<<

and Bute Council Planning and Regulatory Services

Delegated or Committee Planning Application Report and Report of handling as required by Schedule 2 of the Town and Country Planning (Development Management Procedure) () Regulations 2013 relative to applications for Planning Permission or Planning Permission in Principle ______

Reference No: 16/02911/MIN

Planning Hierarchy: Major Development

Applicant: A and L McCrae Ltd

Proposal: Development of a quarry allowing for the extraction and processing of sand and gravel and the final restoration of the land

Site Address: Glasdrum, Fasnacloich, ______

DECISION ROUTE

(i) Local Government Scotland Act 1973 ______

(A) THE APPLICATION

(i) Development Requiring Express Planning Permission

 Extraction of 83,000 tonnes of sand and gravel over a period of 5 years and 6 months (approximate annual extraction 15,000 tonnes) with two months initial site preparation and a further eight months of final site restoration works;  Siting of weigh bridge and formation of settling ponds,  Use of existing cottage for site office,  Installation of sump  Formation of soil storage bund at northern boundary of the site,  Formation of car parking area,  Improvement to three existing passing places along U37 Salachail Road.  Site restoration works including importation of inert materials (aggregate waste) to raise levels and re-use of top soil. Site will be returned to agricultural use.

(ii) Other specified operations

 The site extends to some 5.35ha with the working area to some 3.05ha,  Working hours proposed are 7am to 6pm Monday to Friday and 7am to 12noon on Saturdays,  There will be an average of six HGV movements a day (three in and three out) with four daily car movements (two in and two out).  Minor tree felling ______(B) RECOMMENDATION:

It is recommended that in consideration of the Local Development Plan and all other material considerations that the application be refused for the reasons appended below. ______

(C) HISTORY:

16/01059/PAN – Proposal of Application Notice for proposed sand and gravel quarry. – Closed 27/5/2016

16/01060/SCRSCO - Screening and scoping application for proposed sand and gravel quarry – Closed 20/5/2016 ______

(D) CONSULTATIONS:

Scottish Environment Protection Agency (SEPA) – Responses dated 8/12/2016, 28/6/2017, 19/7/2017, SEPA initially objected due to concerns over flood risk. They confirm that they are now in a position to remove their objection and provide the following technical comments:

 The FRA indicates a localised increase (less than a 400m reach) in flooding will occur upstream of the proposed development with a maximum flood depth of approximately 0.36m possible. It is suggested that additional flood storage will be provided as a result of the proposed development works however we would confirm that a localised increase in flooding will still occur.

 In these circumstances SEPA would normally request that further management measures are considered to ensure at least a neutral effect on flooding, as per the requirements of Scottish Planning Policy, however in this instance we would note that the effect of increased flood is localised and only impacts on an area of forestry which is sited within the ownership of the same landowner.

 Furthermore the proposed development is a water compatible use and the working life of the quarry is also acknowledged as being of a temporary nature.

Based on these considerations we are now satisfied that the proposal should not represent a significant increase in flood risk

In response to comments made by the Argyll Fisheries Trust (AFT) SEPA comment that there are no proposals to discharge to the water environment. In an extreme flood event there may be additional silt discharging into the water course but this would only occur once the quarry void had filled and defences failed. In such an occurrence the river would be full of silt from upstream and therefore any impact the quarry might have would not be significant in light of this.

Scottish Natural Heritage – Response dated 21/12/2016, 14/6/2017, and 3/8/2017 SNH agree that best practice methodology has been used for the mammal surveys. However, August is not a useful time for breeding bird surveys as most species have completed their breeding efforts. This loss of small section of bat feeding habitat is unlikely to have significant impact on the populations present, particularly given its location within a glen with other suitable feeding resource. Should the application be approved then pre- construction surveys should be carried out and the mitigation measures identified in the ES adhered to. SNH has raised an objection in their response dated 3rd August 2017 citing a lack of information relating to the proposed silt traps. There is a 53% possibility of a flood event that could result in silts from the quarry entering the River Creran and being carried to the Special Area of Conservation (SAC). The applicant has not provided sufficient detail regarding the proposed silt traps other than to say there will be no discharge from the site other than in an extreme flood event. However, they have not provided confirmation of the type, capacity or form of the traps.

Loch Creran is designated for its serpulid reefs whilst there are native oysters at the mouth of the loch which are a priority marine species. The proposal has the potential to threaten both.

Additionally, should the proposal cause additional silting of the River Creran then this would have an adverse impact on the habitat for Atlantic Salmon which are a European Protected Species when in fresh water.

SNH has confirmed that the proposal will not adversely impact on the following nearby designations:

 Glen Etive and Glen Fyne SPA  Glen Creran Woods SAC and SSSI,

Royal Society for the Protection of Birds (RSPB) – Response dated 21/2/2017 The site is close to the Glen Creran woods and Loch Creran SACs and the Glen Etive and Glen Fyne SPA. They advise that a likely significant effect is unlikely to arise on the SPA. In relation to the Glen Creran woods SAC information as to why dust fall out will not impact on the SAC and its associated mosses and lichens is not fully covered within the EIA. Whilst a flooding incident resulting in sediment deposition within the Loch Creran SAC may seem unlikely they advise that consideration maybe given to further mitigation to ensure that such an event does not occur i.e. formation of a natural reed bed filter system. They advise that Habitats Regulation Appraisals are undertaken by the Council under the Habitats Regulations for these sites.

The bird survey work undertaken was carried out within the autumn passage period and does not adhere to recommended guidance. RSPB advise that if the applicant is serious about survey work to inform this proposal then a breeding bird survey should be carried out.

Nature After Minerals does not seem to feature heavily within the EIA and they would advise that should this application be approved a condition is attached to ensure biodiversity gain is maximised within any restoration.

Forestry Commission Scotland (FCS) – Respond dated 13/12/2016 FCS make comment that compensatory planting (CP) is proposed (section 8.8.1.1 of the ES) as required under policy SG LDP ENV 6 (Development Impact on Trees and Woodland). The CP should be of an equivalent woodland area, on appropriate site types and with at least the equivalent woodland related net public benefits.

A planning condition is recommended by FCS to cover the details of the compensatory planting.

Argyll Fisheries Trust (AFT) – Response dated 24/1/2017 AFT have been working on the River Creran since 1988, building an understanding of the salmonid fish populations and the factors that affect them. More recently they have worked with the fishery owners to improve the river habitat to benefit the salmon population of the river which is not currently in a healthy state. AFTs main concern with the proposal is the continual input of fine sediments into the river. Silt traps reduce the amount of silt entering the river, however they cannot block all silt. In a flood situation, the majority of silt and other fine sediments would be transported downstream to Loch Creran, however there will inevitably be fine sediments deposited within the river bed. A regular input of fines for the development is likely to make the area downstream of the proposed quarry site uninhabitable for salmonids.

The location of the proposed quarry coincides with an AFT long term monitoring site. Since 2004, AFT have recorded relatively good numbers of juvenile salmon fry (eggs hatched that year), which shows that adult salmon are spawning in the area. The habitat at the site consists of pebbles and cobbles, which unlike most of the river is stable with plenty of cover, and is therefore of good quality for salmonid fish. AFT estimate that the distance from this site to the tidal limit is around 750m, and therefore that is the length of the river habitat at risk from this development. There are many issues elsewhere in the river catchment with salmon egg survival, and therefore this productive area of habitat is very important to the salmon population of the River Creran and any deterioration of the habitat will further endanger the fragile fish populations currently present.

West of Scotland Archaeology Service (WoSAS) – Response dated 1/12/2016 WoSAS do not object to the application but recommend that should permission be granted then a planning condition should be attached requiring the submission of a written scheme of investigation to be approved by the planning authority in consultation with WoSAS prior to the commencement of any works.

Scottish Water – Response dated 2/6/2017 Scottish Water confirm that there are no Scottish Water drinking water catchments or water abstraction sources that may be affected by the proposal.

Historic Environment Scotland – Response dated 26/5/2017 HES offer no comments on this proposal.

Argyll and Bute Technical Flood Risk Officer – Response dated 9/11/2016 The southern area of the site lies within the indicative limits of fluvial flooding. Parts of the central and southern areas of the site lie within the indicative limits of surface water flooding shown upon the SEPA map.

The proposal includes the excavation and the creation of soil bunds within the southern section of the site. These activities will affect floodplain storage, with the excavation anticipated to increase storage and bunding expected to decrease it. The Low probability (1000 year) fluvial flood outline from the SEPA map has been used to estimate flood extent and through analysis of topographic survey, floodplain storage. Floodplain storage is estimated to be 16,900m3 predevelopment and 22,300m3 during development and 17,200m3 following restoration. While a site specific estimate of flood flow on the River Creran and hence floodplain storage would have been preferable and increased accuracy, this approach is acceptable.

The proposal also accepts that the site may flood and that activities would be suspended during times of flood. However, the River Creran is not part of a formal SEPA Flood Warning Scheme, therefore it is unclear how lead time would be given to allow the site operator to act. It is recommended that a local flood warning system (such as an alarm sensor in the river) be attached as a planning condition.

The Rational Method using FEH13 rainfalls has been used and is acceptable. However, no evidence has been provided to demonstrate that the 1 in 200 year plus climate change run off event would remain the same. The drainage information within the submission is acceptable. A maintenance regime for the proposed drainage system as not been provided.

The Flood Risk Officer requests that should permission be granted that two conditions are attached:

 Flood warning plan to be developed to allow sufficient time for the operator to act prior to the onset of a flood, and  Surface water drainage to be designed in accordance with CIRIA 753 and Sewers for Scotland 3rd Edition and also include a demonstration that the 1 in 200 year plus climate change event will remain on site and details of the maintenance regime for the surface water drainage system.

Argyll and Bute Development Plans Team – Response dated 18/7/2017 From a minerals policy perspective, we need to recognise that the distribution of sand and gravel resources is not even, and that provision for specialist products (such as fine grade building sand) needs to recognise that sometimes there will be a need to transport material over longer distances than the market areas referred to in the plan. SG LDP MIN 2 specifies a radius of 30 miles as the local market area for mainland quarries.

Building sand supplies are available from quarries at Kilmartin, North and Cairndow, these are all within a 30 mile radius of the likely main sources of demand for building sand in the area, which in both the existing LDP and forthcoming review looking forward to 2030 is likely to remain focused on the /Dunbeg area. Given the availability of sand and gravel from a number of quarries within a 30 mile radius of the proposed quarry at Glen Creran, the proposal would not be consistent with Development Plan Policy LDP 10 and SG LDP MIN 2.

Argyll and Bute Access Officer – Response dated 11/07/2017 The Access Officer has raised no objection to the proposal.

Argyll and Bute Biodiversity Officer – Response dated 6/12/2016 The council’s Biodiversity Officer has declared a conflict of interest and does not intend to provide comment. However, SNH has provided comment in this regard.

Argyll and Bute Area Roads Engineer – Response dated 30/11/2016 The Area Roads Engineer offers no objection subject to conditions relating to:

 Access at the junction with the public road to be constructed in accordance with operational services drawing SD 08/001a  Visibility splays of 53m x 2.4m to cleared and maintained,  A system of surface water drainage is required to prevent the flow of water onto the public road,  Commensurate improvements to the existing public road are required. Three passing places are to be upgraded to a minimum of 15m long x 5.5m wide (including carriageway width) these are (travelling from the site entrance) first on left, third passing place (near new house) and the passing place at St Mary’s. Construction details to be agreed with Roads Engineer.

Argyll and Bute Environmental Health – Response dated 30/1/2017 Environmental Health recommend that the following conditions should be applied should the application be approved:

Noise from site Paragraph 37 of PAN 50 Annex A states: “37. In exceptionally quiet rural areas where the daytime background noise level is below 35 dB(A), a condition limiting mineral operators to a 10 decibel excess over the existing background noise level is likely to be both difficult to achieve and unduly restrictive.

It would not normally be appropriate to require a daytime limit below 45 dB L Aeq,1h, as such a limit should prove tolerable to most people in rural areas. The exercise of care and some flexibility are important in addressing these issues.”

In accordance with this guidance a condition limited noise should be attached.

Hours of Operation Should the proposal be approved then the hours of operation should be limited to:

 0800 – 1800 hours Monday to Friday.  0800 – 1300 on a Saturday.  No working on a Sunday.

Light Nuisance In order to ensure issues from potential from light nuisance can be controlled, I would recommend the following condition should be applied should the application be approved:

“The above hours of operation will ensure that any light nuisance issues can be avoided as lights which are required for the site shall only be used during the operating hours.

These lights should then be turned off when outside of working hours.”

Air quality If the application is approved it is recommended that the following condition is applied to the planning permission:

All operations on the site shall be conducted in accordance with the mitigation measures and Dust Management Strategy contained with the Planning and Environmental Statement dated 20th October 2016.

Appin Community Council – Response dated 2/12/2016 The local community council objects to the proposal on the following grounds:

 The development remains counter to the LDP. The application details fails to provide evidence to demonstrate that there is extraordinary unmet demand for these quarry products available within a 30 mile radius. Without this evidence the proposal is not consistent with the LDP,  The proposed development brings no benefit to the local community and would detract from its economy by causing harm, particularly to a key tourist destination. This is evidenced by the sheer volume of objections from non-residents and visitors that have been lodged against this application.  The proposed access for heavy commercial vehicles is totally unsatisfactory. This is because the road from the proposed quarry entrance to the Loch Creran two lane road is single track and used frequently by residents, tourists, walkers and cyclists, and subject to erosion, poor stability and is unsuitable for regular long term heavy traffic. This road was a converted country track which was not designed or built for such punishing heavy use.

Ardchattan Community Council – Response dated 13/1/2017 The nearby community council objects to this proposal on a number of grounds. These are summarised below:  The proposal will have a significant visual impact on the glen which is presently unspoilt, highly valued for its scenic nature and situated in the middle of a very popular walking and hill walking area.

 Since the A828 Creagan Bridge was opened in 1999, the loop road around Loch Creran has become a very popular and safe circular walking, running and cycling route for both locals and visitors. It is connected directly with the Sustrans NCN78 Caledonian Way cycle path, and is ideally situated as a recreational route with short links to Appin, Barcaldine and . We feel this route has significant economic value for the nearby tourist industry, as well as being a highly valued amenity for the local population. Although not completely traffic free, it is quiet and enjoyable to use, and we have serious concerns about the impact which a large increase in volume of HGV traffic would have on this.

 Concerns were also expressed at the meeting about the potential effect of run-off water from the operations on the local water environment. Although we appreciate that this would be tightly controlled, given the proximity of River Creran to the site, there is surely a risk of accidental or flood related discharges into the river, and hence SAC-designated Loch Creran itself.

 In addition, the community council has not seen any evidence of the need for the increased supply in the area and considers that Culcharron Quarry at Benderloch provides sufficient material to meet demand.

Duror and Kentallen Community Council – Response dated 24/11/2016 The nearby community council object to the proposal on the basis of:

 Visual impact on an Area of Panoramic Quality (APQ),  Increased vehicular movements along a single track road will be dangerous,  The Local Development Plan (LDP) requires a ‘need’ case to be presented and all current reserves should be exhausted prior to the opening of new sites,  The restoration plan includes the dumping of inert material to fill the void,  The proposal would be detrimental to the tourism industry of the local area, and  There is strong public opinion against the development. ______

(E) PUBLICITY:

The proposal has been advertised in terms of a site notice (closing date 19/12/2016), an EIA advert (closing date 15/12/2016) and an advert under Regulation 20 (8/12/2016). ______

(F) REPRESENTATIONS:

There have been a total of 1,359 objections to the proposal with 9 businesses in support and a further 21 making representation. A list of third parties can be found in Appendix B. A number of personalised comments relating to the landowner have been submitted and these have not been repeated below as they are not material in the determination of this planning application.

Elected Member Representation

Councillor Julie McKenzie (dated 25/7/16)

The points of objection relate to lack of need, no exceptional case and conflict with the development plan. (i) Summary of issues raised

 Two objections have been submitted by Burness Paul LLP on behalf of Mr and Mrs Wolfinger. These objections contain reports by specialist consultants. Rather than detailing each matter raised in these reports the applicant has provided responses which generally addresses their concerns. Regardless, the matters raised in these reports have been addressed by officers through the report of handling.

Burness Paul LLP, on behalf of Mr and Mrs Wolfinger (15/12/2016  Review of Environmental Statement, EnviroCentre, December 2016  Report Addressing Needs Assessment, Johnson, Poole and Bloomer, December 2016

Burness Paul LLP, on behalf of Mr and Mrs Wolfinger (16/6/2017)  Letter commenting on the needs assessment, Johnson, Poole and Bloomer, June 2017

The applicant has responded to these in the following documents:  Letter and comment, Dalgleish Associates Limited, 29/03/2017  Letter and comment, Dalgleish Associates Limited, 28/06/2017

Comment: In response to the issue of ‘need’ this has been covered extensively below in the main report. With respect to the noise report prepared by EnviroCentre it should be noted that PAN 50 advocates the use of BS 5228 as the appropriate methodology. The EnviroCentre report has used a different methodology, BS 4142, which is reserved for industrial fixed plant. With this in mind little weight can be afforded to the EnviroCentre report other than consideration of background noise and anecdotal comment. Furthermore, EnviroCentre has prepared a flood risk report. This is covered in depth in various sections in the assessment below.

Officers are satisfied that the ES complies with the requirements of the Town and Country Planning (Environmental Impact Assessment) (Scotland) Regulations 2011.

 Adverse impact on wildlife especially on bats, birds and mammals. Impact on the National Nature Reserve. Impact on agricultural live stock through dust and vibration resulting from crushing 2 -3 times a year. Comment: This has been assessed by both RSPB and SNH. The submitted ecology chapter within the ES is considered acceptable for the purposes of this assessment. There will not be a significant impact on the National Nature Reserve arising from dust given the mitigation measures the applicant has proposed. Crushing 2 -3 times a year would not have an adverse effect ecology given the infrequency and mitigation proposed by the applicant.

 Loss of area to the development. Comment: It is not known what is meant by this comment. The land is currently agricultural but of poor quality with parts of the site quite boggy and prone to flooding. The land will be restored to agricultural use upon completion.

 Visual impact on the APQ and views from the nearby peaks. Comment: The potential impact on the APQ is assessed in Appendix A below.

 Landscape impact as the site is an APQ. Comment: The issue of landscape impact is addressed in detail in Appendix A.  Traffic impact and road safety for pedestrians and cyclists. The road on the other side of the glen would be more suitable for heavy vehicles. Comment: The council’s Area Roads Engineer has not raised any concerns with respect to the additional vehicular movements. There would be an additional six HGV movements and four car movements each day (average). The applicant would be improving three passing places from the site access to the Loch Creran loop road and thus improving the existing situation. It is understood that the passing places in their current state do not allow for the existing forestry lorries to pass and therefore the proposal would offer some measure of planning gain through the improvement of these passing places.

 No demonstrable need for the development as Argyll has many other quarries offering the same products. Comment: This is covered in depth in Appendix A below.

 Impact on residential amenity in terms of noise, dust and general disruption. Noise will reverberate around the glen. Low frequency noise. Comment: This has been assessed in detail in Appendix A below.

 Adverse impact on tourism and on local tourism businesses including sound studio, campsite, B&Bs. Comment: Poorly sited quarries can have an adverse impact if within a landscape that tourism relies upon. The issues of landscape and visual impacts are addressed in detail in Appendix A.

 Project needs a full EIA and details of restoration costs. Proposal should not be allowed to become like the open cast derelict sites in South Comment: The proposal has been subject to EIA procedures and details of restoration costs have been submitted. This is detailed in Appendix A below.

 Proposal should not be approved just for the short term gain of a few people. Comment: Comments such as this have been common throughout a great number of representations. Issues such as where the landowner is from, what his business interests are and what they seek to gain from the proposal are not material planning considerations.

 Impact on long term sustainability of the glen. Comment: The proposal is for a relatively short period of time with only five years of extraction. After this the site would be returned to agriculture.

 Site should be a SSSI. Comment: The allocation of SSSIs are not within the council’s remit and are managed by SNH.

 Concerns over what the 40,000 tonnes of infill material will be and should this contaminate what impact this will have. Comment: The infill material will be inert aggregate material that will be regulated by SEPA under license. It is common practice to raise land levels using such material and prevent it from going to council landfill sites. The land is raised to a set level and then topped with soils. There are no concerns regarding this element of the proposal from the view of the planning authority.

 Site is near the Glasdrum nature reserve with species such as chequered skipper (butterfly) and pearl bordered fritillary. Comment: SNH has not raised any concerns regarding the potential impact on protected species and consider the EIA documentation on this matter to be appropriate.

 There are proposals to extend the quarry even further throughout the glen. Comment: The planning authority can only consider the current application and not potential development proposals.

 Proposal cannot be commercially sound. Comment: This is not a material planning consideration.

 Site is described as a ‘red zone’ and therefore should not be built on. Comment: This comment is repeated several times across many representations. It is not known what is mean by this comment. The development plan has never used a red colour to demark this area. It is assumed that people are referring to its designation as countryside within the Local Development Plan. This would then refer to policy LDP DM 1 for general development proposals but the appropriate policy assessment is under SG LDP MIN 2. This is fully assessed in appendix A below.

 Concerns over contracting silicosis Comment: According to several websites including NHS and Health and Safety Executive silicosis is contracted as a result of working with silica sand. The applicant does not intend to work silica sand.

 Adverse impact on local business at St Mary’s which operates as a sound studio Comment: This has been fully assessed by the planning authority and Environmental Health. Initial concerns were raised with respect to the 70dB noise limits during times of site preparation. This has now been reduced to 45dB which will not have an adverse impact on the ability of the studio to operate.

 Significant local opinion against the proposal Comment: The details of the representations have been presented before members for consideration.

 Benderloch Quarry has reserves in excess of 30 years providing material that can be used for concrete production. Opening a new general sand and gravel site only 7 miles away would not be consistent with policy. Furthermore, there may be a lack of building sand available locally but national developers and retailers will be tied into national contracts much the same way as Tesco’s Oban branch do not buy sausages from farms around Oban. Comment: This is assessed in detail in Appendix A.

 An ACE should be carried out. Comment: Policy LDP DM 1 requires an Area Capacity Evaluation in the countryside development management zone for all developments where an exceptional case has been successfully demonstrated. In this instance an exceptional case has not been demonstrated and the proposal is not consistent with LDP DM 1. Therefore, an ACE is not required.

 If approved this will set a precedent for development in other protected areas (APQs) Comment: Each planning application is determined on its own merits.

 Query over whether or not the material is actually present. Comment: This is not for the planning authority to determine but the applicant has submitted extensive borehole results in the ES which suggests that around one third of the material to be extracted is building sand.

 The potential impact on River Creran resulting from silt running from the site into the river and then into the Loch which is a SAC. Comment: This is covered extensively in Appendix A below. Please also see comments by Argyll Fisheries Trust, SEPA and SNH.

 Glen should remain wild and undeveloped. Comment: The glen has significant signs of manmade intervention from hydro schemes, roads, specific field systems, forestry plantation, houses etc. It is not considered wild or undeveloped but rather has a rural development pattern common to settled glens.

 Road is not suitable for HGV traffic. Comment: The road is currently being used by forestry and agricultural HGVs. The applicant intends to add to this by six HGV movements a day (three in and three out). The applicant will improve three passing places to assist with this additional traffic movement.

 Concerns over how noise impact will be effectively monitored. Comment: If the proposal were to be approved then the planning authority could carry out random spot checks to ensure the conditions relating to noise were being adhered to. Furthermore, it is possible to separate noise from various sources.

 Concerns over the suitability of the passing places to be upgraded. Comment: The council’s Roads Engineer has not raised any concerns over the prospect of the passing places to be upgraded. If the proposal were approved and the applicant could not improve the passing places then the applicant would need to either not proceed with the proposal or seek an alternative mitigation method.

 Reference is made to the new Town and Country Planning (Environmental Impact Assessment) (Scotland) Regulations 2017 and its requirements. Comment: As the scoping opinion was issued before 16th May 2017 the former 2013 regulations still apply.

 No drawings of the proposed passing places have been submitted by the applicant. Comment: The applicant has supplied the location of the passing places in figure 12.1 of the ES but has not provided any significant details of the construction.

 An alternative noise report has been submitted from EnviroCentre providing different noise impacts than that provided by the applicant. Comment: The report submitted by EnviroCentre has not been completed to the appropriate methodology as specified in Planning Advice Note (PAN) 50. It has been completed to BS 4142 which is for industrial fixed plant whereas the appropriate methodology should have been BS 5228 for minerals extraction. Therefore, very little weight can be afforded to the EnviroCentre report.

 Despite the applicant making a case for building sand they state that the proposal will provide the applicant’s own need with respect to acting as a contractor and in relation to its ready-mix concrete plant. Comment: The issue of need is assessed below in Appendix A.

 The proposal will have an adverse impact on water supplies. Comment: Scottish Water has confirmed that the proposal will not impact on public water supply and give there is no adverse impact on the water environment there will not be an adverse impact on private water supplies.

 Presence of Japanese Knotweed on the river edge. Comment: The applicant’s proposal does not extend to the water’s edge. This is an issue for the land owner to address.

 The proposal will have an adverse impact on Sea Eagles and Golden Eagles. Comment: The Golden Eagle range is some distance to the south east whilst there are no records of White Tailed Eagles using the site or being nesting in direct view. SNH has not raised any concerns with this aspect of the proposal.

 Adverse impact on mammals including badgers, pine martens, wild cat etc. Comment: SNH has confirmed that the methodology for mammal surveys follows best practice and has been carried out by qualified individuals. They have not raised any concerns with this element of the proposal. With respect to badgers a third party has submitted a badger report claiming they are using the site. This is not disputed. But mitigation measures can be put in place to prevent this and licenses can be obtained from SNH to move setts etc. The applicant has commented:

“The report refers to a sett with 11 entrances. As there is not enough spoil for them to be linked, the likelihood is that there are several setts. Badgers regularly create new setts like this, particularly in sandy soil, due to collapse. It is fully acknowledged that badgers are a protected species and any works have to meet legislative requirement. This is not a main/breeding sett and it can be closed under licence. As the sett could easily be excluded with a minor amendment to the excavation, or closed under licence, the presence of badgers in the area should not have any significant bearing in the determination of the planning application.”

The presence of badgers is a material consideration in the determination of this application but the impacts can be mitigated.

 Potential adverse impact of oil spills etc. Comment: Should the application be approved then the applicant will have a procedure in place to clean up spills i.e. oil spill kit etc. Furthermore, any unauthorised discharge into the water environment will be regulated by SEPA.

 Areas such as Glen Creran offer health benefits beyond walking, cycling etc. The sense of open space and fresh air has obvious benefits. Comment: This is not disputed but is not a material planning consideration.

 Adverse impact on property values. Comment: This is not a material planning consideration.

 The proposal could result in job losses resulting in the closure or scaling back of works at other quarries.  Comment: There is no evidence to suggest that this would be the case should the application be approved.

 The proposal will result in an increase in traffic along the A828.  Comment: The proposal would unlikely to increase traffic along the A828 north of Glasdrum given the applicant would be seeking to take material south to Barrachander Quarry.

 The proposal is not consistent with policies LDP STRAT 1 or LDP 3.  Comment: A detailed policy assessment is contained within appendix A.

Letters of support have been elicited from:

 M & K MacLeod  Soutar Sports Ltd imported 900 tonnes of sand from the for the Mossfield Park project.  Jewson Ltd,  Colin Sloss Builders,  Fraser Inglis Landscaping,  A. MacGregor and Sons Ltd  Captain of Dunstaffnage  TSL Limited  Gow Ground Works ______

(G) SUPPORTING INFORMATION

Has the application been the subject of:

(i) Environmental Statement: Yes

 Introduction  Background to the Proposal  The Applicant Company  Site Location, Description, Topography, Land Use and Services  Geology  Assessment of Need  Consideration of Alternatives  Quarry Development and Method of Working  Planning and Development Framework  Scoping the Assessment  Landscape and Visual Impact Assessment  Hydrological and Hydrogeological Assessment  Ecology  Restoration  Noise  Air Quality  Access and Traffic  Archaeology  Recreational Access  Management of Waste from Extractive Industries  Summary of Impacts and Mitigation  References

(ii) An appropriate assessment under the Conservation No (Natural Habitats) Regulations 1994:

(iii) A design or design/access statement: No

(iv) A report on the impact of the proposed development Yes e.g. retail impact, transport impact, noise impact, flood risk, drainage impact etc: The applicant submitted further information relating to the needs assessment, restoration and hydrology / flood risk. ______

(H) PLANNING OBLIGATIONS

(i) Is a Section 75 obligation required: No ______

(I) Has a Direction been issued by Scottish Ministers in terms of No Regulation 30, 31 or 32: ______

(J) Section 25 of the Act; Development Plan and any other material considerations over and above those listed above which have been taken into account in the assessment of the application

(i) List of all Development Plan Policy considerations taken into account in assessment of the application.

Argyll and Bute Local Development Plan (March 2015)

LDP STRAT 1 – Sustainable Development LDP DM 1 – Development within the Development Management Zones LDP 3 – Supporting the Protection Conservation and Enhancement of our Environment LDP 5 –Supporting the Sustainable Growth of our Economy LDP 8 – Supporting the Strength of our Communities LDP 9 – Development Setting, Layout and Design LDP 10 – Maximising our Resources and Reducing our Consumption

SG 5 - Sustainability Checklist SG LDP BAD 1 - Bad Neighbour Development SG LDP CC 1 - Climate Change and Sustainable Development SG LDP ENV 1 - Development Impact on Habitats, Species and our Biodiversity (i.e. biological diversity) SG LDP ENV 2 - Development Impact on European Sites SG LDP ENV 4 - Development Impact on Sites of Special Scientific Interest (SSSIs) and National Nature Reserves SG LDP ENV 5 - Development Impact on Local Nature Conservation Sites (LNCS) SG LDP ENV 6 - Development Impact on Trees / Woodland SG LDP ENV 7 - Water Quality and the Environment SG LDP ENV 13 - Development Impact on Areas of Panoramic Quality (APQs) SG LDP ENV 14 - Landscape SG LDP ENV 16A - Development Impact on Listed Buildings SG LDP ENV 19 - Development Impact on Scheduled Ancient Monuments SG LDP ENV 20 - Development Impact on Sites of Archaeological Importance SG LDP MIN 2 - Mineral Extraction SG LDP SERV 7 - Flooding and Land Erosion The Risk Framework for Development SG LDP TRAN 1 - Access to the Outdoors SG LDP TRAN 4 - New And Existing, Public Roads And Private Access Regimes

(ii) List of all other material planning considerations taken into account in the assessment of the application, having due regard to Annex A of Circular 4/2009.

Scottish Planning Policy (2014) Planning Advice Note 1/2013 Environmental Impact Assessment (2013) Planning Advice Note 50 – Controlling the Environmental Effects of Surface Mineral Workings Planning Advice Note 51 – Environmental Protection Planning Advice Note 64 – Reclamation of Surface Mineral Workings Third party representations raising material planning considerations Consultee responses Argyll and Clyde Landscape Assessment, SNH, 1996 ______

(K) Is the proposal a Schedule 2 Development not requiring an No Environmental Impact Assessment:

Proposal is schedule 2 development and an ES has been submitted. ______

(L) Has the application been the subject of statutory pre-application Yes consultation (PAC):

PAC did take place with a public meeting at Appin Village Hall. The applicant has provided a PAC report as part of the submission detailing responses from the public meeting and written comments thereafter. They have provided a review of these comments. ______

(M) Has a sustainability check list been submitted: Yes ______

(N) Does the Council have an interest in the site: No ______

(O) Requirement for a hearing: No

Given the complexity and degree of public interest officers would normally recommend a discretionary hearing. However, the application is missing key technical details as required by SNH which has resulted in their objection. SNH has commented that it has not been proven beyond reasonable scientific doubt that the Loch Creran Special Area of Conservation will not be adversely impacted upon by this development. In consideration of this appreciation must be had to the recent European Court of Justice decision reference C-127/02 “Waddenzee”.

The Waddenzee case is an influential judgement which has clarified what ‘likely significant effect’ means when considering potential impact on European designated (Natura) sites. In this case the European Court of Justice ruled that a plan or project should undergo an appropriate assessment ‘if it cannot be excluded on the basis of objective information, that it will have a significant effect on the site’. Therefore, ‘likely’ in the context of the Habitats Regulations Appraisal has been interpreted strictly. It means that unless a significant effect can be objectively ruled out with certainty then it is ‘likely’.

