Weekly Worker

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Weekly Worker A paper of Marxist polemic and Marxist unity weekly Latest ‘Star Wars’ movie: n Labour’s reshuffle workern Saudi Arabia lashes out recapturing lost nostalgia or n Neil Davidson’s papers a money spinning cargo cult? n Herbert Spencer reloaded No 1088 Thursday January 7 2016 Towards a Communist Party of the European Union £1/€1.10 Docrock Popular militia vs standing army 2 weekly January 7 2016 1088 worker LETTERS Letters may have been society of freely associated producers can issues shows that those opposing me including to the structure of elected In 1916 the Labour Party programme shortened because of grow within and outwith the trade unions do not view debate as a dialectical officerships and committees, should be was neither republican nor anti-unionist space. Some names and the labour movement. At some point process which aims to get us closer to decided at an AGM, not at the SGM, and supported imperialist wars. Connolly may have been changed in the near future a consciousness will the truth. Obviously, there is little point which has no such constitutional altering stood for the opposite. A river of blood emerge of the need for a campaign for in debating with people who agree with remit. divided these two positions. In 2016 the Labourism RIP Marxist parties worldwide to support me. The dialectical conflict of opposites Also deciding that the conference Labour Party remains committed to the Labourism is dead. Long live socialism! workers to realise this goal. is a necessary part of the process of arrangements committee reserves the UK constitution based on the monarchy The doctrine that a political party Marxists can extend and publicise development. The problem with Ted’s right to rule on whether the subject of the and the union, and has continued to back representing the trade unions can bring their critique of Keynesian ‘alternatives’ view is that it regards Marxism as existing amendments falls within the remit of the imperialist wars, despite the election of socialism into being is now in the dustbin and show that socialism is the only outside of the dialectical process - that is, SGM, or whether they should be referred Corbyn and the over-excitement of the of history. Trade unions are calling for alternative to austerity. It is highly above criticism. But the laws of dialectics to the subsequent AGM (to be held later Trotskyist left. a limited fiscal stimulus to lift the UK unlikely that the ruling class will allow apply to Marxism as well. In other words, in 2016), means that the democratic rights My point about Left Unity and the economy out of a depression. This has as the restoration of public expenditure and the Marxist ‘thesis’ is bound to generate of affiliated organisations are abolished. CPGB’s Communist Platform is not that much in common with a globally planned workers’ rights to pre-1979 levels. This an antithesis which leads human thought No AGM up to now had any such they should organise an armed uprising classless society as the mummified body is a reason why the Labour leadership forward. Dogmas come from those who bureaucratic control on motions. Given any time soon, but rather that LU has no of an ancient pharaoh with a new born will continue its progress from left to have abandoned the scientific method, the outrageous bureaucratic structures future unless it changes its programme child. right. Austerity needs to be fought at all and don’t know dialectics. of Momentum so far, a 60-strong and becomes an anti-unionist republican At the 2015 Labour Party conference, levels - from above and below, globally This is why anyone who defends appointed anonymous committee with no socialist party. Then and only then will the new trade union-backed leader as well as locally. Unscathed by the death Marxism, or regard it as above criticism, democratic mandate, obviously chosen LU be in a position to relate to Rise declared he was a British patriot. He has spasms of Labourism, Marxists can play should take me on in the pages of the for the flexibility of political backbones, (Scottish left alliance). Then and only subsequently compromised on going to a significant role in the leadership of this Weekly Worker. Running away is simply this move is to prevent any far more then will it place its relations with the war. He no longer calls for the ending fight. abandoning dialectics. This is a form of structurally democratic organisation like Corbyn movement in England and Wales of tuition fees and the restoration of The struggle against austerity entails suppressing criticism. As someone who the LRC operating, lest it be far more on a solid basis. LU will become a party student grants. He has dropped plans to the democratic mobilisation of workers believes in a democratic socialist society, attractive to the new membership than with its own distinct democratic political nationalise