MALVERN HILLS DISTRICT COUNCIL

HOUSING LAND SUPPLY MONITOR

2 013/ 2014

Data Monitored up to 31/03/2014

CONTENTS

INTRODUCTION 2

PART ONE: Malvern Hills District‟s Dwelling Completions 2013/14 3

PART TWO: Malvern Hills District‟s Dwelling Commitments at April 2014 14

PART THREE: Meeting Malvern Hills District‟s Housing Requirements 21

PART FOUR: Assessing and Delivering Housing Land – Components of Supply 23

PART FIVE: Five Year Housing Land Supply Update (2014-2019) 37

PART SIX: Conclusions 42

APPENDICES

APPENDIX A – Main Data Report APPENDIX B – Commitments Table APPENDIX C – Windfall Allowance Calculation Sites APPENDIX D – SWDP Site Allocations in Five Year Supply APPENDIX E – Large Windfall Sites in Five Year Supply APPENDIX F – Over/Under Supply Calculations APPENDIX G – Five Year Housing Land Supply Summary Table

Malvern Hills District Council - Housing Land Supply Monitor 2014 1

INTRODUCTION

The Malvern Hills Housing Land Supply Monitor is the principal information source for the annual housing supply update within Malvern Hills District. This report contains analysis of the housing land situation at 31st March 2014. This study examines the trend in planning permissions, housing completions, progress in the provision of affordable housing and the contribution made towards the supply of housing on previously developed land.

This report examines Malvern Hills District‟s supply of available and deliverable housing land and provides an update on Malvern Hills‟ five year housing land supply. The status of each site is obtained from status update checks carried out by planning officers in April to May of each year.

This report has been produced to take into account the continued joint working of Malvern Hills District Council, Worcester City Council and Wychavon District Council in preparing the South Worcestershire Development Plan (SWDP) and tracking progress towards meeting the proposed housing requirements of South Worcestershire from 2006 to 2030.

Please note that the uplift in the housing requirements recommended by the Inspector examining the South Worcestershire Development Plan (SWDP) in his further interim conclusions (28th March 2014) is referenced in section five but at this stage the distribution of the housing between the three south Worcestershire Councils has not been finalised and therefore only „policy-off‟ housing requirements are outlined.

For additional information, please see the appendices that accompany this main report for a full breakdown of the data used in the study.

For further information relating to the housing requirement, and approaches to calculating the five year housing land supply, please see the council‟s Position Statements on Housing Land Supply, available on the MHDC website.

Malvern Hills District Council - Housing Land Supply Monitor 2014 2

PART ONE MALVERN HILLS DISTRICT - DWELLING COMPLETIONS 2013/14

1.1 This section examines the number and make up of dwellings completed within Malvern Hills District in 2013/14. The section is split into two themes, firstly total annual new build completions and secondly demolitions, conversions and change of use. The combined result of these two themes provides a net additional dwellings figure for 2013/14. The net figure, along with previous net figures, is used to monitor against relevant housing targets.

Total Annual New Build Completions in 2013/14 1.2 In the twelve months up to 31st March 2014, a total of 198 dwellings (gross) were completed in Malvern Hills District. The gross completions average per annum since 2006/07 is 228 dwellings. For gross new build completions, Malvern Hills‟ total for 2013/14 is 145 dwellings. Taking into account demolitions, changes of use and conversions, the net increase to the dwelling stock during 2013/14 is 184 dwellings.

1.3

Net Net

use

Year

Total Total

Change of

(gross)

NewBuild

Dwellings**

Conversion

Demolitions

Total Total Annual Completions

Completions*

losses/ gains losses/ gains

Net Net Additional Net 2006/07 160 2 4 21 187 183 2007/08 212 21 21 87 330 299 2008/09 182 16 27 63 272 256 2009/10 174 17 2 63 245 222 2010/11 107 7 4 33 149 137 2011/12 209 5 0 25 254 229 2012/13 145 5 14 22 191 176 2013/14 145 2 25 16 198 184 TOTAL 1,334 75 97 330 1,826 1,686

Table 1: Net Additional dwellings completed April 2006 to March 2014

Malvern Hills District Council - Housing Land Supply Monitor 2014 3

*‟Total Completions‟ is a gross figure which takes into account all dwellings built (including replacement dwellings and demolitions). **The formula used to establish total net additional dwellings is as follows:

Total annual new build completions (gross) + Conversion losses and gains + Change of use losses and gains – Demolitions.

Figure 1: Net Additional Dwellings by Year since 2006/07

1.4 The total amount of new builds in this monitoring period 2013/14 equates to 145 dwellings on 36 sites. This is the same outcome as 2012/13, but with the total spread out over an increased number of sites. 2013/14 saw a 4 per cent increase in net additional dwellings when compared to the previous monitoring year. It is likely that this upward trend will continue over the next few years at a greater rate, with net dwelling completions set to increase as a result of an anticipated uplift in the number of planning permissions contributing to the supply.

Malvern Hills District Council - Housing Land Supply Monitor 2014 4

1.5 In terms of future supply contributing to the housing stock for Malvern Hills, the remaining housing land allocated in the adopted Local Plan (1996-2011) is mostly built out and the South Worcestershire Development Plan (SWDP) containing future proposed housing allocations is currently at the examination stage and has yet to reach formal adoption. However, a number of planning applications have now been granted permission on some of the proposed SWDP allocation sites, with a number of these sites included in the 2013/14 supply. Additionally, there are further sites that have a resolution to grant permission subject to the signing of a Section 106 Agreement. While these sites are expected to be counted as official commitments in the 2014/15 monitoring period, these sites have also been included as an additional component of the Five Year Supply for 2013/14 as they are considered to be partly or wholly deliverable within five years. Appendix ‘D’ provides a list of these sites.

1.6 Planning applications have also been submitted on a number of large windfall (i.e. non-SWDP) sites. Of those listed in Appendix ‘E’, most of the sites have been approved at Planning Committee or as a delegated decision (subject to Section 106 agreements), but some sites have been allowed on appeal by the Planning Inspectorate. Most sites were not approved (i.e. signed S106) during the 2013/14 monitoring period but have been included as an additional component of the Five Year Supply for 2013/14 as they are considered to be partly or wholly deliverable within five years (sites have been monitored up to 30th June 2014). It is anticipated that this upturn in supply of housing sites will subsequently increase the annual future dwelling stock completions in Malvern Hills in future years. For information relating to affordable housing (completions and commitments), please see pages 16 to 20.

1.7 Figure 2 below illustrates the gross number and proportion of new dwellings completed on previously developed (brownfield land) and greenfield land categorisations, which includes residential garden land sites. For the purposes of this chart, gross completions are made up of

Malvern Hills District Council - Housing Land Supply Monitor 2014 5

new build dwellings, gains from change of use and gains from conversions.

Figure 2: Gross Brownfield and Greenfield land completions since 2006/07.

1.8 The proportion of new housing completed on greenfield land had been in decline for the monitoring years up to 2009/10. However during 2010/11 and 2011/12, the number of greenfield completions as a proportion of total completions rose, with 2011/12 recording the highest percentage to date. 2012/13 saw an improvement of brownfield land completions (primarily due to the 99 dwellings completed on the Malvern Vale/North Site development), taking the proportion back up to 80%. For 2013/14, the brownfield/greenfield split almost mimics that of 2011/12, including a higher than average proportion of greenfield site completions. Since 2006/07, 77% of all gross completions have been on previously developed (brownfield) land. However, it is anticipated that completions on large greenfield sites (5 dwellings or more) will increase in the next five years following the current (and forecast) rise in planning applications and subsequent permissions on such sites. This will be a combination of SWDP sites and large windfall sites.

Malvern Hills District Council - Housing Land Supply Monitor 2014 6

Total Year 06/07 07/08 08/09 09/10 10/11 11/12 12/13 13/14 to Date

Greenfield 50 69 35 39 44 98 39 75 449 Land

Brownfield 137 261 237 206 104 156 152 123 1,376 Land TOTALS 187 330 272 245 148 254 191 198 1,825 Table 2: Gross dwelling completions on greenfield and brownfield land since 2006/07.

1.9 Table 3 and Figure 3 indicate that in recent years, Malvern Hills has increasingly relied on allocated Local Plan sites (1996-2011) as an important component of the housing land supply. However, this has changed in 2013/14 with no local plan sites recorded as complete within the year. There are still a few Local Plan sites remaining that are yet to commence or be fully built out but it is expected that SWDP sites and (to a lesser extent) large windfall sites will constitute the majority of the supply in future years. In terms of windfalls (permissions on unallocated sites), the completions breakdown on sites in 2013/14 has been fairly evenly spread between small (1 to 4) and large windfalls (10 plus) with medium categories (between 5-9 dwellings) only counting for 7% of the total. 93% of the completions in 2013/14 were from windfalls.

Malvern Hills District Council - Housing Land Supply Monitor 2014 7

MHDC District Windfall Sites* Proposed Local Plan Year SWDP Sites Allocated 10 Dwellings 5 to 9 1 to 4 Total Windfalls (2006-2030) Sites (1996- or More Dwellings Dwellings 2011) 2006/07 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 18 (10%) 169 (90%) 187 (100%) 2007/08 0 (0%) 14 (4%) 70 (21%) 246 (75%) 316 (96%) 2008/09 0 (0%) 59 (22%) 96 (35%) 118 (43%) 214 (78%) 2009/10 0 (0%) 93 (38%) 66 (27%) 86 (35%) 152 (62%) 2010/11 0 (0%) 62 (42%) 14 (9%) 10 (7%) 63 (42%) 87 (58%) 2011/12 0 (0%) 93 (37%) 33 (13%) 24 (9%) 104 (41%) 161 (63%) 2012/13 0 (0%) 99 (52%) 0 (0%) 21 (11%) 71 (37%) 92 (48%) 2013/14 14 (7%) 0 (0%) 80 (40%) 13 (7%) 91 (46%) 184 (93%) TOTALS 14 (1%) 420 (23%) 377 (20%) 1,016 (56%) 1,393 (76%) Table 3: Total number of gross completions by planning policy housing type *This includes Brownfield, Greenfield and Residential Garden Land Completions

Figure 3: Small windfall sites (0 to 4 dwellings), large windfall sites (5 or more dwellings), local plan allocated sites and proposed SWDP sites completions as a percentage of the total per year.

Malvern Hills District Council - Housing Land Supply Monitor 2014 8

1.10 Table 4 below shows a further breakdown of completed dwellings by type and size. Analysis of all properties built this year shows that of the total 198 dwellings completed (gross), 165 were houses (83%), 32 were flats (16%) and 1 site was unknown (1%).

No. of Bed Units Dwelling 4 Bed & Total Type 1 Bed 2 Bed 3 Bed more Houses & 4 34 68 59 165 Bungalows Flats & 9 23 0 0 32 Maisonettes Unknown 1

Totals 13 57 68 59 198 Totals As % 7% 29% 34% 30% 100%

Table 4: Completed dwellings by type and size 2013/14

1.11 As illustrated by Tables 4 and 5, there has been a slight decrease in the number of flatted developments when compared to the previous monitoring period. The largest element of built dwellings continue to be from two, three and four-plus bedroomed houses and bungalows. It is important to monitor these trends to ensure the appropriate types of dwellings are meeting the needs of the district in line with emerging policy SWDP 14: Housing Mix. Table 5 shows the breakdown of completed dwellings by type since 2006/07.

Malvern Hills District Council - Housing Land Supply Monitor 2014 9

Houses & Flats & Unknown/Not Year Total (Gross) Bungalows Maisonettes Categorised* 2006/07 150 18 19 187 2007/08 247 63 20 330 2008/09 146 117 9 272 2009/10 195 33 17 245 2010/11 128 19 2 149 2011/12 218 34 2 254 2012/13 142 48 1 191 2013/14 165 32 1 198 TOTALS 1,391 364 71 1,826

Table 5: Completed dwellings by type since 2006/07 *These are sites where either dwelling type information was unavailable or sites were not categorised, e.g. mobile homes.

1.12 The total average gross density1 of completed sites and or completed phases for larger schemes on the total gross site area was 14 dwellings per hectare. This calculation only includes fully completed sites and completed phases of larger sites. For this calculation there were 162 dwellings completed (net) on 11.54 hectares of land (gross site areas).

1.13 Using the above method, the average gross density for completions on fully completed small sites (those sites of 4 dwellings or less) was 9 dwellings per hectare (77 dwellings net on 8.45 hectares, gross), while the average density of dwellings on fully completed large sites (those sites of 5 or more dwellings) was approximately 27 dwellings per hectare (85 dwellings net on 3.09 hectares, gross).

1.14 As well as the average density, density by band is monitored. The result of the bands for 2013/14 is shown in figure 4 below:

1 Gross density is the number of net units on site divided by the gross site area (i.e. no discounts for on site provision such as green infrastructure and roads/pathways).

Malvern Hills District Council - Housing Land Supply Monitor 2014 10

Figure 4: Average density of completed dwellings on completed sites and or completed phases (gross site areas)

1.15 While there is no particular recognisable pattern with regard to density by band in Malvern Hills district, the primary policy objective is establishing the most appropriate densities in the correct locations.

How many new dwellings have been added to Malvern Hills District’s housing stock during 2013/14?

1.16 This is calculated as the sum of new build completions (gross), minus demolitions, plus any net gain through residential conversions and changes of use into and out of dwellings. Paragraph 1.22 illustrates the formula used to establish the annual net increase in housing stock.

Demolitions 1.17 In the twelve months ending 31st March 2014, 2 dwellings on 2 sites were demolished.

Malvern Hills District Council - Housing Land Supply Monitor 2014 11

Conversions 1.18 Conversion Gains: In the twelve months ending 31st March 2014, 25 dwellings on 17 sites were provided by way of conversions of residential buildings to create additional units.

1.19 Conversion Losses: In the twelve months ending 31st March 2014, 0 dwelling was lost by way of conversion from residential buildings to other uses.

Change of Use 1.20 Change of Use Gains: In the twelve months ending 31st March 2014, change of use from other previous uses accounted for 16 dwellings on 12 sites (all dwellings were on small sites). Out of this total, only 1 dwelling (1 site) was in a greenfield location.

1.21 Change of Use Losses: In the twelve months ending 31st March 2014, there were 0 recorded dwellings lost due to change of use.

Net Additional Dwellings

1.22 The formula used is: A - B + C + D = E (Net Completions) A: New Build Completions (gross) 145 B: Demolitions 2 C: Changes of Use (net gain) 16 D: Conversions (net gain) 25 E: (145 – 2 + 16 + 25) 184

Therefore net additional dwellings figure for 2013/14 is: 184 dwellings

Malvern Hills District Council - Housing Land Supply Monitor 2014 12

Changes to the Permitted Development Rights (at April 2014)

1.23 On 30th May 2013, a number of changes to the Town and Country Planning (General Permitted Development) Order were introduced, some of which will effect the monitoring of the dwelling stock throughout the district. It is now possible for premises in B1(a) office use to change to C3 residential use without requiring planning permission (subject to a prior approval process covering flooding, highways and transport issues and contamination). Further exceptions for changes of use from agricultural to B1a use (and thus subsequently to residential use) have also been introduced. These new permitted development rights will apply until 30th May 2016 but do not apply on land in certain areas, including certain military sites, safety hazard areas and areas described as Article 1(6A) land.

1.24 From 6th April 2014 a further round of Permitted Development Rights changes came into effect. This included new legislation which permits shops (A1) and financial and professional services (A2) up to 150 square metres to be converted to homes and agricultural buildings up to 450 square metres to change to up to 3 dwellings. As previously stated, all of these changes will be subject to restrictions and conditions and require a notification process to the Council.

1.25 These changes follow on from a previous measure to allow two flats to be created above a shop without the need for planning permission (the limit was previously one flat). This change to permitted development rights came into force on 1st October 2012 and applies to A1 (retail units) and A2 (financial/professional services units) commercial properties.

1.26 The cumulative effect of these changes will mean the council cannot control the principle of the change in these circumstances. Monitoring arrangements will be reviewed for future reports to ensure any new dwellings from this source are identified and included as a source of supply.

Malvern Hills District Council - Housing Land Supply Monitor 2014 13

PART TWO

MALVERN HILLS DISTRICT’S DWELLINGS - COMMITMENTS AT APRIL 2014

2.1 At 31st March 2014 there were 700 dwellings with unimplemented (extant) detailed or outline planning permission, 260 dwellings under construction and 36 dwellings capacity on 3 allocated local plan sites (1996-2011) without planning permission. Therefore, the gross number of dwellings committed through these sources of supply (i.e. those sites with planning consent or an allocated local plan site) totals 996, compared with 611 in 2012/13. Figure 5 below shows the trend in housing commitments since 2006.

Figure 5: Malvern Hills District‟s annual supply of dwelling commitments (gross) since April 2006.

2.2 The level of commitments peaked in April 2008 with the annual housing commitments declining on an annual basis, until 2014. A significant factor of this decline can be attributed to the general impact of economic constraints felt in this time period, coupled with the fact that the majority of

Malvern Hills District Council - Housing Land Supply Monitor 2014 14

the Local Plan allocated site commitments (1996-2011) have now been built out and the emerging new Local Plan (the South Worcestershire Development Plan) has not yet reached formal adoption. The South Worcestershire Development Plan is currently at examination and is scheduled for adoption in 2015. However, this trend has been reversed in 2013/14, with supply increasing for the first time since 2008. This can be partly explained by the implementation of new planning guidance in the form of the National Planning Policy Framework (NPPF), which came into force in March 2012, coupled with an implied growth in confidence of the housing land market as a result of the new national policies that give a presumption in favour of sustainable development. Table 6 below illustrates that more dwellings are now gaining planning consent than either being built out or permissions for them expiring. This trend is predicted to continue over the coming years via a combination of proposed SWDP allocation sites coming forward and, to a lesser extent, unanticipated sites (windfalls) gaining planning permission.

Annual change in Housing Number of Dwellings Commitments during 2013/14

Planning consents granted on new sites* +643 Expired planning consent -34 Built out planning consent -198 Outstanding Local Plan Allocations +36 Total annual change in housing supply +447

Table 6: Annual change in Malvern Hills District Housing Commitments (Calculations are based on gross figures) *Excludes any renewal/time limit extension permissions

2.3 At 31st March 2014, approximately 42% (297 out of 700) of all dwellings with outstanding planning permission (gross) are located on previously developed (brownfield) land. This figure takes into account recent changes to the definition of previously developed land and specifically exclusion of private residential gardens, in line with national policy set out

Malvern Hills District Council - Housing Land Supply Monitor 2014 15

in the NPPF (See table 7 below). The figure is down 23% compared with 65% in 2012/13.

2.4 Out of the 845 net commitments at 31st March 2014 (outstanding and under construction sites, excludes local plan sites), approximately 75 dwellings with outstanding permission involve the use of garden land, 9% of the total outstanding supply. 78% of all commitments are on large sites (5 dwellings or more) whilst small sites (1 to 4 dwellings) comprising 22% of all commitments.

Detailed Outline Total Net Commitments % total permission permission Housing Greenfield land 388 71 459 54% Garden Land 73 2 75 9% Brownfield land 184 127 311 37% TOTAL 645 200 845 100% Large sites (5+) 279 382 661 78% Small sites (1 to 4) 166 18 184 22% TOTAL 445 400 845 100% Table 7: Housing land commitments at 31st March 2014

Monitoring Affordable Housing Provision

2.5 In the 2013/14 monitoring year, 53 affordable homes were delivered across sites in the district, approximately 27% of the total gross supply for 2013/14 (table 8). Figure 6 below shows affordable housing delivery in Malvern Hills district since 2006/07. While there is no particular trend in the number of affordable homes being delivered throughout the monitoring periods, the proportion of affordable homes delivered has not fallen below 20 per cent of all net completions since 2006/07, except for in 2012/13. 2013/14 therefore represents a return more akin to pre 2012/13 levels in terms of completions when compared to the previous monitoring years. It is worth noting that in 2011/12, 115 affordable dwellings were delivered, which was the highest annual delivery since 2007/08. On average, approximately 58 affordable dwellings have been delivered per annum

Malvern Hills District Council - Housing Land Supply Monitor 2014 16

since 2006/07. Affordable housing provision is set to increase in forthcoming monitoring periods as there is a known supply of outstanding commitments for affordable housing coming forward in future years. Table 9 below sets out these sites. In addition, table 10 also outlines the affordable housing element of the North Site (Malvern Vale), which is expected to come forward in future monitoring periods.

Social Affordable Planning Intermediate Total Homes Location Rented Rent App Ref Housing Delivered Housing Housing Bank House Bowling Club, 12/00562/FUL Bransford 10 0 0 10

North Site Phase 7, Leigh 12/01240/FUL Sinton Road, Malvern 15 14 0 29

Land rear of 26-30 12/01703/FUL Mountbatten Road, Malvern 2 0 0 2

Land adjacent Green Hedges, 12/01661/FUL Claphill Lane, Rushwick 7 0 0 7

Redundant road/land behind Orford Way and Elgar 12/01717/FUL 3 0 0 3 Avenue, Malvern

6-7 Baxters Walk, Malvern 12/00907/FUL 2 0 0 2

Total 39 14 0 53

Table 8: Total Affordable Housing Completions during 2013/14

Affordable Housing Definitions

1. Affordable Rented Housing is let by local authorities or private registered providers of social housing to households who are eligible for social rented housing. Affordable Rent is subject to rent controls that require a rent of no more than 80 per cent of the local market rent (including service charges, where applicable).

2. Social Rented Housing is owned by local authorities and private registered providers (as defined in section 80 of the Housing and Regeneration Act 2008), for which guideline target rents are determined through the national rent regime. It may also be owned by other persons and provided under equivalent rental arrangements

Malvern Hills District Council - Housing Land Supply Monitor 2014 17

to the above, as agreed with the local authority or with the Homes and Communities Agency.

3. Intermediate Housing is homes for sale and rent provided at a cost above social rent, but below market levels subject to the criteria in the Affordable Housing definition above. These can include shared equity (shared ownership and equity loans), other low cost homes for sale and intermediate rent, but not affordable rented housing.

Monitoring 2006/07 2007/08 2008/09 2009/10 2010/11 2011/12 2012/13 2013/14 TOTALS Year Affordable Housing 39 23 100 51 74 115 8 53 463 Delivered Total Net 183 299 256 222 137 229 176 184 1,686 Completions % Affordable Housing of total 21.3 7.7 39.1 23.0 54.0 50.2 4.5 28.8 27.6 net completions Figure 6: Affordable Housing Delivery since 2006/07. Please note that the above data has been revised from previous monitoring years following a reassessment of affordable housing completions.

Malvern Hills District Council - Housing Land Supply Monitor 2014 18

Number of Total affordable number of Planning dwellings Address Description dwellings Status Application proposed/ on site remaining (gross) (gross)

Redundant road/land Proposed affordable housing - Under behind Orford Way 5 no 3 bedroom 5 person 12/01717/FUL 2 5 Construction and Elgar Avenue, semi-detached and terraced (3 completed) Malvern houses

Demolition of Alexandra Alexandra Gardens and Brookside and Under Gardens/Brookside, 10/01499/FUL replacement with an 81 101 Gloucester Close, Construction affordable mixed tenure Malvern independent living scheme Land at adjacent 250 Under Proposed 3 bedroom 12/01706/FUL Elgar Avenue, 1 1 affordable dwelling Construction Malvern Under Land adjacent Green Residential development of 12/01661/FUL Hedges, Claphill 28 dwellings, including 11 4 28 Construction Lane, Rushwick affordable dwellings (7 completed)

Proposed affordable house 12/01704/FUL Land at Wren Avenue, development of 2 no. semi 2 2 Outstanding Malvern detached 3 bedroom houses Land adjacent the Residential development of 13/00069/FUL Crown Public House, 45 dwellings (including 18 18 45 Outstanding Malvern affordable dwellings) Outline application for 12/00876/OUT Land at Oldwood residential development of 18 44 Outstanding Road, Tenbury Wells 44 dwellings (including 18 affordable dwellings) Outline application for Land at Lawn Farm, 12/01087/OUT residential development of 20 50 Outstanding Drake Street, Welland up to 50 houses Outline application with all Eight Oaks Farm, matters reserved by the 13/01223/OUT Eight Oaks, 1 1 Outstanding erection of an affordable Castlemorton home Outline application for the Land at Main Road, 13/00417/OUT erection of up to 120 48 120 Outstanding Kempsey dwellings Extension of time limit to S&T Buildings, commence development on 10/01577/OEX QinetiQ, St Andrews 12 28 Outstanding application 05/00329/OUT - Road, Malvern 28 residential units Extension of time limit to Barrack Stores, commence development on 10/01581/OEX QinetiQ, St Andrews 12 28 Outstanding application 05/00383/OUT - Road, Malvern 28 residential units

Malvern Hills District Council - Housing Land Supply Monitor 2014 19

Land rear of 5 Residential development of 10/00093/FUL Florence Close, 3 7 Outstanding 7 no. dwellings Kempsey Change of use and alterations to existing C2 Sheffield House, 36 12/00837/FUL residential institution to 6 6 Outstanding Court Road, Malvern create 6 self contained C3 flats Outstanding (Site is under Post Office Cottage, construction Residential development for 5 09/01603/FUL Newnham Bridge, 2 5 dwellings but not Tenbury Wells affordable element)

123A Main Road, Outline Planning application Kempsey, for 6 new residential dwellings 11/00872/OUT 2 6 Outstanding Worcestershire, WR5 (4 Detached houses and 2 3LQ Bungalows)

TOTALS 232 477

Table 9: Affordable Housing Commitments at 31st March 2014

Number of Total Number Planning Address Status Affordable of Units Application Units Proposed Proposed Application 48 – Shared 12/01488/REM North Site Phase 4a Decision 48 Equity Units Pending S106 Application Approved 12/01650/REM North Site Phase 6 7 26 12/04/2013 - Outstanding TOTALS 55 74

Table 10: North Site (Malvern Vale) – Additional Affordable Units Proposed (Post 31st March 2014 Monitoring)

Malvern Hills District Council - Housing Land Supply Monitor 2014 20

PART THREE

DETERMINING MALVERN HILLS DISTRICT’S HOUSING REQUIREMENT

3.1 The National Planning Policy Framework (NPPF) came into force on 27th March 2012, stating that local planning authorities need to annually identify and update a supply of specific deliverable sites sufficient to provide five years worth of housing against their housing requirements. In addition to this, a buffer of 5 per cent (moved forward from later in the plan period, or 20 per cent for persistent under delivery) is also required to ensure choice and competition in the market for land.

3.2 In order to calculate a five year housing land supply, a requirement or „target‟ needs to be identified against which supply can be measured. Paragraph 47 of the Framework indicates that „requirements‟ should be identified in Local Plans, and that it is these requirements against which the five year supply should be measured.

3.3 The Localism Act (November 2011) set in motion the abolition of Regional Strategies that had hitherto provided regional and lower level housing targets for district areas. The adopted West Midlands Regional Strategy 2008 (WMRSS) was revoked on 20th May 2013. The Regional Strategy Phase 2 Revision had progressed to the post-examination „Panel Report Stage‟ in 2009 before being discontinued in 2010. While the saved targets of the Malvern Hills District Local Plan are still saved and extant, they only cover the period 2006-2011. The Stage 1 hearings into the South Worcestershire Development Plan (SWDP) concluded in March 2014, having being reconvened from October 2013 following recommendations made by the Inspector relating to (among other matters) establishing the full Objectively Assessed Housing Need (OAHN) for South Worcestershire. In short, the SWDP housing need was recommended by the Inspector as a result of his Further Interim Conclusions from the reconvened March hearings, as 28,370 dwellings, with the requirement for Malvern Hills District being 8,590 dwellings of this total.

Malvern Hills District Council - Housing Land Supply Monitor 2014 21

3.4 For the purposes of this report, the current starting point for assessing the Five Year Housing Land Supply is therefore the Objectively Assessed Housing Need outcome of 8,590 dwellings for Malvern Hills District. This is an „unconstrained‟ figure and does not take into account adjustments relating to the proposed „policy-on‟ approach in the SWDP, which puts forward the Wider Worcester Area re-distribution strategy. This policy approach is scheduled for examination at Stage 2 of the SWDP hearings. For further information, please visit the South Worcestershire Development Plan website‟s Examination page.

Malvern Hills District Council - Housing Land Supply Monitor 2014 22

PART FOUR

ASSESSING AND DELIVERING HOUSING LAND – COMPONENTS OF SUPPLY

4.1 The council‟s housing land supply database holds records of all sites with planning permission for residential development. This includes outstanding permissions, sites under construction, and also outstanding allocations in the MHDC Adopted Local Plan (July 2006) and proposed SWDP site allocations. For the purposes of the April 2014 to March 2019 (five year) housing land supply, all sites with full planning permission, sites under construction and allocated sites (both the Local Plan 1996-2011and the SWDP) deemed deliverable over the next five years have been included, unless stated otherwise. These sites are a mixture of new build, change of use and residential conversions on both brownfield and greenfield sites. A further selection of large sites (proposed SWDP and large windfall sites) with either planning permission or the subject of a S106 post 31st March 2014 (sites monitored up to 30th June 2014) that have been deemed deliverable in whole or partially within the five years have also been included (see Appendices „D‟ and „E‟).

4.2 A 5% lapse rate has been applied to the outstanding commitments. This is based on the outcome of the reconvened stage 1 hearings into the SWDP where the Planning Inspector was satisfied with the evidence put forward regarding non-delivery rates and recommended that a 5% lapse rate average should be applied for all three councils. This lapse rate has not been applied to adopted Local Plan sites or proposed SWDP allocations with planning permission in the Five Year Supply calculation (188 dwellings of the overall total). A windfall allowance has also been included (see pages 29 - 31), but only for three years out of the five year period, to avoid the general double counting of small site permissions in the outstanding commitments that are already known to be coming forward. This allowance provides Malvern Hills with a greater degree of

Malvern Hills District Council - Housing Land Supply Monitor 2014 23

certainty and strengthens the district‟s ability to substantiate a housing land supply.