In this instance SNH has advised that the potential for a significant effect cannot be ruled out with certainty (i.e. it cannot be proven beyond reasonable scientific doubt) then the competent authority cannot approve the application. ______(P) Assessment and summary of determining issues and material considerations

The proposed quarry is situated in Glen Creran some 22km to the north east of Oban and some 7.8km east of Appin and 7km north east of Barcaldine. The site is approximately centred on National Grid Reference NN015462. The site is part of Glen Creran Estate and is located within Glen Creran on the northern side of the River Creran, some 1km south west of Loch Baile and some 1.3km to the north east of Loch Creran.

The site itself measures some 5.35 hectares and comprises primarily agricultural land (rough grazing), with some broad leaved and coniferous woodland and hard standing associated with field access. There is a small cottage on the site which is owned by the estate and will be used as a site office.

Works will commence as follows:

 Erection of stock proof fencing,  Soil stripping will occur across the site with storage/ screening mounds on the south western and north western boundaries of the excavation area,  In the following two months site infrastructure works shall be undertaken prior to the commencement of excavation operations.  Improvements to passing places on the Salachail Road,  The upgrade of the site access and internal access route,  The installation of a weigh bridge in the vicinity of Glasdrum Cottage,  The formation of settling ponds for the closed circuit recycling of water from processing operations,  The formation of blind catch ditches or small bunds on the peripheral boundaries to ensure that surface run off does not enter the site and that any runoff within the site is contained, and  The stripping of the southern processing area with soils being placed within the western storage and screening mound.

Following these works the excavation of material shall commence from phase 1 working northwards. Material shall be excavated by a wheeled loading shovel which will load directly into the processing plant. The processing shall be a wet screening operation. Where larger gravels are recovered these shall be stored on site and shall be subject to crushing on an intermittent basis from site analysis it is estimated that crushing will be required for a period of around three days per annum.

With respect to restoration the applicant intends to import some 35,000 cubic tonnes of inert material over the six year period to raise the land level. This will fill the void left by extraction. The top will then be covered by overburden with a small water body. The site will be monitored for a period of five years.

Policy SG LD MIN 2 states that new proposals need to demonstrate a local need for the material. In this instance the market area is a 30mile radius around the site. In this area there are several sand and gravel sites including Dornie, Benderloch, North Connel and Clachan. If we take the Mineral Products Association (MPA) advice that in rural areas this figure can be flexible to accommodate to reflect the large spread of development then we can include Kilmartin Quarry. Of these Dornie, Benderloch and Kilmartin each have permissions lasting in excess of ten years providing the required land bank of reserve required by Scottish Planning Policy (SPP). The applicant based their submission on a lack of building sand in the area. Of those sites listed above they all produce building sand with the exception of Benderloch. It should be noted that SPP does not differentiate between different types of sand product. Regardless of this within the market area both Dornie and Kilmartin will produce building sand for a period in excess of ten years. With this in mind there is already a local supply within the market area and therefore no demonstrable need for the development.

The proposal will have an adverse impact on the North Argyll Area of Panoramic Quality (APQ) in terms of creating an incongruous feature within the landscape and breaking the distinct mosaic field pattern through the glen. When viewed on ground level the site is well screened with existing trees that the applicant intends to maintain and provide additional planting. However, when viewed from the upper ridges above the southern slopes of the glen the site will add an incongruous element into the landscape. This will however be temporary for a period of five years. The restoration proposals are poor with the sides of the water feature too steep to allow for regeneration of grass. Tree planting could also be significantly improved. With this in mind there will be a long adverse impact on the qualifying interests of the APQ.

The applicant has carried out ecological studies. The methodology is considered sound and SNH has provided comment. There are badgers using the site but through the use of conditions as per the proposed mitigation measures SNH would not object.

There has been significant objection to the proposal as detailed above. Equal consideration has been given to the letters of support from businesses including Jewsons Ltd, Colin Sloss Builders, M and K MacLeod etc. However, those letters of support are generally anecdotal and do not raise many material considerations other than to say it would be beneficial to have a resource of building sand on hand and they are generally having to import material from further afield. However it is not known why these businesses are not buying from quarries within and adjacent Argyll. The letters of objection do raise material matters including those of need and ecological impacts.

The application is recommended for refusal on the basis that there is no demonstrable need for the development and that there will be a long term significant impact on the qualifying interests of the APQ. ______

(Q) Is the proposal consistent with the Development Plan: No ______

(R) Reasons why planning permission or a Planning Permission in Principle should be refused

1. The application site lies within Glen Creran which is an upland glen defined in the ‘Landscape Assessment of Argyll and the ’ (SNH 1996) as being within the Mountain Glen Landscape Character Type (LCT). The glen has a distinctive narrow form and strong sense of enclosure by steep sides and irregular ridgelines containing a small scale landscape, characterised by dispersed rural settlement, pockets of woodland and a marked field enclosure pattern. The experience within the glen contrasts markedly with the views into the glen from the adjacent Craggy Upland and High Tops LCT’s. Upland enclosing the glen to the west lies within the SNH defined Loch Etive Wild Land Area, characterised by an absence of development and elevated vantage points affording a sense of remoteness. The site and its wider surroundings all lie within a Local Development Plan defined Area of Panoramic Quality in recognition of the area’s scenic qualities of regional importance. The proposed mineral operations would be conspicuous from frequented upland vantage points affording views down into Glen Creran, which reveal a distinctive mosaic field pattern sensitive to intrusive and disruptive forms of development, which might not otherwise be so readily experienced from within the glen itself. The development by virtue of its impact on the landform, and the presence and operation of plant required to support the winning of minerals from the site, would constitute a conspicuous and intrusive form of development within this settled rural landscape, to the detriment of landscape character, the scenic qualities of the Area of Panoramic Quality, and the experience of the adjoining Wild Land Area. Although the extraction is only proposed for a five year period, the less than satisfactory restoration scheme proposed does not provide confidence that lasting adverse effects would be avoided. The proposal therefore fails to meet the requirements of Policies LDP STRAT 1 – Sustainable Development, LDP 9 – Development Setting, Layout and Design, LDP 10 – Maximising our Resources and Reducing our Consumption, SG LDP ENV 13 - Development Impact on Areas of Panoramic Quality (APQs), SG LDP ENV 14 – Landscape and SG LDP MIN 2 - Mineral Extraction of the ‘Argyll and Bute Local Plan’ 2015.

2. This proposal for mineral extraction is subject to the effect of sector specific Policy SG LDP MIN 2, which is derived from Policy LDP 10 of the adopted ‘Argyll and Bute Local Plan’ 2015, and which sets out a criteria based approach to the determination of minerals consent applications. This establishes a presumption against new mineral workings other than where an exceptional local need can be demonstrated, or where it is intended to supply the export of specialised minerals. The applicant has sought to demonstrate an exceptional local need founded around a needs assessment supported by anecdotal comments from local businesses involved in the North Lorn economy. Having regard to the development plan, the expectation is that the settlements of Oban and Dunbeg will be the main focus of development during the life of the current plan. Within a 30 mile radius of this area there are operational quarries able to provide a sufficient local supply of mineral resources, including Benderloch, North Connel, Dornie and Kilmartin, with the ability to provide a range of materials over the lifespan of the development plan. Although Scottish Planning Policy requires a ten year land bank of permissions within market areas, the limited life expectancy of the quarry proposed will only be comparable to that of North Connel, whilst both Kilmartin and Benderloch will continue to provide material thereafter. The proposal will not meaningfully add to the available supply within the North Lorn market area, or address any anticipated serious shortfall in supply, and any contribution which it could make would be offset by adverse local environmental consequences identified in the preceding reason for refusal. The proposal therefore fails to meet the requirements of Policies LDP STRAT 1 – Sustainable Development, LDP 9 – Development Setting, Layout and Design, LDP 10 – Maximising our Resources and Reducing our Consumption and SG LDP MIN 2 - Mineral Extraction of the ‘Argyll and Bute Local Plan’ 2015.

3. There is a 53% chance of a major flood event that could result in silts being deposited in River Creran and ultimately ending up in Loch Creran which is a SAC designated so for its serpulid reefs. SNH has confirmed that they object to the proposal on the basis of a lack of information regarding the proposed silt traps. The applicant has not provided sufficient information relating to the form, type or capacity of the traps. Argyll Fisheries Trust has concluded that regardless of silt traps material will be carried into River Creran and therefore in Loch Creran.

If material is deposited in River Creran then it would have the potential to significantly impact on the Atlantic Salmon habitat rendering some 700m of the river unusable by this species. Atlantic Salmon are a European Protected Species when found in fresh water. Furthermore the silt could adversely impact on Native Oysters which are a priority marine species and thus afforded protection.

SNH consider that there is insufficient information to determine beyond reasonable scientific doubt that the proposal will not have an adverse effect on the qualifying interests of the Loch Creran SAC. The proposal is therefore not consistent with paragraphs 194, 203 and 204 of Scottish Planning Policy (SPP), policy LDP 3 – Supporting the Protection, Conservation and Enhancement of our Environment, SG LDP ENV 1 – Development Impact on Species, Habitats and our Biodiversity and SG LDP ENV 2 – Development Impact on European Sites. 4. The proposal is not consistent with policy LDP DM 1 which requires most development types, including applications for mineral extraction, in the countryside development management zone to demonstrate an exceptional case. In this instance policy SG LDP MIN 2 sets out the criteria for an exceptional case. The applicant has stated that they consider that there is an insufficient supply of building sand to meet an existing local based need. However, officers have demonstrated that there are quarries in the area that can supply building sand to the market area. Therefore it is considered that there is no exceptional case for the development of the quarry and therefore the proposal is not consistent with policy LDP DM 1. ______

(S) Reasoned justification for a departure to the provisions of the Development Plan

N/A ______

(T) Need for notification to Scottish Ministers or Historic Environment Scotland: No ______

Author of Report: David Love Date: 7th August 2017

Reviewing Officer: Sandra Davies Date: 10th August 2017

Angus Gilmour Head of Planning and Regulatory Services

GROUNDS OF REFUSAL RELATIVE TO APPLICATION REFERENCE 16/02911/MIN 1. The application site lies within Glen Creran which is an upland glen defined in the ‘Landscape Assessment of Argyll and the Firth of Clyde’ (SNH 1996) as being within the Mountain Glen Landscape Character Type (LCT). The glen has a distinctive narrow form and strong sense of enclosure by steep sides and irregular ridgelines containing a small scale landscape, characterised by dispersed rural settlement, pockets of woodland and a marked field enclosure pattern. The experience within the glen contrasts markedly with the views into the glen from the adjacent Craggy Upland and High Tops LCT’s. Upland enclosing the glen to the west lies within the SNH defined Loch Etive Wild Land Area, characterised by an absence of development and elevated vantage points affording a sense of remoteness. The site and its wider surroundings all lie within a Local Development Plan defined Area of Panoramic Quality in recognition of the area’s scenic qualities of regional importance. The proposed mineral operations would be conspicuous from frequented upland vantage points affording views down into Glen Creran, which reveal a distinctive mosaic field pattern sensitive to intrusive and disruptive forms of development, which might not otherwise be so readily experienced from within the glen itself. The development by virtue of its impact on the landform, and the presence and operation of plant required to support the winning of minerals from the site, would constitute a conspicuous and intrusive form of development within this settled rural landscape, to the detriment of landscape character, the scenic qualities of the Area of Panoramic Quality, and the experience of the adjoining Wild Land Area. Although the extraction is only proposed for a five year period, the less than satisfactory restoration scheme proposed does not provide confidence that lasting adverse effects would be avoided. The proposal therefore fails to meet the requirements of Policies LDP STRAT 1 – Sustainable Development, LDP 9 – Development Setting, Layout and Design, LDP 10 – Maximising our Resources and Reducing our Consumption, SG LDP ENV 13 - Development Impact on Areas of Panoramic Quality (APQs), SG LDP ENV 14 – Landscape and SG LDP MIN 2 - Mineral Extraction of the ‘Argyll and Bute Local Plan’ 2015.

2. This proposal for mineral extraction is subject to the effect of sector specific Policy SG LDP MIN 2, which is derived from Policy LDP 10 of the adopted ‘Argyll and Bute Local Plan’ 2015, and which sets out a criteria based approach to the determination of minerals consent applications. This establishes a presumption against new mineral workings other than where an exceptional local need can be demonstrated, or where it is intended to supply the export of specialised minerals. The applicant has sought to demonstrate an exceptional local need founded around a needs assessment supported by anecdotal comments from local businesses involved in the North Lorn economy. Having regard to the development plan, the expectation is that the settlements of Oban and Dunbeg will be the main focus of development during the life of the current plan. Within a 30 mile radius of this area there are operational quarries able to provide a sufficient local supply of mineral resources, including Benderloch, North Connel, Dornie and Kilmartin, with the ability to provide a range of materials over the lifespan of the development plan. Although Scottish Planning Policy requires a ten year land bank of permissions within market areas, the limited life expectancy of the quarry proposed will only be comparable to that of North Connel, whilst both Kilmartin and Benderloch will continue to provide material thereafter. The proposal will not meaningfully add to the available supply within the North Lorn market area, or address any anticipated serious shortfall in supply, and any contribution which it could make would be offset by adverse local environmental consequences identified in the preceding reason for refusal. The proposal therefore fails to meet the requirements of Policies LDP STRAT 1 – Sustainable Development, LDP 9 – Development Setting, Layout and Design, LDP 10 – Maximising our Resources and Reducing our Consumption and SG LDP MIN 2 - Mineral Extraction of the ‘Argyll and Bute Local Plan’ 2015. 3. There is a 53% chance of a major flood event that could result in silts being deposited in River Creran and ultimately ending up in Loch Creran which is a SAC designated so for its serpulid reefs. SNH has confirmed that they object to the proposal on the basis of a lack of information regarding the proposed silt traps. The applicant has not provided sufficient information relating to the form, type or capacity of the traps. Argyll Fisheries Trust has concluded that regardless of silt traps material will be carried into River Creran and therefore in Loch Creran.

If material is deposited in River Creran then it would have the potential to significantly impact on the Atlantic Salmon habitat rendering some 700m of the river unusable by this species. Atlantic Salmon are a European Protected Species when found in fresh water. Furthermore the silt could adversely impact on Native Oysters which are a priority marine species and thus afforded protection.

SNH consider that there is insufficient information to determine beyond reasonable scientific doubt that the proposal will not have an adverse effect on the qualifying interests of the Loch Creran SAC. The proposal is therefore not consistent with paragraphs 194, 203 and 204 of Scottish Planning Policy (SPP), policy LDP 3 – Supporting the Protection, Conservation and Enhancement of our Environment, SG LDP ENV 1 – Development Impact on Species, Habitats and our Biodiversity and SG LDP ENV 2 – Development Impact on European Sites.

4. The proposal is not consistent with policy LDP DM 1 which requires most development types, including applications for mineral extraction, in the countryside development management zone to demonstrate an exceptional case. In this instance policy SG LDP MIN 2 sets out the criteria for an exceptional case. The applicant has stated that they consider that there is an insufficient supply of building sand to meet an existing local based need. However, officers have demonstrated that there are quarries in the area that can supply building sand to the market area. Therefore it is considered that there is no exceptional case for the development of the quarry and therefore the proposal is not consistent with policy LDP DM 1. APPENDIX A – RELATIVE TO APPLICATION NUMBER: 16/02911/MIN

PLANNING LAND USE AND POLICY ASSESSMENT

A. Settlement Strategy

The site is located within the countryside development management zone of the LDP. Policy LDP DM 1 requires applications within the countryside zone to demonstrate an exceptional case. In the case of application for mineral extraction the criteria is set out within policy SG LDP MIN 2.

SG LDP MIN 2 has a general presumption against the development of new minerals working sites unless the proposal can satisfy specific criteria of this policy. In the case of a new quarry the applicant must demonstrate that there is a local based need for the product to satisfy an existing shortfall in supply. The applicant has not demonstrated an exceptional case requiring this development, an in-depth assessment against policy SG LDP MIN 2 is provided below. Therefore it is not consistent with policy LDP DM 1.

The proposal is not consistent with policy LDP DM 1 as the applicant has failed to demonstrate an exceptional case to justify development in the countryside development management zone.

B. Location, Nature and Design of Proposed Development

Location The proposed quarry is situated in Glen Creran some 22km to the north east of Oban and some 7.8km east of Appin and 7km north east of Barcaldine. The site is approximately centred on National Grid Reference NN015462. The site is part of Glen Creran Estate and is located within Glen Creran to the northern side of the River Creran, some 1km south west of Loch Baile and some 1.3km to the north east of Loch Creran.

The site itself measures some 5.35 hectares and comprises primarily agricultural land (rough grazing), with some broad leaved and coniferous woodland and hard standing associated with field access. There is a small cottage on the site which is owned by the estate.

The topography of the site is relatively flat, varying between 4m Above Ordnance Datum (AOD) in the south to 8m AOD in the north east. The wider area comprises agricultural land with extensive areas of woodland which climb up the lower slopes of the glen. Loch Creran is a sea loch located to the south west. To the north west and south east of the site the land climbs steeply to Beinn Churalain (549m AOD) and Beinn Sgulaird (937m AOD).

Description of Proposal The proposed extraction area measures some 3.05ha which includes a nominal extraction area of 0.8ha for processing and stockpiling area. The applicant intends to extract some 83,000 tonnes of sand and gravel over an extraction period of five years and six months. A further two months shall be required for the initial formation of site infrastructure and eight months shall be required to complete restoration works on cessation of operations.

Prior to the commencement of works the site enclosure shall be secured and where appropriate fencing shall be erected for the purpose of public safety and to ensure the operational area is kept stock-proofed. Throughout the duration of operations the boundary shall be maintained until the restoration of the site is complete.

Soil stripping will occur thereafter with soils having an average depth of 0.52m across the site. Soils shall be initially be placed in storage / screening mounds on the south western and north western boundaries of the excavation area. Thereafter soils stripped in advance of the excavation shall be utilised for the progressive restoration of the quarried land as the excavation progresses northwards. To minimise the potential for dust uplift, mounds shall be created with gentle slopes and shall be accessible for dampening by water spraying. All soil mounds shall be evenly graded, with domed tops, and shaped to prevent water ponding on them. On formation, mounds shall be seeded to grass. To minimise the potential for visual intrusion the height of soil mounds shall vary with a maximum of 4.1m.

In the following two months the site infrastructure works shall be undertaken prior to the commencement of excavation operations. This shall entail:

 Improvements to passing places on the Salachail Road,  The upgrade of the site access and internal access route,  The installation of a weigh bridge in the vicinity of Glasdrum Cottage,  The formation of settling ponds for the closed circuit recycling of water from processing operations,  The formation of blind catch ditches or small bunds on the peripheral boundaries to ensure that surface run off does not enter the site and that any runoff within the site is contained, and  The stripping of the southern processing area with soils being placed within the western storage and screening mound.

Phase one relates to the excavation and processing of shallow layer of sand and gravel that will be excavated to a depth of between 0.5m and 1.2m across the processing and stockpiling area in the south of the site. As processing of the sand and gravel proceeds soils shall be excavated from the central phase 1 excavation area and utilised to form the north western soil storage and screening mound. Thereafter sand and gravel shall be excavated in a general south to north direction through phase 1 with a varying excavation depth of between 0.6m and 4.9m. All excavation operations shall be dry working i.e. all excavation shall be undertaken above the groundwater table.

Material shall be excavated by a wheeled loading shovel which will load directly into the processing plant. The processing shall be a wet screening operation. Where larger gravels are recovered these shall be stored on site and shall be subject to crushing on an intermittent basis from site analysis it is estimated that crushing will be required for a period of around three days per annum.

As excavated operations near completion, advance soil stripping shall be undertaken in the southern section of phase two with soils stripped in advance of extraction operations in phase 2 being utilised to reinstate previously worked land to the south of the advancing extraction. Over the dry working area, to ensure that the land is adequately drained, it is proposed to utilise imported inert materials and silts derived from aggregate processing to raise the profile of the land to around 2m above the water table prior to the replacement of soils. No imported material will be placed below the water table.

Phase two development extends the excavation area both westwards and northwards. The sand and gravel will be dry worked across Phase two to depths varying between 2.5m and 3.5m. The dry worked sand and gravel will continue to be transported to the processing area by wheeled loading shovel.

In the west of phase two a limited area shall be worked below the water table to a depth of 6.2m below original ground level. Sand and gravel shall be dug out by a tracked excavator and deposited on the previously dry worked quarry floor and left to allow initial drainage to take place before the material is then transported by wheeled loading shovel to the processing area. Progressive restoration shall be on-going as soils are stripped in advance of extraction operations they shall be utilised to reinstate previously worked land to the south of the advancing excavation.

Restoration From the commencement of phase two, progressive restoration shall be ongoing, soil shall be stripped in advance of the excavation and utilised for progressive restoration on the worked area behind the working face. Over the dry working area, to ensure that the land is adequately drained, it is proposed to utilise limited quantities of imported inert materials and materials which fall outwith the product specification (silts derived from aggregate processing) to raise the profile of the land to around 2m above the water table prior to the replacement of soils. The excavation boundaries shall link to existing profiles at shallow gradients of 1 in 10 or less, ensuring that the restored land is suitable for agricultural use (grass crop). At the completion of excavation operations in Phase two, soils from the north western bund shall be utilised to complete the reinstatement of the excavation area.

Whilst the majority of land will be reinstated to agriculture the restoration design also makes provision for the creation of a small pond on the western edge of phase two where the area of wet working was undertaken. Appropriate marginal planting shall be undertaken around the water body.

As referenced above it is intended to import material to ensure the land is adequately drained prior to utilising over burden material. This will require the importation of some 35,000 cubic tonnes of material over the six year period. Materials will be brought in by the vehicles utilised for the dispatch of sand and gravel so there would be no increase in HGV movements (approximately two loads inert inwards for every three loads of aggregates going out). The proposed importation of materials for quarry reinstatement would be exempt from waste management licensing. However, SEPA has advised that given the nature of the materials the applicant is proposing to use an infill and the proximity to the water table and River Creran their approval is not guaranteed. This is not a matter for the planning authority to determine but for SEPA under their own legislation.

The imported waste will be solid inert material from construction or demolition work, soil or stones and will be non-toxic and non-ferrous in nature with plasterboard and wood specifically excluded. No imported material will be placed below the water table.

On completion of processing and despatch, the settlement ponds and temporary plant shall be removed and the soils in the western bund shall be utilised to reinstate the processing and stockpile of the area.

It is proposed to implement an aftercare scheme for a period of five years to ensure the effective restoration of the site. A restoration bond liability has been calculated at £55,156. However, after consideration of an assumed 3% increase in interest and escalation in process this totals £63,429.

C. Natural Environment

There are several natural environment designations in the surrounding area. Some distance to the north is the Glen Creran Woods Special Area of Conservation (SAC), and the Glen Creran Woods Site of Special Scientific Interest (SSSI). To the east is an area of Semi Natural Ancient Woodland whilst on the other side of the River Creran is the Glen Etive and Glen Fyne Special Protection Area (SPA). Covering the site and much of the wider area is the North Argyll Area of Panoramic Quality (APQ). Some distance to the west is the Glasdrum National Nature Reserve, the North Argyll APQ, Glen Creran Woods SSSI and SAC. The River Creran runs adjacent the site to the south which flows into Loch Creran which is a SAC. SNH has confirmed that the proposal will not have an adverse effect on the Glen Creran Woods SAC and SSSI or on the Glen Etive and Glen Fyne SPA. However, SNH has objected to the proposal with respect to a lack of information relating to the proposed silt traps. Both AFT and SNH has raised concerns with respect to the potential for silts to enter the River Creran and damage Atlantic Salmon habitat. AFT advise that such an event could render some 700m of the river habitat unusable for this species.

SNH has advised that the applicant has not provided sufficient information with respect to the proposed silt traps. Should the silt traps allow the silting of the river then this would result in material flowing into Loch Creran and potentially damaging the serpulid reefs the Loch is designated to protect. There would also be potential to damage native oysters which are a priority species.

SPP states in paragraph 194 bullet points two and three that the planning system should:

 Conserve and enhance protected sites and species, taking account of the need to maintain healthy ecosystems and works with the natural processes which provide important services to communities  Promote protection and improvement of the water environment, including rivers, lochs, estuaries, wetlands, coastal waters and groundwater, in a sustainable and co-ordinated way.

Further to this paragraph 203 states that:

“Planning permission should be refused where the nature or scale of proposed development would have an unacceptable impact on the natural environment. Direct or indirect effects on statutorily protected sites will be an important consideration, but designation does not impose an automatic prohibition on development.”

Policy SG LDP ENV 1 (Development Impact on Habitat, Species and our Biodiversity) considers that:

“Development proposals which are likely to have an adverse effect on protected species and habitats will only be permitted where it can be justified in accordance with the relevant protected species legislation (contained within this Supplementary Guidance) or otherwise preset in the equivalent information within any required EIA”

Policy SG LDP ENV 2 (Development Impact on European Sites) states that “where it cannot be ascertained that the development would not adversely affect the integrity of the site it will not be supported…”

In this regard SNH has confirmed that the applicant has not successfully demonstrated that the proposal will not have an adverse impact on River Creran and its associated Atlantic Salmon habitat and Loch Creran SAC. Therefore the proposal is not consistent with the SPP or policies SG LDP ENV 1.

With respect to dust generation the applicant has developed a full Dust Management Strategy which includes suppression and the cessation of operations if necessary during adverse weather conditions. HGVs will leave the site sheeted to prevent dust from escaping the vehicles. The trees surrounding the site will be maintained. With this in mind there will be no adverse impact resulting from dust on nearby lichens or other environmental features or areas of human habitation.

Given the proximity to these designations and to the river which flows into the loch there is potential for impact on these areas. In order to protect the river, and thus the loch, the applicant intends to install a silt trap that will catch soils resulting from a flooding event topping over the river and into the site.

AFT’s main concern with the proposal is the continual input of fine sediments into the river. Silt traps reduce the amount of silt entering the river, however they cannot block all silt. In a flood situation, the majority of silt and other fine sediments would be transported downstream to Loch Creran, however there will inevitably be fine sediments deposited within the river bed. A regular input of fine sediment from the development is likely to make the area downstream of the proposed quarry site uninhabitable for salmonids.

The location of the proposed quarry coincides with an AFT long term monitoring site. Since 2004, AFT have recorded relatively good numbers of juvenile salmon fry (eggs hatched that year), which shows that adult salmon are spawning in the area. The habitat at the site consists of pebbles and cobbles, which unlike most of the river is stable with plenty of cover, and is therefore of good quality for salmonid fish. AFT estimate that the distance from this site to the tidal limit is around 750m, and therefore that is the length of the river habitat at risk from this development. There are many issues elsewhere in the river catchment with salmon egg survival, and therefore this productive area of habitat is very important to the salmon population of the River Creran and any deterioration of the habitat will further endanger the fragile fish populations currently present.

The quarry has been designed so as not to discharge to the water environment and therefore there is no reason to believe that there will be a regular release of silt into the river. The only time that the quarry will discharge silt will be during an extreme flood event. In such a case the void will fill with water first with most solids drifting to the bottom of the void. It will only be water topping the void that will carry silts into the water environment. During such an extreme event there will be a degree of natural erosion occurring that will carry an unquantified volume of silt into the water course. SEPA has not raised any objection to this risk given it is limited and the applicant is putting in place the relevant and reasonable levels of mitigation measures such as silt fences.

The proposal is not considered to be consistent with supplementary guidance policy SG LDP ENV 1, SG LDP ENV 2 or SG LDP ENV 7 as the applicant has not successfully demonstrated that the impacts of silt in the River Creran and Loch Creran can be suitably mitigated.

D. Bad Neighbour Impact

Dust The proposed quarrying operations at Glasdrum have the potential to produce dust from a variety of sources and activities associated with:

 Soil / drift stripping and storage,  Excavation and loading of sand and gravel,  Transportation of sand and gravel on-site,  Processing,  Temporary storage of sand and gravel,  Transportation of sand and gravel off site,  Importation of materials for restoration, and  Restoration.

In order to address any potential adverse effects of dust from the site the applicant intends to offer dust control measures in line with Planning Advice Note (PAN) 50 Annex B. Should the application be approved then the applicant would implement a Site Dust Management Strategy with consideration to:  Site layout,  Method of working and dust control measures to be adopted,  Site management systems, and  Monitoring and response procedures.

With the emphasis on the use of best practice to maintain acceptable site dust levels, identification of dust sources and the most appropriate mitigation must be considered within overall site management practices. A Dust Management Strategy has been developed which adopts the principles of prevention and containment and includes the following control measures in order to minimise dust nuisance:

 During prolonged periods of dry weather, plant and vehicles do not travel over unwatered haulage roads,  A portable water sprayer shall be used to minimise dust on haul roads during periods of site activity,  An adequate supply of water shall be made available for the motorised spraying unit,  All vehicles used for the movement of materials within the site shall be equipped with exhausts pointing away from the ground,  All relevant plant shall be fitted with radiator fan deflector plates, and  If, in extreme adverse conditions the aforementioned measures are not adequate, the following action shall be taken; o Restriction on the speed of vehicles on site, o Temporary cessation of activities giving rise to concern.

The following measures shall be adopted to ensure effective day to day dust management during operational periods:  The site manager will be the responsible person for ensuring that the dust management strategy is enforced. In his absence a suitable competent person will be nominated,  Regular visual inspections of dust conditions will be undertaken by site staff. The frequency of inspections will be determined on a daily basis in accordance with prevailing conditions.  Regular visual assessments of dust emissions will be made daily by site supervisory staff and remedial actions initiated as necessary. The results of such monitoring will be recorded in a daily log book.  Site management will give attention to advance weather forecasts and organise dust management requirements accordingly.  In the event of a complaint concerning dust emission, the site manager shall immediately undertake an investigation and instigate any necessary remedial action.

The applicant has assessed the potential adverse impact on the nearest residential properties of both St Mary’s and Invercreran. Both are some 500m away and given the mitigation measures proposed by the applicant neither should suffer from any adverse air quality impact resulting from the proposal.

Noise The nearest third party properties to the proposal are St Mary’s and Invercreran. These are some 500m and 510m to the North West and north respectively. Closer properties are in the ownership of the landowner and are therefore considered to have a financial interest in the development and can accept higher tolerable noise limits. The background noise, as existing, is around 40dB as per the council’s measurement. The applicant and a third party carried out separate assessments which gave roughly the same figure. Variances can be attributed to traffic, movement of livestock etc. as occurring at the specific time of monitoring. It is important to note that the figures are not significantly different. Planning Advice Note (PAN) 50 advises that acceptable noise limits are considered to be 45dB during working times and 70dB during soil stripping and site preparation times. The council has assessed the applicant’s submission and found it consistent with the methodology of BS 5228 as required by PAN 50. This found that noise limits will not be exceeded and the increase will only result in a +5dB rating. A third party submitted a report by EnviroCentre. Unfortunately little weight can be afforded to their noise assessment as the methodology was carried out to BS 4142 which is more suitable for industrial fixed plant and not quarries. However, it does provide anecdotal comment that an increase of a few dB is barely perceptible. Therefore it is considered that the proposal would not adversely impact on residential properties in terms of noise.

There is an existing business within the glen at St Mary’s. This is the closest third party property. It is a music studio with a unique recording space not common within Scotland. It offers a large single area for recording music as opposed to single booths for musicians to record separately. This is the home owner’s main source of income. It is a unique recording space insofar as it offers a large room to record in as opposed to a more common ‘room within a room’ space.

Further assessment carried out by the council’s Environmental Health officer determined that the development would not adversely affect this property and that conditions could be attached to any permission that would limit the effects of noise above existing background levels to a rating of 45dB. The measured prevailing noise environment at St Mary’s was dominated by the sound of the river and was measured by ABC to be 39.6 dB(A) LA90 and 40.4dB dB(A) LAeq. Additionally, the upper limit for soil stripping and site preparation has been reduced to 45dB. The applicant has indicated that should the planning authority be minded to approve the application they would accept such limitations.

