Tying Law in the European Union: Theory and Application Doctoral

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Tying Law in the European Union: Theory and Application Doctoral Tying Law in the European Union: Theory and Application Doctoral Thesis Doctorate in Philosophy (Law) Matthew Jonathan Cole September 2014 I Abstract This research investigates the theoretical foundations of EU competition tying law. While tying prohibitions have existed in the EEC Treaty since 1957 the theoretical foundations of tying are not well understood. This thesis provides crucial insight into the theory and theoretical validity of tying law. This thesis focuses on answering three questions in relation to tying: One, what was the original economic theory underlying the prohibition on tying? Two, how has this changed and on what economic principles is tying law currently based? Three, are these principles appropriately aligned with the current state of economic thinking? In order to answer these three questions this thesis considers three leading schools of thought in competition law (Ordoliberalism, the Chicago School of antitrust analysis and post-Chicago antitrust analysis) before analysing the jurisprudence of the EU Commission and courts and establishing which theory forms the foundation of EU tying law. This research makes an interdisciplinary contribution through the use of both legal-historical analysis and legal-economic analysis. This yields important results on the historical development of tying law in Europe and also provides an economic analysis of the validity of EU law, assessing whether the aims of the law are economically valid and effectively applied. Where there are failures in the application of the law, normative proposals are given in order to demonstrate how the law and its application can be improved. The result of this analysis is to establish two distinct periods of theoretical influence (the author calls these the mono- and di-theoretical periods). A novel analysis of the tying decisions made in the software market is also presented and a new theory of foreclosure proposed that explains the decisions made in that market. II DECLARATION This work has not been submitted in substance for any other degree or award at this or any other university or place of learning, nor is being submitted concurrently in candidature for any degree or other award. Signed ………………………………………… (candidate) Date ………………………… STATEMENT 1 This thesis is being submitted in partial fulfilment of the requirements for the degree of PhD Signed………………………………………… (candidate) Date ………………………… STATEMENT 2 This thesis is the result of my own independent work/investigation, except where otherwise stated. Other sources are acknowledged by explicit references. The views expressed are my own. Signed………………………………………… (candidate) Date ………………………… STATEMENT 3 I hereby give consent for my thesis, if accepted, to be available for photocopying and for inter-library loan, and for the title and summary to be made available to outside organisations. Signed………………………………………… (candidate) Date ………………………… STATEMENT 4: PREVIOUSLY APPROVED BAR ON ACCESS I hereby give consent for my thesis, if accepted, to be available for photocopying and for inter-library loans after expiry of a bar on access previously approved by the Academic Standards & Quality Committee. Signed………………………………………… (candidate) Date ………………………… III Table of Contents Introduction ...................................................................................................... 1 Chapter One: Ordoliberalism and its Influence on EU Tying Law 1.0 Introduction .......................................................................................... 12 2.0 The historical context of Ordoliberalism: the Birth of Ordoliberalism ... 15 3.0 General principles of Ordoliberalism .................................................... 18 3.1. Economic power ......................................................................... 18 3.2. Competition ................................................................................ 18 3.3. The basis of economics .............................................................. 20 3.4. Economic Constitution ................................................................ 22 3.5. The independent monopoly office .............................................. 22 4.0 Ordoliberal influence in Germany ......................................................... 24 4.1. Leading personalities in the implementation of Ordoliberalism in Germany .................................................................................................... 26 5.0 Tying law in the German legal system: the historical development ...... 28 6.0 Ordoliberal theory’s transition from German law to the EU competition law 31 6.1. Evidence in support of the Ordoliberal influence ............................... 34 6.2. The involvement of Ordoliberals in the Treaty negotiations .............. 34 6.3. German Research ............................................................................ 35 6.4. Memoirs ............................................................................................ 36 6.5. Broader European research .............................................................. 