The Science of Aging Skin Leslie Baumann, MD; Susan Weinkle, MD
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
REVIEW Improving Elasticity: The Science of Aging Skin Leslie Baumann, MD; Susan Weinkle, MD Although collagen changes from both chronologic aging and photoaging have been well stud- ied, there is a dearth of research into the elastin component of the dermis. No products have been approved by the US Food and Drug Administration for either replacing elastin or stimulating its syn- thesis. Recently, a zinc complex was shown to increase dermal elastin staining, hypodermal fat, and epidermal thickness in animal studies. Histologic studies of the same zinc complex in humans have revealed increased deposition of functional elastin fibers following 10 days of use. In the clinical trials reported here, there was an increase in functional elastin, as well as improvements in fine lines and wrinkles. COSNo adverse events were noted. DERM ollagen and elastin are the fibers that make collagen bundles and endow the skin with rebounding up the dermal matrix. Cosmetic dermatol- properties. Tropoelastin molecules, which are precur- ogists have long used topical medications, sors to elastin, bind covalently with cross-links to form fillers, and light-based and laser-based elastin. Elastin fibers are assembled on bundles of micro- therapies to improve the loss of collagen fibrils composed of fibrillin. The latter forms a template Cthat occurs in aging skin. However, until recently, no fill- on which elastin is deposited.1 Most elastin production ers orDo topical agents have been availableNot to treat the loss is restricted Copy to a narrow window of development. Elas- of function of elastin, which is also an important feature togenesis increases dramatically during fetal life, peaks of dermal photoaging. The loss of collagen, elastin, and near birth and early neonatal life, decreases significantly other dermal matrix components translates into the wrin- thereafter, and is nearly nonexistent by maturity. kled, sagging, fragile skin associated with chronologic In contrast to collagen fibers, elastin fibers are present aging and photoaging. in various stages of maturity. Oxytalan fibers, the least mature elastin fibers, course perpendicularly from the THE ROLE OF ELASTIN IN THE dermal-epidermal junction to the top of the reticular APPEARANCE OF AGING SKIN dermis whereas elaunin fibers, the more mature elastin Elastin is a resilient connective tissue in the extracel- fibers, attach to a horizontal plexus of fibers found in lular matrix. Elastin fibers are found at the periphery of the reticular dermis. Elaunin fibers are more mature because they have more elastin deposited on the fibril- Dr. Baumann is Chief, Division of Cosmetic Dermatology, lin mesh. The most mature elastin fibers are unnamed and Associate Professor, Department of Dermatology and and are found deeper in the reticular dermis.1,2 This Cutaneous Surgery, Univesity of Miami School of Medicine, fibrous network running from the uppermost section of Florida. Dr. Weinkle is Assistant Clinical Professor of the papillary dermis to just beneath the basement mem- Dermatology, University of South Florida, Tampa, and in private brane lends elasticity to young skin. As this network practice, Bradenton, Florida. deteriorates with age, the loss of or damage to elastin Dr. Baumann is an advisory board member and investi- fibers may play a significant role in skin sagging and loss gator for Allergan, Inc; Dermik Laboratories; and Medicis of youthful resilience.3,4 Pharmaceutical Corporation; and an advisory board member Photoaging initially leads to hyperplasia of elastin fibers and consultant for Revance Therapeutics, Inc. according to the level of UV exposure. Later, a degenerative 168 Cosmetic Dermatology® • MARCH 2007 • VOL. 20 NO. 3 Copyright Cosmetic Dermatology 2010. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored, or transmitted without the prior written permission of the Publisher. IMPROVING ELASTICITY IN AGING SKIN response occurs with resultant loss of skin elasticity.5,6 When viewed by light microscopy, degraded elastin appears as an amorphous substance that accumulates in UV Reactive Oxygen Species the papillary dermis.1,7 The resultant elastosis, a hallmark of photoaged skin, is due to the breakdown of elastic fibers and loss of functional elastin. Defective or dam- aged elastin may lead to wrinkles, even in the absence of Map Kinases sun exposure and aging. A child with wrinkled skin syn- drome was shown to have a deficiency of elastin fibers, ERK JNK which demonstrates the important contribution of elastin to skin integrity.1 Studies have demonstrated that, with aging, there is a c-Jun c-Fos reduction in the elastin content of protected areas of the skin. In a study of Egyptian subjects, the relative amount of elastin in the non–UV-exposed abdominal skin decreased significantly from 49.2%±0.6% in the first decade of life to Activator Protein 1 30.4%±0.8% in the ninth decade.2 Another study on elas- tin content in the non–UV-exposed skin of the buttocks of Complicated signaling cascade that leads to collagen degradation. 