned ............................................................................................... 75 A. Conclusions .................................................................................................................................. 76 B. Lessons Learned ........................................................................................................................... 81 VI. Annexes ......................................................................................................................................... 84 Annex 1- Terms of Reference ........................................................................................................... 84 Annex 2 - Questionnaire .................................................................................................................. 95 Annex 3 - List of individuals consulted and interviewed during the main evaluation phase ............10 1 Annex 4 - 1999 – 2006 GEF funding and co-financing for ODS phase out .....................................10 5 Annex 5 - CEIT ODS consumption and duration of GEF IS projects (separate Excel file) .............1 06 Annex 6 - Assessment of the quality of project design .....................................................................1 07 Annex 7 - Project budget ..................................................................................................................12 2 Annex 8 - Reconstructed Theory of Change .....................................................................................12 5 Annex 9 - Brief resume of the consultant .........................................................................................1 26 3 Acknowledgements I would like to express my very great appreciation to Ms. Harriet Matsaert the Evaluation Officer in the UNEP Evaluation and Oversight Unit for her patient guidance and valuable and constructive critiques during the planning and development of this evaluation, and writing the report. I would like to extend my sincere gratitude to Ms. Elisa
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Cesifo WORLD ECONOMIC SURVEY
    CESifo, a joint initiative of the University of Munich’s Center for Economic Studies and the Ifo Institute for Economic Research CESifo WORLD ECONOMIC SURVEY VOLUME 4, NO. 1 FEBRUARY 2005 WORLD ECONOMIC CLIMATE World Economic Climate is softening ECONOMIC EXPECTATIONS Current economic situation and economic expactations have been downgraded somewhat INFLATION No pick-up expected in 2005 INTEREST RATES Trend of rising interest rates is expected to slow down CURRENCIES US dollar seen as clearly undervalued SPECIAL TOPIC Increased international co-operation on the protection of intellectual property rights required With the support of www.cesifo.de/wes All time series presented in this document plus additional series for about 80 countries may be ordered from the Ifo Institute. For further information please contact Mrs. Stallhofer ([email protected]) For further information apply to: Anna Stangl, e-mail [email protected] (Responsible for statistical processing and analysis) Dr. Gernot Nerb, e-mail [email protected] (Head of Industry Branch Research) CESifo World Economic Survey ISSN 1613-6012 A quarterly publication on the world economic climate Publisher and distributor: Ifo Institute for Economic Research Poschingerstr. 5, D-81679 Munich, Germany Telephone ++49 89 9224-0, Telefax ++49 89 9224-1463, e-mail [email protected] Annual subscription rate: €40.00 Editor: Dr. Gernot Nerb, e-mail [email protected] Reproduction permitted only if source is stated and copy is sent to the Ifo Institute February 2005 Ifo World Economic Survey Regions I World economy: Economy
    [Show full text]
  • Assessing Opportunities and Threats in Kazakhstan's Wild Liquorice Root Trade
    April 2021 SWEET DREAMS ASSESSING OPPORTUNITIES AND THREATS IN KAZAKHSTAN’S WILD LIQUORICE ROOT TRADE Nadejda Gemedzhieva, Artyom Khrokov, Elise Heral, Anastasiya Timoshyna JOINT REPORT ABOUT US TRAFFIC is a leading non-governmental organisation working globally on trade in wild animals and plants in the context of both biodiversity conservation and sustainable development. Reproduction of material appearing in this report requires written permission from the publisher. The designations of geographical entities in this publication, and the presentation of the material, do not imply the expression of any opinion ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS whatsoever on the part of TRAFFIC or its supporting This report was completed under a project implemented between organisations concerning the legal status of any country, territory, or area, or of its authorities, 2019-2022 by TRAFFIC and the Association for the Conservation of or concerning the delimitation of its frontiers or Biodiversity of Kazakhstan (ACBK), under the support of the Keidanren boundaries. Nature Conservation Fund (KNCF). Complementary funds were also gratefully received from Aktionsgemeinschaft Artenschutz (AGA) e.V. Lead author The project aims to reduce unsustainable commercial harvest, which Nadejda Gemedzhieva poses a threat to biodiversity conservation, and to scale up successful sustainable wild liquorice root production from which local people and Published by: nature benefit. We extend our thanks to KNCF for their support. TRAFFIC International, Cambridge, United Kingdom. During the course of this study, many individuals contributed their time, SUGGESTED CITATION expertise, original research and professional advice and the authors Gemedzhieva, N., Khrokov, A., Heral. E., Timoshyna, would like to thank the staff of the following institutions: Forestry A.
