Santa Ana River Hydroelectric System San
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
SANTA ANA RIVER HYDROELECTRIC SYSTEM HAER No. CA-130 SAN BERNARDINO NATIONAL FOREST REDLANDS VICINITY SAN BERNARDINO COUNTY PF_R CALIFORNIA PHOTOGRAPHS WRITTEN HISTORICAL AND DESCRIPTIVE DATA HISTORIC AMERICAN ENIGNEERING RECORD NATIONAL PARK SERVICE WESTERN REGIONAL OFFICE DEPARTMENT OF THE INTERIOR SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA 94107 ma c, 0-/-- HISTORIC AMERICAN ENGINEERING RECORD Ou7 • SANTA ANA RIVER HYDROELECTRIC SYSTEM HAER No. CA-130 Location: The southern boundary of the Santa Ana Hydroelectric System is located in the Santa Ana River Canyon, 1.4 miles northeast of the City of Redlands in San Bernardino County, California and 0,52 mile northeast of Greenspot Road. The distance between the northern and southern ends of the system is approximately 3.8 miles, oriented southwest to northeast. USGS Yucaipa and Keller Peak Quadrangles, Universal Transverse Mercator Coordinates: North end (SAR 1): 10.494720.3778100. South end (SAR 3): 10.490900.3773920 Date of Construction: SAR 1 - 1898; SAR 2 - 1905; SAR 3 - 1904 Engineer: O. H. Ensign; E. M. Boggs Builder: Thornton and Leonardy, Redlands; Mentone Power Company (SAR 3) Present Owner: Southern California Edison Company, P.O. Box 800, Rosemead, California 91770 Present Use: Operating hydroelectric generating facilities to be affected by new Seven Oaks Dam Significance: When completed in 1898, Powerhouse 1 had the longest transmission line in the country, and possibly the largest hydroelectric generators in the world. Innovative features which became industry standards include the individual tail races, internal revolving field alternators, and transposition of wires. When Powerhouses 2 and 3 were added, the system became the prototype for the larger hydroelectric systems of the twentieth century. Nominated to the National Register of Historic Places in 1985; American Society of Civil Engineers Historic and Engineering Landmark in 1985. Report Prepared by: Mark T. Swanson, Historian Greenwood and Associates 725 Jacon Way Pacific Palisades, California 90272-2830 David De Vries, Photographer Mesa Technical 2630 Hilgard Berkeley, California 94709-1002 Date: November 1992 Santa Ana River Hydroelectric System HAER No. CA-130 Page 2 CONTENTS Introduction 5 Environmental Setting 5 Historical Setting 9 Generalized Scheme of Powerhouse Operation 11 Summary 12 Early Electrical Work 18 Period to ca. 1875 18 Supremacy of Arc Lights, 1876-ca. 1879 21 Edison's Achievements, 1879-1886 24 Direct Current and the First Motors 27 Development of Alternating Current, ca. 1885-1890 30 Consolidation of Electrical Companies, ca. 1889-1892 35 Early Electrical Developments in Southern California 39 Overview, 1892-1892 39 The Pomona Plant, 1891-1892 43 The Mill Creek Plant, 1892-1896 46 Westside Lighting Company and the Southern California Edison System, 1888-1909 52 Development of Santa Ana River No. 1 56 The Santa Ana Canal, 1892-1894 56 » Organizational Beginnings 60 Construction and Original Layout of SAR 1 Features 61 Intake/Headworks 62 Conduit Systems/Tunnels and Flumes 63 Reservoir, Forebay, and Pressure Pipe 68 Receiver 69 Powerhouse Construction 71 Physical Plant 71 Water Wheels, Governors, Tail Races 73 Generators 7 6 Exciters 76 Wiring, Switchboards, and Transformers 77 Orville Ensign and the Development of the Transmission Line 79 Line Wires and Insulators 81 Transmission Line and Wire Transposition 84 Plant Start-Up and Initial Problems 87 Other Famous Santa Ana Plant Personnel 89 Major Support Structures at SAR 1 90 Impact of SAR 1 and Subsequent Development of the Edison Electric Company 92 Santa Ana River Hydroelectric System HAER No. CA-130 Page 3 Santa Ana River No. 2 95 Intake and Conduit System 96 Powerhouse Plant 98 Water Wheels 99 Generators and Exciters 100 Transformers and Wiring 101 7. Santa Ana River No. 3 103 Intake and Conduit System 103 Pressure Pipe 106 Physical Plant and Auxiliary Buildings 106 Water Wheel 107 Generators and Exciters 108 Wiring, Switchboard, and Transformers 109 Plans for Other Powerhouses in the Canyon 110 8. The Santa Ana River Hydroelectric Community, 1905-1921 111 9. Development of the Edison Distribution System 119 Hydroelectric Developments in the Sierra Nevada 119 Evolution of the Edison System, ca. 1910-1940s 121 Alterations to the SAR System, 1912-1980 125 10. Conclusion 135 Sources 139 References 140 # Appendix List of Engineering Drawings at Southern California Edison 156 Figures 1. Vicinity Map 2. Drainage Basins and the Powerhouses 3. Brush Arc-Lamp, ca. 1880 22 4. Early Edison Lamps 25 5. The Edison General Electric Company, 1891 28 6. Sprague Electric Motor 29 7. Early Transformers 33 8. Principle of the Pelton Wheel 42 9. Three-Phase Synchronous Motor, 1903 49 10. Plan of Sand Box 63 11. Flume Construction 67 12. Plan and Profile of SAR 1, 1899 72 13. End Section of SAR 1 75 14. Plan of Tail Races 75 15. Interior of SAR 1 Powerhouse, 1909 79 16. Wiring Diagram, SAR 1, 1910 80 17. 