Minutes of 275th WRC meeting held on May l-2,2017

r-il| Part - III (2nd May 2Of7)

The 275th meeting of WRC was held on May 7-2t 20L7.

THE IVIEETING WAS ATTENDED BY THE FOLLOWING MEIYBERS:-

01 Dr. Louis Vernal State representative of Goa (Chairperson for this meetinq) 02 Prof. J.S. Grewal Member

03 Prof. Freny Tarapore Member

04 Shri Anil Bedge Member

05 Shri Prabhakar Shrivastava State representative of Madhya Pradesh

Shri Awadhesh Nayak Regional Director (Convener), WRC, NCTE, Bhooal

Shri L.S. Baghel, Member and the State Representatives of Chhattisgarh, and ; expressed their inability to attend the meeting. The Representatives of States/UTs of Daman & Diu and Dadra & Nagar Haveli did not give any information about their presence.

The RD informed that Shri Chandrashekhar Vazalwar, Chairperson WRC is not able to attend the meeting. The RD requested the Committee to nominate a member as a Chairperson for the 275th WRC meeting. The members unanimously nominated Dr. Louis Vernal as a Chairperson for the 275th WRC meeting.

At the outset, Shri Awadhesh Nayak, Regional Director and Convener, welcomed the Chairperson and all the members of WRC, NCTE to the 275th meeting of the WRC.

The Regional Director, being Convener of the WRC, presented each agenda item for consideration of the WRC.

The agenda were taken up as follows:-

275.1 Correction in the minutes ol 275rh Meeting of WRC (Part- I) The minutes of the 275th (Part-I) Meeting were confirmed by the Committee except for the Following Corrections:- i) Serial No, 67 (APP201660208 ID: 9832) :- Course name be read as D.Et.Ed. course and the decision be read as "LOI be issued for 2 units of D.El.Ed. course."

275.2 Action Taken Report of 274th Meeting of WRC The Action Taken Reports were noted

275.3 Policy decisions/letters received from NCTE Hqrs. National Council for Teacher Education (Recognition Norms and Procedure) A dment Regulations, 2017, notified on 28th April ,201-7 in the Gazette of noted,

29 Minutes of 275th WRC meeting held on May l-2,2017

MADHYA PRADESH 275.4.13 Consid eration of Reply of LOI/Show Cause Noti celClarification after LOI s. CODE NAME OF THE COURSE DECISION OF WRC NO NO. INSTITUTION 85. APP20166 ABVM COLLGE OF D. El . Ed. Show Cause Notice was issued to the 0220 EDUCATION, KHASRA NO institution regarding similarity of 238/2, VILLAGE VILLAGE building in this college as well as in ID: 10169 LAWAN (BADANPUR), another College in ABVM Group of STREET/ROAD BLOCK Colleges (APPg18). ATER, TOWN/CITY _ VILAGE LAWAN ( BADAN PU R), The institution has clarified that the 2 TA LU KA/ MAN DAL/ DISTRICT building are identical and has . BHIN D, PIN CODE submitted a verification certificate dt. 477OO1, MADHYA PRADESH 24/O4l2OL7 to this effect from the SDM, Bhind. Hence, LOI be issued for 1 unit of the D.El.Ed, course in view of the NCTE Hqrs. letter dt. LO/OZl2OL7 clarifying that "No additional intake be allowed beyond a total ol 2 units." A copy of the decision regarding the similarity of building together with the certificate from the SDM, Bhind be also sent to ABVM Group of Colleges (APP918).The Show Cause Notice issued to it is withdrar /n.

86. APP20166 R S INSTITUTE OF TEACHER D. El. Ed. The case file was seen. Consequent to 0080 EDU CATIO N the issue of LOI, the institution has vr LLAG E/TOW N/CrTY- submitted a list of 1 Principal and 15 ID:8765 CHAKJUGRU PURA, faculty members who are qualified and STREET/ROAD SUSHERA approved by the competent authority. MADAN PURA ROAD, TALU KA/ MAN DAL- Hence, Recognition be granted for BHADROLI GWALIOR, 2 units of the D.El.Ed. course from DISTRICT- GWALIOR, PIN the academic session 2OL7-2OL8. CODE- 474005, MADHYA PRADESH

MAHARASHTRA 2 5.7.4 Conslderation o Re of LOI s. CODE NAME OF THE COURSE DECISION OF WRC NO NO. INSTITUTION 87. APP2O16 H.G.M. AZAM COLLEGE OF B.Sc, B. Ed. The case file was seen. Consequent to 60156 EDU CATIO N, VI LLEG E the issue of LOI, the institution has STREET/ROAD-2390 K. B. submitted a staff profile of 12 faculty ID:8462 HIDAYATU LLHA ROAD, members. Out of these, Lecturer at TALU KA/MAN DAL- HAVELI, Serial t\to. 4 does not have the 30 Minutes of 275th WRC meeting held on May l-Z,Z0l7

s. CODE NAME OF THE COURSE DECISION OF WRC NO NO. INSTITUTION TOWN/CITY-PUNE, DIST. required 55o/o at PG level. PUNE, MAHARASHTRA. The institution should submit another staff profile duly approved by the Registrar/BCUD with proper seal and signature. The list should clearly mention the subjects at the PG level. The institution also needs to identify an HOD,

Hence, Clarification be obtained on the above grounds.

MADHYA PRADESH 275.4.13 Consideration of Reply of LOI/Show Cause Not celClarification after LOI s. CODE NAME OF THE COURSE DECISION OF WRC NO NO. INSTITUTION 88. APP15688 J M COLLEGE OF D. Et . Ed. The case file was seen. Consequent to EDUCATION, PLOT/KHASRA the issue of LOI, the institution has NO.449, VILLAGE JAIDA, submitted a list of 8 faculty members POST who are qualified and approved by the O FFICE/TE H SI L/TALU KA/ competent authority. DISTRICT - SHEOPUR, PIN CODE 476337, MADHYA Hence, Recognition be granted for PRADESH. l additional unit of the D,El.Ed. course from the academic session 20L7-2018.

89. APPz0166 JAIN COLLEGE OF D. El. Ed. The case file was seen. Consequent to 0257 EDUCATION, KHASRA NO the issue of LOI, the institution has 384, VILLAGE - MANDSAUR, submitted a list of 1 PrincipaUHOD and ID LO7 4L STREET/ROAD - MHOW 15 faculty members who are qualified NEEMUCH ROAD, and approved by the competent TA LU KA/ MAN DAL/TOW N/CIT authority. Y I DISTRICT . MAN DSAU R, PIN CODE - 45BOO1, Hence, Recognition be granted for MADHYA PRADESH l additiona! unit of the D.El.Ed. course from the academic session 20L7-2019.

90. APP3555 T.D. SHIKSHA B.Sc. B. Ed. The case file was seen. Consequent to MAHAVIDYALAYA, PLOT / the issue of LOI, the institution has KHASRA NO. 59/2, VILLAGE submitted a list of 1 Principal and 15 - SATPURA, POST OFFICE faculty members who are qualified and CHAKG HAT, ALLAHABAD approved by the competent authority. ROAD, TEHSIL I TALU KA However, Lecturer at Serial No, 4 does THYONTHAR, CIry-REWA, not have the required 55% at the PG DIST- REWA-486226, level. MADHYA PRADESH Also, from the experience certificate of 31

( t Minutes of 275th WRC meeting held on May 1-2,2017

s. CODE NAME OF THE COURSE DECISION OF WRC NO NO. INSTITUTION the Principal it is not clear whether all the experience is in Secondary Teacher Education institutions.

Hence, Clarification be obtained on the above grounds.

91. APP3557 T.D. EDUCATION COLLEGE, B.Sc. B. Ed. The case file was seen. Consequent to PLOT/KHASRA NO, L387 /L, the issue of LOI, the institution has t387 /2, L38713,L383/2, submitted a list of 1 Principal and 16 VILLAGE-LAXMANPUR, POST faculty members who are qualified and OFFICE-LAKSH MAN PU R, approved by the competent authority. SIRMAUR ROAD, TE H S I L/TA LU KA- RAI PU R However, from the experience KARCHULIYAN, CITY-REWA- certificate of the Principal it is not clear 486440, MADHYA PRADESH whether all the experience is in Secondary Teacher Education institutions.

Hence, Clarification be obtained on the above grounds.

92. APP20166 MGM COLLEGE OF D. P. S. E. The case file was seen. Consequent to o275 EDUCATION, KHASRA NO.: the issue of LOI, the institution has L4913, STREET/ROAD: submitted a list of 1 Principal and 15 ID: 10855 CHHONDA, faculty members who are qualified and TA LU KA/ MAN DAL+TOW N/CI approved by the competent authority. TY: MORENA, DISTRICT: MORENA.47600I, MADHYA Recognition be granted for 1 unit PRADESH of the D.P.S.E. course from the academic session 2O L7 -2Ot8.

