Archaeologist Volume 30 Summer 1980 No
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
OHIO ARCHAEOLOGIST VOLUME 30 SUMMER 1980 NO. 3 Published by THE ARCHAEOLOGICAL SOCIETY OF OHIO The Archaeological Society of Ohio Robert Harter, 1961 Buttermilk Hill, Delaware, Ohio Officers—terms expire 1984 Associate Editor. Martha P. Otto, President—Frank Otto, Ohio Historical Society, Columbus, Ohio 1503 Hempwood Drive, Columbus, Ohio Jeff Carskadden, 960 Eastward Circle, Colony North, Vice President—Mike Kish, Zanesvilje, Ohio 43701 39 Parkview Ave., Westerville, Ohio Executive Secretary—Don Gehlbach, All articles, reviews and comments on the Ohio Archae 3435 Sciotangy Drive, Columbus, Ohio ologist should be sent to the Editor. Memberships, re Treasurer—Scott Haskins, quests for back issues, changes of address, and other 484 Stinchcomb Drive, Columbus, Ohio matter should be sent to the business office. Recording Secretary—Chris Olenick, PLEASE NOTIFY BUSINESS OFFICE IMMEDIATELY 8140 Anne St., S.W., Navarre, Ohio OF ADDRESS CHANGES. BY POSTAL REGULATIONS Trustees SOCIETY MAIL CANNOT BE FORWARDED. Term expires Editorial Office Dana Baker, 17240 Township Road 206, 199 Converse Drive, Plain City, Ohio 43064 Mt. Victory, Ohio 1982 Steve Balazs, 1010 N. Mulbeery St., Business Office Mt. Vernon, Ohio 1982 Summers Redick, 35 West Riverglen Drive, Doug Hooks, 120 Yoha Drive, Worthington, Ohio 43085 Mansfield, Ohio 1982 Membership and Dues Wayne Mortine, Scott Drive, Oxford Heights, Annual dues to the Archaeological Society of Ohio are Newcomerstown, Ohio 1982 payable on the first of January as follows: Regular mem- Ernest Good, 3402 Civic Place, bership$8.50; Husband and wife (one copy of publication) Grove City, Ohio 1984 $9.50; Contributing $25.00. Funds are used for publish Alva McGraw, 1177 Eastern Ave., ing the Ohio Archaeologist. The Archaeological Society Chillicothe, Ohio 1984 of Ohio is an incorporated non-profit organization and Donald Casto, 138 Ann Court, has no paid officers or employees. Lancaster, Ohio 1984 Jan Sorgenfrei, The Ohio Archaeologist is published quarterly and subscription is included in the membership dues. Pandora, Ohio 1984 Back Issues Regional Collaborators Publications and back issues of the Ohio Archaeologist: David W. Kuhn, 2642 Shawnee Rd., Portsmouth, Ohio Ohio Flint Types, by Robert N. Converse $4.00 Charles H. Stout, Sr., 91 Redbank Drive, Fairborn, Ohio Ohio Stone Tools, by Robert N. Converse .... 3.00 Mark W. Long. Box 467, Wellston. Ohio Ohio Slate Types, by Robert N. Converse .... 7.00 Steven Kelley. Seaman. Ohio Back issues—black and white—each 3.00 William Tiell. 13435 Lake Ave., Lakewood. Ohio Back issues—four full color plates—each 3.00 Robert Jackman, Box 30, Wellsville, Ohio 43968 Back issues of the Ohio Archaeologist printed prior James L. Murphy, 102 Wilbur Ave., to 1964 are generally out of print but copies are available Columbus, Ohio 43215 from time to time. Write to business office for prices and Gordon Hart, 760 N. Main St., Bluffton, Indiana 46714 availability. STANDING COMMITTEES SPECIAL COMMITTEES NOMINATING COMMITTEE PROGRAM COMMITTEE PRESERVATION COMMITTEE Robert N. Converse, Chairman Jack Hooks, Chairman Dana Baker, Chairman Ensil Chadwick Martha Otto, Chairman Jan Sorgenfrei Wayne Mortine William Tiell Charles Stout, Sr. Don Bapst Charles Stout, Sr. Alva McGraw Jan Sorgenfrei Gordon Hart Bert Drennan David Brose John Winsch AUDITING COMMITTEE SPECIAL PUBLICATIONS Robert Hill, Chairman MEMBERSHIP COMMITTEE Charles Stout, Jr. COMMITTEE Don Gehlbach Owen Cowan Robert Converse, Chairman Jack Hooks Kendall Saunders Lar Hothem Tom Stropki Jeff Carskadden Jack Lanam Wayne Mortine Steve Parker Martha Otto EXHIBITS COMMITTEE George Morelock Gordon Hart Steve Balazs, Co-Chairman Ed Hughes RAFFLE COMMITTEE Don Gehlbach, Co-Chairman Charles Voshall Billy Hillen William Haney, Chairman John Baldwin Graig Clola Frank Otto Jerry Hagerty Earl Noble Dorothy Good FRAUDULENT ARTIFACTS EDUCATION AND PUBLICITY COMMITTEE LEGISLATIVE COMMITTEE Jan Sorgenfrei, Chairman Mike Kish, Chairman Alva McGraw, Chairman Doug Hooks Lar Hothem Dwight Shipley Don Bapst Dorothy Good David Kuhn Ernest Good Marylyn Harness Gilbert Dilley Jack Hooks Martha Otto Earl Townsend Joy Jones 2 EDITOR S PAGE TABLE OF CONTENTS Just recently I received an anonymous letter The FAI-270 Project and the Keller Figurine 4 from one of our members in northern Ohio. It de A Bird Point Site 8 tailed the activities of a person who allegedly fakes The Basinger Dovetail 8 artifacts and regularly sells them at flea markets and to collectors. To quote the letter "He is cheating Archaeological Conservancy Acquires Hopewell collectors and flea market dealers alike. He is Mounds 9 making gorgets, birdstones, pendants, trophy axes, A Mesoamerican Artifact in Ohio 12 bannerstones, from black, brown, and red and green A Lake Erie Bifurcated Point From Miller's Ridge .... 