Chondrites and Chondrules
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
THIN SECTION OF CHONDRITE viewed through the microscope moved from their matrix in a chondrite. The sections were photo. (top) is interspersed with chondrules (colored bodies). The photo· graphed through polarizing filters, which here give the chondrules micrograph at bottom shows round chondrules that have been reo their color. Chondrules range from size of a pinhead to that of a pea. © 1963 SCIENTIFIC AMERICAN, INC Chondrites and Chondrules The first are stony m�eteorites; the second, the small spherical bodies they contain. There is evidence that the chondrules date back to the opening stages in the evolution of the solar system by John A. Wood n 1802 an English chemist named bodies occurring in chondrites soon came similar to those of the solar atmosphere. Edward C. Howard cautiously titled to be called chondrules. In 1930 the German spectroscopists I a paper he had written "Observa From the beginning investigators Ida and Walter Noddack pointed out tions on certain stony and metallic Sub have tended to believe that chondrites additional evidence. They found that stances, which at different Times are said are pieces of planetary matter in a very chondrites contain a more generous as to have fallen on the Earth." Howard primitive state. If this matter is not still sortment of trace elements in measur seems to have been the first person to in exactly the form it took when the able amounts than any type of earth examine carefully the internal structure planets first coalesced, it is not many rock does. In particular chondrites con of stony meteorites, and in all four speci evolutionary steps removed from that tain, mingled together, lithophile, chal mens he studied (stones from England, form. Recent studies of chondrites and cophile and siderophile elements-ele Italy, Bohemia and India) he found chondrules provide reinforcement for ments that respectively tend to associate "abundant small bodies, some perfectly this concept and tell a story about the with silicate and oxide material, sulfide globular, others rather elongated or early history of the solar system. material and metallic iron material. If elliptical." Their size ranged from that the chondrites had been melted in the of a pinhead to that of a small pea, and The Antiquity of Chondrites parent meteorite planet, or if any kind their color from gray to brownish. of extensive material transfer had oc At that time the idea that meteorites At first the belief that chondrites are curred, the lithophile, chalcophile and were of extraterrestrial origin enjoyed primitive planetary matter stemmed siderophile elements would have tended roughly the same reputation flying largely from the mystique that is natu to segregate themselves as they have in saucers do today. In 1803, however, the rally excited by material from inter the earth. French village of L'Aigle was pelted by planetary space. In 1929, however, the Finally, isotopic-dating techniques de a shower of falling stones so dense first quantitative evidence appeared. At veloped during the past decade have (more than 2,000 were recovered) that that time the astrophysicist Henry Nor shown that although chondrites are very the Academie des Sciences was moved ris Russell, working at the Mount Wilson old-older than any earth rock studied, to appoint a commission, headed by the Observatory, used solar spectrograms to their ages clustering around 4.6 billion eminent physicist Jean Baptiste Biot, to make the first crude estimate of the rela years-they have been cold, inert bodies investigate the event. Biot's detailed re tive abundances of the elements in the most of this time. Some chondrites have port eliminated the possibility that the sun's atmosphere. He found that the recently been found to contain excessive stones were a hoax or a terrestrial abundance pattern for metallic elements amounts of the rare isotope xenon 129 phenomenon. Soon the idea that meteor matched the abundances in chondrites [see "The Age of the Elements in the So ites are fragments of another planet or fairly well. Later and more precise work IaI' System," by John H. Reynolds; SCI planets, probably broken up by mutual on the composition of the solar atmos ENTIFIC AMERICAN, November, 1960]. collisions, won wide acceptance. phere showed the match to be quite Xenon 129 is produced by the decay of After Biot's report museums began to striking [see illustration on page 75]. Ap iodine 129, an isotope with a half life collect meteorites enthusiastically. By parently both sun and chondrites were that is brief by cosmic standards: 16.4 1864 almost 200 meteorites had been made from the same parent material, million years. Those chondrites with studied, and it was evident that the great and the metal content of both has re excess xenon 129 must have cooled to a ma jority of meteorite falls were stones mained unchanged since. If melting low temperature