the major energy companies. around a plan that goes beyond cuts and to Ted I say, in a memorable communist Momentum, which they will have no objectives and not seem like some His shadow chancellor has abandoned workers’ rights. This plan might include slogan: “Let a hundred flowers bloom. Let direct means of influencing. Corbyn groupie hanging around the stage the idea of bringing the Bank of England calls for full employment; a shorter a hundred schools of thought contend.” The reason given for the bureaucratic door hoping for a sprinkle of star dust. back into state control. Both have stated working week; a living income in or out Tony Clark manoeuvres in the opening paragraph Tony makes one revealing gaff. He they are friends of business and industry. of work; free housing, fuel, transport, Labour Supporter - “Hostile elements still abound, in the says that “When the political debate Paul Marshall, co-founder of the $22 education, health, education and social parliamentary party, the organisational in this country is focused on the battle billion hedge fund, Marshall Ware, has care; the socialisation of transnational No answer apparatus and beyond. There can be no between left and right within the Labour applauded Labour plans for “people’s corporations under workers’ control; the In ‘A perfectly ordinary, highly instructive place for routinism - the left must raise its Party”, Left Unity is finished (“their day quantitative easing”. He thinks it would workplace election of managers; and the document’ (December 17), Lars T Lih game to meet the new tasks we now face” has long gone”). But what is meant by be a useful means of stabilising the redistribution of resources from arms writes: “The Bolsheviks rejected any - in no way justifies this postponement. “this country”? Does he mean the UK, economy the next time there is a financial and fossil fuel to socially useful forms of sort of political agreement or alliance Its obvious motivation is to manoeuvre Britain or England (and Wales)? Scotland crisis. The Money, Macro and Finance production. with the liberal bourgeoisie because they against its critics from the left and from has different politics, which I highlighted Research Group also discussed the Such calls articulate needs that are felt that these leaders would sell out the the potential of the new membership. In in Bermondsey. (As he missed the key Labour leader’s economic policies at a part of a collective struggle to overthrow revolution after it started by making a the tradition of that master of bureaucratic point in my election campaign, he just conference in September. This group capitalism. They will be fully realised deal or agreement with tsarism.” manoeuvres, Uncle Joe, on some lost the job as my spin doctor!) consists of investment bankers, business with the establishment of a democratically Very true. But, after the February occasions the revolutionary or even more However, Tony does make a telling economists, private equity and hedge planned classless society worldwide. revolution of 1917, there is no tsarism radical left is a greater enemy of those point that the CPGB is in a contradictory fund managers. Contributors scoffed Paul B Smith around to make a deal with - but there who command the apparatus. position over Labour and Left Unity by at the idea that creating money by email is still a liberal bourgeoisie intent on The aim of this manoeuvre is to trying to run with the hare and hunt with order of the government would create selling out the revolution. What then, Dr effectively abolish the LRC itself and the hounds. Programme must come hyperinflation. Flower oil Lih? Lih refuses to recognise the sheer its continued existence in a hobbled before tactics. Which side of the river In other words there are intelligent Understanding the relationship between novelty of this situation and the equally form is aimed at preventing any other of blood should socialists stand? On the members of the ruling class who support peak oil and the global economy is novel political questions raised by it and democratic radical leftist organisation right bank with Kier Hardie and Ramsay the Labour leader and his advisory team crucial to knowing how the present crisis to which the pre-1917 polemics among emerging that would develop the McDonald’s Labourism, or the left bank of conservative Keynesian economists. of capitalism will play out. Debating European and Russian Social Democrats leftism of the new membership by with James Connolly’s anti-unionist They can see the point of using the socialism without grasping the energy could offer no unequivocal answer. Only giving them this democratic space, thus republican programme? No contest. Labour leader’s mainstream economic issue in general and peak oil in particular Trotsky developed the correct answer preventing embarrassment to Corbyn and Steve Freeman ideas if policies associated with austerity is a futile exercise.
