Study Circles Participant Manual
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Study Circles Participant Manual One World United & Virtuous A Non-Profit Education Foundation 55 Hillandale Rd. Rye Brook, New York 10573 www. oneworlduv.com (US) 914-939-3766 2 Contents An Introduction to Study Circles Outline of Syllabus 4 Session One Reading • An Introduction to One World Untied and Virtuous 12 Session One Agenda Session Two Reading • The Legacy of Cosmopolitanism 22 Session Two Agenda 35 Session Three Readings • Global Citizenship, Appiah 36 • The Resurgent Idea of World Government, Craig 47 Session Three Agenda 56 Session Four Readings • Article About Kung 57 • Global Ethic Article by Kung 62 • Universal Declaration of Human Rights 68 Session Four Agenda 73 • Basic Human Rights Activity 75 Session Five Reading • Beck: Cosmopolitanism is in the Air 76 • Case Study on Intervention 83 • The Travels of a Tee Shirt (optional) 86 Session Five Agenda 90 • The Fifty Dollar Tent 92 • Session Six Readings • Moving From Talk to Action 93 • Action Plan 98 Session Six Agenda 100 Supplemental Readings 101 Feedback Form 118 3 An Introduction to Study Circles Welcome, and thank you for agreeing to participate in this unique series of One World Study Circles. One World United and Virtuous is a grassroots not-for-profit educational foundation that seeks to foster the body of knowledge on the idealistic legacy of cosmopolitanism and world citizenship, blending those concepts with our real world experience to create learning vehicles and action projects that nurture the perception of common humanity among peoples and groups, and lead to more effective means of global cooperation, governance, and communication. This series of One World Study Circles is intended as a first step. We started at my dining room table with friends and neighbors, now, One World study circles are video-conferenced internationally. We also involve ourselves directly through One World-related service projects and organizations that build community bridges, One World school clubs, and educational programs intended to foster cosmopolitanism. We are not allied with, nor do we represent the views of, any existing political party, religion, or fraternal/civic organization, and we will actively discourage the advocacy of partisan views. The goal of these conversations will be to foster a greater awareness of our “global citizenship”, of our connection to each other across the boundaries of nations and states, of ethnicity, race and religion, socio-economic status and gender. One World Study Circles are intended to provide a safe space for the democratic exchange of ideas on the social and political issues relevant to cosmopolitanism. They are vehicles for deliberation, but they are also intended to be vehicles for community building and action planning. We hope you find these discussions enlightening, engaging, and open to your participation in this grand endeavor. Jack J. Zaccara Director of Education 4 Outline of Syllabus: One World Study Circles Session One Theme: Introduction to OWUV Foundation and the Business Case for One World Advance reading: An Introduction to One World United & Virtuous Discussion: A. Intro of One World United & Virtuous • Background (5 minutes) • Mission and Vision (5 minutes) B. Personal Introductions (20 minutes) • A brief personal introduction • A brief statement of motivation for coming to study circle C. Study Circles Overview • Goals and expectations (5 minutes) • Syllabus and Structure of classes (5 minutes) D. Ground Rules for Respectful Dialogue (5 minutes) E. Q and A opportunity before proceeding (10 minutes) F. Facilitator conducts a quick review of the main points of the pre-reading: “An Introduction to One World United & Virtuous” (10 minutes) G. Facilitator leads a discussion on the group’s reaction to the Business Case (55 minutes) in particular: • What was their general reaction to the reading? • What were the most compelling items to them? • How practical are our goals? • What are their concerns about the goals of our foundation? • Do you believe “ordinary” people can make a difference? • What would motivate them to become involved? • What are the areas they’d like to know more about H. Homework: The Legacy of Cosmopolitanism (Thumbnails) (2 minutes) I. Reflections on our first session J. Unstructured social time 5 Session Two Theme: The Rich History of Cosmopolitan Thinking Advance reading: The Legacy of Cosmopolitanism - Pick one person to report out on Discussion: A. Welcome back and group “housekeeping” (5 minutes) B. Weekly check-in on One World in the news or personal stories of “One World moments” you’ve encountered since our last meeting (30 minutes) C. Discuss reaction to thumbnails. • What was you general reaction to this reading? • Who did you choose to report out on? Why? • Do individual report-outs • Include examples of individuals who transitioned from introspection and theorizing to