SussexSussex MothMoth GroupGroup NewsletterNewsletter November 2015
Main features inside this issue: Ringing the Changes by David Burrows 2
A New Ac on Plan for Moths by Steve Wheatley 3
The Force Awakens by Colin Piper 5
Thoughts on Becoming a Moth‐er at 70+ by Pat Brothwell 7
So, What’s New in 2015? by Robin Harris 9
Some Sussex Mothing Highlights for 2015 11
Deadwood Habitat by Heather Mar n 16
A Vec s Ramble by John Maskell 18
Finding Orange Olive Crescents by Steve Wheatley 20 Commi ee members and 2016 indoor mee ng dates Back page Chairman’s Corner
Although winter is fast approaching it s ll feels like early autumn as I write this in mid‐ November, with overnight temperatures hovering around 13oC in recent nights. We have had another year of unusual weather in Sussex which now seems to be becoming the norm, and this is undoubtedly having an effect on the county’s moths as well as the flora that most spe‐ cies feed on as larva. This autumn many leaf mines appeared to be in rather short supply, which could be related to the bad weather condi ons in the first genera on’s flight season earlier in the year. With the changing climate the records from regular garden moth trapping are invaluable for providing the phenology data that can map some of these changes.
The lepidopteral highlights of 2015 were perhaps the breeding Long‐tailed Blue and overwin‐ tering Scarce Tortoiseshell bu erflies – however, for moths, it was not a par cularly notable season. Although a sma ering of migrants were recorded across the county there were no long periods of sustained immigra on during the year, and I don’t remember any traps heav‐ ing with large numbers of moths. On a posi ve note, however, Colin did confirm at least ten species as con nuing to colonise the county.
On the subject of colonisers, this autumn Pen and I finally caught our first Clifden Nonpareil; a species that has been top of our moth ‘wish list’ for a long me. The moth was as beau ful as we had hoped for and it was a delight to watch it feeding at sugar when we released it the following evening.
Although catching unusual immigrant moths can be very exci ng, there is something extra special about a visit from a rare resident or coloniser – par cularly when they have a blue hindwing! Dave Green Clifden Nonpareil
11 Ringing the Changes by David Burrows
Early July 2015 will be remembered for some record breaking warmth, with temper‐ atures on the first of the month reaching the high 30’s cen grade. My regular trap site from late April to early November is in my daughter’s garden in the Brede Valley, about five and a half miles inland from the coast at Has ngs, East Sussex. On the morning of 4th July, a er a night with an overnight shower and a minimum temperature of 17◦c I was about half way through inspec ng the egg trays when I spo ed an unfamiliar geometer with lacy‐pa erned wings, and froze; once this moth was successfully boxed I went through the remaining contents with added ex‐ pecta on. A total count of 162 macros and 61 species, but no other migrants, alt‐ hough five days later (8/7/15) at the same site I recorded Catoptria verellus. Colin Pra , County Moth Recorder for Sussex, said that the Ringed Border was the first County record and is believed to be the fourth U.K. record (S.PC. Atropos, num‐ ber 53). Had this record been a year earlier it would have featured on 2014 moth night.
22 A New Action Plan for Moths
by Steve Wheatley Senior Regional Officer - South East
How can Bu erfly Conserva on best help to conserve moths? What are the priority spe‐ cies? Where are the most important places? And what should we do over the next ten years or so? These are the ques ons Bu erfly Conserva on is asking in order to develop a new Ac on Plan which can deliver the best and most effec ve conserva on ac on. If you have thoughts on what moths and places will be most important and what ac ons will be most valuable in Sussex please do get involved. Back in the late 1990’s Bu erfly Conserva on produced a South East Regional Ac on Plan for Sussex, Kent and Surrey. This included a list of 25 high priority moth species and 75 other priority moths for Sussex. Amongst the moths listed at that me were: Barred Tooth‐striped – which has now been the focus of annual targeted searches at known or historical spots along the Sussex coast and has led to good conserva on advice to land managers in these areas. Toadflax Brocade moth which, a er colonising Britain in the twen eth century, has con nued to spread. Clay Fan‐foot became a major focus of the South East Woodlands Project in East Sus‐ sex and was recorded in record‐breaking numbers across a number of woods. Olive Crescent – which was listed as a rare immigrant just a few decades ago and now seems to have spread across a wide area. Good search methods have been devised and the RSPB (amongst others) has now taken up the reigns of char ng this moth’s progress. It’s not all good news ‐ Orange Upperwing is thought to have been lost from most, if not all of Sussex. Marsh Mallow Moth popula ons remain extremely important na onally, and if we stopped working on this species it could very easily be lost. The State of Britain’s Larger Moths 2013 report showed that two‐thirds of common and widespread moths declined over the 40‐year study. 37% of the 337 species decreased by