4.3 Similar to previous years, allocated Local Plan (1996-2011) sites which are either still unimplemented or have the benefit of planning permission have been assessed for deliverability. There are eight Local Plan allocated sites still to be fully built out; five of which have planning permission (H1, H6, H11, H12 and H13); and three without planning permission (H3, H4 and H10). All unimplemented sites have been assessed against the deliverability criteria (see page 27) and are considered to be deliverable over the next five years with the exception of H11, which is being developed under use class C2 and is therefore not considered applicable to the general housing supply. Site H3 previously had planning permission for 20 dwellings but this expired in 2012 and remains unimplemented. The site has been re-added to the supply with the potential to deliver 15 dwellings, as previously outlined in the Local Plan (1996-2011). The MHDC Local Plan allocated sites and their current status are outlined below on pages 25 and 26 (Table 11 and Figure 7).

Malvern Hills District Council - Housing Land Supply Monitor 2014 24

Local Plan Address Allocation Status (also see figure 5) ID

Site Under Construction – 479 North Site (All Phases Consent granted for up dwellings likely to be built (plus an H1 except Phase 7) to 490 dwellings additional 58 dwellings on Phase 7)

Former Brooklyn Ford H2 49 dwellings Site Completed Garage, Worcester Road

Former Railway Sidings, Allocated for 15 Site Outstanding - No Current H3 Peachfield Road dwellings Planning Permission

Site Outstanding – No Current H4 Lower Howsell Road Allocated for 6 dwellings Planning Permission

Former Garage Site, H5 5 dwellings Site Completed Worcester Road

Former Garage Site, Planning Permission H6 Site Outstanding Newtown Road granted for 13 dwellings

Former Laundry, Yates Hay H7 38 dwellings Site Completed Road

Site at Worcester/Zetland H8 14 dwellings Site Completed Road

H9 Mill farm, Guarlford Road 7 dwellings Site Completed

Hospital Site, Lansdowne Allocated for 15 Site Outstanding – No Current H10 Crescent dwellings Planning Permission

Site Under Construction (nearing completion) Former Treasurers Site, Planning Permission H11 C2 Use Class – Not Included as a Victoria Road granted for 54 dwellings commitment or in the Five Year Supply

QinetiQ S&T Site, St Planning Permission H12 Site Outstanding Andrews Road granted for 28 dwellings

Barrack Store Site, Court Planning Permission H13 Site Outstanding Road granted for 28 dwellings

Table 11: Malvern Hills District Local Plan (2006) site status at April 2014

Malvern Hills District Council - Housing Land Supply Monitor 2014 25

Figure 7: Malvern Hills District Local Plan (1996-2011) Housing Allocations - Site Status

Malvern Hills District Council - Housing Land Supply Monitor 2014 26

Assessing Housing Land Supply (Deliverability Criteria)

4.4 Deliverability criteria (NPPF footnotes 11 and 12) are used to assess housing land supply to ascertain whether or not a site is included in the district‟s housing supply. For the purposes of inclusion in the five year supply, to meet the criteria outlined in footnote 11, sites need to be determined as deliverable. Three sub-tests are also factored into the criteria; whether or not sites are available, suitable and achievable. Footnote 12 sets out the criteria for developable sites, which are sites that are identified to come forward later in the plan period beyond the initial five year timeframe.

4.5 Footnote 11 of the NPPF states that for sites to be deliverable (i.e. included in the five year supply), the sites for housing supply should be “available now, offer a suitable location for development now, and be achievable with a realistic prospect that housing will be delivered on the site within five years and in particular that the development of the site is viable”.

4.6 The NPPF states that “Sites with planning permission should be considered deliverable until permission expires, unless there is clear evidence that schemes will not be implemented within five years, for example they will not be viable, there is no longer a demand for the type of units or sites have long term phasing plans”.

4.7 A „recovered‟ appeal decision at Oaklands, Ersham Road, Hailsham on 18th June 2013 (APP/C1435/A/12/2186147) has confirmed that sites without the benefit of planning permission can be included in the supply, if they can be shown to be deliverable within the five year period.

4.8 A High Court Judgement in the case of Wainhomes (South West) Holdings limited v the Secretary of State for Communities and Local Government (Case CO/122207/2012) issued on 25th March 2013 also confirms that sites without planning permission can be included in supply if it can be demonstrated that they are deliverable.

Malvern Hills District Council - Housing Land Supply Monitor 2014 27

4.9 For the purposes of the Housing Land Supply Monitor, for sites to be deemed "available now”, there is no requirement for a grant of planning permission. It means that if there was planning permission there is no other legal or physical impediment integral to the site that would prevent immediate development. MHDC have considered sites which:

 are under construction;  have planning permission  are allocated sites in the adopted Local Plan (adopted July 2006) currently without planning permission but are; owned by a developer or have known developer interest; or are advertised for sale; and  selected emerging SWDP allocations (see Appendix ‘D’), subject to developer interest/applications.  Large windfall sites (5 plus dwellings) post 31st March 2014 with planning permission or awaiting s106 sign off (Appendix ‘E’).

4.10 For sites to be considered suitable, they should "offer a suitable location for development now". A site with planning permission is 'suitable'. A site allocated in a development plan is suitable unless there is specific evidence to suggest planning permission is unlikely to be forthcoming. Allocation in an emerging DPD is evidence of suitability, although the outcome of a particular planning application cannot be guaranteed. Sites which accord with the adopted development plan and come forward as windfall permissions will be suitable.

4.11 For sites to be considered achievable, they should "be achievable with a realistic prospect that housing will be delivered on the site within five years". This includes:

(1) Sites with planning permission, which start with a presumption of deliverability according to the Framework.

Malvern Hills District Council - Housing Land Supply Monitor 2014 28

(2) Other sites, including those allocated in an emerging DPD, require site specific justification, but the fact of their allocation is a starting point for evidence of deliverability.

(3) Planning applications on emerging SWDP sites is further evidence of achievability to which weight can properly be given.

(4) Large windfall sites (5 plus dwellings) post 31st March 2014 with planning permission or awaiting s106 sign off (Appendix ‘E’).

Sites should also meet the following additional criteria:

a) have no known ownership constraints (for example, owner is not willing to release the site for housing or the site is under multiple ownership); b) have no known physical or environmental constraints; and c) have no other conditions that would prevent the development occurring within the five year period.

4.12 Footnote 12 of the NPPF states that for sites to be considered developable, sites should be in a suitable location for housing development and there should be a reasonable prospect that the site is available and could be viably developed at the point envisaged. Developable sites are not included in the five year housing land supply calculation (with the exception of elements of the unconstrained „policy off‟‟ five year supply calculation, see table 15) but are a key component in delivering the long term housing strategy for Malvern Hills district and the other south Worcestershire authorities up to 2030.

Calculating Windfall Allowance

4.13 The National Planning Policy Framework (NPPF) permits local planning authorities to make allowances for windfall sites within their housing land supply if there is evidence that proves such sites consistently become

Malvern Hills District Council - Housing Land Supply Monitor 2014 29

available in the local area and will provide a reliable source of supply (NPPF, paragraph 48). Malvern Hills District Council has made such allowances within their current five year housing land supply calculation (3 out of the 5 years as previously explained).

4.14 Malvern Hills District‟s windfall allowance is calculated by determining the average rate of net small windfall completions over the monitored years of the plan period (2006/07 – 2013/14). The figure for windfalls (table 12) is heavily discounted; it excludes greenfield sites (including residential garden land) and only includes small brownfield windfalls on sites of below 5 dwellings. Larger windfall sites (5 dwellings and above) are not included in the calculation as these are normally expected to have been identified through the Strategic Housing Land Availability Assessment (SHLAA) or the Local Plan/emerging SWDP allocations process, although a number of large windfall sites have, and will continue to come forward and contribute to supply. The windfall figure is therefore considered to be a conservative estimate.

Windfall allowance: Plan period Number of net dwellings number of dwellings progress completed divided by years of plan period to date 2006/07 – 2013/14 278 (small brownfield sites of 4 278/8 = 35 dwellings per (8 Years) dwellings or less) annum Table 12: Windfall allowance calculation

4.15 In terms of the submitted SWDP, in order to avoid the double counting of small site commitments, the first two years of the windfall allowance have not been included (2014/15 – 2015/16). Following this, a windfall allowance of 35 dwellings per annum has been determined for the following ten years (2016/17 – 2025/26). Thereafter, a lower rate of 23 dwellings per annum (approximately two thirds of the windfall allowance calculation) is applied (from 2026/27 – 2029/30), which takes into consideration the balance between windfall supply and the likely increase

Malvern Hills District Council - Housing Land Supply Monitor 2014 30

in completions of allocated sites as the plan period progresses. To summarise:

35 dwellings per annum from 2016/17– 2025/26 (10 years) = 350 dwellings 23 dwellings per annum from 2026/27 – 2029/30 (4 years) = 92 dwellings

Total windfall allowance 2016/17 – 2029/30 = 442 dwellings Please see Appendix ‘C’ for a list of sites that provide evidence for the windfall allowance.

Please note that the windfall allowance calculation may show some variation when compared to the housing trajectory set out in the SWDP evidence base in terms of the calculation variables used and how the allowance is distributed over the plan period timescale. Note that Worcester City Council and Wychavon District Council count sites of 9 dwellings or less as small windfall sites.

Inclusion of proposed SWDP site allocations and large windfall (non- SWDP) sites in the housing land supply calculation (post 31st March 2014)

4.16 Following a large number of planning permissions (some subject to outstanding S106 agreements) on proposed SWDP allocation sites post 31st March 2014, it is considered appropriate to include an element of the proposed housing land allocations within the SWDP for the purposes of calculating the five year housing land supply. By taking into account the proportion of the proposed SWDP site allocations that are considered deliverable within the current five year supply period, Malvern Hills District could deliver an additional supply of approximately 321 dwellings phased over the period 2014 – 2019. This figure has discounted a proportion of dwellings from some larger sites that have planning consent but are considered to not be entirely deliverable within the five year period (see table 15 and associated footnotes for further details).

Malvern Hills District Council - Housing Land Supply Monitor 2014 31

4.17 In addition to this, it is also the case that there are further permissions (some subject to S106 agreements) and planning applications that have already been submitted (most post 31st March 2014) on large windfall (i.e. 5 plus dwellings) non-SWDP sites that are considered to be deliverable within the five year period. These sites would add approximately a further 503 dwellings to the supply. For a list of the included sites, see Appendices ‘D’ and ‘E’ of this report.

Emerging South Worcestershire Development Plan (SWDP) - Housing Requirement for the Plan Period (MHDC’s Proportion)

4.18 Following recommendations from the Planning Inspector post Stage 1 of the SWDP hearings relating to the production of the SWDP, Malvern Hills District‟s Objectively Assessed Housing Need stands at 8,590 dwellings from 2006 to 2030. This is an unconstrained „policy off‟ requirement which does not factor in the proposed re-distribution strategy between the three south Worcestershire Councils set out in the SWDP. The re-distribution strategy has yet to be scrutinised by the Planning Inspector but is proposed for examination as part of the eventual Stage 2 proceedings.

4.19 Over the first eight years of the plan period, Malvern Hills District has delivered 1,686 dwellings (net), leaving 6,904 dwellings out of the 8,590 required to meet the overall SWDP requirement. Taking into account commitments (those dwellings currently under construction and those with planning permission), plus an element of varying annual windfall allowance (see pages 29 to 31), Malvern Hills District needs to provide for an additional 5,641 dwellings to meet its housing requirement for the remainder of the SWDP plan period.

4.20 To address this requirement, sites for approximately 3,093 dwellings are proposed to be allocated within the emerging SWDP document (outside of the Wider Worcester Area). 419 dwellings need to be discounted off this

Malvern Hills District Council - Housing Land Supply Monitor 2014 32

total to account for sites that are already in as commitments or are outstanding Local Plan sites that are to be re-allocated in the SWDP. This makes the revised total for the purposes of this calculation 2,674. With these additional proposed housing allocations taken into account, Malvern Hills would have a potential under supply of 2,967 dwellings over the plan period (see table 13 below).

4.21 However, by applying the outstanding Local Plan housing allocations at 31st March 2014 without planning permission (36 dwellings in total) and a proportion of the Wider Worcester Area urban extensions that are proposed to be delivered in Malvern Hills district, an additional 4,621 dwellings can be accounted for. Table 13 below therefore shows that Malvern Hills District will have a sufficient supply of sites to meet its housing requirement over the plan period for an Objectively Assessed Housing Need „policy off‟ scenario when analysed over the plan period‟s timeframe. A „policy on‟ scenario will be assessed at a time when the SWDP has suitably progressed.

Malvern Hills District Council - Housing Land Supply Monitor 2014 33

Table 13: MHDC Housing Land Position at 31st March 2014

Unconstrained ‘Policy Off’ Target SWDP – Objectively Assessed Housing Need Requirement (2006-2030) 8,590

Net Completions to date (2006/07-2013/14) 1,686

Net Commitments at 31st March 2014 (172) (Dwellings under construction) (673) (Dwellings outstanding with planning permission) (649) Assuming a 5% non-implementation rate (on outstanding sites – no discount applied to adopted local plan or proposed SWDP sites with planning 821 permission – 188 dwellings)

Net Windfall Allowance: 1/4/2016 to 31/3/2030 (first two years from current monitoring year discounted to avoid double counting of commitments) 442 35 per annum from 2016/17 – 2025/26 = 350 23 per annum from 2026/27 – 2029/30 = 92

SWDP: Proposed Allocations (minus those that are in the planning commitments/completions above or are re-allocated Local Plan sites, 419 2,674 dwellings in total)

Residual Balance ((Completions (1,686) + Commitments (821) + Windfall - 2,967 Allowance (442) + SWDP Allocations (2,674)) - SWDP requirement (8,590))

Outstanding Local Plan Housing Allocations at 31st March 2014 without planning permission

H3 – Former Railway Sidings, Peachfield Road 15

H4 - Lower Howsell Road 6

H10 - Hospital site, Lansdowne Crescent 15

Total Local Plan Allocations 36

Proportion of the Wider Worcester Area Urban Extensions in MHDC (Policy Off)

SWDP 45/1 – Worcester South 2,435

SWDP 45/2 – Worcester West 2,150

Wider Worcester Area Proportion Total 4,585

Total Potential Over/Under Supply +1,654 Dwellings

Malvern Hills District Council - Housing Land Supply Monitor 2014 34

Background Context of the Wider Worcester Area (WWA)

4.22 Following the outcome of the SWDP Stage 1 Hearings, at 8,590 dwellings, the housing requirement for Malvern Hills District accounts for approximately 30 per cent of the total 28, 370 dwellings set out in the Planning Inspector‟s recommendations from the SWDP Stage 1 hearings Further Interim Conclusions report for South Worcestershire. The SWDP has responded to this outcome by proposing a re-distribution „policy on‟ strategy which redirects 2,990 dwellings of the housing requirement from the Malvern Hills sub area to the Wider Worcester Area (WWA) (to be examined at Stage 2 of the SWDP hearings).

4.23 Additionally, not all of the housing growth at Worcester City required under the Objectively Assessed Housing Need as recommended by the Planning Inspector following the outcome of the SWDP Stage 1 hearings can be delivered within the city‟s administrative boundary. While approximately 6,750 dwellings can be accommodated within Worcester City, the remainder (3,080) is proposed to be delivered through urban extensions immediately adjoining the city boundary located in the Malvern Hills and Wychavon Districts (i.e. the WWA). The total proposed re- distribution to the WWA is 5,450 dwellings, but the WWA supply is 6,070 dwellings, so the over supply of 620 dwellings can be transferred to Wychavon District, which has the available capacity. The breakdowns and adjustments for each sub area are set out below in table 14.

Malvern Hills District Council - Housing Land Supply Monitor 2014 35

SWDP Housing SWDP Stage SWDP Provision Breakdown of Adjustments 1 Hearings ‘Policy On’ (2006-2030) 620 gained from WWA (+ 30 extra Wychavon 9,950 10,600 dwellings to round up the total so 650) Malvern Hills 8,590 5,600 2,990 to WWA Worcester City 9,830 6,750 3,080 from Worcester City to WWA 2,990 from MHDC Wider Worcester n/a 5,450 3,080 from WCC Area (WWA) Then 620 unmet need to WDC TOTAL 28,370 28,400 + 30 for rounding up purposes Table 14: Proposed Housing Strategy post SWDP Stage 1 Hearings (March 2014)

Figure 8: Proposed „policy on‟ spatial distribution of South Worcestershire‟s Housing Requirements 2006-2030 (relates to Table 14 above)

Malvern Hills District Council - Housing Land Supply Monitor 2014 36

PART FIVE

FIVE YEAR HOUSING LAND SUPPLY UPDATE (2014-2019)

5.1 The NPPF does not contain definitive advice or guidance as to which plan target or methodology should be used for the purposes of calculating the five year housing land supply in the absence of an adopted development plan target. However, the recent National Planning Policy Guidance (Methodology – Stage 5: Final evidence base, paragraph 30) states that where evidence in Local Plans has become out-dated and policies in emerging plans are not yet capable of carrying sufficient weight, information provided in the latest full assessment of housing needs should be considered. For the purposes of this report, this is the recently established Objectively Assessed Housing Need (OAHN) for the South Worcestershire Councils from the recommendations of the Inspectors Further Interim Conclusions of the reconvened SWDP Stage 1 Hearings in March 2014.

5.2 In summary, as previously stated, the Inspector‟s report recommended that the three South Worcestershire councils adopt an overall dwelling requirement that was established from a „mid-point‟ between two Sensitivity Scenarios of dwelling projections based on demographic and employment based evidence in order to establish the full, objectively- assessed level of housing need for the Plan Period. This resulted in 28,370 dwellings for South Worcestershire for the period 2006-2030, of which 8,590 dwellings were apportioned to Malvern Hills District. This „unconstrained‟ figure does not account for the re-distribution of some of Malvern‟s growth to the Wider Worcester Area urban extensions (and to a lesser extent Wychavon district), primarily due to environmental constraints and the need for Worcester to grow strategically beyond its administrative boundary.

5.3 The Previous Malvern Hills Five Year Housing Land Supply Position Statement (Nov 2013) discussed the methodology for assessing previous

Malvern Hills District Council - Housing Land Supply Monitor 2014 37

performance and concluded that the „Sedgefield‟ (frontloading any previous under supply into the first five years of the Plan period) approach should be used. An alternative „Liverpool‟ approach scenario (spreading out the residual requirement across the Plan period) has not been used in the methodology for the calculations in this report.

5.4 It is considered that the district does not have a record of persistent under delivery when the plan period delivery rates are analysed over the previous monitoring years against the relevant adopted targets for the appropriate year (see Appendix ‘F’ for source tables). However, is it accepted that Malvern Hills District has under delivered against the stage 1 hearings „unconstrained‟ target‟ (358 dwellings per annum, table 15), scenario. The district council would therefore be considered a “20%” authority for the purposes of the „Sedgefield‟ five year supply calculations (as shown in table 15 below). However, as the OAHN requirement („unconstrained‟) has only been in place since March 2014, it could be considered that MHDC have not persistently under delivered historically as there have been different plan period targets throughout the monitoring years in which to grade performance. The under supply will nonetheless be added to the five year supply calculation as predicated on the OAHN requirement. In order to substantiate an over/under supply outcome for each scenario in table 15, the over/undersupply calculations in the five year supply table use a consistent plan period baseline target (source tables also available in Appendix ‘F’).

5.5 Based on the approach set out in the previous November 2013 Position Statement and the information and justification set out in this HLSM, it is concluded that Malvern Hills District Council cannot currently demonstrate a five year housing land supply against a Sedgefield „unconstrained‟ scenario (3.82 years at 5%, 3.52 years at 20%). Approximately 720 additional dwellings need to be added to the supply (as at 31st March 2014) to rectify the deficit for a 5% calculation, or 988 for a 20% calculation. Table 15 below outlines the five year housing land supply position for Malvern Hills district. Please note that this is an indicative

Malvern Hills District Council - Housing Land Supply Monitor 2014 38

housing land supply based on the OAHN as at March 2014 which factors in sites that are considered to be deliverable post the 1st April 2013 to 31st March 2014 monitoring period (Table 15 footnotes 5, 6 and 7). The five year housing land supply will be kept under review as per progress made on the SWDP.

Malvern Hills District Council - Housing Land Supply Monitor 2014 39

Five Year Housing Land Supply SWDP POST STAGE 1 HEARINGS ‘UNCONSTRAINED’ APPROACH (OAHN) Requirements 8 (1st April 2014 to 31st March 2006 – 2030 (24 Years) 2019) COLUMN 1: ‘SEDGEFIELD’ METHOD Plan Period Target 8,590 (358 per annum) Net Completions to Date 1,686 Residual Target 6,904 Over/Under Supply1 1,178 under supply 3,058 (358 x 5 + 5% (90) + 1,178) 612 per Five Year Target +5%2 annum 3,326 (358 x 5 + 20% (358) + 1,178) 665 per Five Year Target +20% annum

(673) 601 (5% lapse rate – 24 dwellings - not

) applied to adopted local plan sites and proposed SWDP sites with planning permission, 188) (Outstanding)3

48 dwellings also discounted off total from Land north of Brookend Lane, Kempsey site (120 total on site).4

Commitments Commitments (Net (Under Construction) 172 Total 773 (601 + 172) Local Plan Sites (H3, H4 and H10) 36 105 (35 per annum for current 5 year period – Windfall Allowance (Brownfield) Net 3 out of 5 years) Proposed SWDP Site Allocations included in supply (some subject to 321 (net) S106)5 Other Large sites Approved (some 503 (net) subject to S106)6 Proportion of the Wider Worcester 600 Area Urban Extensions (Worcester (Worcester West = 300, West and Worcester South)7 Worcester South = 300) 2,338 Total Supply

-720 Balance

3.82 Years supply (+5%)

-988 Balance

3.52 Years supply (+20%)

Table 15: MHDC Five Year Housing Land Supply Summary Table 2013/14

Malvern Hills District Council - Housing Land Supply Monitor 2014 40

[1] The under supply is calculated by comparing previous net completions against the plan period target per annum since the start of the plan Period (i.e. 2006).

[2] The 5% and 20% allowance is added onto the five year requirement only and not the under supply.

[3] The lapse rate for is based on the Inspectors findings and recommendations from the South Worcestershire Development Plan Stage 1 Hearings.

[4] 48 dwellings discounted off Land north of Brookend Lane, Kempsey site (120 total on site - 13/00417/OUT). This assumes two years discounted to obtain full planning permission then 24 dwellings per annum for the remaining three years (72). 72 + 48 = 120. Data monitored up to 30th June 2014.

[5] Contains those SWDP sites with either full planning permission, sites subject to S106 and current planning applications post 31st March 2014. Additionally, 76 dwellings discounted off Land adj. the Lawns and Bight Farm Kempsey Sites (190 in total on site - 13/01130/OUT and 14/00021/OUT). This assumes two years discounted to obtain full planning permission then 38 dwellings per annum for the remaining three years (114). 76 + 114 = 190. Data monitored up to 30th June 2014.

[6] Includes all large sites post 31st March 2014 considered deliverable within five years, some subject to a S106 agreement. Data monitored up to 30th June 2014.

[7] Approximately 600 dwellings to be delivered within five years. This assumes two years discounted for full permissions to be granted then 100 dwellings per annum over 3 years = 300 per Urban Extension, so 600 in total over the five years.

[8] The figures in this table are indicative of the Objectively Assessed Housing Need and will be kept under review as regards progress of the SWDP.

Malvern Hills District Council - Housing Land Supply Monitor 2014 41

PART SIX

CONCLUSIONS

6.1 Based on the information contained in this report, it is indicated that Malvern Hills District Council cannot currently demonstrate a five year supply of land for housing based on the SWDP Stage 1 reconvened Hearings „unconstrained‟ scenario for the Objectively Assessed Housing Need calculations (OAHN of 8,590; 3.82 years at 5% allowance and 3.52 years at 20% allowance „Sedgefield‟ method).

6.2 Evidence from this Housing Land Supply Monitor indicates that the current stock of available housing land commitments has increased in 2013/14 (page 14). This is a result of an increase in planning permissions on large sites, both proposed SWDP allocations and windfall sites, some of which having being allowed on appeal by the Planning Inspectorate. It is anticipated that the stock of commitments will increase in forthcoming monitoring years as further sites come through the planning system, some of which will have been anticipated, other sites will be unforeseen. As demonstrated by Appendices ‘D’ and ‘E’ a combination of SWDP and non-SWDP sites are already coming forward, either as permissions, planning applications or pre-applications (SWDP sites only), demonstrating that the supply of deliverable housing land is readily available and set to increase in the forthcoming monitoring periods.

6.3 The planning applications and associated enquires that have been made and received for some of the SWDP sites are tending towards increased numbers above those set out in the SWDP. Certain sites have demonstrated to the council that modest increases in numbers can be supported, for appropriate schemes as set out in Appendix ‘D’.

6.4 Following the conclusions of the SWDP Stage 1 reconvened hearings, it has been determined that Malvern Hills District needs to find additional sites to allocate within the SWDP in order to meet the increased housing

Malvern Hills District Council - Housing Land Supply Monitor 2014 42

numbers from the Inspector‟s Objectively Assessed Housing Need conclusions. Following an additional proposed „Call for Sites‟ consultation and subsequent site assessment, it is anticipated that sufficient available sites will be selected to contribute to the required housing uplift and the overall housing supply with the district. Sites will be subject to formal consultation and examination as part of the SWDP hearing process.

6.5 For further information regarding the data used in this Housing Land Supply Monitor, please see the accompanying appendices.

Malvern Hills District Council - Housing Land Supply Monitor 2014 43 APPENDIX A Housing Land Supply Monitor 2014 - Data Report

Housing Land Position at 31st March 2014: Based on the outcome of Stage1 SWDP Hearings (Objective Assessment of Housing Need) 'policy off'

SWDP Stage 1 Hearing Outcome (OAHN) 'Policy Off' (March 2014) 2006 - 2030 Plan Period (24 Years) South Worcestershire* 28,370 Malvern Hills 8,590

* 'Policy off': 9,950 (Wychavon) + 9,830 (Worcester) + 8,590 (Malvern Hills)

SWDP Stage 1 Hearing OAHN (2006-2030) 8,590 Dwellings (Unconstrained 'Policy Off') Net Completions 1,686

Dwellings under construction (net) 172 Dwellings outstanding (net)** 649 Sub Total of commitments (net) (172 + 649) 821 Residual Balance (Completions + Commitments) 2,507

Outstanding Local Plan Allocations 36 Windfall Allowance*** 442

SWDP - Proposed Site Allocations (minus those in as commitments, 2,674 419) Proportion of the Wider Worcester Area Urban Extensions in MHDC 4,585 Balance 10,244 Potential Over/Under Supply 1,654 **A 5% non-implementation rate has been applied to outstanding dwellings, but not to any local plan or proposed SWDP sites with planning permission (188 dwellings)

***1/4/2014 to 31/3/2030 (based on average previous windfall completions): 35 per annum from 2016/17 – 2025/26 = 350 23 per annum from 2026/27 – 2029/30 = 92 Total: 442 (calculation excludes sites of 5 dwellings or more net, greenfield sites and residential garden land) First two years from current monitoring year discounted to avoid some potential for double count with commitments.