action…what moved them to action? • What was their moral imperative? How were they different and similar? • How did they think about effectiveness and moral choice? • Do you know of any thinkers or leaders who are currently talking about cosmopolitanism? • Why are there few, if any, group entities that work to make One World a reality? (25 minutes) • How does all this history relate to the “Business case” for One World we discussed last week? D. Facilitator leads: (20 minutes) • How do you define your community? • What communities do you participate in? • How does nation-state affiliation color your world view? • How are your responsibilities different for people who are inside or outside of your community? E. “Thanksgiving turkey for your neighbors vs. writing a check for Darfur” exercise. Why was this easy or difficult? What kinds of considerations came into play? (15 minutes) F. Homework: Appiah Keynote on Gl0bal Citizenship and Campbell Craig, The Resurgent Idea of World Government G. Reflections (5 minutes) H. Social time over coffee, unstructured discussion 6 Session Three Theme: What is our Moral Responsibility to Others? Advance Reading: Appiah Keynote on Global Citizenship, Campbell Craig, The Resurgent Idea of World Government A. Welcome back and group “housekeeping” (5 minutes) B. Weekly check-in on One World in the news or personal stories of “One World moments” you’ve encountered since our last meeting (30 minutes) C. Discuss Appiah and Craig reading: 1. Do you agree with the 3 points Appiah makes early? • We do not need a single world government • We must care for the fate of all human beings • We have much to gain from conversations with one another across our differences 2. Appiah’s concern about world government is that “different communities are entitled to live according to different standards… Must a world government require all communities to live under the same standards? 3. Is One World a threat to cultural diversity? 4. Must cosmopolitanism be relativistic in accepting all cultural practices? 5. Are there cultural practices you can think of that would be unacceptable to you? 6. What can or should you do to change that? 8. How has globalization impacted One World thinking (positively? negatively?) 9. How has technology impacted One World thinking? 10. Do you think world government is desirable as the only way to prevent nuclear war? 11. Do you think world government is inevitable? 12. How does the European Union fit as a One World Model? F. Homework: Consolidated inventory of human rights document, Kung reading (5 minutes) G. Reflections (5 minutes) H. Social time over coffee, unstructured discussion. 7 Session Four Theme: Global Ethics and the Quest for Universal Rights & Responsibilities Advance reading: Consolidated inventory of human rights document, Kung reading Discussion: A. Welcome back and group “housekeeping” admin/ground rules, etc. (5 minutes) B. Check-in on One World “AHA” moments or One World “in the news” that week (20 minutes) C. Facilitator led discussion on Kung reading. Some suggested discussion questions include: 1. Was there anything that stood out for you in the Kung reading? 2. Do you think a global ethic might ever be attainable? 3. Is there a “necessary minimum of common values, standards, and basic attitudes? 4. What role does religion play in either helping or hindering a values consensus? 5. Do you agree with Kung’s assertion that “there can be no new world order without a world ethic, a global ethic? 6. Could this be achieved without imposing the norms of one culture upon another? 7. Kung talks about human responsibilities as well as human rights. Do you agree that individual rights should not be dependent upon someone meeting their human responsibility? 8. Lets discuss his three summary statements and how you feel about each one: i. There will be no survival of our globe without a global ethic. ii. There will be no peace among the nations without peace among the religions. iii. There will be no peace among the religions without dialogue and cooperation among the religions and civilizations C. Activity: How Easy is a Global Ethic? Facilitator leads exercise: 8 1. Each person must decide which 3 rights from the handout “Thirteen Basic Human Rights” they would choose as the most important. Give individuals the right to edit a statement to make it more acceptable to them. 2. After each person has decided, split the study circle into groups of 3 or 4 people and ask each group to negotiate an agreement on the 3 most important basic rights. 3. As time allows, ask the groups to then try and reach agreement with each other on the top 3 basic rights. D. Discussion Questions: 1. How easy was it for you to decide on three rights individually? 2. What did you struggle with? 3. Did you use your editorial right on any statement? 4. What was the process like in small group? 5. Who led? Dominated? Was the mediator? 6. Were you able to agree? Why or why not? 7.