DOCSLIB.ORG

CHAPTER 4 Preparing for Research: Metatheoretical Considerations

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
CHAPTER 4 Preparing for Research: Metatheoretical Considerations Lor International & comparative librarianship, chapter 4, rev. 2017-01-11 CHAPTER 4 Preparing for research: metatheoretical considerations “Go and be somethingological directly.” – Mrs Gradgrind to her children, in Charles Dickens's Hard Times (Dickens [1854] 1996, 56) Paradigm issues are crucial; no inquirer, we maintain, ought to go about the business of inquiry without being clear about just what paradigm informs and guides his or her approach. (Guba and Lincoln 1994, 116) There is no denying that what follows is a Cook’s tour of complicated philosophies that demand more detailed attention in their own right… (Schwandt 2000, 190) OUTLINE 4.1 Introduction 4.2 Method, methodology and metatheory 4.3 Metatheory, methodology and methods: the Iceberg Model 4.4 Metatheoretical dimensions 4.5 Major research paradigms 4.6 The sociological dimension 4.7 The teleological dimension 4.8 The ontological dimension 4.9 The epistemological dimension 4.10 The ethical dimension 4.11 Decisions relating to metatheoretical assumptions 4.12 Towards methodology This is a draft chapter from: Lor, Peter Johan (in prep.) International and comparative librarianship: concepts and methods for global studies. This version of Chapter 4, which replaces an earlier Chapter 3, is dated 2017-01-11. It is not yet final but it is made available for information and comment. It may be used for educational and research purposes subject to author attribution. © Peter Johan Lor, 2017. Text: 24580 Bibl: 5154 Total: 29734 1 Lor International & comparative librarianship, chapter 4, rev. 2017-01-11 4.1 Introduction Following on the historical and conceptual basis laid in Part I, Part II deals with method, broadly understood as including considerations of metatheory, methodology and methods. While Part II has grown out of reflection on method in comparative librarianship, most of what is covered here also applies to both research and practice in international librarianship. In Part II a tripartite division is followed, a chapter being devoted to each of metatheory, methodology and methods. Extensive use is made here of literature from other comparative fields, especially comparative education, which was a major early influence on comparative librarianship. This chapter1 starts by distinguishing between metatheory, methodology and method, before discussing metatheory in more detail. 4.2 Method, methodology and metatheory Students of Ancient Greek will know that the preposition μετά (meta), which is embedded in each of these three terms, can express many relationships. Meta can mean, inter alia, ‘in the midst of’, ‘among’, ‘after’, and ‘in pursuit of’.2 Combined with ὁδός (hodós, “way, motion, journey”) it gives ‘method’,3 denoting a process or a way of doing something. With –ology’’ added to express the notion of science or discipline, it gives ‘methodology’, denoting the study of method. In ‘metatheory’ the prefix meta means ‘after’, ‘beyond’, or ‘transcending’, hence in English, theory about or above theory.4 In this book these three terms are used with distinct meanings and are conceived of in a hierarchical relationship. Methods and methodology Methods, in the plural, is used here to refer to procedures and techniques of research, the contents of the research ‘toolkit’, such as sampling, interviewing, surveying, observations, data analysis and their associated instruments, such as questionnaires, interview schedules and observation protocols. Typically, a large proportion of research method texts in LIS is devoted to methods, and in research reports the methods used will normally be described and a motivation will be provided for their selection. Collectively, methods and methodology may be referred to by the singular, method – which will be avoided here. Methodology, originally ‘the study of method’, is now widely used to refer to a set of methods, a description of the methods used in a study, an elaborate method, or simply as a grand word for a method. In this book I use ‘methodology’ in a more specialized sense to refer to high-level decisions on research approaches, strategy and research design. These decisions are fundamental to the selection of the specific methods to be employed. Metatheory Of the three terms, metatheory is the least known and it is infrequently mentioned in research articles and reports. It refers to assumptions which underpin researchers’ decisions on methodology and methods for specific projects, assumptions of which they may or may not be 1 In this chapter I make extensive use of an article published in Journal of documentation (Lor 2014). 