Housing Land Position at 31st March 2014 APPENDIX A Housing Land Supply Monitor 2014 - Data Report

Housing Land Position at 31st March 2014: Based on the outcome of Stage1 SWDP Hearings (Objective Assessment of Housing Need) 'policy off'

**A 5% non-implementation rate has been applied to outstanding dwellings, but not to any local plan or proposed SWDP sites with planning permission (188 dwellings)

Housing Land Position at 31st March 2014 APPENDIX A Housing Land Supply Monitor 2014 - Data Report Gross Completions by Parish 2013/2014

SWS = Small Windfall Site; LWS = Large Windfall Site; LPS = Local Plan Site Gross Completed Parish Site Type Net Units Units 2013/14 Abberley Total 0 0 0 SWS 1 1 1 Alfrick SWS 1 1 1 Total 2 2 2 SWS 1 1 1 Astley and Dunley Total 1 1 1 SWS 1 1 1 Bayton Total 1 1 1 Berrow Total 0 0 0 SWS 1 0 1 Birtsmorton Total 1 0 1 Bockleton Total 0 0 0 SWS 1 1 1 LWS 10 10 10 Bransford SWS 1 1 1 Total 12 12 12 SWS 1 1 1 Broadheath SWS 4 3 4 Total 5 4 5 Broadwas Total 0 0 0 Bushley Total 0 0 0 SWS 3 3 3 Castlemorton SWS 1 0 1 Total 4 3 4 Clifton upon Teme Total 0 0 0 Cotheridge Total 0 0 0 Croome D'abitot Total 0 0 0 Doddenham Total 0 0 0 Earl's Croome Total 0 0 0 Eastham Total 0 0 0 SWS 1 1 1 Eldersfield Total 1 1 1 SWS 1 1 1 Great Witley SWS 1 1 1 Total 2 2 2 SWS 2 2 1 Grimley Total 2 2 1 Guarlford Total 0 0 0 SWS 1 1 1 Hallow Total 1 1 1 SWS 1 1 1 Hanley SWS 3 3 1 Total 4 4 2

Gross Completions by Parish 2013/14 APPENDIX A Housing Land Supply Monitor 2014 - Data Report Gross Completed Parish Site Type Net Units Units 2013/14 SWS 1 1 1 Hanley Castle SWS 1 0 1 Total 2 1 2 Hill Croome Total 0 0 0 Hillhampton Total 0 0 0 Holdfast Total 0 0 0 SWS 1 1 1 Holt Total 1 1 1 Kempsey Total 0 0 0 Kenswick Total 0 0 0 Knighton on Teme Total 0 0 0 Knightwick Total 0 0 0 SWS 1 1 1 Kyre Total 1 1 1 SWS 1 1 1 Leigh SWS 2 1 2 Total 3 2 3 Lindridge Total 0 0 0 Little Malvern Total 0 0 0 Little Witley Total 0 0 0 SWS 2 2 1 Longdon Total 2 2 1 SWS 1 0 1 Lower Sapey Total 1 0 1 Lulsley Total 0 0 0 Madresfield Total 0 0 0 SWS 2 2 2 SWS 2 2 2 SWS 1 1 1 LWS 12 11 12 SWS 4 4 4 LWS 6 6 6 SWS 1 1 1 SWS 2 2 2 SWS 3 3 3 SWS 1 1 1 Malvern Town SWS 1 1 1 SWS 1 1 1 SWS 1 1 1 SWS 2 2 2 SWS 1 1 1 SWS 1 1 1 SWS 1 1 1 LWS 58 58 58 SWS 1 0 1 SWS 1 1 1 SWS 2 2 2

Gross Completions by Parish 2013/14 APPENDIX A Housing Land Supply Monitor 2014 - Data Report Gross Completed Parish Site Type Net Units Units 2013/14 SWS 1 1 1 Malvern Town LWS 9 9 4 LWS 5 5 3 Total 119 117 112 SWS 1 0 1 SWS 1 1 1 Malvern Wells SWS 1 1 1 SWS 2 1 2 Total 5 3 5 Mamble Total 0 0 0 SWS 1 0 1 Martley SWS 2 2 2 Total 3 2 3 Newland Total 0 0 0 Pendock Total 0 0 0 Pensax Total 0 0 0 SWS 1 1 1 Powick Total 1 1 1 Queenhill Total 0 0 0 Ripple Total 0 0 0 Rochford Total 0 0 0 SWS 1 1 1 Rushwick LWS/SWDP 28 28 14 Total 29 29 15 Severn Stoke Total 0 0 0 Shelsley Beauchamp Total 0 0 0 Shelsley Walsh Total 0 0 0 SWS 1 1 1 Shrawley Total 1 1 1 Stanford with Orleton Total 0 0 0 Stockton on Teme Total 0 0 0 Stoke Bliss Total 0 0 0 Suckley Total 0 0 0 SWS 1 1 1 SWS 4 3 1 SWS 1 1 1 Tenbury SWS 1 -1 1 SWS 3 3 3 SWS 1 0 1 Total 11 7 8 SWS 4 3 4 SWS 2 2 2 Upton-upon-Severn SWS 1 1 1 SWS 2 2 2 Total 9 8 9 SWS 2 2 2 Welland Total 2 2 2

Gross Completions by Parish 2013/14 APPENDIX A Housing Land Supply Monitor 2014 - Data Report Gross Completed Parish Site Type Net Units Units 2013/14 West Malvern Total 0 0 0 Wichenford Total 0 0 0 TOTAL 226 210 198

Gross and Net units columns contain full site capacities where an element of which may be under construction and as such has been included in the figure.

Gross Completions by Parish 2013/14 APPENDIX A Housing Land Supply Monitor 2014 - Data Report

Gross Completions by Parish 2013/14 APPENDIX A Housing Land Supply Monitor 2014 - Data Report

Gross Completions by Parish 2013/14 APPENDIX A Housing Land Supply Monitor 2014 - Data Report

Gross Completions by Parish 2013/14 APPENDIX A Housing Land Supply Monitor 2014 - Data Report

Completions on Local Plan Allocated Sites 2013/14

Site Application Decision Gross Net Comp U/C O/S Address Phasing Area Number Date Units Units 2013-14 2013-14 2013-14 (ha) NO COMPLETIONS 0 Total 0

Completions on Local Plan Allocated Sites 2013/2014 APPENDIX A Housing Land Supply Monitor 2013/14 - Data Report

Completions on Large Windfall Sites 2013/14

Application Decision Gross Site Area Comp UC OS Address Parish Net Units No Date Units (ha) 2013/14 2013/14 2013/14 PT Former Malvernian Tours Site 11/00800/FUL Newtown Road/Belmont Road, Malvern 19/09/2012 6 6 0.10 6 0 0 Malvern

12/00562/FUL Bransford 20/12/2012 10 10 0.25 10 0 0 Bank House Bowling Club, Bransford 10/01368/FUL 24 Hayslan Road, Malvern Malvern 01/03/2011 11 12 0.43 12 0 0 North Site Phase 7, Leigh Sinton 12/01240/FUL Road, Malvern (separate from Local Malvern 10/04/2013 58 58 2.31 58 0 0 Plan Allocation)

12/01661/FUL Land adjacent Green Hedges, Claphill Rushwick 07/02/2013 28 28 0.98 14 14 0 Lane, Rushwick (SWDP site) Redundant road/land behind Orford 12/01717/FUL Malvern 20/06/2013 5 5 0.23 3 2 0 Way and Elgar Avenue, Malvern 12/01605/FUL 137-141 Church Street, Malvern Malvern 16/04/2013 9 9 0.22 4 5 0 Total 107

Completions on Large Windfall Sites 2013/14 APPENDIX A Housing Land Supply Monitor 2013/14 - Data Report Completions on Small Windfall Sites 2013/14

Site Decision Net Gross Comp U/C 2013- O/S 2013- Application Number Address Area Date Units Units 2013-14 14 14 (ha) Alfrick 12/01414/CLE Top Knapp, Bridges Stone, Alfrick 11/12/2013 0.26 1 1 1 0 0 98/00773/FUL Coppice End, Kigshill, Leigh Sinton, Malvern 17/08/1998 0.30 1 1 1 0 0

Astley and Dunley 12/01600/CLE Tudor Rose Nursery, Dunley, Worcestershire 17/12/2012 0.01 1 1 1 0 0

Bayton 09/01446/FUL The Redlands, Clows Top 29/12/2009 0.03 1 1 1 0 0

Birtsmorton 10/01106/FUL Little Arley, Birtsmorton 15/10/2010 0.18 0 1 1 0 0

Bransford 12/00242/CLE Land adj Owls Roost, Chapel Lane, Bransford 03/04/2012 0.08 1 1 1 0 0 12/00970/FUL Croft House, Bransford, Worcestershire 23/08/2012 0.18 1 1 1 0 0

Broadheath 11/01307/FUL 3 Manorfield, Lower Broadheath 15/11/2011 0.09 1 1 1 0 0 12/01138/FUL Rowanwood, Bell Lane, Lower Broadheath 04/10/2012 0.18 3 4 4 0 0

Castlemorton 09/00477/FUL Walk Farm, Castlemorton, Malvern 09/06/2009 0.36 3 3 3 0 0 12/00804/FUL Bradfords Farm, Castlemorton 28/08/2012 0.23 0 1 1 0 0

Eldersfield 12/00756/CLE Hooze Farm, Eldersfield 08/10/2012 0.17 1 1 1 0 0

Completions on Small Windfall Sites 2013/14 APPENDIX A Housing Land Supply Monitor 2013/14 - Data Report Site Decision Net Gross Comp U/C 2013- O/S 2013- Application Number Address Area Date Units Units 2013-14 14 14 (ha) Great Witley 13/01055/FUL 05/11/2013 0.02 1 1 1 0 0 The Coach House, 17A Fountain Court, Great Witley 12/01343/CLE Lieranta, Worcester Road, Great Witley 07/01/2013 0.61 1 1 1 0 0

Grimley 09/00901/FUL Holywards Farm, Moseley Road, Hallow 12/04/2010 0.18 2 2 1 1 0

Hallow 10/01085/FUL Chapel House, Moseley Road, Hallow 26/10/2010 0.06 1 1 1 0 0

Hanley 12/00965/FUL Church Farm, Hanley Willliam 03/07/2013 0.22 1 1 1 0 0 05/01681/FUL Court Farm Hanley Childe 06/01/2006 0.23 3 3 1 1 0

Hanley Castle 11/01496/FUL Land adj 34 Winnington Gardens, Hanley Swan 29/11/2011 0.03 1 1 1 0 0 12/00448/FUL Avenue Riding Centre, Hanley Road, Welland 02/11/2012 0.21 0 1 1 0 0

Holt 11/00398/FUL The Conifers, Holt Heath 09/05/2011 0.07 1 1 1 0 0

Kyre 13/00628/FUL Six Acres Barn, Sutton, Worcestershire 26/11/2013 0.10 1 1 1 0 0

Leigh 06/01104 Land At Teme Lane Leigh Worcester 14/11/2006 3.00 1 1 1 0 0 09/01328 Bank Farm, Brockamin, Leigh 24/11/2009 0.03 1 2 2 0 0

Completions on Small Windfall Sites 2013/14 APPENDIX A Housing Land Supply Monitor 2013/14 - Data Report Site Decision Net Gross Comp U/C 2013- O/S 2013- Application Number Address Area Date Units Units 2013-14 14 14 (ha) Longdon 13/01103 Lake Cottage, Chambers Court, Longdon 15/10/2013 0.31 2 2 1 1 0

Malvern 10/00137/FUL Land adj 50 Worcester Road, Malvern 29/06/2010 0.18 2 2 2 0 0 10/00242/FUL 180 Worcester Road, Malvern 06/04/2010 0.02 2 2 2 0 0 10/01006/PEX Land adj Fairoaks, 27 Cockshot Road, Malvern 24/09/2010 0.17 1 1 1 0 0 11/00442/FUL 21 Wedderburn Road, Malvern 26/07/2011 0.20 4 4 4 0 0 Halfkey House, Half Key, Malvern, Worcestershire, 27/02/2012 0.03 1 1 1 0 0 11/00860/FUL WR14 1UP 11/01148/FUL Club Chambers, Grange Road, Malvern 11/11/2011 0.02 2 2 2 0 0 11/01150/FUL Club Chambers, Grange Road, Malvern 15/11/2011 0.02 3 3 3 0 0 12/00032/FUL 105 Barnards Green Road, Malvern 29/02/2012 0.03 1 1 1 0 0 12/00088/FUL Rear of 229 Worcester Road, Malvern 19/03/2012 0.02 1 1 1 0 0 12/00445/FUL Grassendale House, 3 Victoria Road, Malvern 01/06/2012 0.12 1 1 1 0 0 12/00697/FUL Flat 2, 131 Barnards Green Road, Malvern 21/06/2012 0.01 1 1 1 0 0 12/00907/FUL 6-7 Baxters Walk, Malvern 17/08/2012 0.07 2 2 2 0 0 14/08/2012 0.03 1 1 1 0 0 12/00916/FUL Former Garages at Viewfield, Como Road, Malvern

24/08/2012 0.07 1 1 1 0 0 12/00968/FUL Land at (OS 7891 4622), Pickersleigh Road, Malvern Eastry 3 College Grove Malvern, Worcestershire 15/10/2012 0.01 1 1 1 0 0 12/01175/FUL WR14 3HP 12/01575/FUL Baxhill Nursery, 179 Worcester Road, Malvern 19/02/2013 0.30 0 1 1 0 0 12/01625/FUL 50 Upper Howsell Road, Malvern 24/01/2013 0.01 1 1 1 0 0 12/01703/FUL Land rear of 26-30 Mountbatten Road, Malvern 18/04/2013 0.07 2 2 2 0 0 13/00319/CPU 5-7 Abbey Road, Malvern 09/05/2013 0.01 1 1 1 0 0

Malvern Wells 11/00501/FUL 56 Old Wyche Road , Malvern 25/05/2011 0.25 0 1 1 0 0 11/01323/FUL 32 Peachfield Road, Malvern 16/12/2011 0.17 1 1 1 0 0

Completions on Small Windfall Sites 2013/14 APPENDIX A Housing Land Supply Monitor 2013/14 - Data Report Site Decision Net Gross Comp U/C 2013- O/S 2013- Application Number Address Area Date Units Units 2013-14 14 14 (ha) 12/00691/FUL 27 King Edwards Road, Malvern 04/07/2012 0.06 1 1 1 0 0 12/01160/FUL Wells House Chapel, Holywell Road, Malvern 06/11/2012 0.33 1 2 2 0 0

Martley 11/01119/FUL Bramblewood, Hipplecote, Martley 28/10/2011 0.89 0 1 1 0 0 Horsham Court Stables, Hill Top Farm, Horsham 08/11/2012 2 0 12/01159/FUL Lane, Horsham 0.27 2 2 0

Powick 13/00657/FUL The Old Forge, Old Malvern Road, Powick 17/07/2013 1.10 1 1 1 0 0

Rushwick Shenley Stores, Bransford Road, Rushwick, 13/00919/FUL 16/09/2013 0.04 1 1 1 0 0 Worcestershire, WR2 5TA

Shrawley 29/05/2012 1 0 12/00329/CLE The Flat, Goodyears Farm, Rectory Lane, Shrawley 0.00 1 1 0

Tenbury 30/10/2003 0.04 1 1 1 0 0 03/00861/FUL Barn at Upper Green, St Michaels, Tenbury Wells 06/01788/FUL Pal Mrya, Terrills Lane, Tenbury Wells 12/02/2007 0.18 3 4 1 0 0 10/00037/FUL 1 Mount Orchard, Tenbury Wells 26/03/2010 0.06 1 1 1 0 0 12/00263/FUL 1 & 2 Upper Green, St Michaels, Tenbury 27/04/2012 0.17 -1 1 1 0 0 Warehouse and Cider House, Church Street, 13/06/2013 0.04 3 3 3 0 0 12/00698/FUL Tenbury Wells 13/00310/FUL Dorothys Rock, Rhyse Lane, Tenbury Wells 30/05/2013 0.12 0 1 1 0 0

Completions on Small Windfall Sites 2013/14 APPENDIX A Housing Land Supply Monitor 2013/14 - Data Report Site Decision Net Gross Comp U/C 2013- O/S 2013- Application Number Address Area Date Units Units 2013-14 14 14 (ha) Upton Upon Severn 11/01584 11 New Street, Upton-upon-Severn 31/01/2012 0.03 3 4 4 0 0 13/00033 Land rear of 57 Old Street, Upton 23/05/2013 0.03 2 2 2 0 0 13/00217 69 Old Street, Upton upon Severn, WR8 0HN 05/04/2013 0.04 1 1 1 0 0 Units 1-4 Haywards Yard, Court Street, Upton-upon- 23/04/2013 0.03 2 2 2 0 13/00222 Severn 0

Welland 12/01320/FUL Welland Garage, Gloucester Road, Welland 19/12/2012 0.16 2 2 2 0 0

Total 90

Completions on Small Windfall Sites 2013/14 APPENDIX A Housing Land Supply Monitor 2013/14 - Data Report

Completions on Small Windfall Sites 2013/14 APPENDIX A Housing Land Supply Monitor 2013/14 - Data Report

Local Plan Allocated Sites Under Construction 2013/14

Decision Site Area Net Gross Comp U/C 2013- O/S 2013- Application No Address Parish Date (ha) Units Units 2013-14 14 14 NO SITES 0 Total 0

Local Plan Allocated Sites Under Construction 2013/14 APPENDIX A Housing Land Supply Monitor 2014 - Data Report

Large Windfall Sites Under Construction 2013/14

Site Decision Net Gross Comp U/C 2013- O/S 2013- Application Address Parish Area Date Units Units 2013-14 14 14 (ha) Post Office Cottage, Newnham Bridge, Knighton on 09/01603/FUL 13/02/2012 0.24 5 5 0 2 0 Tenbury Wells Teme Alexandra Gardens/Brookside, Gloucester 10/01499/FUL Malvern 06/10/2011 1.33 25 101 0 101 0 Close, Malvern Malvern 11/00657/FUL 18A Peachfield Road, Malvern 22/06/2012 0.16 5 6 0 6 0 Wells 12/01380/PEX 2 Orchard Road, Malvern Malvern 22/01/2013 0.17 7 8 0 8 0 Land adjacent Green Hedges, Claphill Lane, 12/01661/FUL Rushwick 07/02/2013 0.98 28 28 14 14 0 Rushwick (SWDP site) Redundant road/land behind Orford Way and 12/01717/FUL Malvern 20/06/2013 0.23 5 5 3 2 0 Elgar Avenue, Malvern 13/00087/FUL Land adj The Crown, Martley (SWDP site) Martley 18/12/2013 3.91 51 51 0 51 0 12/01605/FUL 137-141 Church Street, Malvern Malvern 16/04/2013 0.22 9 9 4 5 0 Total 189

Large Windfall Sites Under Construction 2013/2014 APPENDIX A Housing Land Supply Monitor 2014 - Data Report

Small Windfall Sites Under Construction 2013/14

Site Decision Net Gross Comp U/C O/S Application Address Area Date Units Units 2013/14 2013/14 2013/14 (ha) 13/00814/FUL The Vineyards, 23 Bowling Green Road, Powick 19/09/2013 0.28 1 2 0 2 0 13/00826/FUL Little Birches, Bockleton 11/10/2013 0.21 0 1 0 1 0 13/00742/FUL Pensax C of E Primary School, Pensax Common 24/07/2013 0.25 1 1 0 1 0 13/00808/FUL Woodlands Farm, Astley Burf 15/10/2013 0.09 1 1 0 1 0 13/01031/FUL 281 Pickersleigh Road, Malvern 11/10/2013 0.02 1 1 0 1 0 13/01103/PEX Lake Cottage, Chambers Court, Longdon 15/10/2013 0.31 2 2 1 1 0 05/01681/FUL Court Farm Hanley Childe 06/01/2006 0.23 3 3 1 1 0 08/00241/FUL 0 3 0 41 Wells Road, Malvern, Worcestershire WR14 4RJ 14/04/2008 0.10 2 3 08/00800/FUL Sinton House Farm, Stocks Lane, Leigh Sinton 12/12/2008 0.06 1 1 0 1 0 08/01237/FUL Baptist Chapel, Church Street, Kempsey 01/10/2008 0.10 2 2 0 1 0 09/00511/FUL 0 1 0 Violet Morris House, 7 Market Square, Tenbury Wells 27/08/2009 0.05 4 4 09/00678/FUL Barn at (7489 5268) Alfrick 17/07/2009 0.20 2 2 0 2 0 09/00749/FUL The Old Court, Horsham, Martley 01/07/2010 0.62 1 1 0 1 0 09/00901/FUL Holywards Farm, Moseley Road, Hallow 12/04/2010 0.18 2 2 1 1 0 09/01236/FUL 1 Manor Road, Clifton-on-Teme 05/11/2009 0.03 1 1 0 1 0 10/00551/FUL Land adjacent 27 Church End, Hanley Castle 23/02/2011 0.04 1 1 0 1 0 10/00643/FUL Briarlea, Bell Lane, Lower Broadheath 22/10/2010 0.10 1 1 0 1 0 Zourka, Church Lane, Broadwas, Worcestershire, WR6 10/00766/FUL 0 1 0 5NQ 22/09/2010 0.29 0 1 10/00948/PEX 0 1 0 Hillcourt Farm, Welland, Worcestershire, WR13 6NH 13/09/2010 0.30 3 3 10/01509/FUL Hanley Court Gardens, Hanley William 20/05/2011 0.70 1 1 0 1 0 11/00026/FUL Land adj Primrose Cottage, Longdon 05/07/2011 0.10 1 1 0 1 0 11/00374/FUL 28 Cowleigh Road, Malvern 04/07/2011 0.08 2 2 0 2 0 11/00427/FUL Bluebell Farm, Pershore Road, Earls Croome 25/05/2011 0.17 3 3 0 3 0

Small Windfall Sites Under Construction 2013/2014 APPENDIX A Housing Land Supply Monitor 2014 - Data Report

Site Decision Net Gross Comp U/C O/S Application Address Area Date Units Units 2013/14 2013/14 2013/14 (ha) Aymestry House, Bromyard Road, Crown East, 11/00769/FUL 0 3 0 Worcestershire, WR2 5TR 23/05/2012 0.76 2 3 11/00788/FUL 123 Newtown Road Malvern 19/08/2011 0.02 1 1 0 1 0 Witley Park Farm, Worcester Road, Great Witley, 11/00874/FUL 0 2 0 Worcestershire 13/12/2011 0.15 2 2 12/00325/FUL 11 Court Street, Upton-upon-Severn 07/06/2012 0.01 1 1 0 1 0 12/00425/FUL The Granary, Worcester Road, Great Witley 25/06/2012 0.10 1 1 0 1 0 12/00501/FUL Eastgrove Farm, Sankyns Green, Little Witley 24/05/2012 0.08 1 1 0 1 0 12/00571/FUL 0 1 0 Land at Newtown Farm, Romers Common, Bockleton 13/08/2012 0.29 1 1 12/00771/FUL 0 1 0 Woodbridge Farm, Rectory Lane, Guarlford, Malvern 15/01/2013 0.18 1 1 12/00793/FUL St Marys Church, Knightsford Bridge, Knightwick 10/09/2012 0.07 1 1 0 1 0 12/00976/FUL Bush Farm, Bush Lane, Callow End 30/01/2014 0.35 4 4 0 4 0 12/00979/FUL Pickersleigh Court, North End Lane, Malvern 02/10/2012 0.55 4 4 0 4 0 Stoke Bliss and Kyre Village Hall, Stoke Bliss, 12/01046/FUL 0 2 0 Worcestershire 15/10/2012 0.13 2 2 12/01072/FUL Plot 17 Woodbury Park, Holt Heath 11/03/2013 0.09 1 1 0 1 0 12/01144/FUL 0 1 0 Aytons Heath Barn Clifton On Teme,Worcestershire 28/09/2012 1.38 1 1

12/01354/FUL 0 1 0 Severn End Hanley Castle Worcestershire WR8 0BW 10/01/2013 0.15 1 1 11/01596/FUL 71 Court Road, Malvern 16/02/2012 0.02 1 1 0 1 0 Land at (OS 7936 4671) Adjacent 250 Elgar Avenue, 12/01706/FUL 0 1 0 Malvern 05/02/2013 0.05 1 1 12/01723/FUL Coverside Farm, Hanley Swan 14/03/2013 0.16 0 1 0 1 0 13/00173/FUL The Retreat, Ockeridge, Wichenford 18/06/2013 0.22 0 1 0 1 0 13/00270/FUL The Bridge Hotel, 87 Teme Street 15/04/2013 0.20 1 1 0 1 0 13/00356/FUL Threeways, Naunton, Upton upon Severn 29/07/2013 0.05 0 1 0 1 0 13/00438/FUL Cherry View, Firth Common, Eardiston 23/07/2013 0.08 0 1 0 1 0

Small Windfall Sites Under Construction 2013/2014 APPENDIX A Housing Land Supply Monitor 2014 - Data Report

Site Decision Net Gross Comp U/C O/S Application Address Area Date Units Units 2013/14 2013/14 2013/14 (ha) 13/01128/S73 2 The Dog, Baughton, Earls Croome 18/10/2013 0.56 1 2 0 2 0 13/00553/FUL 0 1 0 Land adj The Highways, Worcester Road, Great Witley 04/07/2013 0.16 3 3 13/00616/FUL Land at (OS 7959 4580), Bellars Lane, Malvern 04/10/2013 0.05 1 1 0 1 0 13/00676/FUL 17 Minge Lane, Upton upon Severn 16/08/2013 0.04 1 1 0 1 0 Elm Hurst Farm, Hereford Road, Leigh Sinton, 11/00019/FUL 0 1 0 Worcestershire, WR13 5EA 16/03/2011 0.06 1 1 13/01467/FUL Greenhill Farm, Greenhill Lane, Hallow 28/02/2014 1.20 3 3 0 3 0 TOTAL 71

Small Windfall Sites Under Construction 2013/2014 APPENDIX A Housing Land Supply Monitor 2014 - Data Report

Local Plan Allocated Sites Outstanding 2013/14 (with planning consent)

Decision Site Area Net Gross Comp U/C 2013- O/S 2013- Application Address Parish Date (ha) Units Units 2013-14 14 14 04/00182/OUT DRA, North Site, Leigh Sinton Road, Malvern Malvern 15/12/2006 17.93 48 48 0 0 48 (12/01488/REM) S&T Buildings, QinetiQ, St Andrews Road, 10/01577/OEX Malvern 02/06/2011 0.61 28 28 0 0 28 Malvern Barrack Stores, QinetiQ, St Andrews Road, 10/01581/OEX Malvern 16/06/2011 0.95 28 28 0 0 28 Malvern

11/00980/OEX 165-167 Newtown Road, Malvern Malvern 27/10/2011 0.27 13 13 0 0 13

North Site Phase 6 (Malvern Vale), Leigh Sinton 12/01650/REM Malvern 12/04/2013 0.26 26 26 0 0 26 Road, Malvern Total 143

Local Plan Allocated Sites Outstanding 2013/14 (with planning consent) APPENDIX A Housing Land Supply Monitor 2014 - Data Report

Large Windfall Sites Outstanding 2013/14

Site Net Gross O/S Application Address Parish Decision Date Area Units Units 2013-14 (ha) 10/00093/FUL Land rear of 5 Florence Close, Kempsey Kempsey 06/06/2011 0.24 7 7 7 Former Margaret Prior Sports Hall, Malvern College, 65 Abbey Road, 11/00227/FUL Malvern Malvern 19/09/2011 0.36 7 7 7 11/00370/FUL 124 Worcester Road, Malvern Malvern 03/02/2012 0.10 12 12 12 11/00872/OUT 123A Main Road, Kempsey, Worcestershire, WR5 3LQ Kempsey 06/06/2012 0.33 6 6 6 11/01167/FUL Ivydene, 55-57 Albert Road North, Malvern Malvern 03/05/2012 0.17 13 15 15 11/01312/FUL Day of Salvation Ministries Ltd, Ranelagh Road, Malvern Malvern 20/12/2013 0.44 10 10 10 11/01406/FUL Day of Salvation Ministeries Ltd, Ranelagh Road, Malvern Malvern 20/12/2013 0.30 14 14 14 12/00401/FUL Land to the West of Ranelagh Road, Malvern Malvern 20/12/2013 0.30 3 5 5 12/00837/FUL Sheffield House, 36 Court Road, Malvern Malvern 31/07/2012 0.05 6 6 6

13/00069/FUL Land at (OS 8189 5091) Adjacent the Crown Public House, Malvern Powick 10/01/2014 2.70 45 45 45 13/00388/S73 Hampton House, Abbey Road, Malvern Malvern 25/03/2014 0.64 12 12 12 Land At (Os 5921 6771),Oldwood Road,Tenbury 12/00659/FUL Wells,Worcestershire Tenbury 30/09/2013 2.37 45 45 45 13/00417/OUT Land at (OS 8552 4989) Main Road, Kempsey Kempsey 12/12/2013 6.70 120 120 120* 13/01476/PDU Unit 4c, The Bruff Business Centre, Suckley Suckley 11/12/2013 0.14 7 7 7 13/00582/PEX Christian Science Society, Albert Park Road, Malvern Malvern 09/10/2013 0.68 6 6 6 12/00876/OUT Land at (OS 5921 6771), Oldwood Road, Tenbury Wells Tenbury 13/08/2013 3.66 44 44 44 12/01087/OUT Land at Lawn Farm, Drake Street, Welland Welland 20/01/2014 12.80 50 50 50 Total 411

*45 dwellings have been discounted off Land north of Brookend Lane, Kempsey site (120 total on site) in the Five Year Supply Calculation in terms of deliverability estimates over five years.

