Consultation on the Establishment of a New All-Age School for Pupils Aged 4-18 in Llanfair Caereinion
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
1 Establishment of a new all-age school for pupils aged 4-18 in Llanfair Caereinion Objection Report 1 Consultation on the establishment of a new all-age school for pupils aged 4-18 in Llanfair Caereinion Objection Report Contents 1. OVERVIEW OF THE CONSULTATION .............................................................. 3 2. OBJECTIONS RECEIVED .................................................................................. 3 3. ISSUES RAISED DURING THE OBJECTION PERIOD ..................................... 5 If you require a copy of the document in a different format, please contact the Transforming Education Team on 01597 826618, or e-mail [email protected]. 2 Consultation on the establishment of a new all-age school for pupils aged 4-18 in Llanfair Caereinion Objection Report 1. BACKGROUND Powys County Council consulted on proposals to establish a new all-age school for pupils aged 4-18 in Llanfair Caereinion. The consultation took place from the 13th October 2020 to the 24th November 2020. The Council published a consultation report outlining the findings of the consultation exercise. On 16th February 2021, the Council’s Cabinet agreed to proceed with the proposal, and Statutory Notices were published from the 23rd February 2021 to the 23rd March 2021. The proposals were as follows: From 31 August 2022: i) The Council proposes to discontinue the following two schools which are maintained by Powys County Council: Llanfair Caereinion Community Primary School/Ysgol Gynradd Llanfair Caereinion, Llanfair Caereinion, Welshpool, Powys, SY21 0SF (“Llanfair Caereinion C.P. School”); Caereinion High School, Llanfair Caereinion, Welshpool, Powys, SY21 0HW. From 1 September 2022: i) The Council proposes to establish a new bilingual community school maintained by Powys County Council for boys and girls aged 4-18 years old, that will operate on the current sites of Llanfair Caereinion C.P. School and Caereinion High School. 2. OBJECTIONS RECEIVED 31 objections were received during the statutory objection period. Objections were received from the following: - Parents of pupils at Caereinion High School, Ysgol Dafydd Llwyd and Ysgol Gymraeg y Trallwng - Members of the community - The governing body of Ysgol Dafydd Llwyd - The governing body of Ysgol Gymraeg y Trallwng 3 - Newtown & Llanllwchiarn Town Council - Rhieni dros Addysg Gymraeg (Parents for Welsh-medium Education) The issues raised in the objection are outlined on the following page, along with the Council’s response. 4 3. ISSUES RAISED DURING THE OBJECTION PERIOD The following headings and tables list the issues raised during the objection period, and provide the local authority’s response to these issues. Objection 1 Issue Points raised Council response 1.1 1) There are 26% of surplus places in the secondary Comment noted, however the current proposal relates to sector in Powys. establishing a new dual stream all-age school in Llanfair Caereinion, in the buildings currently occupied by Llanfair Caereinion C.P. School and Caereinion High School, and would not impact on surplus places. The Council is fully aware of the level of surplus places in its schools – ‘High number of surplus places’ is one of the reasons listed in the ‘Education in Powys – why change is needed’ section of the Strategy for Transforming Education in Powys. This is one of the reasons why the Council’s current intention is to develop designated Welsh-medium provision within its current infrastructure, in order to ensure that there is no increase in surplus places. 1.2 2) Political decision to support 13 secondary schools, The Council’s Strategy for Transforming Education in 5 in east Montgomeryshire. This decision is not Powys, which was approved in April 2020 includes an based on the logic of educational standards. objective to ‘Develop a network of all-age schools based around the 13 current secondary school locations’. The strategy was developed following engagement with a range of stakeholders, and the aim of the Strategy is to provide education which provides the best opportunities for 5 learners across Powys – the Strategy sets out a vision for education in Powys, which is as follows: ‘All children and young people in Powys will experience a high-quality, inspiring education to help develop the knowledge, skills and attributes that will enable them to become healthy, personally fulfilled, economically productive, socially responsible and globally engaged citizens of 21st century Wales.’ 1.3 3) Powys's dual-stream secondary schools policy The Council fully acknowledges the need to develop it’s since 1989 to provide Welsh-medium education has Welsh-medium provision. The Council’s Strategy for been an undoubted failure. No growth in the Transforming Education in Powys includes a clear aim to numbers of Welsh-medium pupils post 11. ‘Improve access to Welsh-medium provision across all key stages.’ The Council fully agrees that designated Welsh-medium schools are the preferred delivery model for Welsh-medium pupils, particularly for pupils from a non-Welsh speaking background. 