2 Wiktionary, “μετά”, https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/%CE%BC%CE%B5%CF%84%CE%AC#Ancient_Greek, accessed 2016-11-23. 3 Wiktionary, “method”, https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/method, accessed 2016-11-23. 4 Wiktionary, “meta-“, https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/meta-#English, accessed 2016-11-23. 2 Lor International & comparative librarianship, chapter 4, rev. 2017-01-11 aware. Such assumptions do not apply only to research, but are also worth bringing to the surface in the context of international activities and relations in LIS. International initiatives that are undertaken without reflection on the assumptions held by the partners, risk unanticipated difficulties. This applies to such activities as library development aid, the education and training of librarians from other countries, and the introduction of new systems and technologies. Dervin defined metatheory as ...presuppositions which provide general perspectives or ways of looking, based on assumptions about the nature of reality and human beings (ontology), the nature of knowing (epistemology), the purposes of theory and research (teleology); values and ethics (axiology); and the nature of power (ideology) (Dervin 2003, 136). A complementary view of metatheory was provided by Hjørland: ...metatheories are broader and less specific than theories. They are more or less conscious or unconscious assumptions behind theoretical, empirical and practical work. Metatheoretical assumptions are connected to philosophical views, and are often part of interdisciplinary trends, which again can be connected to the Zeitgeist (Hjørland 1998, 607). Various terms are used for these high-level theoretical points of departure for research. Here I use ‘metatheory’ as a collective noun, and ‘paradigm’ for the specific metatheoretical perspectives or worldviews, for example, positivist or constructivist paradigms. For our purposes a paradigm is a more or less coherent set of metatheoretical assumptions – a worldview – held by like-minded scholars across a number of disciplines. 4.3 Metatheory, methodology and methods: the Iceberg Model There is general agreement that there is an order of precedence, or a hierarchical relationship, between methods, methodology and metatheory. As a general principle, researchers should first clarify their metatheoretical assumptions and then consider methodological decisions, before selecting and developing methods. In distinguishing between metatheory, methodology and method, Dervin (2003, 136–37) placed metatheory before methodology and method, where methodology serves as a bridge between the other two. Similarly, Pickard (2007, xv-xv11) proposed the following “research hierarchy”: Research paradigm (positivist, interpretivist) → Research methodology (qualitative or quantitative) → Research method (survey, case study, Delphi study, etc.) → Research technique (questionnaire, experiment, interview) → Research instrument (human, pencil & paper, etc.). A somewhat similar scheme is found in Mouton (1996, 36–37), who identified “three levels of the methodological dimension”: research techniques, research methods and methodological paradigms, the latter being related to epistemological and ontological assumptions, whereas the methodological paradigms comprise quantitative, qualitative and participatory action paradigms. 3 Lor International & comparative librarianship, chapter 4, rev. 2017-01-11 Here I follow Dervin’s tripartite division, relating it to Pickard’s and Mouton’s categories as set out in Table 4.1: TABLE 4.1: Research hierarchy according to Dervin, Pickard and Mouton Dervin (1999) Pickard (2007) Mouton (1996) Metatheory Research paradigm Epistemological and ontological assumptions Methodology Research methodology Methodological paradigm Research method (or Research method strategy) Method Research technique Research technique Research instrument A floating iceberg can serve as a metaphor for the relative visibility and significance of metatheory, methodology and methods. Because the specific gravity of ice is less than that of water, approximately 