Recommended publications
  • March 2016 EDITORIAL – BURNING IVORY IS WRONG
    Ethical Record The Proceedings of the Conway Hall Ethical Society Vol. 121 No. 3 £1.50 March 2016 EDITORIAL – BURNING IVORY IS WRONG Throughout history, even highly sophisticated people have held the curious belief that qualities of goodness or power, when attributes of an admired god or animal, can be transferred to oneself by consumption of the god or possession of the animal part. Although the Eucharist ceremony doesn’t usually cause harm, mutilating animals certainly does – and it can cause the extinction of the species. It was therefore cheering to read of United for Wildlife’s plans to curb the terrible trading of elephant tusks and rhino horns, wanted for their alleged properties – until I read that Kenya intended to burn their 120-ton stockpile of valuable ivory seized from the poaching gangs. Nothing will please these gangs more than this proposed wanton destruction of this precious material, increasing its scarcity value and the incentive for further poaching. Kenya should instead store the ivory and sell it (and rhino horn) in small quantities to craftsmen, scientists and even gullible others (without a guarantee of magical efficacy) in order to finance the high cost of the animals’ protection. DEMOCRACY FOR THE 21ST CENTURY Derek Bates 3 LOTS HAPPENING AT CONWAY HALL Jim Walsh 6 POLITICS SHOULD MOVE TO THE LEFT Tom Rubens 8 POLITICS SHOULD NOT MOVE TO THE LEFT Tim Bale 14 EPIPHENOMENALISM – A REJOINDER Chris Bratcher 16 VIEWPOINTS J. Ginn, J, Tazewell, T, Rubens, Don Langdown 20 BOOK REVIEWS THE CONSOLATIONS OF AUTUMN by Hazhir Teimourian Norman Bacrac 22 TWO VIEWS OF JEREMY CORBYN Comrade Corbyn by Rosa Prince - and - Jeremy Corbyn - Accidental Hero by W.
    [Show full text]
  • Open Letter to Jeremy Corbyn Leo
    & Workers’ Liberty SolFor siociadl ownershaip of the branks aind intdustry y No 490 9 January 2019 50p/£1 Open letter to Jeremy Corbyn Leo An open letter to Jeremy Corbyn Panitch “I think we need to respect the referendum. As I say, I think that there is a deal which can be struck within Parliament that brings ev - on erybody together, that respects the views and wishes of communities whether they voted Leave or Remain” —Rebecca Long-Bailey, Shadow Secretary for Business, Sky News, 16 Trump December. Interview pages 6-8 Comrade Corbyn! The 2016 referendum vote that the UK FIGHT should withdraw from the EU, after 45 years membership, plunged Britain into a prolonged political crisis. Today, less than three months before Britain is due to leave, that crisis has not yet been resolved. The 2016 vote plunged the Labour Party into a crisis too. In that vote Labour opposed any form of Brexit and advocated a vote to remain. Assessing the Turn to page 5 Gilets Jaunes Michael Elms surveys the Gilets Jaunes BREXIT movement in France, still active despite the Christmas and New Year pause. See page 9 Bolsonaro sets out plans Andressa Alegre reports on the first measures, and the plans, of “Brazil’s Trump”. See page 2 Renew Labour! A new Stop Brexit campaign See page 4 2 NEWS More online at www.workersliberty.org Bolsonaro sets out plans behind lines of armed police to in - was to lower the minimum salary guidelines (though it does seem We haven’t yet quite had a taste By Andressa Alegre timidate the press, Bolsonaro from 1006 reais (approx.