    [Show full text]
  • Sergey Abashin Institute of Ethnology and Anthropology of the Russian Academy of Sciences (Moscow) [email protected]
    Sergey Abashin Institute of Ethnology and Anthropology of the Russian Academy of Sciences (Moscow) [email protected] Cultural Processes and Transcultural Influences In Contemporary Central Asia Issues addressed and the aims of the text What is this text about? What are the goals of its author? Some preliminary explanations may help shape the expectations of the reader and prevent possible disappointment. My main purpose is to give a three-dimensional overview of the state of cultural affairs in Central Asian societies after the states in the region achieved independence and to describe the main current tendencies defining local cultural processes and transcultural influences in the long term. I am interested in such themes as: culture and the changing political landscape; the institutional environment for culture; culture and education; culture and language; culture and ethnic minorities; culture and religion; the cultural marketplace; culture and business; culture and globalisation. My questions: how is the Soviet experience of "cultural construction” used and transformed in the modern nation-states of Central Asia? what restrictions on cultural production are imposed by the political situation and economic possibilities of these countries? how do the processes of isolationism and globalisation interact? what changes are being wrought by the islamisation of these societies? what is the future potential of secular, European-style, culture? who are the main players in the region’s cultural space? These questions might seem too general, but without considering and judging them, any attempt to understand the essence of events in narrower fields of cultural life is, surely, doomed to failure. In an “analytical note”, a number of general recommendations for the work of international organisations in the cultural sphere of Central Asia are presented.
    [Show full text]
  • Medicine Prices and Pricing Policies in Vietnam
    MEDICINE PRICES AND PRICING POLICIES IN VIETNAM Tuan Anh Nguyen A thesis submitted in fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy School of Public Health & Community Medicine Faculty of Medicine, University of New South Wales, Australia April 2011 THE UNIVERSITY OF NEW SOUTH WALES Thesis/Dissertation Sheet Surname or Family name: Nguyen First name: Tuan Anh Other name/s: Abbreviation for degree as given in the University calendar: PhD School: Public Health and Community Medicine Faculty: Medicine Title: Medicine prices and pricing policies in Vietnam Abstract 350 words maximum: Availability of affordable medicines is one precondition to realizing the fundamental human right of access to essential healthcare. Although Vietnam is progressing well with several health-related targets of the Millennium Development Goals being achieved ahead of time, attaining equitable access to affordable medicines remains problematic. In this thesis, a mixed-method approach was adopted in the analysis of medicine prices and polices. The literature was reviewed, followed by an analysis of Vietnam’s pharmaceutical market and legislation. A quantitative study of medicine prices, and a qualitative study on how and why high, unaffordable prices occurred, were conducted. The findings were synthesized to form policy recommendations. The studies demonstrated that medicine prices in Vietnam were unreasonably high. Adjusted for Purchasing Power Parity in 2005, prices in the public sector were 46.58 times the international reference price for innovator-brand medicines and 11.41 times for the lowest-priced generic equivalents. Monopoly of supply was an important cause of high innovator-brand prices. More complex, intrinsic features of Vietnam’s healthcare system were also reported by key stakeholders as driving up prices.
