Infant Places, Spaces and Objects: Exploring the Physical in Learning Environments for Infants Under Two

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Infant Places, Spaces and Objects: Exploring the Physical in Learning Environments for Infants Under Two Technological University Dublin ARROW@TU Dublin Doctoral Applied Arts 2011-11 Infant Places, Spaces and Objects: Exploring the Physical in Learning Environments for Infants Under Two Helen Lynch Technological University Dublin, [email protected] Follow this and additional works at: https://arrow.tudublin.ie/appadoc Part of the Social and Behavioral Sciences Commons Recommended Citation Lynch, H. (2011) Infant Places, Spaces and Objects: Exploring the Physical in Learning Environments for Infants Under Two. Doctoral Thesis, Technological University Dublin. doi:10.21427/D73W37 This Theses, Ph.D is brought to you for free and open access by the Applied Arts at ARROW@TU Dublin. It has been accepted for inclusion in Doctoral by an authorized administrator of ARROW@TU Dublin. For more information, please contact [email protected], [email protected]. This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial-Share Alike 4.0 License INFANT PLACES, SPACES AND OBJECTS: EXPLORING THE PHYSICAL IN LEARNING ENVIRONMENTS FOR INFANTS UNDER TWO Helen Lynch, MSc, Dip. C. O. T. Submitted in fulfilment of the requirements for the award of PhD, Dublin Institute of Technology, Supervisor: Dr. Noirin Hayes School of Social Science and Law NOVEMBER 2011 Volume 1 Abstract While the relationship between play and development is well documented, there is less known about the influence of the physical environment in that process. The purpose of this qualitative study is to describe play interactions of infants under two with the home physical environment. The aim is to explore and identify ways in which infants develop and learn through engaging with objects and spaces of everyday life in the home. A qualitative ethnographic approach was employed to gather data on five infants, two new-borns and three one-year olds, and their families over twelve months. Data was generated through video, interview and observations of the infants engaging in play with typical objects, in their natural home environments. Families were visited monthly to capture change in infant-environment transactions over time. Analysis focused on infant-environment transactions during play events in typical daily routines, guided by a grounded theory analytical approach. The study identifies that infant play is multidimensional, and combines and includes play not just with objects and people, but with space. Findings relate to the following aspects: play in relation to the physical environment of the home as observed through engaging with body space, near space, middle space and home space; the nature of change in play over time as it relates to affordances of the physical environment, and parental reasoning in families that shapes play interactions. Emerging findings relate to considering play as transactional processes that have an influence on development, and argues for an amended perspective on the home as a ‘just-right’ environment. This study describes how five Irish families support play in home environments and informs an understanding of influences on play development from a physical- sociocultural perspective. Suggestions are made in relation to how this study can inform the development of home-based play environments as a result. ii Declaration: I certify that this thesis which I now submit for examination for the award of PhD, is entirely my own work and has not been taken from the work of others save and to the extent that such work has been cited and acknowledged within the text of my work. This thesis was prepared according to the regulations for postgraduate study by research of the Dublin Institute of Technology and has not been submitted in whole or part for an award in any other Institute or University. The work reported on in this thesis conforms to the principles and requirements of the Institutes guidelines for ethics in research. The Dublin Institute of Technology has permission to keep, lend or to copy this thesis in whole or part, on condition that any such use of the material of the thesis be duly acknowledged. Signature___________________________________ Date______________ Helen Lynch November 2011 iii Acknowledgements This thesis has only been possible due to the unending support from my husband Albert, children Sarah and Jack, and family members who have never failed over the past four years to give me encouragement in the extremes of research that typically include breathtaking highs and despairing lows. Many others have enabled me in my study and to those I extend my heartfelt thanks for their support and encouragement: To my supervisor Dr. Noirin Hayes for her constant positive energy, enthusiasm and belief in my work and to the CECDE and the Dublin Institute of Technology who funded the scholarship programme. To my PhD colleagues who helped share the journey of discovery of learning and truly illuminated for me what it means to have a community of practice To my other friends who have also been on their own journeys of exploration in occupational therapy and occupational science, and continue to impress me with their work ethic and commitment To the friends then who have witnessed and never given up on me when I have not been present for them. But most of all, to the special children and their families whom I had the great fortune to meet during this work. I am most grateful for their kindness in welcoming me into their lives and their generosity of spirit which I hope I can repay if not to them to others, in the spirit of ‘paying it forward’… iv Table of Contents: ABSTRACT ................................................................................................................................................ II DECLARATION: ......................................................................................................................................... III ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS ............................................................................................................................ IV TABLE OF CONTENTS: .............................................................................................................................. 