38 7.0 Conclusion ........................................................................................... 40 Chapter Two: The Chicago School of Antitrust Analysis 1.0 Introduction .......................................................................................... 43 2.0 Historical Context and Development 1880-1950 .................................. 46 2.1. Historical Context .............................................................................. 46 2.2. The Harvard School of Antitrust Analysis ......................................... 48 2.3. The Origin of the Chicago School of Antitrust Analysis ..................... 49 3.0 Substantive Elements of the Chicago School of Thought .................... 51 3.1. The Purpose of Antitrust Law ............................................................ 53 3.2. Barriers to Entry ................................................................................ 54 3.3. Cartels and Price Fixing .................................................................... 54 3.4. Resale Price Maintenance ................................................................ 55 3.5. Predatory Pricing .............................................................................. 56 IV 3.6. Vertical Integration ............................................................................ 57 3.7. Tying ................................................................................................. 57 4.0 Criticism of the Chicago School of Antitrust Analysis ........................... 59 4.1. Barriers to Entry ................................................................................ 59 4.2. Challenges to the Chicago School .................................................... 63 5.0 Conclusion ........................................................................................... 66 Chapter Three: Post-Chicago Antitrust Analysis 1.0. Introduction .......................................................................................... 69 1.1. The shifting influence from Chicago to post-Chicago ........................ 70 1.2. Challenging the principles of the Chicago School ............................. 71 2.0 General principles of Post-Chicago analysis ........................................ 72 2.1 The Post Chicago method of investigation........................................ 72 2.2 The use of game theory in predicting firms’ behaviour ..................... 73 2.3 The measure of welfare .................................................................... 74 2.4 Cartels .............................................................................................. 76 2.5 Predatory pricing ............................................................................... 76 3.0 Tying theories ...................................................................................... 78 3.1 Whinston’s model 1990 ........................................................................ 78 3.2 Choi and Stefanadis model 2001 ......................................................... 79 3.3 Nalebuff model 2005 ............................................................................ 80 3.4 Carlton and Waldman model 2002 ....................................................... 80 3.5 Evans and Salinger model 2005 ........................................................... 83 4.0 Criticism of Post-Chicago ..................................................................... 84 4.1 Concerns about government intervention ......................................... 84 4.2 Prevalence of harm and consistency of approach ............................ 85 4.3 The ability of the courts to administer post-Chicago principles ......... 86 5.0 How should tying be treated by the courts? ......................................... 90 6.0 Application in EU competition law ........................................................ 95 7.0 Conclusion ........................................................................................... 96 Chapter Four: The EU Approach to Tying: The mono-theoretical period 1.0 Introduction .......................................................................................... 99 2.0 EU Tying Law 1957-2004 ................................................................... 102 3.0 Ordoliberalism in the Approach to Tying: Customer Freedom ........... 107 3.1. The significance of the mono-theoretical period ............................. 107 V 3.2. EU Tying Commission
Recommended publications
  • Node.Js As a Networking Tool