In terms of enforcing this limit it is important to note that this would be a complex process given the proximity to the agricultural works. Cumulative noise impact and its assessment against limits can be a complex process given the variability of noise levels, intermittency and periods of operation of different items of plant and presence any other extraneous sources. The technique generally adopted is to identify and isolate the activity and source of the noise which is causing the problem and then to assess the source(s) against the limits where these are applied. The measurement of intermittent periods of noise can be mathematically aggregated to assess an operation against the limit which is effectively a one hour average. Should the application be approved a condition limiting noise can be attached to any grant of permission.

E. Biodiversity

The applicant has submitted details of biodiversity within the ES. The applicant has carried out a number of surveys including ornithology, mammal and extended Phase 1 Habitat Survey. The surveys identified:

 Otters,  Badgers,  Bats,  Red squirrels  Atlantic Salmon  Brown Trout

Otters Otters are known to be present in the wider area although there are no records for the site itself. The bank of the River Creran were searched for field signs and no signs recorded. However, if the proposal were to be granted permission a pre-start survey would be required. The otter survey seems adequate. SNH have indicated agreement with the advice given in the documents, that another survey (for all mammals) should be performed pre-works

Bats The site and adjacent habitat was noted as being suitable for use as a foraging resource for a number of bat species. Broadleaf woodland, in particular along the River Creran was also noted as being of potential use as a roosting site. Many of the buildings within the glen are also likely to present suitable roosting sites.

As a result a preliminary tree survey was undertaken to identify those areas of woodland with the highest potential to support bat roosts was undertaken.

This survey identified that those trees central to the development have no or low potential for the support of bat roosts as they do not support suitable cavities. Mature broadleaf trees to the immediate east of the processing area have medium to high potential although none shall be lost as a result of the development. Two oak trees are located within the proposed development area to the south of the conifer plantation and both are considered to have high roost potential.

Mitigation, embedded in the proposal, avoids the requirement to fell any trees with significant potential for bat roosts. The alteration to habitat is not considered significant in terms of the foraging resource for bats and there is no associated legislative implication of the proposed development.

The loss of this small section of bat feeding habitat is unlikely to have a significant impact on the populations present, particularly given its location within a glen with other suitable feeding resource.

Badgers Badgers are known to be present in the wider area although there are no historical records for the site itself. The survey area was searched for field signs and as a result of initial findings as well as comment being submitted further survey work was undertaken.

The results of the field survey confirm that this is an active badger territory. A suitable stand-off ensures there is no concern in relation to the eastern sett. In relation to the western single entrance sett which may or may not be used by badgers. It is still likely to be used than not. The quarry design has taken into account the presence of a sett within the development as originally proposed, and a stand-off is proposed. A semi-elliptical area around 15m – 20m to the south of the entrance (towards the processing area) has been set aside from the development as a buffer. This ensures legislative compliance to protect badgers from persecution.

A third party submitted a further report which refers to a sett with 11 entrances. The applicant has commented:

“As there is not enough spoil for them to be linked, the likelihood is that there are several setts. Badgers regularly create new setts like this, particularly in sandy soil, due to collapse. It is fully acknowledged that badgers are a protected species and any works have to meet legislative requirement. This is not a main/breeding sett and it can be closed under licence. As the sett could easily be excluded with a minor amendment to the excavation, or closed under licence, the presence of badgers in the area should not have any significant bearing in the determination of the planning application.”

The applicant’s badger survey is considered adequate for the purposes of this proposal. Guidelines for disturbance close to badger setts are:  Minimum distances from setts – 30m moving substrate, 100m drilling, blasting rock, pile driving and rock crushing – depending on substrate and vibration levels. What constitutes disturbance depends on the nature of the activity proposed: as a rule a licence is normally required for any works within 30 metres of a badger sett, but this distance may increase for more disruptive activities such as blasting or pile-driving.

Should the proposal be approved then planning conditions requiring the development to be carried out as per the suggested mitigation measures in the ES and a pre- commencement survey can be attached.

Red Squirrels Red Squirrels are known to be present in the Glen. However, there are no dreys within the application area and, compared to the available foraging habitat in the surrounding area, the removal of a tiny area of woodland will have no impact on the species.

Salmonids The proposal will not need authorisation from SEPA as day to day operations are not discharging into the River Creran. However, the applicant has not provided details of the proposed silt mitigation measures and has supplied only anecdotal evidence that suppliers consider their product acceptable in this instance. This does not provide SNH with sufficient evidence that can conclude beyond reasonable scientific doubt that in the proposal will not discharge significant volumes of silt into the River Creran. Should such an event occur then this would have the potential to render some 700m of the river uninhabitable to Atlantic Salmon which are a European Protected Species when found in fresh water.

Native Oysters Native oysters are present at the mouth of Loch Creran. These are a priority marine species which are highly sensitive to low and high levels of siltation change. Therefore, as the proposal represents a risk to the silt levels in the river and loch there remains the potential to adversely impact on this species. The applicant has not provided enough information to demonstrate that native oysters will not be adversely affected by the development.

The methodology used for the mammal survey appears to be following best practice guidance, and timing is appropriate. However August is not a useful time to look for breeding birds as it is late in the season when most species will have completed breeding efforts, however should the proposal be approved a further survey can be covered via condition.

In order to improve biodiversity the applicant intends to maintain existing trees required for screening and enhance these groups with additional planting. This would certainly help maintain biodiversity and enhance screening from a landscape and visual perspective. They may also, depending on their design, provide opportunities for some biodiversity gains as well.

This element of the proposal, coupled with conditions, would not be consistent with policies SG LDP 4 (Development Impact on SSSIs and National Nature Reserves), SG LDP ENV 5 (Development Impact on Local Nature Conservation Sites) and SG LDP ENV 6 (Development Impact on Trees / Woodland).

F. Impact on Woodland

There is approximately some 0.8ha of woodland to be removed with 0.75ha of this being coniferous plantation. This loss would be offset with compensatory planting off site to ensure compliance with the Scottish Government’s policy for woodland removal. The area for compensatory planting is within Glen Creran Estate, to the southwest of the site, at Druimavuic.

Equally, the planting of additional trees and shrubs for screening of the site will offset the loss of scrub. However, there are few details of the proposed compensatory planting. Should the application be approved then planning conditions will be required to identify the exact location of planting, species mix etc. prior to the commencement of works.

This approach is advocated by Forestry Commission Scotland (FCS) who do not raise any objection to this element of the proposal subject to conditions covering the proposed compensatory planting.

This element of the proposal is consistent with Local Development Plan policy SG LDP ENV 6 (Development Impact on Trees and Woodland).

G. Landscape Character

SNH’s Argyll and Clyde Landscape Assessment, 1996 describes the area as ‘Mountain Glens’. This is a landscape that can be described as:

 Flat floor of narrow, linear mountain glens with a sharp break of slope at valley side,  Ribbon lochs in lower valley, glacial moraine creates uneven landform with small, rounded lochs on flor of upper valley,  Mudflats and winding creeks at loch heads and at the mouth of the glen,  Meandering river, fringed with groups of trees, contrasts with rectangular pastures drained by straight ditches,  Small blocks of woodland and some conifer plantations,  Linear settlements strung out along lanes at the foot of the steep side slopes,  Castles and country houses are important local landmarks.

The key landscape issues are: the character of the existing broadleaf woodland along outer edges of the glen, the special scenic qualities of the river corridor and the natural, unspoilt character of creeks and mudflats at the mouth of the glen and the setting of historic local landmarks. The document provides specific landscape guidelines and in this instance advises that:

“The meandering river, with its bankside trees, small woodlands and remnant water meadows, is an important visual focus within the glen, and should be carefully conserved. The relationship between the landscape pattern of the river corridor and the straight drainage channels of the flat fields on either side is also attractive; changes in agricultural practice might disrupt the traditional juxtaposition of fields, woodland and wetlands should be discouraged”

Policy SG LDP ENV 13 (Development Impact on Areas of Panoramic Quality) sets out that:

“Argyll and Bute Council will resist development in, or affecting, an Area of Panoramic Quality where its scale, location or design will have a significant adverse impact on the character of the landscape”

Landscape Character and Context Glen Creran has a distinct sense of seclusion due to the absence of through roads and its sparse settlement. Extensive oak woodlands on the north side of the glen and the dramatic backdrop of steep-sided mountains which strongly contain the narrow glen floor add to the scenic richness of its landscape. Glen Creran is designated as an Area of Panoramic Quality (APQ). Although there is no citation for this APQ, it is presumed that the scenic composition of narrow farmed floodplain pastures (with diverse woodlands and field trees), steep and richly wooded hill slopes and rugged open high mountain tops are key special qualities of the designation. In addition to the APQ, the Loch Etive Mountains Wild Land Area (WLA) lies in close proximity to Glen Creran as does the National Nature Reserve and a number of SACs and an SPA. The nearby Munro hill of Beinn Sgulaird is a prominent feature seen in views from Glen Creran. This hill is commonly accessed from Elleric within Glen Creran.

In the area of the proposed quarry site, the character of Glen Creran is adversely affected by detractive estate buildings, storage and hard standing areas. Estate/farm buildings and storage areas have a cluttered disparate appearance which contrast with the generally little modified character of the Glen. Conifer plantations on the glen floor are additionally an incongruous feature especially given the richness of extensive broadleaved woodlands on valley sides, native riparian woodland near the River Creran and mature plantings of lime and ash lining the minor road, tracks and field boundaries on the glen floor.

The proposed quarry development will add to the detractive components of farm buildings, hard standing and storage area in the locality of the Glasdrum area. It could also diminish the sense of seclusion and tranquillity associated with Glen Creran during the operational phase due to the presence of heavy vehicle movements and noise. While the proposed development site and its immediate surrounds is of lower sensitivity than the surrounding area of Glen Creran, in the longer term it is considered that its character will be further degraded by the restoration measures proposed. This proposal would consequently have an adverse effect on landscape character and on the special qualities of the APQ overall. There could also be some adverse effects on the sense of naturalness and solitude experienced from the western edge of the Loch Etive Mountains WLA although this is unlikely to be significant due to the limited extent of the excavated area.

There is potential to mitigate landscape effects by adopting more appropriate mitigation and enhancement measures and this is discussed in more detail at the end of this report.

Effects on Views The site is well-screened from low-level views from minor roads. Some properties will be affected by views of the works and vehicle movement but these are likely to be relatively few in number (3-4). More elevated views will however be significant – these primarily from the slopes and summit of the Munro of Beinn Sgulaird. The principal focus of views from the summit of this hill is to the Etive and Glencoe mountains and west to the sea and islands. This hill also lies within the Loch Etive Wild Land Area and this increases receptor sensitivity.

In elevated views from Beinn Sgulaird the contrast of disturbed land (with working machinery) would be obvious within the pastoral glen floor. The relatively limited size of the development and the focus of viewers on the Etive and Glencoe mountains from the summit of this hill would reduce the magnitude of change to some degree although the effects would be significant and adverse but short term.

Proposed restoration of the quarry site Argyll and Bute Council requested in their response to the screening and scoping request (letter dated 20th May 2016) that ‘details for the management, improvement and enhancement of the remaining trees’. There is however no mention of this in chapter 9 of the ES which describes the restoration proposals.

The objectives of the restoration are set out in 9.4 of the ES. In terms of these, there is no evidence to suggest that this restoration scheme will ‘conserve or enhance the character of the local area’ or that it will be ‘in keeping with the surrounding area’. There will be minimal new tree planting as can be seen in the meagre specification set out in Table 9.1. This is not acceptable given the visual impact on elevated views (and disruption/effects of vehicle movements and noise) on the special character of Glen Creran. Officers strongly disagree with the conclusions of the LVIA that the ‘effects will be ameliorated through restoration’. Specific issues related to the proposed restoration proposals outlined in the ES include:  The profile of the proposed water body is too steep to allow marginal vegetation to established – grades of 1:2.75 and 1:3 (ES, 9.5.3.4)  The proposed restoration to agricultural grassland would require fill to be imported necessitating additional truck movements. It also appears from the cross sections shown in the ES to be likely that restored levels will result in a poor fit with the surrounding natural topography. The proposed site does not appear to be well- used for grazing at present and there is little in the ES to confirm that the restored site will provide suitable grazing land in future.  There appears to be no consideration of the ‘enhancement’ requested by the Council in putting together the restoration proposals for the quarry.  The ES provides no details of felling or compensatory planting off-site or of other measures aimed at landscape and ecological enhancement (noted in section 8 of the ES but not committed to elsewhere)

Conclusions There would be significant adverse effects on the character of part of Glen Creran and on the special qualities of the APQ. While the proposed quarry would be relatively well- screened from low-level views, there would be significant adverse effects on elevated views from Beinn Sgulaird. In general adverse visual impacts would be relatively short term, lasting approximately 5-6 years, although impacts on landscape character would be likely to be permanent if the restoration proposals outlined in the ES were adopted.

Given the sensitivity of Glen Creran and the surrounding landscape, it is recommended that the applicant should commit to more appropriate restoration and wider enhancement measures if this development were to be consented. In order to improve the restoration proposals the applicant should consider the following:  Creation of a larger and more naturalistic water body with more variation in slope profile including shallower sides more able to support marginal vegetation and more substantial planting of native woodland on the site rather than agricultural land.  In the area within and surrounding the development site, replace all inappropriate conifer plantations with native broadleaves to enhance the character of the glen floor and create a more naturalistic land cover more in keeping with the overall character of Glen Creran.  Plant lime and other broadleaved trees (protect from deer and stock) along the north-eastern boundary of Glasdrum Farm against the proposed quarry access track to replicate and enhance existing field boundary plantings on the glen floor.

The proposal will have a significant adverse impact on the outstanding qualities of the APQ from the upper slopes of the southern ridges and from the slopes and top of Ben Sgulaird. The proposal will break with existing field patterns and, coupled with existing agricultural works, will result in significant visual impacts. Although the works will be relatively short term the restoration proposals are wholly inadequate resulting in a long term adverse impact on the character of the glen and the APQ.

The proposal is not considered to be consistent with supplementary guidance policy SG LDP ENV 13 (A) as the applicant has not successfully demonstrated that the landscape impacts from the APQ are outweighed by any benefits of the proposal. H. Minerals

The principal Local Development Plan (LDP) policy governing the extraction of minerals is contained in approved supplementary guidance under SG LDP MIN 2, which is derived from Policy LDP 10 of the adopted plan. SG LDP MIN 2 establishes a general presumption against the opening of new minerals sites unless there is an identified need for a proposal which satisfies the criteria set out in that policy. This section of the Report of Handling assesses whether there is a justifiable need for the development based on information submitted by the applicant and consideration of the policy position established by the LDP.

SG LDP MIN 2 sets out a general presumption against the opening of new or abandoned extraction works in favour of extending the lifespan of existing sites where possible. However, it does set out a criteria based approach to be considered, as required by SPP, when faced with a proposal for the establishment of a new site. With this in mind, the applicant has sought to address this by providing a market analysis, assessing need and identifying what material is available in the market area, and materials being imported to Argyll and Bute. Support has also been elicited from retailers and tradesmen / builders by the applicant including Jewson’s, Soutar Sports Ltd, Colin Sloss Builders etc.

Policy SG LDP MIN 2 states that:

“There will be a presumption against the re-opening of abandoned works, new or extended quarry developments, where adequate permitted reserves already exist. Applications for planning consent will only therefore be considered where:-

(A) The applicant can successfully demonstrate an exceptional local* need for the specific mineral type and quality to be extracted; OR, (B) The applicant can successfully demonstrate that the proposal is to satisfy export demands for specialised minerals beyond the boundaries of Argyll and Bute and is consistent with national mineral policy;”

*Local need is defined as being for the predominant use within a 30 mile radius of the extraction site, or in the case of islands on the same island or within 30 mile transportation distance by road in the case of larger islands.

For the purposes of the policy assessment below, the applicant has sought to demonstrate that there is a justifiable local need for the product. Therefore, the policy assessment required is against criterion (A). Criterion (B) is not applicable in this case as it is meant to govern the assessment for specialised products, such as precious metals, rare earths etc.

In order to be able to assess the proposal against Scottish Planning Policy (SPP) and LDP policy consideration has been given to the applicant’s submission and comments made by informed third parties. To further inform the required assessment, officers have sought information from quarry operators serving the same market area in terms of production and products, and remaining permitted reserves covered by existing minerals permissions has been quantified.

It is necessary to establish whether there is a need in the local market area. The market area is defined by SG LDP MIN 2 as being a 30 mile radius around the site. It is also necessary to identify the locations of main areas of development pressure and activity. The Local Development Plan allocations and National Planning Framework (NPF) provide a degree of foresight with respect to development pressure over the development plan period, and can therefore assist in anticipating demand for minerals on an area basis. It is important to consider what supply is already available and the number of sites providing this material within the market area. The key question is whether, over the development plan period, the additional material is required to meet anticipated local needs and whether the proposal is necessary to meet otherwise unfulfilled demand in the market area.

As per the policy position established by SPP, local authorities are expected to ensure an ongoing ten year supply of aggregate minerals within a market area. Local authorities are expected to ‘safeguard workable resources and ensure that an adequate and steady supply is available to meet the needs of the construction, energy and other sectors’ (paragraph 235, SPP). A market area is defined by SG LDP MIN 2 as being a 30 mile radius around the proposed site. However, it is acknowledged by the Minerals Products Association (MPA) that in more rural areas products may be expected to travel further given the spread of development pressures. Market areas will often cross planning authority boundaries therefore it is important to consider all other sources of material and not just those within the boundary of the determining authority.

Section 238 of the SPP states that:

“Plans should support the maintenance of a land bank of permitted reserves for construction aggregates of at least 10 years at all times in all market areas through the identification of areas of search. Such areas can be promoted by developers or landowners as part of the plan preparation process or by planning authorities where they wish to guide development to particular areas. As an alternative, a criteria-based approach may be taken, particularly where a sufficient land bank already exists or substantial unconstrained deposits are available.”

The applicant contests that there is a distinct lack of quality building sand available within Argyll and Bute as a whole, and that there are insufficient volumes of general sand and gravel available locally. The application aims to satisfy an existing demand for building sand. However, the applicant also states that they are looking to fulfil their own needs as a contractor and for their own ready-mix concrete plant. A third party has submitted an analysis by consultants with credible expertise in the minerals sector (Johnson, Poole and Bloomer). This report identifies that demand for sand and gravel is currently being met from outwith Argyll and Bute. This involves minerals being transported significant distances by road, with undesirable environmental and economic consequences. This would suggest that there is a shortfall in supply of this material. The issue to be examined is whether there is a sufficient demand / supply problem to warrant the opening of a new site and if that demand is from within the Oban, Dunbeg and North Lorn areas.

There are several sites near to Glasdrum with Benderloch, North Connel, Clachan, Dornie and Kilmartin all within reasonable distances. Benderloch and North Connel are within 30 miles of the proposed site. SG LDP MIN 2 specifies a radius of 30miles from the extraction site as the market area. Of the sites named above are within this radius of Oban and Dunbeg. Torosay sand pit has not been considered as part of this assessment because it is located on the which is considered its own market area. The table below provides a summary of the circumstances of these sites: Planning Site and Materials Expiry of Distance to Permission Location Permission Glasdrum and Reference Oban (road miles) 09/00021/FULLO Dornie Quarry, Sand, gravel 2045 37 miles, ( and hard rock 49.5 miles Council) (inc. building sand) 15/02114/MIN Kilmartin Quarry, Sand and 2031 44.8 miles, Kilmartin gravel 29.3 miles (including building sand) 16/01163/MIN North Connel Sand and c. 2022 10.3 miles, Quarry, North gravel (inc. 6 miles Connel building sand) 03/00238/MIN Benderloch Sand and 2032 7 miles Quarry, gravel (no 8.8 miles Benderloch building sand) 15/02012/MIN Bonnar Sand Sand, gravel 2022 52.6 miles, and Gravel, and hard rock 46.1 miles Clachan (inc. building sand)

In terms of production volumes, both Clachan and North Connel are permitted to produce 2,000 tonnes a year each of sand and gravel under existing permissions. Benderloch received permission in 2004 to extract over 1m tonnes of sand and gravel although none of this is building sand, as confirmed by the operator, but they do produce concrete. Dornie Quarry has permission until 2045 to extract a range of material including sand and gravel. Despite having asked the question of how much is building sand, the operator has declined to provide this information, probably because of its commercially sensitive nature.

From discussions with existing operators it is evident that a range of sand and gravel products are available from Clachan, Kilmartin, Benderloch and Dornie. Permission has been granted at North Connel under reference 16/01163/MIN for the extraction of a further 10,000 tonnes of sand over a 5 year period which is generally building sand. This will expire in February 2022. Clachan Quarry’s permission expires on 31st December 2022. Considering the ten year land supply requirement, as per the SPP, this leaves Dornie, Benderloch and Kilmartin quarries fulfilling this criteria within the market area that Glasdrum aims to serve after 2022. Of these, Benderloch does not produce building sand and there is little likelihood of success in any attempt to extend the extraction at North Connel due to its proximity to the nearby caravan park. The operators of Clachan Quarry have advised that there may be scope, in terms of geology, to extend this site in the future. However this is not a matter before officers at this time.

The applicant has set out a detailed case using regional figures that demonstrate 50% of all sand and gravel demand in Argyll and Bute is imported. However, consideration of this needs to be taken in context of the nature of Argyll and Bute within which the main development pressures are Oban and North Lorn and Helensburgh. There are no quarries within the planning authority area of Helensburgh and Lomond given its proximity to and the availability of products from the central belt, and it is not unreasonable to assume that the entire needs of the building industry in this area can be met from quarries outwith Argyll and Bute, for example Dumbuckhill. Therefore it is only natural that there will be significant importation of material from outwith Argyll and Bute. On 17th January 2017 officers requested further information from the applicant with respect to local need. On 29th March the applicant responded with various statements but specifically provided commentary from local developers providing positive comment toward the development and presenting anecdotal evidence of a lack of quality building sand. Further comment was made that in the processing of a recent permission for Kilmartin Quarry that it was considered unacceptable for material to travel from Benderloch to Kilmartin and therefore it must be reasonably applied in the opposite direction. In response to this officers would comment that both sites supply different market areas but these areas have some degree of overlap at Oban and Dunbeg. No specific local data for Oban, Dunbeg and North Lorn was provided. Policy requires the applicant to demonstrate local need and the onus is placed on them to provide this information otherwise there is a presumption against development. It is not for officers to demonstrate otherwise. Given that the onus is placed upon the applicant they have failed to provide a more detailed local analysis, the proposals are contrary to SG LDP MIN 2.

SPP requires local authorities to ensure a reasonable supply of building materials over a ten year period within market areas. The 30 mile radius market area around Glasdrum has four sites producing sand and gravels over the next five years, namely Benderloch, Clachan, Dornie and North Connel. Regardless of the developer’s assertion regarding the lack of building sand, the site will produce a range of materials and must be considered in light of this. The anticipated development pressure would be expected to be at Oban and Dunbeg, the main centres of population, and therefore Kilmartin Quarry can also be considered as a means of supply. If the MPA approach to rural market areas is accepted, with consideration given to dispersed demand and longer travel distances, then it could be appropriate to consider some additional demand arising from outwith the LDP defined market area.

Officers contacted local quarry operators to establish which sites are producing building sand. There are five sites within the 30 mile radius of Oban and Dunbeg producing sand and gravels with four of these producing building sand. Kilmartin, Dornie and Benderloch contribute to the ten year land supply required by the SPP with permissions lasting until 2031 and 2032 respectively whilst North Connel and Clachan are only permitted until 2022.

Anticipating likely future demand within the local area which the proposed quarry would intend to serve is not an exact science. The National Planning Framework (NPF) and LDP can provide guidance in terms of proposed projects and allocations. The NPF is proposing the expansion at Cruachan power station whilst the LDP is proposing 450 dwellings across Oban and Dunbeg. Within 30 miles of these development pressures there are several sites producing sand and gravel.

There are five sites producing sand and gravel in the Oban market area – Kilmartin, North Connel, Benderloch, Dornie and Clachan. Three of these, Benderloch, Dornie and Kilmartin, already contribute to the ten year requirement of the SPP. The proposal is only for a five year period and therefore does not contribute to the SPP requirement for a ten year supply of minerals.

Ultimately officers disagree with the applicant assertion that there is a local based need for this development. The applicant states that 50% of sand and gravel used in Argyll and Bute is imported. This is considered on balance of probability natural given that there are no quarries in the Helensburgh and Lomond area given the proximity of existing quarries in the central belt. Therefore officers disagree that this demonstrates an actual shortfall in supply within the market area identified by the applicant. SG LDP MIN 2 sets the onus on the applicant to demonstrate a local need. The applicant has relied on regional figures to demonstrate a lack of sand and gravel material in Argyll and Bute, but as demonstrated above such figures are only to be expected given the proximity of Helensburgh to minerals markets in the central belt. Local figures are limited given their commercial sensitivity, however there are sufficient reserves of sand and gravel in Benderloch and Kilmartin quarries to satisfy the requirements of SPP and serve the needs of the Oban, Dunbeg and North Lorn areas. It is considered that the Oban, Dunbeg and North Lorn area can be sufficiently supplied with general sand and gravels from extensive reserves at Benderloch, Dornie and Kilmartin. Building sand is a scarcer resource nationally and therefore it is not unreasonable to expect this resource to be found over a more extensive distance. SPP requires a landbank for aggregate materials and does not specify different types of sand and gravel. With this in mind Oban and Dunbeg can continue being served for building sand by Kilmartin, Clachan, Dornie and North Connel. Once North Connel expires in 2022 Oban, Dunbeg and South Lorn will continue being served for building sand by Kilmartin. Given there are no major building projects planned for North Lorn it is reasonable to consider that this area can be served by Dornie Quarry for building sand. The information provided by the applicant is not sufficient to convince officers of a justification of approval and therefore the proposal is not consistent with the provisions of SG LDP MIN 2 and therefore cannot be supported by officers.

The applicant has specified that their submission is to address an existing local shortfall in building sand. Only one third, 5,000 tonnes, of the material to be extracted is expected to be building sand with the remainder being general sands and gravels. Within the market area of Oban there are four sites producing building sand – Kilmartin, Clachan, Dornie and North Connel. Of these Kilmartin and Dornie satisfies the SPP requirement for a ten year land supply. North Connel is expected to cease production in February 2022. General sands and gravels can be produced from both Kilmartin, Dornie and Benderloch with the latter producing ready mix concrete. Dornie quarry can supply a range of materials in the northern market area until 2045. Given the applicant has admitted that the supply of material is to satisfy their own demand as a contractor and in the production of ready mix concrete it is considered that the planning authority are already meeting the requirements of SPP with building sand available from Kilmartin and Dornie until at least 2031 and general sands and gravels from Benderloch until at least 2032.

It is important to note that this assessment represents an evaluation of the current situation. It might be that the various projects above are fully realised and that an increased demand for sand and gravel products emerges during the remaining life of the LDP in which case the situation would require revisiting.

Given the information supplied by the applicant, the life expectancy and available supplies from existing quarries with permitted reserves within reasonable travel distances, it can be concluded that there is sufficient permitted sand and gravel reserves in consented sites to be able to supply anticipated future development demand within the local market area,.

The proposal is not considered to be consistent with supplementary guidance policy SG LDP MIN 2 criterion (A) as the applicant has not successfully provided a detailed market analysis of local supply and demand which has proven that there is a need for the additional material over the projected lifespan of the proposal.

I. Road Network, Parking and Associated Transport Matters The applicant intends to extract 85,000 tonnes of sand and gravel over a five year period. This will result in 15,000 tonnes a year with six vehicle movements a day i.e. three full loads and three empty. Vehicles will exit the quarry using the existing estate tracks onto the glen road (ZU037) and then out onto the A828. As part of this application the applicant has detailed improvements to three existing passing places by lengthening and widening which has been agreed with the Area Roads Engineer.

A number of planning objections relating to the use of the glen road by these vehicles. It should be noted that there a number of existing forestry lorries using this road to extract timber but these are exempt from planning controls. As part of the determination process the applicant was asked to consider alternative arrangements as there is a bridge across the river some 700m to the north-north-east of the application area. The applicant was asked to comment as to the suitability of this bridge. It has been assessed and is only suitable for farm traffic and could not accommodate loaded HGVs. With this in mind the bridge would require a complete rebuild which would result in having a significant adverse economic impact on the proposal given the small quantity of material to be extracted and the short lifespan of the development. This route would also require the creation of a 700m haul route through the countryside which would be a further cost and add potential significant visual impacts across a much larger area of the glen.

Additionally the applicant considered taking a new road through the fields to the west of the site and coming out onto the Salachail Road (ZU037) almost opposite St Mary’s. During the noise assessment it was noted that St Mary’s and the estate croft house were in close proximity meaning that vehicles stopping and then accelerating away would have a significant adverse effect on the amenity of both these properties. Consequently it was decided to use the existing estate roads shared with the agricultural sheds. This provides greater separation distance for vehicles on the internal access route and reduces the period during which they are close to sensitive properties.

The council’s Area Roads Engineer has not raised any concerns over the prospect of six HGV movements on this road per day as resulting in a significant adverse effect. The improvements to the road network is commensurate with the increase in road traffic.

The proposal would provide some planning gain in the form of the improved passing places and could result in material being transported fewer miles through fewer settlements. Rather than material being brought in from Tayside, etc. building sand could be sourced from within the local area. Several large scale businesses including Jewson’s, M and K MacLeod and TSL Limited have all indicated support for the proposal on the basis that they could buy quality material locally. However, as explained above it is the view of officers that such material is available within Argyll.

The proposal is considered consistent with policy SG LDP TRAN 4 in that the applicant can provide commensurate road improvements consistent with the expected increase in traffic movements.

J. Flood Risk

The southern area of the site lies within the indicative limits of fluvial flooding. Parts of the central and southern areas of the site lie within the indicative limits of surface water flooding shown upon the SEPA map.

The proposal includes the excavation and the creation of soil bunds within the southern section of the site. These activities will affect floodplain storage, with the excavation anticipated to increase storage and bunding expected to decrease it. The Low probability (1000 year) fluvial flood outline from the SEPA map has been used to estimate flood extent and through analysis of topographic survey, floodplain storage. Floodplain storage is estimated to be 16,900m3 predevelopment and 22,300m3 during development and 17,200m3 following restoration. While a site specific estimate of flood flow on the River Creran and hence floodplain storage would have been preferable and increased accuracy, this approach is acceptable.

The proposal also accepts that the site may flood and that activities would be suspended during times of flood. However, the River Creran is not part of a formal SEPA Flood Warning Scheme, therefore it is unclear how lead time would be given to allow the site operator to act. It is recommended that a local flood warning system (such as an alarm sensor in the river) be attached as a planning condition.

The Rational Method using FEH13 rainfalls has been used and is acceptable. However, no evidence has been provided to demonstrate that the 1 in 200 year plus climate change run off event would remain the same.

The drainage information within the submission is acceptable. A maintenance regime for the proposed drainage system as not been provided.

The Flood Risk Officer requests that should permission be granted that two conditions are attached:

 Flood warning plan to be developed to allow sufficient time for the operator to act prior to the onset of a flood, and  Surface water drainage to be designed in accordance with CIRIA 753 and Sewers for Scotland 3rd Edition and also include a demonstration that the 1 in 200 year plus climate change event will remain on site and details of the maintenance regime for the surface water drainage system.

Furthermore, SEPA has not objected to the proposal. They do not recommend conditions. However, they do acknowledge that during an extreme flood event there will be an adverse impact on the River Creran with potential for impact on Loch Creran with respect to silting. During an extreme flood event this would happen anyway and the quarry void would need to fill and silt traps fail before any material would enter the river from the site. The additional impact of material entering the river from the site cannot be quantified however SEPA’s view is that during an extreme event this will not be a significant addition.

K. Conclusion

The proposal seeks to extract 15,000 tonnes of sand and gravel a year for 5 years totalling some 83,000 tonnes. Approximately one third of this material will be quality building sand with the remainder as general sand and gravels. Access will be taken along the minor glen road with an additional six vehicle movements a day (three in and three out). As mitigation the applicant intends to improve three existing passing places between the access and the Loch Creran loop road.

From ground level the site will be well screened by existing agricultural sheds and woodland. However, from the higher tops and peaks to the south the site will appear to break existing established field patterns. In elevated views from Beinn Sgulaird the contrast of disturbed land (with working machinery) would be obvious within the pastoral glen floor. The relatively limited size of the development and the focus of viewers on the Etive and Glencoe mountains from the summit of this hill would reduce the magnitude of change to some degree although the effects would be significant and adverse but short term.