33 Con nued….
50% or more. It’s now me to create the new Ac on Plan. The first step is to devise priority lists and plan out what we can achieve. We’re already working with our County Recorder, Colin Pra , to produce a shortlist of poten ally high priority species. This me around we want to keep the list as short and focussed as possible, bearing in mind the limited resources available. But clearly Bu erfly Conserva on and Sussex Moth Group can’t reverse these declines and achieve everything alone. We need to engage and inspire others to help deliver the things we want. Some partners will hopefully be easy to work with, such as Sussex Wildlife Trust with whom we obviously already have strong working links. Bu erfly Conserva on also has good links with Natural England and the Forestry Commission and we can work to focus their efforts be er. But we also need to engage many other groups and organisa ons, including conserva on or‐ ganisa ons and land managers such as the Na onal Trust and RSPB, and local authori es such as County and District Councils. Their increasingly limited conserva on budgets mean they are under more pressure than ever to focus and target their efforts for the best outcomes. This new ac on plan will help them to do this, plus we have the exper se and poten al to survey and record their successes, feeding back posi ve stories. Where specific areas can be iden fied for unique and fascina ng moths, local pride, inter‐ est and enthusiasm can be encouraged and developed. Local champions will be wel‐ comed, whether this be an organisa on, an individual or even the local MP. Our message needs to be clear and targeted to the person or group we’re engaging with. That’s why it’s so important to define the key areas for each priority moth and know the ac ons we are asking for. I hope this will also help to inspire some targeted ac ons by Sussex Moth Group members – looking for specific priority species or inspiring others to get involved. The ac on plan is being developed now and will be published in the spring. Then it will be a key part of my day job to engage with organisa ons and promote the ac ons that will ma er. More informa on about the Ac on Plan will follow. If you have sugges ons for priority species, important places or useful ac ons we can promote, please contact Dave Green, Jim Barre (Sussex Ac on Plan coordinator) or me (Bu erfly Conserva on’s Re‐ gional Officer). swheatley@bu erfly‐conserva on.org
44 The Force Awakens
by Colin Piper
Some me in 1992 Barry Spence caught a Deaths' Head Hawk Moth at Spurn Bird Observa‐ tory. I thought it one of the most extraordinary creatures I had ever seen, par cularly when it squeaked as you stroked it: I was hooked. When I moved to Southwick in 1996 one of the Spurn regulars made me a MV trap. Amazingly a second atropos turned up soon a er but not in the Southwick garden, it was on the school field at my workplace in Bognor Regis.
Being new to the county I went on any wildlife trips I could. On one such ou ng I met a young man kneeling on all fours in Brighton Cemetery ‐ it was the middle of the night and he was peering at the ground. My Yorkshire friends had told me Brighton would be differ‐ ent. It turned out his name was Simon Curson, he worked for the Sussex Wildlife Trust and he was looking at a moth. We became good friends, and if Wendy searches through the cobweb covered scrolls in her a c I think she will discover that Simon and I were the first chair and secretary respec vely of Sussex Moth Group ‐ not that I knew one end of a moth from the other (I s ll don't). It was a sort of deal, Simon helped me to learn salsa and I agreed to write up the minutes of SMG mee ngs in return.
Life moved on: Simon moved to the New Forest and I bought a bachelor pad and had to get rid of the trap. The recent move to part‐ me working means more me and energy to re‐connect with old hobbies, however, and in some ways I feel I'm back where I was 20 years ago.
Which brings me to the SMG Spring mee ng, with its excellent talk and extremely friendly welcome. That was followed by the purchase of a generator and trap, the la er being set up on the bathroom windowsill. The upstairs neighbours don't seem to mind and the only real problems have been nocturnal visits from cats, and interes ng shower experiences the following morning.
There are advantages to running the trap indoors, for one thing the moths cannot escape if you've shut the window. I don't get the variety or numbers I got in Southwick 20 years ago but that may be due to geography and habitat, as much as the traps loca on. There were no hawk‐moths this year and I wonder if that is because the larger moths are deflected by the window. I've no ced that large moths o en do a number of fly‐bys before entering a trap and I suspect they just don't make it through the opening. I check the outside wall but have so far only ever found geometer moths there, itself an interes ng observa on.
