DOCSLIB.ORG

United States of Aimerica Before Federal Trade Commission

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
United States of Aimerica Before Federal Trade Commission PUBLIC RECORD VERSION UNITED STATES OF AIMERICA BEFORE FEDERAL TRADE COMMISSION DOCKET NO. 9273 In the lMatter of TOYS “R” US a corporation. INITIAL DECISION James P. Timony Administrative Law Judge Date: September 25, 1997 —— UNITED STATES OF AMERICA BEFORE FEDERAL TRADE COMMISSION ) In the Matter of ) ) Docket No. 9278 TOYS “R” US ) a corporation. ) ) IMTIAL DECISION By James P. Timony, Administrative Law Judge L. Barry Costilo, Esq.; Richard B. Dagen, Esq.; Patrick J. Roach, Esq.; Sara Oxenham Allen, Esq.; James W. Frost, Esq.; Michael E. Antalics, Esq.; Mary Forster, Industry Analyst: Patrice Parker. FTC Assistant; and Bradley Podliska, Paralegal Counsel Supporting the Complaint Michael S. Feldberg, Esq.; Harry S. Da\is, Esq.; Royce L Wain, Esq. Todd S. Fishman, Esq. Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP 900 Third Avenue New York, New York 10022 Irving Scher, Esq. Weil Gotchal & Manges LLP 767 Fifth Avenue New York, New York 10153 Counsel for Respondent. I I I TABLE 01’ CONTENTS Introduction . ...1 FINDINGS . ...3 RETAIL SALE OF TOYS INTHE UNITED STATES . ...3 A. Respondent . ...3 Toy Industry . ...3 1. Retail sale oftoys . ...3 7 Toy manufacturing . ...4 B. warehouse Clubs . ...5 1. Growth . .5 -.7 Toy sales . ...8 AGREEhlE\”?’S . ...9 .\. lVarehouse Clubs as an Innovation . ...9 B. TRUandthe JVare!louse Clubs. ...12 1. Toy manufacturers..,,...,.. ...10 -.? Ceasing sales totheclul’s . ...13 . -’ Coordinated response . ...15 4, Nlanufhcturers . ...17 -.i O[{ici Pr”o 01{() . ...17 6. TRU”sorchestration oicombination . 18 71. TRU-s intent . ...23 c, .~greements . .,, . ., ., ., . ...24 1. Mattel . ..24 -.7 Hasbro . .....~~ . -.1 Fisher-Price, . ......~l 4. Tyco Toys . ..~~ 5. Little Tikes . ..~$ 6. Today’s Kids . ..52 7. Tiger Electronics . ...54 8. VTech Industries . ...57 9. Binney & Smith . ...57 10. Leg~, ,,, , ..,,,,,,,.,.,,, . ...58 11. Saga . ...59 12. Huffy . ...61 13. JustToys . ...63 14. New Bright . ...63 D. Success ofthe TRU Campaign. ...63 AXTICONIPETITIVEEF FECTS. ., . ...64 .4. Effects . ...64 1. TRUimpeded growthoftheclubs . ..64 a. gro~mllofthe~t’arellotlse clubs . ...64 _ b. the clubs’ ability toobtainregdar Iine toy products . .66 c. the clubs ability [o obtain products frollllnajor l~lan~lfactLlrers .67 -.7 Retail price competition . ...67 a. TRU’sprices to consumers . ...67 b. the clubs’ prices . ..68 3. The warehouse clubs’ pricecornpetition . .,, . ...69 B. \larket Power . , . ...71 1. TRU’s buyerpower . , . ...73 -.7 TRLT’spower atretail .,...... ...76 DEFENSES . ., . ...73 A. Economic Defenses . ...78 1. .\dvertisinS . ...79 -.7 In-store promotion . ...’..... ...80 . -~ Sho~vroom . ..81 4, Year-round ftdl line. ,,, ..,.,.,..,,...,,..,.,,, . ...82 -.5 Compensation . ...83 6. Benetlts to TRU . ...85 7, “Hot’’T oys . ...85 s. “Free-Ride” . ...86 9, Overall costs and benefits . ..S6 B, Other Defenses . ...87 RE}lEDY . ., . ..SS LEG~\L.4N-ALYSIS, .,,.,..,.. ,,, ,., ., . ..S9 .-\GREEYIEXTS . , . ...92 ,4. Vertical Agreement, .,.... ...92 1. klanufacturers’ acquiescence. ...93 -.? Advance approval . ...101 3. Colgat e . ...101 B. Horizontal Agreement . ...102 1. Manufacturers’i nterest . ...102 7-. Coordinated response .,....... ..103 3. Manufacturers would goalong . ...104 4. Ouid Pro Our . ...104 5. TRU’s assurances . ...105 6. Policing the agreemen t...... ...106 7. NlanLlfacttlrers contactect eacllotller. 107 s. Summary ofagreement . ...107 c. ProofofAgreement . ...109 D. RuleofReaso n . ......lo~ _ 1. Non-price vertical restraint . ., . ..
