Appendix A: Responses to Consultation Paper

[See Chapter 2. This list includes the stakeholders whom we met during the consultation period or who submitted written responses to the Consultation Paper . Entries within each group are in alphabetical order. All of those listed submitted written responses except those marked with an asterisk who met with the Commission, or hosted an event attended by it.]

CENTRAL GOVERNMENT

Department of Communities, Housing and Local Government * Planning Inspectorate (PINS) Welsh Government (including Cadw) *

LOCAL AUTHORITY REPRESENTATIVE BODIES (6)

Association of Local Government Ecologists North Development Managers Group One Voice Wales * Planning Officers’ Society (POS) [England] Planning Officers’ Society Wales (POSW) POSW North Wales * POSW South-East Wales POSW South-West Wales * Welsh Local Government Association

LOCAL AUTHORITIES (18)

Blaenau Gwent CBC Bridgend CBC Caerphilly CBC Cardiff Council Carmarthenshire CC Ceredigion CC Denbighshire CC Flintshire CC Gwynedd CC Merthyr Tydfil CBC

407

Monmouthshire CC Neath Port Talbot CBC Newport City Council Pembrokeshire CC Rhondda Cynon Taf CBC Swansea Council Torfaen CBC Ynys Mon CC

NATIONAL PARK AUTHORITIES (2)

National Parks Wales Pembrokeshire Coast National Park Authority

COMMUNITY AND TOWN COUNCILS (21)

Arddleen Community Council Barry Town Council Bay of Colwyn Town Council Caersws Community Council Carreghofa Community Council Churchstoke Community Council Cynwyl Elfed Community Council Holywell Town Council Lladydilio Community Council Llandrinio Community Council Llanfair Dyffryn Clwyd Community Council Llantwit Major Town Council Town Council Newtown and Llanllwchaiarn Town Council Pembrey and Burry Port Town Council Pestrowed Community Council Pontarddulais Town Council Pontypridd Town Council Presteigne & Norton Town Council Welsh St Donats Community Council Welshpool Town Council

408

OTHER PUBLIC BODIES (6)

Health & Safety Executive Natural Resources Wales Public Service Ombudsman for Wales South Wales Police Welsh Assembly Welsh Language Commissioner

PROFESSIONAL BODIES (15)

Bar Council British Architectural Trust Chartered Institute of Architectural Technologists Chartered Institute of Building Institute of Chartered Engineers (ICE) Wales Cymru Institute of Historic Buildings Conservation (IHBC) IHBC (Wales Branch) Law Society Planning and Environment Committee Lawyers in Local Government National Association of Planning Enforcement (NAPE) Planning and Environment Bar Association (PEBA) Royal Institution of Chartered Surveyors (RICS) Royal Society of Architects in Wales Royal Town Planning Institute (RTPI Cymru) UK Environmental Law Association (UKELA)

LAWYERS, PLANNING CONSULTANTS, ARCHITECTS ETC (7)

39 Essex Chambers * Doug Hughes Associates Francis Taylor Building * Ove Arup Planning Aid Wales Sirius Planning Welsh Planning Consultants’ Forum *

409

HOUSING BODIES (4)

Barratt & David Wilson Homes South Wales Community Housing Cymru Home Builders Federation Redrow Homes (South Wales) Residential Landlords’ Association *

RURAL LANDOWNERS (9)

Canal & River Trust The Central Association of Agricultural Valuers Community Land Advisory Service Country Land & Business Association (CLA) Farmers Union of Wales Friends of the Earth Cymru The National Trust Open Spaces Society Royal Society for the Protection of Birds (RSPB)

OTHER LANDOWNERS, DEVELOPERS ETC (7)

Accessible Retail Arqiva Innogy Renewables UK Mineral Products Association National Grid Southern Power Energy Networks Tidal Lagoon Power

HERITAGE BODIES (20)

Aberystwyth & District Civic Society Ancient Monuments Society Chartered Institute for Archaeologists Council for British Archaeology Design Commission for Wales Dyfed Archaeological Trust

410

Glamorgan-Gwent Archaeological Trust Gwynedd Archaeological Planning Service Gwynedd Archaeological Trust Historic Environment Group * Historic Houses Association Joint Committee of National Amenity Societies * Llandaff Conservation Area Advisory Group Manchester Civic Society Mid and West Wales Conservation Officers’ Group Royal Commission on Ancient and Historical Monuments in Wales Save Britain’s Heritage Society for the Protection of Ancient Buildings (SPAB) Society of Antiquaries South Wales Conservation Group Theatres Trust Wales Heritage Group

TREE-RELATED ORGANISATIONS (8)

Ancient Trees Forum Arboricultural Association Cedarwood Tree Care Ltd Institute of Chartered Foresters London Tree Officers Association Simon Pryce Arboriculture Woodland Trust Wrexham County Council (arboricultural section)

FAITH GROUPS (5)

Churches Legislation Advisory Service Church Buildings Council (Church of England) Cytun (Churches Together in Wales) Diocese of Llandaff Diocesan Advisory Committee for the Care of Churches

411

OTHER ORGANISATIONS (2)

Radio Society of Great Britain CMet Residents Action Group

INDIVIDUALS (36)

Mr John Almond Mr Allan Archer, independent planning adviser Mr Chris Bell, of Donald Insall Associates Mr Simon Bradley Mr Andrew Bramwell Mr Keith Bush, QC (Hon) Sir Richard Buxton Dr Martin Cherry Ms Molly Edwards Mr Huw Evans Mr Eric Franklin Mr Martin Goodall, of Keystone Law Mr Andrew Goodyear, independent planning adviser Mr Steven Hansberger Mr Richard Harwood QC Mr Nigel Hewitson, of Brook Street des Roches Ms Jessica Holland, of Donald Insall Associates Ms Lydia Inglis, architectural historian Sir Donsall Insall [112], architect and planner Ms Caroline James, of CJ Consulting Mr Philip Jenkins Mr Edward Lewis, of Donald Insall Associates Mr Neil McKay Mr Mark Mackworth-Praed, of David Archer Associates Mr Julian Morris Mr Andrew Muir, of Boyer Planning Mr Matt Osmont, of Donald Insall Associates Ms Pippa Richardson Ms Ruth Richardson Ms Sarah Richardson Mr Gethin Roberts, of Donald Insall Associates

412

Mr Mark Teale Mr Peter Thomas Mr Michael Tree Mr Jordan Whittaker (small business) Mr Elfed Williams, of ERW Consulting Mr Huw Williams, of Geldards Mr Owain Wyn, town planner

413