    Node.js As a networking tool 28.12.2010 About Contributor Co-founder Felix Geisendörfer node.js driver node-formidable Who are you? Node.js? JavaScript? Port = 80 ? Port != 80 ? Node's goal is to provide an easy way to build scalable network programs. Node.js • Created by Ryan Dahl • Google’s V8 JavaScript engine (no DOM) • Module system, I/O bindings, Common Protocols Network Edition Hello World $ cat hello.js var net = require('net'); net.createServer(function(socket) { socket.write('hello world\n'); socket.end(); }).listen(0x27C3); $ node hello.js & [1] 3591 $ nc localhost 10179 hello world Why JavaScript? 3 Reasons #1 - The good parts V8 (Chrome) SpiderMonkey (Firefox) JavaScriptCore (Safari) #2 - JS Engine Wars Chakra (IE9) Carakan (Opera) #3 - No I/O or Threads Non-blocking I/O Blocking I/O db.query('SELECT A'); console.log('query A done'); db.query('SELECT B'); console.log('query B done'); Time = SUM(A, B) Non-Blocking I/O db.query('SELECT A', function(result) { console.log('query A done'); }); db.query('SELECT B', function(result) { console.log('query B done'); }); Time = MAX(A, B) libev by Marc Lehmann libev • An infinite loop (event loop) • Polls the OS for events (select, epoll, kqueue, ...) • Allows you to register watchers / callbacks for the events you care about Buffers Buffers • Raw C memory allocation • Similar to an array of integers • Can be converted to and from JS strings Buffers buffer.write('Hello Buffer'); buffer.toString('utf-8'); buffer[0] = 23; buffer.slice(10, 20); Reverse Hello World $ cat reverse_hello.js
    [Show full text]
  • General Report on the Activities of the European Union Gnrl Report General 2010 Nteatvte Fteerpa No — on the Activities of the European Union 2010
    NA-AD-11-001-EN-C ISSN ISSN 1608-7321 GENERAL REPORT ON THE ACTIVITIES OF THE EUROPEAN UNION GENERAL GENERAL REPORT 2010 ON THE ACTIVITIES OF THE EUROPEAN UNION UNION EUROPEAN THE OF ACTIVITIES THE ON — 2010 doi:10.2775/59174 EN EUROPEAN COMMISSION Price (excluding VAT) in Luxembourg: EUR 7 The European Union 0500 km Açores (PT) Reykjavík Ísland Madeira (PT) Canarias (ES) Guadeloupe (FR) Martinique (FR) Suomi Paramaribo Finland Guyane Norge Suriname Réunion (FR) (FR) Helsinki Brasil Helsingfors Oslo Sverige Stockholm Tallinn Rossija Eesti Moskva United Kingdom RƯga Latvija Danmark Baile Átha Cliath Éire København Dublin Lietuva Ireland Vilnius R. Minsk Nederland Belarus' London Qazaqstan Amsterdam Berlin Warszawa België Brussel Polska Bruxelles Deutschland Belgique Kyïv Luxembourg Praha Paris Ukraʀna Luxembourg ýeská republika Slovensko Bratislava Wien Moldova France Schweiz Liechtenstein Budapest Bern Suisse Österreich Chiúinău Svizzera Magyarország Slovenija Ljubljana Zagreb România Hrvatska Sakartvelo Tbilisi Bucureúti Bosna i Beograd Azԥrbaycan San Marino Hercegovina Portugal Monaco Srbija Haʀastan General Report on the Activities of the European Union — 2010 Andorra Sarajevo Ȼɴɥɝɚɪɢɹ Yerevan Crna Priština Bulgaria (Azԥr.) Madrid Gora Lisboa Italia Kosovo ɋɨɮɢɹ Roma Podgorica * UNSCR 1244 Sofia Iran Skopje European Commission España Città del Vaticano Tiranë P.J.R.M. Shqipëria Ankara Directorate-General for Communication Türkiye ǼȜȜȐįĮ Publications Ellada ǹșȒȞĮȚ Athinai Alger 1049 Brussels Souriya Rabat Tunis ȁİȣțȦıȓĮ ȀȪʌȡȠȢ Lefkosia Iraq Lefkosa El Maghreb El Djazâir Valletta Kypros BELGIUM Tounis Malta Kibris Libnan Beyrouth Dimashq Member States of the European Union (2011) The General Report on the Activities of the European Union — 2010 Candidate countries was adopted by the European Commission on 16 February 2011 under reference number SEC(2011) 189.
    [Show full text]
  • Microsoft in Education Professional Development Suite UNLOCK the POTENTIAL of YOUR DISTRICT
    SERVICES FLYER Microsoft in Education Professional Development Suite UNLOCK THE POTENTIAL OF YOUR DISTRICT As the world’s leading provider of education IT, Lenovo understands that Why Lenovo and Education Collaborators? making technology matter to learning Real World – Real Results The unique demands of your school and students isn’t just about hardware and software. require a diverse set of learning strategies. We will work Teachers must be empowered with with your team to design a plan that leverages your existing resources and addresses both your needs and tools that build on their dedication your budget requirements. and expertise. Research shows that professional development drives stronger outcomes. Educators, and ultimately students, Through a partnership with Educational will benefit from the collaboration and differentiated Collaborators, a nationally recognized learning techniques, delivered in ways that matter to them. leader in educational training, Lenovo Multiple Learning Platforms offers a customizable combination Support your teachers’ own unique learning styles through face-to-face, train-the-trainer, or web-based of training programs that enable training, all conducted by experts skilled in their your school or district to support the specific area of interest. professional development that’s been • On-Site, hands-on, interactive workshops at proven fundamental to stronger student your location. outcomes — all delivered in a method that • Webinars, small group teaching and learning, best suits your budget and needs. capitalizing on the personal face-to-face collaboration of video conferencing and features such as screen sharing, Q&A app, and more. Facilitated by Educational Collaborators, the classes focus on the Microsoft • Mentoring, personalized one-on-one professional development via scheduled, remote mentoring that Professional Development Suite for facilitates continued personal learning and exposure Education, guiding participants through to tools they can learn today and use tomorrow.
    [Show full text]
  • CHOICE – a NEW STANDARD for COMPETITION LAW ANALYSIS? a Choice — a New Standard for Competition Law Analysis?
