Peter Clarke and Tony Claydon (Eds.), the Church, the Afterlife and the Fate of the Soul

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Peter Clarke and Tony Claydon (Eds.), the Church, the Afterlife and the Fate of the Soul Book Reviews / CHRC .– () – Peter Clarke and Tony Claydon (Eds.), The Church, the Afterlife and the Fate of the Soul. Papers Read at the Summer Meeting and the Winter Meeting of the Ecclesiastical History Society [Studies in Church History ]. Boydell & Brewer, Woodbridge/Rochester, NY , pp., b/w ill. ISBN . ; US. The Venerable Bede once reported that an old pagan compared human life to a swiftly-flying sparrow in flight from a darkened to an illuminated hall and then again to a darkened one. Light, however momentary, offered a reason to convert. Ideas about the afterlife have ever been central to the Christian Church’s thinking. Notions about the fate of souls after death seasoned debates between Eastern and Western traditions, were crucial to the Reformation, and ordered the spread of Christianity beyond Europe. Arranged chronologically, thirty essays by ecclesiastical historians grace this pricey but impressive tome whose central theme embraces the impact of belief in the afterlife on the Church’s history and evolution, as well as the manifold ways in which that belief has impinged upon and been reflected in the lives, expectations, and aspirations of Christians across the centuries. By considering the whole sequential spread of the Church’s experience, these authors, both senior and junior, seek to highlight and share the current excitement of schol- arly study of the afterlife. Frequently questioned are such deeply-held assump- tions as the late development of purgatory in Christian thought and the divorce between the living and the dead in the western tradition after the sixteenth cen- tury. A brief sampling of topics considered will give some idea of the enormous and enormously interesting field considered. The span is both local and global, serious and humorous, the coverage focused and broad. Topics include: escha- tology and Creation, the Last Judgment, the theme of death in Augustine’s ser- mons, Anglo-Saxon and Byzantine notions of purgatory, hagiography and sote- riology, salvation among the Visigoths, the afterlife, its geography and appari- tions or revenants (ghosts), the judgment of the soul in Irish tradition, com- memoration, the harrowing of Hell, colonial American piety, Chinese (Con- fucian), Korean, African, and Maltese views, eighteenth-century anti-heathen Anglican theology, Evangelical premillennialism, nineteenth and twentieth- century angelology, and st-century views of the afterlife in York, England. For this review, I have arbitrarily selected the first eighteen contributions for synopsis. Thankfully, Clarke and Claydon do an outstanding job of editing and graciously chose not to contribute otherwise. After R.N. Swanson’s introductory overview, Fr. Young’s ‘Naked or Clothed? © Koninklijke Brill NV, Leiden, DOI: 10.1163/187124111X609838 Book Reviews / CHRC .– () – Eschatology and the Doctrine of Creation’ focuses on the resurrection of the body linked both to creation and to world reformation, according to Gregory of Nyssa, whereby all physical and spiritual elements are rejoined and restored after death. Second-century disputes over the emerging doctrine of creatio ex nihilo involve the theocentric arguments of Justin Martyr’s pupil Tatian that are seen to propose human immortality as embedded within God’s own incorruptibility: “[…] the body and soul belong together and after death may be reconstituted by the Creator God who created them in the first place” (pp. –). For Augustine, the first resurrection is of the soul, the final one of the body (which will be whole, free of distortion, and at peace with God). J. Laffin, ‘What Happened to the Last Judgement in the Early Church?’ addresses evidence both visual (early Christian art) and textual (from a passel of patristic texts) regarding depictions of the Last Judgment. Initially rare, con- soling, or soteriological images (Jonah, the Good Shepherd) are substituted by more regal representations of Christ as glorious judge or in apocalyptic majesty. Patristic eschatology emphasized hope rather than the later medieval stress on fearful doom. Laffin captions structured references to the Last Judgment in Tertullian, bishops Irenaeus of Lyons and Cyprian of Carthage, Clement of Alexandria, Origen, Basil the Great and his brother Gregory of Nyssa, Ambrose of Milan, Jerome, and Augustine—all of whom recognized some remedial and temporary punishment for the soul. In ‘Timor Mortis: The Fear of Death in Augustine’s Sermons on the Martyrs,’ E. Martin examines the role of celebra- tory North African martyr festivals in encouraging discussion of the afterlife insofar as “[…] eschatological hopes had long given meaning to martyrdom, exposing the order permeating chaos, pointing towards beauty amid human suffering, and revealing death as the gateway to true life” (p. ). In his theo- logical treatises, Augustine terrifies with intimidating fire and brimstone, as he underscores the transitoriness of the “first death” and the horror of the perma- nent one, endless and tormenting. His optimistic sermons, however, with their understanding of how fear paralyzes, accentuate life as a pilgrimage within the paradigm of martyrdom leading to heavenly wonders and a glorious eternal life. M.J. dal Santo, in ‘Philosophy, Hagiology and the Early Byzantine Origins of Purgatory,’ takes up the psychological issue of post mortem expiation (expe- rienced in a sort of intermediate waiting room, as described by Pope Gregory the Great), while reporting on sixth-century controversies that pondered the problematic link between the soul and the body—the integrity of human per- sonality. The question was: can the disembodied soul be active after death? That is, does the soul require the physical body for “mobility and perception”.
Recommended publications
  • What Is Hell Like? What Is Hell Like?
    WHAT IS HELL LIKE? WHAT IS HELL LIKE? • What does the Bible tell us about hell? • How should we respond to the doctrine of hell? WHAT IS HELL LIKE? Hell is: • Just (Rom 3:23; 6:23; 2 Thess 1:6-9; Matthew 25:46). WHAT IS HELL LIKE? For after all it is only just for God to repay with affliction those who afflict you, and to give relief to you who are afflicted and to us as well when the Lord Jesus will be revealed from heaven with His mighty angels WHAT IS HELL LIKE? in flaming fire, dealing out retribution to those who do not know God and to those who do not obey the gospel of our Lord Jesus. These will pay the penalty of eternal destruction, WHAT IS HELL LIKE? away from the presence of the Lord and from the glory of His power. 2 Thessalonians 1:6-9 WHAT IS HELL LIKE? These will go away into eternal punishment, but the righteous into eternal life. Matthew 25:46 WHAT IS HELL LIKE? Hell is: • Just (Rom 3:23; 6:23; 2 Thess 1:6-9; Matthew 25:46). • Eternal (Revelation 20:10-15; Mark 9:42- 49). WHAT IS HELL LIKE? And the devil who deceived them was thrown into the lake of fire and brimstone, where the beast and the false prophet are also; and they will be tormented day and night forever and ever… WHAT IS HELL LIKE? Then death and Hades were thrown into the lake of fire. This is the second death, the lake of fire.
    [Show full text]
  • Sins and Sinners Numen Book Series
    Sins and Sinners Numen Book Series Studies in the History of Religions Series Editors Steven Engler (Mount Royal University, Calgary, Canada) Richard King (University of Glasgow, Scotland) Kocku von Stuckrad (University of Groningen, The Netherlands) Gerard Wiegers (University of Amsterdam, The Netherlands) VOLUME 139 The titles published in this series are listed at brill.nl/nus Sins and Sinners Perspectives from Asian Religions Edited by Phyllis Granoff and Koichi Shinohara LEIDEN • BOSTON 2012 Cover illustration: Participant at the Makar Melā bathing in front of the Kṛṣṇa temple, Panautī, Nepal. Photograph taken in January 2010, by Prasant Shrestha. Reproduced with kind permission from the photographer. Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Sins and sinners : perspectives from Asian religions / edited by Phyllis Granoff and Koichi Shinohara. p. cm. — (Numen book series, ISSN 0169-8834 ; v. 139) Proceedings of a conference held in the fall of 2010 at Yale University. Includes index. ISBN 978-90-04-22946-4 (hardback : alk. paper) — ISBN 978-90-04-23200-6 (e-book) 1. Asia—Religions—Congresses. 2. Sin—Congresses. I. Granoff, P. E. (Phyllis Emily), 1947– II. Shinohara, Koichi, 1941– BL1033.S56 2012 202’.2—dc23 2012017165 This publication has been typeset in the multilingual “Brill” typeface. With over 5,100 characters covering Latin, IPA, Greek, and Cyrillic, this typeface is especially suitable for use in the humanities. For more information, please see www.brill.nl/brill-typeface. ISSN 0169-8834 ISBN 978 90 04 22946 4 (hardback) ISBN 978 90 04 23200 6 (e-book) Copyright 2012 by Koninklijke Brill NV, Leiden, The Netherlands.