In the area of the proposed quarry site, the character of Glen Creran is affected by detractive estate buildings, storage and hard standing areas. Estate/farm buildings and storage areas have a cluttered disparate appearance which contrast with the generally little modified character of the Glen. Conifer plantations on the glen floor are additionally an incongruous feature especially given the richness of extensive broadleaved woodlands on valley sides, native riparian woodland near the River Creran and mature plantings of lime and ash lining the minor road, tracks and field boundaries on the glen floor. This proposal would consequently have an adverse effect on landscape character and on the special qualities of the APQ overall given it would add to the cluttered appearance and break with the existing distinctive mosaic field pattern experienced from view above the glen.

Upon completion of extraction works the restoration scheme would result in a long term adverse impact as a result from poor planting proposals and the water body. The sides of the water body are too steep to allow appropriate regeneration of grass resulting in an incongruous feature within the landscape.

Upon completion the applicant intends to import inert waste to fill the void, top with existing on site over burden and leave a small water feature. However, there is no guarantee that this will be authorised by SEPA whilst the slopes of the water feature are too steep to fully green up and the planting proposals are poor. This will result in a long term incongruous element within the landscape.

SPP requires planning authorities to ensure a ten year land bank for building materials within market areas. SG LDP MIN 2 establishes the market area as 30 mile radius around the proposed site. Over the ten year period Benderloch and Dornie quarries provide a range of materials including sand and gravels over the required timescale. The main market area will be Oban and Dunbeg and Kilmartin Quarry is able to provide material. SPP does not distinguish between different types of aggregate materials just hard rock and sand and gravel both of which are abundantly available within both market areas of the site and Oban and Dunbeg. Building sand is a scarcer resource nationally and therefore it is not unreasonable to expect it to travel longer distances.

The proposal is not consistent with policies LDP DM 1 and SG LDP MIN 2 given the onus is on the applicant to demonstrate a need for the proposal which they have failed to do. The proposal will have a significant impact on the APQ and is therefore not consistent with the provisions of SG LDP ENV 13(a) and SG LDP ENV 14.

SNH has raised an objection with respect to the potential for adverse impact on the Loch Creran SAC and its associated serpulid reefs. It cannot be determined beyond reasonable scientific doubt that the proposal will not result in significant volumes of silt entering the River Creran and thus the loch. This would then impact on the SAC. In light of the applicant’s failure to demonstrate that the proposal will not impact on the SAC SNH has objected on the grounds of lack information.

In the event that significant volumes of silt does enter River Creran then this could render some 700m of the watercourse uninhabitable for Atlantic Salmon. This species are protected under Schedule 3 of the Habitats Regulations 1994. Furthermore, the proposal has the potential to then impact on native oysters which are present at the head of Loch Creran.

The applicant has not provided sufficient information to demonstrate beyond reasonable scientific doubt that the proposal will not adversely impact on the Loch Creran SAC. Therefore the proposal is not consistent with policies LDP 3, SG LDP ENV 1, SG LDP ENV 2 and SG LDP ENV 7. Furthermore, in the event that the silt mitigation measures fail then the River Creran could be rendered unacceptable to Atlantic Salmon which are a European Protected Species and native oysters which are priority marine species. In this regard the proposal is not consistent with policies LDP 3, SG LDP ENV 1 and SG LDP ENV 7. Appendix B – Representations

Full Name ADDRESS Date INFAVOUR 50 Road Festival Square EH3 Burness Paull LLP, 15-May-17 O 9WJ Mills Hill Motors, NW7 4SD 30-Nov-16 O Scotland 28-Jul-17 O Information, Wolfinger And 17-Jul-17 R Kersley, Coletta, A 23 Camus Road Dunbeg Oban PA37 1QD 16-Dec-16 O Calder, Abby No Address 12-Dec-16 O Lopez, Abdon Arlington TX 29-May-17 O Buracchi, Adam SM4 5JQ 28-Nov-16 O Carter, Adam 365 Longford Lane Gloucester GL2 9EL 29-Nov-16 O Reeves, Adam 5 Achinreir Barcaldine Argyll A37 1SL 13-Dec-16 O Askew, Adrian 149 Morrison St Edinburgh 12-Dec-16 O Fotos, Agnes PA38 4DF 30-Nov-16 O Gouveia, Agnes BH21 1JU 22-Nov-16 O Moffat, Aileen G72 8LF 02-Dec-16 O Park, Aileen EH4 7PR 01-Dec-16 O Kelly, Aimee 20 Byron Close Hampton TW12 1EL 24-Nov-16 O Barnetche, Alain 33800 Bordeaux 01-Dec-16 O Rhugarbh Church Barcaldine Oban Argyll And Anderson, Alan 22-Feb-17 O Bute PA37 1SE Gardiner, Alan Cocklaw Farm Biggar ML12 6RD 29-Nov-16 O Johnston, Alan 71 Dalyell Place EH48 2QB 06-Dec-16 O Laird, Alan 2 Birkenwood Cottages Kippen FK8 3JH 01-Dec-16 O Mackay, Alan Hillhead Croft Newmachar AB21 7XB 02-Dec-16 O McCall, Alan 4 Kendal Road East Kilbride Glasgow 13-Dec-16 O 64 Lorn Road Dunbeg Oban Argyll And Bute Moore, Alan 10-Jul-17 O PA37 1QQ No Surname, Alan Oban 01-Dec-16 O Watson, Alan 11 Annfield Drive Arbroath 06-Dec-16 O 8 Laurie Terrace Gow, Alan Thurso 05-Dec-16 S KW14 8NR McRae, Alana 17D Argyll Square Oban 21-Nov-16 O