90% of an iceberg is below the water. In Figure 4.1 metatheory, methodology and methods are depicted at different levels of a floating iceberg. FIGURE 4.1: The “Iceberg Model” of research assumptions and decisions Metatheory corresponds to the submerged part of the iceberg, and comprises the less visible dimensions of social science research, which are discussed in this chapter. They are pictured as below the surface since key assumptions concerning where we are coming from as researchers (the sociological dimension of research), what we want to achieve through our research (the teleological dimension), what is an appropriate object for study (the ontological dimension), and how we can come to knowledge of it (the epistemological dimension), are often left 4 Lor International & comparative librarianship, chapter 4, rev. 2017-01-11 unexamined and unchallenged, and they are not often
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Logic and Its Metatheory
    Logic and its Metatheory Philosophy 432 Spring 2017 T & TH: 300-450pm Olds Hall 109 Instructor Information Matthew McKeon Office: 503 South Kedzie Hall Office hours: 1-2:30pm on T & TH and by appointment. Telephone: Dept. Office—355-4490 E-mail: [email protected] Required Text Courseware Package (Text plus CD software): Jon Barwise and John Etchemendy. Language, Proof and Logic. 2nd edition. Stanford, CA: CLSI Publications, 2011. The courseware package includes several software tools that students will use to complete homework assignments and the self-diagnostic exercises from the text. DO NOT BUY USED BOOKS, BECAUSE THEY LACK THE CD, WHICH CONTAINS THE SOFTWARE. The software, easy to learn and use, makes some of the more technical aspects of symbolic logic accessible to introductory students and it is fun to use (or so I think). It is OK to have an earlier edition of the text as long as you have the CD with the password key that will allow you to access the text’s online site (https://ggweb.gradegrinder.net/lpl). Here you can update the software suite and download the 2nd edition of the text. At the site you can also purchase the software and an electronic version of the text. Primary Course Objectives • Deepen your understanding of the concept of logical consequence and sharpen your ability to see that one sentence is a logical consequence of others. • Introduce you to the basic methods of proof (both formal and informal), and teach you how to use them effectively to prove that one sentence is a logical consequence of others.
    [Show full text]
  • Mobile Leapfrogging and Digital Divide Policy Assessing the Limitations of Mobile Internet Access
    New America Foundation Mobile Leapfrogging and Digital Divide Policy Assessing the limitations of mobile Internet access By Philip M. Napoli and Jonathan A. Obar1 April 2013 This paper examines the emerging global phenomenon of mobile leapfrogging in Internet access. Leapfrogging refers to the process in which new Internet users are obtaining access by mobile devices and are skipping the traditional means of access: personal computers. This leapfrogging of PC-based Internet access has been hailed in many quarters as an important means of rapidly and inexpensively reducing the gap in Internet access between developed and developing nations, thereby reducing the need for policy interventions to address this persistent digital divide. This paper offers a critical perspective on the process of mobile leapfrogging. Drawing upon data on Internet access and device penetration from 34 countries, this paper first shows that while greater access to mobile technologies suggests the possibility of a leapfrog effect, the lack of 3G adoption suggests that mobile phones are not yet acting as functionally equivalent substitutes for personal computers. Next, this paper puts forth a set of concerns regarding the limitations and potential shortcomings of mobile-based Internet access relative to traditional PC-based Internet access. This paper illustrates a number of important relative shortcomings in terms of memory and speed, content availability, network architecture, and patterns of information seeking and content creation amongst users. This paper concludes that policymakers should be cautions about promoting mobile access as a solution to the digital divide, and undertake policy reforms that ensure that communities that rely on mobile as their only gateway to the Internet do not get left further behind.
