Concept Plan—University of Technology, Sydney (UTS) Broadway Heritage Impact Statement
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Concept Plan—University of Technology, Sydney (UTS) Broadway Heritage Impact Statement Report prepared for the University of Technology, Sydney April 2009 Report Register The following report register documents the development and issue of the report entitled Concept Plan— University of Technology, Sydney (UTS) Broadway—Heritage Impact Statement, undertaken by Godden Mackay Logan Pty Ltd in accordance with its quality management system. Godden Mackay Logan operates under a quality management system which has been certified as complying with the Australian/New Zealand Standard for quality management systems AS/NZS ISO 9001:2000. Job No. Issue No. Notes/Description Issue Date 08-0366 1 Draft report January 2009 08-0366 2 Draft final report February 2009 08-0366 3 Final report February 2009 08-0366 4 Final report version 2 March 2009 08-0366 5 Final report version 3 April 2009 Contents Page 1.0 Introduction ..........................................................................................................................................1 1.1 Preamble..........................................................................................................................................1 1.2 Methodology ....................................................................................................................................1 1.3 Background......................................................................................................................................1 1.4 Documentation.................................................................................................................................2 1.5 Limitations ........................................................................................................................................2 1.6 Authorship ........................................................................................................................................3 1.7 Acknowledgements .........................................................................................................................3 2.0 Identification of Study Area .................................................................................................................3 2.1 Site Location ....................................................................................................................................3 2.2 Heritage Listings ..............................................................................................................................4 3.0 Summary History.................................................................................................................................7 3.1 Aboriginal Ethnohistory....................................................................................................................7 3.2 Ultimo Estate....................................................................................................................................7 3.3 Subdivision and Development.........................................................................................................8 3.4 Early Twentieth Century Development ...........................................................................................9 3.5 Fairfax and the University of Technology 1950–1985..................................................................10 4.0 Site Description..................................................................................................................................14 4.1 Setting and Context .......................................................................................................................14 4.2 Heritage Items within UTS Broadway Precinct.............................................................................14 4.3 Other Buildings Assessed within UTS Broadway Precinct ..........................................................15 4.4 Heritage Items in the Vicinity of UTS Broadway Precinct ............................................................18 5.0 Significance Assessment ..................................................................................................................24 5.1 Conclusions of the Built Heritage Assessment.............................................................................24 6.0 Archaeological Assessment..............................................................................................................25 6.1 Aboriginal Archaeology..................................................................................................................25 6.2 Historical (non-Aboriginal) Archaeology........................................................................................26 7.0 Concept Plan Proposal.......................................................................................................................27 8.0 Heritage Impacts within UTS Broadway Precinct.............................................................................28 8.1 Heritage Impacts on UTS Broadway Precinct Layout..................................................................28 8.2 Impacts on Heritage Items within UTS Broadway Precinct..........................................................28 8.3 Heritage Impacts on Other Buildings within UTS Broadway Precinct .........................................30 8.4 Impacts on Archaeological and Aboriginal Cultural Values .........................................................31 9.0 Heritage Impacts in the Vicinity of the UTS Broadway Precinct ......................................................33 9.1 Impacts on Built Heritage Items in the Vicinity of UTS Broadway Precinct .................................33 9.2 Impacts on Other Heritage Items in the Vicinity of the Site..........................................................34 10.0 Conclusions and Recommendations..............................................................................................35 10.1 Conclusion ...................................................................................................................................35 10.2 Recommendations.......................................................................................................................36 11.0 Endnotes..........................................................................................................................................37 Concept Plan—University of Technology, Sydney (UTS) Broadway—Heritage Impact Statement—Final Report Version 3, April 2009 12.0 Appendices..........................................................................................................................................39 Appendix A................................................................................................................................................39 State Heritage Inventory forms.............................................................................................................39 Appendix B................................................................................................................................................39 Concept Plan—University of Technology, Sydney (UTS) Broadway—Aboriginal and Historical Archaeological Assessment, prepared by Godden Mackay Logan, February 2009..........................39 Concept Plan—University of Technology, Sydney (UTS) Broadway—Heritage Impact Statement—Final Report Version 3, April 2009 Concept Plan—University of Technology, Sydney (UTS) Broadway—Heritage Impact Statement 1.0 Introduction 1.1 Preamble Godden Mackay Logan (GML) has been commissioned by the University of Technology, Sydney (UTS) to prepare a heritage impact statement (HIS) to accompany the UTS Concept Plan application under the Environmental Planning and Assessment Act 1979 (NSW). This HIS identifies and assesses the potential heritage impact of the proposal on the existing buildings and site as well as any potential impacts on the heritage significance of the setting, heritage streetscapes, Aboriginal and historical archaeological remains, conservation areas and landscape and built heritage items in the vicinity of the site. 1.2 Methodology GML undertook a comprehensive assessment of the built heritage and archaeological potential of the UTS Broadway Precinct (the study site) in three stages: • Stage 1—Built Heritage Assessment provided assessment of three heritage-listed buildings (CB03, CB08 and CB11) and four further potential heritage items (CB09, CB10, CB12 and CB13). GML assessed the seven buildings against NSW Heritage Criteria and prepared State Heritage Inventory forms for each detailing the conclusions. These inventory forms are provided in Appendix A of this report. • Stage 2—Archaeological Assessment was an Aboriginal and European archaeological assessment of the UTS site. The assessment was prepared to identify known or potential Aboriginal and historical archaeological heritage within the site and provide advice regarding the management of the known and potential archaeological resource. • Stage 3—Heritage Impact Statement (this report) assesses the potential impact of the UTS Concept Plan application on the archaeological potential and heritage items within the study site and its vicinity. The conclusions of the Stage 1 and 2 assessments have been used to guide this heritage impact assessment. In preparing this HIS, reference has been made to the NSW Heritage Manual Guidelines for the preparation of Statements of Heritage Impact (NSW Department of Planning and Heritage Council