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Music Industry Tastemaker Randy Jackson Joins Hasbro's PLAYSKOOL Brand to Celebrate the Launch of LET's ROCK! ELMO
    September 20, 2011 Music Industry Tastemaker Randy Jackson Joins Hasbro's PLAYSKOOL Brand to Celebrate the Launch of LET'S ROCK! ELMO Most Interactive Elmo Toy Yet Invites Kids to Make Music in Rock Star Fashion PAWTUCKET, R.I., Sept. 20, 2011 /PRNewswire/ -- Are you ready to rock? It's show time as Hasbro Inc.'s (NASDAQ: HAS) iconic PLAYSKOOL brand introduces the LET'S ROCK! ELMO interactive plush, the most innovative Elmo toy yet. Joined by music industry veteran and Grammy Award-winning producer Randy Jackson, LET'S ROCK! ELMO made his official debut at a private event yesterday at the Empire Hotel in New York, NY. Known for his ability to guide the next generation of music superstars into the spotlight, Jackson was on hand to offer advice as LET'S ROCK! ELMO takes the stage at retail this fall. The truly interactive LET'S ROCK! ELMO plush character sings, plays instruments, and invites little musicians to rock out with him! To view the multimedia assets associated with this release, please click: http://www.multivu.com/mnr/52202-randy-jackson-joins- hasbro-playskool-for-let-s-rock-elmo-launch (Photo: http://photos.prnewswire.com/prnh/20110920/MM70945 ) Children can sing along with their favorite red furry rocker to six on-board songs, including the popular "Elmo's World," "What Elmo Likes About You" and original "Elmo Likes to Rock & Roll," while the LET'S ROCK! ELMO toy jams along. When children hand LET'S ROCK! ELMO the included drums, tambourine or microphone, he recognizes which instrument he is playing! Little musicians can join in with a LET'S ROCK! guitar, keyboard or microphone (each sold separately) to form their own rock band with the LET'S ROCK! ELMO toy.
    [Show full text]
  • Download the List of History Films and Videos (PDF)
    Video List in Alphabetical Order Department of History # Title of Video Description Producer/Dir Year 532 1984 Who controls the past controls the future Istanb ul Int. 1984 Film 540 12 Years a Slave In 1841, Northup an accomplished, free citizen of New Dolby 2013 York, is kidnapped and sold into slavery. Stripped of his identity and deprived of dignity, Northup is ultimately purchased by ruthless plantation owner Edwin Epps and must find the strength to survive. Approx. 134 mins., color. 460 4 Months, 3 Weeks and Two college roommates have 24 hours to make the IFC Films 2 Days 235 500 Nations Story of America’s original inhabitants; filmed at actual TIG 2004 locations from jungles of Central American to the Productions Canadian Artic. Color; 372 mins. 166 Abraham Lincoln (2 This intimate portrait of Lincoln, using authentic stills of Simitar 1994 tapes) the time, will help in understanding the complexities of our Entertainment 16th President of the United States. (94 min.) 402 Abe Lincoln in Illinois “Handsome, dignified, human and moving. WB 2009 (DVD) 430 Afghan Star This timely and moving film follows the dramatic stories Zeitgest video 2009 of your young finalists—two men and two very brave women—as they hazard everything to become the nation’s favorite performer. By observing the Afghani people’s relationship to their pop culture. Afghan Star is the perfect window into a country’s tenuous, ongoing struggle for modernity. What Americans consider frivolous entertainment is downright revolutionary in this embattled part of the world. Approx. 88 min. Color with English subtitles 369 Africa 4 DVDs This epic series presents Africa through the eyes of its National 2001 Episode 1 Episode people, conveying the diversity and beauty of the land and Geographic 5 the compelling personal stories of the people who shape Episode 2 Episode its future.