14 slate. He is also faking large and small sandstone Spencer Ohio Blade Cache and an Unusual Drill 15 effigy pipes". According to the writer, one of these Artifacts From the Glenn Spray Collection 17 fake pipes is pictured in a current archaeological Underwater Archaeological Find From Lake Erie .... 18 publication (not the Ohio Archaeologist). East Central Indiana-West Central Ohio Flint As with any unsigned letter, this one must be put Artifacts 19 in limbo on the basis that anyone who has been From Our Old Files 20 cheated should not be afraid to give his own name An Outstanding Adena Artifact From Putnam as well as the name of the person who allegedly cheated him. Anyone giving such information need County, Ohio 21 have no fear that his name will be divulged since it Alste Stemmed Pipes From The Vietzen Collection . .22 would be held in the strictest confidence anyway. Artistic Achievement In A Rare Pipe Form 23 The letter does, however, bring to focus a Surface Hunting in Indiana 24 continuing and growing problem—that of fake Some Outstanding Slate Artifacts From The artifacts. Frauds in the field of collecting and Walls Collection 25 archaeology have been perpetrated since the The Hunt Site (33BL16) Part V: Burials and middle of the nineteenth century—the Piltdown Interpretation 26 hoax being a case in point. In a number of early Part of the Copeland Collection 29 instances there seemed to be only an attempt to Intrusive Mound Type Pipes From The fool the "experts". The old archaeological journals Col. Raymond Vietzen Collection 30 are replete with pictures of fake items. Later, such Maize of the Brokaw Site 31 people as the Guffey family manufactured bird- An Engraved Slate Artifact 34 stones and bannerstones by the hundreds as a profitable business. Ohio Banner Axe 35 The Libben Site, Ottawa County, Ohio-Part IV 36 Today, with the technology of the lapidarist and the ever increasing research of archaeologists into Flint Artifacts From Southern Indiana 38 the flint knapping field, the faker has a ready body An Unusual Dental Wear Pattern In A Late of reference material he can use to perfect his Archaic Individual 39 frauds and make illegal money. Fraudulent Artifacts and Criminal Liability 42 One faker in particular, who I am sorry to say at Book Review 43 one time lived in Ohio and was a member of our My own personal advice to the unwary or novice Society, presently carries on a thriving business of collector is this—know who you are buying from or producing and selling fraudulent flint artifacts. For if you don't know him, ask the advice of someone several years he has been flooding the market with who is more knowledgable. While bargains oc his phony material. When confronted at one of our casionally surface at flea markets, and legitimate meetings by your Editor before he moved from our dealers often sell there, beware of those who seem state he fell back on the lame pretext that he was to have large numbers of birdstones, trophy axes, making "reproductions", a dishonest but convenient gorgets and pendants of exotic material, or banner refuge for such cheaters. This particular defrauder stones. Usually material of such quality does not now veils his dishonest activities with an aura of have to be carried to a flea market by a legitimate supposed honesty by publishing pseuo-scientific dealer to be disposed of. In addition.-if the seller is publications on flint chipping. In reality he has legitimate, he should have no qualms whatever probably done more to undermine legitimate about allowing return privileges on any piece he collecting and to break the hearts of unsuspecting sells. While the Archaeological Society of Ohio young collectors than any single person. Incredibly, cannot legally interfere with such fraudulent a recent archaeological publication actually ad practises, we can offer the services of our Fraudu vertised one of this charlatan's books which is lent Artifact Committee to give an opinion on analagous to giving a loaded gun to someone who questionable pieces. We can also remove from our is trying to shoot you. Ironically, advertising Society anyone who has been proved to sell such anything from such a faker for whatever reason material. defeats the very purpose to which this archaeologi Robert N. Converse cal journal is dedicated. Editor FRONT COVER The Keller figurine. The second of two outstanding figurines found during excavations of the FAI-270 Project near East St. Louis, Illinois. Its discovery is detailed in the article on pages 4, 5, 6, in this issue of The Ohio Archaeologist by project director Dr. fames W. Porter. 3 The FAI-270 Project and the Keller Figurine James W. Porter Project Director University of Illinois, Urbana-Champaign Photographs by Jeff Abrams, FAI-270 Project Fig. 1 (Porter) Rear view of Keller figurine. The Winter issue of this journal contained gation Project in Illinois can refer back to an article by N.E. Hakiel (1980) which was Hakiel's article since it contains the basic designed to briefly present the FAI-270 details about the project area and the potential Project objectives, record some of the results for the research involved.