Scott, Alasdair Lochvoil House Dunuaran Road Oban PA34 4NE 16-Jan-17 O

Scott, Alasdair Lochvoil House Dunuaran Road Oban PA34 4NE 14-Jul-17 O

Whyte, Alasdair 21 North Berwick Cr. Greenhills East Kilbride 24-Jan-17 O Whyte, Alasdair 21 North Berwick Cr. Greenhills East Kilbride 11-Jul-17 O Irving, Alastair 26 Lydgait Gardens Haddington EH41 3DB 08-Dec-16 O Irving, Alastair 26 Lydgait Gardens Haddington EH41 3DB 10-Jul-17 O Maam House Inveraray Argyll And Bute PA32 Briggs, Alec 01-Dec-16 O 8XH MacCall, Alec D 7736 22nd Ave NE Seattle WA USA 98115 26-May-17 O Brown, Alex Newbarn Stenton EH42 1TB 08-Dec-16 O Gourlay, Alex The Studio The Pier Port Appin Argyll PA38 4DN 01-Dec-16 O Hamilton, Alex 14 Swift Crescent Glasgow G13 4QL 28-Nov-16 O McLay, Alex 21 Richmond Drive Lymm Cheshire 08-Dec-16 O Clark, Alexander Heanish Ganavan Oban 09-Dec-16 O Dewar, Alexander 2 Underwood Longistan Road Oban PA34 5JW 14-Dec-16 O Dewar, Alexander 2 Underwood Longistan Road Oban PA34 5JW 14-Jul-17 O 38 MacDonald Smtih Drive Carnouise Angus Irvine, Alexander 11-Jul-17 O DD7 7NR Riverdale Barran Kilmore Oban Argyll And Bute Smart, Alexander 12-Dec-16 O PA34 4XR Riverdale Barran Kilmore Oban Argyll And Bute Smart, Alexander 13-Jul-17 O PA34 4XR Stoddart, Alexander 9 Cameron Brae Kentallen Appin PA38 4BF 29-Nov-16 O Stoddart, Alexander 9 Cameron Brae Kentallen Appin PA38 4BF 07-Jul-17 O Fetherstonhaugh, 19 St Anns Villas W11 4RT 25-Nov-16 O Alexia Laird, Alexina Birkenwood Stirlingshire 01-Dec-16 O 143 Parklands Road Chichester West Sussex Cunningham, Ali 29-Nov-16 O PO19 3DY Howdle, Alice Kemyshall Kirkton Dumfries DG1 1SX 01-Dec-16 O 6 Creran Gardens Oban Argyll And Bute PA34 Johnston, Alice 28-Nov-16 O 4JU Hanby Rectory Hill Rickinghall Diss Norfolf IP22 Bacon-Snow, Alison 14-Dec-16 O 1EH Killean Farm Achnacroish Isle Of Lismore Oban Brooks, Alison 12-Dec-16 O Argyll And Bute PA34 5UG Brown, Alison No Address 07-Dec-16 O Chadwick, Alison No Address Given 12-Dec-16 O Godfrey, Alison 12 Cromarty Close Darlington DL1 3RE 06-Dec-16 O 20 Newport Road Eccleshall Staffordshire ST21 Mckenna, Alison 14-Dec-16 O 6BD Rodgers, Alison Platkias Rethymno 74060 Crete 24-Nov-16 O Skelton, Alison 842 Dunsmuir Road Victoria BC Canada 06-Dec-16 O Skelton, Alison 842 Dunsmuir Road Victoria BC Canada 10-Jul-17 O Cuan House Cuan Ferry Isle Of Oban Argyll Fothergill, Alistair 28-Nov-16 O And Bute PA34 4RB The Pines North Connel Oban Argyll And Bute Nicol, Alistair 09-Dec-16 O PA37 1QX The Pines North Connel Oban Argyll And Bute Nicol, Alistair 11-Jul-17 O PA37 1QX Russell, Alistair PH33 7HY 28-Nov-16 O Derrick, Allan Torran Drive Erskine 01-Dec-16 O Hendry, Allan FK10 2NX 02-Dec-16 O McIntyre, Allan 8 St Michaels Yard Dundee DD4 9AP 24-Nov-16 O Mckerracher, Ally 75 Nant Drive 22-Nov-16 O Watson, Ally 12/7 Oxgangs Street Edinburgh 08-Dec-16 O Kilchurn Ganavan Road Oban Argyll And Bute Lawson, Allyson 24-Nov-16 O PA34 5TU Denholm, Alyn 10 The Hill FK8 3PT 07-Jul-17 O Brunton, Amanda 54 Harris Way Grantham NG31 7BY 25-Nov-16 O Cressey, Amanda 10 Casteldyke South Barton Upon Humber 06-Dec-16 O Hendry, Amanda 80 Roman Cr Old Kilpatrick Glasgow G60 5JU 01-Dec-16 O Hendry, Amanda 80 Roman Cr Old Kilpatrick Glasgow G60 5JU 10-Jul-17 O McSween, Amanda 66 Killermont Road Bearsden G61 2LS 01-Dec-16 O McSween, Amanda 66 Killermont Road Bearsden G61 2LS 10-Jul-17 O Mcsween, Amanda 66 Killermont Street Bearsden G61 2LS 10-Jul-17 O Rionnagan House Dunmore Tarbert Argyll And Scott, Amanda 14-Dec-16 O Bute PA29 6XZ Rionnagan House Dunmore Tarbert Argyll And Scott, Amanda 14-Jul-17 O Bute PA29 6XZ MacColl, Amy PA34 5AT 28-Nov-16 O McColl, Amy 92013 San Diego California USA 02-Jun-17 O Rees, Anabelle PA35 1HP 30-Nov-16 O Rees, Anabelle PA35 1HP 06-Jul-17 O Harrison, Andrea 40 Woodstock Drive Worsley Manchester 15-May-17 O Skeabost Old Ferry Road North Gilbert, Andrew 30-Nov-16 O Fort William PH33 6SA The Fox Ceum Dhun Righ Benderloch Oban Jones, Andrew 23-Nov-16 O PA37 1ST The Fox Ceum Dhun Righ Benderloch Oban Jones, Andrew 05-Jul-17 O PA37 1ST The Fox Ceum Dhun Righ Benderloch Oban Jones, Andrew 26-Jul-17 O PA37 1ST Macdonald, Andrew PA34 5DX 23-Nov-16 O McPherson, Andrew Tigh Na Sith North Connel Argyll PA37 1RW 22-Nov-16 O Morley, Andrew HP7 9BX 24-Nov-16 O Nisbet, Andrew 20 Craigie Avenue Boat Of Garten PH24 3BL 11-Jul-17 O Scott, Andrew 109 Rockmount Avenue Giffnock Glasgow 04-Jul-17 O Scott, Andrew No Address 23-Nov-16 O Spence, Andrew Nellbank Kilmore PA34 4XT 09-Dec-16 O Spence, Andrew Nellbank Kilmore PA34 4XT 11-Jul-17 O Sterling, Andrew 11 Bealach Na Mara Port Appin PA38 4DR 24-Nov-16 O Flat 1, Laroch House, Loanfern Ballachulish Thornton, Andrew 25-Nov-16 O PH49 4JE C/O E Thornton & Co 17-19 Lochside Street Vennard, Andrew 23-Jun-17 O Oban PA34 4HP North Shian Ferry House Appin Argyll And Bute Wager, Andrew 19-Jun-17 O PA38 4BA Wallace, Andrew 3 Strathcarron Place Dundee DD2 4BB 07-Dec-16 O Weisman, Andrew 23 Avenue Mirebeau France 07-Jul-17 O Weisman, Andrew Hester Road SW11 4AR 01-Dec-16 O Law, Andy Heriot Toun Farmhouse Heroit 12-Dec-16 O Tigh An Eaglais Kilmore Oban Argyll And Bute MacArthur, Andy 02-Dec-16 O PA34 4XX Macdonald, Andy 7B Argyll Street Oban Argyll And Bute PA34 5SG 09-Dec-16 O McNeill, Andy Of Appin PA38 30-Nov-16 O Wren, Andy 60 Highbury Hill London N51 AP 07-Dec-16 O Bailey, Angela 1 Benvoullin Lane Oban PA34 5DX 16-Jan-17 O Bailey, Angela 1 Benvoullin Lane Oban PA34 5DX 14-Jul-17 O McDougall, Angela Etiveawe Taynuilt Argyll And Bute PA35 1JQ 30-Nov-16 O The Lodge Little Hedgecourt Copthorne Willis, Angela 07-Dec-16 O Felbridge RH19 2QQ Owen, Angelina Glaceriska Appin Argyll 23-Nov-16 O No Surname, Anita PA34 5UL 09-Dec-16 O No Surname, Anita PA34 5UL 01-Aug-17 O Colthart, Ann Duriehill Connell Oban PA37 1PQ 12-Jan-17 O Franssen, Ann 12 Allander Road G62 8PN 02-Dec-16 O Franssen, Ann 12 Allander Road G62 8PN 11-Jul-17 O 7 Kilmartin Court Shore Street Oban Argyll And Jacobs, Ann 07-Dec-16 O Bute PA34 4NT Le C, Ann Millar Street Crieff 01-Dec-16 O Williams, Ann 77 Gordon Road London E11 2RA 06-Dec-16 O Bunn, Anna 1 Oaks Way Ketley Telford TF1 5FQ 08-Dec-16 O Clark, Anna SA45 5YW 06-Dec-16 O Whitelaw, Anna PA38 4BN 21-Nov-16 O Bogle, Anna Kenrick 31 Mossgiel Road Glasgow 23-Nov-16 O Springbank Argyll And Bute Archer, Anne 01-Dec-16 O PA21 2EJ Springbank Tighnabruaich Argyll And Bute Archer, Anne 07-Jul-17 O PA21 2EJ Springbank Tighnabruaich Argyll And Bute Archer, Anne 31-Jul-17 O PA21 2EJ Barr, Anne 3 Mull Terrace Oban Argyll And Bute PA34 4YB 14-Dec-16 O Cottage Old Ferry Road North Beech, Anne 30-Nov-16 O Ballachulish OH33 6SA Macarthur, Anne 108 Cotton Street Castle Douglas DG7 1AN 22-Jun-17 O Macarthur, Anne 108 Cotton Street Castle Douglas DG7 1AN 09-Dec-16 O Macewen, Anne No Address 07-Dec-16 O McColl, Anne 5942 Henley Drive San Diego CA 92120 07-Jun-17 O McKenzie, Anne 6 Curzon Road Weybridge KT13 8UW 24-Nov-16 O Smith, Anne 7 Birkhall Ave Inchinnan PA4 9QA 01-Dec-16 O Suckling, Anne The Dean West Linton 17-Jul-17 O Carmichael, Annelie Muirhall Road Perth 01-Dec-16 O 2 Impasse Aux Impasse Aux Choux 5030 Gerard, Annick 01-Dec-16 O Gembloux Forwood, Annie 16 Grampian Cr Boat Of Garten PH24 3BJ 24-Nov-16 O Inver Boathouse Loch Creran Appin Argyll And Everington, Anthony 12-Dec-16 O Bute PA38 4BQ Inver Boathouse Loch Creran Appin Argyll And Everington, Anthony 31-Jul-17 O Bute PA38 4BQ The Old Barn Coilleveneach Fasnacloich Appin Hawkins, Anthony 09-Dec-16 O Argyll And Bute PA38 4BJ Hawkins, Anthony The Old Barn Fasnacloich Appin PA38 4BJ 04-Jul-17 O Lancaster, Anthony 24 WF8 4SJ 11-Jul-17 O Wackett, Anthony 14/2 Dock Place EH6 6LU 09-Dec-16 O Wackett, Anthony 14/2 Dock Place EH6 6LU 10-Jul-17 O Wackett, Anthony 14/2 Dock Place EH6 6LU 01-Aug-17 O MacNeacail, The Rock Carlops By Penicuik Peeblesshire 28-Jun-17 O Aonghas EH26 9NF Manderley Benvoullin Road Oban Argyll And MacDonald, Archi 24-Nov-16 O Bute PA34 5EF Manderley Benvoullin Road Oban Argyll And MacDonald, Archi 07-Jul-17 O Bute PA34 5EF MacKenzie Balderson, Lochside Cottage Glen Creran 24-Nov-16 O Arngrimur Stalker, Ashley 3 Glenbervie Road Grangemouth FK3 9LE 06-Dec-16 O Anderson, Ashling Bearsden G61 3HL 29-Nov-16 O Murphy, Aura 3 Maxwell Avenue Glasgow G61 1NH 24-Nov-16 O Lawson, Avril 1 Trenchard Pl KY12 9EW 01-Dec-16 O Blackadder, B Tobermory Isle Of Mull 31-Jul-17 O 10 Hillside Dunbeg Oban Argyll And Bute PA37 Coughlan, Barbara 12-Dec-16 O 1QL 10 Hillside Dunbeg Oban Argyll And Bute PA37 Coughlan, Barbara 11-Jul-17 O 1QL Hawkins, Barbara The Old Barn Fasbacloich Appin PA38 4BJ 04-Jul-17 O Hawkins, Barbara The Old Barn Glen Creran Appin PA38 4BJ 08-Dec-16 O Caerthann House Grosvenor Crescent Connel Macfarlane, Barbara 01-Dec-16 O PA37 1PQ MacPherson, 4800 Daleview Avenue El Monte C A 91731 05-Jun-17 O Barbara Williamson, Barbara 107 Harrow Drive Hornchurch Essex RM11 1NT 09-Dec-16 O Miller, Barrie No Address 08-Dec-16 O Cole, Barry 171 Bridgemere Road Eastbourne E Sussex 30-Nov-16 O Cole, Barry 171 Bridgemere Road Eastbourne E Sussex 07-Jul-17 O 7A The Gables London Road Whitchurch RG28 Donaldson, Barry 05-Jul-17 O 7HN 8 Clover Court Brigg North Lincolnshire DN20 Jenkinson, Barry 23-Nov-16 O 8FE Wallace, Ben 2 West Laroch Ballachulish PH49 4JJ 21-Nov-16 O Wallace, Ben 2 West Laroch Ballachulish PH49 4JJ 28-Jun-17 O Buchanan Smith, Eriska Benderloch By Oban PA37 1SD 06-Dec-16 O Beppo Buchanan Smith, Eriska Benderloch By Oban PA37 1SD 07-Jul-17 O Beppo Kellerman, 1 Clifton Place Glasgow G3 7LX 09-Dec-16 O Bernadette McLaughlan, Bernie No Address 22-Nov-16 O Hartleyk, Beryl 39 Clissold Court London N4 2EZ 13-Jan-17 O Gribben, Bess Keirfold Avenue Tullibody FK10 3BE 30-Nov-16 O Gribben, Bess Keirfold Avenue Tullibody FK10 3BE 05-Jul-17 O Williams, Bettina 20 Kings Drive Basechurch SY4 2DG 14-Dec-16 O No Surname, Betty 22021 Hackney Ce Delaware 19960 USA 22-Feb-17 O Graham, Bill 01-Dec-16 O Grant, Bill 249 Bearsden Road Glasgow 06-Dec-16 O Grant, Bill 249 Bearsden Road Glasgow 10-Jul-17 O Buchanan, Billy 16 Borneskitaig Kilmuir Portree IV51 9YS 01-Dec-16 O Buchanan, Billy 16 Borneskitaig Kilmuir Portree IV51 9YS 10-Jul-17 O Salvarli, Birgitte Mo Dhachaidh Appin Argyll PA38 4BL 12-Dec-16 O Salvarli, Birgitte Mo Dhachaidh Appin Argyll PA38 4BL 11-Jul-17 O Cornish, Bob Tom-a-Ghiuthais Fasnacloich Appin PA38 4BJ 28-Jun-17 O Shepton, Bob Innisfree Appin PA38 4BL 30-Nov-16 O Shepton, Bob Innisfree Appin PA38 4BL 30-Jun-17 O Wilson, Bob G3 6LH 01-Dec-16 O Ryvoan North Connel Oban Argyll And Bute Smyth, Breege 12-Dec-16 O PA37 1RD 23 Lorn Road Dunbeg Oban Argyll And Bute McGuckin, Brendan 24-Nov-16 O PA37 1QG Dempsey, Brian No Address 01-Dec-16 O 7 Dale Crescent Hathersage Hope Valley S32 Griffiths, Brian 01-Aug-17 O 1AP Khan, Brian PA34 4XF 11-Jul-17 O Lawson, Brian 4 Hawthorn Street Leven KY8 4QE 02-Dec-16 O McKenna, Brian 18 Kirkmuir Drive Stewarton Ayrshire KA3 3HP 16-Jan-17 O McKenna, Brian 18 Kirkmuir Drive Stewarton Ayrshire KA3 3HP 14-Jul-17 O Robin, Brian Claunie Balvicar Oban PA34 4TG 28-Nov-16 O Scally, Brian 5 Shaftsbury Crescent Newarthill 02-Dec-16 O McColl, Brian A 92103 San Diego California USA 02-Jun-17 O Coates, Bruce 22 Ashmore Road Cotteridge B30 2HA 30-Nov-16 O Gamble, Bruce 9 Dundaff Hill Cumbernauld G68 9AH 09-Dec-16 O Woodend Cottage Kirkton Griffiths, Bruce Taynuilt 08-Dec-16 O Argyll And Bute PA35 1HW Lee, Bruce 30 Glebe Ave Bedworth CV12 0DP 07-Dec-16 O Woodend Cottage Kirkton Taynuilt Argyll And No Surname, Bruce 11-Jul-17 O Bute PA35 1HW Curran, Bryan No Address 01-Dec-16 O Macpherson, Bryan 12 The Grange Terrace Fort William PH33 6JG 12-Dec-16 O Macpherson, Bryan 12 The Grange Terrace Fort William PH33 6JG 11-Jul-17 O Grigor, Bryceina Meoble Proby Street Maryburgh IV7 8DZ 08-Dec-16 O Harvey Wolfinger C/O Burness Paull 50 Lothian Paull, Burness 20-Jun-17 O Road Festival Square Edinburgh EH3 9WJ Lesley Wolfinger C/O Burness Paull 50 Lothian Paull, Burness 20-Jun-17 O Road Festival Square Edinburgh EH3 9WJ Hall, C Kentallen 19-Jun-17 O 2 Burnside Court Miller Road Oban Argyll And No Surname, Cairon 22-Nov-16 R Bute PA34 4DL Black, Callum 05 Braids Drive Crookston Glasgow G53 7SH 07-Dec-16 O Black, Callum 05 Braids Drive Crookston Glasgow G53 7SH 10-Jul-17 O Macleod, Callum PA34 5QD 01-Jun-17 O 37 Catalina Avenue Oban Argyll And Bute PA34 No Surmane, Calum 23-Nov-16 O 4GD North Shian Ferry House Appin Argyll And Bute Doig, Cameron 19-Jun-17 O PA38 4BA Bowlby, Camilla Manor Farm Aisby Grantham 25-Nov-16 O Slimon, Campbell Feith Buidhe Laggan PH20 1BT 09-Dec-16 R Slimon, Campbell Feith Buidhe Laggan Newtonmore PH20 1BT 11-Jul-17 R Langille, Canon Mell 1 Deans Road Fortrose IV10 8TJ 09-Dec-16 O Flat C 126 George Street Oban Argyll And Bute Potts, Cara 29-Nov-16 O PA34 5NT Ruiters, Carl IV55 8GW 07-Dec-16 O Cooper, Carmen No Address Given 29-Nov-16 O Burnside, Carol 45 Nant Drive Oban Argyll And Bute PA34 4NL 30-Nov-16 O Burnside, Carol 45 Nant Drive Oban Argyll And Bute PA34 4NL 07-Jul-17 O Macintyre, Carol Innisfree Glencruitten Oban PA34 4QB 22-Nov-16 O MacIntyre, Carol Innisfree Glencruitten Road Oban PA34 4QB 30-Jun-17 O MacNiven, Carol 29 Morven Hill Oban 01-Dec-16 O Ross, Carol 47 Pennor Drive St Austell PL25 4UW 24-Nov-16 O Leighton, Carole 16 Forge Close Hayes UB3 5JF 01-Dec-16 O Robertson, Carole No Address 08-Dec-16 O 7C Terrace Oban Argyll And Bute Berry, Caroline 30-Nov-16 O PA34 4YL Boswell, Caroline Quarry Glen Creran 29-Nov-16 O Drummond, 100 West Princes Street Helensburgh Argyll 01-Dec-16 O Caroline And Bute G84 8XD Scott, Caroline 36 Tippet Knowes Park Winchburgh EH52 6UJ 01-Dec-16 O Spencer, Caroline EX24 6HW 07-Dec-16 O Maam House Inveraray Argyll And Bute PA32 Walker, Caroline 30-Nov-16 O 8XH Maam House Inveraray Argyll And Bute PA32 Walker, Caroline 10-Jul-17 O 8XH Walton, Caroline Kakadu Barcaldine PA37 9SG 28-Nov-16 O 4 Newfield Terrace Achnacroish Isle Of Lismore Willis, Caroline 25-Nov-16 O Oban Argyll And Bute PA34 5UJ 4 Newfield Terrace Achnacroish Isle Of Lismore Willis, Caroline 07-Jul-17 O Oban Argyll And Bute PA34 5UJ Wolfinger, Cassie 19 Hydethorpe Road SW12 0JE 22-Nov-16 O Achnashie Glenmore Road Oban Argyll And Newsheller, Cat 21-Nov-16 O Bute PA34 4ND Greenbank Glenmore Road Oban Argyll And Gillies, Catherine 29-Nov-16 O Bute PA34 4NB Howe, Catherine 78 Albert Road Gourock PA19 1ML 01-Dec-16 O Mooney, Catherine 37 Rowallan Gardens Glasgow 12-Dec-16 O Mooney, Catherine 37 Rowallan Gardens Glasgow 01-Aug-17 O Elsby, Catherine 134 Norse Road G14 9EH 22-Nov-16 R Morrison, Cathie 12 Kelburn Court Largs Ayrshire 01-Dec-16 O Watts, Cathy Saskatoon Sk. Canada S7N 0N8 25-May-17 O Watts, Cathy Saskatoon Sk. Canada S7N 0N8 17-Jul-17 O Campbell, Catriona Southview The Row Letham KY15 7RS 09-Dec-16 O Campbell, Catriona Southview The Row Letham KY15 7RS 13-Jul-17 O Jameson, Charles PO Box 7516 Athens GA USA 09-Dec-16 O Cairn Court Flat J28 Staff Accommodation Knoery, Charles 12-Dec-16 O Raigmore Inverness IV2 3UJ Macdonell, Charles Am Fasgadh Brae Of Kinkell Dingwall IV7 8HZ 30-Nov-16 O Macdonell, Charles Am Fasgadh Brae Of Kinkell Dingwall IV7 8HZ 06-Jul-17 O Robertson Construction Group Robertson Worling, Charlie 27-Apr-17 S House Castle Business Park Stirling FK9 4TZ Smith, Charlotte No Address Given 07-Jun-17 O St Mary's Fasnacloich Appin Argyll And Bute Smith, Charlotte 30-Nov-16 O PA38 4BJ Smith, Charlotte St Mary's Fasnacloich Appin PA38 30-Jun-17 O Stout, Charlotte Full Address Not Given 10-Jul-17 O Taylor, Chloe 3 Road Oban Argyll And Bute PA34 4YG 08-Dec-16 O Flat 1/1 1 Big Kiln Street Campbeltown Argyll Annetts, Chris 01-Dec-16 O And Bute PA28 6JF Hobbs, Chris 34 Baldwin Road Leicester LE2 6HA 01-Dec-16 O Miles, Chris Balwearie House Kirkcaldy Fife KY2 5UL 13-Dec-16 O Miles, Chris Balwearie House Kirkcaldy Fife KY2 5UL 17-Jul-17 O Outram, Chris 19 Rashierig Broxburn West Lothian 22-Nov-16 O Pearman, Chris Beauly Duror Of Appin PA38 4BS 29-Nov-16 O Pearman, Chris Beauly Duror Of Appin PA38 4BS 12-Jun-17 O Pearman, Chris Beauly Duror Of Appin PA38 4BS 05-Jul-17 O Brown, Chrisanne Northwood Barcaldine By Oban PA37 1SG 01-Dec-16 O Top Flat 3B Glencruitten Road Oban Argyll And Armstrong, Christian 01-Dec-16 O Bute PA34 4DN Malcolm, Christian The Lookout Cuil Bay Duror Appin 30-Nov-16 O Potter, Christina 22 Lansdown Parade Cheltenham GL50 2LH 10-Feb-17 O Potter, Christina 22 Lansdown Parade Cheltenham GL50 2LH 14-Jul-17 O Scott Barber, IP21 5SA 28-Nov-16 O Christina Cuan Ard Cuan Ferry Isle Of Seil Oban Argyll Wills, Christina 12-Dec-16 O And Bute PA34 4RB Cuan Ard Cuan Ferry Isle Of Seil Oban Argyll Wills, Christina 11-Jul-17 O And Bute PA34 4RB Irvine, Christine 3 Enderby Drive Hexham NE46 2PA 30-Nov-16 O MacDonald, 4B Millpark Terrace Soroba Road Oban 22-Nov-16 O Christine Mochner, Christine Langhansstr 149 13086 Berlin 02-Dec-16 O Veale, Christine 92109 San Diego California USA 30-May-17 O Main, Christine AB12 5BX 01-Dec-16 O Mary Rigaut, Christophe No Address 09-Dec-16 O Rigaut, Christophe No Address 11-Jul-17 O Can Parroquia Apdo Corr 393 St Esteve De Carnie, Christopher 09-Dec-16 O Palau Barcelona Catalonia Morris, Christopher Lynamer Tulloch Ethy Bridge PH25 3EF 30-Nov-16 O Paine, Christopher Frith Hill Farm Great Missenden HP16 9QF 24-Jan-17 O 27 King Street Twyford Melton Mowbray LE14 Trent, Christopher 01-Dec-16 O 2 HR De Mortimer, Claire Barr Bheag Taynuilt Argyll And Bute PA35 1HY 29-Nov-16 O De Mortimer, Claire Barr Bheag Taynuilt Argyll And Bute PA35 1HY 06-Jul-17 O North Shian Ferry House Appin Argyll And Bute Doig, Claire 19-Jun-17 O PA38 4BA Kinlochlaich House Appin Argyll And Bute PA38 Hutchison, Claire 09-Dec-16 O 4BD Kinlochlaich House Appin Argyll And Bute PA38 Hutchison, Claire 17-Jul-17 O 4BD Treasurer, Claire 10 Stevenson Street Oban Argyll And Bute 07-Dec-16 O Treasurer, Claire 10 Stevenson Street Oban Argyll And Bute 07-Jul-17 O Abbott, Clare Sabdenbrook PA34 5DY 06-Dec-16 O Baldry, Clare 153 Ravenslea Road London SW12 8RT 30-Jun-17 O Gardner, Clare Plasyberllan Tanygroes Cardigan 22-Nov-16 O Heath, Clare No Address 07-Dec-16 O 6 The Fairways Leamington Spa Warks CV32 Holmes, Clare 23-Nov-16 O 6PR Hunt, Clare Tigh Na Faidh Appin PA38 4BA 14-Dec-16 O Hunt, Clare Tigh Na Faidh Appin PA38 4BA 14-Jul-17 O McHugh, Clare 54 Iain Road 25-Nov-16 O No Surname, Clare No Address 30-Nov-16 O Wood, Clare S17 4HR 01-Dec-16 O No Surname, Clare SW12 8RT 23-Nov-16 R Astrand, Clifford Bridgend Strathkanaird Ullapool IV26 2TW 05-Jul-17 O Brewer, Clive 11 Scapa Court 01-Dec-16 O Carswell, Colin PA34 5JA 22-Nov-16 O Chilcott, Colin EH9 3DB 12-Dec-16 O Gauld, Colin 20 Commercial Road Insch 10-Jul-17 O Irvine, Colin Tighardreservations Isle Of Canna PH44 4RS 09-Dec-16 O McPherson, Colin Hazelwood Cottage Tigh A Phuirt Ballachullish 28-Jun-17 O Hodge, Colin Achalic Farm Lerags Oban Argyll PA34 4SE 16-Jan-17 R 1910 Roosevelt Ave #4 San Diego California McColl, Colin R 30-May-17 O 92109 McColl, Corinne 12580 Mirar De Valle Valley Center Ca 92082 29-May-17 O Macadam, Craig 24 Norwood Crescent Alloa 17-Jul-17 O Mitchell, Craig 2/2 9 Lochburn Gate Glasgow G20 0sn 11-Jul-17 O Druimneil Cottage Port Appin Appin Argyll And Williamson, Craig 24-Nov-16 O Bute PA38 4DQ Bonomy, Cris PH1 1EZ 06-Dec-16 O Bonomy, Cris PH1 1EZ 14-Jul-17 O Burn, D 28 Marionville Crescent Edinburgh EH7 6AU 24-Jan-17 O Roxborough, D W IV21 2BP 01-Dec-16 O Powell, Damon Bonawe House PA35 1JQ 23-Nov-16 O White, Dan Kilmore Oban Argyll 05-Jul-17 O White, Dan PA34 4XX 28-Nov-16 O Ralston, Dane 8 Darluith Park PA5 8DD 28-Nov-16 O Ralston, Dane 8 Darluith Park PA5 8DD 04-Jul-17 O London, Daniel 110 Thames Road London W4 3RQ 06-Dec-16 O Morgan, Danny CN20 2FP 09-Dec-16 O Morgan, Danny CN20 2FP 10-Jul-17 O Morrison, Darren Druim Cas Appin Argyll And Bute PA38 4BA 25-Nov-16 O Dixey, Dave 77 Regent Road Leicester LE1 6YG 30-Nov-16 O 1B Millpark Place Oban Argyll And Bute PA34 Hoare, Dave 30-Nov-16 O 4JY 1B Millpark Place Oban Argyll And Bute PA34 Hoare, Dave 05-Jul-17 O 4JY Randle, Dave 10A Dalintart Drive Oban 22-Nov-16 O Daley, Daveena 11 Penn Street Belper Derbyshire 07-Dec-16 O Aitken, David PA34 4GD 30-Nov-16 O Bleazard, David 12A Etive Park North Connel Argyll PA37 1SJ 06-Dec-16 O Bleazard, David 12A Etive Park North Connel Argyll PA37 1SJ 07-Jul-17 O Booth, David 23 Delves Place Hackenthorpe S12 4AG 02-Dec-16 O Chessum, David 34 Central Avenue Troon Ayrshire KA10 7AZ 01-Dec-16 O Forrest, David 18 Farm Road Blantyre G72 9AH 30-Nov-16 O Griffiths, David Pa34 4JE 28-Nov-16 O Gunn, David 20 Lorn Drive Glencoe PH49 4HR 11-Jul-17 O Henderson, David PA34 5UH 01-Dec-16 O Hill, David 3 Lora View North Connel By Oban PA37 1RR 22-Nov-16 O Howdle, David Kemyshall DG1 1SX 01-Dec-16 O Drumrae Barbour Road Kilcreggan Helensburgh Jamieson, David 12-Dec-16 O Argyll And Bute G84 0JN Drumrae Barbour Road Kilcreggan Helensburgh Jamieson, David 11-Jul-17 O Argyll And Bute G84 0JN 1/2 Ambassador Court Musselburgh East Kelly, David 12-Dec-16 O Lothian 16 Nelson Road Oban Argyll And Bute PA34 MacCuish, David 22-Nov-16 O 4DQ Marshall, David 30 Scott Road KY6 1AB 01-Dec-16 O Mason, David G67 3DA 07-Dec-16 O Mathieson, David Appin House Appin Argyll And Bute PA38 4BN 19-Jun-17 O Ardtully Cottage Ardtully Brae Hunters Quay McNeil, David 07-Dec-16 O Argyll And Bute PA23 8LD Millar, David 7 The Avenue Dundee DD2 5HN 16-Jan-17 O Morley, David Parkhall Balfron G63 0LQ 29-Nov-16 O Bay Cottage Airds Bay Taynuilt Argyll And Bute Robinson, David 30-Nov-16 O PA35 1JR Stevenson, David 31 Blacklands Road East Kilbride G74 1BE 29-Nov-16 O 1 Wellington House 160 Upper Richmond Rd Strang, David 09-Dec-16 O Putney London SW15 2SW Williams, David Allt-Na-Craobh Old Shore Road Connel 28-Nov-16 O Williams, David Allt-Na-Craobh Old Shore Road Connel 13-Jul-17 O Yapp, David 5 Nottingham Road Bristol BS7 9DH 01-Dec-16 O Cathro, David No Address Given 27-Apr-17 S Murgatroyd, David A 22 Lune Road Clitheroe BB7 2FW 22-Feb-17 O Murgatroyd, David A 22 Lune Road Clitheroe BB7 2FW 14-Jul-17 O Potts, David J East Coilleard Rhugarbh Appin Argyll PA38 4BA 21-Nov-16 O Potts, David J East Coilleard Rhugarbh Appin Argyll PA38 4BA 31-Jul-17 O Wills, David P Kiloran Inverfolla Appin Argyll PA38 4BA 29-Nov-16 O Wills, David P Kiloran Inverfolla Appin Argyll PA38 4BA 05-Jun-17 O Wills, David P Kiloran Inverfolla Appin Argyll PA38 4BA 04-Aug-17 O Gray, David T 1 Valley View Place Falkirk FK2 7JB 24-Nov-16 O Feldwick, Daya 41 Burghlee Crescent Loanhead Midlothian 14-Feb-17 O Bruins, Debora LE4 3FA 29-Nov-16 O 8827 60th Dr NE Marysville Wahsington 98270 Glazener, Deborah 06-Dec-16 O USA Campbell, Deirdre 150 Erskinefauld Road Linwood 23-Nov-16 O Campbell, Deirdre 150 Erskinefauld Road Linwood 06-Jul-17 O No Surname, Denice No Address 09-Dec-16 O Macintyre, Denise PA34 4DH 28-Jun-17 O Archer, Dennis Springbank Tighnabruaich Argyll PA21 2EJ 06-Dec-16 O Davies, Dennis 7 Forties Road Houston PA6 7JP 07-Dec-16 O Mathieson, Denys Appin House Appin Argyll And Bute PA38 4BN 19-Jun-17 O Mathieson, Denys Appin House Appin Argyll And Bute PA38 4BN 26-Jul-17 O Stewart Amsden, Clachaig Dunmore Tarbert Argyll And Bute 09-Dec-16 O Derby PA29 6XZ Stewart Amsden, Clachaig Dunmore Tarbert Argyll And Bute 13-Jul-17 O Derby PA29 6XZ Mortimer, Derek 6 The Tail Race Maidstone Kent ME15 6YL 30-Nov-16 O Mortimer, Derek 6 The Tail Race Maidstone Kent ME15 6YL 07-Jul-17 O Stenhouse, Derek 12 Exhline Place South Queensferry 29-Nov-16 O No Surname, 06410 23-Nov-16 O Desvaux Upper Flat Morrishill Rockfield Road Oban Johnston, Diana 07-Dec-16 O Argyll And Bute PA34 5DH Upper Flat Morrishill Rockfield Road Oban Johnston, Diana 10-Jul-17 O Argyll And Bute PA34 5DH Campbell House Glen Loy Banavie Fort William Bettess, Diane 06-Dec-16 O PH33 7PD 2 Cruachan Buildings Lochawe Dalmally PA33 Elliott, Diane 30-Nov-16 O 1AJ 49 Jubilee Crescent Gorebridge Midlothian Erasmuson, Diane 09-Dec-16 O EH23 4XB The Old Manse Kilmartin Lochgilphead Argyll Roberts, Diane 28-Nov-16 O And Bute PA31 8RQ The Old Manse Kilmartin Lochgilphead Argyll Roberts, Diane 06-Jul-17 O And Bute PA31 8RQ Conquest Villa Conquest Drove Farcet Smith, Diane 01-Dec-16 O Peterborough Randle, Dianne 59 Central Ave Southend On Sea 28-Nov-16 O 110 Persimmon Dr Peregian Beach Queensland Breckenridge, Don 30-Nov-16 O 4573 Australia Carmichael, Donald Grianan Appin PA38 4BL 01-Dec-16 O Carmichael, Donald Grianan Appin PA38 4BL 13-Dec-16 O Dimock, Donald 543 Clay Street E Monmouth OR USA 30-Nov-16 O Forrest, Donald 2 St Brides Ave Newtonmore 06-Dec-16 O Craobh Chuilinn Appin Argyll And Bute PA38 Hutchison, Donald 08-Jun-17 O 4BA Lawrie, Donald No Address 23-Nov-16 O Maclean, Donald 7A Angus Terrace Oban PA34 4EG 23-Nov-16 O McLeod, Donald 9 Pulpit Road Oban Argyll And Bute PA34 4LF 21-Nov-16 O Duff, Donella No Address 01-Dec-16 O DuCarme, Donna The Hirsel Kincardine Hill Ardgay IV24 3DJ 01-Dec-16 O Croit Buidhe Croft Road Oban Argyll And Bute Smith, Donna 30-Nov-16 O PA34 5JN Hirt, Donna Rae 53 Clinton Place Newton Center MA 02459 09-Dec-16 O MacLeod, Doreen F 10 Shuna Terrace Oban Argyll And Bute PA34 29-Nov-16 O G 4YE Pincock, Dougie 1 View Auchtertyre 09-Dec-16 O Woodward, DRD Rhuvaal Road Oban 12-Dec-16 O Ferguson, Dugald 31 College Road Norwich NR2 3JW 13-Dec-16 O Ferguson, Duncan PA34 4BN 21-Nov-16 O Ardachy Albyn Drive Corpach For William PH33 Grout, Duncan 22-Nov-16 O 7LW Ardachy Albyn Drive Corpach For William PH33 Grout, Duncan 30-Jun-17 O 7LW Sofia, Dylan 51 Daws Lane Mill Hill NW7 4SD 22-Nov-16 O Silkowski, E Cruachan North Shian Appin Argyll PA38 4BA 30-May-17 O Thornton, E Dennistoun 12-Dec-16 O Potts, Eamonn 55 Lochside Road Dumfries 06-Dec-16 O April Cottage 7 Russell Street Wilton Salisbury Broadbent, Earle 12-Dec-16 O SP2 0BG April Cottage 7 Russell Street Wilton Salisbury Broadbent, Earle 30-Jun-17 O SP2 0BG Price, Edna Ben View Villa Road Oban 01-Dec-16 O Price, Edna Ben View Villa Road Oban 07-Jul-17 O Smith, Edward 1 The Drummonds Epping Essex CM16 4PJ 22-Nov-16 O Smith, Edward 1 The Drummonds Epping Essex CM16 4PJ 30-Jun-17 O Smith, Edward 1 The Drummonds Epping Essex CM16 4PJ 28-Jul-17 O Harrison, Edyth 28 Nant Y Felin Pentraeth Anglesey LL75 8UY 01-Dec-16 O Harrison, Edyth 28 Nant Y Felin Pentraeth Anglesey LL75 8UY 10-Jul-17 O Dempsey, Eileen 68 Fingal Street Glasgow G20 0LB 01-Dec-16 O Mcsween, Eileen 520 Anniesland Road Glasgow G13 1YB 22-Nov-16 O MacLennan, Eilidh 36 Nant Drive Oban PA34 4LA 22-Nov-16 O MacLennan, Eilidh 36 Nant Drive Oban PA34 4LA 30-Jun-17 O Baleveolan Isle Of Lismore Oban Argyll And Macnamara, Eilidh 01-Dec-16 O Bute PA34 5UG No Surname, Eilidh Baligrundle 4 Isle Of Lismore 22-Nov-16 O No Surname, Eilidh Oban 02-Dec-16 O No Surname, Eilidh PA37 1NZ 09-Dec-16 O Azzopardi, Elaine PA34 4LE 22-Nov-16 O Azzopardi, Elaine PA34 4LE 31-Jul-17 O Healy, Elaine 205 Hamilton Road Cambuslang 01-Dec-16 O Mackay, Elaine 16 Moorfoot Avenue Paisley PA2 8AF 24-Nov-16 O Dungrianach Crannaig-a-Mhinister Oban Argyll Robertson, Elaine 12-Jan-17 O PA34 4LU 5 Cnoc Beag Balvicar Isle Of Seil Oban Argyll Rodger, Elaine 12-Dec-16 O And Bute PA34 4TH Starkey, Elayne Ariogan House Oban 24-Nov-16 O Wharf Farmhouse Wisborough Green West Bell, Eleanor 28-Nov-16 O Sussex RH1 40JG Porter, Eleanor The Strone Blairgowrie Road Dunkeld PH8 0EP 05-Dec-16 O Mochner, Elisabeth Germany 29-Nov-16 O Cooney, Elizabeth 39 Tooting Bec Gardens SW16 1RE 15-Dec-16 O Denholm, Elizabeth 86 Capelrig Drive East Kilbirde G74 3BZ 01-Dec-16 O Finlayson, Elizabeth 1 Easter Powside Almondbank Perth PH1 3NF 14-Dec-16 O Gunning, Elizabeth 6 Dolbeare Road Ashburton Devon TQ13 7As 07-Dec-16 O Marshall, Elizabeth 7 Overtoun Road Irvine Ayrshire 07-Dec-16 O McDougall, 23 Lorn Road Dunbeg Oban Argyll And Bute 29-Nov-16 O Elizabeth PA37 1QG Shephard, Elizabeth Lakefield Taynuilt Argyll And Bute PA35 1JW 30-Nov-16 O Duran, Ella M41 8UL 22-Nov-16 O Boyd, Ellie 3241 NE 95th Street Seattle WA 98115 29-Mar-17 O 43 High Street Westbury On Trym Bristol BS9 Soakell, Ellie 01-Dec-16 O 3ED Morrison, Elliot Rehoboth 3 Creran Gardens Oban PA34 4JU 14-Dec-16 O Morrison, Elliot Rehoboth 3 Creran Gardens Oban PA34 4JU 14-Jul-17 O Morrison, Elliot Rehoboth 3 Creran Gardens Oban PA34 4JU 04-Aug-17 O New Selma Benderloch Oban Argyll And Bute Jones, Elwyn 24-Nov-16 O PA37 1QP Miller, Emily BB2 6LB 30-Nov-16 O Gardiner, Emma Cocklaw Biggar ML12 6RD 23-Nov-16 O Gardiner, Emma Cocklaw Biggar ML12 6RD 06-Jul-17 O No Surname, Emma Rillside Pantersbridge Mount Bodwin Cornwall 06-Dec-16 O Scobie, Emma 4 Kiel Crofts Benderloch PA37 1QS 07-Dec-16 O Scobie, Emma 4 Kiel Crofts Benderloch PA37 1QS 10-Jul-17 O 39 Aldersyde Taynuilt Argyll And Bute PA35 Thomas, Emma 30-Nov-16 O 1AG Breadalbane Street Oban Argyll And Darcy, Emma 23-Nov-16 R Bute PA34 5PA Mclaughlin, Emmet BT48 8DH 28-Nov-16 O Taher, Emmie 22 Hamilton Avenue Glasgow G41 4JF 28-Nov-16 O Fyfe, Eoin 15 Loch Eilde Road Kinlochleven PH50 4RH 11-Jul-17 O 21 Creag An Airm Oban Argyll And Bute PA34 McGinty, Eoin 24-Nov-16 O 4BX 21 Creag An Airm Oban Argyll And Bute PA34 McGinty, Eoin 13-Jul-17 O 4BX Macarthur, Eric 108 Cotton Street Castle Douglas DG7 1AN 30-Nov-16 O Macarthur, Eric 108 Cotton Street Castle Douglas DG7 1AN 12-Jun-17 O Macarthur, Eric 108 Cotton Street Castle Douglas DG7 1AN 27-Jul-17 O 5 Ganavan Sands Oban Argyll And Bute PA34 Walton, Eric 12-Dec-16 O 5TB 21 Cygnet Close Ashington Northumberland