93. APPP2O16 SHRI RAWATPURA SARKAR B.A.B.Ed. The case file was seen. Consequent to 60262 COLLEGE OF EDUCATION, the issue of LOI, the institution has KHASARA NO.: 66812, submitted a list of 1 HOD and 15 ID: 11042 STREET/ROAD: CHORAI TO faculty members who are qualified and NADIGON ROAD, approved by the competent authority, TALU KA/MAN DAL: LAHAR, TOWN/CITY: LAHAR, Hence, Recognition be granted for DISTRICT: BHIN D-457 446, 2 units of the B.A.B.Ed. course MADHYA PRADESH from the academic session 2OL7- 2018..\

32 Minutes of 275th WRC meeting held on May l-2,2017

CHHATTISGARH 275.6.4.6.+ Consideraticonsaderation of Replv of LOI/ShoW Cause Notice/Clarification after LOI s. CODE NAME OF THE COURSE DECISION OF WRC NO NO. INSTITUTION 94. APP3 148 SANSKAR CITY COLLEGE OF B, Ed. The case file was seen. Consequent to EDUCATION, PLOT NO. the issue of Clarification letter, the zolt & OTHERS, institution has a ppointed another STREET/ROAD- c.E. ROAD, Principal who is qualified and approved. VILLAGE -THAKURTOLA, POST OFFICE- Hence, Recognition be granted for RAJNANDGAON, DISTRICT- 2 units of the B.Ed. course from RAJ NAN DGAON, the academic session 2OL7-}OLA, CHHATTISGARH- 49L44T.

95. APP3 146 SANSKAR CITY COLLEGE OF D, EI. Ed. The case file was seen. Consequent to EDUCATIO N, PLOT N O. the issue of Clarification letter, the zO/L & OTHERS, institution has a ppointed a nother STREET/ROAD- G.E, ROAD, Principal who is qualified and approved. VILLAGE -THAKURTOLA, POST OFFICE- Hence, Recognition be granted for RAJNANDGAON, DISTRICT- 2 units of the D.El.Ed. course from RAJ NAN DGAON, the academic session 2OL7-2O18. CHHATTISGARH - 49I44T.

GUJARAT 275.6.5 Considerationsid of Reply_qf LOIlShow Cause Notice/Clarification after LOI s. CODE NAME OF THE COURSE DECISION OF WRC NO NO. INSTITUTION 96. APP755B DEPARTM ENT OF M.Ed. The case file was seen. Consequent to EDUCATION, C.U. SHAH the issue of LOI, the institution has UNIVERSITY, WADHWAN submitted a list of 2 Professors, 2 CITY, SURENDRANAGAR- Associate Professors and 6 Assistant Professors. Out of these it is seen that AHMADABAD HIGHWAY, the Associate Professor at serial no. 4 GUJARAT-363035 does not have the required 55o/o at PG level.

Secondly, the subjects at the PG level has not been indicated,

Further, a scrutiny of the M.Ed. college, Vadu (325054) does not show the name of Dr. Kiritkumar Babulal Vyas in the faculty list.

Hence, Clarification be obtained on the above grounds.

33u Minutes of 275th WRC meeting held on May l-2,2017

CHHATTISGARH 275.7.4 Consideration of Reolv of LOI/Show Cause Notice/Clarification after LOI s. CODE NAME OF THE COURSE DECISION OF WRC NO NO. INSTITUTION 97. APP8735 SHAILDEVI B.Sc. B, Ed, The case file was seen. Consequent to MAHAVIDYALAYA, PLOT NO. (4 Years the issue of LOI, the institution has 25135, KHASRA NO. 763 Integrated) submitted a list of 1 HOD and 9 faculty members who are qualified except for (NEW KHASRA NO. lecturer at serial no, 6 who does not 763/2), VILLEGE - ANDA, have the required 55o/o at the PG STREET/ROAD - JANJGIRI level. Recognition for 1 unit of can be ROAD, TALU KA/MAN DAL given excluding this lecturer. DURG, DISTRICT - DURG, CHHATTISGARH - 49L22T. However, the institution has not as yet submitted a Building Completion Certificate from a Govt. Engineer as was indicated vide WRO letter dt. 2elo4l2oL7.

Hence, Clarification be obtained on the above grounds.

98. APP3442 KRUTI SCHOOL OF B,Ed. The case file was seen. Consequent to BUSINESS MANAGEMENT, the issue of LOI, the institution has PLOT NO. 1560 AND OTHER, submitted a list of 1 Principal/HOD and VILLAGE- NARDAHA, POST 15 faculty members who are qualified OFFICE- NARDAHA, and approved by the competent TEHSIL/TALU KA- ARANG, authority, DISTRICT- RAIPU R, CHHATTISGARH- 493111 However, lecturer at serial no. 15 is shown against the post of Performing Arts but the individual Affidavit does not show any degree in Performing Arts,

Hence, Clarification be obtained on the above grounds.

99, APP3445 KRUTI SCHOOL OF D. EI, Ed. The case file was seen. Consequent to BUSINESS MANAGEMENT, the issue of LOI, the institution has PLOT NO. 1560 AND submitted a list of 1 Principal/HOD and OTHERS, VILLAGE- 15 faculty members who are qualified NARDAHA, POST OFFICE- and approved by the competent NARDAHA, TEHSIL/TALUKA- authority. ARANG, DISTRICT- RAIPUR, CHHATTISGARH- 493111 Hence, Recognition be grapted for 2 units of the D.El.Ed. course from the academ icr session 2O L7 -2OL8.

34 Minutes of 275th WRC meeting held on May 1-2,2017

GOA 275.6.8 Consideration of Reply of Clarification after LOI s. CODE NAME OF THE COURSE DECISION OF WRC NO NO. INSTITUTION 100. APP2596 GVMS DR. DATA VAIDYA M.Ed. The case file was seen. In the 261't COLLEGE OF EDUCATION, meeting of the WRC, the question of PLOT NO, -27 6/O, appointing lecturers on pro-rata basis STRE ETlROAD- FA RMAG U D I, was referred to the NCTE Hqrs. VILLAG E. BAN DO RA, POST OFFICE-PON DA, DIST. However, the NCTE Hqrs. vide letter NORTH GOA, GOA-403401 dt. 10/0tl2}17has communicated that such provision does not exist. This was communicated to the institution vide WRO letter dt. 0LlO3l2OL7,

The institution replied on t3/04/20L7 but it has not enclosed the list of staff appointed for the proposed M.Ed. course as per Regulations, 20L4. Show Cause Notice be issued for compliance of the norms.

CHHATTISGARH 2 5.7.4 Conslderation of Reolv of LOI s. CODE NAME OF THE COURSE DECISION OF WRC NO NO. INSTITUTION 101. APPBB94 DEV SANSKRITI COLLEGE D, EI. Ed. The case file was seen. Consequent to OF EDUCATION & (Add r. the issue of LOI, the institution has TECH NOLOGY, VILLAGE Intake) submitted a list of 1 HOD and 15 faculty members who are qualified and KHAPRI, STRE ETlROAD approved by the competent authority. DHAMDHA ROAD, TALUKA/MANDAL DURG, Hence, Recognition be granted for DISTRICT DURG, l additional unit of the D.El.Ed. CHHATTISGARH _ 491001 course from the academic session 20L7-2018.

MADHYA PRADESH 275.4.13 Consid eration of Reply of LOI/Show Cause Noti celClarification after LOI s. CODE NAME OF THt COURSE DECISION OF WRC NO NO. INSTITUTION LOz. APP20166 PT. BRIJKISHORE PATERIA B.A.B.Ed. The case file was seen. Consequent to 007 4 COLLEGE OF EDUCATION, the issue of LOI, the institution has VILLAGE: DEORI, submitted a list of 1 HOD and 15 faculty members who are qualified and ID: 8811 STREET/ROAD : KHAN DERAO approved by the competent authority WARD, TALU KA/MAN DAL: except for the lecturer at serial no. t2 DEORI, TOWN/CITY: DEORI, who does not have the required 55o/o DISTRICT: SAGAR-470226, at the Master's level. \ 35 \ Minutes of 275th WRC meeting held on May l-2,2017

S. CODE NAME OF THE COURSE DECISION OF WRC NO NO. INSTITUTION MADHYA PRADESH Since, the institution does not have the required number of faculty members for two units, Recognition be granted for 1 unit of the B.A. B. Ed. cou rse from the academic session 2O L7 -2Ot8.