    [Show full text]
  • Prevention of Perinatal HBV Transmission
    PreventionPrevention ofof perinatalperinatal HBVHBV transmission:transmission: EvaluationEvaluation ofof programsprograms andand successsuccess storiesstories fromfrom CentralCentral AsiaAsia andand KazakhstanKazakhstan Michael O. Favorov MD, Ph.D., D.Sc. Ludmila Mosina MD CDC Central Asia Office Division of Viral Hepatitis, NCID, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention Key Elements in Developing a Program to Prevent HBV Transmission Define epidemiology of disease Quantify disease burden Develop a comprehensive prevention strategy Identify resources to implement program Define epidemiology of disease and quantify disease burden ReportedReported AcuteAcute ViralViral HepatitisHepatitis IncidenceIncidence RateRate inin CentralCentral AsiaAsia byby Country,Country, 19871987--20052005 1600 Kazakhstan 1400 Kyrgyzstan p 1200 e Tajikistan r 1000 Turkmenistan 1 0 Uzbekistan 0 800 0 600 0 0 400 200 0 7 8 9 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 0 1 2 3 4 5 8 8 8 9 9 9 9 9 9 9 9 9 9 00 Year 2 EtiologyEtiology ofof acuteacute viralviral hepatitishepatitis inin KazakhstanKazakhstan,, 20042004 non A-C HВV - 0,9% 15,5% HDV - 0,1% HСV - 2,5% HЕV- 0,02% HАV - 81,0% AcuteAcute ViralViral HepatitisHepatitis SentinelSentinel SurveillanceSurveillance Sites,Sites, KyrgyzstanKyrgyzstan 20002000 Total Total CCaasesses repor reportedted – –20,42220,422 SentinelSentinel S Sitesites CaseCasess – –11,178,178 (5.8%) (5.8%) 20012001 Total Total casescases repor reportedted – –111,3981,398 SentinelSentinel S Sitesites CaseCasess – –679679 (5.9%) (5.9%) Jaundice EtiologyEtiology ofof
    [Show full text]
  • New Technologies for Human Development in Kazakhstan National Human Development Report - 2006
    New technologies for human development in Kazakhstan National human development report - 2006 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY for the development of human potential and the current status of technological development in Kazakhstan. Present-day development trends The purpose of create the need for a new approach to Technologies as a tool for social and economy is human defining the purpose of development and human development the economy. The traditional definition development The first chapter looks at human aiming to ensure a states the main purpose of an economy is to meet growing human needs with development as an end, to which human decent life finite resources. Today, recognizing the development factors such as economic important role of human development, growth, education, healthcare and go- this definition should be changed to say: od environment are the means: new “The purpose of an economy is human technologies are regarded as a tool for the development aiming to ensure a decent development of human potential. life”. Human development is understood Thus, innovations improve productivity, to be the continuous expansion of profits and people’s income and ensure human opportunities to enjoy or have access to better quality goods and a choice of political, economic, social, services. New technologies have a positive spiritual and cultural participation. A effect on human and social health by decent life implies broad-based access reducing deaths and increasing births and to high-quality education, healthcare, life expectancy. The introduction of new social schemes, healthy food, extensive technologies in education is vital to the participation in society and other benefits competitiveness of national human capital.
    [Show full text]
  • Mid Term Evaluation Report
    MID TERM EVALUATION REPORT UNODC Project AD/RER/00/E29 Precursor Control in Central Asia Kazakhstan, Kyrgyzstan, Tajikistan, Turkmenistan and Uzbekistan Report of Evaluator Steve Alm M.Sc. Special Analyst 31 October – 25 November 2005 UNITED NATIONS OFFICE ON DRUGS AND CRIME Vienna 1 CONTENTS Page LIST OF ACRONYMS 3 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY 4 I. INTRODUCTION 8 1.1. Background and Context 8 1.2. Purpose and Objective of the Evaluation 10 1.3. Executing Modality / Management Arrangements 10 1.4. Scope of the Evaluation 11 1.5. Evaluation Methodology 12 2. ANALYSIS AND MAJOR FINDINGS 2.1. Overall performance assessment (Appropriateness, Relevance, 13 Effectiveness, Efficiency) 2.2. Attainment of Objectives 16 2.3. Achievement of Programme/Project Results and outputs 17 2.4. Implementation (Operational Plan, Monitoring