Scales, Ernie 29-Nov-16 O NE63 0DF 21 Cygnet Close Ashington Northumberland Scales, Ernie 07-Jul-17 O NE63 0DF Meldrum, Euan Dunfraoch Taynuilt Argyll And Bute PA35 1JE 22-Nov-16 R Taher Montefiore, 22 Hamilton Avenue Glasgow G41 4JR 28-Nov-16 O Evine Taher Montefiore, 22 Hamilton Avenue Glasgow G41 4JR 31-Jul-17 O Evine MacLellan, Ewan Blackmount Bridge Of Orchy Argyll PA36 4AH 23-Nov-16 O Peat, Ewan Dalleagles Cumnock KA18 4QR 07-Dec-16 O Peat, Ewan Dalleagles Cumnock KA18 4QR 10-Jul-17 O Binnie, F Cairneyhill 24-Jan-17 O 5 Clachandubh Cottages Balvicar Isle Of Seil MacNaught, F 28-Nov-16 O Oban Argyll And Bute PA34 4GH Richardson, F WF4 2NP 30-Jun-17 O Burnbrae Portnacroish Appin Argyll And Bute Gray, Fabia 29-Nov-16 O PA38 4BB Pentleugh Fasnacloich Appin Argyll And Bute Bunge, Fedor 30-Nov-16 O PA38 4BJ Pentleugh Fasnacloich Appin Argyll And Bute Bunge, Fedor 10-Jul-17 O PA38 4BJ No Surname, Fee No Address 07-Dec-16 O Anderson, Fiona 1 Raglan Street Lane Alexandria G83 9JD 06-Dec-16 O Bell, Fiona 32 Dunterlie Avenue Glasgow G13 3BA 23-Nov-16 O Campbell Hall, Fiona Linnhe View Kentallen PA38 4BU 14-Dec-16 O Campbell, Fiona Taigh A Bhalachain Airds Bay Taynuilt 08-Dec-16 O Church-Michael, Aros Station Road Buchlyvie 16-Jan-17 O Fiona Craig, Fiona 90 Mastrick Drive Aberdeen AB16 6UJ 12-Dec-16 O North Shian Ferry House Appin Argyll And Bute Fleming, Fiona 19-Jun-17 O PA38 4BA Hunter, Fiona Rosebank Appin 21-Nov-16 O Hunter, Fiona Rosebank Appin 30-Jun-17 O Hunter, Fiona Rosebank Appin 28-Jul-17 O Hutchison, Fiona Blarchasgaig Appin Argyll PA38 4BG 22-Nov-16 O Hutton, Fiona Rockville Duror Appin PA38 4DA 08-Dec-16 O Hutton, Fiona Rockville Duror Appin PA38 4DA 11-Jul-17 O Landale, Fiona Berandhu Appin PA38 4DD 31-Jul-17 O McNeill, Fiona 41 Dowland Close Swindon 30-Nov-16 O Stage, Fiona PA34 5DJ 13-Dec-16 O Walton, Fiona Dalvreck Cottages PH7 4JN 12-Dec-16 O Walton, Fiona Dalvreck Cottages PH7 4JN 17-Jul-17 O Herder Wynne, Ichrechan House Taynuilt 30-Nov-16 O Fionnuala Creran Cottage Benderloch Oban Argyll And Gilkes, Florence 08-Dec-16 O Bute PA37 1SD Creran Cottage Benderloch Oban Argyll And Gilkes, Florence 11-Jul-17 O Bute PA37 1SD No Surname, Coatbridge 25-Nov-16 O Frances No Surname, Via S Carlo 410 29-Nov-16 O Francesca Laverty, Frank Flat 12/F 154 Broomhill Drive Glasgow G11 7NF 01-Dec-16 O Williams, Fraser 6 Elliot Road Dundee DD2 1TB 07-Dec-16 O Williams, Fraser 6 Elliot Road Dundee DD2 1TB 10-Jul-17 O Bristoe Linn, G Fosghail Duror Appin PA38 4DA 30-Nov-16 O Bristoe Linn, G Fosghail Duror Appin PA38 4DA 06-Jul-17 O Fairbairn, G Shian Bay Appin Argyll And Bute PA38 4BA 12-Dec-16 O Mannion, G PH7 4BS 09-Dec-16 O 33 The Square Newtongrange Dalkeith EH22 O Boyle, Gail 07-Dec-16 O 4PW Duncan, Garth 38 Mayshade Road Loanhead EH20 9HJ 12-Dec-16 O Milne, Gaynor 38 Dryburgh Avenue Rutherglen G73 3EU 28-Nov-16 O Carter, Gemma 7 Ellaleen Grove Crossford KY12 8QQ 23-Nov-16 O Dunn, Gemma SA43 2BE 23-Nov-16 O Elizabeth Antcliff, Geoffrey 41 St Martons Terrace Camborne Cornwall 25-Nov-16 O Antcliff, Geoffrey 41 St Martons Terrace Camborne Cornwall 04-Jul-17 O Atkinson, Geoffrey Beech Cottage Drumoak AB31 5AL 09-Dec-16 O Atkinson, Geoffrey Beech Cottage Drumoak AB31 5AL 11-Jul-17 O Burton, George Ragstone 23 Kilhallon Par Cornwall 13-Jan-17 O Burton, George Ragstone 23 Kilhallon Par Cornwall 14-Jul-17 O Gilkes, George Creran Cottage Eriska Road Benderloch 08-Dec-16 O Gilkes, George Creran Cottage Eriska Road Benderloch 11-Jul-17 O 36 Lochnell Road Dunbeg Oban Argyll And Bute MacKenzie, George 28-Nov-16 O PA37 1QJ Windsor Aubrey, 69 Merville Road Stillorgan Co Dublin 28-Nov-16 O George Windsor Aubrey, 69 Merville Road Stillorgan Co Dublin 05-Jul-17 O George Mills, Georgia 23 B Picton Street Bristol BS8 3PG 02-Dec-16 O Thackeray, Georgina 13 Canal Close Louth LN11 0FH 06-Dec-16 O Comstive, Gerald Lockerbie Dumbriesshire DG11 1TJ 31-Jul-17 O John Dunn, Geraldine Glencrenan Church Fasnacloich PA38 4BJ 30-Nov-16 O Stevenson, Gerda EH26 9NF 28-Jun-17 O Stevenson, Gerda EH26 9NF 26-Jul-17 O Stevenson, Gerda The Rock Carlops By Penicuik EH26 9NF 12-Dec-16 O Stevenson, Gerda The Rock Carlops By Penicuik EH26 9NF 26-Jul-17 O Skeabost Old Ferry Road North Ballachulish Gilbert, Gerry 29-Nov-16 O PH33 6SA Skeabost Old Ferry Road North Ballachulish Gilbert, Gerry 07-Jul-17 O PH33 6SA Perring, Giles Knockrome Old School Isle Of Jura PA60 7XZ 01-Dec-16 O Milne, Gill Eliburn Livingston EH54 6TG 15-Dec-16 O MacCorquodale, Druim Na Moina Appin Argyll And Bute PA38 28-Nov-16 O Gillian 4BQ MacCorquodale, Druim Na Moina Appin Argyll And Bute PA38 13-Jul-17 O Gillian 4BQ Sinclair, Gillian 59 Mortonhall Gate Edinburgh EH16 6TJ 01-Dec-16 O Snedden, Gillian 10 Forfar Road Dundee DD4 7AR 30-Nov-16 O Patterson, Gladys 6 Schools Lane Dumbarton G82 4BP 01-Dec-16 O Patterson, Gladys 6 Schools Lane Dumbarton G82 4BP 10-Jul-17 O Dewar, Glynis 2 Underwood Longistan Road Oban PA34 5JW 14-Dec-16 O Dalnatraigh Airds Bay Taynuilt Argyll And Bute Service, GM 12-Dec-16 O PA35 1JR Dalnatraigh Airds Bay Taynuilt Argyll And Bute Service, GM 11-Jul-17 O PA35 1JR Abel, Gordon 46 Kype View ML10 6BX 06-Dec-16 O Brown, Gordon 189 Bon Accord Street Aberdeen 12-Dec-16 O Crichton, Gordon No Address 24-Nov-16 O McPhee, Gordon Oak View Findon Mill Culbokie IV7 8JJ 23-Nov-16 O Miller, Gordon Muiredge Farm Cottage Erroll Perth PH2 7RD 30-Nov-16 O Morrison, Gordon 27 John Burnside Drive G81 5DY 02-Dec-16 O Morrison, Gordon 27 John Burnside Drive G81 5DY 10-Jul-17 O Swinton, Gordon Glebe Cottage Arbroath 01-Dec-16 O Thomson, Gordon 15 Bennochy View Kirkcaldy KY2 5JD 11-Jul-17 O Bey, Grace 26 Hops Close Chilmark 01-Dec-16 O Dempsey, Graham 12 Holmpark Bishopton 01-Dec-16 O MacQueen, Graham Tigh A'Gharaidh Glencruitten Oban PA34 4QB 14-Dec-16 O MacQueen, Graham Tigh A'Gharaidh Glencruitten Oban PA34 4QB 10-Jul-17 O McLaughlan, Bearsden 22-Nov-16 O Graham Meek, Graham 6 Barassie East Kilbride Lanarkshire G74 4SD 22-Nov-16 O King, Graham P 1 Couston Street Dunfermline Fife KY12 7QW 12-Dec-16 O Addison, Grant 2 Longdale Crescent Oban 22-Nov-16 O Carter, Greg 7 Ellaleen Grove Crossford KY12 8QQ 28-Nov-16 O Carter, Greg 7 Ellaleen Grove Crossford KY12 8QQ 04-Jul-17 O MacKinnon, Gregor 3 Fearnoch Taynuilt PA35 1JB 06-Dec-16 O 31 Balmellie Road Turriff Aberdeenshire AB53 Wells, Gregor 06-Dec-16 O 4DP MacPherson, 9372 Goyetter Pl Santee CA 92071 USA 31-May-17 O Gregory Richards, Greig 2 Gavins Road Hardgate G81 6AA 22-Nov-16 O Singh, Gurvinder SW9 6HY 23-Nov-16 O Davies, Guy 3 Hempcroft Road Timperley WA15 7JN 06-Dec-16 O The Old Barn Coilleveneach Fasnacloich Appin Hawkins, Guy 14-Jul-17 O PA38 4BJ The Old Barn Coilleveneach Fasnacloich Appin Hawkins, Guy 31-Jul-17 O PA38 4BJ Gowie, Gwen 2 Hillcrest Place Aberdeen AB16 7BP 01-Dec-16 O Walne, Gwyneth 20 Henrietta Road Bath 30-Nov-16 O Adams, H Kilmoluag Appin Argyll And Bute PA38 4DD 12-Dec-16 O Ross, H 29 Church St SN10 4DU 07-Dec-16 O MacDougall, Hamish Woodhall Appin Argyll And Bute PA38 4BA 23-Jun-17 O MacDougall, Hamish Woodhall Appin Argyll And Bute PA38 4BA 26-Jul-17 O Kersley, Hannah PA34 4GZ 22-Nov-16 O Knowles, Hannah Marine View East Links Brae EH42 1GT 02-Dec-16 O No Surname, Banalog Farm Banalog Terrace Hollybush NP12 09-Dec-16 O Hannah 0SF Luke, Harriet No Address 07-Dec-16 O Luke, Harriet No Address 11-Jul-17 O 179 High Street Isle Of Bute Argyll Hutton, Harry 01-Dec-16 O And Bute PA20 9BS C/O Burness Paull Union Plaza 1 Union Wynd Wolfinger, Harvey 20-Dec-16 O Aberdeen AB10 1DQ C/O Burness Paull Union Plaza 1 Union Wynd Wolfinger, Harvey 22-Jun-17 O Aberdeen AB10 1DQ Wolfinger, Harvey Invercreran House Glen Creran Appin PA38 4BJ 26-May-17 O Wolfinger, Harvey Invercreran House Glen Creran Appin PA38 4BJ 30-May-17 O Wolfinger, Harvey Invercreran House Glen Creran Appin PA38 4BJ 31-May-17 O Wolfinger, Harvey Invercreran House Glen Creran Appin PA38 4BJ 20-Jul-17 O Wolfinger, Harvey Invercreran House Glen Creran Appin PA38 4BJ 27-Jul-17 O Invercreran Lodge Glen Creran Appin Argyll Kersley, Hayley 23-Nov-16 O PA38 4BJ Fallan, Hazel ML2 8RP 07-Dec-16 O Taylor, Hazel 32 Moorfield Road Portland Dorset DT5 1HJ 07-Dec-16 O North Shian Ferry House Appin Argyll And Bute Wager, Hazel 19-Jun-17 O PA38 4BA Warner, Hazel 19 Mid Street Keith 24-Nov-16 O 24 Greenways Crescent Bury St Edmunds Doggett, Heather 14-Dec-16 O Suffolk IP32 7JP 24 Greenways Crescent Bury St Edmunds Doggett, Heather 17-Jul-17 O Suffolk IP32 7JP Holmes, Heather 4 Cove Walk Cove Bay Aberdeen AB12 3DY 02-Dec-16 O Holmes, Heather 4 Cove Walk Cove Bay Aberdeen AB12 3DY 17-Jul-17 O MacLean, Heather Craig Cottage Appin Argyll PA38 4BB 23-Nov-16 O Tokyo Bag Locked Bag 40 Kingston ACT 2604 McIntyre, Heather 23-Nov-16 O Australia Morgan, Heather PO Box 1295 Frankfort KY 40602 29-May-17 O Morning, Heather Birch House Inshriach 29-Nov-16 O Millmailing Cottage Symington Biggar ML12 Petrie, Heather 09-Dec-16 O 6LW 446 Kilmarnock Road Newlands Glasgow G43 Urquhart, Heather 22-Nov-16 O 2RL White, Heather Wales 06-Dec-16 O Crawford, Hector 129 Auchmead Road Greenock PA16 0JN 08-Dec-16 O Allen, Heidi Spessartstr 88 63457 Hanau 01-Dec-16 O MacColl, Heidi 10A Dalintart Drive Oban 01-Dec-16 O MacColl, Heidi 10A Dalintart Drive Oban 07-Jul-17 O Galbraith, Heleh 53 Ash Grove Blackburn West Lothian EH4 7QJ 06-Dec-16 O Brough, Helen 9 Stratheden Place Auchtermuchty Fife 07-Dec-16 O Currie, Helen No Address Given 21-Jun-17 O Woodlands Barcaldine Oban Argyll And Bute Hope, Helen 24-Nov-16 O PA37 1SG Howie, Helen 5 Dol Elidir Llanberis Gwynedd LL55 4TN 06-Dec-16 O Lochnell Lodge Benderloch Oban Argyll And MacLucas, Helen 12-Dec-16 O Bute PA37 1QS Lochnell Lodge Benderloch Oban Argyll And MacLucas, Helen 13-Jul-17 O Bute PA37 1QS Skulina, Helen 201/8 Easter Road Edinburgh EH6 8LF 01-Dec-16 O Skulina, Helen 201/8 Easter Road Edinburgh EH6 8LF 07-Jul-17 O Thomson, Helena 96 White Cart Tower G74 2EF 06-Dec-16 O Thomson, Helena 96 White Cart Tower G74 2EF 10-Jul-17 O Newhall, Hilary 132 Walnut Avenue Weaverham CW8 3DX 07-Dec-16 O Sheasby, Holly 12 Bartram Gardens Gateshead NE8 4SJ 22-Nov-16 O Bell, Hugh 12 Rossie Woods DD10 9TS 08-Dec-16 O Noble, Hugh Cathedral Square Dunblane FGK15 0AH 07-Jun-17 O Silkowski, I Cruachan Appin Argyll And Bute PA38 4BA 13-Dec-16 O Taylor, I C 14 Greenbank Chester CH4 7EH 22-Nov-16 O Davidson, Iain Greenhaugh Court Braco FK15 9PS 11-Jul-17 O English, Iain Nethan Gate Hamilton 01-Dec-16 O 3 Benmore View North Connel Oban Argyll And Ferguson, Iain 02-Dec-16 O Bute PA37 1SN 3 Benmore View North Connel Oban Argyll And Ferguson, Iain 10-Jul-17 O Bute PA37 1SN MacEchern, Iain Gharadail Duror Of Appin Argyll PA38 4Bw 12-Dec-16 O MacEchern, Iain Gharadail Duror Of Appin Argyll PA38 4Bw 13-Jul-17 O Mackenzie, Iain 48 Park Way G67 2BU 01-Dec-16 O Dunvegan Port Appin Appin Argyll And Bute McNicol, Iain 02-Dec-16 O PA38 4DE Morrison, Iain 46 Road Kirkintilloch 02-Dec-16 O Muir, Iain PO Box 424 Huntly Victoria Australia 3551 01-Dec-16 O Wilson, Iain 4 Langlands Road Forfar DD8 1JU 09-Dec-16 O Boyd, Iain A Seo-nis Connel Argyll 23-Nov-16 O Campbell, Ian 23 Park Road PA34 4GZ 22-Nov-16 O Little, Ian Vanburgh Court Seaton Delaval Tyne And Wear 11-Jul-17 O MacInnes, Ian 17 Mossfield Drive Oban PA34 4EQ 23-Nov-16 O MacInnes, Ian 17 Mossfield Drive Oban PA34 4EQ 30-Jun-17 O McConnell, Ian Tigh Sonas Laroch Beag Ballachulish PH49 4LB 11-Jul-17 O 2 Firgrove Ardconnel Road Reid, Ian Oban 28-Nov-16 O Argyll And Bute PA34 5DW Ross, Ian Burnbank PH21 1JX 29-Nov-16 O Taylor, Ian 14 Greenbank Chester 09-Jan-17 O Taylor, Ian 14 Greenbank Chester 11-Jul-17 O Ward, Ian 1D Calside Court Paisley 08-Dec-16 O Ward, Ian 1D Calside Court Paisley 10-Jul-17 O 77A Puxton Drive Kidderminster Worcs DY11 McFarlane, Ian D 01-Dec-16 O 5HH Mian, Iftikar 256 Union Street Aberdeen AB10 1TP 09-Dec-16 O 26 Mossfield Drive Oban Argyll And Bute PA34 Anderton, 25-Nov-16 O 4EN Campbell, Iona PA35 1JW 24-Nov-16 O Macaulay, Iona FK1 4NZ 07-Dec-16 O Rennie, Iona Stockmans Cottage Aberdeen AB12 5YQ 24-Nov-16 O Rennie, Iona Stockmans Cottage Aberdeen AB12 5YQ 31-Jul-17 O McOmish, Irene 3 Royal Scot Way Dunfermline KY12 0PS 28-Nov-16 O Recesio, Irene Timalan Balsahan Hillsview Naic Cavite 12-Dec-16 R Arania Tirfuir Isle Of Lismore Oban Argyll And Bute No Surname, Iris 28-Nov-16 O PA34 5UL Blyth, Isabel Carnoch Taynuilt Argyll And Bute PA35 1HP 30-Nov-16 O Miller, Isla 333 Rue De Vaugirard 75015 Paris 23-Nov-16 O Gray, Isobel G76 8PU 28-Nov-16 O The Moorings Connel Oban Argyll And Bute Carss, J 28-Nov-16 O PA37 1PT Davies, J 11 Four Acres Drive Kilmaurs 06-Dec-16 O Wormell, J Askival Benderloch Oban PA37 1SA 16-Jan-17 O Wormell, J Askival Benderloch Oban PA37 1SA 17-Jul-17 O Grant, J. S. Burnbank Brocklet Ballachulish Argyll PA49 4JG 29-Nov-16 O No Surname, Jack 42 Longsdale Crescent Oban PA34 5JR 22-Nov-16 O Invercreran Lodge Fasnacloich Appin Argyll And Kesley, Jackie 12-Dec-16 O Bute PA38 4BJ Invercreran Lodge Fasnacloich Appin Argyll And Kesley, Jackie 30-Jun-17 O Bute PA38 4BJ Cumming, 2/1 141 Craigpark Drive Glasgow G31 2NU 01-Dec-16 O Jacqueline 54 Pitt Farm Park Homes Spy Post Wellington Kirwan, Jacqueline 12-Jan-17 O Somerset TA21 9PY Martin, Jacqueline 9D Colonsay Terrace Soroba Oban 24-Nov-16 O Pattinson, FK2 0BX 30-Nov-16 O Jacqueline Reynolds, Jacqueline 14 St Aubyns Road Lowestoft Suffolk NR33 0EG 01-Dec-16 O Anderson, James 224 High Street Linlithgow EH49 7ES 16-Jan-17 O 10 Soroba Road Oban Argyll And Bute PA34 Cameron, James 29-Nov-16 O 4HU Campbell, James Lamancha Old Banavie Road Fort William 29-Nov-16 O Colthart, James Tynribbie House Appin Argyll PA38 4DB 22-Nov-16 O Glass, James Ardtur House Port Appin PA38 4DD 08-Dec-16 O Haslam, James Tigh Na Crois Appin PA38 4BL 13-Dec-16 O Henry, James PA2 7EX 30-Nov-16 O Irvine, James 15 Meadowfield Crescent Scalloway 08-Dec-16 O Jenkinson, James 39 The Crescent Melton Mowbray LE13 0NF 24-Jan-17 O Lee, James 14 Church Street Oadby LE2 5DB 30-Nov-16 O Martin, James Pineapple House 07-Jun-17 O Martin, James Pineapple House Duror Nr Appin 28-Jun-17 O Robertson, James 8 Kirkton Appin Argyll 12-Dec-16 O Robertson, James 8 Kirkton Appin Argyll 11-Jul-17 O The Old Post Office 12A Douglas Square Rowan, James 09-Dec-16 O Newcastleton TD9 0QD The Granary Ledaig Oban Argyll And Bute PA37 Strang, James 24-Nov-16 O 1NY Lochridge, James C 21 Barrmill Road Glasgow G43 1EL 01-Dec-16 O Lamb, Jamie Beechwood Benderloch By Oban 09-Dec-16 O Provan, Jamie 14 Skaethorn Road G20 0TQ 02-Dec-16 O Sheasby, Jamie W5 2NX 23-Nov-16 O Fasnacloich House Fasnacloich Appin Argyll Smith, Jamie 06-Dec-16 O And Bute PA38 4BJ Smith, Jamie No Address Given 07-Jun-17 O Cowan, Jan Viewfield Armadale Thurso KW14 7SA 30-Jun-17 O Croxford, Jan 4 Old Railway Goods Yard Ballachulish 09-Dec-16 O Croxford, Jan 4 Old Railway Goods Yard Ballachulish 11-Jul-17 O Hamilton, Jan 25 Park Road Ballachulish PH49 4JS 30-Jun-17 O Wolfe, Jan 1 Whin Bank Clachan Seil 24-Jan-17 O Alexander, Jane Achnaba Cottage North Connel PA37 1RF 13-Jan-17 O Newdykes Farm Cottage Shawfarm Road Baird, Jane 30-Nov-16 O Prestwick KA9 1HE Barrington, Jane Failte Benderloch Argyll PA37 1QU 22-Nov-16 O Sheep Fank Cottage U25 Musdale Road East Of Kilmore From U18 To The Ford At Musdale Farm Darby, Jane 25-Nov-16 O Kilmore Argyll And Bute PA34 4XX Sheep Fank Cottage U25 Musdale Road East Of Kilmore From U18 To The Ford At Musdale Farm Darby, Jane 05-Jul-17 O Kilmore Argyll And Bute PA34 4XX Kershaw, Jane Oban 29-Nov-16 O Kershaw, Jane Oban 31-Jul-17 O Marsden, Jane Old Gartmore Road Drymen G63 0EA 01-Dec-16 O Nichols, Jane An Cala Benderloch Oban PA37 1QP 01-Dec-16 O Simons-Brown, Jane 22 The Heathery Dunfermline Fife KY11 8TS 30-Nov-16 O 126A Abercromby Avenue High Wycombe Wilkinson, Jane 13-Jan-17 O Bucks HP12 3BJ 126A Abercromby Avenue High Wycombe Wilkinson, Jane 14-Jul-17 O Bucks HP12 3BJ Willians, Jane Pintalia Appin Argyll And Bute PA38 4BA 01-Dec-16 O Lee, Janet F2 25 Cumberland Street Edinburgh EH3 6RT 12-Dec-16 O Lee, Janet Old Post Office Glencreran PA38 4BJ 17-Jul-17 O Lee, Janet Old Post Office Glencreran PA38 4BJ 26-Jul-17 O Corbie Lynn Benderloch Oban Argyll And Bute MacLeod, Janet 11-Jul-17 O PA37 1QP McColl, Janet 1038 Hooker Road Sequim WA 98382 26-May-17 O Turner, Janet Benderloch Oban PA37 1QS 12-Jan-17 O Borthwick, Janice Silverthorn Port Appin Argyll 12-Dec-16 O Borthwick, Janice Silverthorn Port Appin Argyll 14-Jul-17 O Forrest, Janice G21 2EB 09-Jan-17 O Hamilton, Janice EH48 4JT 08-Dec-16 O Hendry, Janice 6 Midbank Street Strathmiglo Fife KY14 7QU 07-Jul-17 O Lawson, Janice 4 Mossend Midlothian 07-Dec-16 O Honeyman, Jasmine Fishers Glen Argyll PA35 1HY 13-Dec-16 O Mahmoud, Jayne PA34 4QB 23-Nov-16 O Stevens, Jayne 102 Knighton Church Road Leicester LE2 3JH 06-Dec-16 O Stevens, Jayne 102 Knighton Church Road Leicester LE2 3JH 10-Jul-17 O Campbell, Jean Glasdrum Cottage Fasnacloich Appin PA38 4BJ 21-Nov-16 O Campbell, Jean Glasdrum Cottage Fasnacloich Appin PA38 4BJ 30-Jun-17 O Carfantan, Jean Vallee Heureuse 64110 Gelos France 01-Dec-16 O Docherty, Jean 5 Bogside Road Port Glasgow 01-Dec-16 O Fleming, Jean 01 140 Dalmarnock Road Glasgow G40 4DD 21-Nov-16 O Frew, Jean 89 High Road Stevenson KA20 3DZ 30-Nov-16 O Mccolm, Jean 2 Smith Field Cres Tarnbolton Ayr Ayrshire 06-Dec-16 O Ritchie, Jean 42 Jackson Street Penicuik EH26 9BJ 22-Feb-17 O Killean Farm Achnacroish Isle Of Lismore Oban Brooks, Jean Ellen 12-Dec-16 O Argyll And Bute PA34 5UG Newell, Jeanette Sunset View IV55 8GD 02-Dec-16 O Sheep Fank Cottage Kilmore Oban Argyll And Darby, Jeff 30-Nov-16 O Bute PA34 4XX Sheep Fank Cottage Kilmore Oban Argyll And Darby, Jeff 10-Jul-17 O Bute PA34 4XX Wimberley, Jenni 14 Echline Rigg South Queensberry EH30 9XN 09-Dec-16 O Ashford, Jennifer 5 Barwis Hill Penzance TR18 2AL 12-Dec-16 O Ashford, Jennifer 5 Barwis Hill Penzance TR18 2AL 13-Jul-17 O Burnside Cottage Corpach Fort William PH33 Ford, Jennifer 12-Dec-16 O 7LT Burnside Cottage Corpach Fort William PH33 Ford, Jennifer 11-Jul-17 O 7LT Gill, Jennifer 16329 Swartz Canyon Rd Ramona Ca. 92065 31-May-17 O Robertson, Jennifer 3 Pentland Villas Edinburgh EH14 5EQ 12-Dec-16 O Cheesman, Jenny 27 Ash Tree Grove Leeds LS25 7QA 16-Jan-17 O Hill, Jenny 42 Langsdale Crescent Oban 25-Nov-16 O Macdonald, Jenny 1 London Avenue Glasgow G40 3HR 06-Dec-16 O Macdonald, Jenny 1 London Avenue Glasgow G40 3HR 11-Jul-17 O Law, Jeremy 3000 Leuven Belgium 02-Jun-17 O Smith, Jess Coishavachan Invergeldie Glen Lednock 09-Dec-16 O Barulis, Jessica CO6 1UJ 22-Nov-16 O Brettle, Jessica 1/16 Salmond Place Edinburgh EH7 5ST 12-Dec-16 O Allaway, Jessie The Mill Farm Barcaldine Argyll 30-Nov-16 O Allaway, Jessie The Mill Farm Barcaldine Argyll 07-Jul-17 O Wilson, Jessie 10 Lorne Walk St Anns Nottingham NG3 4FX 06-Dec-16 O Sherpa, Jill 24 Bradfield Avenue G12 0QA 28-Nov-16 O Drim Na Vullin Blarbuie Road Lochgilphead Byatt, Jilly 12-Dec-16 O Argyll And Bute PA31 8LE Downie, Jim 75 Fergushill Kilwinning KA13 7LW 30-Nov-16 O Downie, Jim 75 Fergushill Kilwinning KA13 7LW 06-Jul-17 O Lynch, Jim 8 Balvicar Road Oban PA34 4RP 26-Jul-17 O Lianaig Barcaldine Oban Argyll And Bute PA37 MacKay, Jim 28-Nov-16 O 1SG Lianaig Barcaldine Oban Argyll And Bute PA37 MacKay, Jim 04-Jul-17 O 1SG McKinlay, Jim 5 Heatherlee Court Kinlochleven 17-Jul-17 O Montgomery, Jim EH45 8EZ 05-Dec-16 O Scott, Jim 3 Cuttyfield Place Carronshore Falkirk FK2 8TA 09-Dec-16 O The Bush, Jimmy 15 Albert Road Ballachulish PH49 4JR 11-Jul-17 O James, Jo Auchentrail PA10 7NW 23-Nov-16 O Roberts, Joan 58 Burnbrae Road 16-Feb-17 R Garvin, Joanie Greencourt Benvoullin Road Oban PAA34 5EF 16-Jan-17 O Gosling, Joanna PA34 5JA 12-Dec-16 O Hogg, Joanna 27 Linden Lea Brookslands Road Sale M33 3 GL 28-Nov-16 O Service, Joanna No Address 12-Dec-16 O Medhurst, Joanne 135 Russell Road RG14 5JY 23-Nov-16 O Ward, Jocelyn 1 Cawdor Place Nairn IV12 4QE 28-Nov-16 O Hithersay, Joe 16 Coniston Way GU52 6RS 09-Dec-16 O Mccann, Joe BT63 5YL 01-Dec-16 O 3 Glenbervie Road Grangemouth Stirlingshire Russell, Joe 06-Dec-16 O FK3 9LE Gordon, Johanna 58 Mameulah Road Newmachar AB21 0WW 08-Dec-16 O Baird, John 60 Kirkcaldy Road Glasgow G41 4LD 30-Jan-17 O Barrington, John Failte Benderloch Connel PA37 1QU 30-Jun-17 O Burton, John 15B Dalintart Drive Oban Argyll PA34 4EE 07-Dec-16 O Camus Port Appin Appin Argyll And Bute PA38 Connolly, John 12-Dec-16 O 4DE Docherty, John Novar Ardconnel Terrace Oban PA34 5DJ 14-Dec-16 O 16/22 Market Hall Victorian Market Inverness Finnie, John 01-Dec-16 O IV1 1PJ Fullerton, John 8 Lawrence Street Glasgow G11 5HQ 12-Dec-16 O Siskin Barcaldine Oban Argyll And Bute PA37 Gosling, John 30-Nov-16 O 1SG Craigellachie 1 Keil Crofts Benderloch Oban Grant, John 21-Nov-16 O PA37 1QS Holms, John 57 Falcon Court Edinburgh 07-Dec-16 O Holms, John 57 Falcon Court Edinburgh 11-Jul-17 O Howieson, John Glen Critten Oban 01-Dec-16 O Landale, John Berandhu Appin PA38 4DD 31-Jul-17 O MacDonald, John PAr44YD 23-Nov-16 O Macfarlane, John Tighnambarr Taynuilt Argyll And Bute PA35 1JQ 09-Dec-16 O Macfarlane, John Tighnambarr Taynuilt Argyll And Bute PA35 1JQ 10-Jul-17 O Macfarlane, John Tighnambarr Taynuilt Argyll And Bute PA35 1JQ 01-Aug-17 O 1/1 Sunnybank Lower London Road Edinburgh Mcillaney, John 06-Dec-16 O EH7 5TL Meredith, John 3 Long Close Quern LE12 1TS 30-Nov-16 O Hard Bank Croft Hard Bank How Mill Brampton Rayworth, John 22-Nov-16 O Cumbria CA8 9LL Reddington, John 27 Gresley Close Welwyn Garden City Herts 07-Dec-16 O Renton, John Walden Place Gifford 01-Dec-16 O Russell, John 41 Caledonian Court Falkirk 28-Jun-17 O Russell, John 41 Caledonian Court Falkirk 31-Jul-17 O George Street Fish And Chip Shop 13 - 15 Stewart, John 02-Dec-16 O George Street Oban Argyll And Bute PA34 5RU The Skerries Port Appin Appin Argyll And Bute Tricker, John 06-Dec-16 O PA38 4DE Tudor, John 11/1 Murdoch Terrace Edinburgh EH11 1BE 06-Dec-16 O Wade, John Ben Rhu Duror 30-Nov-16 O Young, John Livingston EH54 9HB 01-Aug-17 O Russell, John 41 Caledonian Court Falkirk 23-Feb-17 Llewellyn, Jojo Limerick Cottage Gower Swansea SA3 2EQ 07-Dec-16 O 4 The Greens Glencruitten Road Oban PA34 Wood, Jon 22-Nov-16 O 4DD High Sykehouse Church Street Broughton In Stockton, Jonathan 12-Jun-17 O Furness Cumbria LA20 6ER Coventry, Jonny EH7 5EH 11-Jul-17 O Guitart, Jordi 15 Pettis Road St Ives Cambs PE27 6SR 30-Nov-16 O Finch, Joseph Pottery House Tanygroes SA43 2HR 22-Nov-16 O Finch, Joseph Pottery House Tanygroes SA43 2HR 31-Jul-17 O Shonkwiler, Joseph 99 Sheephill Road Riverside CT 06878 23-Nov-16 O Gannon, Josephine No Address Given 12-Dec-16 O Macdonald, Appin Lodge Appin PA38 4BN 01-Dec-16 O Josephine Macdonald, Appin Lodge Appin PA38 4BN 07-Jul-17 O Josephine McGuire, Josephine 15 Gladney Avenue Glasgow G13 4JB 02-Dec-16 O Shore Lane House Corpach Fort William PH33 Biggin, Joy 16-Jan-17 O 7JJ Blakeney, Joy Moss Croft Benderloch PA37 1QU 14-Dec-16 O Hendry, Joy 4 Broughton Place Edinburgh 12-Dec-16 O Hendry, Joy 4 Broughton Place Edinburgh 17-Jul-17 O Chessum, Joyce 34 Central Avenue Troon KA10 7AZ 28-Jun-17 O Hall, Joyce Tahsis Kilmore Oban Argyll And Bute PA34 4XX 01-Dec-16 O Harkin, Joyce 8 Heather Avenue Hardgate G81 6LH 07-Dec-16 O Noble, Joyce Cathedral Square Dunblane FGK15 0AH 07-Jun-17 O Chessum, Joyce 34 Central Ave Troon KA10 7AZ 01-Dec-16 O Lennox Bradbury, Judith 9 Bankside Avenue Uppermill Oldham 30-Nov-16 O Bradbury, Judith 9 Bankside Avenue Uppermill Oldham 06-Jul-17 O Halliday, Judith 14 Lilac Court Keynsham Bristol 06-Dec-16 O Lowe, Judith Tigh-A-Churrak Kentallen Appin 30-Nov-16 O Standing, Judith 22 Middleton Road Kidderminster DY11 5EY 07-Dec-16 O Druimneil Cottage Port Appin Appin Argyll And Williamson, Judith 24-Nov-16 O Bute PA38 4DQ Druimneil Cottage Port Appin Appin Argyll And Williamson, Judith 04-Jul-17 O Bute PA38 4DQ Witts, Judith Drimfern Inveraray Argyll And Bute PA32 8XJ 29-Nov-16 O Witts, Judith Drimfern Inveraray Argyll And Bute PA32 8XJ 06-Jul-17 O Koslowski, Julene 6841 Raven Road Vernon British Columbia 06-Dec-16 R Francis, Julia 5 Hillrise Wrexham 07-Dec-16 O Richmond, Julia 86 Rang 8 Marston Quebec Canada 09-Dec-16 O Richmond, Julia 86 Rang 8 Marston Quebec Canada 11-Jul-17 O The Boathouse Lochnell Estate Benderloch Allan, Julie 01-Dec-16 O Oban PA37 1QT Armstrong, Julie 14 William Close Thatcham Berkshire 07-Dec-16 O Chrisite, Julie Well Road Rosemarkie IV10 8UW 11-Jul-17 O Cordiner, Julie Cedar Hill CT3 1UR 06-Dec-16 O Gamble, Julie G68 9AH 09-Dec-16 O Gove, Julie PA34 4UX 22-Nov-16 O Leverton, Julie 7 Torry Drive Alva FK12 5NQ 24-Jan-17 O Leverton, Julie 7 Torry Drive Alva FK12 5NQ 10-Jul-17 O Mahar, Julie 15805 Cumberland Dr Poway Ca 92064 29-May-17 O McKenzie, Julie 37 Creag Bhan Village Oban Argyll PA34 4BF 06-Dec-16 O Ruddock, Julie PA35 1HZ 23-Nov-16 O Turner, Julie 4 Halesden Road SK4 5EF 25-Nov-16 O C/o Markham And Frogatt 4 Windmill Street Stevens, Juliet 12-Dec-16 O London WiT 1AA Brodie, Juline 52 Wilson Drive Outwood Wakefield WF1 3DN 06-Dec-16 O Brodie, Juline 52 Wilson Drive Outwood Wakefield WF1 3DN 30-Jun-17 O Achnacroibh Kilchrenan Taynuilt Argyll And Raven, June 02-Dec-16 O Bute PA35 1HD Smith, June Blairadam By Kelty Fife KY4 0JG 07-Dec-16 O Smith, June Blairadam By Kelty Fife KY4 0JG 31-Jul-17 O Thomson, June 2 Seagate Montrose DD10 8BA 06-Dec-16 O Cramer, Jurairat No Address 28-Nov-16 O 8 Kirkton Tynribbie Appin Argyll And Bute PA38 Robertson, Justine 12-Dec-16 O 4DL Lawrence, K 4 Castleton Road Auchterarder Perthshire 09-Dec-16 O 16 Letter Daill Cairnbaan Lochgilphead Argyll MacKay, K 17-Jul-17 O And Bute PA31 8SX Cowieson, K R 41 Well Way Porth Cornwall TR7 3LS 29-Nov-16 O Moore, Kaireen 13 Corran Brae Dunollie PA34 5AJ 14-Jul-17 O Owen, Kara 15 Keston Road SE15 4JA 28-Nov-16 O Blackburn, Karen 43 Lochside Crescent Montrose DD10 9BF 08-Dec-16 O Dauner, Karen 109 Jackson Road Hopewell Junction New York 01-Dec-16 O Derrick, Karen 31 Strathspey Drive Grantown PH26 3EY 22-Nov-16 O Francis, Karen 1 Printonan Duns TD11 3HX 01-Dec-16 O MacLeod, Karen 11A New Garrabost HS2 0PL 01-Dec-16 O MacLeod, Karen PA34 4YN 24-Nov-16 O No Surname, Karen No Address Given 01-Dec-16 O An Tobar Argyll Terrace Tobermory Isle Of Mull Ray, Karen 28-Nov-16 O Argyll And Bute PA75 6PB An Tobar Argyll Terrace Tobermory Isle Of Mull Ray, Karen 04-Jul-17 O Argyll And Bute PA75 6PB Speake, Karen 87 Aros Drive Glasgow G52 1TN 28-Nov-16 O Rosemount Soroba Road Oban Argyll And Bute MacLean, Karma 22-Nov-16 O PA34 4JJ Rhugarbh Church Barcaldine Oban Argyll And Anderson, Kate 19-Jun-17 O Bute PA37 1SE Blair, Kate G12 0SD 22-Nov-16 O MacCallum, Kate 4 Etive Gardens Oban Argyll And Bute PA34 4JP 10-Jul-17 O Mackay, Kate 47 The Crosspath Radlet Herts WD7 8HP 30-Jun-17 O Mason, Kate 30 Melrose Ave Sutton Coldfield 01-Dec-16 O No Surname, Kate 32 Weidner Road Newcastle NE15 6QQ 06-Dec-16 O Rennie, Kate C/o Tigh An Tuim Benderloch 24-Nov-16 O 7A The Gables London Road Whitchurch RG28 Donaldson, Kath 30-Nov-16 O 7NH 7A The Gables London Road Whitchurch RG28 Donaldson, Kath 05-Jul-17 O 7NH Emsden, Katharine P O Box 907 La Veta Colorado 81055 USA 13-Dec-16 O Cameron, Kathleen Oak Cottage Fort William PH33 6SD 12-Dec-16 O Cameron, Kathleen Oak Cottage Onich Fort William PH33 6SD 13-Jul-17 O De Mengel, No Address 07-Dec-16 O Kathleen MacCallum, Innesdale 4 Etive Gardens Oban Argyll And 07-Dec-16 O Kathleen Bute PA34 4JP McColl, Kathleen 92026 Escondidio California 05-Jun-17 O Murgatroyd, 41 Achlonan Taynuilt PA35 1JJ 23-Nov-16 O Kathleen Murgatroyd, 41 Achlonan Taynuilt PA35 1JJ 04-Jul-17 O Kathleen Sinclair, Kathleen 41 Rustington Road Brighton BN1 8DQ 01-Dec-16 O Wegener, Kathleen 9112 Fletcher Drive La Mesa CA 91941 30-May-17 O Wallace Hindle, Kathryn Strathlael Ullapool IV23 2RS 01-Dec-16 O 52 Lorn Road Dunbeg Oban Argyll And Bute MacIntyre, Kathryn 29-Nov-16 O PA37 1QQ Beattie, Kathy Appin Cottage Appin Argyll PA38 4BN 23-Nov-16 O Lindner, Kathy P.O.Box 2 Litchfield CA 96117 USA 14-Dec-16 O Lindner, Kathy P.O.Box 2 Litchfield CA 96117 USA 14-Jul-17 O 16 Tarbert Avenue West Kilbride Ayrshire KA23 Kean, Katie 09-Dec-16 O 9DL 16 Tarbert Avenue West Kilbride Ayrshire KA23 Kean, Katie 11-Jul-17 O 9DL No Surname, Katie 7 Midway AB30 1DW 01-Dec-16 O No Surname, Katie EH8 9PU 12-Dec-16 O Scott, Katrina 7 Balgray Crescent Barrhead Glasgow G78 2NE 07-Dec-16 O Scott, Katrina 7 Balgray Crescent Barrhead Glasgow G78 2NE 11-Jul-17 O Clova Barran Kilmore Oban Argyll And Bute Pollock, Katy 23-Nov-16 O PA34 4XR Offord, Kay 14 Blackberry Way Red Lodge 11-Jul-17 O Carmichael, Keith Laich House Appin Argyll And Bute PA38 4DD 09-Dec-16 O Tigh A Ghlinne Glenshellach Road Oban Argyll Miller, Keith 30-Nov-16 O And Bute PA34 4PP Tigh A Ghlinne Glenshellach Road Oban Argyll Miller, Keith 06-Jul-17 O And Bute PA34 4PP Page, Keith 40 Killerton Road Ex23 8EN 22-Nov-16 O Thomson, Kelli 6 Glendoune Street Girvan KA26 0AB 01-Dec-16 O Shearer, Kelly 3/1 23 Marwick Street Glasgow G31 3NF 24-Nov-16 O Cockburn, Ken 12/2 Great Michael Rise Edinburgh EH6 4JB 16-Feb-17 O Lawrence, Kendra 9 Kirkton Appin PA38 4DL 27-Mar-17 O Lawrence, Kendra 9 Kirkton Appin PA38 4DL 26-Jul-17 O Allaway, Kenneth Mill Farm Barcaldine PA37 1SE 29-May-17 O Cunningham, 12 Mill Road Hamilton 06-Dec-16 O Kenneth MacTaggart, 28 Broadstone Park Inverness IV2 3LA 12-Dec-16 O Kenneth Scott, Kenneth Lochvoil House Dunuaran Road Oban PA34 4NE 16-Jan-17 O