    [Show full text]
  • Leapfrogging: Look Before You Leap
    UNITED NATIONS CONFERENCE ON TRADE AND DEVELOPMENT No.71 DECEMBER 2018 LEAPFROGGING: LOOK BEFORE YOU LEAP New technologies, such as digital mobile communications, drones for precision agriculture and decentralized renewable energy systems that provide electricity in rural areas far from the grid, open up opportunities for leapfrogging. As developing countries have limited capabilities, opportunities for leapfrogging in these countries are presented primarily through the adoption of technologies. Innovation policies can help developing countries foster and facilitate the deployment of frontier technologies and their adaptation to meet their needs, to promote sustainable development.1 Frontier technologies and Potential for leapfrogging leapfrogging In large part, the experience of the ICT Discussions of the developmental dimension sector has brought increased attention to of frontier technologies, particularly digital leapfrogging. Rapid technological advances technologies, often highlight the possibility and cost reductions in ICT in recent decades have enabled some developing countries, POLICY BRIEF of “leapfrogging”, the concept of “bypassing intermediate stages of technology through notably in Africa and Asia, to skip the Key points which countries have historically passed development of landline infrastructure by 2 moving directly to mobile telecommunications. • Countries engage in during the development process”. The leapfrogging by bypassing traditional notion of “catch-up” refers For example, in the early 2000s, Cambodia, the imtermediate stages of to the narrowing of gaps in income and Côte d’Ivoire, Gambia, Ghana, Mali, Nepal technology in a development technological capabilities between a late- and Timor-Leste had less than three fixed- process. telephone subscriptions per 100 inhabitants, • Rapid technological advances developing country and a front-runner and cost reductions in country.
    [Show full text]
  • The Trajectory of the Anthropocene: the Great Acceleration
    ANR0010.1177/2053019614564785The Anthropocene ReviewSteffen et al. 564785research-article2015 Review The Anthropocene Review 1 –18 The trajectory of the © The Author(s) 2015 Reprints and permissions: Anthropocene: The Great sagepub.co.uk/journalsPermissions.nav DOI: 10.1177/2053019614564785 Acceleration anr.sagepub.com Will Steffen,1,2 Wendy Broadgate,3 Lisa Deutsch,1 Owen Gaffney3 and Cornelia Ludwig1 Abstract The ‘Great Acceleration’ graphs, originally published in 2004 to show socio-economic and Earth System trends from 1750 to 2000, have now been updated to 2010. In the graphs of socio-economic trends, where the data permit, the activity of the wealthy (OECD) countries, those countries with emerging economies, and the rest of the world have now been differentiated. The dominant feature of the socio-economic trends is that the economic activity of the human enterprise continues to grow at a rapid rate. However, the differentiated graphs clearly show that strong equity issues are masked by considering global aggregates only. Most of the population growth since 1950 has been in the non-OECD world but the world’s economy (GDP), and hence consumption, is still strongly dominated by the OECD world. The Earth System indicators, in general, continued their long-term, post-industrial rise, although a few, such as atmospheric methane concentration and stratospheric ozone loss, showed a slowing or apparent stabilisation over the past decade. The post-1950 acceleration in the Earth System indicators remains clear. Only beyond the mid-20th century is there clear evidence for fundamental shifts in the state and functioning of the Earth System that are beyond the range of variability of the Holocene and driven by human activities.
    [Show full text]
  • Leapfrogging Technology
    privateP UBLIC POLICY FORsector THE NOTE NUMBER 254 Leapfrogging Technology Masami Kojima FEBRUARY 2003 Masami Kojima is a lead Cost-Effective Solution for Pollution in Developing Countries? energy and environment specialist at the World Leapfrogging technology makes sense where technological advances Bank focusing on joint are driven by market demand, as in telecommunications and energy, environment, and transport policy issues, information technology. But technological advances driven by the especially fuel quality, need to deal with such externalities as pollution are more vehicle emission control, fuel pricing policy, and the complicated, for they do not inherently increase profitability or health impact of pollution. efficiency. Using air pollution by vehicles as an illustration, this Note She has worked on these issues in Bank programs examines the issues that need to be considered in deciding whether in Latin America, South leapfrogging technology is a cost-effective solution. Asia, Central Asia, and the Caucasus. The pace of technological advance in the past ernment budget, removing one of the potential few decades has opened new possibilities. obstacles to implementation. Consider the technology for controlling emis- sions from cars, buses, and trucks. Government Danger of considering technology-based regulations have driven this technology as much regulations in isolation as the technology has driven regulations, result- The argument is appealing. If all else remained ing in vehicle emission standards in industrial the same, imposing stringent standards that PRIVATE SECTOR AND INFRASTRUCTURE NETWORK countries that have become increasingly require the best available technology would stringent—far more so than those in developing indeed improve air quality, reduce illness, and countries.
