Historic Preservation Commission Community Development & Planning Department, City Hall, 101 First Street SE, Cedar Rapids, IA 52401, 319-286-5041
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
City of Cedar Rapids Historic Preservation Commission Community Development & Planning Department, City Hall, 101 First Street SE, Cedar Rapids, IA 52401, 319-286-5041 MEETING NOTICE The City of Cedar Rapids Historic Preservation Commission will meet at: 4:30 P.M. Thursday, October 9, 2014 in the Collins Conference Room, City Hall 101 First Street SE, Cedar Rapids, Iowa AGENDA Call Meeting to Order Public Comment Each member of the public is welcome to speak and we ask that you keep your comments to five (5) minutes or less. If the proceedings become lengthy, the Chair may ask that comments be focused on any new facts or evidence not already presented. 1. Approve Meeting Minutes 2. Action Items a) DEMOLITION Applications (10 Minutes) i. 2200 West Post Road SW – Private Property ii. 1415 4th Street SW – Private Property b) Certificate of Appropriateness (COA) (5 minutes) i. 1734 Park Avenue SE – Install wood fence c) Cedar Rapids Citywide Historic and Architectural Reconnaissance Survey (20 minutes) d) Draft Content for Kiosk Near 3rd Street SE and 12th Avenue SE (20 minutes) 3. Old Business a) Demolition Applications UNDER REVIEW (5 minutes) i. 1257 3rd Avenue SE – Private Property – November 17, 2014 b) COA Applications UNDER REVIEW (5 minutes) i. 1527 2nd Avenue SE – Demolition in Historic District – Reviewed June 13, 2013 4. Adjournment FUTURE MEETINGS Items for future agendas: a) Plaque on NW corner of 1st Avenue Bridge b) Ordinance updates: Partial Demolition, Accessory structures, ornamentation, historic district guidelines City of Cedar Rapids 101 First Street SE Cedar Rapids, IA 52401 Telephone: (319) 286-5041 MINUTES HISTORIC PRESERVATION COMMISSION REGULAR MEETING, Thursday, September 25, 2014 @ 4:30 p.m. Collins Conference Room, City Hall, 101 First Street SE Members Present: Amanda McKnight-Grafton Chair Todd McNall Vice Chair Sam Bergus Pat Cargin Bob Grafton B.J. Hobart Ron Mussman Tim Oberbroeckling Mark Stoffer Hunter Barbara Westercamp Members Absent: Caitlin Hartman City Staff: Jeff Hintz, Planner Anne Russett, Planner Jennifer Pratt, Interim Community Development Director Alicia Abernathey, Administrative Assistant Guests: Cindy Hadish, Call Meeting to Order • Amanda McKnight Grafton called the meeting to order at 4:32 p.m. • Ten (10) Commissioners were present with one (1) absent. 1. Approve Meeting Minutes • Barbara Westercamp made a motion to approve the minutes from September 18, 2014. Tim Oberbroeckling seconded the motion. The motion passed unanimously. Todd McNall arrived at 4:34 p.m. 2. Action Items a. DEMOLITION Applications i. 2816 Fruitland Boulevard SW – Private Property • Jeff Hintz stated the property was built in 1925 and is not eligible for the National Register. The property is out of character with the adjacent properties and is in poor condition. The owner would like to build a new house on the property. Pat Cargin arrived at 4:36 p.m. 1 • Tim Oberbroeckling made a motion to approve demolition of 2816 Fruitland Boulevard SW. Todd McNall seconded the motion. The motion passed unanimously. ii. 1533 Ellis Boulevard NW – Private Property • Mr. Hintz stated the property was built in 1900 and was flooded in 2008. The property was not gutted after the flood and is not eligible for the National Register. • Todd McNall made a motion to approve the demolition of 1533 Ellis Boulevard NW. Tim Oberbroeckling seconded the motion. The motion passed unanimously. 3. New Business a) 2015 Work Plan • Anne Russett identified the current goals and tasks of the HPC work plan and also identified new tasks to be incorporated into the 2015 Work Plan. • Barbara Westercamp made a motion to approve the 2015 HPC Work Plan. Tim Oberbroeckling seconded the motion. The motion passed unanimously. b) 2015 Preservation Showcase i. Develop sub-committee • Ms. McKnight-Grafton stated the showcase will be held in May. The location hasn’t been determined but the Vets Memorial Building has been offered as a location. • Discussion included logos, budget, outreach options, etc. Members of the commission volunteered to serve on various sub-committees. c) Industrial Building Nomination • Ms. Russett stated the Industrial Building nomination is part of a MOA. The Smulekoff’s warehouse building has been identified and the owner is interested. The 2nd choice for nomination is the City’s Water Building. d) LOA Update • Ms. Russett stated in order to mitigate the impact of 82 historic property demolitions and LOA was identified to nominate 12 properties to the National Register. Due to 14 of the 82 properties opting out of the buyout program, the LOA will be removed. 