Large Windfall Sites Outstanding 2013/14 APPENDIX A Housing Land Supply Monitor 2014 - Data Report

Small Windfall Sites Outstanding 2013/14

Decision Site Area Gross O/S 2013- Application Address Net Units Date (ha) Units 14 Abberley 10/00554/OUT Manchester House, The Common, Abberley 26/05/2011 0.13 3 4 4 Land Adjacent to The Common, Abberley, 11/01495/OUT 04/01/2012 0.06 1 1 1 Worcestershire,WR6 6AY

Alfrick 13/01361/FUL Lane End, Green Street, Lulsley 19/12/2013 0.35 0 1 1

Bayton 13/01501/FUL Former Coach House at Glebe House, Bayton 07/02/2014 0.15 1 1 1

Bockleton Bockleton Barn, Bockleton Farm, Bockleton, 11/00791FUL 05/09/2011 0.08 1 1 1 Worcestershire, WR15 8PP

Bransford 13/01094/OUT Fir Tree House, Bransford 09/12/2013 0.10 1 1 1 12/00007/FUL The Older Cider House, Chapel Lane, Bransford 05/03/2012 0.12 1 1 1

Broadheath 13/01033/OUT Land off Ankderine Road, Lower Broadheath 12/12/2013 0.51 3 3 3 13/01271/FUL Penrhyn, Grange Lane, Lower Broadheath 09/12/2013 0.00 1 1 1 Offices at Heath Grange Farm, Grange Lane, Lower 11/00995/FUL 29/11/2012 0.03 1 1 1 Broadheath Land adj 61 Jacomb Road, Lower Broadheath, 11/01168/PEX 18/10/2011 0.13 1 1 1 Worcestershire, WR2 6QW 11/01720/FUL The Art Studio, Crown East Lane, Lower Broadheath 04/10/2012 0.02 1 1 1

Small Windfall Sites Outstanding 2013/2014 APPENDIX A Housing Land Supply Monitor 2014 - Data Report Decision Site Area Gross O/S 2013- Application Address Net Units Date (ha) Units 14 Broadwas 11/00722/PEX Broadwas Garage, Broadwas, 18/10/2011 0.04 1 1 1 13/00059/FUL Hillside, Broadwas, Worcestershire, WR6 5NL 04/10/2012 0.25 1 0 1

Bushley 13/00077/FUL Mythe Bridge House, Ledbury Road, Tewkesbury 30/09/2013 0.23 0 1 1

Castlemorton 13/01223/OUT Eight Oaks Farm, Eight Oaks, Castlemorton 20/03/2014 0.17 1 1 1

Clifton Upon Teme Land At (Os 7169 6148), Church Road, Clifton On Teme, 13/01592/OUT 07/02/2014 0.07 1 1 1 Worcestershire,

Cotheridge Upper Howsen Farm, Howsen, Cotheridge, Worcestershire, 11/00868/FUL 05/10/2011 0.20 1 1 1 WR6 5LR

Eldersfield 12/01566/FUL Downend Farm, Long Green, Forthampton 01/03/2013 3.30 4 5 5

Grimley 13/00884/FUL The Retreat,Grimley,Worcestershire 05/09/2013 0.38 1 1 1 12/00327/FUL Land adj to Yew Tree Cottage, Sinton Green, Hallow 03/12/2012 0.03 1 1 1 12/00973/FUL Land adj New Inn, Sinton Green, Hallow 17/10/2013 0.10 1 1 1 13/00198/OEX Rose Cottage, Grimley, Worcester 02/04/2013 0.29 0 1 1

Hallow 11/00260/FUL The Coach House, Hallow Park, Hallow 12/05/2011 4.13 1 1 1 The Orchards, Moseley Road, Hallow, Worcestershire, WR2 11/01157/FUL 10/01/2012 0.10 1 2 2 6NJ

Small Windfall Sites Outstanding 2013/2014 APPENDIX A Housing Land Supply Monitor 2014 - Data Report Decision Site Area Gross O/S 2013- Application Address Net Units Date (ha) Units 14 Hanley Castle Land rear of New House/Motrose Cottage, Welland Road, 13/01045/FUL 14/02/2014 0.20 2 2 2 Hanley Swan 13/00959/FUL Rear of 32 Quay Lane, Hanley Castle 23/10/2013 0.02 1 1 1

Holt 12/01654/FUL Land adj Stonecroft, Holt Heath 26/03/2013 0.09 1 1 1

Kempsey 11/00873/OUT 09/12/2011 0.07 0 1 1 123A Main Road, Kempsey, Worcestershire, WR5 3LQ 12/00434/FUL The Holdings, Broomhall Lane, Broomhall, Worcester 08/10/2012 0.01 0 1 1 13/01228/PDU Baynhall Farm, Main Road, Kempsey 21/11/2013 0.19 1 1 1 13/01305/FUL 1 Old Road South, Kempsey 20/12/2013 0.10 1 1 1

Knighton Upon Teme 12/00779/FUL The Tavern, Tavern Lane, Newnham Bridge, WR15 8LR 01/08/2012 0.71 0 2 2

Leigh 12/01325/OUT Brockamin Farm, Brockamin, Leigh 08/11/2012 0.06 1 1 1 13/00145/FUL Brockamin Farm, Brockamin, Leigh 05/04/2013 0.05 1 1 1

Lindridge 13/00768/FUL Little Lambswick Farm House, Eardiston 23/08/2013 0.26 1 1 1

Longdon 12/01658/FUL Lower Swell Farm, Longdon Marsh 21/01/2013 0.15 1 1 1

Small Windfall Sites Outstanding 2013/2014 APPENDIX A Housing Land Supply Monitor 2014 - Data Report Decision Site Area Gross O/S 2013- Application Address Net Units Date (ha) Units 14 Lower Sapey Barn Known as Margots Hen House, Harpley, Clifton-upon- 11/00494/FUL 21/08/2012 0.10 1 1 1 Teme

Malvern 13/00781/FUL Duriston, 1 St Andrews Road, Malvern 23/09/2013 0.03 1 1 1 13/00970/FUL 31A Upper Howsell Road, Malvern 30/12/2013 0.05 1 1 1 13/00961/FUL 90/92 Worcester Road, Malvern 11/09/2013 0.02 1 1 1 13/00887/FUL Land adj 81 Old Hollow, Malvern 29/10/2013 0.08 1 1 1 13/00948/PEX Land at Baskerville Hall, Cowleigh Bank, Malvern 01/10/2013 0.10 1 1 1 13/00825/FUL The Shrubbery, Happy Valley, Malvern 04/11/2013 0.11 1 1 1 14/00047/FUL Rear of 213-215 Worcester Road, Malvern 28/02/2014 0.04 1 1 1 14/00082/FUL 204-207 Elgar Avenue, Malvern 28/02/2014 0.02 2 2 2 The Coach House at Barnards Green House, 10 Poolbrook 11/00110/FUL 31/05/2011 0.24 1 1 1 Road, Malvern 11/00871/REM 17 Pump Street, Malvern 07/09/2011 0.03 1 1 1 11/01503/FUL 1 Arosa Drive, Malvern 27/02/2012 0.04 1 1 1 12/00060/PEX 8 Victoria Road, Malvern 22/02/2012 0.40 2 2 2 12/00083/FUL Rear of 9 North End Lane, Malvern 02/03/2012 0.03 1 1 1 12/00119/FUL 3 North Hill Gardens, Malvern 19/03/2012 0.05 1 1 1 12/00496/FUL Wells House, Holywell Road, Malvern 29/06/2012 1 1 1 12/00578/PEX 28/08/2012 0.09 3 3 3 Ivydene Hall & Summerside, Albert Road North, Malvern 12/01017/FUL 47 Cowleigh Bank, Malvern 20/09/2012 0.02 1 1 1 12/01094/FUL Land, 49A Cowleigh Road, Malvern 24/09/2012 0.03 1 1 1 12/01201/FUL 8 Somers Road, Malvern 23/04/2013 0.38 4 4 4 12/01357/REM Adj to 24 St Peters Road, Malvern 23/11/2012 0.10 1 1 1 12/01704/FUL Land at (OS 7924 4676), Wren Avenue, Malvern 15/05/2013 0.07 2 2 2 13/00090/FUL Land at 102 Longridge Road, Malvern 28/06/2013 0.02 1 1 1 13/00448/FUL 114 Poolbrook Road, Malvern 10/06/2013 0.01 2 2 2 13/01246/OUT 6 Pound Bank Road, Malvern 08/01/2014 0.02 1 1 1

Small Windfall Sites Outstanding 2013/2014 APPENDIX A Housing Land Supply Monitor 2014 - Data Report Decision Site Area Gross O/S 2013- Application Address Net Units Date (ha) Units 14 13/01302/FUL Land adj 86 Guarlford Road, Malvern 04/12/2013 0.18 1 1 1 13/01166/FUL Land at (Os 7752 4538), Wells Road, Malvern 01/11/2013 0.07 2 2 2 13/01056/FUL 419 Pickersleigh Road, Malvern 03/01/2014 0.03 1 1 1 13/01205/FUL Crystal Mount, 59 Albert Road North, Malvern 13/11/2013 0.01 1 1 1 14/00208/FUL 67 Upper Howsell Road, Malvern 31/03/2014 0.02 1 1 1 Former Tennis Court Site Land at (OS 7763 4500), College 13/01354/FUL 20/01/2014 0.27 2 2 2 Road, Malvern

Malvern Wells 11/00687/OEX Chestnut Hill, Green Lane, Malvern 12/07/2011 0.25 3 4 4 12/00920/FUL 211-213 Wells Road, Malvern 21/08/2012 0.20 3 4 4 13/00012/FUL Chestnut Hill, Green Lane, Malvern 02/04/2013 0.26 2 3 3

Mamble 13/00058/FUL Westwood Farm, Mamble 14/06/2013 0.08 0 1 1

Martley 13/01485/FUL Old Tannery, Martley 13/01/2014 0.01 1 1 1

Pensax 11/01399/FUL Woodhouse Farm, Stockton 02/02/2012 6.62 2 2 2

Powick 13/00862/FUL The Post House, Ham Lane, Powick 06/11/2013 0.03 -1 -1 -1 13/00958/FUL Gas Works Site, Hospital Lane, Powick 15/11/2013 0.27 3 3 3 12/00241/FUL Coach House, Kings End Road, Powick 14/09/2012 0.20 1 1 1 13/00138/FUL Old Hills Cottage, 112 Old Hills, Callow End 05/04/2013 0.13 0 1 1 13/00611/FUL 17 Kings End Road, Powick 03/09/2013 0.01 0 1 1 Court Farm,Jennett Tree Lane,Callow 12/00016/REM 15/02/2012 0.08 1 1 1 End,Worcestershire,WR2 4UE 14/00045FUL 2 Highfield, Callow End 11/03/2014 0.02 1 1 1

Small Windfall Sites Outstanding 2013/2014 APPENDIX A Housing Land Supply Monitor 2014 - Data Report Decision Site Area Gross O/S 2013- Application Address Net Units Date (ha) Units 14 Ripple 12/00136/FUL Saxons Lode Farm, Saxons Lode, Uckinghall 19/03/2012 0.09 1 1 1 12/01021/PEX Lady Key, Holly Green, Upton-upon-Severn 07/09/2012 0.05 1 1 1 12/01673/FUL Ryall Court Farm, Ryall Court Lane, Holly Green 28/03/2013 0.39 1 1 1

Rochford 13/01210/FUL Wood Park Farm, Rochford 07/02/2014 0.07 1 2 2

Rushwick 11/00017/FUL Willow House, Rushwick 15/04/2011 0.07 1 2 2

Severn Stoke 13/00189/FUL Old Forge Works, Kinnersley, Severn Stoke 14/06/2013 0.04 1 1 1 13/01091/FUL The Old School House, Severn Stoke 12/11/2013 0.48 3 3 3

Shrawley 12/01689/FUL Goodyears Farm, Rectory Lane, Shrawley 26/02/2013 0.07 0 1 1

Tenbury The Manor Farm,Oldwood Common,Worcestershire,WR15 13/00880/FUL 03/09/2013 0.95 1 1 1 8TF 14/00101/FUL 40 Teme Street, Tenbury Wells 21/03/2014 0.01 1 1 1 Cadmore Lodge Country Hotel, Berrington Green, Tenbury 11/01228/FUL 20/02/2012 0.67 1 1 1 Wells 11/01641/OEX Greenhill Springs, Kyrewood Road, Tenbury Wells 18/01/2012 0.06 3 3 3 13/01164/FUL The Pottery, 18 Teme Street, Tenbury Wells 18/11/2013 0.01 1 1 1 13/00348/FUL Lower Town Farm, Berrington 05/02/2014 0.10 1 1 1

Upton Upon Severn 11/00992/FUL Butterfly Cottage, Welland Road, Upton-upon-Severn 09/01/2012 0.11 0 1 1

Small Windfall Sites Outstanding 2013/2014 APPENDIX A Housing Land Supply Monitor 2014 - Data Report Decision Site Area Gross O/S 2013- Application Address Net Units Date (ha) Units 14 12/00687/FUL 08/08/2012 0.04 2 2 2 The Royal Oak, Oak Row/Oak Street, Upton-upon-Severn 12/00995/FUL 44a Backfields Lane, Upton upon Severn 18/07/2013 0.10 1 1 1 13/01120/FUL Cowhills Farm, Wheatley lane, Upton-upon-Severn 07/02/2014 0.01 0 1 1

West Malvern 12/01105/FUL The Lamb Inn, 87 West Malvern Road, Malvern 20/12/2012 0.05 2 2 2 13/00403/FUL The Lamb Inn, 87 West Malvern Road, Malvern 22/08/2013 0.08 4 4 4 14/00178/FUL Land at 20 Lower Montpelier Road, Malvern 31/03/2014 0.05 1 1 1 13/00580/FUL Kenwyn, Brockhill Road, Malvern 28/06/2013 0.53 0 1 1 TOTAL 146

Small Windfall Sites Outstanding 2013/2014 APPENDIX A Housing Land Supply Monitor 2014 - Data Report

Breakdown by Previous Use 2013/14

Comp Comp U/C U/C O/S O/S Previous Use 2013-14 % 2013-14 % 2013-14 % Brownfield Industry 0 0% 0 0% 61 21% Offices 7 5% 1 1% 11 4% Residential 16 13% 29 40% 78 26% Retailing 1 1% 1 1% 2 1% Warehousing & Storage 6 5% 0 0% 4 1% Other 93 76% 42 58% 141 47% Total Brownfield (Gross) 123 100% 73 100% 297 100%

Greenfield Agricultural Buildings 10 14% 93 50% 20 5% Agricultural Land 19 25% 71 38% 312 77% Garden Land 33 44% 19 10% 57 14% Outdoor and Recreation 0 0% 0 0% 1 1% Other 13 17% 4 2% 13 3% Total Greenfield (Gross) 75 100% 187 100% 403 100%

Totals (Gross) 198 100% 260 100% 700 100%

Breakdown by Previous Use 2013/14 APPENDIX A Housing Land Supply Monitor 2014 - Data Report

Completed Dwellings (Gross) by Number of Bedrooms 2013/14

No of Bed units Dwelling Type Total 1 Bed 2 Bed 3 Bed 4 Bed Houses & Bungalows 4 34 68 59 165 Flats & Maisonettes 9 23 0 0 32 Unknown 1 Total 13 57 68 59 198 Totals as % 7% 29% 34% 30% 100%

Completed Dwellings (Gross) by Number of Bedrooms 2013/14 APPENDIX A Housing Land Supply Monitor 2014 - Data Report

Replacement Dwellings Completed 2013/14

Replacement Gross Net Application Address Dwellings Units Units Completed 10/01106/FUL Little Arley, Birtsmorton 1 0 1 11/00501/FUL 56 Old Wyche Road , Malvern 1 0 1 11/01119/FUL Bramblewood, Hipplecote, Martley 1 0 1 12/00263/FUL 1 & 2 Upper Green, St Michaels, Tenbury 1 -1 1 12/00448/FUL Avenue Riding Centre, Hanley Road, Welland 1 0 1 12/00804/FUL Bradfords Farm, Castlemorton 1 0 1 12/01139/FUL The Knoll Bungalow, Clifton on Teme 1 0 1 13/00310/FUL Dorothys Rock, Rhyse Lane, Tenbury Wells 1 0 1 TOTAL 8

Replacement Dwellings Completed 2013/2014 APPENDIX A Housing Land Supply Monitor 2014 - Data Report

Density of Completions 2013/14 (Gross Density)

Number of Gross Proportion of Average dwellings Site Area Total Density (gross) (Ha) (dwellings) Less than 30dph 115 10.74 13 dph 71% 30-50 dph 17 0.45 37 dph 11% More than 50 dph 30 0.35 111 dph 18% Total 162 11.54 14 dph 100% dph = dwellings per hectare (Only includes dwellings on sites that have been built out, including phases, gross site area)

Affordable Housing Completions 2013/14

Total Planning App Affordable Intermediate Affordable Location Social Rent Ref Rent Housing Homes Delivered Bank House Bowling Club, Bransford 12/00562/FUL 10 0 0 10 North Site Phase 7, Leigh Sinton Road, Malvern 12/01240/FUL 15 0 14 29 Land rear of 26-30 Mountbatten Road, Malvern 12/01703/FUL 2 0 0 2 Land adjacent Green Hedges, Claphill Lane, Rushwick 12/01661/FUL 7 0 0 7 Redundant road/land behind Orford Way and Elgar Avenue, 12/01717/FUL 3 0 0 3 Malvern 6-7 Baxters Walk, Malvern 12/00907/FUL 2 0 0 2 TOTALS 39 0 14 53

Density of Net Completions and Affordable Housing Completions 2013/2014 APPENDIX A Housing Land Supply Monitor 2014 - Data Report

Dwelling Completions in the Malvern Urban and Rural Areas 2013/14

Gross Completions Percentage (%) Within the Malvern Urban Area Settlement Boundary 115 58 Rural Area - Within Settlement Boundary 27 14 Rural Area - Outside Settlement Boundary 56 28 Total 198 100

Dwellings Completions Inside and Outside of Settlement Boundaries 2013/14

Gross % of Year Completions total Completions Outside Settlement Boundary 56 28% Inside Settlement Boundary 142 72% Total 198 100

Housing Completions in the Malvern Urban and Rural Areas 2013/14 APPENDIX A Housing Land Supply Monitor 2014 - Data Report

New Permissions Granted 2013/2014

Small Local Plan Large Windfall Windfall Total Sites Sites Sites New Permissions (Number of 1 16 84 101 Applications) Dwellings (gross) 26 509 118 653 This includes reserved matters and extensions of time limits, as well as new full or outline permissions

Planning Application Renewals 2013/2014

Renewals Renewals Total as % of total Permissions 4 99 4.04% Dwellings (gross) 10 559 1.79%

Figure illustrates OEX and PEX (Extension of Time limits) and does not include renewals due to amended scheme/design etc.

Permissions Granted and Renewals 2012/2013 APPENDIX A Housing Land Supply Monitor 2014 - Data Report

Annual Build Rates 2000-2014

% of Gross Annual 1st Year 2nd Year 3rd Year 5th Year Total Gross Permitted Decision Gross (Gross 4th Year (Gross (Gross (Gross Completions Dwellings Year Permitted Completions) Same (Gross Completions) Completions) Completions) Completions) after 5 years Completed Dwellings as Decision Year After 5 Years 2000-2001 206 24 12% 75 36% 50 21% 24 12% 6 3% 179 87% 2001-2002 223 17 8% 97 43% 57 25% 5 2% 6 3% 182 82% 2002-2003 270 45 17% 106 39% 39 14% 17 6% 7 3% 214 79% 2003-2004 272 71 26% 145 53% 13 5% 17 6% 26 10% 272 100% 2004-2005 237 45 19% 79 33% 32 10% 18 8% 0 0% 174 73% 2005-2006 328 60 18% 86 26% 69 21% 10 26% 21 6% 246 75% 2006-2007 352 34 10% 150 43% 50 14% 29 8% 4 1% 267 76% 2007-2008 456 55 12% 174 38% 47 10% 11 2% 0 0% 287 63% 2008-2009 274 21 8% 93 34% 31 11% 31 11% 7 3% 183 67% 2009-2010 370 50 14% 69 19% 30 8% 9 2% 7 2% 165 45% 2010-2011 420 25 6% 71 17% 118 28% 74 18% 2011-2012 347 20 6% 32 9% 22 6% 2012-2013 182 23 13% 60 33% 2013-2014 653 103 16% 2000-2014 4,590 593 13% 1,237 27% 558 12% 245 5% 84 2% 2,169 73% (From 2,988 gross permissions Lapse Rate 2013-2014 between 2000-01 and 2009-10 that have now had 5 built out 2013- Annual change in Housing Supply Number of years) 2014 during 2013/2014 Dwellings Net Commitments as at April 881* Planning consents granted on new sites** +643 Expired 31/03/2014 (gross) 34 Expired planning consent -34 Gross Completions -198 *Outstanding sites with planning permission Outstanding Local Plan Allocations +36 (673), under construction sites (172) and Total Annual Change in Housing Supply +447 outstanding Local Plan sites (36). **Excludes any renewal/time limit extension permissions

Annual Build Rates 2000-2014 APPENDIX A Housing Land Supply Monitor 2014 - Data Report

Annual Windfall Permissions by Gross Dwellings

Large and Small Windfall Sites Gross Dwellings Small Windfall Sites Gross Dwellings

2000/2001 206 2000/2001 93 2001/2002 223 2001/2002 110 2002/2003 270 2002/2003 175 2003/2004 272 2003/2004 217 2004/2005 237 2004/2005 157 2005/2006 328 2005/2006 204 2006/2007 352 2006/2007 185 2007/2008 335 2007/2008 153 2008/2009 274 2008/2009 167 2009/2010 183 2009/2010 126 2010/2011 203 2010/2011 123 2011/2012 161 2011/2012 104 2012/2013 183 2012/2013 105 2013/2014* 627 2013/2014 118 Average 2000-2014 275 Average 2000-2014 146

*Includes phase 7 of North Site (58) and some proposed SWDP allocation sites (124)

Annual Windfall Permissions by Gross Dwellings APPENDIX A Housing Land Supply Monitor 2014 - Data Report

Urban/Rural Split 2013/2014

Completions 2013/2014 Gross Net Year Urban Rural Total Urban Rural Total 2006/07 90 97 187 88 84 172 % 48% 52% 100% 51% 49% 100% 2007/08 140 188 328 134 172 306 % 43% 57% 100% 44% 56% 100% 2008/09 196 76 272 183 73 256 % 72% 28% 100% 71% 29% 100% 2009/10 181 64 245 171 51 222 % 74% 26% 100% 77% 23% 100% 2010/11 110 39 149 102 34 136 % 74% 26% 100% 75% 25% 100% 2011/12* 135 119 254 130 104 234 % 53% 47% 100% 56% 44% 100% 2012/13 157 34 191 152 29 181 % 82% 18% 100% 84% 16% 100% 2013/14 115 83 198 113 73 186 % 58% 42% 100% 61% 39% 100% Average 141 88 228 134 78 212 Average % 63% 37% 100% 65% 35% 100%

Commitments 2013/2014 Gross Net Urban Rural Total Urban Rural Total U/C 136 124 260 57 115 172 % 52% 48% 100% 33% 67% 100% OS 287 413 700 280 393 673 % 41% 59% 100% 42% 58% 100% Totals 423 537 960 337 508 845

Urban completions constitute development within Malvern’s Settlement boundary. Rural completions constitute development outside of Malvern‘s boundary.

* From 2011/12 excludes demolitions from net completions

Urban/Rural Split 2013/2014 APPENDIX A Housing Land Supply Monitor 2014 - Data Report

Expiry/Lapse Rates of Planning Applications

Year of Expiry 2006/07 2007/08 2008/09 2009/10 2010/11 2011/12 2012/13 2013/14 TOTALS Gross Expiries 17 24 28 118 103 76 125 34 525

Gross Commitments 1,286 1,235 1,192 1,013 894 865 611 902 7,998

Expiries as a % of Commitments 1.32% 1.94% 2.35% 11.65% 11.52% 8.79% 20.46% 3.77% 6.56%

Expiry figures do not factor in any applications that have re-gained planning permission with the same year

Laspe Rates 2006/07-2013/14 APPENDIX B Housing Land Supply Monitor 2014 - Commitments List

Application Site Gross Net Decision O/S U/C Comp Type Status Address Description Parish Ward Expiry Date* No Type Units Units Date 2013-14 2013-14 2013-14 Amended scheme for previously approved application 98/00773 FUL C Coppice End, Kigshill, Leigh Sinton, Malvern SWS Alfrick Temeside 1 1 17/08/1998 17/08/2003 0 0 1 (MH 97/0112) to rebuild derelict timber framed dwelling 03/00861 FUL C Barn at Upper Green, St Michaels, Tenbury Wells SWS Conversion of barn to one dwelling Tenbury Tenbury 1 1 30/10/2003 30/10/2008 0 0 1 NORTH SITE Redevelopment for housing, employment (Class B1), school, local centre, open space, landscaping, Malvern Dyson 04/00182 OUT OS DRA, North Site, Leigh Sinton Road, Malvern LPS Malvern 48 48 15/12/2006 15/12/2009 48 0 0 site roads amendment of existing access and creation of Perrins new access (12/01488/REM). Conversion of barns to three dwellings and garaging to 05/01681 FUL UC Court Farm Hanley Childe SWS Hanley Teme Valley 3 3 06/01/2006 06/01/2011 0 1 1 replace modern agricultural buildings Land At (OS 7720 5417) Teme Lane Leigh Leigh & 06/01104 FUL C SWS Agricultural Dwelling Leigh 1 1 14/11/2006 14/11/2009 0 0 1 Worcester Bransford Demolition of existing dwelling and erection of 4 no. 06/01788 FUL C Pal Mrya, Terrills Lane, Tenbury Wells SWS Tenbury Tenbury 4 3 12/02/2007 12/02/2010 0 0 1 dwellings 08/00241 FUL UC 41 Wells Road, Malvern, Worcestershire WR14 4RJ SWS Conversion to three apartments and erection of portico Malvern Malvern Priory 3 2 14/04/2008 14/04/2011 0 3 0 Conversion of existing stables and construction of single Alfrick and 08/00800 FUL UC Sinton House Farm, Stocks Lane, Leigh Sinton SWS Leigh 1 1 12/12/2008 12/12/2011 0 1 0 storey extension to form dwelling Leigh 2 No. detached dwellings. Resubmission of approved 08/01237 FUL UC Baptist Chapel, Church Street, Kempsey SWS Kempsey Kempsey 2 2 01/10/2008 01/10/2011 0 1 0 application 08/00319/FUL 09/00477 FUL C Walk Farm, Castlemorton, Malvern SWS Conversion of redundant barns to 3 residential units Castlemorton Morton 3 3 09/06/2009 09/06/2012 0 0 3 Change of use of former hostel for the elderly to form 4 no. 09/00511 FUL UC Violet Morris House, 7 Market Square, Tenbury Wells SWS Tenbury Tenbury 4 4 27/08/2009 27/08/2012 0 1 0 dwellings/residential units Conversion of redundant agricultural building to 2 No Alfrick and 09/00678 FUL UC Barn at (7489 5268) Alfrick SWS Alfrick 2 2 17/07/2009 17/07/2012 0 2 0 residential dwellings and provision of garage Leigh Refurbishment of derelict former house with 2 storey 09/00749 FUL UC The Old Court, Horsham, Martley SWS Martley Martley 1 1 01/07/2010 01/04/2013 0 1 0 extension to create dwelling 09/00901 FUL UC Holywards Farm, Moseley Road, Hallow SWS Conversion of existing barns to form two dwellings Grimley Hallow 2 2 12/04/2010 12/04/2013 0 1 1 Clifton Upon 09/01236 FUL UC 1 Manor Road, Clifton-on-Teme SWS Erection of dwelling Teme Valley 1 1 05/11/2009 05/11/2012 0 1 0 Teme Alfrick and 09/01328 FUL C Bank Farm, Brockamin, Leigh SWS Formation of two dwellings (division of existing farmhouse) Leigh 2 1 24/11/2009 24/11/2012 0 0 2 Leigh 09/01446 FUL C The Redlands, Clows Top SWS Erection of dwelling Bayton Lindridge 1 1 29/12/2009 29/12/2012 0 0 1 09/01603 FUL UC Post Office Cottage, Newnham Bridge, Tenbury Wells LWS Residential development for 5 dwellings Knighton on Teme Lindridge 5 5 13/02/2012 13/02/2015 0 2 0 Erection of a two bedroom bungalow with new vehicular 10/00037 FUL C 1 Mount Orchard, Tenbury Wells SWS Tenbury Tenbury 1 1 26/03/2010 26/03/2013 0 0 1 access 10/00093 FUL OS Land rear of 5 Florence Close, Kempsey LWS Residential development of 7 no. dwellings Kempsey Kempsey 7 7 06/06/2011 06/06/2014 7 0 0 Proposed residential development of 2 semi-detached 10/00137 FUL C Land adj 50 Worcester Road, Malvern SWS Malvern Malvern Priory 2 2 29/06/2010 29/06/2013 0 0 2 dwellings 10/00242 FUL C 180 Worcester Road, Malvern SWS Change of use from commercial to residential Malvern Malvern Link 2 2 06/04/2010 06/04/2013 0 0 2 Upton and 10/00551 FUL UC Land adjacent 27 Church End, Hanley Castle SWS Detached dwelling Hanley Castle 1 1 23/02/2011 23/02/2014 0 1 0 Hanley 10/00554 OUT OS Manchester House, The Common, Abberley SWS Development of 4 houses Abberley Woodbury 4 3 26/05/2011 26/05/2014 4 0 0 New detached dwelling (revised proposal for Approval 10/00643 FUL UC Briarlea, Bell Lane, Lower Broadheath SWS Broadheath Broadheath 1 1 22/10/2010 22/10/2013 0 1 0 08/00220/REM) Zourka, Church Lane, Broadwas, Worcestershire, WR6 10/00766 FUL UC SWS Replacement Dwelling Broadwas Broadheath 1 0 22/09/2010 22/09/2013 0 1 0 5NQ Extension of time limit to commence development on 10/00948 PEX UC Hillcourt Farm, Welland, Worcestershire, WR13 6NH SWS application 07/00916/FUL - Conversion of 3 barns to 3 Welland Morton 3 3 13/09/2010 13/09/2013 0 1 0 dwellings and reconstruction of cow byre to form garaging. Extension of time limit to commence development on 10/01006 PEX C Land adj Fairoaks, 27 Cockshot Road, Malvern SWS Malvern Malvern Priory 1 1 24/09/2010 24/09/2013 0 0 1 07/01295 one detached dwelling 10/01085 FUL C Chapel House, Moseley Road, Hallow SWS Conversion of chapel to residential use Hallow Hallow 1 1 26/10/2010 26/10/2013 0 0 1 Proposed amendments to existing planning consent 10/01106 FUL C Little Arley, Birtsmorton SWS Birtsmorton Morton 1 0 15/10/2010 15/10/2013 0 0 1 09/01338/FUL for a replacement dwelling Construction of 11 dwellings and replacement of one Malvern 10/01368 FUL C 24 Hayslan Road, Malvern LWS Malvern 12 11 01/03/2011 01/03/2014 0 0 12 dwelling Pickersleigh Demolition of Alexandra Gardens and Brookside and Alexandra Gardens/Brookside, Gloucester Close, 10/01499 FUL UC LWS replacement with an affordable mixed tenure independent Malvern Malvern Link 101 25 06/10/2011 06/10/2014 0 101 0 Malvern living scheme