    [Show full text]
  • Labour Goes for New Public Vote
    & Workers’ Liberty SolFor siociadl ownershaip of the branks aind intdustry y No 497 26 February 2019 50p/£1 Labour goes for new public vote All out on 23 March See page 12 After the Umunna split Sean Matgamna writes an open letter to Jeremy Corbyn, page 9; Editorial on the Umunna split and after, page 5 See pages 5 & 9 LABOUR: New school climate protest 15 March Alan Simpson discusses what we can BOn MondayA 25 FebruaryC the LabouKr Party leade rshipR came out E• By reMdoubling the callA for a speciaIl conNference in wh! ich the learn from the 15 February school walk- for a new public vote on Brexit. Labour Party sorts itself out. outs Shadow Brexit minister Keir Starmer and shadow foreign secretary On Monday 25th “a Labour spokesman”, presumably from the Emily Thornberry have said they would vote Remain in that refer - Leader’s Office, was telling Reuters that “a referendum giving a See page 7 endum. choice between May’s deal and Remain would not be acceptable”. This is a great victory for the anti-Brexit left. We should clinch it: The Skwawkbox blog, known as an unofficial feed from the • By mobilising on the streets to add pressure on Parliament. Leader’s Office, branded the story that Labour was backing a second Labour should sponsor a big bloc on the 23 March “People’s Vote” Brexit referendum as “‘mainstream’ fake news”. Labour for a demonstration. Labour for a Socialist Europe, the anti-Brexit left Labour members have to guard against backsliding, and against group in Labour, has already started organising for that.
    [Show full text]
  • Feet on the Ground a Blog by “Xavier”
    Feet On The Ground a blog by “Xavier” being the journal of a mega-millions lottery winner fotg the third Produced by HTSP Editorial Division, 10/SK6 4EG, G.B. © “Xavier” MM15-16 F&F BOOKS www.FarragoBooks.co.uk Feet On The Ground : “Xavier 3” 1 The Mathemagics of Religion 1st June 2015 “Two plus two equals five.” “No, you’re wrong, it’s one plus three that’s equal to five.” “Excuse me, but you’re both wrong. It’s three plus three that’s equal to five.” Which was the better cup final? 1st June 2015 A straw poll at the Mansion gave it to the Scottish cup by a landslide. Which makes it the more strange that the Sunday Telegraph didn’t deign to offer a match report in what was supposed to be its Sport section. What was the highlite of race 2 in Detroit? 1st June 2015 There was enormous satisfaction in Will Power, the whingeing Aussie, crashing into the wall in the final stages. Despite not finishing, he still got 13 points. And Muños, who completed only 5 of the 70 laps, collected 7 points. Indycar’s something for nothing culture is just great. Not our job, mate 4th June 2015 To those who say Britain ditching the European Convention on ’Uman Rights would set the wrong example to the rest of the world, 2 points: 1. It’s not our job to set examples for the rest of the world. 2. There’s nothing wrong with abandoning the court in Feet On The Ground : “Xavier 3” 2 Strasbourg if it is incompetent and staffed by people who are unqualified to make sensible judgements.
    [Show full text]
  • User-Generated Ideology in the Age of Jeremy Corbyn and Social Media Fuchs, Christian
    WestminsterResearch http://www.westminster.ac.uk/westminsterresearch Red Scare 2.0: User-Generated Ideology in the Age of Jeremy Corbyn and Social Media Fuchs, Christian This is an author's accepted manuscript of an article published in the Journal of Language and Politics, 15 (4), pp. 369-398, 2016. The final definitive version is available online at: https://dx.doi.org/10.1075/jlp.15.4.01fuc The article is under copyright and that the publisher should be contacted for permission to re-use or reprint the material in any form. The WestminsterResearch online digital archive at the University of Westminster aims to make the research output of the University available to a wider audience. Copyright and Moral Rights remain with the authors and/or copyright owners. Whilst further distribution of specific materials from within this archive is forbidden, you may freely distribute the URL of WestminsterResearch: ((http://westminsterresearch.wmin.ac.uk/). In case of abuse or copyright appearing without permission e-mail [email protected] Fuchs, Christian. 2016. Red Scare 2.0: User-Generated Ideology in the Age of Jeremy Corbyn and Social Media. Journal of Language and Politics 15 (4): 369-398. Red Scare 2.0: User-Generated Ideology in the Age of Jeremy Corbyn and Social Media Christian Fuchs <369:> Abstract This paper asks: How has Jeremy Corbyn been framed in discourses on Twitter in an ideological manner and how have such ideological discourses been challenged? It uses ideology critique as method for the investigation of tweets mentioning Jeremy Corbyn that were collected during the final phase of the Labour Party’s 2015 leadership election.
