A History of Australia's Defence White Papers
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
RESEARCH PAPER SERIES, 2015–16 20 AUGUST 2015 Defending Australia: a history of Australia’s defence white papers Nicole Brangwin, Nathan Church, Steve Dyer and David Watt Foreign Affairs, Defence and Security Section Executive summary • Australia published defence white papers in 1976, 1987, 1994, 2000, 2009 and 2013 and a new white paper is expected in 2015. • A community consultation process was undertaken as part of the 2000 and 2009 defence white papers and a similar process is being carried out for the upcoming 2015 defence white paper. • The need to defend Australia against a major aggressor remains the primary driver in Australian defence policy. • Regional security and contributing to the global order have been secondary, but still important priorities in Australian defence planning. • Each of the defence white papers has been created on the basis that Australia should be able to defend itself against a potential aggressor without outside assistance (the principle of self-reliance), while at the same time stressing the importance of the alliance with the United States. • Threat perceptions have changed from the Cold War influences reflected in the 1976 and 1987 white papers to a contemporary focus on terrorism while also incorporating emerging threats such as cyber attacks and the rise of China. • Defence white papers are not produced in a vacuum but are informed by key reviews of Australia’s strategic situation, industry policy and force posture. • Defence policy is subject to the broader economic conditions of the time and the Department of Defence must contend with many other priorities for government funding. • The financial plans set out in the various defence white papers are often ambitious and rarely brought to fruition. • On the whole, capability choices have displayed continuity between the different white papers regardless of changes in government. This is understandable given the length of time required for major capital equipment acquisitions. • Recent white papers have placed a greater emphasis on regional engagement. • The contribution of the Australian Defence Force (ADF) to humanitarian assistance and disaster relief operations, as well as to border protection activities, has also been included in the most recent white papers. ISSN 2203-5249 Introduction ................................................................................................ 4 Background ................................................................................................. 4 The purpose of Australia’s defence white papers .......................................... 5 Historical context: 1870–1976 ...................................................................... 6 Australian Defence (1976 Defence White Paper) .......................................... 11 Introduction .................................................................................................... 11 Strategic objectives ........................................................................................ 12 Identified capability choices ........................................................................... 12 Cost of capability ............................................................................................ 13 Alignment of cost, capability and strategic objectives ................................... 13 The Defence of Australia (1987 Defence White Paper) ................................. 16 Introduction .................................................................................................... 17 Review of Australia’s defence capabilities ................................................... 17 Review of Australia’s industry for defence .................................................. 18 Government response .................................................................................... 19 1987 Defence White Paper............................................................................... 20 Strategic objectives ........................................................................................ 20 Identified capability choices ........................................................................... 21 Alignment of cost, capability and strategic objectives ................................... 22 Defending Australia (1994 Defence White Paper) ........................................ 24 Introduction .................................................................................................... 25 Force Structure Review 1991 ....................................................................... 25 Australia’s Strategic Planning in the 1990s .................................................. 25 Strategic Review 1993 .................................................................................. 26 Public consultation – defence white paper process .................................... 26 1994 Defence White Paper............................................................................... 27 Strategic objectives ........................................................................................ 27 Identified capability choices ........................................................................... 29 Industry for defence ....................................................................................... 30 Alignment of cost, capability and strategic objectives ................................... 32 Defence 2000: Our Future Defence Force (2000 Defence White Paper) .......... 34 Introduction .................................................................................................... 34 Defence Efficiency Review 1996 .................................................................. 35 Australia’s Strategic Policy 1997 .................................................................. 36 Defence Review 2000—Our Future Defence Force: a Public Discussion Paper ............................................................................................................ 36 2000 Defence White Paper............................................................................... 37 Strategic objectives ........................................................................................ 37 Industry for defence ....................................................................................... 38 Defence Capability Plan .................................................................................. 40 Identified capability choices ........................................................................... 40 Cost of capability ............................................................................................ 42 Alignment of cost, capability and strategic objectives ................................... 42 Defending Australia: a history of Australia’s defence white papers 2 Australia’s National Security: A Defence Update 2003, 2005 and 2007 .......... 45 Introduction .................................................................................................... 46 2003 Defence Update ....................................................................................... 46 2005 Defence Update ....................................................................................... 48 2007 Defence Update ....................................................................................... 50 Defending Australia in the Asia Pacific Century: Force 2030 (2009 Defence White Paper) ..............................................................................................53 Introduction .................................................................................................... 54 2008 Audit of the Defence Budget ............................................................... 54 Looking Over the Horizon: Australians Consider Defence ........................... 55 Review of Australia’s air combat capability ................................................. 55 Force Structure Review ................................................................................ 56 Mortimer review .......................................................................................... 57 2009 Defence White Paper—Companion Reviews ...................................... 57 2009 Defence White Paper............................................................................... 57 Strategic Objectives ........................................................................................ 58 Identified Capability Choices .......................................................................... 60 Maritime forces ............................................................................................ 61 Land forces ................................................................................................... 62 Air power ...................................................................................................... 62 Defence industry ............................................................................................ 63 Defence Capability Plan 2009 ....................................................................... 64 Cost of capability ............................................................................................ 64 Alignment of cost, capability and strategic objectives ................................... 65 Defence White Paper 2013 (2013 Defence White Paper) .............................. 67 Introduction .................................................................................................... 68 Australian Defence Force Posture