Implementation of the Current EU Fisheries Control System by Member States (2014-19)
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
STUDY Requested by the PECH committee Implementation of the current EU fisheries control system by Member States (2014-19) Policy Department for Structural and Cohesion Policies Directorate-General for Internal Policies PE 652.205 - July 2020 EN RESEARCH FOR PECH COMMITTEE Implementation of the current EU fisheries control system by Member States (2014-19) Abstract This study assesses the implementation of the current EU fisheries control system by Member States. It focuses on the application of national infringement procedures, sanctions and the point system for serious infringements from 2014 to 2019. The research shows results based on interviews and survey replies by 17 out of 22 coastal Member States and it presents case studies for the following seven countries: Denmark, France, Germany, Ireland, Italy, Lithuania and Spain. This document was requested by the European Parliament's Committee on Fisheries. AUTHORS Blomeyer & Sanz: Margarita SANZ, Kim STOBBERUP, Roland BLOMEYER Research administrator: Marcus BREUER Project and publication assistance: Mariana VÁCLAVOVÁ Policy Department for Structural and Cohesion Policies, European Parliament LINGUISTIC VERSIONS Original: EN ABOUT THE PUBLISHER To contact the Policy Department or to subscribe to updates on our work for the PECH Committee please write to: [email protected] Manuscript completed in July 2020 © European Union, 2020 This document is available on the internet in summary with option to download the full text at: https://bit.ly/2zmeRka This document is available on the internet at: https://www.europarl.europa.eu/thinktank/es/document.html?reference=IPOL_STU(282020)2965220 5 Further information on research for PECH by the Policy Department is available at: https://research4committees.blog/PECH/ Follow us on Twitter: @PolicyPECH Please use the following reference to cite this study: Sanz, M., Stobberup, K., Blomeyer, R., 2020, Research for PECH Committee – Implementation of the current EU fisheries control system by Member States (2014-19), European Parliament, Policy Department for Structural and Cohesion Policies, Brussels Please use the following reference for in-text citations: Sanz, Stobberup and Blomeyer (2020) DISCLAIMER The opinions expressed in this document are the sole responsibility of the author and do not necessarily represent the official position of the European Parliament. Reproduction and translation for non-commercial purposes are authorized, provided the source is acknowledged and the publisher is given prior notice and sent a copy. © Cover image used under licence from Shutterstock.com 4 Implementation of the current EU fisheries control system by Member States (2014-19) CONTENTS LIST OF ABBREVIATIONS 5 LIST OF TABLES 7 LIST OF FIGURES 10 LIST OF BOXES 10 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY 11 1. INTRODUCTION 17 1.1. Research objectives 17 1.2. Methodology 17 1.3. Study structure 18 2. BACKGROUND 19 2.1. Legal framework for the EU fisheries control system 19 2.2. Revision of the EU Fisheries Control Regulation 20 2.3. Feedback from the stakeholders 21 3. INFRINGEMENT PROCEDURES 23 3.1. Overview of the infringement procedures 23 3.2. Competent authorities for sanctions and controls 24 3.3. Average length of infringement procedures 25 4. EU OVERVIEW: CONTROLS AND SANCTIONS IMPOSED 27 4.1. Identified infringements and sanctions imposed by type of infringement 27 4.2. Minimum and maximum sanctions laid down in the law 32 4.3. Sanctions imposed 33 5. PENALTIES AND POINT SYSTEM 37 5.1. EU overview: penalties by law in each Member State 37 5.2. Point system for serious infringements 38 6. CASE STUDIES 47 6.1. Case study summaries 47 6.2. Denmark 52 6.3. France 67 6.4. Germany 100 6.5. Ireland 112 6.6. Italy 132 3 IPOL | Policy Department for Structural and Cohesion Policies 6.7. Lithuania 154 6.8. Spain 171 7. RECOMMENDATIONS 185 7.1. Point System 185 7.2. Controls 185 REFERENCES 189 ANNEX I – STAKEHOLDER INTERVIEWS 201 ANNEX II – QUESTIONNAIRE TO THE MEMBER STATE 203 4 Implementation of the current EU fisheries control system by Member States (2014-19) LIST OF ABBREVIATIONS BBND Bazinis bausmių ir nuobaudų dydis Minimal threshold for fines (Lithuania) BLE Bundesanstalt für Landwirtschaft und Ernährung Federal Office for Agriculture and Food (Germany) CCNP Centro controllo nazionale pesca National centre for fisheries control (Italy) CCTV Closed-circuit television CEGs Control Expert Groups CFP Common Fisheries Policy CNSP Centre National de Surveillance de la Pêche National Fisheries Monitoring Centre (France) CRPM Code Rural et de la Pêche Maritime Rural and Maritime Fishing Code (France) CSO Civil Society Organisation CSP Centres de Surveillance de la Pêche Fisheries