Br. Cathol. Hist. (2019), vol. 34(4), pp. 562–586 © Trustees of the Catholic Record Society 2019. doi:10.1017/bch.2019.25 Published by Cambridge University Press Ralph Sheldon (1537–1613) of Beoley and Weston: cloaked in conformity? Hilary L. Turner* Email:
[email protected] On two occasions, in 1580–1 and 1587, the Worcestershire gentleman Ralph Sheldon of Beoley and Weston (1537–1613) undertook to attend services in his parish church. This article seeks to make sense of these occasions of ‘con- formity’, in the context of the situation and choices facing Catholics in Protestant England. It argues that Ralph consciously rejected the Jesuit message about non-attendance at the state church, a view he never abandoned. Never described by his contemporaries as ‘papistically affected’, let alone as an ‘obsti- nate recusant’, his later reputation as such is mistaken. By exploring the evi- dence relating to these occasions of official conformity, it is possible to see how he managed the challenge of being a Catholic living within the law. He could be regarded, and treated, as an obedient subject. He might thus be viewed as a church papist. However, since occasional conformity must itself also sug- gest recusancy, a more nuanced understanding of his position requires a recon- sideration of some of the evidence. Keywords: Sheldon, conformity, Jesuits, loyalty, church papist alph Sheldon of Beoley and Weston (1537–1613) opened his will with a strongly Catholic preamble, followed by a decla- R ration of his wish to die as he had lived, in the verities of the Catholic church.1 This statement appears to contradict his under- taking in 1581 to remain loyal to the queen and to attend church, in other words to conform to the law demanding attendance.