City Life in Place Des Arts
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
City life in Place des Arts Prepared by Mahsa Mozayeni Supervised by Dr. Ipek Tureli Peter Guo-hua Fu School of Architecture McGill University, Montreal September 2018 Key words: Place des Arts, Urban design, Public space, Social interaction, Public life Abstract Place des Arts, in the Quartier des Spectacles, is one of the Montreal districts planned to increase socio-cultural activities by providing large-scale events and enhancing the quality of urban space to stimulate people to join together in city spaces and enjoy city life. The aim of this research is to analyze Place des Arts as a cultural and people-oriented public space to investigate how vibrant public life takes place in Place des Arts and how different people, as the users of this place, perceive it. This research argues whether Place des Arts is successful in terms of the quality of public life in order to explore how people interact with this public space in everyday life. By simultaneously focusing on observing current public life in Place des Arts, the semi- structured interviews with different users and studying the development process of Place des Arts, this paper attempts to explore what makes the experiences in Place des Arts comfortable and interesting for its users and how people use this public space for optional activities and social interaction. It also shows the practical limitations of the creative city concept in the cultural revitalization of Place des Arts. This research is conducted to determine the spatial and social characteristics of Place des Arts that promote the quality of public life. City life in Place des Arts Prepared by Mahsa Mozayeni Supervised by Dr. Ipek Tureli Peter Guo-hua Fu School of Architecture McGill University, Montreal September 2018 City life in Place des Arts By Mahsa Mozayeni Peter Guo-hua Fu School of Architecture McGill University, Montreal September 2018 A research project submitted to Graduate and postdoctoral Studies at McGill University In partial fulfillment of the requirements of the degree of M-Arch (Post- Professional) in Urban Design and Housing © Mahsa Mozayeni 2018 City life in Place des Arts Mahsa Mozayeni Table of Contents Abstract 3 Résumé 4 Acknowledgments 5 Chapter 1: Introduction and Literature Review 6 1.1.Statement of Problem 7 1.2.Objective and Research Questions 7 1.3.Literature Review 8 1.3.1 Vibrant Public life 8 1.3.1.1 Democratic Characteristics 9 1.3.1.2 Social Characteristics 10 1.3.1.3 Spatial Characteristics 14 1.4.Methodology 19 1.4.1 Observation 20 1.4.1.1 Behavioral mapping 20 1.4.1.2 Tracing 21 1.4.1.3 Photography 21 1.4.2 Semi-Structured Interviews 22 1.4.3 Sampling 23 1.5.Significance 24 1.6.Chapter summaries 25 Chapter 2: The Development of Place des Arts 27 2.1 The Project Objectives 28 2.2 Key Actors and Phases 31 2.3 Accessibility 37 2.4 Democratic Characteristics 41 2.4.1Environment for All 41 2.4.2 The Problems Associated with Gentrification 44 2.4.3 Practical Limitation of Creative City Concept 46 1 City life in Place des Arts Mahsa Mozayeni Chapter 3: The Users’ Experiences and Perceptions of Place des Arts 49 3.1 Social and Spatial Characteristics 50 3.1.1 Social Activities and Behavioral Patterns 50 3.1.2 Stationary Activities 51 3.1.3 Public Plays 62 3.1.4 Pedestrian Movements 64 3.1.5 Experiences and Perceptions 70 3.1.6 The Desire to Live near Place des Arts 71 3.2 The Method of Transport 72 3.3 Safety and Protection 73 3.4 Problems in the Users’ Perspectives 74 3.5 Findings 75 Conclusion 77 Bibliography 80 2 City life in Place des Arts Mahsa Mozayeni Abstract Place des Arts, in the Quartier des Spectacles, is one of the Montreal districts planned to increase socio-cultural activities by providing large-scale events and enhancing the quality of urban space to stimulate people to join together in city spaces and enjoy city life. The aim of this research is to analyze Place des Arts as a cultural and people-oriented public space to investigate how vibrant public life takes place in Place des Arts and how different people, as the users of this place, perceive it. This research argues whether Place des Arts is successful in terms of the quality of public life in order to explore how people interact with this public space in everyday life. By simultaneously focusing on observing current public life in Place des Arts, the semi- structured interviews with different users and studying the development process of Place des Arts, this paper attempts to explore what makes the experiences in Place des Arts comfortable and interesting for its users and how people use this public space for optional activities and social interaction. It also shows the practical limitations of the creative city concept in the cultural revitalization of Place des Arts. This research is conducted