Scott, Kenneth Lochvoil House Dunuaran Road Oban PA34 4NE 14-Jul-17 O

Lloyd, Kenny 27 Norway Street Portslade East Sussex 01-Dec-16 O Scott, Kerrie 17 The Glebe Twynholm DG6 4NZ 06-Dec-16 O Jenkinson, Kerry 39 The Crescent Melton Mowbray LE13 0NF 30-Nov-16 O McSween, Kerry 27 Alderman Road Glasgow G13 3YF 25-Nov-16 O Anderson, Kevin EH3 9LN 12-Dec-16 O Flat B 15 Dalintart Drive Oban Argyll And Bute Burton, Kevin 30-Nov-16 O PA34 4EE Crofts, Kevin 32A Moncrieff Avenue Glasgow G66 4NJ 21-Nov-16 O Derrick, Kevin 9 Boswell Crescent Inverness IV2 3ET 01-Dec-16 O Howett, Kevin Buddleia Cottage Gwydyr Road Crieff PH7 4BS 13-Jul-17 O Vallely, Kevin 77 Drumcairn Road Ard Mhacha BT61 8DWQ 01-Dec-16 O Anderson, Kieran KY2 5UA 01-Dec-16 O Turner, Kieran Liberty Croft Turriff AB53 5QL 30-Nov-16 O Green, Kieron Flat 1 49C Combie Street Oban 13-Dec-16 O No Surname, Kieron 40 Roberts Gate Lofthouse WF3 3PZ 01-Dec-16 O MacColl, Kiki Barrmor Cottage Isle Of Lismore PA34 5UH 24-Nov-16 O Craig, Kim Colyne Farmhouse Corse Huntly 01-Dec-16 O , Kimberley 2/2 58 Brownhill Road G43 2AE 24-Nov-16 O Bell, Kirsteen Fort William 09-Dec-16 O 12 Hazeldean Crescent Oban Argyll And Bute Smith, Kirstie 22-Nov-16 O PA34 5JT 64 Springfield View South Queensferry EH30 Knowles, Kirsty 30-Nov-16 O 9UZ Macdonald, Kirsty 8 Iona Drive Oban Argyll And Bute PA34 5AR 22-Nov-16 O 64 Lorn Road Dunbeg Oban Argyll And Bute Moore, Kirsty 10-Jul-17 O PA37 1QQ Roed, Kirsty Nordre Strandvei 61 3145 Tjome Norway 23-Nov-16 O Lambo, Krista Chicago IL 23-Nov-16 O 9 Sinclair Avenue Inveraray Argyll And Bute Renton, Kyle 01-Dec-16 O PA32 8UL Slind, Kyrre Briar Cottage Main Street West Lothian 12-Dec-16 O Silkowski, L Cruachan North Shian Appin Argyll PA38 4BA 30-May-17 O Silkowski, L Cruachan Appan Argyll 13-Dec-16 O 9 Riverside Road Kinlochleven Argyll Highlands Minnis, Lachlan 06-Dec-16 O PH50 4QH 11 Strumore Lochmaddy Isle Of HS6 MacLeod, Lachlan M 14-Dec-16 O 5AG 11 Strumore Lochmaddy Isle Of North Uist HS6 MacLeod, Lachlan M 14-Jul-17 O 5AG Mcgillivray, Lamont PA34 5UL 23-Nov-16 O Suil Na Mara Isle Of Lismore Oban Argyll And Cook, Laura 24-Nov-16 O Bute PA34 5UG Gunn, Laura KA24 4DU 14-Dec-16 O McSween, Laura G23 5SW 24-Nov-16 O Murphy, Laura PA34 4DQ 23-Nov-16 O No Surname, Laura No Address 02-Dec-16 O Ralston, Laura 9 Barnwell Mews Stirling FK9 5HB 22-Feb-17 O Boag, Lauren 23 Victoria Park Drive North Glasgow G14 9NH 01-Dec-16 O Boag, Lauren 23 Victoria Park Drive North Glasgow G14 9NH 06-Jul-17 O 7 Kilmartin Court Shore Street Oban Argyll And Jacobs, Laurie 07-Dec-16 O Bute PA34 4NT No Surname, 12 Northbourne Avenue Morpeth NE61 1JG 22-Nov-16 O Leanme Ichrachan House Taynuilt Argyll And Bute PA35 Irwin, Leanne 30-Nov-16 O 1HP 27 Haddon Road Bridlington East Yorkshire Wilson, Leanne 23-Nov-16 O YO16 6EU 40 Symington Way Market Harborough LE16 Allatson, Lee 30-Nov-16 O 7XA 40 Symington Way Market Harborough LE16 Allatson, Lee 06-Jul-17 O 7XA 27 Mossfield Drive Oban Argyll And Bute PA34 McKillop, Lee 21-Nov-16 O 4EN Gemmell, Leigh PA34 4ED 23-Nov-16 O Cmelakova, Lenka No Address 06-Dec-16 O Signal House Ganavan Road Oban Argyll And Faccenda, Leo 24-Nov-16 O Bute PA34 5TU Signal House Ganavan Road Oban Argyll And Faccenda, Leo 05-Jul-17 O Bute PA34 5TU 49 Lochnell Road Dunbeg Oban Argyll And Bute Fraser, Lesley 29-Nov-16 O PA37 1QJ 49 Lochnell Road Dunbeg Oban Argyll And Bute Fraser, Lesley 05-Jul-17 O PA37 1QJ Larsen, Lesley No Address 06-Dec-16 O McGinty, Lesley 17 Denbeath Court Ferniegair ML3 7TR 24-Nov-16 O Pinnelli, Lesley Osprey Drive G71 6HZ 02-Dec-16 O C/O Burness Paull Union Plaza 1 Union Wynd Wolfinger, Lesley 20-Dec-16 O Aberdeen AB10 1DQ C/O Burness Paull Union Plaza 1 Union Wynd Wolfinger, Lesley 22-Jun-17 O Aberdeen AB10 1DQ Towler, Leslie 20 Donview Road 07-Dec-16 O Towler, Leslie 20 Donview Road 10-Jul-17 O 3 Brockholes Farm Cottages Grantshouse TD11 No Surname, Lia 30-Nov-16 O 3RL Roberts, Liam 6 Ach An Duin Benerrloch 30-Nov-16 O Jamieson, Libby 151 Newdyke Road G66 2EL 01-Dec-16 O Jamieson, Libby 151 Newdyke Road G66 2EL 07-Jul-17 O Kenta, Lillace Kirribilli Australia 23-Nov-16 O Beynon, Linda 75 Leicester Road Fleckney LE8 8BG 30-Nov-16 O Bradshaw Wood, Dyffryn Bach Dihewyd Lampter Wales SA48 07-Dec-16 O Linda 7PN Bremner, Linda 21 Woodside Farm Drive Inverness IV2 5TD 22-Nov-16 O Corbett, Linda 9 Haygate Avenue Brightons Falkirk FK2 0TL 01-Dec-16 O Currie, Linda Dungraftin Balcaldine Argyll 23-Nov-16 O Currie, Linda Dungraftin Balcaldine Argyll 06-Jul-17 O Ferguson, Linda Beauly Duror Of Appin PA38 4BS 12-Jun-17 O Willow Cottage Mossfield Avenue Oban Argyll Fraser, Linda 30-Nov-16 O And Bute PA34 4EL Willow Cottage Mossfield Avenue Oban Argyll Fraser, Linda 07-Jul-17 O And Bute PA34 4EL Griffin, Linda 1 Caer Henwassy Llandysul Ceredigion 07-Dec-16 O 6 Shuna Terrace Oban Argyll And Bute PA34 Kerr, Linda 12-Dec-16 O 4YE 6 Shuna Terrace Oban Argyll And Bute PA34 Kerr, Linda 13-Jul-17 O 4YE MacEwan, Linda 8 Croft Road Ballachulish Argyll PA49 4JW 06-Dec-16 O O'Higgins, Linda Cork Ireland 23-Nov-16 O Price, Linda 17 Cowan Close Rugby CV22 7HW 06-Dec-16 O Price, Linda 17 Cowan Close Rugby CV22 7HW 10-Jul-17 O Rae, Linda 1 Old Glasgow Road Kilwinning 01-Dec-16 O Samsel, Linda 22 Glenfield Gardens Cowdenbeath 01-Dec-16 O Wilson, Linda 12A High Street Oban PA34 4BG 26-Jul-17 O Wilson, Linda PA34 4BG 30-Nov-16 O Wilson, Linda PA34 4BG 30-Jun-17 O 18 Albyn Avenue Campbeltown Argyll And Bute Ford, Lindi 30-Nov-16 O PA28 6LY 18 Albyn Avenue Campbeltown Argyll And Bute Ford, Lindi 10-Jul-17 O PA28 6LY 8665 Pickford Street Apt 10 Los Angeles CA Hedged, Lindsay 29-May-17 O 90035 USA Bramall, Lindsey 5 Castle Road Winchburgh 24-Nov-16 O Bramall, Lindsey 5 Castle Road Winchburgh 04-Jul-17 O Campbell, Lindsey Stag Cottage FK21 8UA 07-Jul-17 O Campbell, Lindsey Stag Cottage Killin FK21 8UA 01-Dec-16 O Arbuthnott, Linsay 50 Market Street Brechin DD9 6BB 01-Dec-16 O Samson, Lisa 2 Coblecrook Lane Alva 01-Dec-16 O Shanley, Lisa No Address 09-Dec-16 O Mayer, Lisa Ceri Plum Tree Cottage Aberporth SA43 2HE 24-Nov-16 O Mayer, Lisa Ceri Plum Tree Cottage Aberporth SA43 2HE 31-Jul-17 O No Surname, Liz No Address 28-Nov-16 O OGrady, Loclann 23D Jerningham Road London SE14 5NQ 01-Dec-16 O Barulis, Lori 5 Marriages Yard Colchester CO1 2ZE 15-Jun-17 O 19 Combie Court Glencruitten Road Oban Hannah, Lori 22-Nov-16 O Argyll And Bute PA34 4BY 19 Combie Court Glencruitten Road Oban Hannah, Lori 30-Jun-17 O Argyll And Bute PA34 4BY Mason, Lorna BN1 8EF 29-Nov-16 O Mason, Lorna Full Address Not Given 06-Jul-17 O McWilliams, Lorna 10 Lane Irvine KA11 1DQ 30-Nov-16 O Paterson, Lorna Tigh Na Mara Port Appin PA38 4DE 23-Nov-16 O Bertram, Lorraine 8 Cockburn Place Coatbridge ML5 5JS 02-Dec-16 O Balure Of Shian Benderloch Oban Argyll And Hogg, Lorraine 28-Nov-16 O Bute PA37 1SD Owens, Lorraine 184 South 5th Street Barlow Kentucky 42024 02-Dec-16 O Macpherson USA Gardiner, Louisa Ladyurd Farm West Linton EH46 7DH 28-Nov-16 O Dawson, Louise LE2 1HP 01-Dec-16 O McAllister, Louise 2/2 24 Thornwood Avenue Glasgow G11 7TW 06-Dec-16 O McAllister, Louise 2/2 24 Thornwood Avenue Glasgow G11 7TW 10-Jul-17 O 34 Lora View North Connel Oban Argyll And No Surname, Louise 01-Dec-16 O Bute PA37 1RR Marshall, Lucianne Lathkill Lodge Bakewell Derbyshire 01-Dec-16 O Whitrow, Lucinda Kilverts Parsonage Langley Burrell SN15 4LE 25-Nov-16 O Cammack, Lucy 143 Parklands Road Chichester 11-Jul-17 O Cammack, Lucy No Address 02-Dec-16 O Hamilton, Lucy 2 Quarry Road Oban PA34 4DP 10-May-17 O Heycock, Lucy Carinya IV6 7XN 22-Nov-16 O Aonach Mor Hamlet Hill North Ailey Road Cove Hollingworth, Lucy 28-Nov-16 O Helensburgh Argyll And Bute G84 0NB Aonach Mor Hamlet Hill North Ailey Road Cove Hollingworth, Lucy 05-Jul-17 O Helensburgh Argyll And Bute G84 0NB Flat Number 2 Grosvenor Place Main Street St Molero, Luis 22-Nov-16 O Boswells TD6 0AT No Surname, Lunsey PA34 4PD 09-Dec-16 O 1 Sarn Y Bryn Caled Belan Welshpool Powys Ballard, Lynda 01-Dec-16 O SY21 8SA Fletcher, Lynda 13 Girvan Crescent Corrimal NSW 2518 01-Dec-16 O Fletcher, Lynda 13 Girvan Crescent Corrimal NSW 2518 14-Jul-17 O Lee, Lynda 13 Somerville Road KY8 4EB 01-Dec-16 O 15 The Close Sallins Park Sallins Co Kildare McGilloway, Lynda 30-Nov-16 O Ireland Maclean, Lyndsey 6 Kirkton Appin 21-Nov-16 O Driftwood Barcaldine Oban Argyll And Bute Amos, Lynn 29-Nov-16 O PA37 1SG Irving, Lynn 4 School Lane LE14 4PB 06-Dec-16 O Reid, Lynn No Address 12-Dec-16 O Thom, Lynne Marie PA34 4TF 06-Dec-16 O McPherson, Lynsey 29 Brora Road Glasgow 01-Dec-16 O Drewett, Lynsie 33 Simmil Road Claygate KT10 0RU 22-Nov-16 O Knowlson, M Cell Mara PA38 4BW 28-Jun-17 O Knowlson, M Ceol Mara Duror 30-Nov-16 O Relich, M EH14 1LG 09-Dec-16 O Jenkinson, 8 Clover Court Brigg North Lincolnshire DN20 23-Nov-16 O Madeleine 8FE Jenkinson, 8 Clover Court Brigg North Lincolnshire DN20 04-Jul-17 O Madeleine 8FE Kaye, Maggi DG7 3UR 29-Nov-16 O Beaton, Maggie No Address Given 23-Jun-17 O 12 Achinreir Barcaldine Oban Argyll And Bute Brotherston, Maggie 29-Nov-16 O PA37 1SL 12 Achinreir Barcaldine Oban Argyll And Bute Brotherston, Maggie 11-Jul-17 O PA37 1SL Hopkins, Maggie No Address 06-Dec-16 O Hill Farm Lascot Hill Wedmore Somerset BS28 Tattersall, Maggie 12-Jun-17 O 4QU Dunbar, Mairi 1D Cleveden Place Glasgow G12 0HG 12-Dec-16 O Lester, Mairi 124 Binalong Bay St Helens Tasmania Australia 18-Apr-17 O Lester, Mairi 124 Binalong Bay St Helens Tasmania Australia 17-Jul-17 O Croit Buidhe Croft Road Oban Argyll And Bute Lester, Mairi 29-Nov-16 O PA34 5JN Inverlochan Benderloch Oban Argyll And Bute Stones, Mairi 17-Jul-17 O PA37 1SA Hughes, Malcolm 112 Main Street Kirkliston Edinburgh EH29 9AD 12-Dec-16 O Hughes, Malcolm 112 Main Street Kirkliston Edinburgh EH29 9AD 13-Jul-17 O Tedd, Malcolm 34 Briar Meads Oadby Leicester LE2 5WD 01-Dec-16 O Wright, Malcolm PA1 3TU 02-Dec-16 O Hall, Malcolm J Tahsis Kilmore Oban Argyll And Bute PA34 4XX 01-Dec-16 O No Surname, Mandy Garth Pednandrea Redruth 06-Dec-16 O Gorman, Manuel 19 Hillside Avenue Kingussie PH21 1PA 01-Dec-16 O Gorman, Manuel 19 Hillside Avenue Kingussie PH21 1PA 21-Jul-17 O Mathews, Marcy 11024 Montgomery Albuquerque 02-Dec-16 O Bennett, Margaret Grange Of Locherlour Ochtertyre PH7 4JS 09-Dec-16 O Gibson, Margaret Ardveich Appin Argyll And Bute PA38 4BA 21-Jun-17 O Gibson, Margaret Ardveich Appin Argyll And Bute PA38 4BA 17-Jul-17 O The Cottage Coilleveneach Fasnacloich Appin Hawkins, Margaret 07-Dec-16 O Argyll And Bute PA38 4BJ Galeed Whitegates Road Lochgilphead Argyll Jacobsen, Margaret 28-Nov-16 O And Bute PA31 8SY Galeed Whitegates Road Lochgilphead Argyll Jacobsen, Margaret 07-Jul-17 O And Bute PA31 8SY Allt-Na-Craobh Connel Oban Argyll And Bute Kirk, Margaret 28-Nov-16 O PA37 1PT Lindsay, Margaret 15 Ferry Road Millport KA28 0DZ 07-Dec-16 O MacEachen, Aros Ard Crannaig-A-Mhinister Oban PA34 4LX 16-Jan-17 O Margaret MacEachen, Aros Ard Crannaig-A-Mhinister Oban PA34 4LX 14-Jul-17 O Margaret No Surname, G83 9AH 02-Dec-16 O Margaret Raeburn, Margaret 38 Taymouth Drive Kenmore PH15 2HJ 07-Dec-16 O Raeburn, Margaret 38 Taymouth Drive Kenmore PH15 2HJ 11-Jul-17 O The Steadings Fasnacloich Glencreran Argyll Rayworth, Margaret 25-Nov-16 O And Bute PA38 4BJ The Steadings Fasnacloich Glencreran Argyll Rayworth, Margaret 29-Nov-16 O And Bute PA38 4BJ Stuart, Margaret PH50 4RN 28-Nov-16 O Stuart, Margaret PH50 4RN 11-Jul-17 O Thompson, 14 Fairoak Way Baughurst Tadley RG26 5NT 07-Dec-16 O Margaret Warsap, Margaret Llaneth House St Margarets Hereford HR2 0RF 12-Jan-17 O Young, Margaret 32 Murieston Valley Livingston EH54 9HB 01-Aug-17 O Flat 1 Granary House Granary Street Burghead Bray, Margery 09-Dec-16 O IV30 5UA Flat 1 Granary House Granary Street Burghead Bray, Margery 10-Jul-17 O IV30 5UA Poullos, Maria 101 Rous Road Buckhurst Hill Essex IG9 6BU 07-Dec-16 O Montgomery, Dunkinty 7 Brochroy Crofts Taynuilt Argyll And 17-Jul-17 O Marian Bute PA35 1JQ Kersley, Marie An Grinan Glen Creran Appin PA38 4BJ 13-Dec-16 O Kersley, Marie An Grinan Glen Creran Appin PA38 4BJ 04-Jul-17 O Parry, Marilyn 3822 S Big River Salt Lake City Utah 30-Nov-16 O Rowan Lodge Creagan Dearg Tayvallich Jeffrey, Marion 19-Jun-17 O Lochgilphead Argyll And Bute PA31 8AJ Rae, Marion Dunbeg 29-Nov-16 O 21 Pilot Street Dunoon Argyll And Bute PA23 Van Helmond, Marji 06-Dec-16 O 8DB Flat 1 Laroch House Loanfern Thornton, Marjie 29-Nov-16 O Ballachulish PH49 4JE Flat 1 Laroch House Loanfern Thornton, Marjie 11-Jul-17 O Ballachulish PH49 4JE Arbuthnott, Mark 50 Market Street Brechin Angus 01-Dec-16 O Conner, Mark 19 Bighty Road Glenrothes 02-Dec-16 O Elder, Mark 2 Bayview Kentallen Appin Argyll PA38 4BU 13-Dec-16 O Jackson, Mark LL13 0PF 01-Dec-16 O Robinson, Mark LE3 5RX 07-Dec-16 O Sanders, Mark 17 Loxley Road Birmingham B67 6BL 01-Dec-16 O Stockdale, Mark 129 Keltyhill Road Kelty KY4 0EW 01-Dec-16 O Stockdale, Mark 129 Keltyhill Road Kelty KY4 0EW 07-Jul-17 O Stuart, Mark 4 Abhaimn Cottages Duror 06-Dec-16 O Mirecka, Marta PA34 4GB 01-Dec-16 O Philbey, Martha 12 Moor Street London W1D 5NG 25-Nov-16 O Pollard, Martha 38/1 Watson Crescent Edinburgh EH11 1EU 12-Dec-16 O Charlton, Martin 34 Magnolia Way Costessey Norwich 01-Dec-16 O Charlton, Martin 34 Magnolia Way Costessey Norwich 10-Jul-17 O Kennedy, Martin 2 Bromley Gardens LU5 5RL 23-Nov-16 O Kennedy, Martin 2 Bromley Gardens LU5 5RL 05-Jul-17 O Mclaughlin, Martin 15 Rosa Belle Street Kirkcaldy Fife KY1 3DP 01-Dec-16 O Mcleod, Martin 19 Crombie Court Oban 30-Nov-16 O Stewart, Martin 1 Eltham Cottage Taynuilt 23-Nov-16 O Weir, Martin Camus Na Ha House PH33 7NN 13-Dec-16 O 3 McCalls Terrace Oban Argyll And Bute PA34 Law, Martine 06-Dec-16 O 4JE Kerr, Mary 26 Coneypark FK7 9LU 30-Nov-16 O MacDougall, Mary An Airidh Lismore 30-Nov-16 O Mcdonald, Mary G72 0JH 01-Dec-16 O Meechan, Mary IV19 1LT 01-Dec-16 O Scott, Mary Nantrigg Taynuilt Argyll PA35 1JQ 12-Jan-17 O Wojniak, Mary No Address 22-Nov-16 O Sheffield, Mary Davaar Connel Oban Argyll And Bute PA37 1PT 07-Dec-16 O Morrice Sheffield, Mary Davaar Connel Oban Argyll And Bute PA37 1PT 10-Jul-17 O Morrice Kirkpatrick, Mary- Sgath-Ma-Creag Ludag East Kilbride Isle Of 30-Jun-17 O Alex HS8 5TS 4549 Portland Avenue Sydenham Ontario K0H Abel, Maryanne 05-Jun-17 O 2TO Burnside, Marza 78 Brucefield Avenue Dunfermline Fife KY11 06-Dec-16 O Jedda 4SY Tait, Maureen 26 Golf View Terrace Inverness IV3 8JJ 30-Nov-16 O Dunrobian Laurel Road Oban Argyll And Bute Wilkins, Maurice 28-Nov-16 O PA34 5EA Dunrobian Laurel Road Oban Argyll And Bute Wilkins, Maurice 05-Jul-17 O PA34 5EA Jenson, Mayana BN44 3AA 03-Aug-17 O No Surname, Maz PA34 4PU 28-Nov-16 O No Surname, MD High Street Inverkeithing 12-Dec-16 O McKenzie, Meg 26 Maxwell Street Fochabers IV32 7DE 26-Jul-17 O Grant, Melanie 87 Bonsall Road Birmingham B23 7DS 22-Nov-16 O Grant, Melanie 87 Bonsall Road Birmingham B23 7DS 30-Jun-17 O Martin, Mhairi 45 Queens Crescent Kinghorn Fife 09-Dec-16 O Martin, Mhairi 45 Queens Crescent Kinghorn Fife 10-Jul-17 O Ross, Mhairi Dail Ghrianach Benderloch Oban 02-Dec-16 O Boyle, Michael Glencairn Oban 02-Dec-16 O Brown, Michael 44 Worminghall Road Ickford HP18 9JD 08-Dec-16 O Brown, Michael 44 Worminghall Road Ickford HP18 9JD 01-Aug-17 O Gassaway, Michael Syllavethy Montgarri Aberdeenshire AB33 8AQ 07-Jul-17 O Morgan, Michael CA8 9JT 01-Dec-16 O Murray, Michael 8 Corsie Ave PH2 7BS 01-Dec-16 O Russell MSP, No Address 09-Dec-16 O Michael Russell MSP, No Address 21-Jul-17 O Michael Turner, Michael Benderloch Oban PA37 1QS 12-Jan-17 O 2/F 3C Lung Tsaiu Tsuen Cheung Chau Hong Waugh, Michael 29-Nov-16 O Kong 2/F 3C Lung Tsaiu Tsuen Cheung Chau Hong Waugh, Michael 06-Jul-17 O Kong Forbes, Michael 1 Campbell Street Oban PA34 4BQ 13-Dec-16 O Robert Rickitt, Michele 18 The Turn Morpeth 25-Nov-16 O Cleadale Barran Kilmore Oban Argyll And Bute McMahon, Michelle 28-Nov-16 O PA34 4XR McMahon, Michelle Cleadale Barron Kilmore Oban 05-Jul-17 O Flat 1 Studio House Craigard Road Oban Argyll Newton, Michelle 30-Nov-16 O And Bute PA34 5NP Pettifer, Michelle 9 Windermere Way Northampton 02-Dec-16 O Barlow, Mike Sunnybrae South Cuan PA34 TU 13-Jan-17 O Barlow, Mike Sunnybrae South Cuan PA34 TU 14-Jul-17 O The Steadings Invercreran Appin Argyll PA38 Rayworth, Mike 05-May-17 O 4BJ 38 Trem Y Mynyyd Burry Port West Wales SA16 Scutt, Mike 22-Feb-17 O 0FZ Thomson, Mike PA34 5AY 23-Nov-16 O Wilkes, Mike 1/2 7 Grandtully Drive Glasagow G12 0DP 22-Nov-16 O Greenford, Miles 10 Breamore Place Thurso 12-Dec-16 O De Colchon, Millie 161 Arden Court Hamilton ML3 6TX 01-Dec-16 O Blennerhassett, Kiloran Inverfolla Appin Argyll And Bute PA38 12-Dec-16 O Miranda 4BA Blennerhassett, Kiloran Inverfolla Appin Argyll And Bute PA38 14-Jul-17 O Miranda 4BA Booth, Miranda 37 Western Park Road LE3 6HQ 24-Jan-17 O Blaikie, Moira 6 Douglas Square Newcastleton TD9 0QU 09-Dec-16 O Blaikie, Moira 6 Douglas Square Newcastleton TD9 0QU 01-Aug-17 O Parker, Moira Smyril Stenness Orkney KW16 3JX 01-Dec-16 O Atkinson, Molly PA37 1SG 11-Jul-17 O McDiarmid, Morag 17 Echline Green South Queensferry EH30 9UU 22-Nov-16 O McDiarmid, Morag 17 Echline Green South Queensferry EH30 9UU 30-Jun-17 O No Surname, Morag 10 Promenade Terrace Portobello EH15 1DT 23-Jan-17 O No Surname, Morag 5 Toravaig Court 23-Nov-16 O Poiree, Morag Cluain Duror Of Appin 13-Jul-17 O Swietlicki, Morag EH26 8NS 30-Nov-16 O Twort, Morag PA34 5AY 01-Dec-16 O 19E Shuna Terrace Oban Argyll And Bute PA34 MacKenzie, Murdo 22-Nov-16 R 4YE Kupris, Muriel PA34 4LX 23-Nov-16 O Venters, Myrna 3 Bannerman Ave Inverkeithing KY11 1NG 12-Dec-16 O Venters, Myrna 3 Bannerman Ave Inverkeithing KY11 1NG 13-Jul-17 O C/o Lismore Post Office Isle Of Lismore Oban Ashford, Nancy 13-Jan-17 O PA34 C/o Lismore Post Office Isle Of Lismore Oban Ashford, Nancy 14-Jul-17 O PA34 Kennedy, Nancy Cruachan Glencoe 22-Nov-16 O Kennedy, Nancy Cruachan Glencoe PH49 4HS 28-Jun-17 O Rimmer, Naomi PA34 4GD 30-Nov-16 O Johannesen, Natalie 4 Hillfield Brae Newton Mearns G77 6GF 28-Nov-16 O White, Natalie FK4 1RJ 09-Dec-16 O No Surname, Natalie No Address 24-Nov-16 R Michie, Natasha 5 Scotstoun Street Glasgow 25-Nov-16 O Stenhouse, Nathan 12 Echline Place South Queensferry 27-Jul-17 O Ballentine, Neil 44 Maryhill Road Queens Cross G20 7BX 02-Dec-16 O Fraser, Neil Basement Flat 5 Burnbank Terrace Oban 14-Dec-16 O Johnston, Neil Sealladha Sguir Old Town Onich PH33 6RZ 08-Dec-16 O Shuna Port Appin Mackie, Neil Appin 05-Dec-16 O Argyll And Bute PA38 4DE McIntosh, Neil 15 Gardens Kirkintilloch 07-Dec-16 O Stewart, Neil 4 Glenbenna Walklerburn EH43 6DD 12-Dec-16 O Lightfoot, Niall 143 Craighlaw Avenue Glasgow G76 0EY 01-Dec-16 O Macleod, Niall Ardconnal Road Oban 10-May-17 O Barnard, Nicholas 10 Windsor Court Bedlington NE22 5PB 25-Nov-16 O Barr Bheag Taynuilt Charlton, Nicholas 08-Dec-16 O Argyll And Bute PA35 1HY Frend, Nicholas 18 Bell Road EN1 3JZ 23-Nov-16 O Duncan, Nicholas W 61 Maltings Way Bury St Edmunds IP32 6EY 14-Dec-16 O C Duncan, Nicholas W 61 Maltings Way Bury St Edmunds IP32 6EY 14-Jul-17 O C McNelly, Nicki The Rectory Ardconnel Tee Oban 09-Dec-16 O Ferguson, Nicola 4 Fullarton Drive Troon Ayrshire KA10 6LE 28-Jul-17 O Ferguson, Nicola No Address 22-Nov-16 O Meekin, Nicola 2 Iola Cottages Inverfolla Appin PA38 4BA 28-Jun-17 O Morgan, Nicola Talisker Nursery Lane Oban Argyll PA34 5JA 02-Jun-17 O North Shian Ferry House Appin Argyll And Bute Wager, Nicola 19-Jun-17 O PA38 4BA Coire Gabhail Rowan Road Oban Argyll And Welsh, Nicola 30-Nov-16 O Bute PA34 5TQ Bischoff, Nicole Hartmannstr 13 02826 Gorlitz 06-Dec-16 O Marie Sinclair, Nicolle Aberdeen AB11 6LS 12-Dec-16 O Lochnell Lodge Benderloch Oban Argyll And MacLucas, Nigel 02-Dec-16 O Bute PA37 1QS Lochnell Lodge Benderloch Oban Argyll And MacLucas, Nigel 17-Jul-17 O Bute PA37 1QS Wright, Nigel Zetland Station Road Newtonmore PH20 1AR 08-Dec-16 O Wright, Nigel Zetland Station Road Newtonmore PH20 1AR 10-Jul-17 O Baker, Nikki 119A Newington Green Road N1 4QY 24-Nov-16 O Harris, Nina No Address 01-Dec-16 O 1 John Anderson House Shore Street Oban Long, Nina 29-Nov-16 O Argyll And Bute PA34 4NT Nicol, Nina The Pines North Connelly By Oban PA37 2QX 29-Nov-16 O Walnut Barn Wind Hill Magdalen Laver CM5 Spencer, Nina 30-Nov-16 O 0DS Walnut Barn Wind Hill Magdalen Laver CM5 Spencer, Nina 05-Jul-17 O 0DS Brown, No 440 Strand London WC2R 0QS 29-Nov-16 O Forename Mcneill, No 2 Courthill Rosneath Helensburgh Argyll And 30-Nov-16 O Forename Bute G84 0RN Nicholson, No No Address 01-Dec-16 O Forename No Surname, No 2/1 126 George Street Oban PA34 5NT 12-Jan-17 O Forename No Surnanme, No 51 Imeravale Port Ellen Isle Of Islay Argyll And 29-Nov-16 O Forename Bute PA42 7AL Sykes, No Forename PA75 6PS 16-Jan-17 O Green Woman, No G84 8HL 23-Nov-16 R Forename Rok, No Forename No Address 14-Dec-16 R Reeves, Norman 75 Cromer Road Ipswich Suffolk IP1 5EP 28-Jun-17 O Trapp, Oliver Kuerschnerweg 30 97246 Eibelstadt Germany 01-Dec-16 O Reeves, P 5 Achinreir PA37 1SL 23-Nov-16 O 6 McCalls Terrace Oban Argyll And Bute PA34 Venters, Pamela 09-Dec-16 O 4JE 6 McCalls Terrace Oban Argyll And Bute PA34 Venters, Pamela 26-Jul-17 O 4JE Martin, Pat ThenLonghouse Glenmore Road Oban 14-Dec-16 O Tyrrel, Pat Pentcleugh Fasnacloich Appin Argyll 21-Nov-16 O Burke, Patricia 22 Ferniehill Street Edinburgh 30-Nov-16 O Tom-a-Ghiuthais Fasnacloich Appin Argyll Cornish, Patricia 13-Dec-16 O PA38 4BJ Hervo, Patricia 2 Farm Street Falkirk FK2 7SS 01-Dec-16 O Stocker, Patricia Wester Killichonan Rannoch PH17 2QW 28-Nov-16 O Stocker, Patricia Wester Killichonan Rannoch PH17 2QW 06-Jul-17 O Bridge, Patrick 11 Giles Court RG26 3RL 06-Dec-16 O Meeze, Patrick Leuven Belgium 30-May-17 O Thomson, Patsy Burnside Burnside Place Cromarty 09-Dec-16 O Thomson, Patsy Burnside Burnside Place Cromarty 11-Jul-17 O Kersley, Paul 1E Castle Road Dunollie Oban PA34 5AN 28-Nov-16 O Kersley, Paul 1E Castle Road Dunollie Oban PA34 5AN 13-Jul-17 O Mackay, Paul PA37 1QE 01-Dec-16 O McSween, Paul 66 Killermont Street Bearsden G61 2LS 10-Jul-17 O Montalto, Paul SW3 2JY 28-Nov-16 O 37 Kirkby Folly Road Sutton In Ashfield Notts Weaver, Paul 01-Dec-16 O NG17 5HP Williams, Paul Mingulay Cuil Bay Duror Appin 01-Dec-16 O Williams, Paul Mingulay Cuil Bay Duror Appin 07-Jul-17 O Burnbank Cottage Taynuilt Argyll And Bute Tett, Paul 02-Dec-16 R PA35 1HP Amos, Pauline London W11 2AQ 30-Nov-16 O Smith, Pauline 1 The Drummonds Epping Essex CM16 4PJ 22-Nov-16 O Stenhouse, Pauline 12 Echline Place South Queensferry 22-Nov-16 O Cherrybank West Bank Road Ardrishaig Argyll Inglis, Pearl McColl 17-Jan-17 O PA30 8HB Cherrybank West Bank Road Ardrishaig Argyll Inglis, Pearl McColl 14-Jul-17 O PA30 8HB Cunha, Pedro SW12 0JE 28-Nov-16 O 3 Coilleveneach Fasnacloich Appin Argyll PA38 Cousins, Penny 14-Dec-16 O 4BJ Hardy, Pete CV10 0RH 28-Nov-16 O Dunmore Court Dunmore Tarbert Argyll And Amsden, Peter 09-Dec-16 O Bute PA29 6XZ Dunmore Court Dunmore Tarbert Argyll And Amsden, Peter 13-Jul-17 O Bute PA29 6XZ Asher, Peter Cruachan View North Connel Argyll 08-Jun-17 O Asher, Peter PA37 1RA 07-Dec-16 O 12 King Charles Road Freshbrook Swindon SN5 Bates, Peter 01-Dec-16 O 8NA Brownhill, Peter Fair View Knowle Lane Buckley CH7 3JA 29-Nov-16 O Brownhill, Peter Fair View Knowle Lane Buckley CH7 3JA 07-Jul-17 O Docherty, Peter 448 Dumbarton Road Partick Glasgow 22-Nov-16 O North Shian Ferry House Appin Argyll And Bute Fleming, Peter 19-Jun-17 O PA38 4BA Foele, Peter KA22 7JQ 01-Dec-16 O Trefewyn 26 Church Hill Helston Cornwall TR13 Jenkinson, Peter 14-Dec-16 O 8NP 1 Shrewsbury Drive Thornton Clevelys Kelly, Peter 07-Dec-16 O Lancashire Maniam, Peter 12 Browns Place East Lothian EH40 3BD 24-Nov-16 O Cragfoot Harbour Street Tarbert Argyll And McCuaig, Peter 07-Dec-16 O Bute PA29 6UD Mclaren, Peter 21 Kelbourne Street Glasgow G20 8PE 06-Dec-16 O Petrie, Peter Waterbeck Mill Lane Collessie Fife 16-Jan-17 O 8 Lorn Road Dunbeg Oban Argyll And Bute Taylor, Peter 07-Dec-16 O PA37 1QG Croxton Old Rectory Croxton St Neots Combs Williams, Peter 07-Jul-17 O PE19 6SU Wyeth, Peter 89 Winchester Road LE8 5PP 30-Nov-16 O Nordsjo 352 914 93 Norrfors Vasterbottens Ian Tait, Peter Richard 01-Dec-16 O Sverige Jones, Petra 36 Mulholland Close CR4 1SX 06-Dec-16 O Eerste Helmersstraat 149 1054DR Amsterdam Hallam, Phil 01-Dec-16 O NL Dun Aluin Kilchrenan Taynuilt Argyll And Bute Price, Philip 25-Nov-16 O PA35 1HG Dun Aluin Kilchrenan Taynuilt Argyll And Bute Price, Philip 17-Jul-17 O PA35 1HG Haymer, Phoebe No Address 24-Jan-17 O Irvine, Polly Dalismore Port Appin Argyll PA38 4BA 23-Nov-16 O Bennett, R 79 Nelson Ave Livingston EH54 6LA 01-Dec-16 O Stevenson, R Cruachan View Cottage Connel Argyll PA37 1PA 12-Dec-16 O W-Fitzwilliam, R M Glaceriska Port Appin Argyll PA38 4DQ 28-Jun-17 O G Cornish, R N Tom A Ghiuthais Fasnacloich Appin PA38 4BJ 16-Jan-17 O Rughriach House Connel Oban Argyll And Bute Black, Rab 30-Nov-16 O PA37 1PT Rughriach House Connel Oban Argyll And Bute Black, Rab 06-Jul-17 O PA37 1PT Adams, Rachel 16 Mount Pleasant Bradford BD6 2EX 07-Dec-16 O 57 Lochnell Road Dunbeg Oban Argyll And Bute Johnstone, Rachel 22-Nov-16 O PA37 1QJ Le, Rachel 37 Mere Bank Davenham Cheshire CW9 8NB 30-Nov-16 O Le, Rachel 37 Mere Bank Davenham Cheshire CW9 8NB 06-Jul-17 O Rowan, Rachel No Address 23-Nov-16 O Smith, Rachel 3 Harbour Red Fortrose 24-Nov-16 O Strachan, Ranald 18 The Crescent Dura Den 14-Jul-17 O Barnham Smyth, Rosebank Connel Oban Argyll And Bute PA37 28-Nov-16 O Rebecca 1PA Bashir, Rebecca The Rectory Duror Appin PA38 4BS 30-Nov-16 O Bashir, Rebecca The Rectory Duror Appin PA38 4BS 06-Jul-17 O McLean, Rebecca PH41 4QF 23-Nov-16 O Shonkwiler, Rebecca 99 Sheephill Road Riverside CT 06878 USA 22-Nov-16 O Annabells Cottage Deirdre Connel Oban Argyll Weeks, Rebecca 07-Dec-16 O And Bute PA37 1PL Rowan Trees Glencruitten Oban Argyll And Forbes, Rebecca 22-Nov-16 R Bute PA34 4QB Macdonald, Rebecca Point House Tayinloan Argyll PA29 6XG 24-Nov-16 O Maxwell Ashford, Regan Can Prat Campins 08472 Spain 08-Dec-16 O Ashford, Regan Can Prat Campins 08472 Spain 17-Jul-17 O Dyer, Rhian 22 SA43 2DL 22-Nov-16 O Kilbrannan Port Appin Appin Argyll And Bute Dunn, Rhona 07-Dec-16 O PA38 4DE Kilbrannan Port Appin Appin Argyll And Bute Dunn, Rhona 07-Jun-17 O PA38 4DE Kilbrannan Port Appin Appin Argyll And Bute Dunn, Rhona 07-Jul-17 O PA38 4DE Rowan Trees Glencruitten Oban Argyll And Forbes, Rhona 22-Nov-16 O Bute PA34 4QB Lawrie, Rhona-May 3/1 3 Buccleuch Street Glasgow G3 6SJ 24-Nov-16 O Pacitti, Riccardo 12 Lunga Road Oban Argyll And Bute PA34 4NP 24-Nov-16 O Craig, Richard Colyen Huntly 01-Dec-16 O 2 Albert Terrace Waterbank Road Sheringham Dunkley, Richard 13-Jan-17 O Norfolk NR26 8SY 2 Albert Terrace Waterbank Road Sheringham Dunkley, Richard 28-Jul-17 O Norfolk NR26 8SY Fowler, Richard 106A George Street Oban 14-Dec-16 O The Cottage Coilleveneach Fasnacloich Appin Hawkins, Richard 07-Dec-16 O Argyll And Bute PA38 4BJ The Willows Connel Oban Argyll And Bute PA37 Hess, Richard 09-Dec-16 O 1PJ Hoare, Richard 33/2 Church Street Dundee DD5 1HB 30-Nov-16 O McColl, Richard 92109 San Diego California USA 30-May-17 O Olver, Richard 13 Queens Gardens KY16 9TA 30-Nov-16 O Pavey, Richard 4 Lawrence Cottages Keig AB33 8BH 01-Dec-16 O Petersson, Richard 1693 Main Street Glastonbury 06033 USA 09-Dec-16 O Scot Atkinson, Rick Fort William 22-Feb-17 O No Surname, Rob 1556 Pyes Pa Road Tauranga NZ 09-Dec-16 O Johnston, Robbie 54 Nant Drive Oban PA34 4LA 22-Nov-16 O Johnston, Robbie 54 Nant Drive Oban PA34 4LA 30-Jun-17 O Greenhalgh, Robert 3 Appin Terrace Appin PA38 4BH 26-Jul-17 O Grove, Robert PA34 4UX 22-Nov-16 O Johnstone, Robert 14 Kingshill Road Aberdeen 02-Dec-16 O Logan, Robert E1W 3NQ 23-Nov-16 O Logan, Robert E1W 3NQ 03-Aug-17 O MacCallum, Robert 4 Etive Gardens Oban Argyll And Bute PA34 4JP 10-Jul-17 O Innesdale 4 Etive Gardens Oban Argyll And Maccallum, Robert 07-Dec-16 O Bute PA34 4JP McCall, Robert 4A Dalintart Drive Oban 05-Dec-16 O McMurray, Robert 12 Orchard Road Edinburgh EH4 2ES 11-Jul-17 O Montgomery, Dunkinty 7 Brochroy Crofts Taynuilt Argyll And 12-Dec-16 O Robert Bute PA35 1JQ Montgomery, Dunkinty 7 Brochroy Crofts Taynuilt Argyll And 17-Jul-17 O Robert Bute PA35 1JQ Roth, Robert No Address Given 07-Jul-17 O Sewell, Robert 14 Rhindmuir Wynd Glasgow G69 6BJ 16-Jan-17 O Stamp, Robert 20 Woodlands Edge Ellon AB41 8BQ 09-Dec-16 O North Shian Ferry House Appin Argyll And Bute Wager, Robert 19-Jun-17 O PA38 4BA Scott, Robert 6 Westercraigs Glasgow G31 2HZ 01-Dec-16 O Dawson Scott, Robert 6 Westercraigs Glasgow G31 2HZ 05-Jul-17 O Dawson McColl, Robert 10951 Gulf Shore Dr. Naples Florida USA 06-Jun-17 O William Barrie, Robin 47 Kirkbank Road Burntisland KY3 9HZ 01-Dec-16 O Fitzwilliam, Robin Glaceriska Port Appin Argyll PA38 4DQ 31-Jul-17 O 3 Coilleveneach Fasnacloich Appin Argyll PA38 Cousins, Rod 14-Dec-16 O 4BJ Ferguson, Roddy 22 Ben Alder Place Kirkcaldy 01-Dec-16 O Forsyth, Roddy Gate Cottage St Catherine's Argyll PA25 8AZ 13-Dec-16 O Mattinson, Roddy 60 Fortis Green N2 9EN 08-Dec-16 O 14 Cowan Place Oban Argyll And Bute PA34 Gray, Roderick 12-Dec-16 O 4GA 14 Cowan Place Oban Argyll And Bute PA34 Gray, Roderick 17-Jul-17 O 4GA Woodwell Cottage Lindeth Road Silverdale Cartwright, Roger 01-Dec-16 O Carnforth LA5 0TX Kennedy, Ronald M11 6SW 06-Dec-16 O Tutty, Ronald 5 St Andrews Drive Armadale West Lothian 01-Dec-16 O Tutty, Ronald 5 St Andrews Drive Armadale West Lothian 11-Jul-17 O Albrecht, Ronny No Address 07-Dec-16 O Houlding, Rosie 24 Lower Breakish IV42 8QA 23-Nov-16 O Gray, Ross 11 Waterfoot Road Newton Mearns 12-Dec-16 O Druimneil Cottage Port Appin Appin Argyll And Williamson, Ross 24-Nov-16 O Bute PA38 4DQ CAD Operator MacLeod Construction Ltd Hodson, Ross Kilmory Industrial Estate Loghgilphead PA31 09-Dec-16 S 8RR MacCulloch, PA37 1NU 24-Nov-16 O Roxanna Herd, Roy Phoenix Mill Kelty 30-Nov-16 O Jeannin, Rozemarijn Kessel-Lo Belgium 05-Jun-17 O Pringle, Ruaridh 127 Edward Street Dunoon Argyll PA23 7PH 29-May-17 O Pringle, Ruaridh 127 Edward Street Dunoon Argyll PA23 7PH 27-Jul-17 O Pringle, Ruaridh 161 Edward Street Dunoon PA23 7PH 13-Dec-16 O Dods, Russell Osprey Glencruitten Oban PA34 4QA 24-Nov-16 O Perry, Russell 29 Northall Road Barnehurst DA7 6HF 06-Dec-16 O Morley, Ruth PA34 4XH 28-Nov-16 O Morley, Ruth PA34 4XH 06-Jul-17 O Morley, Ruth PA34 4XH 13-Jul-17 O Davies, Ryan OL6 6LH 30-Nov-16 O Van Boetzelaer, S 3712XS 14-Dec-16 O Irvine, Sally Fig Tree House Alderburgh IP15 5DU 25-Nov-16 O Stanton, Sally CO91 1NZ 01-Dec-16 O Aminiam, Sam 10 Burgess Place Ipswich Suffolk 05-Dec-16 O 46A Craig Na Gower Avenue Aviemore PH22 Crymble, Sam 16-Jan-17 O 1RW Everington, Sam Inverboathouse Loch Creran Appin PA38 4BQ 13-Jul-17 O Miller, Sam 29 Endrick Drive Paisley PA1 3TU 01-Dec-16 O Miller, Sam 29 Endrick Drive Paisley PA1 3TU 31-Jul-17 O Scott, Sam 22A Shauna Trace Oban Scotland 22-Nov-16 O Turnbull, Samantha 40 The Glebe Kilmelford PA34 4XF 23-Nov-16 O Wood, Samual 12 McColl Terrace PH49 4JH 22-Nov-16 O Brown, Sandra 32 Rankin Avenue Edinburgh Eh9 3DB 12-Dec-16 O Darwish, Sandra No Address 01-Dec-16 O Kuentzel, Sandra 2 Forth Street St Monans KY10 2AU 01-Dec-16 O MacMillan, Sandra 1 Argyll Cottages Ballachulish Argyll 09-Dec-16 O McRitchie, Sandra 1 Earnview Court Burrell Street Comrie 09-Dec-16 O Mortlock, Sandra 5 Windsor Drive March Cambs 06-Dec-16 O Taylor, Sandra 14 Greenbank Chester CH4 7EH 22-Nov-16 O Taylor, Sandra 14 Greenbank Chester CH4 7EH 11-Jul-17 O Hawkins, Sara 10 Victoria Close 30-Jun-17 O 1802 Missoula Ave Missoula Montana USa MacCalman, Sara 09-Dec-16 O 59802 McNeill, Sara Camus South Cuil Duror PA38 28-Nov-16 O Cathro, Sara No Address Given 27-Apr-17 S Phoenix Mill Sawmill Road Blairadam By Kelty Herd, Sarah 23-Nov-16 O Fife KY40 0JG The Old Mill Mains Of Hedderwick Montrose Pettigrew, Sarah 29-Nov-16 O Angus DD10 9ER Youd, Sarah 11 Ferndale Road Wirral CH47 3AT 24-Jan-17 O Morgan, Sarah 4 Parc Tyn Llan Llandyrnog LL16 4HX 23-Nov-16 R 4D Sinclair Drive Oban Argyll And Bute PA34 Davidson, Saskia 22-Nov-16 O 4DR Whitelaw, Saskia 2 Pottie Kilinnan Isle Of Mull 30-Jun-17 O Harvie, Scott 27 Milton Crescent Carluke ML8 5AN 06-Dec-16 O Harvie, Scott 27 Milton Crescent Carluke ML8 5AN 10-Jul-17 O 52 Lorn Road Dunbeg Oban Argyll And Bute MacIntyre, Scott 29-Nov-16 O PA37 1QQ Mannion, Scott PA31 8UU 23-Nov-16 O Mannion, Scott PA31 8UU 04-Jul-17 O McColl, Scott 3000 Leuven Belgium 30-May-17 O Mealyou, Scott Wester Blacklaws Farm Longridge EH47 8AA 01-Dec-16 O Murray, Scott Craighead Cottage Braco Dunblane FK15 0LP 01-Dec-16 O Rowan, Scott PA34 4YQ 23-Nov-16 O Twort, Scott PA34 5AY 22-Nov-16 O Young, Scott KY4 8BY 07-Dec-16 O 39 Aldersyde Taynuilt Argyll And Bute PA35 Jameson, Sean 28-Nov-16 O 1AG 39 Aldersyde Taynuilt Argyll And Bute PA35 Jameson, Sean 05-Jul-17 O 1AG Rowan, Sean 11 Hillside Dunbeg 23-Jan-17 O Hodgson, Serena 5 Kenmure Steading New DG7 3RX 07-Dec-16 O Lopez, Shannon Arlington TX 29-May-17 O No Surname, Sharlo 56 Middlefield Terrace Aberdeen 07-Dec-16 O Hargreaves, Sharon 13 Annesley Park Torphins AB31 4HG 30-Nov-16 O No Surname, Sharon 11 Tytler Gardens Edinburgh 23-Nov-16 O Reilly, Sharon 22 Park Road Oban Argyll And Bute PA34 4GZ 23-Nov-16 O Reilly, Sharon 22 Park Road Oban Argyll And Bute PA34 4GZ 04-Jul-17 O Trish, Sharon PA38 4BW 12-Dec-16 O No Surname, Sharon 13B Millpark Terrace Oban Argyll 23-Nov-16 R Airds Hotel Port Appin Appin Argyll And Bute McKivragan, Shaun 07-Jul-17 O PA38 4DF McKivragan, Shaun The Airds Hotel Port Appin Argyll PA38 4DF 01-Dec-16 O McKivragan, Shaun The Airds Hotel Port Appin Argyll PA38 4DF 03-Aug-17 O No Surname, 7 Powell Place Connel PA37 1AE 01-Dec-16 O Shauna Brown, Sheila 10A Colonsay Terrace Oban PA34 4YN 27-Jul-17 O 30 Dunbar Avenue Johnstone Renfrewshire King, Sheila 01-Dec-16 O PA5 0HE Lawrie, Sheila 9 Bealach Na Mara Appin Argyll 23-Nov-16 O Potts, Sheila East Coilleard Appin 30-Nov-16 O Robson, Sheila 23 Beech Avenue Newton Mearns G77 5PP 17-Jul-17 O