    [Show full text]
  • Attalion April 4, 1996
    Vol. 24, No. 13 Serving Marine Forces Pacific, MCB Hawaii, III Marine Expeditionary Forces, Hawaii and 1st Radio Battalion April 4, 1996 ... Stingers launch i 414 at PTA p Steven Williams 1..5l. He was at the Beach Bash. POHAKULOA TRAINING AREA, 144ftrer- Were you? See B-1 for story. Hawaii -- Okinawa's 1st Stinger Battery, Marine Aircraft Group-18, from Marine Corps Air Station Easter Sunrise Futenma, tested its new ANfrWQ-1 Avenger Air Defense Weapons Service at K-Bay Systems recently at Pohakuloa Rifle Range Training Area. After receiving 30 Avengers by Jan. The base chaplain will host an 1, the battery wanted to test its new Easter service Sunday at 6 a.m., technology in the field, according to at the MCB Hawaii rifle range. Maj. Steven M. Lesher, lstStingBatt For more information. call Petty commanding officer. Officer 1st Class Wood, 257-3552. "This gives us a lot of new capabili- Steven An AN/TVVQ-1 Avenger Air Defense Weapons System, operated by 1st Stinger Battery, Marine Air Group-18 launches ties," said Lesher. We now have a an FM-92A Stinger missile at an aerial heat source during the battery's annual training exercise at Pohakuloa Training 24-hour weapons system. We can Area. Firing the Corps' only ground-to-air, heat-seeking missile, the Okinawa-based battery hit the field in Hawaii recently Easter services find targets at night and engage to test its new Stinger slinger. them as well." some only saw through simulators, Roman Catholic Stinger Marines came to the island which are like "big video games," Thursday at 6 p.m.
    [Show full text]
  • Connecticut Word Wizards Win National School SCRABBLE(R) Championship
    May 5, 2007 Connecticut Word Wizards Win National School SCRABBLE(R) Championship 100 Teams From Across the Nation Competed for National Title PROVIDENCE, R.I., May 5 /PRNewswire/ -- More than a million students play the SCRABBLE® game in approximately 20,000 schools nationwide. Students from across the country hung on every word to see which team would triumph at the 2007 National School SCRABBLE Championship held this weekend in Providence at the Rhode Island Convention Center. A team from the Ridgefield Library in Ridgefield, Conn. won the 2007 National School SCRABBLE Championship. Aune (pronounced Ow-na) Mitchell, 14 of Ridgefield, Conn. and her teammate Matthew Silver, 13 of Westport, Conn. walked away with $5,000. During the final Championship round, the Connecticut team defeated Joey Krafchick, 12 of Roswell, Ga. and Dorian Hill, 13 of Lithonia, Ga. This year's competition had a new twist: ESPN will telecast the Championship as kids head back to school in late August/September 2007. SCRABBLE, the world's most popular crossword game, combines the vocabulary skills of crossword puzzles and anagrams, with the additional element of chance. A family favorite since 1948, the board game today is found in one out of every three homes, according to Hasbro, makers of the SCRABBLE game in the United States and Canada. "Kids everywhere, from all parts of the country, and from all walks of life, love to play SCRABBLE because it's challenging, fun and allows the kids to be creative," says John D. Williams, Jr., executive director, National SCRABBLE Association. "It's not unusual for competitors of this event to have been competing against adults -- and beating them - -in SCRABBLE tournaments across the country." Word Play: Let the Games Begin Teams of 5-8 grade students from the Oregon to Florida competed, playing in teams of two in the tournament.