103. APP20166 TIMES COLLEGE OF B.A.B.Ed, The case file was seen. Consequent to 0119 EDUCATION, VILLAGE: AAM the issue of LOI, the institution has CHOPRA, STREET/ROAD: submitted a list of 1 Principal and 15 ID : 10137 DAMOH, faculty members who are qualified and approved by the competent authority. TALU KA/MAN DAL+TOW N/CI However, L Lecturer in TY: DAMOH, DISTRICT: Performing/Fine Arts has not been DAMOH-47066T, MADHYA appointed as required under NCTE PRAD ES H Regulations, 20L4. Therefore, Recognition be granted only for l unit of the B.A.B.Ed. course from the academic session 20L7-2018.

104. APP2TBB SIDDHI VINAYAK COLLEGE, D. El . Ed. The case file was seen. Consequent to PLOT NO : 26012, 26t, the issue of LOI, the institution has STREET NO: T, VILLAGE: submitted a list of 1 Principal and 15 JAGMAL, POST OFFICE: faculty members who are qualified and JAGMAL, TEHSIL: BEOHARI, approved by the competent authority. CITY: JAGMAL, DISTRICT: SHAHDOL- 484776, MADHYA Hence, Recognition be granted for PRAD ES H 2 units of the D.El.Ed. course from the academic session 2OL7-2O18.

105. APP27 84 SIDDHI VINAYAK COLLEGE, B. Ed. The case file was seen. Consequent to PLOT NO: 26012, 26t, the issue of LOI, the institution has STREET NO : 1, VILLAGE : submitted a list of 1 Principal and 15 JAGMAL, POST OFFICE: faculty members who are qualified and JAGMAL, TEHSIL: BEOHARI, approved by the competent authority. CITY: JAGMAL, DISTRICT: SHAHDOL- 48477 6, MADHYA Hence, Recognition be granted for PRAD ES H 2 units of the B.Ed. course from the academic session 2OL7-2O18.

106. APP20166 HOPE INSTITUTE OF D, Et. Ed. The case file was seen. Consequent to 0087 TEACHER'S TRAINNING, the issue of LOI, the institqtion has SURVEY NO. 594, 598, 600, submitted a list of 1 Principal and 7 ID: 8330 faculty members who are qualified and 6L2, VILLAGE AALAM approved by the competent authority. PU RA, STRE ETIROAD JHANSI ROAD, Hence, Recognition be granted for TALU KA/MAN DAL I unit of the D.El.Ed. course from TIKAMGARH, TOWN/CIW the session 2OL7-2OL8. Tgademicit 36 A Minutes of 275th WRC meeting held on May l-2,2017

s. CODE NAME OF THE COURSE DECISION OF WRC NO NO. INSTITUTION AALAM PURA, DISTRICT TIKAMGARH, PIN CODE 472001, MADHYA PRADESH. to7 . APP3O92 COLLEGE OF ADVANCE B. Ed. The case file was seen. The WRO had STU DIES DATIA, KHAS RA sent copies of Challans supposedly to NO- 24691L2 MIN-1, PLOT have been submitted to the bank as NO- L2, STREET NO- 01, CLU receipt. There was 1 Challan VILLAGE- BIDNIA, POST which was supposed to have been OFFICE. DATIA, TEHSIL- credited in the head of account to DATIA, CITY- DATIA, 0029 and another identical Challan DISTRICT: DATIA- 47566L, supposedly credited to the head of MADHYA PRADESH account 2900 both on 30/0L/20t7. The manager of the State Bank, Datia where these Challans were deposited, has written a letter confirming that the Challan has not been deposited in the Branch on 30/0Llzot7 in the name of Mukesh Yadav, Secretary, Manshee Jan Kalyan Samiti for Rs. 8L,022 /-.

Hence, Show Cause Notice be issued to the institution as to why the Recognition should not be withdrawn on the above grounds under Section 17.

108. APP20166 GANDHI VOCATIONAL B,ED. M. Ed. The case file was seen. Consequent to 017e (A) COLLEGE, VILLAGE: the issue of LOI, the institution has KUSHMODA, STREET/ROAD: submitted a list of 1 Principal, 2 Professors, 2 ID:7500 A. B. ROAD, Associate Professors, and 6 Assistant Professors who are TALU KA/MAN DAL+ qualified and approved by the TOWN/CITY: GUNA, competent authority. DISTRICT: GUNA-47300L, MADHYA PRADESH Hence, Recognition be granted for 1 unit of the M.Ed. course from the academ ic session 2O L7 -2OL8.

109. APP20166 BALKAVI BAIRAGI TEACH ER B.A.B.Ed. The case file was seen. Consequent to 0222 (A) EDUCATIO N RESEARCH the issue of LOI, the institution has CENTER, VILLAGE: submitted a list of l HOD and 15 qualified ID: 10361 KANAWATI, STREET/ROAD: faculty members who are and approved by the competent ar:rthority. M HOW-NASIRABAD ROAD, TALU KA/MAN DAL: Hence, Recognition be granted for NEEMUCH, TOWN/CITY: 2 units of the B.A.B.Ed. course KANAWATI, DISTRICT: from the academic session 2OL7- NEEMUCH -45844L, MADHYA 2018, PRAD ES H o 37 Minutes of 275th WRC meeting held on May l-2,2017

s. CODE NAME OF THE COURSE DECISION OF WRC NO NO. INSTITUTION 1 10. APP20166 TATA SHIKSHA B.Sc. B. Ed. The case file was seen. Consequent to 0191 MAHAVIDYALAY, VILLAGE: the issue of LOI, the institution has SAGRA, STREET/ROAD: submitted a list of 1 Principal and 15 faculty members qualified ID : 8441 RAIPUR KARCHULIAN ROAD, who are and approved by the competent authority. TALUKA/MANDAL: HUZUR, TOWN/CITY: SAGRA, Hence, Recognition be granted for DISTRICT: REWA-486440, l unit of the B.Sc.B.Ed. course MADHYA PRADESH from the academic session 2Ot7- 20 18.

111. APP35O5 SUNRISE INSTITUTE OF D. El. Ed. The case file was seen. Consequent to EDUCATION, PLOT/KHASRA the issue of clarification letter, the NO.73l4, VILLAGE - DABKA, institution has submitted approved list POST for HOD. o FFr c E/TE H Sr L/TA LU KA/TO WN/CITY/DISTRICT Hence, Recognition be granted for GWALIOR, PIN CODE 2 units of the D,El.Ed. course from 474001, MADHYA PRADESH the academic session 2O17-2018.

LLz. APPz0166 COLLEGE, D. El . Ed. The case file was seen. Clarification 0300 INDORE, MADHYA PRADESH letter was issued regarding staff list. The institution has submitted a list of ID:9544 1 Principal and 15 faculty members who are qualified except for lecturers at serial no. 10 and 12 who are not to be appointed, Therefore, Recognition be granted for only l unit of the D.El.Ed. course from the academic session 20L7-2018.

1 13. APP2BB9 PATWA COLLEGE, PLOT NO: B.Sc. B. Ed. The case file was seen. Consequent to 131, VILLAGE: the issue of LOI, the institution has JHANJARWARA, POST submitted a combined list of 1 OFFICE: NEEMUCH, TEHSIL Principal and 15 faculty members who :NEEMUCH, DISTRICT: are qualified and approved by the NEEMUCH-45844L, MADHYA competent authority, for 1 unit of PRAD ES H B.Ed. and 1 unit of B.Sc.B.Ed. course.

However, the institution has not as yet appointed an HOD for the B.Sc.B.Ed. course.

Hence, Clarification be obtained on the above grounds.

38 Minutes of 275th WRC meeting held on May l-2,2017

s. CODE NAME OF THE COURSE DECISION OF WRC NO NO. INSTITUTION LL4, APP28B6 PATWA COLLEGE, PLOT NO: B. Ed. The case file was seen. This case will 131, VILLAGE: be considered as soon as the HOD is JHANJARWARA, POST appointed for the B.Sc.B.Ed. course. OFFICE: NEEMUCH, TEHSIL : NEEMUCH, DISTRICT : The institution be informed NEEMUCH.45B44I, MADHYA accordingly, PRADESH

CHHATTISGARH 275.7.4 Considerationon of Replve of LOI s. CODE NAME OF THt COURSE DECISION OF WRC NO NO. INSTITUTION 1 15. APP3O24 CH HATTISGARH COLLEG E B. Ed. The case file was seen. Consequent to OF EDUCATION, LAN D the issue of LOI, the institution has TITTLE- DURG EDUATION & submitted a list of 1 Principal and 16 CHARITABLE, PLOT NO.- faculty members who are qualified and 659, 660, STREET NO- PH approved by the competent authority. 28, VI LLAG E- D HAN O RA, POST OFFICE- DURG, Hence, Recognition be granted for DISTRICT.DURG, 2 units of the B.Ed. course from CH HATTISGARH - 491001 the academic session 2Ot7-2O18.

1 16. APP3O23 CH HATTISGARH COLLEG E D. El . Ed. The case file was seen. Consequent to OF EDUCATION, LAND the issue of LOI, the institution has TITTLE- DURG EDUATION & submitted a list of 1 HOD and 10 faculty qualified CHARITABLE, PLOT NO.- members who are and approved by the competent authority. 659, 660, STREET NO- PH 28, VILLAGE- DHANORA, Hence, Recognition be granted for POST OFFICE- DURG, 1 unit of the D.El.Ed. course from DISTRICT-DURG, the academic session 2OL7-2OL8. CH HATTISGARH - 491001

tL7. APP35 1B SAI SADAN EDUATION D. El . Ed. The case file was seen. Consequent to scHooL, PLoT NO. L53lL, the issue of LOI, the institution has 251L3 STREET NO. BENDRT, submitted a list of 1 Principal and 7 faculty members who are qualified and VILLAGE. BEN DRI, POST approved by the competent authority. OFFICE- ABHANPUR, TEHSIL/TALU KA- However, Recognition cannot be given ABHAN PU R, DISTRICT- until the institution's B. Ed. course RAIPU R, CH HATTISGARH- (APP3535) matures so as to fulfill 49200t clause 2(b) regarding composite institutions.

The institution be informed as above.

39 Minutes of 275th WRC meeting held on May l-2,2017

MADHYA PRADESH 275.4.13 Consideration of Reolv of LOI/Show Cause Noti celClarification after LOI s. CODE NAME OF THE COURSE DECISION OF WRC NO NO. INSTITUTION 118. APP20166 FI RDOS CO LLEG E O F D. El. Ed. The case file was seen. Consequent to 0208 EDUCATION, KHASRA NO the issue of LOI, the institution has L8L0l2 MIN L, LBtOl2 MrN submitted a list of t Principal and 15 ID: 9832 L, LSLL/2 MIN 2, 1811/1 faculty members who are qualified and TO LSLL/7, VILLAGE approved by the competent authority, KUELITH, STREET/ROAD MOTIJHEEL, TOWN/CITY Hence, Recognition be granted for KU LEITH , 2 units of the D.El.Ed. course from TA LU KA/ MAN DAL/ DISTRICT the academic session 2017-2OLA. - GWALIOR, PIN CODE 474010, MADHYA PRADESH 119. APP20 166 FIRDOS COLLEG E OF B.A.B,Ed, The case file was seen. Consequent to 0215 EDUCATION, VILLAGE: the issue of LOI, the institution has KULEITH, STREET/ROAD: submitted a list of 1 Principal and 15 faculty qualified MOTIJHEEL, members who are and approved by the competent authority. ID: 9792 TALU KA/MAN DAL: GWALIOR, TOWN/CITY: Hence, Recognition be granted for GWALIOR, DISTRICT: 2 units of the B.A.B.Ed. course GWALIOR-474OL0, MADHYA from the academic session 2Ot7- PRADES H 20 18.

120. APP20166 ST. ALOYSIUS INSTITUTE B. Ed. The case file was seen. Consequent to 0130 OF TECH NOLOGY, the issue of LOI, the institution has STREET/ROAD: GOU RAIYA submitted a list of l HOD and 15 ID:10142 GHAT, MANDLA ROAD, faculty members who are qualified. TA LU KA/ MAN DAL+TOW N/CI TY: JABALPUR, DISTRICT: However, the list is not approved by JABALPUR.482OO1, MADHYA the competent authority. PRAD ES H Clarification be obtained on the above grounds. tzL. APP20166 ST. ALOYSIUS INSTITUTE D. El. Ed. The case file was seen. Consequent to 0130 OF TECHNOLOGY, the issue of LOI, the institution has STREET/ROAD: GOURAIYA submitted a list of l HOD and 15 ID:10142 GHAT, MANDLA ROAD, faculty members who are qualified. TA LU KA/ MAN DAL+TOW N/CI TY: JABALPUR, DISTRICT: However, Recognition cannot be JABALPUR-482001, MADHYA granted unless the B. Ed. course PRAD ES H matures so as to comply with Clause 2(b) reqardinq composite institutions.

40 Minutes of 275tt' WRC meeting held on May l-2,2017

MAHARASHTRA 275.7,4 Consideration of Re of LOI s. CODE NAME OF THE COURSE DECISION OF WRC NO NO. INSTITUTION t22, APP20166 TATA INSTITUTE OF SOCIAL B,Ed.M.Ed. The case file was seen. Consequent to 0186 SCI ENCES, VILLAG E- the issue of LOI, the institution has DEONAR, STREET/ROAD- informed that the recruitment is still V.N.PURAV MARG, under process. TALU KA/MAN DAL- DEONAR, TOWN/CITY-DEONAR, Hence, Show Cause Notice be DIST,-GR, , issued on the above grounds. MAHARASHTRA

MADHYA PRADESH 275.4.5.4.5 ConsiderationUOnS on ofor replyrepry receivedrecetveq inrn compliancecompilance to Showw uauseCause NotiNof,tce s. CODE NAME OF THE COURSE DECISION OF WRC NO NO. INSTITUTION t23. APP3491 SHIN E COLLEGE OF D. El . Ed. The case file was seen. A complaint EDUCATION, PLOT/ KHASRA has been received from Firdos College NO-18L0/2, 1811/t, 2, 3, 4, of Education, Gwalior that illegal methods were used Firdos 5, 6, 7, STREET- KULAITH, to show College building as the 'Shine College VI LLAG E. KU LAITH, POST of Education'. OFFICE. KULAITH, TEHSIL- GWALIOR, CITY- GWALIOR, The VT which had visited the Shine DISTRICT: GWALIOR- College on 30th April, 2OL6 had 474009, MADHYA PRADESH reported that it could not find the institution on the site mentioned, The VT also gathered the same information from the local public. The College has alleged that the VT members demanded money.

Show Cause Notice be issued as to why the Recognition should not be refused under Section L7 of the NCTE Act, for both the courses D.EI.Ed, (APP3491) and B.Ed. (APP34gg).

MADHYA PRADESH 275.4,13 Consideration of Replv of LOI/Show Cause Noti celClarification after LOI s. CODE NAME OF THE COURSE DECISION OF WRC NO NO. INSTITUTION t24. APP20 1 66 ANGIRA COLLEGE OF B.A,B.Ed. The case file was seen. Consequent to 0103 EDUCATION, KHASRA NO.: the issue of LOI, the institution has L47 152912, L47 1530, submitted a list of 1 HOD and 15 ID: 8927 STREET/ROAD: NH 76 faculty members who are qualified and NIWARI BHATA, approved by the competent authority. P.O./TEHSIL: NIWARI, DISTRICT: TIKAMGARH- Hence, Recognition be granted for NIWARI - 47566L, MADHYA 2 unl,ts of the B.A.B. Ed. course 41, Minutes of 275th WRC meeting held on May t-2,2017

s. CODE NAME OF THE COURSE DECISION OF WRC NO NO. INSTITUTION PRAD ES H from the academic session 2Ot7- 20 18.

L25. APP2915 ANGIRA COLLEGE OF B. Ed. The case file was seen, Consequent to EDUCATION, KHASRA NO.: the issue of LOI, the institution has L47 /52912, L47 /530, submitted a list of 1 Principal and 15 STREET/ROAD: NH 76 faculty members who are qualified and NIWARI BHATA, approved by the competent authority. P.O,/TEHSIL: NIWARI, DISTRICT: TIKAMGARH- Hence, Recognition be granted for NIWARI - 47566I, MADHYA 2 units of the B.Ed. course from PRAD ES H the academic session 2OL7-2O18. t26. APP2425 ANGI RA CO LLEG E O F D. El. Ed. The case file was seen. Consequent to EDUCATION, KHASRA NO.: the issue of LOI, the institution has L47 1529/2, L47 1530, submitted a list of HOD and 15 faculty STREET/ROAD: NH 76 members who are qualified. However, NIWARI BHATA, the list is approved by someone "For P.O./TEHSIL: NIWARI, Principal" from Govt. Education DISTRICT: TIKAMGARH- College, Chhatarpur, M.P. which is not NIWARI - 47566T, MADHYA acceptable. PRAD ES H Hence, Show Cause Notice be issued on the above ground.