55 Con nued…. In my first season I've trapped no less than four new species for my 10km square, accord‐ ing to the SMG web site anyway. I suspect this has more to do with the difficul es of maintaining websites and databases than anything else, but underlies the role we can all play in expanding and improving our knowledge of what's out there. For the record my four species are: Treble Brown Spot, Clouded Border, Green Silver‐lines and Burnished Brass.
Unlike in Southwick I'm trying to iden fy everything I catch. There are therefore days when I'm quite glad there aren't many new ones and the pugs o en 'escape' before I've had a chance to sort them out. Does anyone else think the pug plate in Skinner is actually out of focus?
There has also been my first SMG field trip for nearly 20 years, 'sleeping' in my car at East Head and then trying to iden fy moths at 4 o'clock in the morning. That's my excuse for ge ng them wrong.
It's been fun, thank you to all the SMG members who helped get me back out there.
The Future of the SMG Newsletter
I’d like to moot the idea of making the moth group newsle er digital ‐ as this will save us over £160 a year in prin ng costs and postage etc. I am of course happy to provide paper copies for those without access to the internet but can you let me know if you are happy for this to go digital as of Spring 2016? If I don't hear from you I will presume you're happy for it to be in a digital format (PDF). Or the other op on is that we just have one issue of the newsle er a year. Any thoughts wel‐ come. If you would like to con nue receiving a paper copy please let me know: [email protected] . If you don’t have an email address in our database then I will automa cally send you a paper copy, so no need to let me know if you don’t have email.
66 Thoughts on becoming a Moth-er at 70+
by Pat Brothwell
Many moons ago – in the early 70s – we spent quite a bit of me in the Orkney Islands and made the acquaintance of Ian Lorimer whom we designated “The Moth Man”. His wife, Daphne, was helping on an archaeological excava on pro‐ ject – our reason for being there – and so we met the en re family.
Their residence was The Manse in Orphir and Ian asked whether he could put a trap in our garden in Deerness and so, I and my children, with the aid of two old copies of South, learnt to iden fy “some moths”. I say “some moths” because we were really beginners and it was Ian who came over and checked them all out. We were immediately entranced, not only by the beauty of moths, but also by their names. Although my children are now, let’s say, “considerably older” they s ll recall some of the magical names, like True Lover’s Knot, Golden Plu‐ sia, Angle Shades, Burnished Brass, Elephants, Tigers ‐ but our chief recollec on was the invasion one evening of an army of Large Yellow Underwings! It is s ll known in our family as “The Night of the Large Yellow Underwings” when we had clouds of them inside the co age and the efforts began to get them all out‐ side!
Later, Ian lent us a trap so we could con nue our efforts in Surrey. Bearing in mind that internet did not exist to provide access to good iden fica on sites, nor did digital cameras and we had no decent moth books apart from South, we had to note down what we saw – thought we saw – and no fy Ian. One day, we found a moth we didn’t know and tried hard to find a similarity with something and all we could think of was a Feathered Ear. We asked Ian about it and he got very excited, sent us a mounted sample and asked us to try to catch another one. Needless to say we failed. But we had a visit from Bernard Skinner who dropped in with his wife and we sat and talked moths, garden ponds, toad spawn and general wildlife etc but s ll we never found anything like the one we had seen. But then, moths are like that – you find something which looks totally different from anything else and turns out to be something very common – maybe just old or pale or a different colour.
So the children grew up, Ian passed away and I also grew old (er!) but s ll the
77 Con nued…. memories of these exquisite insects stuck with me and finally, urged on by a re‐ quest in the BTO’s “Garden Bird Watch” magazine reques ng people to partake in a Garden Moth Scheme in 2012 as well, I decided to go for it and I bought myself a moth trap.
Apart from anything else, I am really interested to know what inhabits my wild‐ life garden which has been developed since I moved in here in 1996 from just a mountainous heap of soil to a somewhat crowded garden full of scented, col‐ ourful, sturdy plants designed to give interest the whole year round and a ract as much interest from wildlife as possible. So as my mothing has progressed I am thrilled to find I can now list over 300 species and recognise things a bit more easily than at the first a empt.