1 LIST OF TABLES ....................................................................................................................................... 5 LIST OF FIGURES AND DIAGRAMS ............................................................................................................ 6 CHAPTER ONE: INTRODUCING THE STUDY ............................................................................. 8 INTRODUCING THE RESEARCH TOPIC: THE IMPORTANCE OF THE STUDY: .................................... 9 INITIAL BROAD RESEARCH AIMS AND QUESTIONS ................................................................. 12 The physical environment: places, spaces and objects ..................................................................... 14 Summary ........................................................................................................................................... 20 INTRODUCING THE RESEARCH CONTEXT: ................................................................................. 21 INTRODUCING THE RESEARCH PLAN: LAYOUT OF THE THESIS ........................................... 25 Summary ........................................................................................................................................... 26 CHAPTER TWO: THEORETICAL FRAMEWORKS: .................................................................. 28 Context: towards an ecological approach ........................................................................................ 28 Transactionalism: ............................................................................................................................. 30 Bioecological approach: .................................................................................................................. 33 An affordance approach to understanding the physical environment: ............................................. 37 Towards an occupational development approach ............................................................................ 40 Summary ........................................................................................................................................... 47 CHAPTER THREE: SETTING THE SCENE FOR EXPLORING THE PHYSICAL ENVIRONMENT .............................................................................................................................. 49 INTRODUCTION: ................................................................................................................................ 49 PHYSICAL ENVIRONMENT AT A NATIONAL LEVEL- CULTURE AND SOCIETY .................. 51 Children in Ireland: policy development and national population-based research ......................... 53 Early Childhood frameworks ............................................................................................................ 55 Children in Ireland: play and the physical environment: ................................................................. 57 Summary ........................................................................................................................................... 58 PHYSICAL ENVIRONMENT AT THE COMMUNITY LEVEL ........................................................ 59 Places and Spaces in community environments: .............................................................................. 60 Playgrounds in neighbourhoods: the purpose-built environment.
Recommended publications
  • Developmental Channels: First, It Is Important to Understand That
    Developmental Channels: First, it is important to understand that children have to grow and develop in many different areas in order to become healthy, happy, productive members of adult society. There are four main areas or channels in which children grow: physical, psychological and cognitive, social and emotional, and sexuality and gender identity. First, the physical channel is most obvious. Children's bodies grow in height and weight over the years and change appearance during puberty. Children also develop certain physical abilities during their progression towards adulthood, including crawling, walking, running and (possibly) writing or shooting a basketball. Secondly, children also develop psychologically and cognitively as their brains absorb more information and they learn how to use that information. Literally, children have to learn how to think on purpose and to process or organize all the information that comes to them from the environment. They must learn how to solve problems, to talk, and to complete mental tasks such as remembering telephone numbers or using computers. Thirdly, children grow socially and emotionally. They learn how to interact, play, work, and live with other people such as family, friends, teachers, and employers. They learn how to understand both their own feelings and others' emotions. They also learn ways of dealing with strong emotions. In order to function well as independent adults, children must develop a sense of self-esteem as they go through the long process of figuring out what shape their identity, or who they are, will take. They develop a sense of morality as they learn the difference between right and wrong.