The staff list be sent to Rajya Shiksha Kendra for verification.

t27. APP20166 BARDOLI COLLEGE, B.A.B.Ed. The case file was seen. Consequent to 0194 VILLAGE: LAKHERA, the issue of LOI, the institution has STREET/ROAD: MURWARA submitted a list of 1 Principal and 15 ID: 10629 ROAD, TALUKA/MANDAL: faculty members. However, the MURWARA, TOWN/CITY: Registrar of the University has not LAKH ERA, DISTRICT: approved the list saying that the KATNI.4835O1, MADHYA appointments were not made as per PRAD ES H Code 28.

Hence, Show Cause Notice be issued on the above qrounds. 128. APP20166 MAHARSHI PANINI B.A,B.Ed. The case file was seen. Consequent to 0049 SANSKRIT EVAM VEDIC the issue of LOI, the institution has VISHWAVIDHYALAYA, not submitted the list containing the names of the Principal and faculty ID: 7596 VILLAGE: UJJAIN, members approved by the cofnpetent STREET/ROAD: DEWAS authority on the proforma provided by ROAD, the NCTE specifying therein the TA LU KA/ MAN DAL+TOW N/CI subjects at the PG and M.Ed. level TY: UJJAI N, DISTRICT: together with percentages alongwith UJJAIN-456010, MADHYA affidavits. PRADESH Hence, Show Cause Nolice be issued on the above qrorrfds. 42 Minutes of 275th WRC meeting held on May l-2,2017

s. CODE NAME OF THE COURSE DECISION OF WRC NO NO. INSTITUTION 729. APP20166 SH RI GAJANAN SHIKSHA B.Sc. B. Ed. The case file was seen. Consequent to 0190 SAMITI COLLEGE, KHASRA the issue of LOI, the institution has NO.: t4O/3,VILLAGE: submitted a list of 1 Principal and 15 ID:10828 KIWLARI, STREET/ROAD: faculty members who are qualified and KIWLARI, TALUKA/MANDAL approved by the competent authority. +TOWN/CITY: SOHAGPUR, DISTRICT: HOSHANGABAD- Hence, Recognition be granted for 46L771, MADHYA PRADESH 2 units of the B.Sc.B.Ed. course from the academic session 2OL7- 20 18.

1 30. APP20166 NIRMALA COLLEGE OF B.Sc. B. Ed. The case file was seen. Consequent to 0160 EDUCATION, SURVEY NO. the issue of LOI, the institution has 44, 45, 46, 49, 50, 51, 52, submitted a list of 1 Principal/HOD and 15 faculty qualified ID:9521 95,96, t04,105 & 109, members who are and approved by the competent VILLAGE- PREM NAGAR, authority. STREET/ROAD- DEWAS ROAD, TALU KA/MANADAL- Hence, Recognition be granted for UJJAIN, TOWM /CrW- PREM l unit of the B.Sc.B,Ed. course NAGAR, CHANDESSARY, from the academic session 2OL7- DISTRICT- UJJAIN- 456664, 20 19, MADHYA PRADESH

131. APP20166 NIRMALA COLLEGE OF D. El. Ed. The case file was seen. Consequent to 0160 EDUCATION, SURVEY NO. the issue of LOI, the institution has 44, 45, 46, 49, 50, 51, 52, submitted a list of 1 HOD and 9 faculty ID members qualified :9521 95,96, L04,105 & 108, who are and approved by the competent authority. VILLAGE- PREM NAGAR, STREET/ROAD- DEWAS Hence, Recognition be granted for ROAD, TALU KA/MANADAL- I unit of the D,El.Ed. course from UJJAIN, TOWM lcrfl- PREM the academic session 2OL7-2OL8. NAGAR, CHANDESSARY, DISTRICT- UJJAIN- 456664, MADHYA PRADESH

132. APP20166 N I RMALA CO LLEG E O F B. Ed. The case file was seen. Consequent to 0160 EDUCATION, SURVEY NO. the issue of LOI, the institution has 44, 45, 46, 49, 50, 51, 52, submitted a Iist of 1 Principal and 9 faculty ID :9521 95, 96, LO4, 105 & 108, members who are approved by the competent authority. However, it VILLAGE- PREM NAGAR, is seen that the Principal .does not STREET/ROAD- DEWAS have the required Ph.D. degree. ROAD, TALU KA/MANADAL- UJJAIN, TOWM/CITY- PREM Hence, Clarification be obtained on NAGAR, CHANDESSARY, the above grounds. DISTRICT- UJJAIN- 456664, MADHYA PRADESH

43 Minutes of 275th WRC meeting held on May l-2,2017

s. CODE NAME OF THE COURSE DECISION OF WRC NO NO. INSTITUTION 1 33. APP15681 MAHARANA PRATAP B.ED. B. Ed. The case file was seen. Consequent to CoLLEGE, PLOT NO- 474/4, the issue of LOI, the institution has STRE ET: WARD N O- 01 , submitted a list of 1 Principal and 7 VILLAGE- JAISINAGAR, faculty members who are qualified and POST OFFICE- JAISINAGAR, approved by the competent authority, TEHSIL- SAGAR, CITY- SAGAR, DISTRICT: SAGAR- Hence, Recognition be granted for 470T25, MADHYA PRADESH 1 unit of the B,Ed. course from the academ ic sessi on 2OL7-2018. t34. APP20166 FACULTY OF EDUCATION, B,A. B. ED. The case file was seen. Clarification 000 1 SRI SAI UNIVERSIW letter was issued to the institution for OF TECH NOLOGY AN D submission of latest premium receipt lD:7044 M EDICAL SCIENCES, for CLU. VILLAGE: ABDULLAPUR, STREET/ROAD: SH- 18, The institution has complied. BH O PAL I N DO RE ROAD, TALUKA/ MANDAL: SEHORE, Hence, Recognition be granted for TOWN/CITY: ABDU LLAPU R, 2 units of the B.A.B.Ed. course DISTRICT : S E H O RE-46600 1, from the academic session 2OL7- MADHYA PRADESH 20 18.

1 35. APP20166 COM P FEEDERS TAKNIKI, D. Et. Ed. The case file was seen. Consequent to 0206 PRASHIKSHAN SANSTHA, the issue of LOI, the institution has KHASRA NO - 582/L, 58213, submitted a list of 1 Principal and 15 ID:9927 faculty members who are qualified and 58214 VTLLAG E approved by the competent authority. RANGWASA, STREET/ROAD- RANGWASA ROAD, Hence, Recognition be granted for DISTRICT -IN DORE, PIN 2 units of the D.El.Ed. course from CODE 452009, MADHYA the academic session 2OL7-2OL8. PRADES H It is clarified here that this is not a case for sanction of additional unit.

MAHARASHTRA 275.4.5 Considerationn eraEtC,n of Visitintrst Teameam Reoorts s. CODE NAME OF THE COURSE DECISION OF WRC NO NO. INSTITUTION 1 36. APP3OOT ST. TERESA'S INSTITUTION M. Ed. The case file was seen. The W visited OF EDUCATION, the institution on 28/04120L7 and SANTACRUZ, MUMBAI 29104/25017. The CD was seen and VTR perused. The CD shows a good building with good instructional and infrastructural facilities. The VT has recommended the case. Hence, LOI be issued for 1 unit of the M,Ed. course. C\ 44 Minutes of 275th WRC meeting held on May l-2,2017

MADHYA PRADESH 275.4.L3.1 Consideratin eration of Reply of LOll Show Cause Noti celClarification after LOI s. CODE NAME OF THE COURSE DECISION OF WRC NO NO. INSTITUTION 137 . APP20166 LIBERAL COLLEGE OF D. El. Ed. The case file was seen. Consequent to oL77 EDU CATIO N, VI LLAG E the issue of LOI, the institution has PIGDAMBER RAU, submitted a list of 1 Principal and 16 ID: 9829 STREET/ROAD IIM ROAD, faculty members who are qualified and TALU KA/MAN DAL M HOW, approved by the competent authority. TOWN/CITY PIGDAM BER MU, DISTRICT INDORE, Hence, Recognition be granted for PIN CODE 453331, l additional unit of the D.El.Ed. MADHYA PRADESH course from the academic session 20L7-2019.

CHHATTISGARH

27 5.7aa .5a Considerationns ra n of non-compilance of Show Ca use Noti ce s. CODE NAME OF THE COURSE DECISION OF WRC NO NO. INSTITUTION 1 38. APPT 547 SH RI MAHANT LALDAS D. Et . Ed. The case file was seen. Show Cause EDU CATIO N CO LLEG E, Notice was issued to the institution on VILLAGE. SHEORINARAYAN, various grounds. STRE ETIROAD- BI LAS PU R The institution has not replied so far. ROAD, TALUKA/MANDAL NAWAGARH, TOWN/CITY- The attention of the institution is SHEORINARAYAN, drawn to the fact that most of the DISTRICT- JANJGIR documents called for the D.El.Ed. CHAM PA, CH HATTISGARH - course are available in the file of their 495557 B.Ed. course (723L39). The institution is required to send all the documents necessary, within 30 days failing which Recognition will be refused.