to determine the spatial and social characteristics of Place des Arts that promote the quality of public life. 3 City life in Place des Arts Mahsa Mozayeni Résumé La Place des Arts, dans le Quartier des spectacles, est l'un des quartiers montréalais prévus pour accroître les activités socioculturelles en organisant des événements de grande envergure et en améliorant la qualité de l'espace urbain pour inciter les gens à s’y retrouver L'objectif de cette recherche est d'analyser la Place des Arts en tant qu'espace public culturel et axé sur les citoyens afin d'étudier la vitalité de la vie publique sur la Place des Arts et la perception de différents groupes, en tant qu'utilisateurs de ce lieu. Cette recherche plaide en faveur du succès de la Place des Arts en termes de qualité de la vie publique afin d’explorer comment les gens interagissent avec cet espace public dans la vie quotidienne. En mettant l'accent simultanément sur l'observation de la vie publique actuelle à la Place des Arts, les entrevues semi-structurées avec différents utilisateurs et l'étude du processus de développement de la Place des Arts, cette recherche tente d'explorer ce qui rend les expériences de la Place des Arts confortables et intéressantes pour ses utilisateurs et comment les gens utilisent cet espace public pour des activités facultatives et des interactions sociales. Il montre également les limites pratiques du concept de ville créative dans la revitalisation culturelle de la Place des Arts. Cette recherche est menée pour déterminer les caractéristiques spatiales et sociales de la Place des Arts qui favorisent la qualité de la vie publique. 4 City life in Place des Arts Mahsa Mozayeni Acknowledgement I would like to thank my supervisor Dr. Ipek Tureli for her continuous guidance, valuable suggestions and availability over the last year that helped to complete this research. I am also grateful for her support and kindness to overcome difficulties in this research work. I would like also thank all my professors for the wonderful opportunities that they provided for the academic learning and background knowledge for this research. I appreciate Ms. Marcia King for her support and advices during my study in the last year. I am thankful for all people who participated in the interviews. My cardinal thanks to Dr. Richard Cooper for his help with editing this report and to Ms. Sonya Faber and Dr. Leila Ghaffari for their helps in French language matters. I am forever thankful to my family for their endless love and support to complete my study successfully. I am intensely grateful to my loving husband for his continues helps, encouragement and patience for immigration difficulties and completion of this program. 5 City life in Place des Arts Mahsa Mozayeni Chapter 1 Introduction and Literature Review 6 City life in Place des Arts Mahsa Mozayeni Chapter 1: Introduction 1.1 Statement of Problem Place des Arts, in the Quartier des Spectacles, is one of the Montreal districts planned to increase socio-cultural activities by performing festivals and enhancing the quality of urban space to stimulate people to join together in city spaces. This research examines the spatial and social experience of Place des Arts specially from the user’s perspective to investigate where and how dynamic public life takes place in this attractive city space. Although many current revitalization initiatives are centered on high technology or large infrastructures, this research emphasizes the essential role that cultural and artistic activities can play in the urban revitalization process to make urban spaces attractive. It also shows the practical limitations of the creative city concept in the cultural revitalization of Place des Arts. The different data collection methods, including the review of policy documents and plans, semi-structured interviews, site observation, tracing, photography and behavioral mapping provide the detailed foundation for the analysis of public life in Place des Arts as a vibrant and cultural public space. 1.2 Objective and Research Questions The objectives of this research are to study people’s activities and behavioral patterns in Place des Arts and to examine the democratic, social and spatial characteristics that make public life vibrant in this cultural public space. The research question for this study is as follows: How does vibrant public life take place in Place des Arts form and how different people perceive it? By simultaneously focusing on observing current public life in Place des Arts, the interviews with users and studying the development process of Place des Arts, this paper attempts to explore 7 City life in Place des Arts Mahsa Mozayeni what makes the experiences in Place des Arts comfortable and interesting for its users and how people use this public space for social activities and interactions.