    [Show full text]
  • Susan Swan: Michael Crummey's Fictional Truth
    Susan Swan: Michael Crummey’s fictional truth $6.50 Vol. 27, No. 1 January/February 2019 DAVID M. MALONE A Bridge Too Far Why Canada has been reluctant to engage with China ALSO IN THIS ISSUE CAROL GOAR on solutions to homelessness MURRAY BREWSTER on the photographers of war PLUS Brian Stewart, Suanne Kelman & Judy Fong Bates Publications Mail Agreement #40032362. Return undeliverable Canadian addresses to LRC, Circulation Dept. PO Box 8, Station K, Toronto, ON M4P 2G1 New from University of Toronto Press “Illuminating and interesting, this collection is a much- needed contribution to the study of Canadian women in medicine today.” –Allyn Walsh McMaster University “Provides remarkable insight “Robyn Lee critiques prevailing “Emilia Nielsen impressively draws into how public policy is made, discourses to provide a thought- on, and enters in dialogue with, a contested, and evolves when there provoking and timely discussion wide range of recent scholarship are multiple layers of authority in a surrounding cultural politics.” addressing illness narratives and federation like Canada.” challenging mainstream breast – Rhonda M. Shaw cancer culture.” –Robert Schertzer Victoria University of Wellington University of Toronto Scarborough –Stella Bolaki University of Kent utorontopress.com Literary Review of Canada 340 King Street East, 2nd Floor Toronto, ON M5A 1K8 email: [email protected] Charitable number: 848431490RR0001 To donate, visit reviewcanada.ca/ support Vol. 27, No. 1 • January/February 2019 EDITORS-IN-CHIEF Murray Campbell (interim) Kyle Wyatt (incoming) [email protected] 3 The Tools of Engagement 21 Being on Fire ART DIRECTOR Kyle Wyatt, Incoming Editor-in-Chief A poem Rachel Tennenhouse Nicholas Bradley ASSISTANT EDITOR 4 Invisible Canadians Elaine Anselmi How can you live decades with someone 22 In the Company of War POETRY EDITOR and know nothing about him? Portraits from behind the lens of Moira MacDougall Finding Mr.
    [Show full text]
  • The Reality of Hell
    THE REALITY OF HELL Bob Ross Is there a place of literal fire where lost sinners will be confined throughout eternity? “HELL” • “SHEOL” • “HADES” • “GEHENNA” • “TARTARUS” The Bible was written in three languages: Hebrew (Old Testament), Chaldee (por- tion of Daniel), and Greek (New Testament). The Bible that we have today is a translation of the Hebrew, Chaldee, and Greek writings into our language. There are many transla- tions of the Bible, the most popular being the King James Version, which you probably own. The Word “Hell” in the King James Version There are four words in the KJV translated “hell.” Of these four words, only one of them is used in the Old Testament. That word is the Hebrew word “Sheol.” In the New Testament, the three words translated “hell” are “hades,” “gehenna,” and “tartarus,” all Greek words. What do these words mean? 1. The Hebrew word “sheol” is translated as follows. “Hell”—31 times, as in Psalm 9:17: “The wicked shall be turned into hell, and all the nations that forget God.” “Grave”—31 times, as in Ecclesiastes 9:10: “Whatsoever thy hand findeth to do, do it with thy might; for there is no work, nor device, nor knowledge, nor wisdom, in the grave, whither thou goest.” “Pit”—3 times, as in Job 17:16: “They shall go down to the bars of the pit, when our rest together is in the dust.” But actually, the Hebrew word “sheol” does not mean either “hell,” “grave,” or “pit.” It means “the unseen world” or “the place of departed spirits.” Notice how it is de- fined: Strong’s Hebrew and Chaldee Dictionary says that “sheol” is “the world of the dead.” Young’s Analytical Concordance says that “sheol” is “the unseen state.” Smiths Bible Dictionary says that “sheol” is “always the abode of departed spirits.” Fausset’s Bible Dictionary and Encyclopedia says that “sheol” is “the common re- ceptacle of the dead.” So sheol does not strictly refer to hell, but to the place of departed spirits, irrespec- tive of whether saved or lost.