91 white subjects between 20 and 80 years of age showed ERK indicates extracellular signal–related kinase; JNK, c-Jun amino- a 51% reduction in elastin tissue.8 terminal kinase. MECHANISMS OF DERMAL AGING Although chronologic aging and photoaging have often formation of advanced glycation end products, which form been considered to be separate processes, research indi- covalent cross-links between proteins that can alter their cates a potential overlap at the molecular and clinical structure and function. Advanced glycation end products 9,11 COS DERM levels. There is substantial evidence that skin aging have been shown to accumulate in tissues with a low is mediated by direct absorption of UV radiation by turnover rate, including dermal collagen and elastin. At chromophores in the skin leading to the production of approximately 35 years of age, glycation of the dermis has reactive oxygen species (ROS).10 ROS-mediated photo- been shown to begin; it then increases rapidly with age.13 chemical reactions can oxidize cutaneous proteins, lipids, Although changes in dermal collagen are well studied, and DNA. The Figure shows the complicated signaling research on changes in dermal elastin is less extensive. cascadeDo that leads to collagen degradation.Not UV radiation In a studyCopy designed to demonstrate differences between leads to the generation of ROS and the formation of the chronologically aged and photoaged elastic tissue, Bouissou mitogen-activated protein kinases (MAPKs), extracellular et al14 found that low–sun-exposed skin showed a disap- signal–related kinase, and c-Jun amino-terminal kinase. pearance of oxytalan fibers beginning at 30 years of age. This, in turn, leads to upregulation of the transcrip- By 40 years of age, there were no oxytalan fibers, and there tion factor c-Jun. When sufficient c-Jun is expressed to was significant lysis of elastic fibers. In high–sun-exposed heterodimerize with c-Fos, activator protein 1 (AP-1) is skin, the same age-related lesions were noted, but elastotic produced.9,10 AP-1 is a transcription factor that stimulates degeneration in the reticular and deep dermis was also the matrix metalloproteinases (MMPs) and reduces type I seen. Chronologic aging appeared to be characterized by procollagen, both of which are seen in chronologically the disintegration of elastic fibers, whereas photoaging was aged and photoaged skin.9,10 Findings reported by Varani characterized by thicker, elastotic fibers. The authors sug- et al11 have suggested that both chronologically aged gested that the lesions of chronologic aging may be due to and photoaged skin also exhibit similar features, such proteases originating in fibroblasts and that the lesions of as connective tissue alterations (eg, progressive loss of photoaging may be due to UV stimulation of fibroblasts. dermal fibroblasts, increased space between connective Scharffetter-Kochanek et al15 have suggested that the AP-1 tissue fiber bundles, and increased disorganization of and MMP cascade may be operative in the characteris- fiber bundles). In addition to the activation of AP-1 and tic elastin changes because MMP-2 has been shown to the MMP cascade, matrix degradation is also mediated degrade both elastin and collagen. by inhibition of transforming growth factor b signaling.12 Human leukocyte elastase (HLE) may play a role in Recently, there has been interest in the contribution elastin degradation. It has been shown that lysosyme of glycation to skin aging. Protein damage by reducing binding to elastin fibers, which may be induced by UV sugars and other reactive carbonyl species leads to the exposure, may prevent their degradation by HLE. A study VOL. 20 NO. 3 • MARCH 2007 • Cosmetic Dermatology® 169 Copyright Cosmetic Dermatology 2010. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored, or transmitted without the prior written permission of the Publisher. IMPROVING ELASTICITY IN AGING SKIN by Seite et al8 revealed that the elastolytic activity of HLE the cosignaling pathways involved, moderate epidermal was reduced by up to 38% after lysosyme binding to areas thickening and marked reversal of hypodermal fat atro- of damaged elastin. phy will also occur over concentration ranges effective for elastin production. COSMETIC MANAGEMENT OF THE AGING DERMIS: FOCUS ON ELASTIN CLINICAL STUDY 1 Cosmetic dermatologists have long addressed colla- Patients and Methods gen loss via collagen replacement injections or topical In a prospective, randomized, double-blind, vehicle- products that support the formation of new collagen. controlled clinical study, both eyes of each of 26 subjects However, no products or procedures have been available received once-daily applications of either a zinc complex to address the changes in elastin resulting in the char- cream for the eye area or a copper peptide formulation. acteristic loss of resilience seen in chronologically aged Subjects were healthy adult females aged 37 to 60 years and photoaged skin.16 Although many topical products who were regular users of eye creams. Clinical follow-up contain collagen and elastin and claim to increase the was at 1, 2, and 4 weeks.