1.4 4) The number of Welsh-medium secondary subjects The Council notes this statement and fully recognises the in Llanfair and Llanfyllin has shrunk over the last 6 need to improve the Welsh-medium provision available in years. Powys, in particular in the secondary sector. As stated in the Strategy for Transforming Education in Powys 2020-30: ‘The size and proportion of the secondary streams varies considerably across the county, and the range of subjects available through the medium of Welsh also varies significantly. The curriculum offer is increasingly limited for Welsh-medium learners, and there is significant concern 6 amongst the profession regarding the commitment of the authority to learners who study in Welsh.’ The Strategy includes an objective to ‘improve access to Welsh-medium provision across all key stages’, and the Council is developing a number of proposals which would eventually lead to a significant improvement in the Welsh- medium provision available in the county. The Council has also made clear throughout the process to establish an all-age school in Llanfair Caereinion that, should the Council proceed with the establishment of the new school, the intention would be to develop the Welsh- medium provision at the new school. When considering the consultation report in respect of the proposal to establish an all-age school in Llanfair Caerienion and approving continuing with the statutory process through the publication of a statutory notice, the Council’s Cabinet also agreed ‘to accelerate the dialogue with representatives of the two schools and the community to explore ways to develop and enhance the Welsh-medium provision in Llanfair Caereinion, and to include all feeder schools in this dialogue.’ Initial discussions have taken place with Caereinion High School and its feeder schools. Should the Cabinet approve the proposal to establish the all-age school in Llanfair Caereinion, this dialogue will continue with the temporary governing body and leadership of the new school, in order to move the school along the language continuum. Feeder 7 schools and other partners will be essential to help develop this vision. If the outcome of this is the need to change the school’s language category, a further statutory process would be required to implement this. 1.5 5) The main growth seen in Welsh-medium pupils has The Council notes the growth that has been seen in Welsh- been in designated primary schools. medium pupil numbers in designated primary schools over recent years. 1.6 6) Immersion in designated schools is the way The Council fully agrees that designated Welsh-medium forward. schools are the preferred delivery model for Welsh-medium pupils, particularly for pupils from a non-Welsh speaking background. 1.7 7) Any school transformation plan must be based on The Council’s new Strategy for Transforming Education in the priority and intention to provide the best Powys does aim to provide the best education to pupils education to pupils. Other considerations are less important. 1.8 8) Forcing parents to receive Welsh-medium education The Council is not forcing parents to receive Welsh-medium is not an effective method and neither does it education. recognise the right of parents to have a choice. Similar schemes have failed in other countries. The best way is to ensure that there is a clear choice for parents between two equivalent language mediums. 1.9 9) The schools and the authority have been guilty over The Council does not agree that it has misled parents the years of misleading parents about Welsh- regarding the Welsh-medium provision available over the medium provision. years. Any information shared by the Council was provided by the schools. 8 1.10 10) Powys education authority is prepared to ignore The Council does not agree with this statement. All facts by using misleading and factually incorrect decisions made related to school reorganisation are based arguments. The organisation does not make on carefully developed proposals and the reasons for decisions on the basis of the validity and merits of proposals are clearly stated in consultation documents and relevant matters, or provide sufficient rationale to Cabinet reports. justify them. It is a reason why Powys education authority has been judged to be a failure. It is not true that Powys education authority has been judged to be ‘a failure’ – Estyn carried out an inspection of Powys education services, which concluded that ‘Powys local government education services are causing significant concern and require follow-up activity.’ Estyn made a number of recommendations in its report. Much work has been done since then to address these, and good progress is being made. 1.11 Considerations arising from the above. The Council is not currently considering wholescale closure A) Too many surplus places. of any of its secondary schools. The ‘Strategy for 1) With funding scarce it is incumbent that the Transforming Education in Powys’ includes a clear authority ensures that there is no waste of public commitment to developing ‘a network of all-age schools money.