Scott, Sheila Lochvoil House Dunuaran Road Oban PA34 4NE 16-Jan-17 O Scott, Sheila Lochvoil House Dunuaran Road Oban PA34 4NE 14-Jul-17 O

Gleanndaloch Connel Oban Argyll And Bute Sinclair, Sheila 29-Nov-16 O PA37 1PA Gleanndaloch Connel Oban Argyll And Bute Sinclair, Sheila 05-Jul-17 O PA37 1PA Melville, Sheona 21 Road Whitehill Bordon 30-Nov-16 O McLennan, Shirley 6 Mull Terrace Oban Argyll And Bute PA34 4YB 23-Nov-16 O 2 Orchard Cottage Appin Argyll And Bute PA38 Whitelaw, Shona 29-Nov-16 O 4BN Allen, Simon 144 Wellmeadow Road SE6 1HP 30-Nov-16 O Fraser, Simon Tomich The Loan West Linton 09-Dec-16 O Fraser, Simon Tomich The Loan West Linton 10-Jul-17 O 31 South Hermitage Shrewsbury Shropshire Hawkins, Simon 30-Nov-16 O SY3 7JS Bishopton House Bishopton Road Lochgilphead Mackenzie, Simon 11-Jul-17 O PA31 8PY No Surname, Simon 2 Inchmickery Avenue Dalgety Bay Fife 01-Dec-16 O Smith, Simon 2 Includes Avenue Dalgety Bay KY11 9NF 10-Jul-17 O Squire, Simon TA18 8AE 01-Dec-16 O Vonderweiden, 7 Rue De Guichet 92110 Clichy France 02-Dec-16 O Sinah Tigh Sonas Barcaldine Oban Argyll And Bute Murray, Sine 23-Nov-16 O PA37 1SG Jackson, Sinead No Address 30-Nov-16 O McDaid, Siobhan G72 7BD 22-Nov-16 R Ross Mhor Knipoch Oban Argyll And Bute PA34 Craig, Solvejg 01-Dec-16 O 4QT Fothringham, Sophia Achnacone Appin 09-Dec-16 O Steuart Mallon, Sophie 1 Mary Slessor Wynd Rutherglen G73 5RJ 22-Nov-16 O Marple, Sophie Downshire Hill NW3 1NU 25-Nov-16 O Rajs, Stan 34 Soroba Road Oban PA34 4HY 22-Nov-16 O Rajs, Stan 34 Soroba Road Oban PA34 4HY 30-Jun-17 O April Cottage 7 Russell Street Wilton Salisbury Broadbent, Stella 30-Jun-17 O SP2 0BG Jeffrey, Stephen Rowan Cottage Port Appim 22-Jun-17 O Johnstone, Stephen No Address 30-Nov-16 O Lockhart, Stephen 9 Angus Terrace Oban Argyll And Bute 25-Nov-16 O Speirs, Stephen No 35 G72 9UP 11-Jul-17 O Alafoss Cuilfail Terrace Kilmelford Oban Argyll Morley, Steve 12-Dec-16 O And Bute PA34 4XH Alafoss Cuilfail Terrace Kilmelford Oban Argyll Morley, Steve 13-Jul-17 O And Bute PA34 4XH Niner, Steve BN8 5LA 02-Dec-16 O 19 Etive Park North Connel Oban Argyll And Benjamins, Steven 06-Dec-16 O Bute PA37 1SJ 19 Etive Park North Connel Oban Argyll And Benjamins, Steven 07-Jul-17 O Bute PA37 1SJ First Floor Left Hand Side 13 Springbank Kersely, Steven 09-Dec-16 O Terrace Aberdeen AB41 8BX Tigh-Air-Oisean Cnoc A' Challtuinn Clachan Seil Jarron, Stevie 28-Nov-16 O Isle Of Seil Oban Argyll And Bute PA34 4TR Melrose, Stewart Ardveich Appin PA38 4BA 13-Dec-16 O Melrose, Stewart Ardveich Appin PA38 4BA 11-Jul-17 O McColl, Stuart 1038 Hooker Road Sequim WA 98382 26-May-17 O Allen, Sue 7 Brookyln Grove Wallheath 07-Dec-16 O

Morgan, Sue Whincroft How Mill Brampton Cumbria CA8 9JT 06-Dec-16 O

Morgan, Sue Whincroft How Mill Brampton Cumbria CA8 9JT 10-Jul-17 O

Morris, Sue White Cottage Brig O'Turk FK17 8HT 27-Jul-17 O Duguid, Susan 2 Clayton Park Bridge Of Earn Perth PH2 9FD 07-Dec-16 O Grassaway, Susan Syllavehy Alford AB33 8AQ 29-Nov-16 O Grassaway, Susan Syllavehy Alford AB33 8AQ 06-Jul-17 O Harrison, Susan 49 Celestial Cresc Hannon Ontario L0R 1P0 29-May-17 O Craobh Chuilinn Appin Argyll And Bute PA38 Hutchison, Susan 12-Dec-16 O 4BD 21 Royal Crescent Dunoon Argyll And Bute Morrison, Susan 07-Dec-16 O PA23 7AG Peters, Susan 19 Ashfield Court Dunbar 01-Dec-16 O Hughes, Susannah Dalnaglar Laurel Road Oban PA34 5EA 23-Nov-16 O 7 Saville Crescent Weston Super Mare BS22 Jennings, Suzanne 06-Dec-16 O 8PG Alvis, Suzie Saorsa Glencruitten Oban PA34 4QB 30-Nov-16 O Blackwell, T 150 Leicester Road LE67 6HJ 30-Nov-16 O Blackwell, T 150 Leicester Road LE67 6HJ 05-Jul-17 O Polley, T N Gyllar Croft Road Oban PA34 5J: 06-Feb-17 O Savage, Tania 47 Kirkbank Road Burntisland KY3 9HZ 02-Dec-16 O Smart, Tanya Folliott Glastonbury BA6 07-Dec-16 O Highfield, Hale House Lane Churt Cole, Terence 30-Nov-16 O Farnham GU10 2NH Gannon, Terry 34 Warren Gardens Chapletown Sheffield 01-Dec-16 O Shuna Cottage Airds Taynuilt Argyll And Bute Spooner, Terry 12-Dec-16 O PA35 1JW Darwin, Tess 12 Royal Terrace Falkland KY15 7AX 30-Nov-16 O Scott, Tess 9 Abertriddwr Llanwddyn 06-Dec-16 O 15 Lorn Road Dunbeg Oban Argyll And Bute Carpenter, Tevor 30-Nov-16 O PA37 1QG Sharp, Thomas PA37 22-Nov-16 O Brand, Tim 1 Achanduin Benderloch Argyll PA37 1QP 22-Nov-16 O Clarke, Tim Port Appin 19-Jun-17 O South Kilworth House Walcott Road South Holmes, Tim 08-Dec-16 O Kilworth LE17 6EQ Price, Tina 29 Queen Anne Street New Bradwell MK13 0BB 07-Dec-16 O Adams, Tom 3B Drimvargie Terrace Oban PA34 4BN 13-Jul-17 O Hayward, Tom Dunollie Road Oban PA34 5JH 22-Nov-16 O Hubbard, Tom 5 Lady Helen Street Kirkcaldy KY1 1PS 09-Dec-16 O Rafferty, Tom 26 Wedderlea Drive Glasgow G52 2SS 30-Nov-16 O Millseat Barns Crudie Turriff Aberdeenshire Spiers, Tom 12-Dec-16 O AB53 5PY Millseat Barns Crudie Turriff Aberdeenshire Spiers, Tom 11-Jul-17 O AB53 5PY 6 Railway Drive Sturminster Marshall Dorset Kerr, Tom F 01-Dec-16 O BH21 4DQ 6 Railway Drive Sturminster Marshall Dorset Kerr, Tom F 07-Jul-17 O BH21 4DQ McGill, Tommy 61 Nant Drive Oban PA34 4NL 02-Dec-16 O Tully, Tommy No Address 01-Dec-16 O Ashford, Tony Queens Court Louth NL11 8RR 15-Dec-16 O Invercreran Lodge Glen Creran Appin PA38 Kersley, Tony 13-Dec-16 O 4BJ Invercreran Lodge Glen Creran Appin PA38 Kersley, Tony 31-May-17 O 4BJ Invercreran Lodge Glen Creran Appin PA38 Kersley, Tony 05-Jul-17 O 4BJ Invercreran Lodge Glen Creran Appin PA38 Kersley, Tony 10-Jul-17 O 4BJ Weeks, Tony 6 Locharthur Terrace Beeswing Dumfries 09-Dec-16 O Weeks, Tony Terrace Beeswing Dumfries 04-Aug-17 O 2 Meadow Road Dunbeg Oban Argyll And Bute MacKinnon, Toots 28-Nov-16 O PA37 1QB Frantzen, Toril Barcaldine PA37 1SG 30-Nov-16 O Frantzen, Toril Barcaldine PA37 1SG 07-Jul-17 O Owen, Tracey Windyneuk Tain Highlands 01-Dec-16 O Southern, Tracey 14 Teal Close Caistor LN7 6TD 08-Dec-16 O West, Tracey No Address 06-Dec-16 O Tidereach Connel Oban Argyll And Bute PA37 Diciacca, Tracy 01-Dec-16 O 1PT Tidereach Connel Oban Argyll And Bute PA37 Diciacca, Tracy 07-Jul-17 O 1PT Fioryn Clachan Seil Davies, Trevor Isle Of Seil Oban 24-Nov-16 O Argyll And Bute PA34 4TJ 101 Summerfield Crescent Birmingham B16 Lines, Trevor 01-Dec-16 O 0EN Didier, Trinocque 22 Avenue Riviera 06500 Menton France 06-Dec-16 O Pottery And Painting Aberporth Road Cardigan Finch, Trudi 23-Nov-16 O West Wales Spiers, Trudie ML6 0BD 01-Dec-16 O Olsen, Twig Ardchuan Taynuilt Argyll And Bute PA35 1HY 12-Dec-16 O Hunter, Una 14 East Church Court Ayrshire 06-Dec-16 O Achilles-Day, Undine PA35 1HP 23-Nov-16 O Iaquinto, Ute Seekante 47 24159 Kiel Germany 01-Dec-16 O 3 Dungallan Terrace Oban Argyll And Bute Hamilton, V 29-Nov-16 O PA34 4PB 3 Dungallan Terrace Oban Argyll And Bute Hamilton, V 07-Jul-17 O PA34 4PB O'Flynn, Val 240B Hainton Avenue Grimsby DN32 9IJ 06-Dec-16 O Shephard, Val 8 Glenview Dalmally Argyll 30-Nov-16 O Shephard, Val 8 Glenview Dalmally Argyll 06-Jul-17 O Douglas, Valeria 16 Saunby Grove Cleethorpes DN35 8NG 01-Dec-16 O Frood, Vanessa 15 The Jordans Maple Square Southend Essex 22-Nov-16 O Port Beag Kilninver Oban Argyll And Bute PA34 Kilpatrick, Vanessa 09-Dec-16 O 4UT Hartley, Vanessa Kenohill Clachan Seil Oban PA34 4TN 13-Jan-17 O Claire 3 Benmore View North Connel Oban Argyll And Ferguson, Vary 30-Nov-16 O Bute PA37 1SN Rastall, Vic Kilbowie OEC Gallanach Road Oban 11-Jul-17 O No Surname, Vicky No Address 22-Nov-16 O Inverawe House Inverawe Taynuilt Argyll And Miller, Victoria 28-Nov-16 O Bute PA35 1HU Johnson, Vikki Sealladh A Sguir Old Town North Ballachulish 09-Dec-16 O Johnson, Vikki Sealladh A Sguir Old Town North Ballachulish 17-Jul-17 O Roberts, Vilas PA35 1JG 30-Nov-16 O Anderson, Virginia 34 Baldwin Road Leicester LE2 6HA 30-Nov-16 O Jenkins, Vivian 121 Fintry Drive Fintry Dundee Angus Dd4 9HQ 07-Dec-16 O Jenkins, Vivian 121 Fintry Drive Fintry Dundee Angus Dd4 9HQ 11-Jul-17 O Stewart, W David Fashacloich Appin Argyll PA28 4BJ 25-Nov-16 O Kincaid, W Robert Mount Stuart Gallanach PA34 4QJ 01-Dec-16 O Kincaid, W Robert Mount Stuart Gallanach PA34 4QJ 17-Jul-17 O Nicholl, Wendy 2 Dinnet Way Newmains Wishaw ML2 9HS 08-Dec-16 O Nicholl, Wendy 2 Dinnet Way Newmains Wishaw ML2 9HS 10-Jul-17 O No Surname, Wendy PA37 1SF 21-Nov-16 O 18 Bakehouse Lane Ockbrook Derbyshire DE72 Perry, Wendy 30-Nov-16 O 3RH 18 Bakehouse Lane Ockbrook Derbyshire DE72 Perry, Wendy 07-Jul-17 O 3RH Thorleyryder, 74 Torrisdale Street Glasgow G42 8PJ 25-Nov-16 O Wendy Turner, Wendy 18 Grange Terrace Bo'Ness EH51 9DS 12-Dec-16 O Webb, Wendy TQ9 6QA 06-Dec-16 O Grosvenor, Wendy PH26 3JN 23-Nov-16 R Currie, Will Dungraftin Barcaldine Argyll 05-Dec-16 O Currie, Will Dungraftin Barcaldine Argyll 04-Jul-17 O Wilson, Willa PA31 8RJ 24-Nov-16 O Tromlee Kilchrenan Taynuilt Argyll And Bute Clarke, William 12-Dec-16 O PA35 1HD Tromlee Kilchrenan Taynuilt Argyll And Bute Clarke, William 11-Jul-17 O PA35 1HD Clifford, William Larch House Appin Argyll And Bute PA38 4BA 06-Jul-17 O Crookes, William Tigh Fiodh Acharacle Argyll PA36 4JL 12-Dec-16 O Douglas, William 16 Saunby Grove Cleethorpes 30-Nov-16 O Ferguson, William 20 Mill Park Hamilton 06-Dec-16 O Ferguson, William 20 Mill Park Hamilton 07-Jul-17 O Giffen, William 76 Dumbuck Cres Dumbarton 06-Dec-16 O Harrison, William 2 Ford Cottages Glenbranter Argyll 01-Dec-16 O Hunter, William 20 Tollohill Gardens Aberdeen AB12 5DX 25-Nov-16 O Hunter, William 20 Tollohill Gardens Aberdeen AB12 5DX 20-Jul-17 O Mackenzie, William 18 Achlonan Taynuilt 22-Nov-16 O 2 Culdoach Road Tongland Kirkcudbright DG6 McDowell, William 07-Dec-16 O 4LU 2 Culdoach Road Tongland Kirkcudbright DG6 McDowell, William 11-Jul-17 O 4LU Mclean, William 17 Turnbull Grove Dunfermline 02-Dec-16 O Nelson, William Cherry Park Inveraray PA32 8XG 08-Dec-16 O The Shieling Balvatin Cottages Perth Road Todd, William 14-Jul-17 O Newtonmore PH20 1BB Davies, William John Upper Gylen Isle Of 12-Jun-17 O Campbell, Willie 13 Fir Road Doune 28-Nov-16 O Tigh An Tuim Benderloch Oban Argyll And Bute Orr, Willie 29-Nov-16 O PA37 1QP Inches, Wilma 63 Abbey Eoad Scone 01-Dec-16 O McColl, Winston F 92026 Escondido California 05-Jun-17 O No Surname, Yomira PA35 1HP 30-Nov-16 O Brown, Yvonne 251 Kirkintilloch Road G64 2JD 29-Nov-16 O Brown, Yvonne 251 Kirkintilloch Road G64 2JD 05-Jul-17 O Major, Yvonne No Address 09-Dec-16 O Russell, Yvonne EH4 2JW 09-Dec-16 O Scott, Yvonne 20 Queen Street Inverness 28-Nov-16 O Smart, Yvonne 4 Stad Y Waun Waungilwen Velindre SA44 5YH 06-Dec-16 O Shuna Port Appin Appin Argyll And Bute PA38 Mackie, Zoe 12-Dec-16 O 4DE Shuttleworth, Zoe 26 Shelley Road SE5 8NN 24-Nov-16 O