*Expiry dates only apply to outstanding sites (OS) where development has yet to commence **Includes demolitions and net gains/losses from change of use and conversions sites 1 of 9 pages APPENDIX B Housing Land Supply Monitor 2014 - Commitments List

Application Site Gross Net Decision O/S U/C Comp Type Status Address Description Parish Ward Expiry Date* No Type Units Units Date 2013-14 2013-14 2013-14 Construction of new dwelling on footprint of former 10/01509 FUL UC Hanley Court Gardens, Hanley William SWS Hanley Teme Valley 1 1 20/05/2011 20/05/2014 0 1 0 glasshouses, root shed and stables Extension of time limit to commence development on 10/01577 OEX OS S&T Buildings, QinetiQ, St Andrews Road, Malvern LPS Malvern Malvern Chase 28 28 02/06/2011 02/06/2014 28 0 0 application 05/00329/OUT - 28 residential units Extension of time limit to commence development on 10/01581 OEX OS Barrack Stores, QinetiQ, St Andrews Road, Malvern LPS Malvern Malvern Chase 28 28 16/06/2011 16/06/2014 28 0 0 application 05/00383/OUT - 28 residential units 11/00017 FUL OS Willow House, Rushwick SWS Conversion of house into 2 flats Rushwick Broadheath 2 1 15/04/2011 15/04/2014 2 0 0 Change of use of land to residential curtilage to provide Elm Hurst Farm, Hereford Road, Leigh Sinton, access to Plot 4. Amendment to approved scheme Alfrick and 11/00019 FUL UC SWS Leigh 1 1 16/03/2011 16/03/2014 0 1 0 Worcestershire, WR13 5EA (08/01734/REM); Re-orientation of dwelling house in Plot Leigh 4. Demolition of redundant building and erection of dwelling 11/00026 FUL UC Land adj Primrose Cottage, Longdon SWS Longdon Longdon 1 1 05/07/2011 05/07/2014 0 1 0 for occupation by disabled person and permanent carer The Coach House at Barnards Green House, 10 Restorations and extensions and change of use of The 11/00110 FUL OS SWS Malvern Malvern Chase 1 1 31/05/2011 31/05/2014 1 0 0 Poolbrook Road, Malvern Coach House into a dwelling Former Margaret Prior Sports Hall, Malvern College, 65 11/00227 FUL OS LWS Residential development of 7 houses Malvern Malvern Priory 7 7 19/09/2011 19/09/2014 7 0 0 Abbey Road, Malvern Change of use of existing B1 office premises to C3 single 11/00260 FUL OS The Coach House, Hallow Park, Hallow SWS Hallow Hallow 1 1 12/05/2011 12/05/2014 1 0 0 residential dwellinghouse 11/00370 FUL OS 124 Worcester Road, Malvern LWS Construction of 10 flats and 2 dwellings Malvern Malvern Link 12 12 03/02/2012 03/02/2015 12 0 0 Erection of detached dwelling to provide two, one 11/00374 FUL UC 28 Cowleigh Road, Malvern SWS Malvern Malvern West 2 2 04/07/2011 04/07/2014 0 2 0 bedroomed apartments 11/00398 FUL C The Conifers, Holt Heath SWS One new private dwelling Holt Baldwin 1 1 09/05/2011 09/05/2014 0 0 1 Proposed conversion of stables to create 3 residential 11/00427 FUL UC Bluebell Farm, Pershore Road, Earls Croome SWS Earls Croome Ripple 3 3 25/05/2011 25/05/2014 0 3 0 units 11/00442 FUL C 21 Wedderburn Road, Malvern SWS Erection of 4 no dwellings and garages Malvern Malvern Chase 4 4 26/07/2011 26/07/2014 0 0 4 Barn Known as Margots Hen House, Harpley, Clifton- 11/00494 FUL OS SWS Conversion to dwelling Lower Sapey Teme Valley 1 1 21/08/2012 21/08/2015 1 0 0 upon-Teme Demolition of existing dwelling and erection of new 11/00501 FUL C 56 Old Wyche Road , Malvern SWS Malvern Wells Malvern Wells 1 0 25/05/2011 25/05/2011 0 0 1 dwelling Erection of 6 two bedroom apartments with associated car 11/00657 FUL UC 18A Peachfield Road, Malvern LWS Malvern Wells Malvern Wells 6 5 22/06/2012 22/06/2015 0 6 0 parking Extension of time limit to commence development on 11/00687 OEX OS Chestnut Hill, Green Lane, Malvern SWS application 08/00469/OUT. Demolition of existing house Malvern Wells Malvern Wells 4 3 12/07/2011 12/07/2014 4 0 0 and replacement with four detached dwellings Extension of time limit to commence development on 11/00722 PEX OS Broadwas Garage, Broadwas, SWS Broadwas Broadheath 1 1 15/08/2011 15/08/2014 1 0 0 application 08/00862, erection of bungalow Aymestry House, Bromyard Road, Crown East, Conversion of remaining part of mansion to 3 separate 11/00769 FUL UC SWS Rushwick Broadheath 3 2 23/05/2012 23/05/2015 0 3 0 Worcestershire, WR2 5TR dwellings 11/00788 FUL UC 123 Newtown Road Malvern SWS Detached 2 Bedroom House Malvern Malvern West 1 1 19/08/2011 19/08/2014 0 1 0 Bockleton Barn, Bockleton Farm, Bockleton, Conversion of a stone barn from agricultural use to 11/00791 FUL OS SWS Bockleton Tenbury 1 1 05/09/2011 05/09/2014 1 0 0 Worcestershire, WR15 8PP Domestic Use PT Former Malvernian Tours Site Newtown Construction of 2 no Pairs of 3 Bedroom Semi-Detached 11/00800 FUL C LWS Malvern Malvern West 6 6 19/09/2012 19/09/2015 0 0 6 Road/Belmont Road Malvern dwellings and 2 No 3 Bedroom detached dwellings.

Halfkey House, Half Key, Malvern, Worcestershire, Malvern Dyson 11/00860 FUL C SWS Provision of managers living accomodation Malvern 1 1 27/02/2012 27/02/2015 0 0 1 WR14 1UP Perrins Conversion of former Hopkiln building in to single 5 Upper Howsen Farm, Howsen, Cotheridge, 11/00868 FUL OS SWS bedroom dwelling. Construction of new detached double Cotheridge Broadheath 1 1 05/10/2011 05/10/2014 1 0 0 Worcestershire, WR6 5LR garage and garden store building Reserved Matters following approval of Outline 11/00871 REM OS 17 Pump Street, Malvern SWS Malvern Malvern West 1 1 07/09/2011 07/09/2014 1 0 0 08/00611/OUT for a detached dwelling Outline Planning application for 6 new residential dwellings 11/00872 OUT OS 123A Main Road, Kempsey, Worcestershire, WR5 3LQ LWS Kempsey Kempsey 6 6 06/06/2012 06/06/2015 6 0 0 (4 Detached houses and 2 Bungalows) 11/00873 OUT OS 123A Main Road, Kempsey< Worcestershire, WR5 3LQ SWS Outline Planning Permission for one replacement dwelling Kempsey Kempsey 1 0 09/12/2011 09/12/2014 1 0 0 Witley Park Farm, Worcester Road, Great Witley, 11/00874 FUL UC SWS Erection of a pair of agricultural workers dwellings Great Witley Woodbury 2 2 13/12/2011 13/12/2014 0 2 0 Worcestershire

*Expiry dates only apply to outstanding sites (OS) where development has yet to commence **Includes demolitions and net gains/losses from change of use and conversions sites 2 of 9 pages APPENDIX B Housing Land Supply Monitor 2014 - Commitments List

Application Site Gross Net Decision O/S U/C Comp Type Status Address Description Parish Ward Expiry Date* No Type Units Units Date 2013-14 2013-14 2013-14 Extension of time limit to commence development on 11/00980 OEX OS 165-167 Newtown Road, Malvern LPS application 08/01014/OUT - Outline application for Malvern Malvern West 13 13 27/10/2011 27/10/2014 13 0 0 erection of 13 dwellings Demolition of existing timber bungalow. Erection of new Upton Upon Upton and 11/00992 FUL OS Butterfly Cottage, Welland Road, Upton-upon-Severn SWS 1 0 09/01/2012 09/01/2015 1 0 0 brick one and half storey dwelling Severn Hanley Offices at Heath Grange Farm, Grange Lane, Lower 11/00995 FUL OS SWS Change of use of office building to single dwelling Broadheath Broadheath 1 1 29/11/2012 29/11/2015 1 0 0 Broadheath 11/01119 FUL C Bramblewood, Hipplecote, Martley SWS Amended Design to replacement dwelling approved Martley Martley 1 0 28/10/2011 28/10/2014 0 0 1 Convert former first floor offices into two 2 bedroom 11/01148 FUL C Club Chambers, Grange Road, Malvern SWS Malvern Malvern Priory 2 2 11/11/2011 11/11/2014 0 0 2 apartments Conversion of redundant offices into two 2 bedroom and 11/01150 FUL C Club Chambers, Grange Road, Malvern SWS Malvern Malvern Priory 3 3 15/11/2011 15/11/2014 0 0 3 one 1 bedroom apartments The Orchards, Moseley Road, Hallow, Worcestershire, 11/01157 FUL OS SWS Demolition of bungalow and erection two dwellings Hallow Hallow 2 1 10/01/2012 10/01/2015 2 0 0 WR2 6NJ Conversion of existing building to create 14 apartments, 11/01167 FUL OS Ivydene, 55-57 Albert Road North, Malvern LWS and replacement of of existing timber bungalow with Malvern Malvern Priory 15 13 03/05/2012 03/05/2015 15 0 0 extension to create 1 apartment Extension of time limit to commence development on Land adj 61 Jacomb Road, Lower Broadheath, 11/01168 PEX OS SWS application 08/00211/FUL Erection of a two bedroomed Broadheath Broadheath 1 1 18/10/2011 18/10/2014 1 0 0 Worcestershire, WR2 6QW dwelling Cadmore Lodge Country Hotel, Berrington Green, Change of use from Hotel Country Club (C1) to private 11/01228 FUL OS SWS Tenbury Tenbury 1 1 20/02/2012 20/02/2015 1 0 0 Tenbury Wells dwellinghouse (C3) 11/01307 FUL C 3 Manorfield, Lower Broadheath SWS Erection of four bedroomed detached house Broadheath Broadheath 1 1 15/11/2011 15/11/2014 0 0 1 Conversion of existing building to 10 no dwellings, 11/01312 FUL OS Day of Salvation Ministries Ltd, Ranelagh Road, Malvern LWS including removal of laundry wing to Manna House, and Malvern Malvern Link 10 10 20/12/2013 20/12/2016 10 0 0 removal of modern extension to Harvest House

Demolition of existing outbuildings/garage and erection of 11/01323 FUL C 32 Peachfield Road, Malvern SWS Malvern Wells Malvern Wells 1 1 16/12/2011 16/11/2014 0 0 1 new dwelling and no 2 replacement garages Proposed conversion of existing storage barn into two 11/01399 FUL OS Woodhouse Farm, Stockton SWS Pensax Woodbury 2 2 02/02/2012 02/02/2015 2 0 0 live/work units Erection of 12 no mews houses on the car park and 2 no Day of Salvation Ministeries Ltd, Ranelagh Road, 11/01406 FUL OS LWS pavillion style dwellings on land to the south west of Malvern Malvern Link 14 14 20/12/2013 20/12/2016 14 0 0 Malvern Salvation House Land Adjacent to The Common, Abberley, 11/01495 OUT OS SWS Erection of detached bungalow Abberley Woodbury 1 1 04/01/2012 04/01/2015 1 0 0 Worcestershire,WR6 6AY Upton and 11/01496 FUL C Land adj 34 Winnington Gardens, Hanley Swan SWS Four bedroomed detached dwelling Hanley Castle 1 1 29/11/2011 29/11/2014 0 0 1 Hanley 11/01503 FUL OS 1 Arosa Drive, Malvern SWS Erection of detached dwelling Malvern Malvern Chase 1 1 27/02/2012 27/02/2015 1 0 0 Upton Upon Upton and 11/01584 FUL C 11 New Street, Upton-upon-Severn SWS Convert veterinary practice into four flats 4 3 31/01/2012 31/01/2015 0 0 4 Severn Hanley 11/01596 FUL UC 71 Court Road, Malvern SWS Two storey detached dwelling Malvern Malvern Chase 1 1 16/02/2012 16/02/2015 0 1 0

Extension of time limit to commence development on 11/01641 OEX OS Greenhill Springs, Kyrewood Road, Tenbury Wells SWS Tenbury Tenbury 3 3 18/01/2012 18/01/2015 3 0 0 application 08/01789/OUT. Proposed three dwellings

11/01720 FUL OS The Art Studio, Crown East Lane, Lower Broadheath SWS Change of use to residential unit and internal renovation Broadheath Broadheath 1 1 04/10/2012 04/10/2015 1 0 0 Alfrick and 12/00007 FUL OS The Older Cider House, Chapel Lane, Bransford SWS Conversion of former cider house to dwelling Bransford 1 1 05/03/2012 05/03/2015 1 0 0 Leigh Reserved Matters application for erection of equestrian Court Farm,Jennett Tree Lane,Callow 12/00016 REM OS SWS workers dwelling following outline application Powick Powick 1 1 15/02/2012 15/02/2015 1 0 0 End,Worcestershire,WR2 4UE 10/01498/OUT Change of use of upper floors B1 (office) use to C3 12/00032 FUL C 105 Barnards Green Road, Malvern SWS Malvern Malvern Chase 1 1 29/02/2012 15/02/2015 0 0 1 (residential use) Extension of time limit to commence development on 12/00060 PEX OS 8 Victoria Road, Malvern SWS application 09/00090/FUL for the extension to existing flats Malvern Malvern Priory 2 2 22/02/2012 22/02/2015 2 0 0 to form 2 additional flats Malvern 12/00083 FUL OS Rear of 9 North End Lane, Malvern SWS Proposed new detached dwelling Malvern 1 1 02/03/2012 02/03/2015 1 0 0 Pickersleigh 12/00088 FUL C Rear of 229 Worcester Road, Malvern SWS Proposed one bedroom flat Malvern Malvern Link 1 1 19/03/2012 19/03/2015 0 0 1

*Expiry dates only apply to outstanding sites (OS) where development has yet to commence **Includes demolitions and net gains/losses from change of use and conversions sites 3 of 9 pages APPENDIX B Housing Land Supply Monitor 2014 - Commitments List

Application Site Gross Net Decision O/S U/C Comp Type Status Address Description Parish Ward Expiry Date* No Type Units Units Date 2013-14 2013-14 2013-14 12/00119 FUL OS 3 North Hill Gardens, Malvern SWS Erection of dwelling Malvern Malvern West 1 1 19/03/2012 19/03/2015 1 0 0 12/00136 FUL OS Saxons Lode Farm, Saxons Lode, Uckinghall SWS Conversion of redundant farm building to one dwelling unit Ripple Ripple 1 1 19/03/2012 19/03/2015 1 0 0 Erection of two storey dwelling, detached garage and 12/00241 FUL OS Coach House, Kings End Road, Powick SWS Powick Powick 1 1 14/09/2012 14/09/2015 1 0 0 associated works Application for certificate of lawful development of new Alfrick and 12/00242 CLE C Land adj Owls Roost, Chapel Lane, Bransford SWS Bransford 1 1 03/04/2012 03/04/2015 0 0 1 bungalow Leigh 12/00263 FUL C 1 & 2 Upper Green, St Michaels, Tenbury SWS Proposed replacement dwelling Tenbury Tenbury 1 -1 27/04/2012 27/04/2015 0 0 1 Upton Upon Upton and 12/00325 FUL UC 11 Court Street, Upton-upon-Severn SWS Change of use from business (A1) to residential (C3) 1 1 07/06/2012 07/06/2015 0 1 0 Severn Hanley 12/00327 FUL OS Land adj to Yew Tree Cottage, Sinton Green, Hallow SWS Proposed new dwelling following demolition of outbuildings Grimley Hallow 1 1 03/12/2012 03/12/2015 1 0 0

Certificate of lawfulness of existing use of the flat as an 12/00329 CLE C The Flat, Goodyears Farm, Rectory Lane, Shrawley SWS Shrawley Baldwin 1 1 29/05/2012 29/05/2015 0 0 1 independent unit of permanent residential accommodation

Conversion of Salvation House from 1 no. to 2 no. 12/00401 FUL OS Land to the West of Ranelagh Road, Malvern LWS dwellings, erection of 2 no. garages and 2 no. dwellings to Malvern Malvern Link 5 3 20/12/2013 20/12/2016 5 0 0 replace an existing garage within the site Woodbury 12/00425 FUL UC The Granary, Worcester Road, Great Witley SWS Erection of three bedroomed bungalow Great Witley 1 1 25/06/2012 25/06/2015 0 1 0 Ward Change of use to Animal Rescue Centre, including 12/00434 FUL OS The Holdings, Broomhall Lane, Broomhall, Worcester SWS kennels, ancillary building, conversion of barn to offices Kempsey Kempsey 1 0 08/10/2012 08/10/2015 1 0 0 and change of use of farmhouse to staff accommodation

12/00445 FUL C Grassendale House, 3 Victoria Road, Malvern SWS Change of use of childrens nursery to residential unit Malvern Malvern Priory 1 1 01/06/2012 01/06/2015 0 0 1 Replacement bungalow with detached garage (amended Upton and 12/00448 FUL C Avenue Riding Centre, Hanley Road, Welland SWS Hanley Castle 1 0 02/11/2012 02/11/2015 0 0 1 scheme) Hanley Internal alterations to form 1 additional one-bedroom 12/00496 FUL OS Wells House, Holywell Road, Malvern SWS Malvern Malvern Wells 1 1 29/06/2012 29/09/2015 1 0 0 dwelling 12/00501 FUL UC Eastgrove Farm, Sankyns Green, Little Witley SWS Conversion of barn to create new unit 2 Shrawley Baldwin 1 1 24/05/2012 24/05/2015 0 1 0 Alfrick and 12/00562 FUL C Bank House Bowling Club, Bransford LWS Rural exception site proposal for 10 new homes (RSL) Bransford 10 10 20/12/2012 20/12/2015 0 0 10 Leigh Dwelling for a rural worker, vehicular access, detached 12/00571 FUL UC Land at Newtown Farm, Romers Common, Bockleton SWS Bockleton Tenbury 1 1 13/08/2012 13/08/2015 0 1 0 double and curtilage works Extension of time limit to commence development on 12/00578 PEX OS Ivydene Hall & Summerside, Albert Road North, Malvern SWS application 09/00294/FUL - 3 No five bedroom terraced Malvern Malvern Priory 3 3 28/08/2012 28/08/2015 3 0 0 houses Outline application for the development of land for up to 45 Land At (Os 5921 6771),Oldwood Road,Tenbury LWS dwellings (of which 12 are affordable and 6 are for social 12/00659 OUT OS Tenbury Tenbury 45 45 30/09/2013 30/09/2016 45 0 0 Wells,Worcestershire (SWDP) rent); sewage pumping station; access roads; footpaths; garages; public open space.

Demolition of existing single storey extension to existing The Royal Oak, Oak Row/Oak Street, Upton-upon- Upton Upon Upton and 12/00687 FUL OS SWS building. Construction of two 2 bedroomed houses 2 2 08/08/2012 08/08/2015 2 0 0 Severn Severn Hanley terraced with existing building (containing two flats) 12/00691 FUL C 27 King Edwards Road, Malvern SWS Erection of dwelling Malvern Wells Malvern Wells 1 1 04/07/2012 04/07/2012 0 0 1 12/00697 FUL C Flat 2, 131 Barnards Green Road, Malvern SWS Change of use from office back to residential flat Malvern Malvern Chase 1 1 21/06/2012 21/06/2015 0 0 1

Warehouse and Cider House, Church Street, Tenbury Conversion of Old Cider House to three self contained 12/00698 FUL C SWS Tenbury Tenbury 3 3 13/06/2013 13/06/2016 0 0 3 Wells dwellings with amenity space and car parking

Application for a Lawful Development Certificate for an 12/00756 CLE C Hooze Farm, Eldersfield SWS Eldersfield Longdon 1 1 08/10/2012 08/10/2015 0 0 1 existing use for the continued use of building as residential

12/00771 FUL UC Woodbridge Farm, Rectory Lane, Guarlford, Malvern SWS Dwelling for agricultural worker Malvern Malvern Chase 1 1 15/01/2013 15/01/2016 0 1 0 Conversion of former public house and existing flats to 12/00779 FUL OS The Tavern, Tavern Lane, Newnham Bridge, WR15 8LR SWS Knighton on Teme Lindridge 2 0 01/08/2012 01/08/2015 2 0 0 form 2 dwellings Alfrick and 12/00793 FUL UC St Marys Church, Knightsford Bridge, Knightwick SWS Conversion of church into 3 bedroom dwelling Doddenham 1 1 10/09/2012 10/09/2015 0 1 0 Leigh

*Expiry dates only apply to outstanding sites (OS) where development has yet to commence **Includes demolitions and net gains/losses from change of use and conversions sites 4 of 9 pages APPENDIX B Housing Land Supply Monitor 2014 - Commitments List

Application Site Gross Net Decision O/S U/C Comp Type Status Address Description Parish Ward Expiry Date* No Type Units Units Date 2013-14 2013-14 2013-14 Proposed replacement of fire damaged farmhouse with 12/00804 FUL C Bradfords Farm, Castlemorton SWS Castlemorton Morton 1 1 28/08/2012 28/08/2015 0 0 1 four bedroomed dwelling. Change of use and alterations to existing C2 residential 12/00837 FUL OS Sheffield House, 36 Court Road, Malvern LWS Malvern Malvern Chase 6 6 31/07/2012 31/07/2015 6 0 0 institution to create 6 self contained C3 flats Outline application for residential development of 44 12/00867 OUT OS LWS Tenbury Tenbury 44 44 29/06/2012 13/08/2016 44 0 0 Land at (OS 5921 6771), Oldwood Road, Tenbury Wells dwellings (including 18 affordable dwellings) Change of use of Pickersleigh Community Centre to two Malvern 12/00907 FUL C 6-7 Baxters Walk, Malvern SWS Malvern 2 2 17/08/2012 17/08/2015 0 0 2 residential (former use) dwellings Pickersleigh Change of use of existing 'stable block' and associated 12/00916 FUL C Former Garages at Viewfield, Como Road, Malvern SWS Malvern Malvern Priory 1 1 14/08/2012 14/08/2015 0 0 1 alterations for form single dwelling Conversion of two lower ground floors and upper floors 12/00920 FUL OS 211-213 Wells Road, Malvern SWS Malvern Wells Malvern Wells 4 3 21/08/2012 21/08/2015 4 0 0 (first and second) into apartments 12/00965 FUL C Church Farm, Hanley Willliam SWS Siting of chalet for residential occupation Hanley Teme Valley 1 1 03/07/2013 03/07/2016 0 0 1 Community Centre with multi purpose nursery space, Malvern 12/00968 FUL C Land at (OS 7891 4622), Pickersleigh Road, Malvern SWS Malvern 1 1 24/08/2012 24/08/2015 0 0 1 reception, offices and caretaker's flat Pickersleigh Change of use of house from guest house (C1) to Alfrick and 12/00970 FUL C Croft House, Bransford, Worcestershire SWS Bransford 1 1 23/08/2012 23/08/2015 0 0 1 residential use (C3) Leigh 12/00973 FUL OS Land adj New Inn, Sinton Green, Hallow SWS Erection of 5 bed unit with access and garaged parking Grimley Hallow 1 1 17/10/2013 17/10/2016 1 0 0

12/00976 FUL UC Bush Farm, Bush Lane, Callow End SWS Conversion of barns to 4 dwellings, revised scheme Powick Powick 4 4 30/01/2014 30/01/2017 0 4 0 Malvern 12/00979 FUL UC Pickersleigh Court, North End Lane, Malvern SWS Residential development of 4 houses Malvern 4 4 02/10/2012 02/10/2015 0 4 0 Pickersleigh Upton Upon Upton and 12/00995 FUL OS 44a Backfields Lane, Upton upon Severn SWS Erection of one live/work unit 1 1 18/07/2013 18/07/2016 1 0 0 Severn Hanley 12/01017 FUL OS 47 Cowleigh Bank, Malvern SWS Construction of detached bungalow Malvern Malvern West 1 1 20/09/2012 20/09/2015 1 0 0 Extension of time limit to commence development on 12/01021 PEX OS Lady Key, Holly Green, Upton-upon-Severn SWS Ripple Ripple 1 1 07/09/2012 07/09/2015 1 0 0 application 08/01953/FUL to erect house in garden Stoke Bliss and Kyre Village Hall, Stoke Bliss, 12/01046 FUL UC SWS Conversion of village hall to two dwelling Stoke Bliss Tenbury 2 2 15/10/2012 15/10/2015 0 2 0 Worcestershire 12/01072 FUL UC Plot 17 Woodbury Park, Holt Heath SWS Erection of dwelling Holt Baldwin 1 1 11/03/2013 11/03/2016 0 1 0 Outline application for residential development of up to 50 12/01087 OUT OS LWS Welland Morton 50 50 20/01/2014 20/01/2017 50 0 0 Land at Lawn Farm, Drake Street, Welland houses 12/01094 FUL OS Land, 49A Cowleigh Road, Malvern SWS Two storey detached dwelling Malvern Malvern West 1 1 24/09/2012 24/09/2015 1 0 0 12/01105 FUL OS The Lamb Inn, 87 West Malvern Road, Malvern SWS Proposed construction of 2 two bedroomed dwellings West Malvern Malvern West 2 2 20/12/2012 20/12/2015 2 0 0 Rowanwood,Bell Lane,Lower 12/01138 FUL C SWS Erection of 4 dwellings Broadheath Broadheath 4 3 04/10/2012 04/10/2015 0 0 4 Broadheath,Worcestershire,WR2 6RR 12/01139 FUL C The Knoll Bungalow, Clifton on Teme SWS Replacement dwelling Lower Sapey Teme Valley 1 0 22/11/2012 22/11/2015 0 0 1 Proposed barn conversion to residential dwelling with Clifton Upon 12/01144 FUL UC Aytons Heath Barn Clifton On Teme,Worcestershire SWS Teme Valley 1 1 28/09/2012 28/09/2015 0 1 0 annexe Teme Horsham Court Stables, Hill Top Farm, Horsham Lane, Conversion of existing stables to dwelling (and 1 new 12/01159 FUL C SWS Martley Martley 2 2 08/11/2012 08/11/2015 0 0 2 Horsham dwelling) Internal alterations to form 1 no three bedroom apartment 12/01160 FUL C Wells House Chapel, Holywell Road, Malvern SWS in lieu of 2 no two bedroom apartments. Conversion of Malvern Wells Malvern Wells 2 1 06/11/2012 06/11/2015 0 0 2 Holywell Chapel into four bedroom dwelling Eastry 3 College Grove Malvern, Worcestershire WR14 Proposed conversion of existing outbuilding into studio 12/01175 FUL C SWS Malvern Malvern Priory 1 1 15/10/2012 15/10/2015 0 0 1 3HP apartment 12/01201 FUL OS 8 Somers Road, Malvern SWS Erection of 4 dwellings Malvern Malvern Link 4 4 23/04/2013 23/04/2016 4 0 0 Malvern Dyson 12/01240 FUL C North Site Phase 7, Leigh Sinton Road, Malvern LWS Erection of 58 dwelling houses and public open space Malvern 58 58 10/04/2013 19/04/2016 0 0 58 Perrins

Construction of two detached dwellings involving 12/01320 FUL C Welland Garage, Gloucester Road, Welland SWS demolition of existing garage following Outline Planning Welland Morton 2 2 19/12/2012 19/12/2015 0 0 2 Permission 08/01959/OUT, renewed 11/00984/OEX Alfrick and 12/01325 OUT OS Brockamin Farm, Brockamin, Leigh SWS Erection of a dwellinghouse for a farm manager Leigh 1 1 08/11/2012 08/11/2015 1 0 0 Leigh Application for a Lawful Development Certificate for an 12/01343 CLE C Lieranta, Worcester Road, Great Witley SWS Great Witley Woodbury 1 1 07/01/2013 07/01/2016 0 0 1 existing use - use as a single dwelling

*Expiry dates only apply to outstanding sites (OS) where development has yet to commence **Includes demolitions and net gains/losses from change of use and conversions sites 5 of 9 pages APPENDIX B Housing Land Supply Monitor 2014 - Commitments List

Application Site Gross Net Decision O/S U/C Comp Type Status Address Description Parish Ward Expiry Date* No Type Units Units Date 2013-14 2013-14 2013-14 Upton and 12/01354 FUL UC Severn End Hanley Castle Worcestershire WR8 0BW SWS Barn Conversion to provide 3 holiday lets and 1 dwelling. Hanley Castle 1 1 10/01/2013 10/01/2016 0 1 0 Hanley 12/01357 REM OS Adj to 24 St Peters Road, Malvern SWS Construction of detached dwelling Malvern Malvern West 1 1 23/11/2012 23/11/2015 1 0 0 Extension of time limit to commence development on 12/01380 PEX UC 2 Orchard Road, Malvern LWS application 10/00201/FUL - demolition of existing building Malvern Malvern Priory 8 7 22/01/2013 22/01/2016 0 8 0 and construction of 8 apartments Application for a Lawful Development Certificate for an existing use of dwelling without compliance with Alfrick and 12/01414 CLE C Top Knapp, Bridges Stone, Alfrick SWS Alfrick 1 1 11/12/2013 0 0 1 Agricultural Occupancy Condition 2 of Planning Leigh Permission 275/65 Sub division of farmhouse, conversion of outbuildings, 12/01566 FUL OS Downend Farm, Long Green, Forthampton SWS Eldersfield Longdon 5 4 01/03/2013 01/03/2016 5 0 0 byre and barns to provide 5 residential units 12/01575 FUL C Baxhill Nursery, 179 Worcester Road, Malvern SWS Change of use to single dwelling Malvern Malvern Link 1 0 19/02/2013 19/02/2016 0 0 1 Application for a Lawful Development Certificate for the 12/01600 CLE C Tudor Rose Nursery, Dunley, Worcestershire, DY13 0TT SWS Astley & Dunley Baldwin 1 1 17/12/2012 17/12/2015 0 0 1 continued use of wooden chalet as a dwelling Re-development of 2 no. buildings to form 9. no residential 12/01605 FUL UC 137-141 Church Street, Malvern LWS Malvern Malvern Priory 9 9 16/04/2013 16/04/2016 0 5 4 properties Malvern Dyson 12/01625 FUL C 50 Upper Howsell Road, Malvern SWS Change of use to residential Malvern 1 1 24/01/2013 24/01/2016 0 0 1 Perrins