    [Show full text]
  • Core Child Welfare Pre-Service Curriculum | Module 4-TG 1
    January 2015 Module 4: Trauma and the Child Core Child Welfare Pre-Service Curriculum | Module 4-TG 1 January 2015 Module 4: Trauma and the Child Display Slide 4.0.1 Time: x hours Module Purpose: This module explains the short and long-term impacts of traumatic events on the child. It also acknowledges the multi-generational nature of trauma and discusses how parents who were traumatized as children continue to experience the effects throughout their adult lives. Display Slide 4.0.2 (PG 2) Agenda: Unit 4.1: Trauma and its impact on the Child Unit 4.2: Approaching Children and Families in a Trauma-Informed Manner Unit 4.3: Referring and Advocating for the Child and Family in a Trauma- Informed Manner Review the agenda with the participants. Core Child Welfare Pre-Service Curriculum | Module 4-TG 2 Materials: • Trainer’s Guide (TG) • Participant’s Guide (PG) (participants should bring their own) • PowerPoint slide deck • Flip chart paper • Highlighters/Markers (at least three per participant) Activities: • Activity: What Did You See? - 17 • Activity: Henry – 28 • Activity: Rewriting Henry’s Experience with Us – 30 • Activity: Using a Trauma-Informed Approach in Child Welfare Practice: Creating Your Rules of Thumb – 32 • Activity: How should I acknowledge Culture or Historical Trauma as a part of the Family Picture? - 50 Core Child Welfare Pre-Service Curriculum | Module 4-TG 3 Unit 4.1: Trauma and Its Impact on the Child Display Slide 4.1.1 Time: Unit Overview: This unit portrays for participants the short- and long-term impacts of traumatic events on the child, highlighting the importance of careful, thoughtful professional communication and intervention.
    [Show full text]
  • A Clinical Handbook on Child Development Paediatrics Pdf, Epub, Ebook
    A CLINICAL HANDBOOK ON CHILD DEVELOPMENT PAEDIATRICS PDF, EPUB, EBOOK Sandra Johnson | 320 pages | 01 Feb 2013 | Elsevier Australia | 9780729540896 | English | Marrickville, NSW, Australia A Clinical Handbook on Child Development Paediatrics PDF Book Parenting styles and overweight status in first grade. There is a phenomenal growth or exponential increase of child development from the age of 4 to 15 years old especially during the age of 4 to 7 years old based on the Yamana chart [45]. Usually present in the neonate and may persist up to 6 months. Help Learn to edit Community portal Recent changes Upload file. Thought and Language. In this case the parent might not suspect the reduced hearing because the child will be able to hear some but not all sounds. Advances in white matter imaging: a review of in vivo magnetic resonance methodologies and their applicability to the study of development and aging. Eventually, they are able to add pronouns to words and combine them to form short sentences. Doctoral thesis. Hyperbilirubinemia has recently been associated with the clinical picture of auditory neuropathy spectrum disorder ANSD. The method, which focuses on the stimulation provided by the carer, can be subject to critique. In Johnson M ed. For example, in Erikson's discussion of stages of personality, this theorist suggests that a lifetime is spent in reworking issues that were originally characteristic of a childhood stage. This includes support for siblings, provid- ing the necessary information to parents and advocacy with other institutions, such as the educational and social support systems. Alternatives to this book are: Paediatrics.
    [Show full text]
  • Child Psychology: Parent Handbook
    DOCUMENT RESUME ED 114 739 88 CG 010 199 TITLE Child Psychology: Parent Handbook. Mehlville School District ESEA Title III, PACE Program. INSTITUTION Mehlville R-9 School District, St. Louis, Mo. SPONS AGENCY Bureau of School Systems (DHEW/OE) ,Washington, D.C. NOTE 19p.; For related documents, see CG 010 197-202 EDRS PRICE MF-$0.76 HC-$1.58 Plus Postage DESCRIPTORS *Child Development; *Child Psychology; *Developmental Psychology; Family Counseling; Manuals; *Parent Education; *Parent Workshops IDENTIFIERS Elementary Second4ry Education Act Title III; ESEA Title III; PACE; *Projects to Advance Creativity in Education ABSTRACT This document is one of a series published by the Mehlville School District (St. Louis, Mo.) and used in their workshops for parents regarding family communications. It includes an explanation of Maslow's Hierarchy of Needs, a definition of characteristics of the family constellation, an examination of child development stages, a brief summary of Piaget's theory of cognitive development, and an enumeration of the stages of puberty. A bibliography is also included. (HMV) *********************************************************************** Documents acquired by ERIC include many informal unpublished * materials not available from other sources. ERIC makes every effort * * to obtain the best copy available. Nevertheless, items of marginal * * reproducibility are often encountered and this affects the quality * * of the microfiche and hardcopy reproductions ERIC makes available * via the ERIC Document Reproduction Service (EDRS). EDRS is not * responsible for the quality of the original document. Reproductions * * supplied by EDRS are the best that can be made from the original. *********************************************************************** CP 010 i9 D11473 9 Nagle.l-ccoTrion _ -_ - - --- Nen LY I LLE--- 00 1_ TD 1.51--R Table of Contents A.
