Parliamentary Debates (Hansard)
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Friday Volume 571 29 November 2013 No. 85 HOUSE OF COMMONS OFFICIAL REPORT PARLIAMENTARY DEBATES (HANSARD) Friday 29 November 2013 £5·00 © Parliamentary Copyright House of Commons 2013 This publication may be reproduced under the terms of the Open Parliament licence, which is published at www.parliament.uk/site-information/copyright/. 527 29 NOVEMBER 2013 528 House of Commons European Union (Referendum) Bill Further consideration of Bill, not amended in the Public Bill Committee Friday 29 November 2013 Clause 1 The House met at half-past Nine o’clock REFERENDUM ON THE UNITED KINGDOM’S PRAYERS MEMBERSHIP OF THE EUROPEAN UNION Amendment proposed: 35, page 1, leave out lines 8 and 9 and insert [MR SPEAKER in the Chair] ‘Should the United Kingdom remain a member of the European Union?’.—(Mike Gapes.) BILL PRESENTED Question put, That the amendment be made. The House proceeded to a Division. UNITED KINGDOM PARLIAMENT (SOVEREIGNTY)BILL Presentation and First Reading (Standing Order No. 57) Mr Speaker: I ask the Serjeant at Arms to investigate Mr William Cash, supported by Mr Bernard Jenkin, the delay in both the Aye and No Lobbies. Mr John Redwood, Sir Edward Leigh, Sir Gerald Howarth, The House having divided: Ayes 3, Noes 244. Mr John Baron, Mr Peter Bone, Jacob Rees-Mogg, Henry Smith, Chris Heaton-Harris, Mr James Clappison Division No. 141] [9.35 am and Sir Richard Shepherd, presented a Bill to make provision for the supremacy of the sovereignty of the AYES United Kingdom Parliament in relation to the United Bailey, Mr Adrian Tellers for the Ayes: Kingdom’s membership of the European Union; and Gapes, Mike Susan Elan Jones and for connected purposes. Horwood, Martin Nic Dakin Bill read the First time; to be read a Second time on Friday 17 January 2014, and to be printed (Bill 136). NOES Afriyie, Adam Clifton-Brown, Geoffrey Aldous, Peter Coffey, Dr Thérèse Amess, Mr David Collins, Damian Andrew, Stuart Colvile, Oliver Arbuthnot, rh Mr James Crabb, Stephen Baker, Steve Crouch, Tracey Baldry, Sir Tony Davies, David T. C. Baldwin, Harriett (Monmouth) Barker, rh Gregory Davies, Glyn Baron, Mr John de Bois, Nick Bebb, Guto Djanogly, Mr Jonathan Bellingham, Mr Henry Dorries, Nadine Benyon, Richard Doyle-Price, Jackie Beresford, Sir Paul Drax, Richard Berry, Jake Duddridge, James Bingham, Andrew Duncan, rh Mr Alan Binley, Mr Brian Dunne, Mr Philip Blackman, Bob Ellis, Michael Boles, Nick Ellison, Jane Bone, Mr Peter Elphicke, Charlie Bottomley, Sir Peter Eustice, George Bradley, Karen Evans, Graham Brady, Mr Graham Evans, Jonathan Bray, Angie Evans, Mr Nigel Brazier, Mr Julian Evennett, Mr David Brine, Steve Fabricant, Michael Brokenshire, James Fallon, rh Michael Bruce, Fiona Field, Mark Buckland, Mr Robert Fitzpatrick, Jim Burley, Mr Aidan Fox,rhDrLiam Burns, rh Mr Simon Francois, rh Mr Mark Burrowes, Mr David Freeman, George Burt, rh Alistair Freer, Mike Byles, Dan Fullbrook, Lorraine Cairns, Alun Fuller, Richard Carmichael, Neil Gale, Sir Roger Carswell, Mr Douglas Garnier, Mark Cash, Mr William Gauke, Mr David Chishti, Rehman Gibb, Mr Nick Chope, Mr Christopher Gillan, rh Mrs Cheryl Clark, rh Greg Glen, John 529 European Union (Referendum) Bill29 NOVEMBER 2013 European Union (Referendum) Bill 530 Goodwill, Mr Robert Milton, Anne Vaizey, Mr Edward Williamson, Chris Graham, Richard Mordaunt, Penny Vara, Mr Shailesh Williamson, Gavin Gray, Mr James Morgan, Nicky Vickers, Martin Wilson, Mr Rob Grayling, rh Chris Morris, Anne Marie Walker, Mr Robin Wollaston, Dr Sarah Green, rh Damian Morris, David Watkinson, Dame Angela Wright, Jeremy Greening, rh Justine Morris, James Weatherley, Mike Yeo, Mr Tim Grieve, rh Mr Dominic Mosley, Stephen Wharton, James Young, rh Sir George Griffiths, Andrew Mowat, David Wheeler, Heather Zahawi, Nadhim Hague, rh Mr William Murray, Sheryll White, Chris Tellers for the Noes: Halfon, Robert Murrison, Dr Andrew Whittaker, Craig Gavin Barwell and Hammond, rh Mr Philip Neill, Robert Whittingdale, Mr John Mr Sam Gyimah Hammond, Stephen Newton, Sarah Hancock, Matthew Nokes, Caroline Hands, Greg Norman, Jesse Question accordingly negatived. Harper, Mr Mark Nuttall, Mr David Amendment proposed: 71, page 1, line 12, leave out Harrington, Richard O’Brien, rh Mr Stephen subsection (6) and insert— Harris, Rebecca Offord, Dr Matthew ‘(6) An order under this section shall be made by statutory Hart, Simon Opperman, Guy instrument. Haselhurst, rh Sir Alan Osborne, rh Mr George Hayes, rh Mr John Ottaway, rh Richard (7) An order under subsection (3) may not be made unless Heald, Oliver Parish, Neil each House of Parliament has passed a resolution that the Heaton-Harris, Chris Patel, Priti referendum shall take place on a day specified in the resolution and the day specified in the resolution is the same as in the order. Henderson, Gordon Paterson, rh Mr Owen Hendry, Charles Pawsey, Mark (8) An order under subsection (5) may not be made unless a Herbert, rh Nick Penning, Mike draft of the order has been laid before, and approved by, a Hinds, Damian Penrose, John resolution of each House of Parliament.’.—(Chris Williamson.) Hollingbery, George Percy, Andrew Question put, That the amendment be made. Hollobone, Mr Philip Perry, Claire The House proceeded to a Division. Hopkins, Kris Pickles, rh Mr Eric Howarth, Sir Gerald Poulter, Dr Daniel Howell, John Prisk, Mr Mark Mr Speaker: Will the Serjeant at Arms investigate the Hunt, rh Mr Jeremy Raab, Mr Dominic delay in the No Lobby, in case, perchance, there is just a Hurd, Mr Nick Randall, rh Sir John single occupant of it? Johnson, Gareth Reckless, Mark Will the Serjeant at Arms investigate the delay in the Johnson, Joseph Redwood, rh Mr John Aye Lobby, please? Jones, Andrew Reevell, Simon Jones, rh Mr David Robertson, rh Hugh The House having divided: Ayes 8, Noes 241. Kawczynski, Daniel Robertson, Mr Laurence Division No. 142] [9.52 am Kelly, Chris Rosindell, Andrew Kirby, Simon Rudd, Amber AYES Kwarteng, Kwasi Rutley, David Bailey, Mr Adrian Mudie, Mr George Lancaster, Mark Sandys, Laura Fitzpatrick, Jim Williamson, Chris Lansley, rh Mr Andrew Scott, Mr Lee Latham, Pauline Selous, Andrew Gapes, Mike Tellers for the Ayes: Leadsom, Andrea Shapps, rh Grant Horwood, Martin Susan Elan Jones and Lee, Jessica Sharma, Alok Lazarowicz, Mark Nic Dakin Lee, Dr Phillip Shepherd, Sir Richard Lefroy, Jeremy Simmonds, Mark