    [Show full text]
  • Vertical Innovation Industry Development to Enable Leapfrogging, Superior Competitiveness and Innovation
    BACKGROUND NOTE Vertical Innovation Industry Development to Enable Leapfrogging, Superior Competitiveness and Innovation René Rohrbeck, Olga Kokshagina, and Susann Roth DISCLAIMER This background paper was prepared for the report Asian Development Outlook 2020: What Drives Innovation in Asia? It is made available here to communicate the results of the underlying research work with the least possible delay. The manuscript of this paper therefore has not been prepared in accordance with the procedures appropriate to formally-edited texts. The findings, interpretations, and conclusions expressed in this paper do not necessarily reflect the views of the Asian Development Bank (ADB), its Board of Governors, or the governments they represent. The ADB does not guarantee the accuracy of the data included in this document and accepts no responsibility for any consequence of their use. The mention of specific companies or products of manufacturers does not imply that they are endorsed or recommended by ADB in preference to others of a similar nature that are not mentioned. Any designation of or reference to a particular territory or geographic area, or use of the term “country” in this document, is not intended to make any judgments as to the legal or other status of any territory or area. Boundaries, colors, denominations, and other information shown on any map in this document do not imply any judgment on the part of the ADB concerning the legal status of any territory or the endorsement or acceptance of such boundaries. VERTICAL INNOVATION INDUSTRY DEVELOPMENT To Enable Leapfrogging, Superior Competitiveness, and Innovation René Rohrbeck, Olga Kokshagina, and Susann Roth1 A.
    [Show full text]
  • Mechanized Metatheory Revisited
    Journal of Automated Reasoning manuscript No. (will be inserted by the editor) Mechanized metatheory revisited Dale Miller Draft: August 29, 2019 Abstract When proof assistants and theorem provers implement the metatheory of logical systems, they must deal with a range of syntactic expressions (e.g., types, for- mulas, and proofs) that involve variable bindings. Since most mature proof assistants do not have built-in methods to treat bindings, they have been extended with various packages and libraries that allow them to encode such syntax using, for example, de Bruijn numerals. We put forward the argument that bindings are such an intimate aspect of the structure of expressions that they should be accounted for directly in the underlying programming language support for proof assistants and not via packages and libraries. We present an approach to designing programming languages and proof assistants that directly supports bindings in syntax. The roots of this approach can be found in the mobility of binders between term-level bindings, formula-level bindings (quantifiers), and proof-level bindings (eigenvariables). In particular, the combination of Church's approach to terms and formulas (found in his Simple Theory of Types) and Gentzen's approach to proofs (found in his sequent calculus) yields a framework for the interaction of bindings with a full range of logical connectives and quantifiers. We will also illustrate how that framework provides a direct and semantically clean treatment of computation and reasoning with syntax containing bindings. Some imple- mented systems, which support this intimate and built-in treatment of bindings, will be briefly described. Keywords mechanized metatheory, λ-tree syntax, mobility of binders 1 Metatheory and its mechanization Theorem proving|in both its interactive and automatic forms|has been applied in a wide range of domains.
