DOCSLIB.ORG

Gothic Mourning and Daughterly Duty in Jay Macpherson's

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Gothic Mourning and Daughterly Duty in Jay Macpherson's Document généré le 27 sept. 2021 04:51 Studies in Canadian Literature / Études en littérature canadienne "Absence, havoc": Gothic Mourning and Daughterly Duty in Jay Macpherson’s Welcoming Disaster Tanis MacDonald Volume 34, numéro 1, 2009 URI : https://id.erudit.org/iderudit/scl34_1art04 Aller au sommaire du numéro Éditeur(s) The University of New Brunswick ISSN 0380-6995 (imprimé) 1718-7850 (numérique) Découvrir la revue Citer cet article MacDonald, T. (2009). "Absence, havoc":: Gothic Mourning and Daughterly Duty in Jay Macpherson’s Welcoming Disaster. Studies in Canadian Literature / Études en littérature canadienne, 34(1), 58–80. All rights reserved © Management Futures, 2009 Ce document est protégé par la loi sur le droit d’auteur. L’utilisation des services d’Érudit (y compris la reproduction) est assujettie à sa politique d’utilisation que vous pouvez consulter en ligne. https://apropos.erudit.org/fr/usagers/politique-dutilisation/ Cet article est diffusé et préservé par Érudit. Érudit est un consortium interuniversitaire sans but lucratif composé de l’Université de Montréal, l’Université Laval et l’Université du Québec à Montréal. Il a pour mission la promotion et la valorisation de la recherche. https://www.erudit.org/fr/ “Absence, havoc”: Gothic Mourning and Daughterly Duty in Jay Macpherson’s Welcoming Disaster Tanis MacDonald Absence, havoc — well, I missed you — Near and dear turned far and strange, Dayshine came disguised as midnight: One thing altered made all change. Fallen? stolen? trapped? entangled? To a lower world betrayed? Endless error held your footsteps, On your brow a deepening shade. Long I sought you, late I found you, Straying on the farther shore: You indeed? A swaying phantom Fades, that flickered on before. Lost, no rescue: only dreams our Wandered, wandered loves restore. — “Absence, Havoc” Welcoming Disaster (67)1 anadian poet Jay Macpherson’s 1974 book of poetry, Welcoming Disaster, was originally published as a sixty-three- page chapbook of short lyric monologues spoken by a female Cpersona. The text is divided into five sections that describe the narrator’s reactions to the loss of her creative powers, preceded and presaged by the disappearance of a paternal magus figure. But Welcoming Disaster remains something of a textual enigma; it has received little critical attention since its publication, even though Macpherson’s previous book, The Boatman, won the Governor-General’s Award for Poetry in 1957. Lorraine Weir, in her thoughtful 1989 monograph, notes that critical discussion of Macpherson’s work is “sparse, occasionally gener- ous, but always incomplete” (“Jay”180). David Bromwich asserts that “Macpherson’s more ambitious poems have been elegiac,” in particular Jay Macpherson 59 those that “lament . an alienated and/or repressed element of the self” (336). About Welcoming Disaster, W.J. Keith assures readers that the text “reveals hints (like The Waste Land, we might add) of a palpable if subtly personal trauma” (32), while Suniti Namjoshi calls it an exploration of “the world of nightmare” (55). Michael Hornyansky points out the text’s “ominous simplicities” and calls Macpherson’s prosody “a very curious blend of the cryptic, the elliptic, and the conversational” (337). Suffice it to say that Welcoming Disaster has baffled many read- ers, with the result that Macpherson’s anthologized work has been drawn almost exclusively from The Boatman. Welcoming Disaster has received only a fraction of the critical attention that it deserves as a poetic sequence, as a feminist text, and as part of the Gothic tradition in Canada. Margaret Atwood, who, as Macpherson’s former student at the University of Toronto, acquired at least some of her sense of the Gothic tradition from Macpherson, asserts that Welcoming Disaster is “more convoluted, darker and more grotesque” than The Boatman (“Jay” 410). Asserting that the text resonates with “echoes of all those nine- teenth-century ghosts, from Catherine Earnshaw on down” and with “vampiristic or sinister-double relationships” and “Faustian pacts with darkness,” Atwood emphasizes Macpherson’s use of the Gothic “lore of magicians, ghouls, mazes