North Site Phase 6 (Malvern Vale), Leigh Sinton Road, Application for all Reserved matters - 26 no 1 and 2 Malvern Dyson 12/01650 REM OS LPS Malvern 26 26 12/04/2013 12/04/2016 26 0 0 Malvern bedroom apartments, 3 retail units Perrins 12/01654 FUL OS Land adj Stonecroft, Holt Heath SWS Erection of a 5 bedroomed detached dwelling Holt Baldwin 1 1 26/03/2013 26/03/2016 1 0 0 12/01658 FUL OS Lower Swell Farm, Longdon Marsh SWS Proposed conversion of barns to single dwelling Longdon Longdon 1 1 21/01/2013 21/01/2016 1 0 0 LWS Residential development of 28 dwellings, including 11 Allowed on 12/01661 FUL UC Land adjacent Green Hedges, Claphill Lane, Rushwick Rushwick Broadheath 28 28 07/02/2013 0 14 14 (SWDP) affordable dwellings Appeal 12/01673 FUL OS Ryall Court Farm, Ryall Court Lane, Holly Green SWS Proposed Agricultural Worker's Dwelling Ripple Ripple 1 1 28/03/2013 28/03/2016 1 0 0 12/01689 FUL OS Goodyears Farm, Rectory Lane, Shrawley SWS Replacement dwelling Shrawley Baldwin 1 0 26/02/2013 26/02/2016 1 0 0 Malvern 12/01703 FUL C Land rear of 26-30 Mountbatten Road, Malvern SWS 2 No. 1 bedroomed affordable single storey dwelling Malvern 2 2 18/04/2013 18/04/2016 0 0 2 Pickersleigh Proposed affordable house development of 2 no. semi Malvern 12/01704 FUL OS Land at (OS 7924 4676), Wren Avenue, Malvern SWS Malvern 2 2 15/05/2013 15/05/2016 2 0 0 detached 3 bedroom houses, Pickersleigh Land at (OS 7936 4671) Adjacent 250 Elgar Avenue, Malvern 12/01706 FUL UC SWS Proposed 3 bedroom affordable dwelling Malvern 1 1 05/02/2013 05/02/2016 0 1 0 Malvern Pickersleigh Redundant road/land behind Orford Way and Elgar Proposed affordable housing - 5 no 3 bedroom 5 person Malvern 12/01717 FUL UC LWS Malvern 5 5 20/06/2013 20/06/2016 0 2 3 Avenue, Malvern semi-detached and terraced houses Pickersleigh Upton and 12/01723 FUL UC Coverside Farm, Hanley Swan SWS Erection of replacement dwelling Hanley Castle 1 0 14/03/2013 14/03/2016 0 1 0 Hanley Demolition of existing property and outbuildings and 13/00012 FUL OS Chestnut Hill, Green Lane, Malvern SWS Malvern Wells Malvern Wells 3 2 02/04/2013 02/04/2016 3 0 0 construction of 3 energy efficient houses Upton Upon Upton and 13/00033 FUL C Land rear of 57 Old Street, Upton SWS Two semi-detached dwellings 2 2 23/05/2013 23/05/2016 0 0 2 Severn Hanley 13/00058 FUL OS Westwood Farm, Mamble SWS Replacement dwelling Mamble Lindridge 1 0 14/06/2013 14/06/2016 1 0 0 13/00059 FUL OS Hillside, Broadwas, Worcestershire, WR6 5NL SWS Replacement mobile home with dwelling Broadwas Broadheath 1 0 06/08/2013 06/08/2016 1 0 0 Land at (OS 8189 5091) Adjacent the Crown Public Residential development of 45 dwellings (including 18 13/00069 FUL OS LWS Powick Powick 45 45 10/01/2014 10/01/2017 45 0 0 House, Malvern affordable dwellings) 13/00077 FUL OS Mythe Bridge House, Ledbury Road, Tewkesbury SWS Demolition and Replacement dwelling house Bushley Longdon 1 0 30/09/2013 30/09/2016 1 0 0 LWS 13/00087 FUL UC Land adj The Crown, Martley Erection of 51 dwellings Martley Martley 51 51 18/12/2013 18/12/2016 0 51 0 (SWDP) Proposed dwelling together with new garage for existing 13/00090 FUL OS Land at 102 Longridge Road, Malvern SWS Malvern Malvern Chase 1 1 28/06/2013 28/06/2016 1 0 0 property Replacement dwelling and erection of detached garage, 13/00138 FUL OS Old Hills Cottage, 112 Old Hills, Callow End SWS Powick Powick 1 0 05/04/2013 05/04/2016 1 0 0 revised scheme Alfrick and 13/00145 FUL OS Brockamin Farm, Brockamin, Leigh SWS Erection of a dwelling house for a farm manager Leigh 1 1 05/04/2013 05/04/2016 1 0 0 Leigh 13/00173 FUL UC The Retreat, Ockeridge, Wichenford SWS Replacement dwelling Little Witley Woodbury 1 0 18/06/2013 18/06/2016 0 1 0 13/00189 FUL OS Old Forge Works, Kinnersley, Severn Stoke SWS Single dwelling to replace redundant workshop Severn Stoke Kempsey 1 1 14/06/2013 14/06/2016 1 0 0 Extension of time limit to commence development on 13/00198 OEX OS Rose Cottage, Grimley, Worcester SWS application 09/01030/OUT. Erection of replacement Grimley Hallow 1 0 02/04/2013 02/04/2016 1 0 0 dwelling Change of use from old doctors clinic back to single Upton Upon Upton and 13/00217 FUL C 69 Old Street, Upton upon Severn, WR8 0HN SWS 1 1 05/04/2013 05/04/2016 0 0 1 residential dwelling Severn Hanley

*Expiry dates only apply to outstanding sites (OS) where development has yet to commence **Includes demolitions and net gains/losses from change of use and conversions sites 6 of 9 pages APPENDIX B Housing Land Supply Monitor 2014 - Commitments List

Application Site Gross Net Decision O/S U/C Comp Type Status Address Description Parish Ward Expiry Date* No Type Units Units Date 2013-14 2013-14 2013-14 Demolition of units 3a, 3b and 4 fronting Severn Drive. Units 1-4 Haywards Yard, Court Street, Upton-upon- Upton Upon Upton and 13/00222 FUL C SWS Conversion of unit 1 & 2 fronting Court Street to form 2 no. 2 2 23/04/2013 23/04/2016 0 0 2 Severn Severn Hanley dwellings and associated works Conversion and refurbishment of a redundant coach 13/00270 FUL UC The Bridge Hotel, 87 Teme Street SWS Tenbury Tenbury 1 1 15/04/2013 15/04/2016 0 1 0 house to provide living accommodation 13/00310 FUL C Dorothys Rock, Rhyse Lane, Tenbury Wells SWS Replacement dwelling (retrospective) Tenbury Tenbury 1 0 30/05/2013 30/05/2013 0 0 1 Application for a Lawful Development Certificate for the 13/00319 CPU C 5-7 Abbey Road, Malvern SWS Malvern Malvern Priory 1 1 09/05/2013 09/05/2016 0 0 1 change of use of upper floor of building to residential unit 13/00348 FUL OS Lower Town Farm, Berrington SWS Conversion of existing stone barn to a dwelling Tenbury Tenbury 1 1 05/02/2014 05/02/2017 1 0 0 13/00356 FUL UC Threeways, Naunton, Upton upon Severn SWS Replacement dwelling Ripple Ripple 1 0 29/07/2013 29/07/2016 0 1 0 Variation of condition 2 on planning permission 12/00511/FUL for Demolition of existing buildings, 13/00388 S73 OS Hampton House, Abbey Road, Malvern LWS conversion of Hampton House to 7 apartments and Malvern Malvern Priory 12 12 25/03/2014 25/03/2017 12 0 0 erection of a courtyard of 5 dwellings - revision to approved scheme. Partial demolition and change of use from former licensed 13/00403 FUL OS The Lamb Inn, 87 West Malvern Road, Malvern SWS premises to single dwelling. Construction of 2 two bed West Malvern Malvern West 4 4 22/08/2013 22/08/2016 4 0 0 dwellings and 1 three bed dwelling Outline application for the erection of up to 120 dwellings, 13/00417 OUT OS Land at (OS 8552 4989) Main Road, Kempsey LWS Kempsey Kempsey 120 120 12/12/2013 12/12/2016 120 0 0 parking, public open space 13/00438 FUL UC Cherry View, Firth Common, Eardiston SWS Erection of detached dwelling Lindridge Lindridge 1 0 23/07/2013 23/07/2016 0 1 0 13/00448 FUL OS 114 Poolbrook Road, Malvern SWS Change of use to two residential units Malvern Malvern Chase 2 2 10/06/2013 10/06/2016 2 0 0

Erection of three detached dwellings with garages and 13/00553 FUL UC Land adj The Highways, Worcester Road, Great Witley SWS Great Witley Woodbury 3 3 04/07/2013 04/07/2016 0 1 0 new access and demolition of derelict double garage 13/00580 FUL OS Kenwyn, Brockhill Road, Malvern SWS Dwelling with garage with associated landscaping West Malvern Malvern West 1 0 28/06/2013 28/09/2016 1 0 0 Extension of time limit to commence development on 13/00582 PEX OS Christian Science Society, Albert Park Road, Malvern LWS 09/00666. Demolition of existing timber frame building and Malvern Malvern Link 6 6 09/10/2013 09/10/2016 6 0 0 erection of 6 no apartments Demolition of existing timber framed dwelling, Erection of a 13/00611 FUL OS 17 Kings End Road, Powick SWS Powick Powick 1 0 03/09/2013 03/09/2016 1 0 0 detached 1.5 storey dwellling 13/00616 FUL UC Land at (OS 7959 4580), Bellars Lane, Malvern SWS Erection of detached dwelling Malvern Malvern Chase 1 1 04/10/2013 04/10/2016 0 1 0 Temporary residential structure as permanent dwelling 13/00628 FUL C Six Acres Barn, Sutton, Worcestershire SWS Kyre Tenbury 1 1 26/11/2013 26/11/2016 0 0 1 and erection of barn Residential use of former Forge retrospective and 13/00657 FUL C The Old Forge, Old Malvern Road, Powick SWS Powick Powick 1 1 17/07/2013 17/07/2016 0 0 1 continuous Alteration to existing Bungalow with proposed new Upton Upon Upton and 13/00676 FUL UC 17 Minge Lane, Upton upon Severn SWS 1 1 16/08/2013 16/08/2016 0 1 0 dwelling to rear Severn Hanley 13/00742 FUL UC Pensax C of E Primary School, Pensax Common SWS Conversion of disused primary school to a single dwelling Pensax Woodbury 1 1 24/07/2013 24/07/2016 0 1 0 Erection of agricultural building, and farmworker's dwelling 13/00768 FUL OS Little Lambswick Farm House, Eardiston SWS Lindridge Lindridge 1 1 23/08/2013 23/08/2016 1 0 0 and access track 13/00781 FUL OS Duriston, 1 St Andrews Road, Malvern SWS New detached dwelling Malvern Malvern Chase 1 1 23/09/2013 23/09/2016 1 0 0 Conversion of an old Dairy building into a dwelling and 13/00808 FUL UC Woodlands Farm, Astley Burf SWS Astley & Dunley Baldwin 1 1 15/10/2013 15/10/2016 0 1 0 garage addition Part demolish and extend the existing bungalow to create 13/00814 FUL UC The Vineyards, 23 Bowling Green Road, Powick SWS two detached bungalows. Two detached garages and Powick Powick 2 1 19/09/2013 19/09/2016 0 2 0 boundary fences 13/00825 FUL OS The Shrubbery, Happy Valley, Malvern SWS Erection of a 3 bed detached dwelling Malvern Malvern Priory 1 1 04/11/2013 04/11/2016 1 0 0 Demolition of existing dwelling and construction of a 13/00826 FUL UC Little Birches, Bockleton SWS Bockleton Tenbury Ward 1 0 11/10/2013 11/10/2016 0 1 0 replacement dwelling Change of use from single dwelling with annexed 13/00862 FUL OS The Post House, Ham Lane, Powick SWS accommodation to B&B with annexed self catering holiday Powick Powick -1 -1 06/11/2013 06/11/2016 -1 0 0 home The Manor Farm,Oldwood Conversion of brick barn into a four bedroom unrestricted 13/00880 FUL OS SWS Tenbury Tenbury 1 1 03/09/2013 03/09/2016 1 0 0 Common,Worcestershire,WR15 8TF residential dwelling. Erection of a dwelling with attached garage and 13/00884 FUL OS The Retreat,Grimley,Worcestershire SWS Grimley Hallow 1 1 05/09/2013 05/09/2016 1 0 0 agricultural store 13/00887 FUL OS Land adj 81 Old Hollow, Malvern SWS New dwelling Malvern Malvern West 1 1 29/10/2013 29/10/2016 1 0 0

*Expiry dates only apply to outstanding sites (OS) where development has yet to commence **Includes demolitions and net gains/losses from change of use and conversions sites 7 of 9 pages APPENDIX B Housing Land Supply Monitor 2014 - Commitments List

Application Site Gross Net Decision O/S U/C Comp Type Status Address Description Parish Ward Expiry Date* No Type Units Units Date 2013-14 2013-14 2013-14 Application for a lawful development certificate for an Shenley Stores, Bransford Road, Rushwick, 13/00919 CLE C SWS existing use or operation to revert the property back to Rushwick Broadheath 1 1 16/09/2013 16/09/2016 0 0 1 Worcestershire, WR2 5TA being solely residential. Extension of time limit to commence development on 13/00948 PEX OS Land at Baskerville Hall, Cowleigh Bank, Malvern SWS Malvern Malvern West 1 1 01/10/2013 01/10/2016 1 0 0 application 10/01197/FUL erection of detached bungalow Re-development and change of use of existing buildings 13/00958 FUL OS Gas Works Site, Hospital Lane, Powick SWS Powick Powick 3 3 15/11/2013 15/11/2016 3 0 0 to form 3 no residential homes Proposed new house. Demolition of garage and altered Upton and 13/00959 FUL OS Rear of 32 Quay Lane, Hanley Castle SWS Hanley Castle 1 1 23/10/2013 23/10/2016 1 0 0 access Hanley Change of use of existing office accommodation (A2) 13/00961 FUL OS 90/92 Worcester Road, Malvern SWS including associated minor alterations to provide single Malvern Malvern Priory 1 1 11/09/2013 11/09/2016 1 0 0 residential flat (C3) Malvern Dyson 13/00970 FUL OS 31A Upper Howsell Road, Malvern SWS Demolition of storage building and erection of 1 dwelling Malvern 1 1 30/12/2013 30/12/2016 1 0 0 Perrins 13/01031 FUL UC 281 Pickersleigh Road, Malvern SWS Erection of detached dwelling Malvern Pickersleigh 1 1 11/10/2013 11/10/2016 0 1 0 Outline application for 3 detached dwellings with 13/01033 OUT OS Land off Ankderine Road, Lower Broadheath SWS Broadheath Broadheath 3 3 12/12/2013 12/12/2016 3 0 0 asscoiated parking Land rear of New House/Motrose Cottage, Welland Upton and 13/01045 FUL OS SWS Erection of 2 no. dwellings and associated private drive Hanley Castle 2 2 14/02/2014 14/02/2017 2 0 0 Road, Hanley Swan Hanley 13/01055 FUL C The Coach House, 17A Fountain Court, Great Witley SWS Conversion of derelict building to residential Great Witley Woodbury 1 1 05/11/2013 05/11/2016 0 0 1 Erection of detached dwelling. Demolition of part of 13/01056 FUL OS 419 Pickersleigh Road, Malvern SWS Malvern Malvern Chase 1 1 03/01/2014 03/01/2017 1 0 0 outbuildings Change of disused hotel Coventry barn for 3 new two 13/01091 FUL OS The Old School House, Severn Stoke SWS storey residential dwellings, demolition of single storey Severn Stoke Kempsey 3 3 12/11/2013 12/11/2016 3 0 0 Cedar Lode Alfrick and 13/01094 OUT OS Fir Tree House, Bransford SWS Erection of a bungalow with accommodation in the roof Bransford 1 1 09/12/2013 09/12/2016 1 0 0 Leigh Extension of time limit to commence development n 13/01103 PEX UC Lake Cottage, Chambers Court, Longdon SWS Longdon Longdon 2 2 15/10/2013 15/10/2016 0 1 1 09/01475/PEX for erection of 2 live/work units Upton Upon Upton and 13/01120 FUL OS Cowhills Farm, Wheatley lane, Upton-upon-Severn SWS Replacement farmhouse 1 0 07/02/2014 07/02/2017 1 0 0 Severn Hanley Variation of condition 2 on planning permission 13/01128 S73 UC 2 The Dog, Baughton, Earls Croome SWS 13/00531/S73 for "conversion and extensions to form two Earls Croome Ripple 2 1 18/10/2013 18/10/2016 0 2 0 dwellings" Conversion of outbuilding located within the curtilage of a 13/01164 FUL OS The Pottery, 18 Teme Street, Tenbury Wells SWS Listed Building to a dwelling including reinstatement of Tenbury Tenbury 1 1 18/11/2013 18/11/2016 1 0 0 lean-to 13/01166 FUL OS Land at (Os 7752 4538), Wells Road, Malvern SWS Erection of extension to provide two apartments Malvern Malvern Priory 2 2 01/11/2013 01/11/2016 2 0 0 Conversion of building into two bedroom apartment with 13/01205 FUL OS Crystal Mount, 59 Albert Road North, Malvern SWS Malvern Malvern Priory 1 1 13/11/2013 13/11/2016 1 0 0 courtyard 13/01210 FUL OS Wood Park Farm, Rochford SWS Conversion of redundant barn into farm owners residence Rochford Tenbury Wells 2 1 07/02/2014 07/02/2017 2 0 0 Outline application with all matters reserved by the 13/01223 OUT OS Eight Oaks Farm, Eight Oaks, Castlemorton SWS erection of an affordable home (to be long cabin/mobile Castlemorton Morton 1 1 20/03/2014 20/03/2017 1 0 0 home type dwelling) Change of use of a building and any land within its curtilage to a use falling within Class C3 (dwellinghouses) 13/01228 PDU OS Baynhall Farm, Main Road, Kempsey SWS Kempsey Kempsey 1 1 21/11/2013 21/11/2016 1 0 0 of the schedule to the Use Classes Order from a use falling within ba(a) (offices) of that Schedule

13/01246 OUT OS 6 Pound Bank Road, Malvern SWS Detached two bedroomed bungalow with parking Malvern Malvern Chase 1 1 08/01/2014 08/01/2017 1 0 0 13/01271 FUL OS Penrhyn, Grange Lane, Lower Broadheath SWS Proposed new dwelling Broadheath Broadheath 1 1 09/12/2013 09/12/2016 1 0 0 13/01302 FUL OS Land adj 86 Guarlford Road, Malvern SWS Erection of new dwelling Malvern Malvern Chase 1 1 04/12/2013 04/12/2016 1 0 0 Conversion of redundant agricultural building to single 13/01305 FUL OS 1 Old Road South, Kempsey SWS Kempsey Kempsey 1 1 20/12/2013 20/12/2016 1 0 0 dwelling (C3) Former Tennis Court Site Land at (OS 7763 4500), 13/01354 FUL OS SWS Erection of two dwellings Malvern Malvern Priory 2 2 20/01/2014 20/01/2017 2 0 0 College Road, Malvern Alfrick and 13/01361 FUL OS Lane End, Green Street, Lulsley SWS Replacement dwelling and garage Alfrick 1 0 19/12/2013 19/12/2016 1 0 0 Leigh

*Expiry dates only apply to outstanding sites (OS) where development has yet to commence **Includes demolitions and net gains/losses from change of use and conversions sites 8 of 9 pages APPENDIX B Housing Land Supply Monitor 2014 - Commitments List

Application Site Gross Net Decision O/S U/C Comp Type Status Address Description Parish Ward Expiry Date* No Type Units Units Date 2013-14 2013-14 2013-14 Conversion of 4 barns to create 1 office building and three 13/01467 FUL UC Greenhill Farm, Greenhill Lane, Hallow SWS dwellings. Relocation of barns A and C and removal of Hallow Hallow 3 3 28/02/2014 28/02/2017 0 3 0 Barn B Prior Notification of Change of Use under Class J (Office Alfrick and 13/01476 PDU OS Unit 4c, The Bruff Business Centre, Suckley LWS Suckley 7 7 11/12/2013 11/12/2016 7 0 0 to residential) Leigh 13/01485 FUL OS Old Tannery, Martley SWS Proposed new dwelling Martley Martley 1 1 13/01/2014 13/01/2017 1 0 0 13/01501 FUL OS Former Coach House at Glebe House, Bayton SWS Conversion of former coach house into a dwelling Bayton Lindridge 1 1 07/02/2014 07/02/2017 1 0 0 Land At (Os 7169 6148), Church Road, Clifton On Teme, Clifton Upon 13/01592 OUT OS SWS Erection of single dwelling Teme Valley 1 1 07/02/2014 07/02/2017 1 0 0 Worcestershire, Teme 14/00045 FUL OS 2 Highfield, Callow End SWS New house Powick Powick 1 1 11/03/2014 11/03/2017 1 0 0 14/00047 FUL OS Rear of 213-215 Worcester Road, Malvern SWS Erection of a single dwelling Malvern Malvern Link 1 1 28/02/2014 28/02/2017 1 0 0 Malvern 14/00082 FUL OS 204-207 Elgar Avenue, Malvern SWS Erection of 2 flats Malvern 2 2 28/02/2014 28/02/2017 2 0 0 Pickersleigh Change of use from 6 offices to an office/shop and 2 bed 14/00101 FUL OS 40 Teme Street, Tenbury Wells SWS Tenbury Tenbury 1 1 21/03/2014 21/03/2017 1 0 0 flat 14/00178 FUL OS Land at 20 Lower Montpelier Road, Malvern SWS Proposed residential unit West Malvern Malvern West 1 1 31/03/2014 31/03/2017 1 0 0 Demolition of existing single garage and the construction Malvern Dyson 14/00208 FUL OS 67 Upper Howsell Road, Malvern SWS Malvern 1 1 31/03/2014 31/03/2017 1 0 0 of three/four bedroomed dwelling Perrins TOTALS GROSS 700 260 198 TOTALS NET 673 172 184**

*Expiry dates only apply to outstanding sites (OS) where development has yet to commence **Includes demolitions and net gains/losses from change of use and conversions sites 9 of 9 pages APPENDIX C Housing Land Supply Monitor 2014 - Windfall Allowance Calculation Sites List (Small brownfield sites of 4 dwellings or less completed between 2006/07 and 2013/14)

Completion Application Application Site Gross Net Site Previous Status Address Description Parish Ward Year Reference Type Area Units Units Type Use 2006/07 05/00169 FUL C Little Witley Garage, Little Witley, Worcester Construction of 2 new dwellings 0.08 Little Witley Woodbury 2 2 SWS BB

2006/07 06/00490 FUL C 182 West Malvern Road, Malvern Change of use from existing holiday let to residential flat 0.05 West Malvern Malvern West 1 1 SWS BB

2006/07 05/00429 FUL C Rame Cabin, Birchwood House, Suckley Replacement house 0.22 Suckley Alfrick and Leigh 1 0 SWS BR

Clifton Upon 2006/07 05/00456 FUL C Yarnton House, Clifton-on-Teme, Worcester New detached replacement dwelling 0.27 Teme Valley 1 0 SWS BR Teme 2006/07 05/00722 FUL C Beaconsfield, 69 Graham Road, Malvern Alterations to provide two additional self-contained apartments 0.12 Malvern Malvern Priory 2 2 SWS BR

2006/07 03/01728 FUL C Building Plots, At De Walden Road, West Malvern Road, Malvern Construction of two detached chalet type dwellings including basement. 0.17 West Malvern Malvern West 2 2 SWS BR

2006/07 04/00703 FUL C The Gables, Bransford, Worcester Demolish existing house and erect replacement - resubmission of 04/00073/FUL 0.20 Bransford Leigh & Bransford 1 0 SWS BR

2006/07 04/01153 FUL C Land at (OS 8079 6803) No Name Cottage, Scots Lane Demolish existing dwelling and outbuilding and construct new cottage 0.17 Astley & Dunley Baldwin 1 0 SWS BR

2006/07 06/00012 FUL C Units 1,2,3 & 4 The Green Stanford Bridge. Conversion of former farm buildings from offices to residential. 0.38 Shelsley Kings Teme Valley 4 4 SWS BO

2006/07 02/00485 FUL C Carters Cottage, Kingswood, Stanford Bridge Replacement Cottage 0.24 Shelsley Kings Woodbury 1 0 SWS BR

2006/07 03/00468 FUL C Land at Marsh Close, Malvern Three two bedroomed bungalows 0.05 Malvern Pickersleigh 3 3 SWS BR

2006/07 03/01240 FUL C The Haven, Old Storridge, Alfrick Replacement Bungalow 0.04 Alfrick Alfrick and Leigh 1 0 SWS BR

2006/07 03/01544 FUL C The Squirrels, 157 Wells Road, Malvern Demolition of existing dwelling and erection of replacement house. 0.35 Malvern Wells Malvern Wells 1 0 SWS BR

2006/07 04/01748 FUL C Old School House, Hanley Castle Reconstruction of existing outbuildings to form new 2 bedroom dwelling 0.28 Hanley Castle Upton and Hanley 1 1 SWS BR Upton Upon 2006/07 05/01163 FUL C Cromwell House, 20 Church Street, Upton-upon-Severn Restoration of first and second floors to residential 0.03 Upton and Hanley 2 2 SWS BS Severn 2006/07 04/00143 FUL C 12 Market Square, Tenbury Wells, Worcestershire Conversion of an existing traditional storage building to form a single one bedroom dwelling. 0.00 Tenbury Tenbury 1 1 SWS BW

2006/07 04/01417 FUL C Former Workshop, Windmill Lane, Kempsey Erection of chalet bungalow and double garage 0.05 Kempsey Kempsey 1 1 SWS BW

2006/07 05/01691 FUL C Kingsmead Kingswood Stanford Bridge Replacement of existing dwelling. 0.26 Shelsley Kings Teme Valley 1 0 SWS BR

2006/07 06/00337 FUL C Kingsmead, Kingswood, Stanford Bridge Replacement of existing dwelling 0.33 Shelsley Kings Teme Valley 1 0 SWS BR Lower 2006/07 06/01070 FUL C Woodend, Crown East Lane, Lower Broadheath Replacement dwelling and garage 0.23 Broadheath 1 0 SWS BR Broadheath 2006/07 06/01272 FUL C Land at (OS 7901 4648) Orford Way, Malvern Residential unit with a ground floor and first floor flat n/a Malvern Pickersleigh 2 2 SWS BR

2006/07 03/00641 FUL C 6 Lower Howsell Road, Malvern Conversion of furniture workshop to two bedsits 0.01 Malvern Malvern Link 2 2 SWS BS Conversion of first and second floors to create two flats from one, making one additional unit of Upton Upon 2006/07 05/01663 FUL C Cromwell House 20 Church Street Upton-Upon-Severn 0.03 Upton and Hanley 2 2 SWS BR accommodation. Severn 2006/07 03/01852 FUL C 225-227 Worcester Road, Malvern, Worcestershire Four flats to the rear. 0.04 Malvern Malvern Link 4 4 SWS BS Application to amend design of previously approved scheme for four houses (app No. 2006/07 05/01732 FUL C 58 Court Road Malvern 0.22 Malvern Malvern Chase 4 3 SWS BR 02/00766/FUL) 2006/07 06/00070 FUL C Knowle Farm, Suckley, Worcester. Amendment to planning permission MH05/01146/FUL - For a replacement dwelling and garage. 0.14 Suckley Alfrick and Leigh 1 0 SWS BR Proposed demolition of existing workshops and the erection of 2 No. semi-detached 3 bedroom, 2006/07 06/00525 FUL C Land South Of 95 & North Of 97 Main Road, Kempsey, Worcester 0.16 Kempsey Kempsey 4 4 SWS BI two storey houses and associated parking and 2 No. 4 bed detached 2 storey houses with 2006/07 Sub-Totals 48 36