    [Show full text]
  • Page 1 of 2) COMPUTATION of INCOME PER COMMON and COMMON EQUIVALENT SHARE ------(In Thousands, Except Per Share Amounts)
    ================================================================================ SECURITIES AND EXCHANGE COMMISSION Washington, D.C. 20549 FORM 10-K (Mark One) [X] Annual report pursuant to section 13 or 15(d) of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934 [Fee Required] for the fiscal year ended December 31, 1994. [_] Transition report pursuant to section 13 or 15(d) of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934 [No Fee Required] for the transition period from _________ to _________. Commission File Number 001-05647 - --------------------------------- MATTEL, INC. ------------ (Exact name of registrant as specified in its charter) Delaware 95-1567322 - ---------------------------------- ------------------- (State or other jurisdiction (I.R.S. Employer of incorporation or organization) Identification No.) 333 Continental Boulevard, El Segundo, California 90245-5012 - ------------------------------------------------- ---------- (Address of principal executive offices) (Zip Code) (Registrant's telephone number) (310) 252-2000 -------------- Securities registered pursuant to Section 12(b) of the Act: Name of each exchange Title of each class on which registered - ------------------- --------------------- Common stock, $1 par value (and New York Stock Exchange the associated Preference Pacific Stock Exchange Share Purchase Rights) 6-7/8% Senior Notes Due 1997 New York Stock Exchange 6-3/4% Senior Notes Due 2000 (None) Securities registered pursuant to Section 12(g) of the Act: (None) Indicate by check mark whether the registrant (1) has filed all reports
    [Show full text]
  • Hasbro's Iconic MR. POTATO HEAD Character Celebrates 60Th Birthday
    February 14, 2012 Hasbro's Iconic MR. POTATO HEAD Character Celebrates 60th Birthday Everyone's Favorite Tater Commemorates 60 Spud-tastic Years as a Pop Culture Icon PAWTUCKET, R.I.--(BUSINESS WIRE)-- This year, Hasbro, Inc. (NASDAQ: HAS) will mark the 60th anniversary of the Company's official "spokes spud," the MR. POTATO HEAD character. A classic rite of passage for most preschoolers, the MR. POTATO HEAD toy is one of Hasbro's most cherished characters with more than 100 million toys sold in more than 30 markets around the world. Through the past 60 years, the timeless tater has evolved from a toy box classic into a pop culture icon and has kept himself relevant by tapping into trends and entertainment. "For the past 60 years, the MR. POTATO HEAD toy has inspired imaginative play in young children and charmed fans of all ages through his roles in movies and on television." said Jerry Perez, Senior Vice President and Global Brand Leader, Playskool. "We're thrilled to see that he has evolved from classic parts and pieces to a household name that is ‘rooted' in pop culture and entertainment." The MR. POTATO HEAD character will celebrate this milestone year on his Facebook page enjoying a year of adventures with the MRS. POTATO HEAD character, starting with a birthday bash at American International Toy Fair in New York City. New product introductions for 2012 include the MASHLY IN TH LOVE MR. AND MRS. 60 ANNIVERSARY EDITION set featuring the couple holding Mr. and Mrs. Potato Head admire a birthday cake as a group sings to celebrate Mr.
    [Show full text]
  • Resume Artisan
    MARK WIESENHAHN VERSATILE German origin: Wiese:(n) yard, meadow, or farm. Hahn:(n) rooster or hen. A free-ranging creative always on the lookout for problems to solve, products to design, businesses to build, stories to tell, and consumers to engage, entertain, and empower! CURIOUS WHO? Pronounciation: “weeze-n-hon” CREATIVELEADER A proven creative leader with experience designing, developing, and implementing successful global products, programs, and stories. A problem solving partner who connects brand centric strategies, stories, products and experiences to seamlessly engage, entertain, and empower their consumers. INNOVATOR Who thrives in and works to create fun, collaborative, dynamic, risk-taking, idea and results driven teams that aren’t afraid to take creative leaps...I always STORYTELLER pack an extra parachute. SELECT ACCOMPLISHMENTS Global Property Development & Creative Brand Management Created and managed Hasbro’s Global Property Development Team After Hasbro made the strategic pivot from a toy and game manufacturer to a branded entertainment company, I led the development team charged with envisioning and Produced over 200 episodes of executing a total brand development process centered around our brand story. entertainment and $1B in total Leveraging this process my team set the brand’s creative vision, strategy, and story commercial revenue. which activated the brand’s commercial blueprint. We worked with all brand partners to align their products and expressions against the blueprint (including core toy and game Grew the Girl’s Entertainment Portfolio products, digital games, entertainment, publishing, and licensed goods). from $125M to over $500M in 3 years. Our branded entertainment development process drove the successful launches of the Grew the Pre-School Entertainment My Little Pony, The Littlest PetShop, Transformers, Transformers Rescue Heroes, Chuck Portfolio by $50M in the first year.