    [Show full text]
  • De-Demonising the Old Testament
    De-Demonising the Old Testament An Investigation of Azazel , Lilith , Deber , Qeteb and Reshef in the Hebrew Bible Judit M. Blair Doctor of Philosophy University of Edinburgh 2008 Declaration I declare that the present thesis has been composed by me, that it represents my own research, and that it has not been submitted for any other degree or professional qualification. ______________________ Judit M. Blair ii ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS There are many people to thank and acknowledge for their support and help over the past years. Firstly I would like to thank the School of Divinity for the scholarship and the opportunity they provided me in being able to do this PhD. I would like to thank my ‘numerous’ supervisors who have given of their time, energy and knowledge in making this thesis possible: To Professor Hans Barstad for his patience, advice and guiding hand, in particular for his ‘adopting’ me as his own. For his understanding and help with German I am most grateful. To Dr Peter Hayman for giving of his own time to help me in learning Hebrew, then accepting me to study for a PhD, and in particular for his attention to detail. To Professor Nick Wyatt who supervised my Masters and PhD before his retirement for his advice and support. I would also like to thank the staff at New College Library for their assistance at all times, and Dr Jessie Paterson and Bronwen Currie for computer support. My fellow colleagues have provided feedback and helpful criticism and I would especially like to thank all members of HOTS-lite I have known over the years.
    [Show full text]
  • Jesus Is Coming Back
    Jesus is coming back As most of you know we have been studying the book of Revelation in our bible study on Sunday mornings. I have read this book before, more than once and I find it very difficult to understand. Teaching Revelation for me was a big challenge because it is largely symbolic and you must know the Old Testament very well to understand the scriptures. As I was reflecting in the past I realized that pastors and teachers alike tend to shy away from this book. The only recollection I had was more than fifty years ago my uncle, Reverend C. R. Price an old Southern Baptist preacher scared the dickens out of me, shaking his finger in my face and spouting something about “hell fire and brimstone.” The point is people don’t like to hear about the end of times, it’s scary, some people see it as negative and hard to believe because of the symbolism. Some people called preterist believe that the prophetic events were fulfilled in the 1st century because of all the suffering of the Jews and Christians. Then we have those that do not believe our loving God could actually fulfill the events in revelation. While reading the scriptures again and keeping in mind that anything is possible with God, I was doing fine with the aid of my study bible and many resources from the internet. Then I came to chapter 9, verses 1-11. The fifth angel sounded his trumpet, and I saw a star that had fallen from the sky to the earth.
    [Show full text]
  • What Is Hades, Hell and Heaven? Many People Are Confused About
    What is hades, hell and heaven? Many people are confused about the difference between "hades" and "hell." Some Bible translations make no distinction in the two words. What about "heaven?" What do you know about the place where the righteous will dwell? Let's take a serious look in the Bible to see if we can find the distinctions and answers to these places of reality. I. IS THERE A DISTINCTION MADE BETWEEN "HADES" AND "HELL"? A. Even though some Bible translations make no distinctions, the original writers of the Greek New Testament made distinctions between them using two different Greek words. B. The two words: "Hades" and "Geenna" or "Gehenna". II. WHAT ARE THE TWO WORDS FOR HADES AND HELL? A. Hades. (26) "Therefore My heart was glad and My tongue exulted; moreover My flesh also will live in hope; (27) because You will not abandon My soul to Hades, nor allow Your Holy One to undergo decay.” Acts 2:26-27 1. Peter is preaching to the Jews on the day of Pentecost, and quotes from the Psalms to show David was speaking about Jesus. 2. At the death of Jesus, what happened to His soul (v.27)? 3. What happened to His body (v.27)? "He looked ahead and spoke of the resurrection of the Christ, that He was neither abandoned to Hades, nor did His flesh suffer decay." Acts 2:31 4. His soul was not abandoned to Hades and His flesh (body) did not remain long enough to decay. 5. Hades is a temporary holding place of the unrighteous souls.