MADHYA PRADESH 275.4,13 Considerationide of Reply of LOll Show Cause Not celClarification after LOI s. CODE NAME OF THE COURSE DECISION OF WRC NO NO. INSTITUTION 1 39. APP20166 RAJENDRA SURI D. El. Ed. The case file was seen. Consequent to 0292 SHIKSHA the issue of LOI, the institution has MAHAVIDHYALAYA, submitted a list of 1 Principal and 9 ID: 1 L452 VILLAGE: GURADIYA DEDA, faculty members who are qualified and approved by the competent authority. STREET/ROAD: M HOW- NEEMUCH ROAD, Hence, Recognition be granted for TALUKA/MANDAL: 1 unit of the D.El.Ed. course from MAN DSAU R, TOWN/CITY: the academicn session 2OL7-2OL8. tr\ 45 Minutes of 275th WRC meeting held on May l-2,2017

s, CODE NAME OF THE COURSE DECISION OF WRC NO NO. INSTITUTION GURADIYA DEDA, DISTRICT: MANDSAUR- 458002, MADHYA PRADESH

140. APP20166 ACHARYA RAJENDRA SURI B. Ed. The case file was seen. Consequent to 0259 SHIKSHA the issue of LOI, the institution has MAHAVIDHYALAYA, submitted a list of 1 Principal/HOD and ID: 1L24O VILLAGE: GURADIYA DEDA, 9 faculty members who are qualified and approved by the competent STREET/ROAD: M HOW- authority. NEEMUCH ROAD, TALU KA/MAN DAL: Hence, Recognition be granted for MANDSAUR, TOWN/CIW: 1 unit of the B.Ed. course from the GURADIYA DEDA, academic session 2O L7 -2OL8. DISTRICT: MANDSAUR- 45BOO2, MADHYA PRADESH

t41. APP20 1 66 ACHARYA RAJENDRA SURI B.A.B.Ed. The case file was seen. Consequent to 0259 SHIKSHA the issue of LOI, the institution has MAHAVIDHYALAYA, submitted a list of 1 Principal, 1 HOD ID: 1L240 VILLAGE: GURADIYA DEDA, and 8 faculty members who are qualified and approved by the STREET/ROAD: M HOW- competent authority. NEEMUCH ROAD, TALU KA/MAN DAL: Hence, Recognition be granted for MANDSAUR, TOWN/CITY: 1 unit of the B.A,B.Ed. course from GURADIYA DEDA, the academic session 2OL7-2OI-A. DISTRICT: MANDSAUR- 458002, MADHYA PRADESH t42. APP20166 POONAMCHAND GUPTA B.Sc. B. Ed. The case file was seen. Consequent to 0065 VOCATIONAL COLLEGE, the issue of LOI, the institution has SURVEY NO, B. NO. submitted a list of 1 Principal, and B ID: 7560 70lP.NO. L7, B.NO. faculty members out of which lecturer 73/P.NO.01, STREET/ROAD : at serial no. 3 is not qualified. Also, 33 CIVIL LINES, the list is not approved by the TALU KA/MAN DAL + competent authority. Further, the TOWN/CITY: KHANDWA, Principal has also not been designated. DISTRICT: KHANDWA. 45OOO1, MADHYA PRADESH Hence, Show Cause Notice be issued on the above grounds. t43. APP259B VIVEKANAND DED COLLEGE, D. El. Ed. The case file was seen. Show Cause KHASRA NO. tltlL, 286/3, Notice was issued regarding 28615, 287, LAND TITLE percentage at PG level of the Principal and 2 faculty members. H BP MAHAJAN CHARITABLE TRUST, PLOT NO. 1315, The institution has appointed new STREET 26, NUMBER faculty members but the list is VI LLAG E/POST O FFIC E approved by lhe Principal, DIET Seoni

46 \ Minutes of 275th WRC meeting held on May l-Z,2Ol7

s. CODE NAME OF THE COURSE DECISION OF WRC NO NO. INSTITUTION KH U RSARA, who is not authorized. Therefore, the TEHSTL/TALU KA/TOWN/ two lists submitted - one on CITY KEWLARI, DISTRICT Ot/Ot/2OL7 and the one submitted now the SEONI, PIN CODE are not approved by competent authority. 480996, MADHYA PRADESH Hence, Clarification be obtained on the above ground.

CHHATTISGARH 275.7.4 Considerationns of Replv of LOI S. CODE NAME OF THE COURSE DECISION OF WRC NO NO. INSTITUTION L44. APP344B CMDPGCOLLEGE, D. Et. Ed. The case file was seen. Consequent to PLOT/KHASRA NO.558/1, the issue of LOI, the institution has STREET NUMBER LINK submitted a list of 1 Principal and 15 faculty members who are qualified and ROAD, VILLAG E approved by the competent authority. BILASPUR, POST OFFICE BILAS PU R, TEHSIL/TALU KA Hence, Recognition be granted for BILASPUR, DISTRICT 2 units of the D.El.Ed. course from BILAS PU R, the academic session 2OL7-2OL8. CHHATTISGARH- 495001

MADHYA PRADESH 275.4.13 Consideration of Replv of LOll Show Cause Noti celClarification after LOI s. CODE NAME OF THE COURSE DECISION OF WRC NO NO. INSTITUTION 145, APP20166 RANI COLLEGE OF B.A. B. Ed. The case file was seen. Consequent to 0116 EDU CATIO N, VI LLAG E : the issue of LOI, the institution has submitted list RAUSAR, STREET/ROAD : a of 6 faculty members who are qualified ID :9363 TIGER SAFFARI ROAD, but not approved by the competent authority. Staff has not TALUKA/MANDAL: HUZUR, been appointed as per requirement TOWN/CITY: RAUSAR, specified in Appendix-13 of the NCTE DISTRICT: REWA 486006, Regulations, 20L4. MADHYA PRADESH Hence, Show Cause Notice be issued on the above grounds. t46. APP20166 SH RI KRISH NA TEACH ER'S B.Sc. B. Ed. The case file was seen. Consequent to 0090 TRAINING INSTITUTE, the issue of Clarification letter, the VI LLAG E : GAU RAIYA, institution has opted for the B.Sc.B.Ed. course, The institution a ID: 9238 STREET/ROAD: SATAI has submitted list of 1 Principal a nd 15 faculty TALUKA/MANDAL: ROAD, members who are qualified and CHHATAPUR, TOWN/CITY: 47 Minutes of 275th WRC meeting held on May l-2,2017

NAME OF THE DECISION OF WRC INSTITUTION GAU RAIYA, DISTRICT: approved by the competent authority. CH HATARPU R-471001, MADHYA PRADESH Hence, Recognition be granted for 2 units of the B.Sc.B.Ed. course from the academic session ZOLI- 20 18.

APP20166 MRC COLLEGE OF B.A.B.Ed. The case file was seen, Show Cause 0267 EDUCATION, VILLAGE: Notice was issued on the ground that SHYAMPUR, STREET/ROAD: subjects at the PG level were not ID:9627 T37, MUKHTAR NAGAR, mentioned. TALU KA/MAN DAL+ The institution has now submitted list TOWN/CITY: SHYAM PU R, with subjects at the PG level. DISTRICT: SEHORE -46665L, MADHYA PRADESH Hence, Recognition be granted for 1 unit of the B.A.B.Ed. course from the academic session 2OL7-2OL8.

148, APP20166 N I RMALA D EVI D EG REE B.A.B.Ed. The case file was seen. Show Cause 0L24 COLLEGE, VILLAGE: AT Notice was issued on the ground that KAN HARGAON, the list was not approved by the ID: 8429 STREET/ROAD: POST JAAM, competent authority. TALU KA /MAN DAL: SEONI, Now the institution has submitted a TOWN/CITY: SEONI, list of l Principal and 15 faculty DISTRICT: SEONI-480661, members who are now approved by MADHYA PRADESH the competent authority,

Hence, Recognition be granted for 2 units of the B.A.B.Ed. course from the academic session 2OI-7- 20 19.

APP3468 SRI NARAYAN COLLEGE OF B.Sc. B. Ed. The case file was seen, Consequent to EDUCATION PORSA, the issue of LOI, the institution has KHASARA N O , 77 612, 777 , submitted a list of 1 Principal and 10 778, 740, 758, 75911 PLOT faculty members who are qualified and NO.: 244, STREET/ROAD: approved by the competent authority. WARD NO. 10, VILL.: PORSA, P.O,: PORSA, Hence, Recognition be granted for TEH./TAL. : PORSA, 1 unit of the B.Sc.B.Ed* course TOWN/CITY: PORSA, DIST.: from the academic session 2OL7- MORENA _ 476L15, MADHYA 2019.