and Backstopping) 17 2.5. Institutional and Management Arrangements 18 3. OUTCOMES, IMPACTS and SUSTAINABILITY 18 3.1. Outcomes 18 3.2. Impact 19 3.3. Sustainability 20 4. LESSONS LEARNED AND BEST PRACTICES 20 4.1. Lessons Learned 20 4.2. Best Practices 21 4.3. Constraints 22 5. RECOMMENDATIONS 22 5.1. Issues resolved during evaluation 24 5.2. Actions/decisions recommended 24 6. OVERALL CONCLUSIONS 25 ANNEXES A. Terms of reference B. Organizations and places visited and persons met C. Activities Table D. Table of removed objectives and activities 2 ACRONYMS DCA Drug Control Agency DLO Drug Liaison Officer FANC Foreign Anti-Narcotics Community INCB International Narcotics Control Board NDS National Data System ROCA Regional Office
    [Show full text]
  • Pdf 527.57 K
    International Journal of Political Science ISSN: 2228-6217 Vol.7, No 4, Winter 2017, (pp.1-21) The Impact of the Shanghai Cooperation Organization on Central Asia’s Security Hedayat Allah Nobar Turkaman1, Fatemeh Hashemi2, Mohammadreza Dehshiri3* 1Department of International Relations, South Tehran Branch, Islamic Azad University, Tehran, Iran 2 2Department of International Relations, South Tehran Branch, Islamic Azad University, Tehran, Iran 3 Department of International Relations, School of International Relations (SIR), Tehran, Iran Received: 22 Nov 2016 ; Accepted: 20 Oct 2017 Abstract: This paper tries to address the impact of the Shanghai Cooperation Organization on Central Asian security. This organization was established on April 26, 1996 to settle security and territo- rial disputes between China and Russia and Central Asian countries (other than Uzbekistan and Turkmenistan). After the accession of Uzbekistan to this assembly, the level of the organization was promoted, and its geographic scope has been expanded in the following years by the mem- bership of new countries. Although significant changes have been made and economic issues have been raised in the process of developments in this regional security cooperation, this or- ganization has paid attention to security-military disputes and problems. The main question of the paper is how does the Shanghai Cooperation Organization play a role in the Central Asia’s security? This paper fully addresses the impact of the Shanghai Cooperation Organization on Central Asia, and the effects of this organization on the security and stability of Central Asia with the settlement of regional conflicts, such as fighting against terrorism, separatism and ex- tremism, drug and arms trade, organizational crimes, concerns about insecurity and domestic instability, and in particular the occurrence of color revolutions in countries and confronting with American influence and unilateralism.
    [Show full text]
  • Journal 2011 08.Indd
    Climate Change and its Impacts on Older Adults’ Health in Kazakhstan Shahjahan H. Bhuiyan1, Hafi z T. A. Khan2 Abstract Th ere has been growing concern over climate change and its impacts on many as- pects of human society, particularly on health. Climate change may aff ect health in a wide range of forms: increased fl oods and droughts, increased frequency and intensity of heat waves, changes in the distribution of vector-borne diseases and ef- fects on the risk of disasters and malnutrition (Haines et al. 2006b). So far, little is known about climate change and its impacts on older adults’ health in Central Asia, particularly in Kazakhstan, where a downturn of life expectancy has been preva- lent. Th e objective of this paper is to examine the impacts of climate change on older adults’ health in Kazakhstan. Based on the literature review and empirical evi- dence, this study concludes that climate change largely aff ects older adults’ health in Kazakhstan. Th is study emphasizes that older adults are becoming increasingly aware of the climate-change risks and its impacts on human health. Older adults are matured human capital of any society and can be utilized to address the climate- related health consequences in the twenty-fi rst century. It is hoped that the fi ndings of this study will have enormous policy implications. Keywords: Climate change; health; Kazakhstan; older adults. 1 Corresponding author. Associate Professor / Chair, Department of Public Administration, Kazakh- stan Institute of Management, Economics, and Strategic Research (KIMEP), Almaty, and Visiting Research Fellow, Oxford Institute of Population Ageing (OIA), University of Oxford, UK.