10,000-Volt Insulators 83 Santa Ana River Hydroelectric System HAER No. CA-130 Page *i 18. Redlands Type Imperial Porcelain Insulator 83 19- Generic Imperial Porcelain Insulator, ca. 1897 85 20. Santa Ana Glass Insulator 85 21. Santa Ana Pole Line 86 22. Transmission Lines in Southern California, 1899 87 23. Plan of SAR i 91 24. SAR 2 Powerhouse, 1907 98 25. Wiring Diagram, SAR 2, 1910 102 26. Southern California Edison Company Transmission Lines, 1913 120 27. Southern California Edison Company Transmission Lines, 1925 122 28. Concrete Sand Box, SAR 1, 1913 126 Table 1. Southern California Edison Genealogy 55 Santa Ana River Hydroelectric System HAER No. CA-130 Page 5 HISTORIC AMERICAN ENGINEERING RECORD, CA-130 SANTA ANA RIVER HYDROELECTRIC SYSTEM 1. INTRODUCTION Environmental Setting Santa Ana River Powerhouses 1, 2, and 3, collectively known as the Santa Ana River Hydroelectric System, are located along the Santa Ana River, between the higher elevations of the San Bernardino Mountains and the mouth of the Santa Ana Canyon at Mentone, The three Santa Ana River powerhouses, and their water intake systems, are all linked together, making use of the same water at successively lower elevations along the Santa Ana River. The whole system is located in the mountainous San Bernardino National Forest, San Bernardino County, California, about 70 miles due east of downtown Los Angeles (Figure 1). The three facilities, currently known as Santa Ana River Powerhouses 1, 2, and 3, are often abbreviated to SAR 1, SAR 2, and SAR 3. Powerhouse 1 is the highest in elevation, followed by the other two in sequential order. The intake for Powerhouse 1 is located near the northeast corner of Section 19, Township 1 North, Range 1 West, San Bernardino Base Meridian. From there, the water conduit extends slightly more than 2.5 miles on the north and west side of the Santa Ana River to Powerhouse 1, located in the northeast quarter of Section 26, Township 1 North, Range 2 West. From the tailrace of SAR 1, the conduit of Powerhouse 2 crosses the river and extends just over 1.5 miles on the south and east side to Powerhouse 2, located in the northeast quarter of Section 34, Township 1 North, Range 2 West. From the tailrace of SAR 2, the conduit for Powerhouse 3 continues on the south and east side of the river for another 2.5 miles until it reaches Powerhouse 3, situated in the southwest quarter of Section 4, Township 1 South, Range 2 West (CA-13 0-56) . The total distance covered by this system, from the intake of SAR 1 to the tailrace of SAR 3, is 7.06 miles (Hornbeck and Botts 1938:19). There is a discrepancy among the most reliable sources as to the elevation of the system, especially SAR 1. To compound the problem, local USGS quadrangle maps vary yet again from the sources. The most accurate elevations appear to be those used by C.E. Fowler in an 18 99 article describing the construction and operation of Santa Ana No. 1. The other disagreements are relatively minor. With these provisos, the total drop in elevation within this system, from the intake of Powerhouse 1 to Powerhouse 3, is roughly 1472 feet. The SAR 1 intake is located at approximately 3422 feet above mean sea level (AMSL) . Water collected here drops 752 feet into Powerhouse 1, situated at 2670 feet AMSL (Fowler 1899:146). The water again drops another 320 Santa Ana River Hydroelectric System HAER No. CA-130 Page 6 Santa Ana River Hydroelectric System HAER No. CA-130 Page 7 feet to Powerhouse 2, situated at 2350 feet AMSL. The final drop of 400 feet goes into Powerhouse 3, situated at 1950 feet AMSL (Hornbeck and Botts 1988:20-21). The three powerhouses are located within the San Bernardino Mountains, one of the east-west Transverse Ranges of southern California. The Transverse Ranges create the mountainous northern rim of the Los Angeles Basin. Within these ranges, the San Bernardino Mountains form a relatively compact group, separated from the San Gabriel Mountains to the west by the Cajon Pass, and differentiated from the Little San Bernardino Mountains to the east by Morongo Valley (Sharp 1976:10-12). The San Bernardino Mountains are among the highest that form the Los Angeles Basin, and the streams that flow from these mountains are some of the largest in southern California. The central portion of the San Bernardino Range is divided into three east-west trending valleys, all of which drain to the west or southwest (Figure 2). The northernmost of these valleys is Bear Valley, drained by Bear Creek. The central valley, also known as the Seven Oaks area, is formed by the upper reaches of the Santa Ana River. The southern valley is formed by Mill Creek. Bear Creek and the upper Santa Ana are separated by Sugarloaf Mountain (9952 feet AMSL) and its ridges.