    GO TO TABLE OF CONTENTS GO TO TABLE OF CONTENTS CHOICE – A NEW STANDARD FOR COMPETITION LAW ANALYSIS? a Choice — A New Standard for Competition Law Analysis? Editors Paul Nihoul Nicolas Charbit Elisa Ramundo Associate Editor Duy D. Pham © Concurrences Review, 2016 GO TO TABLE OF CONTENTS All rights reserved. No photocopying: copyright licenses do not apply. The information provided in this publication is general and may not apply in a specifc situation. Legal advice should always be sought before taking any legal action based on the information provided. The publisher accepts no responsibility for any acts or omissions contained herein. Enquiries concerning reproduction should be sent to the Institute of Competition Law, at the address below. Copyright © 2016 by Institute of Competition Law 60 Broad Street, Suite 3502, NY 10004 www.concurrences.com [email protected] Printed in the United States of America First Printing, 2016 Publisher’s Cataloging-in-Publication (Provided by Quality Books, Inc.) Choice—a new standard for competition law analysis? Editors, Paul Nihoul, Nicolas Charbit, Elisa Ramundo. pages cm LCCN 2016939447 ISBN 978-1-939007-51-3 ISBN 978-1-939007-54-4 ISBN 978-1-939007-55-1 1. Antitrust law. 2. Antitrust law—Europe. 3. Antitrust law—United States. 4. European Union. 5. Consumer behavior. 6. Consumers—Attitudes. 7. Consumption (Economics) I. Nihoul, Paul, editor. II. Charbit, Nicolas, editor. III. Ramundo, Elisa, editor. K3850.C485 2016 343.07’21 QBI16-600070 Cover and book design: Yves Buliard, www.yvesbuliard.fr Layout implementation: Darlene Swanson, www.van-garde.com GO TO TABLE OF CONTENTS ii CHOICE – A NEW STANDARD FOR COMPETITION LAW ANALYSIS? Editors’ Note PAUL NIHOUL NICOLAS CHARBIT ELISA RAMUNDO In this book, ten prominent authors offer eleven contributions that provide their varying perspectives on the subject of consumer choice: Paul Nihoul discusses how freedom of choice has emerged as a crucial concept in the application of EU competition law; Neil W.
    [Show full text]
  • Internet Explorer 9 Features
    m National Institute of Information Technologies NIIT White Paper On “What is New in Internet Explorer 9” Submitted by: Md. Yusuf Hasan Student ID: S093022200027 Year: 1st Quarter: 2nd Program: M.M.S Date - 08 June 2010 Dhaka - Bangladesh Internet Explorer History Abstract: In the early 90s—the dawn of history as far as the World Wide Web is concerned—relatively few users were communicating across this Internet Explorer 9 (abbreviated as IE9) is the upcoming global network. They used an assortment of shareware and other version of the Internet Explorer web browser from software for Microsoft Windows operating system. In 1995, Microsoft Microsoft. It is currently in development, but developer hosted an Internet Strategy Day and announced its commitment to adding Internet capabilities to all its products. In fulfillment of that previews have been released. announcement, Microsoft Internet Explorer arrived as both a graphical Web browser and the name for a set of technologies. IE9 will have complete or nearly complete support for all 1995: Internet Explorer 1.0: In July 1995, Microsoft released the CSS 3 selectors, border-radius CSS 3 property, faster Windows 95 operating system, which included built-in support for JavaScript and embedded ICC v2 or v4 color profiles dial-up networking and TCP/IP (Transmission Control support via Windows Color System. IE9 will feature Protocol/Internet Protocol), key technologies for connecting to the hardware accelerated graphics rendering using Direct2D, Internet. In response to the growing public interest in the Internet, Microsoft created an add-on to the operating system called Internet hardware accelerated text rendering using Direct Write, Explorer 1.0.
    [Show full text]
  • Introducing Silverlight From?