    [Show full text]
  • The Wiley Blackwell Companion to the Qurʾa¯N
    The Wiley Blackwell Companion to the Qurʾa¯n The Wiley Blackwell Companions to Religion The Wiley Blackwell Companions to Religion series presents a collection of the most recent scholarship and knowledge about world religions. Each volume draws together newly commissioned essays by distinguished authors in the field, and is presented in a style which is accessible to undergraduate students, as well as scholars and the interested general reader. These volumes approach the subject in a creative and forward‐thinking style, providing a forum in which leading scholars in the field can make their views and research available to a wider audience. Recently Published The Blackwell Companion to Nineteenth‐Century Theology Edited by David Fergusson The Blackwell Companion to Religion in America Edited by Philip Goff The Blackwell Companion to Jesus Edited by Delbert Burkett The Blackwell Companion to Paul Edited by Stephen Westerholm The Blackwell Companion to Religion and Violence Edited by Andrew R. Murphy The Blackwell Companion to Christian Ethics, Second Edition Edited by Stanley Hauerwas and Samuel Wells The Wiley Blackwell Companion to Practical Theology Edited by Bonnie J. Miller‐McLemore The Wiley Blackwell Companion to Religion and Social Justice Edited by Michael D. Palmer and Stanley M. Burgess The Wiley Blackwell Companion to Chinese Religions Edited by Randall L. Nadeau The Wiley Blackwell Companion to African Religions Edited by Elias Kifon Bongmba The Wiley Blackwell Companion to Christian Mysticism Edited by Julia A. Lamm The Wiley Blackwell Companion to the Anglican Communion Edited by Ian S. Markham, J. Barney Hawkins IV, Justyn Terry, and Leslie Nuñez Steffensen The Wiley Blackwell Companion to Interreligious Dialogue Edited by Catherine Cornille The Wiley Blackwell Companion to East and Inner Asian Buddhism Edited by Mario Poceski The Wiley Blackwell Companion to Latino/a Theology Edited by Orlando O.
    [Show full text]
  • The Goal of the Religious Quest Is Often Described As Immortality Or Eternal Life
    The goal of the religious quest is often described as immortality or eternal life. Humanity has always chafed under the limitations of mortality, and people have found in religion the means to transcend the death which seems to proscribe the possibilities of human existence. Yet we have already gathered under Immortal Soul, pp. 326-34, passages from scripture which recognize that every person has an eternal spirit as his or her birthright. Everyone will continue eternally in some form of existence after the end of this physical life. The question of eternal life, therefore, does not mean eternal existence per se, but rather what form it will take, and whether death will remain a barrier to human fulfillment. We find that the scriptures of many religions give two meanings to the terms "life" and "death." There is the physical meaning of life: existence in this physical realm, and there is the spiritual meaning of life: the state of blessedness which is enduring from life to life and hence transcends death. There is the physical death: the dropping of the body which is an event in the voyage of every soul, and the spiritual death: the condition of distance from God, ignorance, and a hellish existence in the hereafter. Hence when the question of salvation is at issue, the outcomes called "eternal life" and "immortality" are often ciphers to describe the condition of blessedness. This condition is present already in the physical life of the person who realizes Truth or lives in God's grace, and it will continue, unabated, in the hereafter.