and crossroads” (410). Certainly the iconic illustrations in Welcoming Disaster invite a Gothic reading. “Conjuring the Dead” is accompanied by a reproduction of the woodcut from the 1620 quarto of Marlowe’s Doctor Faustus, showing the scientist in his learned robes raising the devil, though significantly, the Welcoming Disaster emblem shows only Faustus brandishing his book within his charmed circle (66). Later in the text, “The Dark Side” is adorned with a gravestone memento mori, a grinning death’s head, decorated with cherubs, bats, and an ourobouros in the background, taken from a 1776 Puritan headstone in Massachusetts (PTT 81; see also Weir, “Jay” 205). When Atwood writes that the poems in Welcoming Disaster “make the hair stand up on the back of your neck” (411), she does not specify whether this effect is a result of fear or admiration, but I suspect both reactions are applicable, and appropriate. One of the hair-raising qualities of these poems is the omnipresence (or lurking “omniabsence”) of the dead. Indeed, the dead in Welcoming Disaster seem to proliferate at an alarming, nearly geometric rate, per- haps because the protagonist insists upon the “closed communion, pact 60 Scl/Élc profound” between the dead and the living. Macpherson writes this relationship as morbidly satisfying on one level, but also acknowledges that it remains frustrating enough to leave the speaker “stupid — cum- bering the ground” (“Conjuring the Dead,” PTT 66).2 Although she has conjured them, the dead react in good elegiac fashion; they do not stay in contact with her, but neither do they have the decency to vanish. Corpses languish in cellars, in graves, in ruined castles, in lost books, in cinema seats, in coffins, and behind locked doors, haunted by the poems’ protagonist, she who craves union with the dead in gen- eral, and with one “wandering love” in particular. If we are to consider Welcoming Disaster a wittily melancholic blend of Gothic and elegiac traditions that work towards feminist concerns, thinking about the tim- ing of publication is also important. Macpherson wrote this text in the years after her success with The Boatman, in the early 1970s as feminist theory was emerging in Europe and while younger Canadian poets like Atwood, Gwendolyn MacEwen, and Susan Musgrave (to name only a few) were beginning to modernize the Gothic with feminist concerns, a project that still is very much in currency. In their 2007 collection Postfeminist Gothic, Benjamin A. Brabon and Stéphanie Genz assert that “the Gothic has always resisted a monological definition and exceeded the laws of genre and categorical thinking” (1), adding that scholars of both Gothic and feminist literature must “now demand a self-criti- cism with respect to their own totalizing gestures and assumptions” (7). Justin D. Edwards’s recent study Gothic Canada works with a wary eye on those same totalizing gestures when he proposes that Canadian Gothic literature struggles with “the grip of an ambivalent impulse that arises equally from a wish to a counter wish, from attraction to repul- sion,” between the colonizing impulse and the wish to escape the force of colonization, creating “an obsessive mindset, in which Canadian writers continually return to ghostly figures who haunt” (xxi). Though Edwards’s Gothic Canada does not concentrate on feminist texts, I sug- gest that Macpherson’s Welcoming Disaster is another such obsessive Gothic text of subjectivity, but with an emphasis upon the female sub- ject rather than the colonial or postcolonial subject. 3 Using not only Gothic motifs but also a Gothic structure, Welcoming Disaster inquires into the gender dynamics of elegiac convention and explores the possibilities for renewed, and renewable, female subjectivity. Though the text of Welcoming Disaster is rendered entirely, and remark- Jay Macpherson 61 ably, in sapphics, ballads, and other verse forms, the narrative describes that of a traditional Gothic novel, parsed here with its attendant “mis- leading clues, postponements of discovery, [and] excessive digressions” by Claire Kahane: Within an imprisoning structure, a protagonist, typically a young woman whose mother has died, is compelled to seek out the centre of a mystery, while vague and usually sexual threats to her person from some powerful male figure hover on the periphery of her con- sciousness. She penetrates the obscure recesses of a vast laby- rinthean space and discovers a secret room sealed off by its associa- tion with death. In this dark, secret centre of the Gothic structure, the boundaries of life and death themselves seem confused. Who died? Has there been a murder? Or merely a disappearance? (334) This description, so accurate and yet so tongue-in-cheek, points to the standard features of a Gothic plot while suggesting that the enigmas of the tradition invite subversion, and further, that the questions that fuel the Gothic novel are potentially strong enough to crack the structure itself. Kahane is not alone in drawing attention to the fact that the “female gothic” has grown beyond the confines of Ellen Moer’s defin- ition in Literary Women (1976). While a poetic sequence is not and never will be a novel — nor should it attempt to be — Macpherson’s sequence shows a surprising amount of correlation with, and witty subversion of, Kahane’s description, suggesting, as Brabon and Genz
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Robert Graves Remembered by Jay Macpherson (1931–2012) Dunstan Ward
    ‘An Immensely Happy Time’: Robert Graves Remembered by Jay Macpherson (1931–2012) Dunstan Ward Eighteen months before her death in March 2012, the distinguished Canadian poet and scholar Jay Macpherson made a return visit to Mallorca, where in 1952 she had met Robert Graves, who so admired her poems that he published her first book himself under his Seizin Press imprint. It was William Graves who suggested at the end of January 2010 that I should try and persuade Professor Macpherson to come to the Tenth Robert Graves Conference in Palma and Deyá that July. ‘She was in Deyá on and off from the early to the late 1950s,’ he wrote. ‘I’ve never seen a copy of Nineteen Poems. I think only she and Terence Hards were given the honour of a Seizin publication.’ I had once spoken briefly with this almost legendary figure, at the Robert Graves Centenary Conference at Oxford in 1995, when Beryl Graves introduced us. Now I wrote to the University of Toronto inviting her to take part in a poetry reading at the conference in Mallorca. I also said that William and I were wondering if she might be prepared to give an interview, in which she could talk about her relationship with Robert Graves and his work. Jay Macpherson’s email reply came two days later: Monday 8 February 2010 Well, yes, tentatively--that is, I have commitments to a sick friend whom I can’t leave without some difficult arranging; but had been hoping to do just that for at least a bit of this summer.
    [Show full text]
  • IN the WHALE's BELLY Jay Macpherson's Poetry
    IN THE WHALE'S BELLY Jay Macpherson's Poetry Suniti Namjoshi J"A.Y MACPHERSON'S FIRST MAJOR BOOK of poems, The Boat- man, was published in 1957 by Oxford University Press and then republished in 1968 with the addition of sixteen new poems.1 Her second book of poems, Wel- coming Disaster, appeared in 1974. No discussion of modern Canadian poetry is complete without at least a mention of Jay Macpherson's name, but the only article on her poetry that I have come across is the one by James Reaney, "The Third Eye: Jay Macpherson's The Boatman," which appeared in Canadian Literature in 1960. Fortunately, that article is almost definitive. Superficially, there seem to be some obvious differences between The Boatman and Welcoming Disaster. The second in some ways seems much "simpler." It is my purpose here to explore some of the similarities and differences with the aid of Jay Macpher- son's other writings,2 which include two theses, two lectures, and a children's text on classical mythology. As Reaney makes clear, the central myth of The Boatman is that of the ark. The ark appears to contain us, as though we were trapped in the belly of some monstrous creature, and its contents appear to be hopelessly miscellaneous; but properly perceived, Man, in fact, contains the ark, and its contents are ordered: In a poem entitled "The Anagogic Man" we are presented with ... the figure of a sleeping Noah whose head contains all creation ... The whole collection of poems requires the reader to transfer himself from the sleep our senses keep to Noah's sleep, and from Noah's sleep eventually to the first morning in Paradise.
    [Show full text]
  • Index to the Tamarack Review
    The Tamarack Review ROBERT WEAVER, IVON M. OWEN, WILLIAM TOYE WILLIAM KILBOURNE, JOHN ROBERT COLOMBO, KILDARE DOBBS AND JANIS RAPOPORT Issue 1 Issue 21 Issue 41 Issue 62 Issue 2 Issue 22 Issue 42 Issue 63 Issue 3 Issue 23 Issue 43 Issue 64 Issue 4 Issue 24 Issue 44 Issue 65 Issue 5 Issue 25 Issue 45 Issue 66 Issue 6 Issue 26 Issue 46 Issue 67 Issue 7 Issue 27 Issue 47 Issue 68 Issue 8 Issue 28 Issue 48 Issue 69 Issue 9 Issue 29 Issue 49 Issue 70 Issue 10 Issue 30 Issue 50-1 Issue 71 Issue 11 Issue 31 Issue 52 Issue 72 Issue 12 Issue 32 Issue 53 Issue 73 Issue 13 Issue 33 Issue 54 Issue 74 Issue 14 Issue 34 Issue 55 Issue 75 Issue 15 Issue 35 Issue 56 Issue 76 Issue 16 Issue 36 Issue 57 Issue 77-8 Issue 17 Issue 37 Issue 58 Issue 79 Issue 18 Issue 38 Issue 59 Issue 80 Issue 19 Issue 39 Issue 60 Issue 81-2 Issue 20 Issue 40 Issue 61 Issue 83-4 ISBN 978-1-55246-804-3 The Tamarack Review Index Volume 81-84 “109 Poets.” Rosemary Aubert article 81- Bickerstaff 83-84:40 82:94-99 “Concerning a Certain Thing Called “A Deposition” J.D. Carpenter poem 81- Houths” Robert Priest poem 81- 82:8-9 82:68-69 “A Mansion in Winter” Daniel David “Control Data” Chris Dewdney, poem, Moses poem 81-82:30-31 81-82:21 “Above an Excavation” Al Moritz poem “Croquet” Al Moritz poem 83-84:98 83-84:99 “Daybook” Ken Cathers poem 81-82:10- “Again” Al Moritz poem 83-84:101 11 “Air Show” J.D.
    [Show full text]
  • We've Got Poetry Invisible Dogs Don Domanski Shortlisted Barry Dempster for the 2013 Governor General’S Award Bite Down Little Whisper “ Is Is
    ARC POETRY MAgAzinE 74, SUMMER 2014 Arc: Canada’s Poetry Magazine, est. 1978 Published by the Arc Poetry Society, est. 1996 Managing Editor: Monty Reid Coordinating Editor: Robyn Jeffrey Editorial Assistant: Meagan Black Art Director: Serge Duguay Intern: Dave Didylowski Poetry Editor: Shane Rhodes Associate Poetry Editor: Lise Rochefort Prose Editor: Chris Jennings Reviews Editor: Brecken Hancock Reviews Coordinator: Frances Boyle Visual Art Editor: Kevin Matthews Editorial Board: Frances Boyle, Anita Dolman, Rhonda Douglas, JM Francheteau, Brecken Hancock, Jenny Haysom, Chris Jennings, Kevin Matthews, Lise Rochefort, Shane Rhodes, Evan Thornton Contributing Editors: Julia Bustos, Aislinn Hunter, Marilyn Irwin, Ben Ladouceur, Carmel Purkis, Lisa Marie Smith Volunteers: Rupert Allen, Kirsten Bussière, Conrad McCallum, John Olsthoorn The Arc Poetry Society gratefully acknowledges the financial support of the Canada Council for the Arts, the Ontario Arts Council, the City of Ottawa and our subscribers. Arc is published three times a year, including an annual themed issue each fall. Arc is distributed by Magazines Canada, available through EBSCO and Gale/Cengage and on microfiche from Micromedia. The contents of this journal, unless otherwise indicated, are copyright © property of the authors, 2014. None of the works may be reproduced without permission in writing from the copyright holder. Arc acquires First Canadian Serial rights. Subscriptions cost $60 for 6 issues over 2 years. Subscriptions can be ordered online at www.arcpoetry.ca, or by mailing in the subscription card found in this issue. All prices include postage and handling unless otherwise stated. Sample copies are $12.50 each. U.S. subscriptions: $80 cdn (2 years); sample issues $17 cdn.
    [Show full text]
  • Ethos and Epic
    ETHOS AND EPIC Paul West ASPECTS OF CONTEMPORARY CANADIAN POETRY A,„N OUTSIDER who has read no Canadian poets might justifiably expect them to supply something rather American : the frontier rather than the sophisticated, the blunt rather than the subtle, the heroic rather than the maisonette, the didactic rather than the oblique. He might add something about the unlikeliness, for a long time, of aestheticism and preciosity; and there he stops. Not all that is distinctly Canadian bears upon poetry written by Canadians. Much that is Ameri- can does. The outsider deserves some sympathy, as well as licence to get as personal as he likes. For (and here I must judge by my own experi- ence ) there are many subtle differences from the European and Ameri- can traditions. With those I cannot be concerned here. But I do want to examine three aspects which seem reasonably obvious: the first two go together — the sharply visual quality of much Canadian poetry, and the unpoeticised bluntness of tone; the third is a potentiality which I hope will come to something like an epic of heterogeneous daily life. Canadian poets writing now seem to have at their disposal most of the European modes. The Parnassian keeps pace with the Whitmanish when one might have expected the latter to dominate the scene with barbaric yawp, rambling exposition and asymmetrical shape. There is a strong tradition of it in the United States, sustained in varying ways by William Carlos (Williams, Robinson Jeffers, Ε. Ε. Cummings and such poems as Allan Ginsberg's Howl. It is the sort of thing produced when the picares- que sensibility tries to write poems ; it is far from the lapidary, but it does not seem to predominate in Canada any more than it does in America.
    [Show full text]
  • A Study in the Creative Imagination in James Reaney's
    THE CREATIVE IMAGINATION IN JAMES REANEY'S LISTEN TO THE WIND THE BROKEN WINDOWPANE: A STUDY IN THE CREATIVE IMAGINATION IN Jft~ES REANEY'S LISTEN TO THE WIND by KATHLEEN JANE BIRCH, R.N., B.A. A Thesis Submitted to the School of Gr.aduateStudies in Partial Fulfilment of the Requirements for the Degree Master of Arts McMaster University September 1973 c Kathleen Jane Birch 1973 MASTER OF ARTS (1973) McMASTER UNIVERSITY (English) Hamilton, Ontario TITLE: The Broken Windowpane: A Study in the Creative Imagination in James Reaney"s Listen to the ~lind AUTHORt Kathl@~fi Jafi@ Eir6h. R6Na (Atkineen S6hool of Nursing). BoA. (University of Waterloo) SUPERVISOR: Professor k.A o Lee NUMBER OF PAGES: iv, 143 SCOPE AND CONTENTS: The thesis is a critical reading of James Reaney's play Listen to the Wind o The play is examined in the light of Reaney's earlier works, both poetic and dramatic. Source material is taken into account and auditory and visual patterns of imagery are explicated in an attempt to demonstrate the playwright's primary concern, the involvement of his audience actively, in the workings of the creative imagination. ii ACKNOWLEDGMENTS I would like to thank Dr. John Ferns for his patience and interest and for allowing me to interrupt his work sporadically and without annoucement, at some points almost daily. To Professor Lee I cannot but say thank-you again and again, for the loan of valuable reviews and articles, for continued enthusiasm and encouragement, and for allowing me to read and write. iii TAB L E o F CONTENTS Page INTRODUCTION 1 CHAPTER ONE: THE LANGUAGE OF LISTEN TO THE WIND 14 CHAPTER TWO: LISTENING TO THE WIND 46 CHAPTER THREE: THE PATTERN OF LISTEN TO THE WIND 102 BIBLIOGRAPHY 139 iv INTRODUCTION James Reaney describes his Listen to the Wind as "the bare stage, just words and you approach"l to theatre.
    [Show full text]
  • Universidad De La Laguna
    UNIVERSIDAD DE LA LAGUNA Alterity and metafiction: poetic design in the work of Michael Ondaatje Autor: Llarena Ascanio, María Jesús Director: Bernhard Dietz Guerrero Departamento de Filología Inglesa y Alemana A Janet Inksetter y a Eugenia Estanga Acknowledgements This study would have been impossible without the help of numerous people and institutions.. I wish to thank the Government of the Canary Islands and its Consejería de Educación, Cultura y Deportes for both a generous four-year Research Scholarship, “Beca de Postgrado Conducente a la Obtención del Grado de Doctor,” (1992-1996),and a second four-month grant to be part of the Canadian Studies Program of the University of Ottawa (1997). Both the Government of the Canary Islands and the Spanish Association for Canadian Studies have contributed financially to various of my conference trips in which I have had the opportunity to test my work in progress. They have alsopartially or totally funded my several stays as a Visiting Scholar at theUniversitiesof Toronto,Ottawa and Manitoba. I am indebted to the Centre for Canadian Studies at the University of La Laguna for providing me with the academic forum as well as the institutional support necessary for the research and writing of this project. My most sincere thanks to Professor Sam Solecki, former Dean of Humanities of the University of Toronto,who kindly guided me for several years since I first went to the University of Toronto in the summer of 1994, as well as to the Staff at Robarts Library and the National Library of Canada, especially to its director Mr.
    [Show full text]
  • Condolence Motion Jean Jay Macpherson.Docx
    CONDOLENCE MOTION Moved by: Councillor Adam Vaughan Seconded by: Councillor Kristyn Wong-Tam The Mayor and Members of Toronto City Council are deeply saddened to learn of the passing of Jean Jay Macpherson on March 21, 2012. Jay Macpherson was one of Canada’s great poets and a widely admired scholar and teacher. She won the Governor General’s Literary Award for her 1957 collection, The Boatman, and for nearly four decades from 1957 to 1996, she was a professor in the English Department at Victoria College in the University of Toronto. Jay was fully engaged in the political life of Toronto and joyfully composed songs of political protest. Macpherson was born in London, England, in 1931 and emigrated from England to Newfoundland with her mother and brother in 1940. She attended high school at Bishop Spencer College, St John’s, and Glebe Collegiate, Ottawa. In 1951 Macpherson received a B.A. from Carleton University, followed by a B.L.S. from McGill University; she then completed her M.A. and Ph.D. at Victoria College, University of Toronto, both supervised by professor and critic Northrop Frye. She began publishing her poems in 1949, at the age of eighteen, and her first pamphlet, Nineteen Poems, was published in 1952 by Robert Graves’s Seizin Press. In 1954 Macpherson began her own small press, Emblem Books, which published her second volume, O earth return. Between 1954 and 1963, Emblem Books published eight chapbooks featuring the work of Canadian poets, including Dorothy Livesay, Alden Nowlan, and Al Purdy. Macpherson's two earlier collections were incorporated into The Boatman, which gained her an international reputation.
    [Show full text]
  • Copyright by Veronica Leigh House 2006
    Copyright by Veronica Leigh House 2006 The Dissertation Committee for Veronica Leigh House certifies that this is the approved version of the following dissertation: BACKWARD TO YOUR SOURCES, SACRED RIVERS: A TRANSATLANTIC FEMINIST TRADITION OF MYTHIC REVISION Committee: ______________________________________ Elizabeth Butler Cullingford, Co-Supervisor ______________________________________ Lesley Dean-Jones, Co-Supervisor ______________________________________ Lisa Moore ______________________________________ Brian Bremen ______________________________________ Charles Rossman BACKWARD TO YOUR SOURCES, SACRED RIVERS: A TRANSATLANTIC FEMINIST TRADITION OF MYTHIC REVISION by Veronica Leigh House, B.A., M.F.A. Dissertation Presented to the Faculty of the Graduate School of the University of Texas at Austin in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of Doctor of Philosophy The University of Texas at Austin May 2006 BACKWARD TO YOUR SOURCES, SACRED RIVERS: A TRANSATLANTIC FEMINIST TRADITION OF MYTHIC REVISION Publication No. __________ Veronica Leigh House, Ph.D. The University of Texas at Austin, 2006 Co-Supervisors: Elizabeth Butler Cullingford and Lesley Dean-Jones This project examines the under-explored tradition of post-WWII mythological poetry by women. The poets in the study engage in cultural politics both by subverting and reaffirming the foundational stories of the Western literary tradition. Greek myths offer some of literature’s strongest and most eloquent female characters, and yet they provide the model for misogynist representations of women in the arts. Post-WWII mythic revision is partly a response to the male high modernist’s (particularly Pound’s and Eliot’s) return to a Greek heroic ideal. The women poets respond to three sets of texts: the original Greek, the male modernist poets’ versions of the myths, and previous mythic revisions by women.
    [Show full text]
  • Frye Unschooled: Mythopoeic Modernism in Canada Melissa Dalgleish York University
    Frye Unschooled: Mythopoeic Modernism in Canada Melissa Dalgleish York University he relationship between Northrop Frye and the group of poets some- Ttimes known as the Frye School1 has been of enough critical interest over the last half-century to produce a significant, if fragmented, body of work on the subject. While it has not received the attention paid to earlier Cana- dian modernist poetry, 2 the Toronto-based mythopoeic tradition has been addressed by some of Canada’s most prominent critics, who begin to note the distinctive character of this tradition in the 1950s. Appraisals of the Frye School generally fall into three camps: critics note the emergence of a mythopoeic tradition in mid-century Toronto but do not tie it directly 1 The term “School of Frye” seems to have been first used in a work of criticism by Milton Wilson in 1959, but he uses it as an alternative to “School of Pratt,” sug- gesting that the mid-century mythopoeic tradition is rooted as much in earlier Canadian poetry as it is in Frye. Kokotailo and Jones make a similar argument. 2 While there are sustained studies of Canadian modernism in the 1920s (Brian Trehearne’s Aestheticism and the Canadian Modernists), 1930s (including Can- dida Rifkind’s Comrades and Critics: Women, Literature, and the Left in 1930s Canada), and the 1940s (Brian Trehearne’s The Montreal Forties: Modernist Poetry in Transition), no full-length study of the 1950s, which would by necessity focus on the poets associated with the Frye School, has yet been undertaken. ESC 37.2 (June 2011): 43–66 to Frye,3 they argue that this tradition emerges explicitly because of Frye’s influence,4 or they challenge Frye’s influence as the crucial factor leading to the tradition’s emergence.5 But despite the continued interest of this Melissa Dalgleish topic to critics, the coeval development of Frye’s archetypal criticism and is a doctoral candidate the highly mythic poetic praxis of the writers grouped under the Frye in English at York School banner, a moment that marks a distinctive shift in the character of University.
    [Show full text]
  • Biographical Influence in Canadian Literature
    In compliance with the Canadian Privacy Legislation some supporting forms may have been removed from this dissertation. While these forms may be included in the document page count, their removal does not represent any loss of content from the dissertation. POSTHUMOUS PRAISE BIOGRAPHICAL INFLUENCE IN CANADIAN LITERATURE By RICHARD ALMONTE, B.A., B.ED., M.A. A Thesis Submitted to the School of Graduate Studies in Partial Fulfilment of the Requirements for the Degree Doctor of Philosophy McMaster University © Copyright by Richard Almonte, September 2003 POSTHUMOUS PRAISE DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHY (2003) McMaster University (English) Hamilton, Ontario TITLE: Posthumous Praise: Biographical Influence in Canadian Literature AUTHOR: Richard Almonte, B.A. (Toronto), B.Ed. (Western), M.A. (Concordia) SUPERVISOR: Professor James King NUMBER OF PAGES: vii, 250 .. \\ Abstract This dissertation explores the phenomenon whereby a number of deceased Canadian women writers have had their lives utilized in subsequent works of fiction, drama, poetry, film, and biography. The dissertation gives this phenomenon a name-biographical influence-and argues that it represents a challenge to traditional literary canonicity in the Canadian context. Whereas literary canonicity has traditionally been the domain ofliterature professors, the phenomenon of biographical influence may be read as a writer-enacted substitution for traditional canonicity. This writer-enacted canon is comprised of literary heroines who have been elevated to their status not, as is traditional, because of the value oftheir work. Rather, entry to this new canon is reserved for writers whose lives often come close to eclipsing the value ascribed to their work. This is an ironic canonicity that valorizes the writer's life, while claiming to valorize the writer's work.
    [Show full text]
  • The Porcupine's Quill Fall 2017
    The Porcupine’s Quill DISTRIBUTED BY UNIVERSITY OF TORONTO PRESS Fall 2017 Press sharply. Now Available as exemplary e-Books In recent years all of our frontlist, and select backlist, has become available in searchable PDF format designed primarily for use on tablets. Ten of these quality digital productions have been favoured with recognition by the eLit awards programme administered by the Jenkins Group of Traverse City,MI. To date the collection as a whole includes almost 100 Porcupine’s Quill titles as well as 18 backlist issues of the Devil’s Artisan.For best selection ... • contact us directly at store.porcupinesquill.ca • or order through Google Play,which will facilitate international sales in any number of local currencies. Digital copies of the Devil’s Artisan are also available from Magzter,and select PQL backlist may be available from Ebsco, Gibson Library Services, ProQuest and Scribd. Thecollection features the poetry of P.K.Page, the Wordless Novels of George A. Walker,and all fifteen titles in our series of ‘Essential Poets’ featuring work by Margaret Avison, Don Coles, Daryl Hine, D.G.Jones, Travis Lane, Jay Macpherson, Richard Outram, P.K.Page, James Reaney and other luminaries. STICKY finger s is a somewhat irreverent moniker we have adopted for a new digital imprint of the Porcupine’s Quill that offers short, attractive, informative editions that probe the intersection between Canadian literature and the book arts, packaged exclusively for mobile devices. Each chapbook is available in ePub for iPads and Android tablets, and Mobi for Kindle, and retails for $2.99.
    [Show full text]