Some mes, it’s a bit of an effort: carrying the trap up from the shed to my top terrace near the outdoor electric supply and checking the forecast to make sure it’s not going to blow a gale and deposit torren al rain in the trap (I’m in the di‐ rect target line of the prevailing South‐Westerlies). Then, on cold mornings, ge ng very chilly in the conservatory iden fying everything. Some mes, it’s all in vain – weeks with “0 Moths” and back to the shed again. But then – a boun ful trap with some love‐ ly temporary residents! And many thanks to Bob and Colin who have put up with lots of “What’s this?” ques ons which, I hope, are ge ng a somewhat fewer as me goes on!
I know it’s ridiculous but I actually can’t resist talking to them as I find them: “Wow, look at you. Aren’t you gorgeous?” “I don’t care if you are a “COMMON” Marbled Carpet! “Common! – I think you are beau ful”. And as for the Dingy Shell – never saw anything less din‐ gy. I’d love to know how some of these lovely insects got their names – why a Conformist? Why an Old Lady? But then who else can say “I got up this morning and found 16 elephants in my gar‐ den!” Now, I’m ge ng hooked on micros. Looking at them through the magni‐ fying glass you just can’t believe how beau ful they are and I don’t care if they do plunder my roses, my not‐very‐produc ve fruit trees or make holes in the leaves of my hardy geraniums.
And excitement mounts when I discover a new one not seen before in my gar‐ den and if it’s got a “no fiable” mark a er it, it’s even more special – even
88 Con nued…. though some of the most spectacular, colourful and beau ful are as usual, simply “COMMON”.
My interested next‐door neighbour is ge ng used to me dropping round at un‐ earthly hours of the morning saying “Just have a look at this before I let it go!”
So I shall con nue as long as possible. Maybe one day I’ll have to request the council to install a Stannah Li from the shed up the ramp and back again…some hope! But each morning, no ma er how cold or how much the back aches – each opening of the trap is like Christmas! Just wish I had a be er camera and some instruc ons on how to use one to get even close to those fantas c photos as seen on the websites.
So, What’s New in 2015? by Robin Harris
I suppose for many of us one of the best parts of being involved in the world of moths is finding a species which is new to wherever it is that we do our trap‐ ping. For me that’s my rural back garden, which is about eight miles inland from the coast between Has ngs and Bexhill as the moth flies (or is blown) and some 130 feet above sea level.
For the past six years, for around 70 nights each year, 40w of ac nic light has shone above my Heath‐type trap. As years pass so the numbers of NFG (New For Garden) species is pre y much sure to decline year on year. But s ll they come, perhaps more of a trickle now than the flood of early years. And s ll, for me, there is a real excitement in finding one of these newcomers.
Among the more interes ng first‐ me visitors was a single Platytes alpinella on 3 August. Volume 4 of Colin’s masterwork states (p207) “Establishments of this Na onally
99 Con nued….
Scarce Class B species, which generally favours coastal sand‐dunes and vegetat‐ ed shingle beaches, have been restricted to the west of Worthing and to the east of St Leonard’s (sic) throughout this century” and in the next paragraph men ons only two inland records ‐ at Walberton in 2012 (J T Radford) and at Etchingham in 2014 (C Moore). Maybe more records of this a rac ve micro will emerge in 2015.
Another new micro, in the form of a Cochylis dubitana (kindly confirmed by Colin Pra ) turned up on 29 August. This moth is seemingly thinly spread in Sus‐ sex and at the me of wri ng is apparently keen to remain incognito as it has declined to allow a photo to appear on our website!
On three nights during the year more than one NFG appeared. 25th June saw Bordered Straw and Eucosma hohenwar ana (kindly confirmed by Caroline Moore) make their debut. Two nights later two more species joined the club: Small Elephant Hawkmoth and Small Mo led Willow. But these were topped by three NFGs presen ng themselves on 17 August – Birch Mocha (why has it tak‐ en so long?), Olive and Jersey Tiger. The Jersey Tiger may be the most inter‐ es ng of the three. Inland records seem by no means common. And, if we go back 20 years, who among the more seasoned of our members would have ex‐ pected me to have trapped this species whilst Garden Tiger re‐ mains unrecorded?
I can’t finish without men oning two giants – one an NFG and one not. The NFG? Red Underwing. The not? My second‐ever Blue Underwing!
1010 Some Sussex Mothing Highlights in 2015
Derek Lee caught this beau ful Cream‐spot in Tiger at Bracklesham May.