    [Show full text]
  • Core Child Welfare Pre-Service Curriculum | Participant Guide Module 1
    January 2015 Module 4: Trauma and the Child Core Child Welfare Pre-Service Curriculum | Module 4-PG 1 Table of Contents Unit 4.1: Trauma and its impact on the Child What is Trauma? Types of Childhood Trauma What is Child Traumatic Stress (CTS)? Child Development Stages Matrix Impact of Trauma on the Child’s Brain The Impact of Trauma on Very Young Children Compact Trauma and How it Impacts Children Impact of Traumatic Stress on Visible Behavior Trauma-Related Behavior in Children of Various Ages Adverse Childhood Experiences (ACE) Study Long Term Impact of Trauma Culture and Trauma Historical Trauma Unit 4.2: Approaching Children and Families in a Trauma-Informed Manner Henry’s Story Worksheet: Rewriting Henry’s Experience with Us Using a Trauma-Informed Approach in Child Welfare Practice My Rules of Thumb – How I will behave in a Trauma-Informed Manner Parents Must Truly Address the Roots of Their Trauma How People Exposed to Trauma React to Authority Unit 4.3: Referring and Advocating for the Child and Family in a Trauma- Informed Manner Screening, Assessments and Evaluation Other Referrals and Advocacy Pharmacology and the Child or Adult What Medication Does NOT Help Evidence-Based Trauma-Informed Treatment Practices Ways to Better Ensure a Trauma-Informed Approach When Culture and Historical Trauma are Considerations Cultural Scenarios Cultural Scenarios Worksheet Core Child Welfare Pre-Service Curriculum | Module 4-PG 2 Unit 4.1: Trauma and its Impact on the Child What is Trauma? • Definition of Trauma: Trauma is an emotional response to an event. The emotional response is intense, distressing and/or painful, and can overwhelm your ability to cope.
    [Show full text]
  • THE VIOLET OAKLANDER MODEL of PSYCHOTHERAPY the Lived
    Running Head: THE VIOLET OAKLANDER MODEL OF PSYCHOTHERAPY The Lived Experience of Facilitating the Violet Oaklander Model of Psychotherapy for Children and Adolescents A dissertation submitted by Blake Brisbois, M.A. To Antioch University Santa Barbara in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Psychology in Clinical Psychology 2016 ____________________________________ RONALD PILATO, PSY.D. Chair ____________________________________ LEE WEISER, PH.D. Second Faculty ____________________________________ VIOLET OAKLANDER, PH.D. External Expert THE VIOLET OAKLANDER MODEL OF PSYCHOTHERAPY ii Copyright © 2016 By Blake Brisbois ii THE VIOLET OAKLANDER MODEL OF PSYCHOTHERAPY ii Abstract The purpose of this phenomenological study was to describe the experience of facilitating the Oaklander Model of Gestalt Play Therapy when treating children or adolescents in psychotherapy. Interviews were conducted with clinicians who have received training and use the Oaklander method in their practice of psychotherapy. Transcriptions of the interviews were coded and analyzed, revealing a consistent experience along various themes. Participants reported that this Gestalt method allows a non-linear method of helping clients to unfold according to the needs and challenges of each session. Participants also reported that the end goal of the Oaklander Gestalt model helped young clients express themselves through the use of customized strategies that included consideration of the experiences and physical capabilities of children. The model’s focus on the strength of the clinician-client, clinician-parent, and parent-client relationship facilitated self-awareness and sense of self through effective mind-body interventions. Further exploration by broadening the range, size, and type of sample studied is recommended. The electronic version of the dissertation is accessible at the Ohiolink ETD center http://www.ohiolink.edu/etd.
