Technical Report
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
South Downtown FRAMING THE FUTURE WATERFRONT Initiative Nanaimo South Downtown Waterfront TECHNICAL REPORT December 2013 SOUTH DOWNTOWN WATERFRONT INITIATIVE COMMITTEE § Vancouver Island University Dave Witty, Chair § Downtown Nanaimo Business Improvement Association Darren Moss § Nanaimo Advisory Planning Committee/City of Nanaimo Fred Pattje § Nanaimo Economic Development Corporation Sasha Angus § Nanaimo Port Authority Mike Davidson § Regional District of Nanaimo Dennis Trudeau/Daniel Pearce § South End Community Association Douglas Hardie § Community Members-at-Large Ann Kjerulf and Doug Kalcsics, Vice Chair Consultant support provided by CitySpaces Consulting Ltd. TABLE OF CONTENTS 1 Introduction ........................................... 1 5 Outcomes ............................................35 Site Access ...................................................................36 2 South Downtown Existing Site Uses .......................................................41 Waterfront Initiative ............................ 3 Green and Open Spaces ........................................42 Background .....................................................................5 Land Uses Introduced .............................................43 History ................................................................................6 Key Programmatic Elements ...............................43 Framing Principles .......................................................9 Discussion Points .......................................................45 Phasing ...........................................................................45 3 Public Engagement .............................11 Common Themes Summary ................................46 Initiative Website ......................................................... 11 Key Variables Summary .........................................48 Website Survey ............................................................. 11 Harbour Fair .................................................................. 12 6 Appendix .............................................49 Exploring Waterfront Development .................. 13 Relevant Plans .............................................................49 Ideas Forum .................................................................. 13 Land Ownership ......................................................... 52 Stakeholder Interviews ............................................ 17 Transportation Plans ................................................54 Socio-Economic Indicators...................................55 4 Design Charrette .................................19 Stakeholders ................................................................ 57 Context ............................................................................19 Climate Change Considerations .........................58 Program .......................................................................... 21 South End Community Association ................ 60 Vision 1....................................................................................22 Harbour Fair Report .................................................. 61 Vision 2 ................................................................................. 24 Ideas Forum Notes ................................................... 75 Vision 3 ................................................................................. 28 Design Charrette Participants Vision 4 ................................................................................. 32 & Facilitators ................................................................98 Verbatim Survey Responses ................................99 Committee Terms of Reference .......................109 South Downtown Waterfront Initiative · FRAMING THE FUTURE · Technical Report · December 2013 4 South Downtown Waterfront Initiative · FRAMINGPLANNING THE FOR FUTURE THE FUTURE? · Technical · December Report 2013· December 2013 1 INTRODUCTION The Nanaimo South Downtown Waterfront Initiative The area is bounded by the Snuneymuxw First Nation is a long-term, high-level consultation and visioning to the south, the Esplanade and Front Street to the process for a 59-hectare (146 acres) study area west, and Cameron Island to the North, with the along Nanaimo’s South Downtown waterfront. eastern boundary extending into Nanaimo Harbour. Spanning a six-month process, the Initiative involved: § Reviewing extensive background materials; BC Ferries § Meeting and consulting with stakeholders; § Conducting public input events; and Port Place § Carrying out a Design Charrette. Mall FRONT ST. This report summarizes the Initiative’s process, undertaken from July to December 2013. Cruise Ship Terminal HALIBURTON ST. Together, this report and the accompanying ESPLANADE FRAMING THE FUTURE: Vision & Guiding Principles Report solidify a shared vision and guiding principles to inform and shape future planning processes and decisions for this important waterfront asset. NICOL ST. MILTON ST. FARQUHAR ST. sSouth Downtown Initiative Study Area South Downtown Waterfront Initiative · FRAMING THE FUTURE · Technical Report · December 2013 1 2 South Downtown Waterfront Initiative · FRAMING THE FUTURE · Technical Report · December 2013 SOUTH DOWNTOWN 2 WATERFRONT INITIATIVE The South Downtown Waterfront Initiative In April 2013, a variety of groups were invited to Study Area comprises a variety of industrial and form the Committee leading this Initiative. These commercial uses, as well as encumbrances, groups included Snuneymuxw First Nation, the rights-of-way, multiple ownerships, and jurisdictions. Nanaimo Port Authority, the Downtown Nanaimo Ownership of the area is represented by: Business Improvement Association, the Nanaimo § The City of Nanaimo; Economic Development Corporation, the South End Community Association, the Nanaimo Advisory § The Nanaimo Port Authority; Planning Committee, Vancouver Island University, § The Province of British Columbia; the Regional District of Nanaimo, and two at-large § The Snuneymuxw First Nation*, and community representatives. § The Canadian Pacific Railway. The Committee was tasked with providing independent leadership and direction throughout While the Initiative will not result in a regulatory the planning process, including identifying document, it will provide guiding principles and opportunities and constraints, conducting public an overall vision as resources for future planning engagement and consultation activities, liaising with processes. This resource aims to serve all stakeholders, and carrying out a design charrette. jurisdictions and ownerships. An initial Committee task was to retain a consultant The vision and guiding principles take into account to assist with the Initiative’s objectives. Following a existing plans, including the City of Nanaimo’s competitive process, CitySpaces Consulting Ltd. 2002 Downtown Plan and 2012 Strategic Plan, the was selected. 2008 Nanaimo Port Authority Land Use Plan, and the purchase agreement between the City and the *Snuneymuxw First Nation decided not to participate in Canadian Pacific Railway. the Committee, but all minutes and agendas were forwarded to the First Nation. South Downtown Waterfront Initiative · FRAMING THE FUTURE · Technical Report · December 2013 3 • Committee formed; roles, scope & mandate determined JUN • Relevant materials and plans reviewed • Presentations related to ownerships and tenancies, Downtown Plan, South End ü Neighbourhood Plan, and transportation (RDN) • Communications & Engagement Strategy confirmed JUL • Presentation: transportation (City of Nanaimo) ü • Walking tour of the Study Area AUG • Framing Principles workshop ü • Economic & environmental situation workshop • Presentations: Nanaimo Economic Development Corporation, & Ministry of Community, Sport and Cultural Development (Preparing for Climate Change) SEP • Sea to land transportation workshop – presentations by Seaspan, Southern Rail, Island ü Corridor Foundation & Canadian Pacific Rail • Launch of website • Harbour Fair Event OCT • Land to Land Transportation Workshop – presentations by Regional District of Nanaimo, BC Transit, City of Nanaimo, Ministry of Transportation/Infrastructure, Transport Canada ü • Individual external stakeholder meetings • Visioning report preparation • Public lecture: “Exploring Waterfront Development” NOV – Larry Beasley, FCIP & Member of Order of Canada ü • Ideas Forum • Design Charrette • Visioning report review DEC • Visioning report completed ü 4 South Downtown Waterfront Initiative · FRAMING THE FUTURE · Technical Report · December 2013 BACKGROUND The vision and guiding principles take into account existing In addition to the background briefings, speakers representing plans, including the City of Nanaimo’s 2002 Downtown Plan and certain stakeholders presented information at the bi-weekly 2012 Strategic Plan, the 2008 Nanaimo Port Authority Land Use meetings. To learn about the transportation context for the Study Plan, and the purchase agreement with Canadian Pacific Rail. Area, speakers from the City of Nanaimo, the Regional District of From June to December 2013, the South Downtown Waterfront Nanaimo, and BC Transit provided information about local and Committee met bi-weekly to discuss and review the background regional transportation planning. Other stakeholders included the materials. The following relevant plans and reports were part of Nanaimo Port Authority, who provided a presentation on its land that review: