Morro Shoulderband Snail Report, Padre
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
MEMORANDUM To: EMC Planning Group Project No: 1902-1172 Attn: Teri Wissler From: Alyssa Berry – Senior Biologist (Padre Associates, Inc.) Kenny Wimer – Staff Biologist (Padre Associates, Inc.) Date: February 3, 2021 Subject: Protocol Survey Results for Morro Shoulderband Snail for the Battery Energy Storage System Project, City of Morro Bay, California This memorandum has been prepared by Padre Associates, Inc. (Padre) to document the progress and interim findings of United States Fish and Wildlife (USFWS) protocol surveys for the Morro shoulderband snail (MSS) (Helminthoglypta walkeriana) at the Battery Energy Storage System (BESS) Project Site, located within the Vistra Power Plant Property (Property) in the City of Morro Bay, California (Project Site). To date, three of the five required surveys have been completed with negative results for MSS. Upon completion of the remaining two surveys, a summary report of results will be prepared and submitted. Surveys were conducted on December 14 and 29, 2020 and January 29, 2021, by Ecological Assets Management, LLC (EAM) USFWS-permitted Biologists, Dwayne Oberhoff and Bob Sloan, with accompaniment by Padre Biologists, Michaela Hoffman and Kenny Wimer on an alternating basis. The surveys are being conducted to document the presence or absence of MSS at the Project Site in support of the BESS permitting application process. Per USFWS protocol, a total of five MSS surveys are required, including a habitat assessment, that are spaced at least one week apart and within 24 hours of a rain event. Survey methodology included traveling by foot throughout the Property while searching for any potential MSS. Living snails, as well as remnant shells, were inspected for MSS identification characteristics such as shell dimensions, spire profile, markings, and groove pattern. A hand magnifying lens was used on some older/sun-bleached shells, as needed. All potentially suitable habitat areas were surveyed, including native/non-native vegetation and around/beneath structures and debris. Special attention was paid to the organic layer (duff) beneath shrub species known to be favored by MSS, including silver bush lupine (Lupinus chamissonis) and coyote brush (Baccharis pilularis). The duff layer was turned over by hand and inspected for snails. Due to the high amount of water runoff during the previous days’ rain, areas of pooled water where remnant shells may have collected were inspected as well. No living or dead MSS were observed during any of the surveys. Other species observed included Big Sur shoulderband snail (Helminthoglypta umbilicata) and brown garden snail (Helix 369 Pacific Street ▲ San Luis Obispo, CA 93401 ▲ (805) 786-2650 ▲ Fax (805) 786-2651 www.padreinc.com Battery Energy Storage System Project Morro Shoulderband Snail Memo February 3, 2021 (1902-1172) aspera). In general, remnant shells and fragments far-outnumbered living snails; however, snail movement and mating was observed, likely related to the previous days’ rain, and indicating that it was an optimal time to survey for MSS. Per USFWS protocol, two more surveys will be conducted during the 2020/2021 rainy season pending additional rain events that are spaced at least one week apart. If you have any questions or comments regarding the contents of this memorandum, please contact Alyssa Berry at (805) 722-5458 or by email at [email protected], or Kenny Wimer at (805) 215-8089, or by email at [email protected]. Sincerely, Padre Associates, Inc. Alyssa Berry Senior Biologist Kenny Wimer Staff Biologist - 2 - U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service Attn. Julie Vanderwier 2493 Portola Road, Suite B Ventura, CA 93003 March 9, 2016 Subject: No-take Concurrence Request for the Proposed Decommissioning of Dynegy’s Morro Bay Power Plant Marine Terminal, (APN 066-331-040), Morro Bay, San Luis Obispo County, California Ms. Julie Vanderweir: The attached Morro shoulderband snail (MSS) protocol survey report has been prepared by Ecological Assets Management LLC (EAM) for Padre Associates, Inc. (Padre) on behalf of Dynegy Morro Bay, LLC (Dynegy) at the Morro Bay Power Plant (APN 066-331-040) located in Morro Bay, San Luis Obispo County, California. This report presents the methods and results of five protocol-level Morro shoulderband snail (MSS) surveys and habitat assessment conducted from November 16, 2015, to January 19, 2016, on an approximate 9.45 acre area (Survey Area) located in the western portion of the 107 acre Morro Bay Power Plant (MBPP) facility. This report provides a description of existing conditions within the Survey Area and adjacent areas, and, in combination with the protocol surveys results, determines whether Morro shoulderband snail and/or suitable habitat for Morro shoulderband snail is present. In summary, the five protocol surveys conducted within the 9.45 acre Survey Area observed no live or empty MSS shells. Restricted and small areas of suitable habitat (e.g. coastal dune scrub, ice plant and sandy soils) were observed within the Survey Area. During the protocol surveys numerous empty shells from both Big Sur shoulderband snail (Helminthoglypta umbilicata) and brown garden snail (Helix aspera) were observed. Numerous previous surveys and monitoring efforts conducted by other biologists from 1999 to 2010 within the Survey Area also found no MSS. Based on the results of the five protocol surveys and habitat assessment presented in this report, and the previous MSS survey and monitoring efforts, “take” of MSS will not occur from the proposed project within the Survey Area. Thus, Padre, on behalf of Dynegy, is requesting a no-take concurrence determination for the proposed project. PO Box 6840, Los Osos, CA 93412 | 805.440.6137 http://www.ecologicalmgmt.com | [email protected] Morro Bay Power Plant No-take Concurrence Request If you have any questions or comments regarding this request please contact me at 805.440.6137 or e-mail at [email protected]. Sincerely, Dwayne Oberhoff Senior Project Biologist Ecological Assets Management, LLC Ecological Assets Management, LLC 2 Morro Shoulderband Snail Protocol Survey Report at Morro Bay Power Plant (APN 066-331-040), Morro Bay, San Luis Obispo County, California Prepared for: Prepared by: Padre Associates, Inc. 369 Pacific Street San Luis Obispo, CA 93401 March 9, 2016 PO Box 6840, Los Osos, CA 93412 | 805.440.6137 http://www.ecologicalmgmt.com | [email protected] Morro Bay Power Plant MSS Protocol Survey Report Introduction The following Morro shoulderband snail (Helminthoglypta walkeriana) protocol survey report has been prepared by Ecological Assets Management LLC (EAM) for Padre Associates, Inc. (Padre) on behalf of Dynegy Morro Bay, LLC (Dynegy) at the Morro Bay Power Plant (APN 066-331-040) located in Morro Bay, San Luis Obispo County, California. This report presents the methods and results of five protocol-level Morro shoulderband snail (MSS) surveys and habitat assessment conducted from November 16, 2015, to January 19, 2016, on an approximate 9.45 acre area (Survey Area) located in the western portion of the 107 acre Morro Bay Power Plant (MBPP) facility. This report provides a description of existing conditions within the Survey Area and adjacent areas, and, in combination with the protocol surveys results, determines whether Morro shoulderband snail and/or suitable habitat for Morro shoulderband snail is present. In summary, the five protocol surveys conducted within the Survey Area observed no live or empty MSS shells. Restricted and small areas of suitable habitat (e.g. coastal dune scrub, ice plant and sandy soils) were observed within the Survey Area. During the protocol surveys numerous empty shells from both Big Sur shoulderband snail (Helminthoglypta umbilicata) and brown garden snail (Helix aspera) were observed. Numerous previous surveys and monitoring efforts conducted by other biologists from 1999 to 2010 within the Survey Area also found no MSS. Based on the results of the five protocol surveys and habitat assessment presented in this report, and the previous MSS survey and monitoring efforts, “take” of MSS will not occur from the proposed project within the Survey Area. Protocol Survey and Habitat Assessment Methods The 2003 United States Fish and Wildlife Service (USFWS) Protocol Survey Guidelines for MSS require that protocol surveys be performed during or immediately following a rain event (i.e. protocol conditions) to establish the presence or absence of MSS at a location. Protocol surveys must include a general habitat assessment that identifies key habitat features within and adjacent to the Survey Area. This report is based on the results of five separate site visits to the approximate 9.45 acre Survey Area of the 107 acre subject parcel to conduct five protocol surveys and a concurrent MSS habitat assessment. The surveys were conducted on November 16, December 11, December 22, 2015; and, January 7, and January 19, 2016. The protocol surveys on November 16 and December 11 and 22, 2015, were conducted by permitted biologists Dwayne Oberhoff and Bob Sloan. The protocol surveys on January 7 and 19, 2016, were conducted by permitted biologist Dwayne Oberhoff. Dwayne Oberhoff is permitted to conduct MSS protocol surveys under federal recovery permit TE-180579-1. Bob Sloan is permitted to conduct MSS protocol surveys under federal recovery permit TE-43937B-0. Padre Staff Biologist, Ms. Michaela Hoffman or Kenny Ecological Assets Management, LLC 1 Morro Bay Power Plant MSS Protocol Survey Report Wimmer, were also present