C 4 4 SWS 2007/08 03/01710 FUL Aymestry School, Bromyard Road, Crown East, Cotheridge Conversion of school into 4 dwellings. 9.70 Rushwick Broadheath BB C 1 1 SWS 2007/08 04/01490 FUL 53 St Andrews Road, Malvern Conversion of coach house to provide one-bedroomed residential unit 0.07 Malvern Malvern Chase BB Upton Upon C 3 3 SWS 2007/08 04/01873 FUL Nixons Garage, Welland Road, Upton-upon-Severn Redevelopment of garage to provide three residential properties 0.38 Severn Upton and Hanley BB C 1 1 SWS 2007/08 05/00580 FUL The Old Village Hall, Shrawley Removal of redundant building and erection of a single detached dwelling 0.04 Shrawley Baldwin BB Demolition of existing bungalow and outbuildings and construction of new one and a half storey Upton Upon C 1 0 SWS 2007/08 05/01083 FUL Backgreen Covert, Longdon Heath house with garage 0.20 Severn Upton and Hanley BR C 1 0 SWS 2007/08 05/01361 FUL The Orchards, Martley Erection of bungalow to replace existing and relocation of access drive 0.35 Martley Martley BR C 2 1 SWS 2007/08 05/01503 FUL 137 Court Road Malvern Division of existing house and workshop into 2 No. cottages. 0.02 Malvern Malvern Chase BR Demolition of derelict cottage & erection of new cottage style residence complete with double C 1 0 SWS 2007/08 05/01628 FUL 164 Upper Welland Road Malvern garage. 0.10 Malvern Wells Malvern Wells BR C 1 0 SWS 2007/08 05/01735 FUL 1 Woodhall Farms Fox Lane Green Street Kempsey Replacement dwelling. 0.88 Kempsey Kempsey BR

Windfall Allowance Calculation - Sites List APPENDIX C Housing Land Supply Monitor 2014 - Windfall Allowance Calculation Sites List (Small brownfield sites of 4 dwellings or less completed between 2006/07 and 2013/14)

Completion Application Application Site Gross Net Site Previous Status Address Description Parish Ward Year Reference Type Area Units Units Type Use Renewal of Planning Permision MH01/00017/FUL for the erection of a replacement dwelling and C 1 0 SWS 2007/08 05/01749 FUL The Bungalow 99 Old Hills Callow End detached double garage 0.17 Powick Powick BR C 1 0 SWS 2007/08 06/00037 FUL Baynhall Garage, Main Road, Kempsey Variation to existing consent for a replacement dwelling (app no 04/0213/FUL) 0.03 Kempsey Kempsey BR C 1 0 SWS 2007/08 06/00106 FUL Willow End Cottage, Blackmore Park Road, Malvern. Replacement of existing sub-standard dwelling with new dwelling. 0.19 Hanley Castle Upton and Hanley BR C 1 0 SWS 2007/08 05/00642 FUL The High Ground Castlemorton Malvern Amendment to planning permission 05/00231/FUL Demolish bungalow and build house 0.34 Castlemorton Morton BR C 1 0 SWS 2007/08 05/00663 FUL Culverness Farm, Clows Top, Kidderminster Demolish existing house and construct new replacement dwelling (farmhouse) 0.35 Bayton Lindridge BR C 1 0 SWS 2007/08 05/00828 FUL Gold Hill, Doddenham, Broadwas Demolish existing house and erection of replacement 0.18 Doddenham Alfrick and Leigh BR C 1 0 SWS 2007/08 04/01856 FUL 54 Malvern Road, Powick Demolition of existing dwelling and erection of detached house with integral garage 0.09 Powick Powick BR C 1 0 SWS 2007/08 06/00290 FUL Coney Gore, Alfrick Replacement dwelling 0.13 Alfrick Alfrick and Leigh BR Clifton Upon C 1 1 SWS 2007/08 07/00541 FUL The Oak House, 21 The Village, Clifton-on-Teme To remove A1 commercial use of shop/post office area to C3 residential use 0.01 Teme Teme Valley BB Upton Upon C 1 1 SWS 2007/08 07/01815 FUL 17 School Lane, Upton-on-Severn, Worcestershire WR8 0LD Change of use from dentist's surgery to residential 0.06 Severn Upton and Hanley BB Alterations to ground floor retail units and conversion of upper floor to form 4 No. dwelling units C 4 4 SWS 2007/08 05/00762 FUL 6-8 Belle Vue Terrace, Malvern inc 2nd floor extension 0.04 Malvern Malvern Priory BO C 1 1 SWS 2007/08 05/01029 FUL Springvale Works, Worcester Road, Hanley Swan Construction of extensions and alterations to convert workshop/office to single dwelling unit 0.05 Hanley Castle Upton and Hanley BO C 4 4 SWS 2007/08 06/01482 FUL Lindfield Mgc, 12 Avenue Road, Malvern Conversion of former school dormitory into 4 residential units 0.19 Malvern Malvern Priory BB C 1 0 SWS 2007/08 06/00768 FUL May Cottage, 15 Wyche Road, Malvern Demolition of existing cottage and replacement with new dwelling 0.06 Malvern Wells Malvern Wells BR C 1 0 SWS 2007/08 00/00398 CAC 60 Old Wyche Road, Malvern Demolition of existing cottage and reconstruction on the same site of a new 4 bed cottage 0.29 Malvern Wells Malvern Wells BR C 2 1 SWS 2007/08 06/00714 FUL Three Winds, Madge Hill, Severn Stoke Subdivision of existing dwelling into two dwellings and single storey extension to new dwelling 0.25 Severn Stoke Kempsey BR C 2 1 SWS 2007/08 06/00436 FUL 45 Giffard Drive Welland Extend and convert 1 dwelling into 2 dwellings 0.03 Welland Morton BR C 1 0 SWS 2007/08 06/00623 FUL Orlando, Alfrick New bungalow 0.40 Alfrick Alfrick and Leigh BR C 2 1 SWS 2007/08 06/01716 FUL Elm Point, Apostles Oak, Abberley Demolition of 1960's split level dwelling and construction of 2 detached dwellings 0.20 Abberley Woodbury BR C 1 1 SWS 2007/08 06/01568 FUL 2 Bank Street, Malvern Retrospective application for the creation of a separate flat on the lower ground floor 0.11 Malvern Malvern Priory BR Upton Upon C 2 1 SWS 2007/08 06/01600 FUL Court Row Lodge, Court Row, Upton-upon-Severn Conversion of dwelling into 2 No dwellings 0.01 Severn Upton and Hanley BR C 2 1 SWS 2007/08 07/00384 FUL 4 Lansdowne Close, Malvern Sub-division of dwelling into two apartments 0.00 Malvern Pickersleigh BR C 3 2 SWS 2007/08 07/01211 FUL 53 Howsell Road, Malvern, Worcestershire, WR14 1TH Conversion of existing dwelling to form 3 No flats 0.50 Malvern Malvern Link BR C 2 0 SWS 2007/08 07/00687 FUL 33 Victoria Road, Malvern Single storey extension and formation of 2 houses from existing 2 flats 0.06 Malvern Malvern Link BR Lower C 1 0 SWS 2007/08 06/00405 FUL Laylocks, Laylocks Lane, Lower Broadheath Replacement dwelling to include change of use agricultural land to garden land 0.08 Broadheath Broadheath BR Change of use of part including formation of 3 no. 1 bedroom flats as part of general C 3 3 SWS 2007/08 06/00826 FUL 90/92 Worcester Road, Malvern redevelopment 0.01 Malvern Malvern Priory BO

C 3 2 SWS 2007/08 06/00992 FUL 170 Worcester Road, Malvern Conversion of existing dwelling to 2 No. flats with extension to form single 'duplex' flat 0.03 Malvern Malvern Link BR C 2 1 SWS 2007/08 06/00238 FUL Bedford House 1 Grundys Lane Malvern. Sub-division of existing dwelling to form 2 no. dwellings. 0.02 Malvern Wells Malvern Wells BR First floor extension and alterations to provide additional living space and 2nd unit of Lower C 1 1 SWS 2007/08 04/01627 FUL Broadheath Stores, Martley Road, Lower Broadheath accommodation and retain retail area (amendment to planning 0.07 Broadheath Broadheath BR C 1 0 SWS 2007/08 06/00675 FUL The Old Forge, Eastham, Tenbury Wells Proposed replacement dwelling 0.13 Eastham Teme Valley BR C 3 2 SWS 2007/08 07/01066 FUL 19 Victoria park Road Malvern Conversion of 3 bed maisonette into 2 X 2 bed apartments 0.04 Malvern Malvern Link BR C 2 2 SWS 2007/08 07/01870 FUL Land At (OS 7950 3994) Gloucester Road Welland Amendments to design of approved bungalow (05/01105/FUL) 0.19 Welland Morton BR C 4 2 SWS 2007/08 06/01332 FUL 1 & 2 Albion Cottages, Hanley Swan, Worcester Demolition of existing cottages and replacement with 4 No. cottages and garages 0.01 Hanley Castle Upton and Hanley BR C 2 2 SWS 2007/08 04/01285 FUL Kyre Park House, Kyre, Tenbury Wells Internal alterations to provide 2 No apartments at second floor 0.09 Kyre Tenbury BO C 1 1 SWS 2007/08 06/00347 FUL Aymestry House, Unit 2 Bromyard Road Conversion of rear wing of existing large country house into self contained/separate dwelling 0.34 Rushwick Broadheath BR Conversion of existing dwelling with business use to lower ground floor to four flats and single C 4 3 SWS 2007/08 06/01192 FUL Beverston, 39 Wells Road, Malvern storey extension. 0.06 Malvern Malvern Wells BR C 1 1 SWS 2007/08 08/00149 FUL Victoria Court, Victoria Road, Malvern, Worcestershire WR14 2TE Creation of additional flat 0.01 Malvern Malvern Priory BR

Windfall Allowance Calculation - Sites List APPENDIX C Housing Land Supply Monitor 2014 - Windfall Allowance Calculation Sites List (Small brownfield sites of 4 dwellings or less completed between 2006/07 and 2013/14)

Completion Application Application Site Gross Net Site Previous Status Address Description Parish Ward Year Reference Type Area Units Units Type Use C 1 0 SWS 2007/08 06/00909 FUL Ridgeacre Farm, Broadgreen, Broadwas Replacement dwelling 0.28 Broadwas Broadheath BR Upton Upon C 1 1 SWS 2007/08 05/01550 FUL Rear Of 10 Old Street Upton-Upon-Severn Use part of bakery and flat to form dwelling house 0.01 Severn Upton and Hanley BS C 4 3 SWS 2007/08 07/00587 FUL Organ Hall, Worcester Road, Malvern Demolition of existing buildings and erection of 4 no. 2 bedroom cottages 0.06 Malvern Malvern Link BR Upton Upon C 1 1 SWS 2007/08 05/01551 FUL Rear Of 10 Old Street Upton-Upon-Severn Formation of separate flat 0.01 Severn Upton and Hanley BS C 1 1 SWS 2007/08 06/01566 FUL 4 Bank Street, Malvern Change of use of existing store to flat 0.01 Malvern Malvern Priory BW Chambers Court Cottage, Longdon, Tewkesbury, Gloucestershire, C 1 0 SWS 2007/08 07/01288 FUL GL20 6AS Replacement cottage 0.26 Longdon Longdon BR C 1 1 SWS 2007/08 07/01919 FUL Rondene, Holywell Road, Malvern, Worcestershire WR14 4LF Proposed conversion of single dwelling back to two dwellings 0.14 Malvern Wells Malvern Wells BR 2007/08 Sub-Totals 91 56 Upton Upon C 2 1 SWS 2008/09 05/01517 FUL 18 Old Street Upton-Upon-Severn Sub-division of existing shop/residential unit into 1 no. lockup shop & 2 no. flats 0.01 Severn Upton and Hanley BB C 1 1 SWS 2008/09 06/01736 FUL 1 Holyrood House, 11 Wells Road, Malvern Alterations to form additional apartment and associated change of use 0.05 Malvern Malvern Priory BB Unit 2 - internal alterations to form 3 bed cottage. Unit 5 alterations to conference centre to C 4 4 SWS 2008/09 06/01812 FUL Building at Runnings Park Hotel, Croft Bank reinstate unit 5 to original dwelling. Unit 6 and 7 alterations to former hotel to form 2 No 3 bed 0.26 West Malvern Malvern West BB

C 1 1 SWS 2008/09 07/01519 FUL 119 Barnards Green Road, Malvern, Worcestershire, WR14 3LT Change of use from music room to bedsit 0.02 Malvern Malvern Chase BB C 1 1 SWS 2008/09 07/01741 FUL Building at (OS 7514 5303) The Old Swan, Alfrick, Worcester Conversion/extension of vacant building to form dwelling 0.03 Alfrick Alfrick and Leigh BB C 1 1 SWS 2008/09 07/01746 FUL 40 Church Street, Malvern, Worcestershire WR14 2AZ Change of use to residential one unit (family home) 0.10 Malvern Malvern Priory BB Land at Horse & Groom Inn, The Grove, Ryall, Upton Upon Severn, Amendment to approved scheme converting former public house to a dwelling (to include a C 2 2 SWS 2008/09 08/00240 FUL Worcestershire WR8 0PP pitched roof over the existing flat roofed former toilet block and lobby) 0.21 Ripple Ripple BB Reversion of main building to one dwelling incl provision of amenities (kitchen, bathroom, C Police Station, School Lane, Upton-Upon-Severn, Worcestershire ensuite) etc. Conversion of single storey section to form one 2-bedroomed living unit with all Upton Upon 2 2 SWS 2008/09 08/00515 FUL WR8 0LE amenities, formation of new boundary 0.06 Severn Upton and Hanley BB Conversion of the Coach House currently used as bed and breakfast accommodation and garage C 1 1 SWS 2008/09 08/00550 FUL Old Vicarage, Hanley Castle, Worcester to single residential unit 0.04 Hanley Castle Upton and Hanley BB Construction of 2 bungalows with garages and private drive - variation of design approved under Upton Upon C 3 3 SWS 2008/09 06/00246 FUL 2 Prices Lane Upton-Upon-Severn. MH04/02039/FUL. 0.08 Severn Upton and Hanley BI C 1 1 SWS 2008/09 05/01867 FUL Barclays Bank Chambers, 2 Worcester Road, Malvern Change of use of redundant first floor offices to flat and refubishment of second floor flat. 0.18 Malvern Malvern Priory BO C 1 1 SWS 2008/09 06/00535 FUL 219 Worcester Road, Malvern Conversion of ground floor offices and store to one apartment 0.04 Malvern Malvern Link BO C 1 0 SWS 2008/09 05/00178 FUL Dugmore Cottage, Pendock, Gloucester Replacement dwelling 0.15 Pendock Longdon BR C 2 1 SWS 2008/09 06/00238 FUL Bedford House 1 Grundys Lane Malvern. Sub-division of existing dwelling to form 2 no. dwellings. 0.02 Malvern Wells Malvern Wells BR C 2 1 SWS 2008/09 06/00866 FUL Flat 1, 3 Queens Drive, Malvern Division of existing property into two flats 0.01 Malvern Malvern Priory BR C 1 0 SWS 2008/09 06/01169 FUL Berrow Downs, Castlemorton, Malvern Removal of existing house, ancillary buildings and replacement with four bedroom dwelling 0.17 Castlemorton Morton BR C 3 2 SWS 2008/09 07/01211 FUL 53 Howsell Road, Malvern, Worcestershire, WR14 1TH Conversion of existing dwelling to form 3 No flats 0.50 Malvern Malvern Link BR C 1 0 SWS 2008/09 07/01229 FUL 1 Delamere Road Malvern Replacement of existing dwelling 0.07 Malvern Pickersleigh BR C 1 0 SWS 2008/09 07/00662 FUL Charleon, Sherridge Road, Leigh Sinton Demolition of substandard dwelling and replacement with new dwelling 0.08 Leigh Alfrick and Leigh BR C 4 3 SWS 2008/09 07/01053 FUL 37 Wells Road, Malvern Conversion of semi-detached four storey dwelling to four flats 0.07 Malvern Malvern Priory BR C 4 4 SWS 2008/09 07/01139 REM 134-136 Newtown Road, Malvern Reserved matters for erection of 4 starter homes 0.07 Malvern Malvern West BR C 1 1 SWS 2008/09 07/01163 FUL Park House, Berrington Road, Tenbury Wells Erection of 3-bedroom bungalow and replacement garage. 0.06 Tenbury Tenbury BR Land Rear of 136 Newtown Road Queens Road Malvern C 2 2 SWS 2008/09 07/01287 REM Worcestershire Reserved matters for the proposed erection of two bungalows 0.05 Malvern Malvern West BR C 3 2 SWS 2008/09 07/01818 FUL 28 Cowleigh Road, Malvern Worcestershire WR14 1QD Sub-division of one dwelling into two flats; creation of one dwelling within existing basement 0.07 Malvern Malvern West BR C 1 0 SWS 2008/09 08/00374 FUL Homeland, Broadmore Green, Rushwick, Worcester WR2 5TE Demolish existing dwelling and replace with new build on existing site 0.07 Rushwick Broadheath BR Extension to existing residential building to provide one two bedroom apartment, one one C 3 3 SWS 2008/09 08/00836 FUL 37 Wells Road, Malvern bedroom apartment and one studio apartment 0.14 Malvern Malvern Priory BR C 1 1 SWS 2008/09 05/01688 FUL 27A Howsell Road Malvern Change of use: Commercial to residential. 0.01 Malvern Malvern Link BS C 1 1 SWS 2008/09 06/00834 FUL Barclays Bank, 253 Worcester Road, Malvern Change of use of first floor accommodation. Reinstatement to residential flat 0.02 Malvern Malvern Link BS

Windfall Allowance Calculation - Sites List APPENDIX C Housing Land Supply Monitor 2014 - Windfall Allowance Calculation Sites List (Small brownfield sites of 4 dwellings or less completed between 2006/07 and 2013/14)

Completion Application Application Site Gross Net Site Previous Status Address Description Parish Ward Year Reference Type Area Units Units Type Use C 1 1 SWS 2008/09 08/00472 FUL Land Rear of 103-105 Newtown Road, Malvern, Worc WR14 1PE Erection of one detached bungalow 0.06 Malvern Malvern West BS C 1 1 SWS 2008/09 08/00620 FUL 2 Teme Street, Tenbury Wells Refurbishment of property, proposed residential unit, first floor 0.01 Tenbury Tenbury BS 2008/09 Sub-Totals 53 42 Unit 2 - internal alterations to form 3 bed cottage. Unit 5 alterations to conference centre to 2009/10 06/01812 FUL C Building at Runnings Park Hotel, Croft Bank 0.26 West Malvern Malvern West 4 4 SWS BB reinstate unit 5 to original dwelling. Unit 6 and 7 alterations to former hotel to form 2 No 3 bed 2009/10 07/00124 FUL C 2 Runnings Park, Croft Bank, Malvern Change of use to private residential accommodation 0.21 West Malvern Malvern West 1 1 SWS BB

2009/10 07/01759 FUL C Raglan, Westminster Bank, Malvern, Worcestershire WR14 4BN Conversion of ground floor recording studio space into 3-bed apartment 0.12 West Malvern Malvern West 1 1 SWS BB

2009/10 08/00272 FUL C 3 & 4 The Lees, Malvern, Worcestershire Change of use from residential institution (C2) to two houses (C3) 0.03 Malvern Malvern Priory 2 2 SWS BB Runnings Park Hotel, Croft Bank, Malvern, Worcestershire WR14 2009/10 08/00310 FUL C Conversion of former hotel to one dwelling unit 0.06 West Malvern Malvern West 1 1 SWS BB 4DU Knighton on 2009/10 09/00346 CLE C Flat 1, Tavern Flats, Tavern Lane, Newnham Bridge, Tenbury Wells Certificate of Lawfulness for an existing use - continue the use as a single dwelling 0.14 Lindridge 1 1 SWS BB Teme Clifton Upon 2009/10 09/01277 FUL C The Old Surgery, Hope Lane, Clifton-on-Teme Change of use with extension and modification to form dwelling 0.07 Teme Valley 1 1 SWS BB Teme Upton Upon 2009/10 09/01215 FUL C 25A School Lane, Upton-upon-Severn Change of use from Physiotherapy Unit back to residential dwelling 0.03 Upton and Hanley 1 1 SWS BB Severn Construction of 2 bungalows with garages and private drive - variation of design approved under Upton Upon 2009/10 06/00246 FUL C 2 Prices Lane Upton-Upon-Severn. 0.08 Upton and Hanley 3 3 SWS BI MH04/02039/FUL. Severn 2009/10 07/01020 FUL C Flat, 35 Graham Road, Malvern Change of use from business to residential 0.16 Malvern Malvern Priory 1 1 SWS BO

2009/10 05/00563 FUL C Bransford Acre, Leigh Replacement dwelling 0.15 Bransford Alfrick and Leigh 1 0 SWS BR

2009/10 06/00488 FUL C 182 West Malvern Road, Malvern Change of use from existing dwelling to three separate flats 0.03 West Malvern Malvern West 3 2 SWS BR

2009/10 06/00660 FUL C Lime Cottage, Hipplecote, Martley Replacement dwelling 0.15 Martley Martley 1 0 SWS BR

2009/10 07/01301 FUL C 403 Pickersleigh Road, Malvern, Worcestershire WR14 2QJ Conversion and extension to form two dwellings 0.06 Malvern Malvern Chase 2 1 SWS BR

2009/10 08/00324 FUL C Pound Farm, Stanford Road, Great Witley, Worcester WR6 6JG Demolish existing farmhouse and provide replacement dwelling 0.38 Shelsley Kings Teme Valley 1 0 SWS BR

2009/10 08/00567 FUL C Saxons Lode Cottages, Saxons Lode, Uckinghall, Tewkesbury Replacement dwelling 0.30 Ripple Ripple 1 0 SWS BR

2009/10 08/01088 FUL C Westkerke, Pensax, Stockton Demolition of existing bungalow and erection replacement dwelling 0.12 Pensax Woodbury 1 0 SWS BR

2009/10 08/01303 FUL C 66 Peachfield Road, Malvern Conversion of bungalow into two dwellings 0.07 Malvern Wells Malvern Wells 2 1 SWS BR

2009/10 08/01791 FUL C 36 Hornyold Road, Malvern Reinstate to a single dwelling, widen access and proposed conservatory 0.05 Malvern Malvern West 1 -2 SWS BR

2009/10 08/01389 FUL C 43 Albert Park Road, Malvern Material change of use from commercial to one-bedroom dwelling 0.01 Malvern Malvern Link 1 1 SWS BS

2009/10 Sub-Totals 30 19

C 4 4 SWS 2010/11 09/00243 FUL The Morgan, 82 Worcester Road, Malvern Conversion of public house to 4 no. residential units 0.04 Malvern Malvern Priory BB C 2 1 SWS 2010/11 09/00791 FUL The Morgan, 82 Worcester Road, Malvern Conversion of units to the rear of The Morgan Inn to 2 No residential units 0.13 Malvern Malvern Priory BB C 2 2 SWS 2010/11 09/01011 FUL 97 Barnards Green Road, Malvern Construction of two apartments (amendment to previous planning permission 08/01836/FUL) 0.01 Malvern Malvern Chase BB C 1 1 SWS 2010/11 10/00080 FUL 21 Players Avneue, Malvern Alteration of position of new house approved under 07/01917/FUL 0.04 Malvern Malvern Link BB Application for a Certificate of Lawfulness for an Existing Development - Erection of dwelling and C 1 1 SWS 2010/11 10/00375 CLE White cottage , kings wood, martley, wr6 6pg associated amenity space 0.50 Martley Martley BB C 3 3 SWS 2010/11 06/00455 FUL Galen House, 231 Worcester Road, Malvern Conversion of office space to living accommodation - 3 No 1 bedroom flats 0.02 Malvern Malvern Link BO C 4 4 SWS 2010/11 07/01729 FUL 62 Albert Road North Malvern Extension to rear to form 4 apartments including demolition of existing single storey element 0.07 Malvern Malvern Priory BO Upton Upon C 2 1 SWS 2010/11 07/01055 FUL 12A Dunns Lane, Upton-Upon-Severn, Worcester Subdivision of dwelling into two dwellings 0.01 Severn Upton and Hanley BR C 1 1 SWS 2010/11 07/01135 FUL Pyndar House, Hanley Castle Change of use of existing outbuilding to form new dwelling 0.12 Hanley Castle Upton and Hanley BR C 2 1 SWS 2010/11 07/01408 FUL Pound Cottage, Leigh Sinton, Malvern, Worcestershire WR13 5EQ Proposed alterations to form 1 No. 2-bedroom unit and 1 No. 1-bedroom unit 0.03 Leigh Alfrick and Leigh BR C 1 0 SWS 2010/11 08/01942 REM Guythorpe, Malvern Road, Staunton, Gloucester Replacement of existing single storey dwelling with bungalow 0.13 Eldersfield Longdon BR C 1 0 SWS 2010/11 09/00567 FUL Needwood, Salt Box Lane, Oldwood, Tenbury Wells Demolition of detached dormer bungalow and erection of a new detached dormer bungalow 1.07 Tenbury Tenbury Town BR 2010/11 - Sub-Totals 24 19 Application for a Lawful Development Certificate for an existing use of building for 2 no C 2 2 SWS 2011/12 11/00974 CLE 49 Abbey Road, Malvern apartments (use Class C3) n/a Malvern Malvern Priory BR

Windfall Allowance Calculation - Sites List APPENDIX C Housing Land Supply Monitor 2014 - Windfall Allowance Calculation Sites List (Small brownfield sites of 4 dwellings or less completed between 2006/07 and 2013/14)

Completion Application Application Site Gross Net Site Previous Status Address Description Parish Ward Year Reference Type Area Units Units Type Use C 2 2 SWS 2011/12 09/01252 FUL Land adj 2 Hospital Bank, Malvern Construction of two new semi-detached dwellings 0.08 Malvern Malvern West BB Extension of lime limit to commence development on 06/01390/FUL - erection of 4 no apartment C 4 4 SWS 2011/12 09/01488 PEX The Vaults PH, 102 Worcester Road, Malvern block 0.08 Malvern Malvern Priory BB C 3 3 SWS 2011/12 10/00386 FUL Malvern Auction Centre, Portland Road, Malvern Construction of three dwellings involving demolition of single storey building 0.03 Malvern Malvern Priory BB The New Gas Tavern,114 Madresfield Proposed mixed use development comprising 373 sq m convenience store and three 2 bedroom C 3 3 SWS 2011/12 10/01348 FUL Road,Malvern,Worcestershire,WR14 2NR townhouses. 0.15 Malvern Pickersleigh BB C 1 1 SWS 2011/12 11/00241 FUL 48 Church Road, Malvern Extension of building to permit part to be residential and the other half to be Osteophathic clinic 0.04 Malvern Malvern Link BB Revised layout and elevations to existing planning permission for 3 new dwellings C 3 3 SWS 2011/12 11/01313 FUL Elm Hurst Farm, Hereford Road, Leigh Sinton (08/01734/REM) 0.12 Leigh Alfrick and Leigh BB C 1 1 SWS 2011/12 12/00029 FUL Thornbury House, 16 Avenue Road, Malvern Change of use to single dwelling house 0.03 Malvern Malvern Priory BB C 3 3 SWS 2011/12 09/00555 FUL 96 Worcester Road, Malvern Conversion of existing office accommodation to three apartments (A2 to C3) 0.02 Malvern Malvern Priory BO Upton Upon C 2 1 SWS 2011/12 09/01198 FUL 4 Court Street, Upton-upon-Severn Change of use of existing offices to two dwellings 0.01 Severn Upton and Hanley BO C 1 1 SWS 2011/12 09/01598 FUL Abbeyfield House, 1 St Andrews Road, Malvern Change of use from Nursing Home (C2) to dwelling house (C3) 0.20 Malvern Malvern Chase BO C 1 1 SWS 2011/12 10/00430 FUL 20 North Malvern Road, Malvern Change of use of existing office accommodation (B1) to two bedroomed apartment (C3) 0.01 Malvern Malvern West BO C 1 0 SWS 2011/12 05/01711 FUL Fair View Willow Road Martley Replacement dwelling 0.40 Martley Martley BR C 2 1 SWS 2011/12 07/01512 FUL Plowstall Farm, Bayton, Kidderminster, Worcestershire, DY14 9LY Division of farmhouse to two dwellings. Erection of detached garage. 0.14 Bayton Lindridge BR The Stable Block, Kyre Park House, Kyre, Tenbury Wells, Proposed change of use of converted stable block of six flats to two storey dwellings and garaging C 2 -4 SWS 2011/12 08/00551 FUL Worcestershire WR15 8RW and store 0.88 Kyre Tenbury BR Demolition of existing bungalow and erection of detached 3 bedroomed dwelling with detached C 1 0 SWS 2011/12 09/00333 FUL Amherst, Bushley, Tewkesbury double garage 0.27 Bushley Longdon BR C 1 0 SWS 2011/12 09/01299 FUL Garth Cottage, 7 Post Office Lane, Kempsey Demolish existing cottage and erect 2 storey dwelling 0.03 Kempsey Kempsey BR C 1 1 SWS 2011/12 09/01302 FUL Burford House, 32 Worcester Road, Malvern Resiting of dwelling (amendment to 08/00849/FUL) 0.16 Malvern Malvern Priory BR C 1 0 SWS 2011/12 11/00856 FUL Nineveh, Menith Wood, WR6 6UB Demolition of existing dwelling and erection of replacement dwelling. 0.64 Lindridge Lindridge BR Application for a Lawful Development Certificate for an existing use - use of annexe as separate Clifton Upon C 1 1 SWS 2011/12 11/00876 CLE Clifton Park, Clifton on Teme dwelling 0.07 Teme Teme Valley BR C 2 1 SWS 2011/12 11/00948 FUL Post Office and Royal Mail Delivery, 6 St Marys Crescent, Alfrick Extension and conversion of shop/post office with flat over to two semi detached houses 0.05 Alfrick Alfrick and Leigh BR C 1 1 SWS 2011/12 11/01716 CLE Two Hoots, Shoulton, Hallow, WR2 6PX Application for certificate of lawfulness development for occupation of 'Two Hoots' as a dwelling 0.01 Hallow Hallow BR C 4 4 SWS 2011/12 08/00898 FUL Rear of Oakleigh Garage, Moseley Road, Hallow Demolition of existing commercial building and redevelopment of 4 No new residential units 0.09 Hallow Hallow BS C 1 1 SWS 2011/12 08/01221 FUL 247 Worcester Road, Malvern Change of use from shop to become a self contained 1 bedroom flat 0.02 Malvern Malvern Link BS C 2 2 SWS 2011/12 08/01674 FUL The Original Stores, 2 Church Street, Kempsey Improvements to existing shop. Provision of 2 No. flats 0.45 Kempsey Kempsey BS C 1 1 SWS 2011/12 10/00433 FUL 14A Merton Road, Malvern Conversion of hair saloon into residential unit 0.02 Malvern Malvern Link BS 2011/12 Sub-Totals 47 34