Monitoring Centres (France) DIRM Direction Inter-régionale de la Mer Inter-regional Directorate of the Sea (France) DKK Danish Krone DPMA Direction des Pêches Maritimes et de l’Aquaculture Directorate of Marine Fisheries and Aquaculture (France) DRMs Directions de la Mer Directorates for the Sea (France) ECA European Court of Auditors EEZ Exclusive Economic Zone EFCA European Fisheries Control Agency 5 IPOL | Policy Department for Structural and Cohesion Policies EUR Euro FIT Fishery Information Technology GU Gazzetta Ufficiale della Repubblica Italiana Official Journal of the Italian Republic IUU Illegal, Unregulated and Unreported Fishing JDP Joint-deployment plan JORF Journal Officiel de la République Française Official Journal of the French Republic LEI Romanian Lev MIPAAF Ministero delle Politiche Agricole, Alimentari e Forestali Ministry of Agricultural, Food and Forest Policies (Italy) NEAFC North East Atlantic Fisheries Commission PECH European Parliament’s Committee on Fisheries Pe.M.Acq. Direzione Generale della Pesca Marittima e dell'Acquacoltura Directorate General of Maritime Fisheries and Aquaculture (Italy) REM Remote Electronic Monitoring SEK Swedish Krona SFMJA Sea Fisheries Maritime Jurisdiction Act 2006 (Ireland) SFPA Sea-Fisheries Protection Authority SGCI Subdirección General de Control e Inspección Vice Directorate General of Control and Inspection (Spain) SIPE Sistema de Información Pesquera Española Spanish Fisheries Information System TAC Total Allowable Catch 6 Implementation of the current EU fisheries control system by Member States (2014-19) LIST OF TABLES Table 1: Systems of infringements procedures in national law (2020) 23 Table 2: Competent authorities for sanctions and controls in the EU 24 Table 3: Average length or time range of infringement procedures 26 Table 4: Number of infringements per type of infringement and per Member State (2014 – 2019) 30 Table 5: Economic sanctions for serious infringements 32 Table 6: Cases of sanctions applied per type of infringement and per Member State (2014 – 2019) 36 Table 7: Penalties imposed in the EU Member States 38 Table 8: Legislation implementing the penalty point system 40 Table 9: Cases where points were attributed per Member State and per type of infringement (2014 – 2019) 45 Table 10: Landings and inspections with respective coverage carried out in port and at sea (2014-2018) (Denmark) 62 Table 11: Number of serious infringements detected, and sanctions applied (2014-2019) (Denmark) 66 Table 12: Summary of serious infringements, points and fines (France) 73 Table 13: Conditions for application of the point system (France) 74 Table 14: Number of controls per type (2014-2017) (France) 81 Table 15: Percentage of controls per type (2014-2017) (France) 81 Table 16: Trends in types of controls (2014-2017) (France) 82 Table 17: Number of controls per type (2017-2018) (Metropolitan France) 82 Table 18: Number of controls according to CNSP (2014-2016) (France) 83 Table 19: Number of infringements identified and sanctions applied (2017) (France) 86 Table 20. Number of infringements identified and sanctions (2018) (France) 88 Table 21: Common types of infringements, Eastern Channel & North Sea region (2015-2019) (France) 90 Table 22: Economic sanctions, Eastern Channel & North Sea region (2015-2019) (France) 90 Table 23: Licences suspensions, Eastern Channel & North Sea region (2015-2019) (France) 91 Table 24: Infringements per type of control, Eastern Channel & North Sea region (2015-2019) (France) 91 Table 25: Points assigned per number of serious infringements, Eastern Channel & North Sea region (2015-19) (France) 92 Table 26: Common types of infringements, South Atlantic region (2016) (France) 93 Table 27: Infringements per type of control, South Atlantic region (2016) (France) 93 Table 28: Sanctions, South Atlantic region (2016) (France) 94 Table 29: Points per number of serious infringements, South Atlantic region (2016) (France) 94 7 IPOL | Policy Department for Structural and Cohesion Policies Table 30: Infringements identified, Mediterranean Sea region (2014-2017) (France) 95 Table 31: Sanctions, Mediterranean Sea region (2014-2017) (France) 96 Table 32: Points per type and number of serious infringements, Mediterranean Sea region (2016-2020) (France) 97 Table 33: Points per year and number of serious infringements, Mediterranean Sea region (2016-19) (France) 98 Table 34: Sanctions indicators, Northern Atlantic-& Western Channel region (2015-2018) (France) 98 Table 35: Major amendments to implement CFP regulations (Germany) 100 Table 36: Serious infringement points and minimum fine (Germany) 101 Table 37: Percentage of controlled fishing trips in relation to the total number of fishing trips (2016-2018) (Germany) 105 Table 38: Coverage of fishing trips by sea controls in the area of responsibility of the federal