    [Show full text]
  • Fuchs, Christian. 2016. Red Scare 2.0: User-Generated Ideology in the Age of Jeremy Corbyn and Social Media. Journal of Language and Politics 15 (4): 369-398
    Fuchs, Christian. 2016. Red Scare 2.0: User-Generated Ideology in the Age of Jeremy Corbyn and Social Media. Journal of Language and Politics 15 (4): 369-398. Red Scare 2.0: User-Generated Ideology in the Age of Jeremy Corbyn and Social Media Christian Fuchs <369:> Abstract This paper asks: How has Jeremy Corbyn been framed in discourses on Twitter in an ideological manner and how have such ideological discourses been challenged? It uses ideology critique as method for the investigation of tweets mentioning Jeremy Corbyn that were collected during the final phase of the Labour Party’s 2015 leadership election. The analysis shows how user-generated ideology portrays Jeremy Corbyn by creating discourse topics focused on general scapegoating, the economy, foreign politics, culture and authoritarianism. Keywords: social media, Twitter, Jeremy Corbyn, Labour Party, anti-socialist ideology, Red Scare, redbaiting, socialism 1. Introduction This paper asks: How has Jeremy Corbyn during the Labour Leadership Election been framed in discourses on Twitter in an ideological manner and how have such ideological discourses been challenged? It uses ideology critique for the investigation of 32,298 tweets mentioning Jeremy Corbyn that were collected in the time period from August 22 until September 13, 2015. Jeremy Corbyn, Andy Burnham, Yvette Cooper and Liz Kendall were the four candidates for the leadership of the Labour Party after Ed Miliband had stepped down in light of Labour’s fruitless attempt to beat the Conservatives in the British 2015 general election. The Labour Party in 2014 changed its electoral process from a system, in which Labour parliamentarians, members and trade unions/affiliated organisations had equal weight to one, in which members and affiliated supporters elect the Labour Party’s Leader.
    [Show full text]
  • Centre Write
    NICK CLEGG MP PROF VERNON BOGDANOR on Brexit, Trump and on how populist politics has the threat to liberalism fuelled a surge in nationalism Centre Write The end of the establishment? Summer 2016 | 1 chris skidmore mp | philip collins | nusr at ghani mp | the rt hon al an milburn Social reform Bright Blue is generating fresh thinking about the purpose, design and financing of the UK’s education and welfare systems to boost life chances and national prosperity. To compete in the global race, Britain needs to significantly improve the skills of its workforce and broaden access to high quality academic and vocational education. As the economy becomes more globalised, competitive and automated, Britain’s social security system also needs revamping to improve its effectiveness and popularity. Green conservatism Bright Blue is a leading centre-right voice devising and promoting policies that can cost-effectively safeguard the environment at the same as strengthening the economy. We produce rigorous analysis and fresh policy ideas to help the UK solve the ‘energy trilemma’ of achieving decarbonisation, affordable energy and security of supply. In particular, our work focuses on key policy areas such as air pollution, protecting the natural environment, the post-coal energy mix, energy efficiency, climate finance and investment, and international development. Human rights Human rights now have a bad reputation among the public, especially conservatives. But human rights are vital. They protect individual freedom, especially from an overreaching state. Our work explores how human rights can be better understood and enhanced in the UK and abroad, with a particular focus on: the contents of the forthcoming British Bill of Rights; the role of human rights in British foreign policy; and how to tackle racial, gender, sexual, disability and religious discrimination.