4. Old Business a) Local Landmarks • Mr. Hintz stated two nominations were sent to SHPO and comments should be received in October. The nominations will then go to City Planning Commission and City Council for recommendation. b) Demolition Applications UNDER REVIEW i. 1257 3rd Avenue SE – Private Property – November 17, 2014 • Mark Stoffer Hunter stated he is still completely intensive research on the property. Bob Grafton stated a consultant is looking into funding for relocation of the property. 5. Adjournment • Barbara Westercamp made a motion to adjourn the meeting at 5:54 p.m. Todd McNall seconded the motion. The motion passed unanimously. Respectfully Submitted, Alicia Abernathey, Administrative Assistant II Community Development 2 Historic Preservation Commission Agenda Item Cover Sheet Meeting Date: October 9, 2014 Property Location: 2200 West Post Road SW Property Owner/Representative: Ray Wacker Year Built: 1870 Description of Agenda Item: Demolition Application COA Other Background and Previous HPC Action: The applicant desires to have the structure demolished due to a fire that occurred at the property. The property is not significant and lacks any real defining features or unique characteristics. The original structure has been modified over the years and now includes aluminum siding and several additions. The property is nestled in a somewhat industrial and agricultural area, surrounded (in general) by fields and warehouses and storage facilities. Historic Eligibility Status: Eligible Not Eligible Unknown N/A Explanation (if necessary): The recently completed Citywide Reconnaissance Survey does not indicate the existence of historically eligible properties or districts in this area. If eligible, which criteria is met: Associated with significant historical events (Criteria A) Associated with significant lives of person (Criteria B) Signifies distinctive architectural character/era (Criteria C) Archaeologically significant (Criteria D) Other Action by City: Yes No N/A Explanation (if necessary): Recommendation: Immediate release. Rationale: Lack of historical or defining features on the property, desires of applicant, infill development potential and development patterns of the area. 1 Historic Preservation Commission Agenda Item Cover Sheet Meeting Date: October 9, 2014 Property Location: 1415 4th Street SW Property Owner/Representative: Platinum Development Year Built: 1900 Description of Agenda Item: Demolition Application COA Other Background and Previous HPC Action: The applicant desires to have the structure demolished due to dilapidation. The property is not significant and lacks any real defining features or unique characteristics. The applicant has indicated their future plans are to build a new structure on the lot. Historic Eligibility Status: Eligible Not Eligible Unknown N/A Explanation (if necessary): This property was surveyed by Louis Berger as a part of the 2009 Flood Reconnaissance Survey. This property is reported as not eligible and the survey also indicates the State Historic Preservation Office (SHPO) concurred with this evaluation. The recently completed Citywide Reconnaissance Survey does not indicate the existence of historically eligible properties or districts in this area. If eligible, which criteria is met: Associated with significant historical events (Criteria A) Associated with significant lives of person (Criteria B) Signifies distinctive architectural character/era (Criteria C) Archaeologically significant (Criteria D) Other Action by City: Yes No N/A Explanation (if necessary): Recommendation: Immediate release. Rationale: Lack of historical or defining features on the property, desires of applicant, infill development potential. 1 Community Development and Planning Department City Hall 101 First Street SE Cedar Rapids, IA 52401 Telephone: (319) 286-5041 To: Historic Preservation Commission Members From: Jeff Hintz, Planner II Subject: COA Request at 1734 Park Avenue SE Date: October 9, 2014 Applicant Name(s): Lorena Moes Local Historic District: Redmond Park-Grande Avenue Historic District Legal Description: BEVER PARK 3RD E 32.5' S 70' STR/LB 12 19 Year Built: 1914 Description of Project: Installation of a wooden fence up to three feet high in the front yard and a fence that is six feet high in the rear yard. Front yard fence would be picket in nature and the fence would have gates which would NOT be attached to the house. The finished side of the fence would face out; materials proposed include pressure treated wood, which would not be painted. Information from Historic Surveys on property: The 1995 Site Inventory Form from the District Nomination survey lists the property as “good” and “moderately well preserved” for integrity. The property is also listed as individually eligible for the National Register and contributing to the district. Excerpt(s) from Guidelines for Cedar Rapids Historic Districts Applicable to