while they still con containing Howard's "small bodies." In or some other form of material trans tained some iodine 129, and they must that year a classification of meteorites fer had occurred in the chondrites, it have remained cold ever since, because was set up by Gustav Rose, a German would have segregated the elements and heat would have driven xenon 129 out mineralogist; he named this majority introduced large-scale heterogeneities of the meteorite as fast as it was created class of meteorites "chondrites" after in metal abundances from one chon by iodine-129 decay. We conclude that their peculiar internal structure. (Choll drite to another. We know such frac the time interval between the creation dl'oS was the ancient Greek word for tionation occurs in the earth. No type of the iodine 129 and final cooling of "grain of seed.") The small, rounded of earth rock has metal abundances some chondrites was short-less than 65 © 1963 SCIENTIFIC AMERICAN, INC BIRTHPLACE OF STARS is probably in dense clouds of gas and at bottom the nebula NGC 6611 in Scutum Sobieski. Light of neb· dust sucb as these nebulae, which contain stars regarded as young. ulae is emitted by atoms excited by radiation of nearby stars. Photo· At top is the Horsehead Nebula, part of the Great Nebula in Orion, graphs were made with 200·inch telescope on Palomar Mountain. 66 © 1963 SCIENTIFIC AMERICAN, INC ' 100 million years. Therefore high-tem eralogy. All gradations between these " ... , .. perature evolutionary events could have conditions were observed among the . .. '. : . - . : : . occurred only during the first 2 per cent chondrites. We know that when rocks ' ,. ,' . ' . , " .. o. :. : . or less of the lifetime of these chondrites. or metals are held for months or years . Chondrites fit rather well into the idea at high temperatures (but not melted), ' . ." astronomers currently have of the nature the textures they had at first are often . ' of primitive planetary matter. For many replaced by systems of new, coarser . ,., years it was supposed that each planet crystals. This recrystallization, or meta " . condensed directly from a discrete mass morphism, to use a geological term, oc '-: .' . of hot gas that had been torn from the curs entirely in the solid state. Petrog sun (the Jeans- Jeffreys hypothesis) . This raphers concluded that all chondrites .' .. ... concept was discredited, however, by a once had clear-cut chondrules but that . ' . .. theoretical study showing that hot gas many, like the stone from Milena shown . : would not remain in discrete masses long in the top illustration on the next page, enough to allow condensation. The view have been recrystallized by heat. Pre now held by most astronomers is that sumably they were heated in the interior any condensation that occurred yielded of their parent planet or planets. a large number of small granules, or The second inference concerns the "planetesimals," and that later these par chondrules themselves. Some were found ticles were brought together to form to contain glass, evidence that they had the planets. According to this picture been melted and then rapidly chilled. ' . ' planetary matter was at first a conglom Glassy chondrules occur only in relative , ' . , . eration of planetesimals. Can it be that ly unrecrystallized chondrites, so that the . chondrules were the planetesimals? melting cannot be associated with the Studies of the intrinsic properties of metamorphic heating just described. chondrules and chondrites have given The presence of glass, the anhydrous or us part of the information needed to an high-temperature character of chondrule swer this question. minerals, the igneous texture of some chondrules and their spheroidal shapes Chondrites under the Microscope all these distinctive features of the chon drules pointed to the conclusion that Much of this information has come they had once been dispersed droplets from the study of meteorites with micro of hot molten silicate: a "fiery rain," in scopes, a study begun by Rose and his the words of the 19th-century English contemporaries. The internal micro microscopist Henry Clifton Sorby. Some structure and mineralogy of a rock can or all of the droplets had cooled rapidly -best be disclosed by making a thin sec on a time scale of minutes or even sec tion of it. A slice of the rock is cemented onds. to a glass slide and carefully ground . ',' down to the thinness of a sheet of paper. The Formation of Chondrules Silicate minerals ground this thin are . quite transparent, so that a fragment Many investigators have speculated = prepared in this way can be viewed on the origin of these hot droplets. Most through a microscope. Thin-section have concluded that the droplets were studies established that the chondrules created on or in parent meteorite planets are unlike any structures occurring in and that truly primitive planetary matter terrestrial rocks but that they are com did not contain chondrules.