Review of Air Quality Impacts Resulting from Particle Emissions from Poultry Farms
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Environment Defra Review of Air Quality Impacts Resulting from Particle Emissions from Poultry Farms Environment Defra Prepared by: .................Checked by: ................. Sam Pollard Gareth Collins Principal Environmental Scientist Technical Director Approved by: ...................... Michele Hackman Technical Director Review of Air Quality Impacts Resulting from Particle Emissions from Poultry Farms Rev No Comments Checked Approved Date by by 1 Draft for Bureau Veritas Comment GMC MPH July 2011 2 Revised to incorporate initial comments from Bureau Veritas GMC MPH July 2011 3 Revised to incorporate additional comments from Bureau Veritas GMC MPH September 2011 4 Revised to incorporate additional comments from Bureau Veritas GMC MPH September 2012 5 Final version GMC MPH October 2012 6 Final version incorporating BV amendments YV* YB* November 2012 * YV (Yasmin Vawda – Bureau Veritas), YB (Yvonne Brown – Bureau Veritas) 9th & 10th Floors, Sunley House, 4 Bedford Park, CR0 2AP Telephone: 020 8639 3500 Website: http://www.aecom.com Job No 60190372 Reference SJP Date Created November 2012 This document has been prepared by AECOM Limited for the sole use of our client (the “Client”) and in accordance with generally accepted consultancy principles, the budget for fees and the terms of reference agreed between AECOM Limited and the Client. Any information provided by third parties and referred to herein has not been checked or verified by AECOM Limited, unless otherwise expressly stated in the document. No third party may rely upon this document without the prior and express written agreement of AECOM Limited. f:\projects\environmental services - laqm services lot 1\laqm poultry farms\pm emissions from poultry farms 26112.doc Table of Contents 1 Introduction ....................................................................................................................................................................... 2 1.1 PM10 Criteria .......................................................................................................................................................... 2 2 Current Screening Criteria ............................................................................................................................................... 4 2.1 Environment Agency (EA) and Scottish Environment Protection Agency (SEPA) Regulation ............................... 4 2.2 Local Air Quality Management Technical Guidance .............................................................................................. 4 3 Summary of UK Poultry Industry ..................................................................................................................................... 7 3.1 Poultry Farming in England ................................................................................................................................... 7 3.2 Poultry Farming in Scotland ................................................................................................................................... 8 3.3 Poultry Farming in Wales ....................................................................................................................................... 8 3.4 Poultry Farming in Northern Ireland ....................................................................................................................... 8 4 Particulate Emissions from Poultry Farms ..................................................................................................................... 9 4.1 Poultry Housing and Ventilation ............................................................................................................................. 9 4.2 Sources of Particulate Emissions from Poultry Farms ........................................................................................... 9 4.3 Factors Affecting Particulate Emissions from Poultry Farms ............................................................................... 10 5 Assessment Methodology .............................................................................................................................................. 12 5.1 Review of Monitoring Studies .............................................................................................................................. 12 5.2 Estimating Poultry Farm Contribution .................................................................................................................. 12 6 Monitoring Studies .......................................................................................................................................................... 14 6.1 Monitoring Studies Undertaken for LAQM Purposes or by the EA ...................................................................... 14 6.2 Estimated Contribution of Poultry Farms to Daily Mean PM10 concentrations ..................................................... 19 6.3 Defra Funded Research Project .......................................................................................................................... 20 7 Emission Factors ............................................................................................................................................................ 23 7.1 Emission Factors Derived from Monitoring Studies ............................................................................................. 23 7.2 Emission Factors from Emissions Inventories ..................................................................................................... 24 7.3 Variation in Emission Rates over Time ................................................................................................................ 24 8 Discussion and Conclusions ......................................................................................................................................... 26 8.1 Origins and Suitability of LAQM.TG(09) Screening Criteria ................................................................................. 26 8.2 Further Evidence Provided By Recent Studies .................................................................................................... 26 8.3 Recommendations for updated Guidance ........................................................................................................... 31 8.4 Conclusions ......................................................................................................................................................... 32 References .................................................................................................................................................................................... 91 Appendix A: Poultry Farm Monitoring Studies ................................................................................................................................ 34 Appendix B: PM10 Increments from Poultry Farms ......................................................................................................................... 50 Appendix C: Terminology ............................................................................................................................................................... 90 Table 1: List of Local Authorities with Poultry Farms in Excess of LAQM.TG(09) Criteria ................................................................6 Table 2: Number of Holdings and Populations of Laying Birds, by Housing Type in 2009 ...............................................................7 Table 3: Poultry Numbers in Northern Ireland, 2010.........................................................................................................................8 Table 4: Location, Method and Duration of Monitoring Undertaken near poultry Farms for LAQM ................................................ 15 Table 5: Location, Method and Duration of Monitoring Undertaken near Poultry Farms by the EA ................................................ 15 Table 6: Poultry Farm Type and Capacity at which LAQM or EA Monitoring was undertaken ....................................................... 16 Table 7: Summary of Results of LAQM and EA Monitoring near UK Poultry Farms ....................................................................... 17 Table 8: Comparison of Monitoring Results to LAQM.TG(09) Screening Criteria ........................................................................... 18 Table 9: Estimated Incremental Contribution of Poultry Farms ....................................................................................................... 19 Table 10: Results of Defra Funded Research Project ..................................................................................................................... 21 Table 11: Estimated Poultry Farm Contribution from Results of Defra Poultry Farm Monitoring Study .......................................... 22 Table 12: Compilation of Emission Factors from Literature (modified from Roumeliotis and Van Heyst) ....................................... 23 Table 13: Estimates of PM10 Emission factors within Emission Inventories .................................................................................... 24 Table 14: Derivation of Scaling Factors from Monitoring Data ....................................................................................................... 28 Table 15: Comparison of Predicted and Measured Results Using Broiler Farm Ratios ................................................................