    [Show full text]
  • Level 2 National the FANCY KRYMSUN 19.5
    2019 AQHA WORLD CHAMPIONSHIP SHOW OPEN DIVISION QUALIFIERS If you have questions on your status as a qualifier, please email AQHA Show Events Coordinator Heidi Lane at [email protected]. As a reminder, entry forms and qualifier information will be sent to the email address on file for the current owner of the qualified horse. View more information about how to update or verify your email address under Latest News and Blogs at www.aqha.com/worldshow Owner - Alpha by First Name Horse Points Class Qualifier Type 2 N LAND & CATTLE COMPANY INC THE FANCY KRYMSUN 19.5 JUNIOR TRAIL - Level 2 National 2 N LAND & CATTLE COMPANY INC THE FANCY KRYMSUN 19.5 JUNIOR TRAIL - Level 3 National 2 N LAND & CATTLE COMPANY INC THE FANCY KRYMSUN 11 PERFORMANCE HALTER MARES- Level 2 National 2 N LAND & CATTLE COMPANY INC THE FANCY KRYMSUN 11 PERFORMANCE HALTER MARES- Level 3 National 6V LIVESTOCK LLC DIAMOND STYLIN SHINE 17.5 JUNIOR DALLY TEAM ROPING-HEELING - LV2 National 6V LIVESTOCK LLC DIAMOND STYLIN SHINE 17.5 JUNIOR DALLY TEAM ROPING-HEELING - LV3 National 6V LIVESTOCK LLC DIAMOND STYLIN SHINE 2.5 PERFORMANCE HALTER STALLIONS - Level 2 National 6V LIVESTOCK LLC DIAMOND STYLIN SHINE 2.5 PERFORMANCE HALTER STALLIONS - Level 3 National 6V LIVESTOCK LLC LEOS SILVER SHINE 18.5 JUNIOR DALLY TEAM ROPING-HEADING - LV2 National 6V LIVESTOCK LLC LEOS SILVER SHINE 18.5 JUNIOR DALLY TEAM ROPING-HEADING - LV3 National 70 RANCH PERFORMANCE HORSES DEZ SHE BOON 11 SENIOR RANCH RIDING - LEVEL 2 National 70 RANCH PERFORMANCE HORSES DEZ SHE BOON 11 SENIOR RANCH RIDING -
    [Show full text]
  • Sega Special Back to Skool Mortal Kombat Gaming Ages
    RG17 Cover UK.qxd:RG17 Cover UK.qxd 20/9/06 16:09 Page 1 retro gamer COMMODORE • SEGA • NINTENDO • ATARI • SINCLAIR • ARCADE * VOLUME TWO ISSUE FIVE Sega Special Game Gear, Mega-CD & Sonic Back to Skool ...with the game’s creators Gaming Ages Dawn of the digital era Mortal Kombat Blood ‘n’ guts gaming Retro Gamer 17 £5.99 UK $14.95 AUS V2 $27.70 NZ 05 Untitled-1 1 1/9/06 12:55:47 RG17 Intro/Contents.qxd:RG17 Intro/Contents.qxd 20/9/06 16:27 Page 3 <EDITORIAL> Editor = Martyn "Faxe & Dab" Carroll ([email protected]) Deputy Editor = Aaron Birch ([email protected]) Art Editor = Craig Chubb Sub Editors = Rachel White + James Clark Contributors = Alicia Ashby + Roy Birch Simon Brew + Richard Burton Jonti Davies + Adam Dawes Paul Drury + Frank Gasking Mark Green + Damien Kapa Craig LewisPer + Arne Sandvik Spanner Spencer + John Szczepaniak <PUBLISHING & ADVERTISING> Operations Manager = Glen Urquhart Group Sales Manager = Linda Henry Advertising Sales = Danny Bowler Accounts Manager = ow great are normally a problem in Retro take place in Kenilworth. Details Karen Battrick magazines? You Gamer, as by its very nature the are a bit thin on the ground at the Circulation Manager = hellocan buy them in a contents aren’t time-sensitive, but moment, but seeing as you’re Steve Hobbs Marketing Manager = shop, take them occasionally some of the things reading this in the future, further Iain "Chopper" Anderson H home, carry them we report can be a little old hat details are probably all over the Editorial Director = from room to room, read them at by the time you read them.