PRAD ES H . Minutes of 27Sth WRC meeting held on May l-2,,2017

CHHATTISGARH 275.7.4 Considerationnstoera ofo Replv of LOI s. CODE NAME OF THE COURSE DECISION OF WRC NO NO, INSTITUTION 1 50. APP2892 GD RUNGTA COLLEGE OF M.Ed. The case file was seen. Consequent to SCIENCE AN D the Show Cause Notice issued on TECH NOLOGY, 0LlO3l2OL7, the institution has PLOT/KHASRA NO. LL39/2, submitted a list of 2 Professors, 2 Associate Professors, and Assistant Lt39/4, LL3gl6, L140/2, 6 Professors who are qualified and STREER NUMBER - KOHAKA approved by the competent authority. ROAD, VILLAGE KURUD, POST OFFICE JAMUL Hence, Recognition be granted for CEMENT WORKS, 1 unit of the M.Ed. course from the TEHSIL/TALUKA DURG, academic session 2O L7 -2OL8. DISTRICT DURG, CHHATTISGARH- 490024.

MADHYA PRADESH

27 5.4.8a Considerationon eratlon of Com int Case s, CODE NAME OF THE COURSE DECISION OF WRC NO NO. INSTITUTION 151. APP20166 SBS COLLEGE, VILLAGE D. El . Ed. The case file was seen. Show Cause 0L64 585, STREET/ROAD NH Notice was issued to the institution 75, TALUKA/MANDAL regard ing the unsigned com plaint ID 97 48 NEAR ANGOORI BARAAJ, about the building. TOWN/CrTY 858, DISTRICT DATIA, PIN The Committee viewed the CDs of SB CODE 47566L, MADHYA College (APP2401) and the current PRAD ES H application of SBS College (ID:97a8) and the Affidavit submitted by the institution was considered.

After detail scrutiny, it has been found that both College buildings are separate and therefore, there is no substance in the complaint, The Committee thereafter considered the staff list submitted by the institution. The list consists 1 Principal and 15 faculty members who are qualified and approved by the competent authority Hence, Recognition be granted for 2 units of the D.El.Ed. course from the academic session 2OL7-2OL8, \\

49 Minutes of 275th WRC meeting held on May l-Z,Z0l7

MADHYA PRADESH 275.4,13 Considerationide of Reply of LOI/Show Cause Not celClarification after LOI s. CODE NAME OF THE COURSE DECISION OF WRC NO NO. INSTITUTION t52. APP27 L5 ASPIRE INSTITUTE, PLOT D. El . Ed. The case file was seen. Consequent to NO- 45312, STREET- the issue of LOI, the institution has KHANDWA ROAD, POST submitted a list of 1 Principal and 16 qualified OFFICE- INDORE, TEHSIL- faculty members who are and approved by the competent authority. INDORE, CITY- INDORE, However, the Principal is common to DISTRICT: INDORE- both the B.Ed. and the D.El.Ed. 452001, MADHYA PRADESH courses. The institution needs to appoint an HOD.

Hence, Clarification be obtained on the above grounds.

1 53. APP2724 AS PI RE I N STITUTE, PLOT B. Ed. The case file was seen. Consequent to NO- 453/2, STREET- the issue of LOI, the institution has KHANDWA ROAD, POST submitted a list of 1 Principal and 16 faculty members. OFFICE- IN DORE, TEHSIL- Out of these, faculty members at serial no. 5 and 14 do not INDORE, INDORE, CIry- have the required 3 years experience DISTRICT: INDORE- at school. Hence, are not qualified. 452001, MADHYA PRADESH Recognition can be considered as soon as the application for the D.El.Ed. course matures. 1 54. APP20166 SARDAR AJ E ET SING H B. Ed. The case file was seen. Consequent to 0086 MEMORIAL COLLEGE, the issue of LOI, the institution has SURVEY NO. L4/L, VILLAGE- submitted a list of 1 Principal and 15 faculty members who qualified ID: 9070 AGARIYA CHOPDA, are and approved by the competent authority. STREET/ROAD- RAISEN, TALUKA/MANDAL- RAISEN, Hence, Recognition be granted for TOWN/CrTY- AGARIYA 2 units of the B.Ed. course from CHOPDA, DISTRICT- the academic session 2OL7-2OL8. RAISEN - 46455L, MADHYA PRAD ES H

1 55. APP20166 NAVAM BEY CO LLEG E OF B,A.B.Ed. The case file was seen. Consequent to 0113 ED U CATIO N, VILLAGE: the issue of LOI, the institution has PU RWA BARELA, submitted a list of 1 Principal and 15 ID:8191 faculty members who are qualified. STREET/ROAD: KH sl3, TA LU KA/ MAN DA L: However, the Registrar of the JABALPUR, TOWN/CIW: University has not approved the list PURWA BARELA, DISTRICT: saying that the appointments were not JABALPUR-483001, MADHYA made as per Code 28. PRADES H Hence, Show Cause Notice be issued on the, above qrounds.

50 Minutes of 275th WRC meeting held on May l-2,2017

s. CODE NAME OF THE COURSE DECISION OF WRC NO NO. INSTITUTION 1 56. APP3333 VEER NARAYAN B. Ed. The case file was seen. Show Cause MAHAVID HYALAYA, PLOT Notice was issued on the ground that NO- 220 /2, VTLLAGE- PANDU the list was not approved by the Registrar. PIPARIYA, POST OFFICE- TAMIA, TEHSIL- TAMIA, The institution has now submitted a CITY- TAMIA, DISTRICT- list of 1 Principal and 9 faculty CHHINDWARA- 480559, members who are qualified and now MADHYA PRADESH approved by the Registrar. Hence, Recognition be granted for 1 unit of the B,Ed. course from the academic session 2O 17 -2OL8. t57 . APP159 SHARDA DEVI SHIKSHA B. Ed. The case file was seen. Clarification MAHAVIDYALAYA, PLOT NO.- letter was issued on the ground that 948-949-950-951, N.H. - 92, the Principal did not have 55o/o marks at the PG level. VILLAGE lP .O./TEHSTL/ DrST- BHIND- 477OOT, MADHYA The institution has now submitted an PRAD ES H approved marksheet of the Principal with the required percentage.

Hence, Recognition be granted for 1 unit of the B.Ed. course from the academic session 20L7-2OL8.

1 58. APP20166 VICTORIA COLLEGE OF D. P. S. E. The case file was seen, Consequent to 0114 EDUCATION INDORE, the issue of LOI, the institution has KHASRA No.: 225/t/1/1 & submitted a list of 1 Principal and 15 faculty members who qualified ID: 8639 225/t/L/2, STREET/ROAD: are and approved by the competent authority. KHANDWA ROAD, TALU KA/MAN DAL: GRAM Hence, Recognition be granted for MOROD, TOWN/CITY: 2 units of the D.P.S.E, course from INDORE, DISTRICT: the academic session 2Ol7-2Ot8. INDORE -452020, MADHYA PRAD ES H

1 59. APP20166 GURU HARGOVIND SINGH B. Ed. The case file was seen. Consequent to 0250 SHIKSHA the issue of LOI, the institution has MAHAVIDHYALAYA, SURVEY submitted a list of 1 Principal and 15 faculty members qualified ID: 1t253 NO. L8L5/213, VILLAGE- who are and approved by the competent authority. BAGOTA, STREET/ROAD- CH HATARPU R, Hence, Recognition be granted for TALU KA/MAN DAL- 2 units of the B.Ed. course from CH H HATARPU R, the academic session 2OL7-2OL8. TOWN/CrTY- BAGOTA, DISTRICT- CH HATARPU R- \ 51 Minutes of 275th WRC meeting held on May l-2,2017

s. CODE NAME OF THE COURSE DECISION OF WRC NO NO. INSTITUTION 47L4O5, MADHYA PRADESH

160. APP20166 GURU HARGOVIND SINGH D. EI, Ed. The case file was seen. Consequent to o24B SHIKSHA the issue of LOI, the institution has MAHAVIDHYALAYA, SURVEY submitted a list of 1 Principal, 1 HOD ID: 1L252 NO. T8L5/2/3, VILLAGE- and 15 faculty members who are qualified and approved by the BAGOTA, STREET/ROAD- competent authority. CH HATARPU R, TALU KA/MAN DAL- Hence, Recognition be granted for CH H HATARPU R, 2 units of the D.El.Ed. course from TOWN/CrTY- BAGOTA, the academic session 2OL7-2OL8. DISTRICT- CH HATARPU R- 47L4O5, MADHYA PRADESH

161. APP3355 ISHWARCHAN D B. Ed. The case file was seen. In the 27L't VIDYASAGAR meeting, copy of the complaint was MAHAVIDYALAYA, PLOTI sent to various authorities. However, no KHASARA NO- 4261t, 42612, reply has been received till date. 43412, STREET- 438/5, The case will be considered as soon as CHILLA, VILLAGE. the replies are received. PATHRAUDA JAWA,TEHSIL- JAWA, CITY- REWA, DISTRICT: REWA- 486223, MADHYA PRADESH

162, APP3485 SIT VIDHYA PEETH, PLOT/ B. Ed. The case file was seen. Before the KHASRA NO- 2021L, tgglt, reply to the LOI could be considered, a 20212, STREET- JAMODI, complaint has been received from VILLAGE- JAMODI SENGRAN, Advocate Ramlakhan Patel who has alleged that the Director of the SIDHI, POST OFFICE- institution was convicted and is now TEHSIL- GOPAD BANAS, released. It has also been stated that CITY- SIDHI, DISTRICT: the Higher Education Department has SIDHI- 48666L, MADHYA directed that all the courses be PRAD ES H withdrawn.