    [Show full text]
  • Child Development Theories File
    CHILD DEVELOPMENT THEORIES Section Outline 1.1. Introduction 1.2. Section objectives 1.3. Child development/Definition of key child development terms 1.3.1. Child developmental theories concept 1.3.2. Growth 1.3.3. Child development 1.3.4. Key questions in Child Development 1.3.5. Child development core issues 1.3.6. Laws of development 1.3.7. Child developmental milestones/landmarks 1.3.8. Motivational and Humanistic theories 1.3.9. Attachment theory 1.3.10. Introduction 1.3.11. Class assignments 1.4. Specific child Developmental theories 1.4.1. Introduction 1.4.2. Class assignments 1.4.2.1. Motivational and Humanistic theories 1.4.2.2. Attachment theory 1.4.2.3. Maturation and Language theories 1.4.2.4. Psychodynamic theories 1.4.2.5. Behaviorist theories 1.4.2.6. Social learning theory 1.4.2.7. Cognitivist theories 1.4.2.8. Constructivist, social, and situational theories 1.5. Summary 1.6. References 1.7. Self-test questions 1.1 Introduction I am delighted to welcome you to this session on child development theories. From conception to adolescence, life is a journey of change. Though we begin the journey as a single cell full of potential, along the way, we undergo dramatic changes in our physical attributes, intellectual capacities, personal characteristics, social habits and skills. In order to understand children and adolescents well, some background knowledge of how children grow and change from birth through adolescence, is essential. Theory is the first part of the continuum for understanding the determinants of behaviors, testing strategies and disseminating effective interventions.
    [Show full text]
  • Developmental Psychology
    Developmental psychology Psychology History · Subfields Basic science Abnormal · Biological Cognitive · Comparative Cultural · Developmental Evolutionary · Experimental Mathematical · Personality Positive · Social Applied science Clinical · Consumer Educational · Health Industrial and organizational Law · Military Occupational health · Political Religion · School · Sport Lists Disciplines · Organizations Outline · Psychologists Psychotherapies · Publications Research methods · Theories Timeline · Topics Portal v · d · e Developmental psychology, also known as human development, is the scientific study of systematic psychological changes that occur in human beings over the course of their life span. Originally concerned with infants and children, the field has expanded to include adolescence, adult development, aging, and the entire life span. This field examines change across a broad range of topics including motor skills and other psycho-physiological processes; cognitive development involving areas such as problem solving, moral understanding, and conceptual understanding; language acquisition; social, personality, and emotional development; and self-concept and identity formation. Developmental psychology includes issues such as the extent to which development occurs through the gradual accumulation of knowledge versus stage-like development, or the extent to which children are born with innate mental structures versus learning through experience. Many researchers are interested in the interaction between personal characteristics, the
    [Show full text]
  • Child Development Stages
    Handout – Child Development The department of Education Publication " New Learning from Serious Case Reviews, July 2012" emphasises the need for all practitioners working with children to understand and have knowledge of normal child development. It highlights that this is an essential component of child protection practice. The publication pays particular attention to bruises and whether they have occurred as a result of activities that would be within a child's normal development or whether they are non accidental and therefore an understanding of gross and fine motor development at which milestones is required. It recognises that children with disabilities will be outside of the normal range of development and practitioners need to be alert to this and to see the child and not just the disability. This handout details the range of normal child development under the headings of:- Child Development Stages Physical Development - Gross and Fine Motor Development Language and speech Development Social and Emotional Development Cognitive Development For each developmental stage it details the age of the child and this is in line with "developmental milestones":- First six weeks 1½ to 3 months 3 to 6 months 6 to 9 months 9 to 12 months 1 to 2 years 2 to 3 years 3 to 5 years 5 to 7 years As per procedures, when observing any mark or injury you should always ask the child how it happened, any mark or injury that is a cause for concern should immediately be reported to the DSL/backup DSL. Any concerns about children who are showing delay in any of the key areas of child development should also be discussed with the DSL/backup DSL 1 Child Development Stages: Birth to 6 Years Birth - 12 Months During this period, young children's physical development is very rapid and they gain increasing control of their muscles.