    [Show full text]
  • The Trajectory of the Anthropocene: The
    ANR0010.1177/2053019614564785The Anthropocene ReviewSteffen et al. 564785research-article2015 Review The Anthropocene Review 1 –18 The trajectory of the © The Author(s) 2015 Reprints and permissions: Anthropocene: The Great sagepub.co.uk/journalsPermissions.nav DOI: 10.1177/2053019614564785 Acceleration anr.sagepub.com Will Steffen,1,2 Wendy Broadgate,3 Lisa Deutsch,1 Owen Gaffney3 and Cornelia Ludwig1 Abstract The ‘Great Acceleration’ graphs, originally published in 2004 to show socio-economic and Earth System trends from 1750 to 2000, have now been updated to 2010. In the graphs of socio-economic trends, where the data permit, the activity of the wealthy (OECD) countries, those countries with emerging economies, and the rest of the world have now been differentiated. The dominant feature of the socio-economic trends is that the economic activity of the human enterprise continues to grow at a rapid rate. However, the differentiated graphs clearly show that strong equity issues are masked by considering global aggregates only. Most of the population growth since 1950 has been in the non-OECD world but the world’s economy (GDP), and hence consumption, is still strongly dominated by the OECD world. The Earth System indicators, in general, continued their long-term, post-industrial rise, although a few, such as atmospheric methane concentration and stratospheric ozone loss, showed a slowing or apparent stabilisation over the past decade. The post-1950 acceleration in the Earth System indicators remains clear. Only beyond the mid-20th century is there clear evidence for fundamental shifts in the state and functioning of the Earth System that are beyond the range of variability of the Holocene and driven by human activities.
    [Show full text]
  • Preparing for Research: Metatheoretical Considerations
    Chapter 3 In Chapter 2 a distinction was made between international and comparative librarianship and the scope of these two fields was outlined. In a sense we were running a little ahead of our material, since any such delimitation rests on certain Preparing for research: metatheoretical basic assumptions. These assumptions, of which we may or may not be aware, can be broadly labeled metatheoretical. They underlie methodological decisions and considerations the design and selection of research methods and techniques for specific projects. Such assumptions do not apply only to research, but are also worth bringing to the Outline surface in the context of international activities and relations in LIS. International initiatives that are undertaken without reflection on the assumptions held by the Metatheory, methodology and method partners risk unanticipated difficulties. Wertheimer (2009) recently illustrated this Metatheories in a discussion of the influence of North American educators on LIS education in Positivism Asia and pointed out that a critical understanding of library contexts in other Postpositivism countries is necessary. Interpretivism Multiple metatheories In this chapter1, the main emphasis is on the assumptions underlying research in The sociological dimension comparative librarianship. To a somewhat lesser extent they are also relevant to Disciplinary and paradigmatic influences Ethnocentricity research and professional practice in international librarianship. Extensive use is Language made here of literature from other comparative fields, especially comparative Multinational research education, which was a major early influence on comparative librarianship. The teleological dimension Positivism and postpositivism Interpretivism Metatheory, methodology and method Applied research The ontological dimension Hjørland (2005b:5) defines metatheories as “...theories about the description, Ontological stances investigation, analysis or criticism of the theories in a domain.
    [Show full text]
  • Read an Abstract of Her Msc Dissertation
    Abstract How may innovation policies and the length of cycle of technologies determine the ability of developing states to achieve technological leapfrogging? Author: Olayinka Bandele Supervisor: Professor Daniele Archibuigi Year of Award: 2018 Keywords: technological leapfrogging, technology transfer, patents, short-cycle industries, innovation, decision-making firms, technological turning point, catching-up, Purpose of the Study This study explores the phenomena of ‘technological leapfrogging’ of developing states and asks the question ‘what are the predictors of technological transformation of these economies?’ The study builds on analyses of short-cycle technologies as a pathway to technological upgrading and the convergence of middle-income economies with developed states. A gap in the literature reveals a lack of research on decision-making of domestic firms within developing states, particularly as influenced by national innovation systems and government policy. Bridging this gap in the literature could further understanding of how these firms navigate competitive forces as they seek to upgrade technology or move into new technologies? This paper considers whether predictions may be made of the point at which a country passes a ‘technological leapfrogging marker or turning point?’ Whilst a number of studies in the literature present concepts on how technological transformation and leapfrogging may occur, there is limited research analysis presented on the theoretical prediction of the leapfrogging phenomena. Further research would enrich understanding of the technological transformation process within key sectors of developing states. Research Design Methodology and Findings The research utilizes a quantitative research methodological approach. A regression analysis was undertaken utilizing patent data of 46 countries over a 25-year period sourced from the US patent classification agency, the National Bureau of Economic Research (NBER).