The institution is required to send para-wise reply.

A copy of the complaint be also sent to the Higher Education Department and Superintendent of Poliie for verification. 163. APP2798 MAHARIS HI S HI KS HA B.A.B.Ed. The case file was seen. Show Cause SANSTHAN (DEPARTMENT Notice was issued on the ground that oF EDUCATION), PLOT NO- the Registrar had not approved the list and the subjects PG level were 39/4, VILLAGE- LAMTI, POST at the not given. OFFICE- VIJAY NAGAR, N 52 Minutes of 275rh WRC meeting held on May l-2,2017 s. CODE NAME OF THE COURSE DECISION OF WRC NO NO. INSTITUTION TEHSIL- JABALPUR, CITY. The institution has replied with the JABALPU R, DISTRICT: approval of the Registrar but subjects JABALPU R- 4B2OO2, at the PG level have still not been g iven. MADHYA PRADESH Hence, Recognition is refused. L64. APP2776 MAHARISHI SHIKSHA B. Ed. The case file was seen. Show Cause SANSTHAN (DEPARTMENT Notice was issued on the ground that oF EDUCATION), PLOT NO- the Registrar had not approved the list 39/4, VILLAGE- LAMTI, and the subjects at the PG level were POST OFFICE- VIJAY not given. NAGAR, TEHSIL- JABALPUR, CITY- JABALPUR, DISTRICT: The institution has replied with the JABALPU R- 482002, approval of the Registrar but subjects MADHYA PRADESH at the PG level have still not been given. Hence, Recognition is refused.

MADHYA PRADESH 275.4.6t-t Considerationn5 raf,ton ofo Reply ofo Clarificationa on Lette s. CODE NAME OF THE COURSE DECISION OF WRC NO NO. INSTITUTION 165, APP20166 PT. RAM LAL S HARMA B.A. B. Ed./ The case file was seen. The VT visited 0102 COLLEGE OF EDUCATION, B.Sc. B. Ed. the institution on 24104/2017. The CD VILLAGE: BUDHWADA, was seen and VTR perused. The CD shows adequate ID:8416 STREET/ROAD: HARDA a building with instructional and infrastructural BYPASS, TALUKA/MANDAL+ facilities. The VT has recommended TOWN/CITY: HOSHAGABAD, the case. DISTRICT: HOSHAGABAD- 461001, MADHYA PRADESH However before further action can be taken, the institution needs to clarify the following : - i) As per CLU, the total land area is only 2405 sq. mtrs. which is insufficient to run the existing 2 units of B.Ed. and the proposed 1 unit of B.A.B.Ed.lB.Sc.B.Ed. ii) The Building Completion Certificate is not signed by a Govt. Engineer. iii) Non-Encumbrance Certificate has not been submitted. iv) The institution should clarify which course it wants to run B.A.B.Ed. or B.Sc.B.Ed. Both cannot be run sirpultaneously in view of thH NCTE Hors. letter dt.

53 { Minutes of 275th WRC meeting held on May l-Z,ZOl7

s. CODE NAME OF THE COURSE DECISION OF WRC NO NO, INSTITUTION 3L/O3/20t6 which states that "...8.A./B.Sc.B.Ed. (Integrated Programme) is one programme and is governed by Appendix-13 of the NCTE Regulation 20L4. The Programme cannot be segregated into two prog ra m mes w ith two different nomenclatures, and sanction of two units each..." Hence, Show Cause Notice be issued to the institution on the above grounds.

MADHYA PRADESH

275.4.5I t Consideration ofq Visitings Teameam Reports s. CODE NAME OF THE COURSE DECISION OF WRC NO NO. INSTITUTION 166. APP20166 SHRI RAMA KRISHNA B.Sc. B. Ed. The case file was seen. The VT visited 0195 COLLEGE OF EDUCATION, (Add. ) the institution on 24104120L7. The CD KHASRA NO.B4I2, 8512, was seen and VTR perused. The CD ID: 10948 8612, VILLAGE: KARHI shows a good building with adequate KOTHAR, STREET/ROAD: instructional and infrastructural CHANDI DAI MANDIR MODE facilities. The VT has recommended N EAR SAHARA CITY, the case. TALU KA /MAN DAL: RAGHURAJNAGAR, Hence, LOI be issued for 1 TOWN/CITY: SATNA, additional unit of the B,Sc.B.Ed. DISTRICT: SATNA-485001, cou rse, MADHYA PRADESH. L67. APP20166 ORIENTAL B.ED.COLLEGE, B.A.B.Ed. The case file was seen. With reference 0058 KHASRA NO. 254/2, 2561L- & to the NCTE Hqrs, letter dt. 2, 257 /t, Lzt/2, 254/4-5-6- B.Sc.B. Ed. 3L/0312016 in the 267th meeting, the ID:7881 7 , 257 /3-4-5-6, VILLAGE: WRC had asked the institution to PANBIHARI, STREET/ROAD: clarify which course it wants to run N EAR BLOCK OFFICE, B.A.B.Ed. or B.Sc.B.Ed. TALU KA/MAN DAL: LALBU RRA, TOWN/CITY: The institution has insisted that it PAN BI HARI, DISTRICT: wants to run both the courses. BALAGHAT-48 L44L, MADHYA PRADESH Vhe matter 9" referred to the \cre Hqrs. frr cla rification. \ (*

54 Minutes of 275th WRC meeting held on May l-2,2017

MADHYA PRADESH 275.4.13 Consid eration of Replv of LOI s. CODE NAME OF THE COURSE DECISION OF WRC NO NO. INSTITUTION 168. APP20166 VICTORIA COLLEGE OF B.Ed. The case file was seen. Consequent to 0100 EDUCATION, VILLAGE: the issue of LOI, the institution has BERKHEDI, STREET/ROAD: submitted a list of 1 Principal, and 15 faculty members who are approved by ID: 9L24 SEHORE ROAD, the competent authority. TALUKA/MANDAL: SEHORE, TOWN/CITY: BERKH EDI, Hence, Recognition be granted for DISTRICT: SEHORE-466001, 1 unit of the B.Ed. course from the MADHYA PRADESH academic session 2O L7 -2OL8,

169. APPz0166 VICTORIA COLLEGE OF D. El . Ed. The case file was seen. Consequent to 0100 EDUCATION, VILLAGE: the issue of LOI, the institution has submitted HOD 15 BERKH EDI, STREET/ROAD : a list of 1 and faculty members who are qualified and ID:9124 SEHORE ROAD, approved by the competent authority. TALUKA/MANDAL: SEHORE, TOWN/CITY: BERKH EDI, Hence, Recognition be granted for DISTRICT: SEHORE-466001, 1 unit of the D,El.Ed. course from MADHYA PRADESH the academic session 2OL7-2O18.

L70. APP20166 VICTO RIA COLLEG E OF B.Sc. B. Ed. The case file was seen. Consequent to 0100 EDUCATION, VILLAGE: the issue of LOI, the institution has submitted 15 BERKH EDI, STREET/ROAD : a list of 1 HOD and faculty members who are qualified and ID:9L24 SEHORE ROAD, approved by the competent authority. TALUKA/MANDAL: SEHORE, TOWN/CITY: BERKH EDI, Hence, Recognition be granted for DISTRICT: SEHORE-466001, l unit of the B.Sc.B.Ed. course MADHYA PRADESH from the academic session 2OL7- 20 19.

/*- Meeting ended with a vote of thanks.

(Dr. Louis Vernal) Member & Chairperson for the Meeting

55