    [Show full text]
  • LF Reading List Volume 2
    Lockdown Reading List With almost all of us stuck at home due to the Coronavirus lockdown, we have compiled a political education list of our recommendations of books you can read and videos you can watch to help pass the time by improving your knowledge of the Labour Party and its history. This second version of the list includes extra suggestions that our supporters have sent to us in response to the initial list. We aren’t suggesting anyone will be able to read everything in the list, more that you will dip in and find something of interest. Please note that prices of some of the out of print books vary wildly on Amazon. Try searching for the titles that you want on websites of local bookshops in your area that do delivery as well. Please do send us your recommendations for other books or videos to add to the list, particularly about non-UK subjects as this is very much focused on the UK and Labour so far. Unfortunately, there’s a lack of diversity in both the subjects and authors of the historical books I’ve listed, for the sad reason that until All Women Shortlists were brought in for parliamentary selections in the 1990s, Labour’s structures were dominated by white men – Nan Sloane has addressed the previously often unrecorded role of women in the party’s history in “The Women in the Room: Labour’s Forgotten History” - https://www.amazon.co.uk/Women-Room-Labours-Forgotten- History-ebook/dp/B07MX8THJT/ History General History of the Labour Party • Old Labour to New - The Dreams That Inspired, the Battles That Divided – Greg Rosen
    [Show full text]
  • The Case of Jeremy Corbyn Abstract In
    This is the author(s) personal version of the manuscript, as accepted after the review process but prior to final layout and copyediting by the publisher. The final version is published as: Mueller, F., Whittle, A. & Gadelshina, G. (forthcoming) ‘The Discursive Construction of Authenticity: The Case of Jeremy Corbyn’ Forthcoming in Discourse, Context and Media. Readers are kindly asked to use the official publication in references. The Discursive Construction of Authenticity: The Case of Jeremy Corbyn Abstract In recent years there has been a yearning for a new, more authentic type of political leader: one who is more ‘true’, ‘real’ and ‘honest’. In this paper, we analyse the discourse through which Jeremy Corbyn was framed as an ‘authentic’ leader in the British press during the 2015 Labour party leadership contest. We use an ethnomethodological approach to the study of media texts to investigate the methods used by journalists and commentators to establish authenticity. Our analysis uncovers three methods that were used to establish Corbyn’s authenticity: consistency, atypicality and commitment to beliefs. We conclude by drawing implications from our findings for the search for authenticity in politics and society. Key words: authenticity, authentic leadership, ethnomethodology, media discourse, political discourse 1 The Discursive Construction of Authenticity: The Case of Jeremy Corbyn “The greatest crime of all in the modern media age is being inauthentic.” (The Guardian, 3rd June 2009)1 “…a credible challenger to Corbyn must achieve that magical ingredient of authenticity that he seems to exude.” (The Observer, 2nd August 2015) Introduction Jeremy Corbyn first came into the limelight in the UK during the 2015 Labour Party leadership contest, when he went from rank outsider to win a landslide victory in the space of less than four months.