NOES Leigh, Sir Edward Simpson, Mr Keith Leslie, Charlotte Skidmore, Chris Afriyie, Adam Brazier, Mr Julian Letwin, rh Mr Oliver Smith, Chloe Aldous, Peter Brine, Steve Lewis, Brandon Smith, Henry Amess, Mr David Brokenshire, James Liddell-Grainger, Mr Ian Smith, Julian Andrew, Stuart Bruce, Fiona Lidington, rh Mr David Soubry, Anna Arbuthnot, rh Mr James Buckland, Mr Robert Lilley, rh Mr Peter Spelman, rh Mrs Caroline Baker, Steve Burley, Mr Aidan Lopresti, Jack Spencer, Mr Mark Baldry, Sir Tony Burns, rh Mr Simon Lord, Jonathan Stephenson, Andrew Baldwin, Harriett Burrowes, Mr David Loughton, Tim Stevenson, John Barker, rh Gregory Burt, rh Alistair Luff, Peter Stewart, Iain Baron, Mr John Byles, Dan Bebb, Guto Macleod, Mary Stewart, Rory Cairns, Alun Bellingham, Mr Henry Main, Mrs Anne Stride, Mel Carmichael, Neil Benyon, Richard May, rh Mrs Theresa Stuart, Mr Graham Carswell, Mr Douglas Beresford, Sir Paul Maynard, Paul Sturdy, Julian Cash, Mr William Berry, Jake McCartney, Jason Swayne, rh Mr Desmond Bingham, Andrew Chishti, Rehman McCartney, Karl Syms, Mr Robert Binley, Mr Brian Chope, Mr Christopher McIntosh, Miss Anne Timpson, Mr Edward Blackman, Bob Clark, rh Greg McPartland, Stephen Tomlinson, Justin Boles, Nick Clifton-Brown, Geoffrey McVey, Esther Tredinnick, David Bone, Mr Peter Coffey, Dr Thérèse Menzies, Mark Truss, Elizabeth Bottomley, Sir Peter Collins, Damian Metcalfe, Stephen Turner, Mr Andrew Bradley, Karen Colvile, Oliver Miller, rh Maria Tyrie, Mr Andrew Brady, Mr Graham Crabb, Stephen Mills, Nigel Uppal, Paul Bray, Angie Crouch, Tracey 531 European Union (Referendum) Bill29 NOVEMBER 2013 European Union (Referendum) Bill 532 Davies, David T. C. Kwarteng, Kwasi Rutley, David Tredinnick, David (Monmouth) Lancaster, Mark Sandys, Laura Truss, Elizabeth Davies, Glyn Lansley, rh Mr Andrew Scott, Mr Lee Turner, Mr Andrew de Bois, Nick Latham, Pauline Selous, Andrew Tyrie, Mr Andrew Djanogly, Mr Jonathan Leadsom, Andrea Shapps, rh Grant Uppal, Paul Dorries, Nadine Lee, Jessica Sharma, Alok Vaizey, Mr Edward Doyle-Price, Jackie Lee, Dr Phillip Shepherd, Sir Richard Vara, Mr Shailesh Drax, Richard Lefroy, Jeremy Simmonds, Mark Vickers, Martin Duddridge, James Leigh, Sir Edward Simpson, Mr Keith Walker, Mr Robin Duncan, rh Mr Alan Leslie, Charlotte Skidmore, Chris Watkinson, Dame Angela Dunne, Mr Philip Letwin, rh Mr Oliver Smith, Chloe Weatherley, Mike Ellis, Michael Lewis, Brandon Smith, Henry Wharton, James Ellison, Jane Liddell-Grainger, Mr Ian Smith, Julian Wheeler, Heather Elphicke, Charlie Lidington, rh Mr David Soubry, Anna White, Chris Eustice, George Lilley, rh Mr Peter Spelman, rh Mrs Caroline Whittaker, Craig Evans, Graham Lopresti, Jack Spencer, Mr Mark Whittingdale, Mr John Evans, Jonathan Lord, Jonathan Stephenson, Andrew Wiggin, Bill Evans, Mr Nigel Loughton, Tim Stevenson, John Williamson, Gavin Evennett, Mr David Luff, Peter Stewart, Iain Wilson, Mr Rob Fabricant, Michael Macleod, Mary Stewart, Rory Wollaston, Dr Sarah Fallon, rh Michael Main, Mrs Anne Stride, Mel Wright, Jeremy Field, Mark May, rh Mrs Theresa Stuart, Mr Graham Yeo, Mr Tim Fox,rhDrLiam Maynard, Paul Sturdy, Julian Young, rh Sir George Freeman, George McCartney, Jason Swayne,