2012/13 C 1 1 SWS 10/00368 FUL Riverlands Farm, Teme Lane, Leigh Erection of dwelling incorporating ancillary office space 36.40 Leigh Alfrick and Leigh BB 2012/13 C 2 2 SWS 10/01548 FUL Hall Farm, Church Lane, Mamble Proposed change of use from craft centre to 2 dwelling units 0.03 Mamble Lindridge BB 2012/13 C 1 1 SWS 11/00481 FUL The Vaults Inn, 102 Worcester Road, Malvern Change of use to residential apartment 0.71 Malvern Malvern Priory BB The Dog At Baughton, Baughton, Earls Croome, Worcestershire, 2012/13 C 2 1 SWS 11/00970 FUL WR8 9DQ Conversion and extension to form two dwellings 0.56 Earls Croome Ripple BB 2012/13 C 4 4 SWS 11/01493 FUL St Anns Orchard, Worcester Road, Malvern Change of use and alterations to form four residential dwellings 0.31 Malvern Malvern Link BB 2012/13 C 2 2 SWS 12/00565 FUL Hall Farm, Church Lane, Mamble Proposed amendments to approved plan (11/00332/FUL and 11/00082/LBC - 2 dwelling units 0.03 Mamble Lindridge BB 2012/13 C 1 1 SWS 12/01344 HOU Malvern House, Leigh Conversion of garage and first floor store to habitable accommodation 0.33 Leigh Alfrick and Leigh BB Upton Upon 2012/13 C 1 1 SWS 11/01415 FUL 36 Old Street, Upton-upon-Severn Change of use of first floor to residential 0.04 Severn Upton and Hanley BI 2012/13 C 1 1 SWS 10/00248 FUL 3 & 3A Worcester Road, Malvern Conversion and change of use of existing office accommodation to one apartment (A2 to C3) 0.02 Malvern Malvern Priory BO Knighton on 2012/13 C 1 1 SWS 10/00435 FUL Brickfields, Bickley, Tenbury Wells Change of use from office to residential 0.06 Teme Lindridge BO 2012/13 C 2 2 SWS 10/01073 FUL Flat 1, 77A Newtown Road, Malvern Change of use, from redundant workshop and offices to 2 no new. 1 bed apartments. 0.02 Malvern Malvern West BO 2012/13 C 4 4 SWS 10/01585 FUL 117 Church Street, Malvern Conversion of offices into residential units 0.08 Malvern Malvern Priory BO

Windfall Allowance Calculation - Sites List APPENDIX C Housing Land Supply Monitor 2014 - Windfall Allowance Calculation Sites List (Small brownfield sites of 4 dwellings or less completed between 2006/07 and 2013/14)

Completion Application Application Site Gross Net Site Previous Status Address Description Parish Ward Year Reference Type Area Units Units Type Use 2012/13 C 1 1 SWS 12/01158 FUL Unit 7, Grosvenor House, 127 Church Street, Malvern Change of use from office unit into residential unit (Class Use C3) 0.01 Malvern Malvern Priory BO 2012/13 C 1 0 SWS 09/00080 FUL Croftway, Green Street, Kempsey Replacement bungalow 0.07 Kempsey Kempsey BR 2012/13 C 1 0 SWS 10/00211 FUL Villa Farm, Corse Lawn Replacement dwelling 0.01 Eldersfield Longdon BR Extension of time limit to commence development on 07/00777/FUL Conversion and extension of 2012/13 C 4 2 SWS 10/00494 PEX Land at 1 & 3 Upper Howsell Road, Malvern 2 no. semi detached units into 2 no. 2-bed maisonettes, 1 no. 1-bed apartment and 1 no. 2-bed 0.05 Malvern Dyson Perrins BR Malvern 2012/13 C 2 1 SWS 10/01116 FUL 207 Elgar Avenue, Malvern Return one flat back into two flats 0.00 Malvern Pickersleigh BR 2012/13 C 2 2 SWS 11/00632 FUL Hillbrook House, 62 Albert Road North, Malvern Provide 2 further apartments in roof space and cellar 0.20 Malvern Malvern Priory BR 2012/13 C 1 1 SWS 11/01405 FUL The Vaults Inn, 102 Worcester Road, Malvern Demolition of sheds, rebuild and also convert existing cellar to create new one bed apartment n/a Malvern Malvern Priory BR 2012/13 C 1 0 SWS 11/01750 FUL Lumber Tree Farm, Hanley Swan Replacement farmhouse 0.03 Welland Morton BR 2012/13 C 1 1 SWS 12/00085 FUL Old Parsonage Farm, Hanley Castle Split into two residences and extensions 0.49 Hanley Castle Upton and Hanley BR 2012/13 C 1 0 SWS 12/01226 FUL Westkerke, Pensax, Stockton Erection of replacement dwelling and detached garage (retrospective) 0.12 Pensax Woodbury BR SWS 2012/13 10/00670 FUL C 164 Worcester Road, Malvern Change of use from retail to two bed flat 0.06 Malvern Malvern Link 1 1 BS 2012/13 Sub-Totals 38 30 Demolition of existing outbuildings/garage and erection of new dwelling and no 2 replacement 2013/14 C 0.17 Malvern Wells Malvern Wells 1 1 SWS BB 11/01323 FUL 32 Peachfield Road, Malvern garages 2013/14 C 0.25 Lower Sapey Teme Valley 1 0 SWS BR 12/01139 FUL The Knoll Bungalow, Clifton on Teme Replacement dwelling 2013/14 C 0.02 Malvern Malvern Link 2 2 SWS BB 10/00242 FUL 180 Worcester Road, Malvern Change of use from commercial to residential 2013/14 C 0.06 Hallow Hallow 1 1 SWS BB 10/01085 FUL Chapel House, Moseley Road, Hallow Conversion of chapel to residential use Malvern Dyson 2013/14 C 0.03 Malvern 1 1 SWS BB 11/00860 FUL Halfkey House, Half Key, Malvern, Worcestershire, WR14 1UP Provision of managers living accomodation Perrins Upton Upon 2013/14 C 0.03 Upton and Hanley 4 3 SWS BB 11/01584 FUL 11 New Street, Upton-upon-Severn Convert veterinary practice into four flats Severn 2013/14 C 0.12 Malvern Malvern Priory 1 1 SWS BB 12/00445 FUL Grassendale House, 3 Victoria Road, Malvern Change of use of childrens nursery to residential unit Conversion of Old Cider House to three self contained dwellings with amenity space and car 2013/14 C 0.04 Tenbury Tenbury 3 3 SWS BB 12/00698 FUL Warehouse and Cider House, Church Street, Tenbury Wells parking Malvern 2013/14 C 0.07 Malvern 2 2 SWS BB 12/00907 FUL 6-7 Baxters Walk, Malvern Change of use of Pickersleigh Community Centre to two residential (former use) dwellings Pickersleigh 2013/14 C 0.18 Bransford Alfrick and Leigh 1 1 SWS BB 12/00970 FUL Croft House, Bransford, Worcestershire Change of use of house from guest house (C1) to residential use (C3) Internal alterations to form 1 no three bedroom apartment in lieu of 2 no two bedroom 2013/14 C 0.33 Malvern Wells Malvern Wells 2 1 SWS BB 12/01160 FUL Wells House Chapel, Holywell Road, Malvern apartments. Conversion of Holywell Chapel into four bedroom dwelling Construction of two detached dwellings involving demolition of existing garage following Outline 2013/14 C 0.16 Welland Morton 2 2 SWS BB 12/01320 FUL Welland Garage, Gloucester Road, Welland Planning Permission 08/01959/OUT, renewed 11/00984/OEX 2013/14 C 0.30 Malvern Malvern Link 1 0 SWS BB 12/01575 FUL Baxhill Nursery, 179 Worcester Road, Malvern Change of use to single dwelling Application for a Lawful Development Certificate for the continued use of wooden chalet as a 2013/14 C 0.01 Astley & Dunley Baldwin 1 1 SWS BB 12/01600 CLE Tudor Rose Nursery, Dunley, Worcestershire, DY13 0TT dwelling Malvern Dyson 2013/14 C 0.01 Malvern 1 1 SWS BB 12/01625 FUL 50 Upper Howsell Road, Malvern Change of use to residential Perrins Upton Upon 2013/14 C 0.04 Upton and Hanley 1 1 SWS BB 13/00217 FUL 69 Old Street, Upton upon Severn, WR8 0HN Change of use from old doctors clinic back to single residential dwelling Severn 2013/14 C 0.10 Powick Powick 1 1 SWS BB 13/00657 FUL The Old Forge, Old Malvern Road, Powick Residential use of former Forge retrospective and continuous 2013/14 C 0.02 Malvern Malvern Priory 2 2 SWS BO 11/01148 FUL Club Chambers, Grange Road, Malvern Convert former first floor offices into two 2 bedroom apartments 2013/14 C 0.02 Malvern Malvern Priory 3 3 SWS BO 11/01150 FUL Club Chambers, Grange Road, Malvern Conversion of redundant offices into two 2 bedroom and one 1 bedroom apartments 2013/14 C 0.03 Malvern Malvern Chase 1 1 SWS BO 12/00032 FUL 105 Barnards Green Road, Malvern Change of use of upper floors B1 (office) use to C3 (residential use) 2013/14 C 0.01 Malvern Malvern Chase 1 1 SWS BO 12/00697 FUL Flat 2, 131 Barnards Green Road, Malvern Change of use from office back to residential flat Shenley Stores, Bransford Road, Rushwick, Worcestershire, WR2 Application for a lawful development certificate for an existing use or operation to revert the 2013/14 C 0.04 Rushwick Broadheath 1 1 SWS BR 13/00919 CLE 5TA property back to being solely residential. 2013/14 C 0.02 Great Witley Woodbury 1 1 SWS BR 13/01055 FUL The Coach House, 17A Fountain Court, Great Witley Conversion of derelict building to residential 2013/14 C 0.03 Leigh Alfrick and Leigh 2 1 SWS BR 09/01328 FUL Bank Farm, Brockamin, Leigh Formation of two dwellings (division of existing farmhouse) 2013/14 C 0.18 Birtsmorton Morton 1 0 SWS BR 10/01106 FUL Little Arley, Birtsmorton Proposed amendments to existing planning consent 09/01338/FUL for a replacement dwelling 2013/14 C 0.25 Malvern Wells Malvern Wells 1 0 SWS BR 11/00501 FUL 56 Old Wyche Road , Malvern Demolition of existing dwelling and erection of new dwelling

Windfall Allowance Calculation - Sites List APPENDIX C Housing Land Supply Monitor 2014 - Windfall Allowance Calculation Sites List (Small brownfield sites of 4 dwellings or less completed between 2006/07 and 2013/14)

Completion Application Application Site Gross Net Site Previous Status Address Description Parish Ward Year Reference Type Area Units Units Type Use 2013/14 C 0.89 Martley Martley 1 0 SWS BR 11/01119 FUL Bramblewood, Hipplecote, Martley Amended Design to replacement dwelling approved 2013/14 C 0.02 Malvern Malvern Link 1 1 SWS BR 12/00088 FUL Rear of 229 Worcester Road, Malvern Proposed one bedroom flat 2013/14 C 0.17 Tenbury Tenbury 1 -1 SWS BR 12/00263 FUL 1 & 2 Upper Green, St Michaels, Tenbury Proposed replacement dwelling Certificate of lawfulness of existing use of the flat as an independent unit of permanent residential 2013/14 C 0.00 Shrawley Baldwin 1 1 SWS BR 12/00329 CLE The Flat, Goodyears Farm, Rectory Lane, Shrawley accommodation 2013/14 C 0.21 Hanley Castle Upton and Hanley 1 0 SWS BR 12/00448 FUL Avenue Riding Centre, Hanley Road, Welland Replacement bungalow with detached garage (amended scheme) 2013/14 C 0.23 Castlemorton Morton 1 0 SWS BR 12/00804 FUL Bradfords Farm, Castlemorton Proposed replacement of fire damaged farmhouse with four bedroomed dwelling. 2013/14 C 0.61 Great Witley Woodbury 1 1 SWS BR 12/01343 CLE Lieranta, Worcester Road, Great Witley Application for a Lawful Development Certificate for an existing use - use as a single dwelling 2013/14 C 0.12 Tenbury Tenbury 1 0 SWS BR 13/00310 FUL Dorothys Rock, Rhyse Lane, Tenbury Wells Replacement dwelling (retrospective) Amended scheme for previously approved application (MH 97/0112) to rebuild derelict timber 2013/14 C 0.30 Alfrick Temeside 1 1 SWS BR 98/00773 FUL Coppice End, Kigshill, Leigh Sinton, Malvern framed dwelling Application for a Lawful Development Certificate for the change of use of upper floor of building 2013/14 C 0.01 Malvern Malvern Priory 1 1 SWS BS 13/00319 CPU 5-7 Abbey Road, Malvern to residential unit 2013/14 C 0.20 Malvern Malvern Chase 4 4 SWS BW 11/00442 FUL 21 Wedderburn Road, Malvern Erection of 4 no dwellings and garages Demolition of units 3a, 3b and 4 fronting Severn Drive. Conversion of unit 1 & 2 fronting Court Upton Upon 2013/14 C 0.03 Upton and Hanley 2 2 SWS BW 13/00222 FUL Units 1-4 Haywards Yard, Court Street, Upton-upon-Severn Street to form 2 no. dwellings and associated works Severn 2013/14 Sub-Totals 55 42

TOTALS 386 278

Windfall Allowance Calculation - Sites List APPENDIX D List of Proposed SWDP Site Allocations Included in the Five Year Supply Calculation*

Indicative Indicative Number Dwellings Pre-app or Number SWDP Site Application Application of Dwellings Decision/ counted in Address Proposal Planning of Reference Ref Date Planning Status the five year Application? Dwellings Application/P supply in SWDP re-App SITES WITH PLANNING PERMISSION

Allowed on appeal 30/09/2013. Now in as a 0 (Already Land at Oldwood Erection of 45 Planning Commitment. SWDP 57/1 12/00659/OUT 03/05/2012 45 30 in as a Road, Tenbury Dwellings Application Reserved matters Commitment) is in for 43 dwellings (14/00006/REM).

Land at Hope Lane, Erection of 30 Planning Approved SWDP 59/3 13/01161/FUL 22/01/2013 30 30 30 Clifton Upon Teme Dwellings Application 24/06/2014

Land North of Approved Erection of 28 Worcester Road and Planning 02/04/2014 - SWDP59/4 dwellings and new 12/01412/FUL 12/10/2012 27 23 27 West of Great Witley C Application Under access of E Primary School Construction

18/12/2013 - 0 (Already Land Adj. The Crown, Erection of 51 Planning SWDP 59/12 13/00087/FUL 11/01/2013 51 51 Under in as a Martley Dwellings Application Construction Commitment)

Granted on 0 (Already Land Adj. Claphill Residential Planning Appeal - SWDP 60/6 12/01661/FUL 30/11/2012 28 23 in as a Lane, Rushwick Development Application 10/06/2013 Under Commitment) Construction

Proposed SWDP Site Allocations included in Five Year Supply Calculation APPENDIX D List of Proposed SWDP Site Allocations Included in the Five Year Supply Calculation*

Indicative Indicative Number Dwellings Pre-app or Number SWDP Site Application Application of Dwellings Decision/ counted in Address Proposal Planning of Reference Ref Date Planning Status the five year Application? Dwellings Application/P supply in SWDP re-App SITES WITH PLANNING PERMISSION SUBJECT TO A SECTION 106 AGREEMENT

Approved at Land adj. to The Residential Planning Planning SWDP 52/4 Homestead, Halfkey Development for 5 13/01585/FUL 26/02/2013 5 6 Committee on 5 Application Road, Malvern Dwellings 19th Feb 2014 Subject to S106

Approved at Planning Land at Sunny Bank Erection of 25 Planning SWDP 58/1 13/00706/OUT 03/06/2013 25 25 Committee 16th 25 Meadow, Holly Green Dwellings Application October 2013. Subject to S106.

Land South of Kempsey adj. to Planning Minded to Residential SWDP 59/8 Lawns Nursing Home Application Approve 7th May Development - 80 13/01130/OUT 22/01/2013 80 80 (Part 1) and including Bights (on part of the 2014 dwellings Farm, Kempsey (Part allocated site) Subject to S106 1) 138 Land South of Kempsey adj. to Planning Minded to Residential SWDP 59/8 Lawns Nursing Home Application Approve 7th May Development - 110 14/00021/OUT 12/07/2013 110 110** (Part 2) and including Bights (on part of the 2014 dwellings Farm, Kempsey (Part allocated site) Subject to S106 2)

Approved at Land to the West of Planning Erection of 48 Planning SWDP 59/9 Bell Lane/South of 13/00878/FUL 27/06/2013 48 40 Committee on 5th 48 dwellings Application Martley Road March 2014 (Subject to S106)

Proposed SWDP Site Allocations included in Five Year Supply Calculation APPENDIX D List of Proposed SWDP Site Allocations Included in the Five Year Supply Calculation*

Indicative Indicative Number Dwellings Pre-app or Number SWDP Site Application Application of Dwellings Decision/ counted in Address Proposal Planning of Reference Ref Date Planning Status the five year Application? Dwellings Application/P supply in SWDP re-App

Approved at Land adjacent to Planning Planning SWDP 60/2 Broadwas School, 10 Dwellings 13/01209/FUL 12/09/2013 10 10 Committee on 5th 10 Application Broadwas March 2014 (Subject to S106)

Approved at Land adjacent Development of 14 Planning Chapel Meadow, new dwellings of Planning Committee SWDP 61/1 13/01157/OUT 03/09/2013 14 13 14 Alfrick, which 4 will be Application on 4th February Worcestershire affordable 2014 (Subject to S106) SITES AT PLANNING APPLICATION OR PRE-APPLICATION STAGE

Land Adj. Hanley Road Application for 43 Planning SWDP 52/3 and Rothwell Road, 14/00262/FUL 06/03/2014 43 35 Outstanding 35 dwellings Application Malvern

Land West of Apostle Erection of 10 SWDP 59/2 22/08/2013 Pre-Application 10 10 Outstanding 10 Oak Cottage, Abberley Dwellings 2013 Pre-App

Land at Welland Road, Residential SWDP 59/6 2012 Pre-App 21/11/2012 Pre-Application 20 20 Outstanding 20 Hanley Swan, Worcs Development

Land at the Pheasant, SWDP 59/13 17 Dwellings 2014 Pre-App 19/02/2014 Pre-Application 17 10 Outstanding 10 Welland

TOTALS** 563 464 397 *Sites included monitored up to 30th June 2014 321** **76 dwellings discounted off this site total for deliverability timescale purposes

Proposed SWDP Site Allocations included in Five Year Supply Calculation APPENDIX E Other Large Sites Included in the Five Year Supply Calculation

Other Large Sites with Planning Permission Included in Five Year Supply*

Application Number of App Ref Address Description Decision Date Date Dwellings SITES WITH PLANNING PERMISSION Land at adjacent to the Crown Public Residential development of 45 dwellings 0 (Already in as a 13/00069/FUL 25/01/2013 10/01/2014 House, Powick (including 18 affordable dwellings) Commitment) Outline application for the erection of up to 0 (Already in as a 13/00417/OUT Land at Main Road, Kempsey 19/04/2013 12/12/2013 120 dwellings Commitment) Outline application for the development of land 0 (Already in as a 12/00876/OUT Land at Oldwood Road, Tenbury Wells 29/06/2012 13/08/2013 for up to 45 dwellings Commitment) Outline application for residential development 0 (Already in as a 12/01087/OUT Lawn Farm, Welland 16/08/2012 20/01/2014 of up to 50 houses Commitment) Demolition of existing bungalow and construction of 10 no. dwellings - This site will 123A Main Road, Kempsey, eventually supercede applications 13/01041/FUL 29/08/2013 28/04/2014 3 Worcestershire 11/00873/OUT and 11/00872/OUT that are in as commitments for 2013/14 -there is a net gain of 3 dwellings Land adj to Martley Primary School, Outline application for a residential 13/00981/OUT 15/08/2013 03/04/2014 14 Martley development 14 dwellings Land adj. Henwick Mill House, Martley Outline application for a maximum of 42 13/00725/OUT 27/06/2013 29/04/2014 42 Road, Lower Broadheath dwellings Demolition of existing dwellings and proposed 13/00900/OUT Pickersleigh Road, Malvern 08/08/2013 16/06/2014 44 residential development for 92 units (44 net) Outline application for a residential 13/00952/OUT Land at Kiln Lane, Leigh Sinton 08/08/2013 06/06/2014 53 development comprising 53 dwellings Land at (OS 8576 4086) north east of Outline application for the erection of up to 70 13/00431/OUT 19/04/2013 06/06/2014 70 Upton Marina, Upton upon Severn residential units Land at Walshes Farm, Clows Top, Outline application for development of 15 13/01398/OUT 18/10/2013 27/06/2014 15 Abberley dwellings (7 to be affordable) SUB TOTAL 241

Other Large Sites Included in the Five Year Supply Calculation APPENDIX E Other Large Sites Included in the Five Year Supply Calculation

Application Number of App Ref Address Description Decision Date Date Dwellings SITES WITH PLANNING PERMISSION SUBJECT TO A SECTION 106 AGREEMENT Outline application for residential development 13/00216/OUT Land at Sparrowhall Lane, Powick 08/03/2013 Site subject to S106 39 for 39 dwellings 13/00009/FUL Welland Road, Upton upon Severn Erection of 43 new dwellings - 22 affordable. 03/01/2013 Site subject to S106 43 Land at Pearl Lane, Astley Cross, Outline application for residential development 13/01405/OUT 08/11/2013 Site subject to S106 62 Worcestershire of up to 62 dwellings Church House Farm, Church Road, Development of 17 dwelling on the site of an 13/01327/FUL 14/10/2013 Site subject to S106 17 Clifton on Teme existing farmstead Land at (OS 7962 4497), Mill Lane, Outline application for up to 63 dwellings 13/01095/OUT Malvern (alternative access at Charlock 14/08/2013 Site subject to S106 63 (including 40% affordable housing) Lane) Land at (Os 7583 5538), Stoney Ley, Residential development of 8 dwellings (3 13/01224/FUL 16/09/2013 Site subject to S106 8 Broadwas affordable) Land adj the Old Post Office, Drake Outline application with all matters reserved 13/01526/OUT 21/11/2013 Site subject to S106 30 Street, Welland for the erection of 30 dwellings (12 affordable) SUB TOTAL 262

*Sites included monitored up to 30th June 2014 GRAND 503 TOTAL

Other Large Sites Included in the Five Year Supply Calculation APPENDIX F Housing Land Supply Monitor 2014 - Data Report Over/Under Supply Tables (used in the 'Sedgefield' Five Year Supply calculation)

SWDP Stage 1 Hearings 'Unconstrained' Requirement (2006-2030) 8,590 Dwellings

SWDP Stage 1 Hearings Net Over/Under Net Monitoring Year 'Unconstrained' Supply (Over/Under Supply results Completions (2006-2030) (Since 2006) restricted to a specific baseline target per plan period) 8,590 Dwellings 2006-2007 183 358 -175 2007-2008 299 358 -59 2008-2009 256 358 -102 2009-2010 222 358 -136 2010-2011 137 358 -221 2011-2012 229 358 -129 2012-2013 176 358 -182 2013-2014 184 358 -174 Totals 1,686 2,864 -1178

Over/Under Supply Tables 2014 APPENDIX F Housing Land Supply Monitor 2014 - Data Report MHDC Housing Delivery 2006/07 - 2013/14: Alternative over/under supply calculations Net completions 2006/07 - 2013/14 against relevant adopted target for year (where applicable) Supply Source A B C D B v C Comments WMRSS Adopted 2004 and again in 2008 Adopted WMRSS 2001-2021 Year Target Completions + or -' Difference (Figs Confirmed) Until Revocation in 2012/13 Phase 1* 2006/07 262 183 - -79 Phase 2** 2007/08 166 299 + 133 2008/09 166 256 + 90 2009/10 166 222 + 56 2010/11 166 137 - -29 Phase 3*** 2011/12 138 229 + 91 SWDP Submitted 28th May 2013, all other 2012/13 204 176 - -28 Submitted SWDP WMRSS targets revoked SWDP Post Stage 1 Hearings 2013/14 358 184 - -174 Unconstrained' Annual Requirement Total 1626 1686 + 60 *2001-2007 target for Worcestershire of 1,900x 13.8%, ** 2007-2011 target for Worcestershire of 1,200x 13.8%, ***2011-2021 target for Worcestershire of 1,000x 13.8%

Net completions 2006/07 - 2013/14 against relevant target for year- variation on adopted targets Supply Source A B C D B v C Comments Various Targets Year Target Completions + or -' Difference Various Targets Adopted WMRSS 2001-2021 Adopted 2004 - First Version Pre-Black 2006/07 262 183 - -79 (2004 Version) Country Review Malvern Hills District 2007/08 260 299 + 39 Adopted 2006 Local Plan Adopted WMRSS 2008 2008/09 171 256 + 85 Adopted 2008 ( figs confirmed) (average) 2001-2021 2009/10 171 222 + 51 2010/11 171 137 - -34 2011/12 171 229 + 58 SWDP Submitted 28th May 2013, all other 2012/13 204 176 - -28 Submitted SWDP WMRSS targets revoked SWDP Post Stage 1 Hearings 2013/14 358 184 - -174 Unconstrained' Annual Requirement Total 1768 1686 - -82

Over/Under Supply Tables 2014 APPENDIX G Housing Land Supply Monitor 2014 - Data Report

Five Year Housing Land Supply Summary Table (2014-2019)

SWDP POST STAGE 1 HEARINGS Five Year Housing Land Supply Requirements ‘UNCONSTRAINED’ APPROACH (OAHN) 8 (1st April 2014 to 31st March 2019) 2006 – 2030 (24 Years)

COLUMN 1: ‘SEDGEFIELD’ METHOD Plan Period Target 8,590 (358 per annum) Completions to Date 1,686 Residual Target 6,904 1 Over/Under Supply 1,178 under supply

2 Five Year Target +5% 3,058 (358 x 5 + 5% (90) + 1,178) 612 per annum

3,326 (358 x 5 + 20% (358) + 1,178) 665 per Five Year Target +20% annum

3 (673) 601 (5% lapse rate – 24 dwellings - not applied to (Outstanding) adopted local plan sites and proposed SWDP sites with 4 planning permission, 188)

(Under Construction) 172 Commitments (Net)

Total 773 (601 + 172)

Local Plan Sites (H3, H4 and H10) 36 105 (35 per annum for current 5 year period – 3 out Windfall Allowance (Brownfield) Gross of 5 years)

Proposed SWDP Site Allocations included in supply 321 (net) 5 (some subject to S106)

6 Other Large Sites Approved (some subject to S106) 503 (net)

600 Proportion of the Wider Worcester Area Urban (Worcester West = 300, 7 Extensions (Worcester West and Worcester South) Worcester South = 300)

Total Supply 2,338 Balance -720 Years supply (+5%) 3.82 Balance -988 Years supply (+20%) 3.52

Five Year Housing Land Supply Summary Table 2013/2014 APPENDIX G Housing Land Supply Monitor 2014 - Data Report

[1] The under supply is calculated by comparing previous net completions against the plan period target per annum since the start of the plan Period (i.e. 2006).

[2] The 5% and 20% allowance is added onto the five year requirement only and not the under supply.

[3] The lapse rate for is based on the Inspectors findings and recommendations from the South Worcestershire Development Plan Stage 1 Hearings.

[4] 48 dwellings discounted off Land north of Brookend Lane, Kempsey site (120 total on site - 13/00417/OUT). This assumes two years discounted to obtain full planning permission then 24 dwellings per annum for the remaining three years (72). 72 + 48 = 120. Data monitored up to 30th June 2014.

[5] Contains those SWDP sites with either full planning permission, sites subject to S106 and current planning applications post 31st March 2014. Additionally, 76 dwellings discounted off Land adj. the Lawns and Bight Farm Kempsey Sites (190 in total on site - 13/01130/OUT and 14/00021/OUT). This assumes two years discounted to obtain full planning permission then 38 dwellings per annum for the remaining three years (114). 76 + 114 = 190. Data monitored up to 30th June 2014.

[6] Includes all large sites post 31st March 2014 considered deliverable within five years, some subject to a S106 agreement. Data monitored up to 30th June 2014.

[7] Approximately 600 dwellings to be delivered within five years. This assumes two years discounted for full permissions to be granted then 100 dwellings per annum over 3 years = 300 per Urban Extension, so 600 in total over the five years.

[8] The figures in this table are indicative of the Objectively Assessed Housing Need and will be kept under review as regards progress of the SWDP.

Five Year Housing Land Supply Summary Table 2013/2014