    [Show full text]
  • Mattel Recalls 2007
    Mattel Recalls 2007 Communication Implications for Quality Control, Outsourcing, and Consumer Relations [ABSTRACT] In August 2007, America's largest toy manufacturer announced the first of what would become five recalls involving 21 million toys—most of which were manufactured in China. This case study and teaching note examine a corporate response to a global crisis and consider the unique communications challenges facing a corporation that operates in an international, cross- cultural arena. The teaching note critiques the response’s suitability to the level and impact of the crisis and recommends alternatives. It illustrates that communicators should be cognizant of their international stakeholders and should proactively manage global issues of public concern such as outsourcing and product safety. An example would be that to avert future recalls, Mattel should work closely with its Chinese suppliers and government agencies to implement realistic quality control solutions for which it can be held accountable. The company must reassure stakeholders that outsourcing to China does not mean sacrificing quality. Regaining consumer confidence and controlling the dissemination of product safety information requires strong corporate communicators who can delicately and deliberately balance complex relationships. Table of Contents I. Case Study 2 1. Overview 2 2. Company History 2 2.1 Beginnings 2 2.2 Reorganization as Mattel, Inc. 3 2.3 Products 3 2.4 Accolades for Ethics 3 2.5 Financial Performance and Annual Report (2006) 4 3. Toy Safety in the United States 4 3.1 Consumer Product Safety Commission (CPSC) Standards 4 3.2 Mattel's Independent Standards 5 4. Issues in Outsourcing to China 6 4.1 China as the World’s Workshop 6 4.2 Quality Control Challenges and Implications 7 4.3 Mattel’s China Operations 7 4.4 Managing International Communication 8 5.
    [Show full text]
  • Mattel, Inc. 2001 Annual Report
    ENERGIZE GLOBALIZE MOBILIZE 2001 MATTEL, INC. ANNUAL REPORT e - op.ti.mize (op˘ ‘t -miz’) tr.v. -mized, -miz.ing, -miz.es 1. To make as perfect or effective as possible. 2. To increase the computing speed and efficiency of. 3. To make the most of. 1 To our shareholders DESPITE THE SIGNIFICANT CHALLENGES WE FACED DURING 2001, MATTEL HAD A SUCCESSFUL YEAR AND IS POISED TO CONTINUE IMPROVING ITS PERFORMANCE IN THE YEARS AHEAD. 2001 presented substantial obstacles for international performance. Our business our company. Global economies softened; also grew strongly in Latin America the September 11th terrorist attacks eroded (20 percent), Canada (10 percent) and U.S. consumer confidence; and as a result, Australia/New Zealand (3 percent). several important U.S. retailers canceled holiday reorders as they intensified their In last year’s letter to shareholders, I wrote focus on inventory management in light of that one of our key priorities for 2001 was uncertain consumer spending prospects. to strengthen core brand momentum in the U.S. and abroad. And we did just that. As a result, despite reaching record levels, Consumer demand for our brands grew Mattel’s three percent worldwide net rev- around the world as we gained market enue growth for the year was at the low end share in virtually every country where of our expectations. A precipitous eight we sell our products. In the U.S., despite percent decline in U.S. shipments during weaker-than-expect- the fourth quarter brought full-year gross ed shipments to revenues down one percent in the U.S., retailers, all of our the world’s largest toy market.
    [Show full text]
  • A Truly Great Company, with the Very Best People, a Compelling Underlying Strategy and Resources for Sustainable Growth
    A TRULY GREAT COMPANY, WITH THE VERY BEST PEOPLE, A COMPELLING UNDERLYING STRATEGY AND RESOURCES FOR SUSTAINABLE GROWTH. MATTEL, INC. 1999 ANNUAL REPORT On the Cover: Robotic Puppy, from Fisher-Price, is a puppy who actually listens and responds to his owner’s voice with life-like actions, emotions and sounds. Jewel Girl Barbie features a belly button and also bends and twists with her new soft waist. Hot Wheels Stunt Track Driver CD-ROM was a top seller in 1999, providing kids with the ultimate in stunt driving excitement. A new version of the game hits stores in 2000. 1 LETTER TO SHAREHOLDERS The bad news for 1999 unfortunately has overshadowed the good news. We are all painfully aware of the negative effect the acquisition of The Learning Company and its subsequent perfor- mance had on our results for 1999. These well-reported difficulties obscured the fundamentally strong performance of Mattel’s core brands and sectors. In the seasonally important fourth quarter, core product sales were up 13 percent in the U.S. – Barbie grew by 11 percent and Fisher-Price by 14 percent. Mattel Entertainment was up 70 percent, Wheels recorded a world- wide sales increase of 6 percent and Pleasant Company achieved a 4 percent growth in sales. These solid performances represent a strong endorsement of Mattel’s strategy, and serve as the underpinning for our optimism for the future. This gives us confidence that Mattel remains a truly great company, with the very best people, a compelling underlying strategy and resources Mattel’s five business unit presidents include, for sustainable growth.
    [Show full text]