    [Show full text]
  • 669430Br0draft0official0use0o
    Public Disclosure Authorized Performance of Transport Corridors in Central and South Asia Measurements 2008-2009 Public Disclosure Authorized Transport Unit, Sustainable Development Department Europe and Central Asia Region DRAFT, May 2011 Public Disclosure Authorized Document of the World Bank Public Disclosure Authorized Vice President, Europe and Central Asia: Phillipe H. Le Houerou Country Director, ECCU8: Motoo Konishi Sector Manager, Transport ECSSD: Henry Kerali Task Team, ECSSD: Cordula Rastogi Nargis Ryskulova ABBREVIATIONS AND ACRONYMS ADB Asian Development Bank BCP Border Crossing Point BEEPS Business Environment and Enterprise Performance Survey BOMCA Border Management Programme in Central Asia CAREC Central Asia Region Economic Cooperation CIS Commonwealth of Independent States ECA Eastern Europe and Central Asia Region ETI Enabling Trade Index EU European Union GTZ Gesellschaft fuer Technische Zusammenarbeit IP Investment Projects ISAF International Security Assistance Force LPG Liquid Petroleum Gas LPI Logistics Performance Index MNA Middle East and Northern Africa Region MS Bar Molten Soft Bar NATO North Atlantic Treaty Organization NSW National Single Window OECD Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development ROW Rest of World RTC Road Transport Corridor TA Technical Assistance TIR Transports Internationaux Routiers TTFCA Trade and Transport Facilitation Central Asia UNCTAD United Nations Conference on Trade and Development USAID United States Agency for International Development WCO World Custom Organization WDR
    [Show full text]
  • Millennium Development Goals in Kazakhstan
    2010 MILLENNIUM DEVELOPMENT GOALS IN KAZAKHSTAN Report materials can be reproduced in full or in parts without prior consent provided proper reference is made to this publication. The views presented in this publication are those of the authors and do not necessarily represent the views of the UN Country Team, the Government of Kazakhstan or other organisations with which the authors may be affiliated. MILLENNIUM DEVELOPMENT GOALS IN KAZAKHSTAN 2010 Table of Contents: EXECUTIVE SUMMARY 11 GOAL 1. TO ERADICATE EXTREME POVERTY AND HUNGER 16 Target 1. To halve, between 1990 and 2015, the proportion of people whose income is below the subsistence minimum Target 2. To halve, between 1990 and 2015, the proportion of people who suffer from hunger GOAL 2. TO ACHIEVE UNIVERSAL PRIMARY EDUCATION 36 Target 3. To ensure that by 2015 children everywhere, boys and girls alike, will be able to complete a full course of primary schooling GOAL 3. TO PROMOTE GENDER EQUALITY AND EMPOWER WOMEN 50 Target 4. To eliminate gender disparity in primary and secondary education, preferably by 2005 and at all levels of education no later than 2015 Target 4+. • To ensure adoption and implementation of measures aimed at increasing representation of women in legislative and executive bodies • To ensure legislative and enforcement measures to prevent and eliminate violence against women • To ensure sustainable gender mainstreaming of national planning and budgeting, especially aiming at minimising the gender wage gap GOAL 4. TO REDUCE CHILD MORTALITY 60 Target 5. To reduce by two thirds, between 1990 and 2015, the under-five mortality rate GOAL 5.
    [Show full text]
  • State of Forests of the Caucasus and Central Asia
    State of Forests of the Caucasus and Central Asia State of Forests of the Caucasus and Central Asia GENEVA TIMBER AND FOREST STUDY PAPER Overview of forests and sustainable forest management in the Caucasus and Central Asia region New York and Geneva, 2019 2 State of Forests of the Caucasus and Central Asia COPYRIGHT AND DISCLAIMER Copyright© 2019 United Nations and the Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations. All rights reserved worldwide. The designations employed in UNECE and FAO publications, which are in conformity with United Nations practice, and the presentation of material therein do not imply the expression of any opinion whatsoever on the part of the United Nations Economic Commission for Europe (UNECE) or the Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations (FAO) concerning the legal status of any country; area or territory or of its authorities, or concerning the delimitation of its frontiers. The responsibility for opinions expressed in this study and other contributions rests solely with their authors, and its publication does not constitute an endorsement by UNECE or FAO of the opinions expressed. Reference to names of firms and commercial products and processes, whether or not these have been patented, does not imply their endorsement by UNECE or FAO, and any failure to mention a particular firm, commercial product or process is not a sign of disapproval. This work is copublished by the United Nations (UNECE) and FAO. ABSTRACT The study on the state of forests in the Caucasus and Central Asia aims to present the forest resources and the forest sector of the region, including trends in, and pressures on the resource, to describe the policies and institutions for the forest sector in the region and to list the major challenges the sector faces, and the policy responses in place or planned.
    [Show full text]