    [Show full text]
  • Balancing Act Living with Fire in the Applegate
    Balancing Act Living with Fire in the Applegate Applegate Communities’ Collaborative Fire Protection Strategy Coordinated by the Applegate Partnership Sandy Shaffer and Jack Shipley, Project Coordinators Diana Coogle, Editor Applegate, Oregon August 2002 About the Applegate Communities' Collaborative Fire Protection Strategy a.k.a. THE APPLEGATE FIRE PLAN The Applegate Fire Plan is a collaborative effort, hatched from an idea that was developed jointly by local citizens and federal agency folks in the Spring of 2001. Due to wide-spread participation throughout the Applegate Valley, general project coordination was organized by the Applegate Partnership, a non-profit community- based group founded in 1992. Initial funding for this project was awarded via the National Fire Plan to the Applegate Partnership in October, 2001. This written plan is the result. The Mission of the Applegate Partnership The Applegate Partnership is a community-based, non- profit organization involving industry, conservation groups, natural resource agencies, and residents cooperating to encourage and facilitate the use of natural resource princi- ples that promote ecosystem health and diversity. Through community involvement and education, this partnership supports management of all land within the watershed in a manner that sustains natural resources and that will, in turn, contribute to economic and community well-being and resilience. The logo for the Applegate Fire Plan was designed by Greeley Wells. Applegate Fire Plan - 3 List of Partners The following local,
    [Show full text]
  • The Works of Charley, Noah, & Hazel Kinney
    S L O W TIME The Works of Charley, Noah, & Hazel Kinney Design: Matt Collinsworth Art Photos: Geoff Carr, Adrian Swain Table of Contents Introduction by Adrian Swain 4 Acknowledgements 6 A Sense of Place by Lee Kogan 8 At the Head of Salt Lick (1980) by John Harrod 31 About the Authors 35 Exhibition Checklist 36 Introduction Anyone with wits about them who visited the Kinney farm had to Charley and Noah were well informed conclude that there was something quite extraordinary taking place about material ‘progress.’ They there, but the relative otherness of the Kinneys’ existence could just picked and chose which of the easily lead one to be distracted by the “old-timey” details of their new ways they would fool with lifestyle. and ignored the rest. Strip away the few conveniences they did Charley and Noah Kinney were born 6 years apart—1906 and adopt, and these two men could 1912 respectively—into a life of subsistence farming not so far survive just fine without them, removed from that eked out by early white settlers in northeast thank you very much, though Kentucky. They died within 6 months of each other in 1991. Their there’s no doubt that Hazel’s lives spanned a tumultuous era in history, a time of unprecedented addition to the family as Noah’s economic, technological, socio-political and cultural change: the wife in 1960 reinstated a much- advent of radio, flight, rural electrification, mechanized farming, missed thread of domestic order. television, chain saws, repeating rifles, indoor plumbing, and other technological marvels.
    [Show full text]
  • Fire and Brimstone — a History of Hell
    Fire and Brimstone A History of Hell Donald E. Knebel May 19, 2019 Slide 1 1. This is the third presentation on the history of Christian beliefs about life and death. 2. Today we will look at the history of Christian teachings about hell. 3. As a respected evangelical minister from Grand Rapids recently wrote : “A staggering number of people have been taught that a select few Christians will spend forever in a peaceful, joyous place called heaven, while the rest of humanity spends forever in torment and punishment in hell with no chance for anything better.” Bell, Love Wins at viii. 4. But another evangelical minister writes that this common idea about hell “reveals ignorance of both biblical forms as well as historical origins for the cartoonish description” of hell. Klassen, What Does the Bible Really Say About Hell at 28. 5. As we will see, the traditional teachings about hell developed largely independently of what the Bible says and contradict many New Testament statements. Slide 2 1. As we saw last week, the earliest parts of the Hebrew Scriptures, which Christians call the Old Testament, say nothing about any kind of afterlife and, as a result, say nothing about punishment after death. 2. That statement can be surprising to people who have read only the King James Version of the Old Testament, which includes 31 references to “hell,” all of which are translations of the Hebrew word “sheol.” 3. As we will discuss more in two weeks, Sheol was simply the place under the earth where all the Jewish dead resided, just as all living people resided on the earth and God and the angels resided in the heavens.
    [Show full text]