    [Show full text]
  • Promises Promises Promises
    D Our Magazine is published every Aug—Sep other month and is freely available to 2017 our members www.cenca.co.uk Stay ‘In Touch’ with the ISSUE 42 Corby & E Northants Conservative Association Published by RM Boyd on behalf of Corby & E Northants Conservative Association and Tom Pursglove, all at CENCA, Cottingham Road, Corby, NN17 1SZ Printed by Contract Printing Services Ltd., Unit J, Cavendish Courtyard, Sallow Road, Weldon North Industrial Estate, Corby, NN17 5DZ PROMISES PROMISES PROMISES REMEMBER THE LEGACY OF THE LAST LABOUR GOVERNMENT? WE SHOULD BE SHOUTING THIS FROM THE ROOFTOPS TO REMIND EVERYONE OF THE DISASTERS OF PREVIOUS LABOUR GOVERNMENTS. LABOUR CAN’T BE TRUSTED WITH THE ECONOMY Conservative Association Chairman’s Report to Members Cllr Helen Harrison (Association Chairman) Jul 2017 We took our campaign to every These are difficult times! For part of our constituency no each of us, and for our matter how hopeless it may Party! have seemed. We talked a good talk on winning in central Just before the County Corby and scared the living Council elections took place, daylights out of the local when we were in full Labour party, forcing them to campaign mode, and focus their efforts on their looking forward to taking a safest divisions. rest from it all, a General Election was called. It was a great result for us, gaining more Conservative votes in every division! And, it We were riding high in the polls and we was this effort that enabled us to keep our made great gains across the Country in the seat at the General Election with a slightly Council elections a few days later.
    [Show full text]
  • Steuart, Kieran Jamie (2018) the Relevance of Social Class, Communications, and General Location, in Contemporary British Labour
    Steuart, Kieran Jamie (2018) The relevance of social class, communications, and general location, in contemporary British Labour Party politics, with a focus on North-West Cumbria. Doctoral thesis, University of Cumbria (awarded by Lancaster University). Downloaded from: http://insight.cumbria.ac.uk/id/eprint/3806/ Usage of any items from the University of Cumbria’s institutional repository ‘Insight’ must conform to the following fair usage guidelines. Any item and its associated metadata held in the University of Cumbria’s institutional repository Insight (unless stated otherwise on the metadata record) may be copied, displayed or performed, and stored in line with the JISC fair dealing guidelines (available here) for educational and not-for-profit activities provided that • the authors, title and full bibliographic details of the item are cited clearly when any part of the work is referred to verbally or in the written form • a hyperlink/URL to the original Insight record of that item is included in any citations of the work • the content is not changed in any way • all files required for usage of the item are kept together with the main item file. You may not • sell any part of an item • refer to any part of an item without citation • amend any item or contextualise it in a way that will impugn the creator’s reputation • remove or alter the copyright statement on an item. The full policy can be found here. Alternatively contact the University of Cumbria Repository Editor by emailing [email protected]. This thesis is submitted for the degree of ‘Doctor of Philosophy’ (Ph.D.) at Lancaster University Kieran Jamie Steuart, M.A., M.Sc./M.Res.
    [Show full text]
  • Simon on Corbyn
    A tale of two Islingtons How Blair opened the door for Corbyn Simon Matthews Tom Bower doesn’t write proper biographies. Over 35 years he has published studies – basically investigative journalism – of Klaus Barbie, Robert Maxwell, Tiny Rowland, Mohamed Al-Fayed, Geoffrey Robinson, Gordon Brown, Conrad Black, Bernie Ecclestone, Simon Cowell, Richard Branson, Tony Blair and Prince Charles. Working for the BBC from 1970, he reported for and then produced Panorama. He hit his stride in 1981 with Blind Eye to Murder: Britain, America and the Purging of Nazi Germany, an account of how, post-1945, various German war criminals were allowed to remain in situ and even flourish with the connivance of the UK and US authorities. After which he went from exposés of billionaire tycoons and major media figures to knocking copy on what were then the UK’s main political players, Brown and Blair. Bower was originally a barrister and his approach would be familiar to anyone who has attended court: slow careful questioning of the subjects’ contemporaries (many of whom portray themselves as victims); a prior position being taken that he is fulfilling a duty to put something bad in the public domain; and an adversarial, one-sided approach that ignores complex factors like intentions, context and general comparisons with whatever other people may or may not have actually done in the same circumstances. Given his monstrous background, this worked with Klaus Barbie. But Simon Cowell? Bower’s books usually lack the footnotes, appendices, access to official documents and reports and wide-ranging interviews that characterize proper biographies.
    [Show full text]