    02_0672330148_ch01.qxd 9/25/08 2:23 PM Page 3 Silverlight 2 Unleashed, published by SAMS, Copyright 2009 Pearson Education, Inc. ISBN 0672330148 CHAPTER 1 IN THIS CHAPTER . Where Does Silverlight Come Introducing Silverlight From? . Using Third-Party Plug-Ins . Running on Multiple Platforms . Making the Web Application Secure t all started when Microsoft presented its revolutionary I . Introducing Silverlight.net user interface (UI) framework, Windows Presentation Foundation, to an enthusiastic crowd of graphics designers, . What Do You Need to Run software developers, and businessmen in March 2006 at the Silverlight? new MIX conference in Las Vegas. Microsoft also added . Updating Your Runtime— one session about a lesser-known technology with the Automatically rather barbarian name Windows Presentation Foundation . Trying Silverlight Demos Everywhere, or WPF/E. There was nothing much to see yet, but the abstract was enticing: “With WPF/E you’ll be able . What Do You Need to Develop to build rich, interactive experiences that run in major Web Silverlight? browsers on major platforms as well as on mobile devices.” . Reading the Documentation A little more than a year later, at the second edition of the . Looking into Silverlight’s same MIX conference, Scott Guthrie (general manager at Future Microsoft, responsible for most of the .NET teams) climbed on stage and gave the crowd an amazing software demon- stration. The barbarian WPF/E was gone; in its place was Silverlight (see Figure 1.1). A bright new logo revolved on the screens. Gradients and animations were all over the place. Planes flew over the web browser’s window, connecting US cities while Scott was planning his next trips; a chess application let the browser’s JavaScript engine play against .NET, demonstrat- ing without any doubt the superior power of the compiled .NET application over JavaScript’s interpreted code.
    [Show full text]
  • User Guide User User Guide
    El color actual del equipo puede variar. puede equipo del actual color El afiliadas a AT&T. © 2010 AT&T Intellectual Property. Todos los derechos reservados. derechos los Todos Property. Intellectual AT&T 2010 © AT&T. a afiliadas contenidas aquí son marcas comerciales de AT&T Intellectual Property y/o compañías compañías y/o Property Intellectual AT&T de comerciales marcas son aquí contenidas del software del teléfono o del proveedor del servicio. Todas las marcas de AT&T AT&T de marcas las Todas servicio. del proveedor del o teléfono del software del Parte del contenido de este guía del usuario puede variar en el teléfono, dependiendo dependiendo teléfono, el en variar puede usuario del guía este de contenido del Parte User Guide User Guide Guía del Usuario Guía del Usuario del Guía Some of the contents in this manual may differ from your phone depending on the software of the phone or your service provider. AT&T marks contained herein are trademarks of AT&T Intellectual Property and/or AT&T affiliated companies. © 2010 AT&T Intellectual Property. All rights reserved. Actual color of the phone may vary. Bluetooth QD ID B016767 ID QD Bluetooth Your phone is designed to make it easy for you to access a wide variety of content. For your protection, we want you to be aware that some applications that you enable may involve the location of your phone being shared. For applications available through AT&T, we offer privacy controls that let you decide how an application may use the location of your phone and other phones on your account.
    [Show full text]
  • SA2MXX English User Manual
    Register your product and get support at www.philips.com/welcome SA2MXX02 SA2MXX04 SA2MXX08 EN User manual 10 Update MIX 15 Contents Contents Manually verify / update firmware 15 English 1 Important safety information 2 11 Troubleshooting 16 General maintenance 2 Recycling the product 4 12 Technical data 17 System requirements 17 2 Your new MIX 6 What’s in the box 6 13 Glossary 18 3 Getting started 7 Overview of the controls and connections 7 Limit the volume 7 Overview of the main menu 7 Connect and charge 8 Software loaded on the MIX 8 Files loaded on the MIX 8 4 Turn MIX on and off 9 Automatic standby and shut-down 9 5 Music 10 Listen to music 10 Find your music 10 6 Radio 11 Listen to FM radio 11 Manually tune a radio station 11 Auto-tune radio station presets 11 Play a preset radio station 11 7 Recordings 12 Record audio/voices 12 Listen to recordings 12 Delete one or more recordings 12 Upload your recordings to a computer 12 Need help? 8 Use the MIX to carry data files 13 Please visit www.philips.com/welcome where you can access a full set of supporting 9 Settings 14 materials such as the user manual, the latest software updates, and answers to frequently asked questions. EN 1 1 Important safety Hearing Safety information Listen at a moderate volume: General maintenance Using headphones at a high volume can impair your hearing. This product can produce sounds The translation of this document is for in decibel ranges that may cause hearing loss for reference only.