    [Show full text]
  • METALOGIC METALOGIC an Introduction to the Metatheory of Standard First Order Logic
    METALOGIC METALOGIC An Introduction to the Metatheory of Standard First Order Logic Geoffrey Hunter Senior Lecturer in the Department of Logic and Metaphysics University of St Andrews PALGRA VE MACMILLAN © Geoffrey Hunter 1971 Softcover reprint of the hardcover 1st edition 1971 All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced or transmitted, in any form or by any means, without permission. First published 1971 by MACMILLAN AND CO LTD London and Basingstoke Associated companies in New York Toronto Dublin Melbourne Johannesburg and Madras SBN 333 11589 9 (hard cover) 333 11590 2 (paper cover) ISBN 978-0-333-11590-9 ISBN 978-1-349-15428-9 (eBook) DOI 10.1007/978-1-349-15428-9 The Papermac edition of this book is sold subject to the condition that it shall not, by way of trade or otherwise, be lent, resold, hired out, or otherwise circulated without the publisher's prior consent, in any form of binding or cover other than that in which it is published and without a similar condition including this condition being imposed on the subsequent purchaser. To my mother and to the memory of my father, Joseph Walter Hunter Contents Preface xi Part One: Introduction: General Notions 1 Formal languages 4 2 Interpretations of formal languages. Model theory 6 3 Deductive apparatuses. Formal systems. Proof theory 7 4 'Syntactic', 'Semantic' 9 5 Metatheory. The metatheory of logic 10 6 Using and mentioning. Object language and metalang- uage. Proofs in a formal system and proofs about a formal system. Theorem and metatheorem 10 7 The notion of effective method in logic and mathematics 13 8 Decidable sets 16 9 1-1 correspondence.
    [Show full text]
  • Economic Challenges in the Anthropocene
    Ignazio Musu, Ca’ Foscari University of Venice. Economic challenges in the Anthropocene. 1 What is Anthropocene. •Nobel laureate Paul Crutzen (2002): for the past three centuries, profound shift between humans and the rest of nature; unprecedented influence of human action. •The Earth system has left the interglacial (Holocene) era and entered a new one: Anthropocene. •The qualitative shift was determined by the industrial era. •Energy bottleneck in the final stage of Holocene removed by diffusion of fossil fuels. 2 During Holocene: •Impact of preindustrial human societies on environment (through hunting, gathering and, later on, agriculture) within the bounds of environment’s natural variability (Steffen and al., 2007). •Constraints to energy available: • Water and wind power only in favorite locations and limited by importable technologies (of watermills, sailing ships and windmills). • Energy from animals (and through them from plants) limited by land suitable for crops and forage. 3 • Fossil fuels removed the energy bottleneck by offering access to carbon stored from millions of years of photosynthesis. • Industrial societies use four or five times as much energy as did agrarian societies , which in turn used three or four times as much as did hunting and gathering societies (Steffen and al., 2007). • Examples of scientific and technological progress based on fossil fuels: • Invention (and refinement) of the steam engine by James Watt in the 1780s; • Ammonia synthesis from atmospheric nitrogen pioneered by Fritz Haber (the Haber-Bosch synthesis) in the early 20th century. 4 Summary on energy transitions (Scott Taylor, 2012) •Biomass (old green power) to Coal •Coal to Liquid Fuels – Oil and Natural Gas •Liquid Fuels – New Green Power (?) •Past transitions were very slow and of relatively small magnitude.
    [Show full text]