    [Show full text]
  • Core Child Welfare Pre-Service Curriculum | Module 3-TG 1
    January 2015 Module 3: Child Development Core Child Welfare Pre-Service Curriculum | Module 3-TG 1 January 2015 Module 3: Child Development Display Slide 3.0.1 Time: 6 hours Module Purpose: In this module, participants will learn about child maturation; the child’s developmental stages; the child’s need for protection, nurturing and well-being. Display Slide 3.0.2 Agenda: Unit 3.1: How Children Develop (6 hours, 30 minutes) Unit 3.2: Protection, Nurturing and Well-Being (4 hours) Review the agenda with the participants. Materials: • Trainer’s Guide (TG) • Participant’s Guide (PG) (participants should bring their own) • PowerPoint slide deck Core Child Welfare Pre-Service Curriculum | Module 3-TG 2 • Flip chart paper • Highlighters/Markers (at least three per participant) • Videos: o Still Face (YouTube) - 49 Activities: Unit 3.1: 0-36 months - 38 Unit 3.1: 3-6 Year Olds – 46 Unit 3.1: 6-11 Year Olds – 52 Unit 3.1: 13-18 Year Olds – 57 Core Child Welfare Pre-Service Curriculum | Module 3-TG 3 Unit 3.1: How Children Develop Display Slide 3.1.1 Time: x hours, x minutes Unit Overview: The purpose of this unit is to provide participants with a strong understanding of the stages of child development and to provide participants with the ability to evaluate children based on the developmental stages. It also introduces the child functioning domain, how to assess a child’s functioning, and how to write adequate content about a child’s functioning. Display Slide 3.1.2 Learning Objectives: 1. Define the term ‘child,’ and explain the child’s role in the family.
    [Show full text]
  • Strengthening Families: Knowledge of Parenting and Child Development1 David C
    FCS2306 Strengthening Families: Knowledge of Parenting and Child Development1 David C. Diehl, Jessica N. Wente, and Larry F. Forthun2 Parenting is a tremendous responsibility full of many extending all the way to adulthood. Parents should be moments of joy. But sometimes the rapid rate of a young knowledgeable of child development stages, constructive child’s growth and development can leave parents feeling discipline, positive communication, and a whole array of a little overwhelmed. This Strengthening Families Series other parenting issues. Parenting is a lifelong exercise in highlights six factors that promote positive parenting and learning that requires the ability to find answers to your protect against stressors and frustrations that can lead to pressing questions. Rather than trying to answer all of the harsh parenting: Parental Resilience, Social Connections, questions parents might have, this fact sheet will focus on Knowledge of Parenting and Child Development, the ways in which parents can explore their own parenting Concrete Support, Social and Emotional Competence, and and find information and solutions that work for them. Nurturing and Attachment. Each of these protective factors offers families and children some defense against distress. However, together they combine to create a solid founda- tion of knowledge, parenting skills, and support that can help families thrive during everyday circumstances as well as persevere during times of stress or crisis (1). Overview Children grow and learn at different paces, often reaching milestones before parents realize it. Parents who under- stand why their children behave the way they do are more capable of directing their children to the desired behavior, and they can apply positive parenting methods and disci- pline that are developmentally appropriate and effective.
    [Show full text]
  • Exemplary Practices in Adolescent Development
    EXEMPLARY PRACTICES IN ADOLESCENT DEVELOPMENT Prepared by Amy Birtwhistle, Sierra Health Foundation Bina Lefkovitz, Consultant Dorothy Meehan, Sierra Health Foundation Heather Needham, Consultant Andy Paul, Consultant © Sierra Health Foundation, July 2004 2 EXEMPLARY PRACTICES IN ADOLESCENT DEVELOPMENT BACKGROUND AND INTRODUCTION In 2003, Sierra Health Foundation’s Board of Directors selected school-aged youth as the target for its next focused grantmaking effort. As part of the program research and development phase, staff and consultants examined evidenced-based practices that appear promising in positively affecting adolescent health and development for young people 10 – 15 years of age. Attachment A to the following report depicts the cognitive, physical, and social and emotional development of the targeted age group. This is provided as reference. The rest of the report is a summary of studies collected and examined as part of this research effort and is organized as follows: • Exemplary Practices of Issue-Focused Efforts: Common themes from the research on six common health-related issues of youth are presented. Detailed descriptions of the research papers examined are included in Attachments B through G at the end of the report. • Exemplary Practices of Strengths-Based Efforts: Three approaches were examined: – Youth Asset Development; – Resiliency; and – School and Community Based Peer Programs. A summary of these approaches and findings from the research are presented. EXEMPLARY PRACTICES OF ISSUE- OR RISK BEHAVIOR-FOCUSED EFFORTS An important step in developing a grant program is the examination of approaches that have proven to cause positive change in the desired program outcomes. Because most funding is categorical in nature, likewise are evaluation studies.
    [Show full text]