    [Show full text]
  • Contents Summary Self-Hosted Applications
    Licensing brief November 2020 Self -Hosted Applications This brief applies to all Microsoft Licensing programs. Contents Summary ...................................................................................................................................................................................................................... 1 Details ........................................................................................................................................................................................................................... 2 Licensing options for Self-Hosted ISVs ....................................................................................................................................................... 2 The Services Provider License Agreement ............................................................................................................................................ 2 The “Self-Hosted Applications” use right .............................................................................................................................................. 2 What is a Qualified Unified Solution? .......................................................................................................................................................... 2 What are the licensing requirements? ......................................................................................................................................................... 3 Required Microsoft Software licenses
    [Show full text]
  • Office Mix Quick Start.Pdf
    Mississippi University for Women Spring 2016 Microsoft Office Mix Recording Quick Start Before you Begin 1. Make sure your slide deck is saved with a PPTX extension. Note: If you want to start with a slide deck saved in the older, PPT format • Open it in PowerPoint 2013. • Then click File on the menu bar, and click Convert. • PowerPoint will open the Save As dialog with the filename and PPTX extension already filled in. 2. Set your audio level before you start recording. Do a test recording with your mic and adjust the volume to find the optimal setting. To do this: • On the Mix tab, click Slide Recording, • On the Audio and Video pane, select your microphone from the drop-down. • You will see your Microphone levels when you speak into your microphone. • If you levels are not high enough, adjust the level of the mixer board in the drawer on the right side. (These levels are already preset, but can be adjusted). 3. To record your test slide, click the Record button. Speak as you would to your class into your microphone. 3 4. As soon as you finish your first slide recording, play it back by clicking the Preview Slide Recording button. 5. If you are satisfied with your recording sound, click the Delete Slide Recording button. 4 5 How to create a slide recording The easiest way to create a slide recording is to create a PowerPoint presentation first. Then record on top of your existing slides. 1. Go to the slide where you want your recording to begin.
    [Show full text]
  • Commercial Licensing Guide
    CommercialCommercial LicensingLicensing GuideGuide i Table of contents Chapter 1: Introduction to Microsoft Commercial Licensing ............................................................................................... 4 How to use this guide ............................................................................................................................................................ 4 Keys to understanding Microsoft Commercial Licensing ................................................................................................. 4 Programs for the type and size of an organization ............................................................................................................ 5 Programs for public sector and other organizations ......................................................................................................... 6 Licensing on-premises software ........................................................................................................................................... 6 Licensing Microsoft cloud services ...................................................................................................................................... 7 Microsoft Financing ............................................................................................................................................................... 7 Chapter 2: Choosing a Commercial Licensing program for commercial organizations ................................................... 8 Microsoft Open Programs
    [Show full text]
  • Getting Started with Xamarin.Forms an Introduction to Building Native User Interfaces for Cross-Platform Apps
    Getting Started with Xamarin.Forms An Introduction to Building Native User Interfaces for Cross-Platform Apps WHITEPAPER © 2017 Progress. All Rights Reserved. All Rights © 2017 Progress. Table of Contents Introduction / 3 Getting to Know Xamarin.Forms / 4 Xamarin.Forms Is More Than Controls / 4 Creating a Basic Xamarin.Forms App / 5 Ideal Use Cases for Xamarin.Forms / 8 Understanding Xamarin.Forms Layouts / 9 StackLayout / 10 Grid / 12 AbsoluteLayout / 15 RelativeLayout / 18 Using XAML in Xamarin.Forms / 22 The Benefits of Using XAML / 22 The Basics / 23 Properties / 25 Reacting to Events / 25 Accessing Static Data Using XAML / 26 StaticExtension Class / 27 Resource Dictionaries / 30 Creating Objects From XAML / 32 Accessing Dynamic Data / 35 Dynamic Resources / 35 Data Binding / 37 © 2017 Progress. All Rights Reserved. All Rights © 2017 Progress. Progress / Telerik UI for Xamarin Introduction Today’s enterprises—especially industry leaders—rely on their mobile applications. These applications can be used for a variety of purposes, from in-field reporting to consumer engagement. However, despite the widespread proliferation of mobile applications, mobile development remains a challenging prospect due to the number of popular operating systems powering these devices. Android, iOS, Universal Windows Platform (UWP)—they’re all unique and require different skills to develop, deploy and maintain applications. At best, building a cross- platform mobile application is an exercise in tedium. At worst, it’s a development nightmare. This is where Xamarin comes in. The Xamarin framework enables developers to build cross- platform mobile applications (with native performance) using a shared codebase—C#. However, that shared codebase only extends to the application logic side of things.
    [Show full text]