Assessment of Indigenous Conflict Resolution Systems and Practices.Pdf
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
MEKELLE UNIVERSITY COLLEGE OF BUSINESS AND ECONOMICS DEPARTMENT OF MANAGEMENT ASSESSMENT OF INDIGENOUS CONFLICT RESOLUTION SYSTEMS AND PRACTICES: IMPLICATIONS FOR SOCIO-ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT: (A SURVEY OF SIMADA WOREDA, AMHARA REGION, ETHIOPIA) BY: BAMLAK YIDEG A THESIS SUBMITTED TO THE DEPARTMENT OF MANAGMENT IN PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OF THE REQUIREMENT FOR THE AWARD OF MASTER OF ARTS DEGREE IN DEVELOPMENT STUDIES (GOVERNANCE, DEMOCRACY AND DEVELOPMENT) PRINCIPAL ADVISOR CO-ADVISOR TESFAY AREGAWI (ASSISTANT PROFESSOR) BETELHEM SISAY (MSc) JUNE, 2013 MEKELLE, ETHIOPIA Mekelle University College of Business and Economics Department of Management Assessment of Indigenous Conflict Resolution Systems and Practices: Implication for Socio-Economic Development: (A Survey of Simada Woreda, Amhara Region, Ethiopia) By Bamlak Yideg Approved by: Signature __________________________________ ______________ (Advisor) _________________________________ ______________ (Internal examiner) ___________________________________ ______________ (External examiner) ii | P a g e Declaration The thesis entitled “Assessment of Indigenous Conflict Resolution Systems and Practices: Implication for Socio-Economic Development: A Survey of Simada Woreda, Amhara Region, Ethiopia” is my original work and has not been presented for a degree, diploma or fellowship to any other university and that all the sources of materials used for the thesis have been dully acknowledged. Bamlak Yideg Signature: _________________ Date: _____________________ i | P a g e Certification This is to certify that this thesis entitled ―Assessment of Indigenous Conflict Resolution Systems and Practices: Implication for Socio-Economic Development: A Survey of Simada Woreda, Amhara Region, Ethiopia‖ Submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirement for the award of the degree of MA, in Development studies of the college of Business and Economics, Mekelle University, through the Department of Management, done by Mr. Bamlak Yideg, ID, No, CBE/PR044/04 is carried out by him under our guidance.. Principal Advisor: Tesfay Aregawi (Assistant Professor) Signature: __________________ Date: _______________________ Co-advisor: Betelhem Sisay (MSc) Signature: __________________ Date: __________________ ii | P a g e Acknowledgements I would like to express my heartfelt and sincere gratitude to my Principal Advisor Tesfay Aregawi (Assistant Professor) for his diligent assistance, important and constructive comments, suggestions and advice, and dedication of his precious time in reading and correcting this research starting from the beginning. My appreciation also goes to my co-advisor Betelhem Sisay for her invaluable support, constructive comments, suggestions and advices in coordination with the principal advisor and independently. I am happy to give my special thanks to the woreda desk and woreda court of Simada for their great role in supplying relevant and up to date information. I am also glad to thank my family and my classmates for their support and advice from the beginning. In addition, I would like to express my special thanks to the community of Simada woreda for their honest cooperation in providing the necessary information. Lastly, I would like to express my deepest gratitude to priest Aschale Gobe (woreda militia desk officer) for his endeavor and diligent work to organize the community, supervise the enumerators and all necessary assistance he made in time of data collection. iii | P a g e List of Abbreviations and Acronyms ADR………….……....Alternative Dispute Resolution CSA…………………..Central Statics Agency CR …………………....Conflict Resolution EACC……………….. Ethiopian Arbitration and Conciliation Center FDRE……………..….Federal Democratic Republic of Ethiopia FGD……………….....Focus Group Discussions GPS…………………..Global Positioning Satellite System ICR …………………..Indigenous Conflict Resolution IK……………………..Indigenous Knowledge Nd ………………….…No date NGOs …………………Non-Governmental Organizations NURC…………………National Unity Reconciliation Commission OSSREA ……………..Organization for Social Science Research in Eastern and Southern Africa SPSS …………………..Statistical Package for Social Science UN……………………. United Nations UNDP………………….United Nations Development Program UNESCO ……………...United Nations Educational Social and Cultural Organization USA…………………… United States of America USAID………………... United States Agency for International Development iv | P a g e Glossary Gadaa: Oromo traditional administrative institution. Giligil: conforms to a kind of amicable process of dispute resolution. Indigenous: originating or occurring naturally in a particular place, native. Irq: The term Irq is the Amharic translation of the term ―conciliation‖. Kolla: lowland or a tropical type of zone. Mahber: is a kind of association which has religious ground; St. Michael and St. Marry for men and women. Shimglina: This literally means elderliness, denotes dispute solution by elderly persons. Tella bet: a house in which people drinking locally prepared beverage. Wina degua: neither highland nor lowland. Woreda: it is an administrative division of Ethiopia (managed by a local government), equivalent to a district. Yezemed danginet/ Yebetezemed danginet: solving disputes by blood or consanguinity relatives. v | P a g e Abstract Unless conflict is managed properly, it results in political, social and economical destruction of human beings. The cost of conflict depends on the type of conflict resolution system that individuals used to settle disagreements. The main objective of this study was assessing indigenous conflict resolution systems and practices and their implication for socio- economic development of the rural people in the study area. Specifically, the study identified the common types of conflict; the common causes of conflict; explored the economic advantage of indigenous conflict resolution system and restoring the social relationship of residents in the study area. Finally the study identified the challenges that indigenous conflict resolution system facing and the weakness that indigenous conflict resolution have. The study was conducted by using a sample of 176 household respondents who have ever experienced disputes. The household respondents selected using snowball sampling technique. Moreover, focus group discussions and interview were also employed to collect qualitative data. The study finds that 127 household respondents are involved in to land and land related conflict and land conflicts are increasing from time to time. The main causes of land conflicts are poor demarcation of boarder, inheritance problem and shortage of land and others. The study further explored the advantage of indigenous conflict resolution systems and practices to economic development. The household respondents who have used indigenous method of conflict resolution system helped them to save their money and time. Because of using this indigenous conflict resolution system, they have been restoring their relationship and inviting their conflict party and support each other. Furthermore, the study finds that to capacitate the ability of local elders the woreda government support is only confined to providing training and the process of selecting trainee is filed by corrupt practices. Lack of office for local elders also another challenge for the task of these local elders to perform their activity. Moreover, the practice of illegal gun trade challenges the daily life of the residents in the study area. The geographical location of the woreda surrounded by two major rivers; Abay/Nile and Beshilo Rivers which borders the study area with Goncha Sisso Enese and Saint Woreda respectively make the situation worst because it is difficult for security forces to control the area. This results in the loss of life of innocent peoples and security forces especially during market day. In addition, the Federal and regional governments release the prisoners following the coming of New Year before finishing their punishment and this is believed to aggravate the problem in which the victim side often takes revenge because of dissatisfaction with the decision of the government. There are different mechanisms that help to minimize the above problems. To minimize the problem of land and land related problems, the woreda land administration desk should immediately enter in to new demarcation process. It shall use the modern and scientific international land cadastre system by using GPS/ satellite navigation system in order to demarcate appropriately and reduce the complains like other woredas in the region. To minimize the problem of illegal gun trade, the woreda police office and woreda militia desk should work cooperatively with the adjacent woredas of Goncha Sisso Enese and Saint. Key words: indigenous conflict resolution, land, conflict, socio-economic, local elders. vi | P a g e Contents Title pages Declaration ....................................................................................................................................... i Certification .................................................................................................................................... ii List of Abbreviations and Acronyms ............................................................................................. iv Glossary .......................................................................................................................................... v Abstract .........................................................................................................................................