DECEMBER, 2011 First Church Congregational Fairfield
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
THE DIAPASON DECEMBER, 2011 First Church Congregational Fairfi eld, Connecticut Cover feature on pages 26–28 Dec 2011 Cover.indd 1 11/14/11 10:39:53 AM Dec 2011 pp. 2-18.indd 2 11/14/11 10:40:50 AM THE DIAPASON Letters to the Editor A Scranton Gillette Publication One Hundred Second Year: No. 12, Whole No. 1225 DECEMBER, 2011 Restoration, Rebuilding, St. Thomas Fifth Avenue Established in 1909 ISSN 0012-2378 Reconstruction, Replication Having read, with interest the corre- An International Monthly Devoted to the Organ, Some thoughts on “R” words, their spondence on the subject of a new organ the Harpsichord, Carillon, and Church Music use and misuse. I truly think that Res- for St. Thomas’s, one would like to com- toration is one of the most misused ment. The instrument that was left by words in our dictionary, and it is all Harrison, and has since been meddled too frequently used in place of more with repeatedly, requires restoration to CONTENTS Editor & Publisher JEROME BUTERA [email protected] accurate words when it comes to or- the Harrison days. This is probably the 847/391-1045 gans. Restoration simply means taking acme of American organbuilding. FEATURES something (in our case, an organ—but Whatever other instruments may be First Presbyterian Church, Marietta, Georgia Associate Editor JOYCE ROBINSON it could just as well be a house, a car, required by the current “titular”, if need Chancel Choir Holy Land Mission Tour [email protected] by Calvert Johnson 19 or a piece of furniture) that may be in be, can be added, above, behind, around, 847/391-1044 bad shape but still essentially intact or within. St. Thomas is the parish I use An Organ Adventure Contributing Editors LARRY PALMER and original, and putting it back into when in New York, visiting with friends. in South Korea Harpsichord good functional condition without al- The thought of losing (what’s left of) by Jay Zoller 20 tering it beyond necessary repairs, the Harrison instrument is painful. The JAMES MCCRAY The University of Michigan which might include the replication of thought of a restoration is joy! Choral Music 51st Conference on Organ Music a few minor missing or badly damaged A. Orin Rosengren, M.D. by Marijim Thoene & Alan Knight 22 parts, but no actual changes. It does, Westmount, Quebec, Canada BRIAN SWAGER Carillon of course, imply that the object in NEWS & DEPARTMENTS question has not suffered any previous Will Carter (Letters: September, Oc- Editor’s Notebook 3 JOHN BISHOP radical alterations, additions, subtrac- tober 2011) rightly laments the loss of Letters to the Editor 3 In the wind . tions, improvements or whatever that G. Donald Harrison’s fi nal statement— Here & There 4, 6, 8, 10, 11 will distance it from its original state the 1956 Aeolian-Skinner rebuild at St. GAVIN BLACK and concept. Thomas New York. I too wish Mr. Harri- Appointments 8 On Teaching Nunc Dimittis 10 There are other “R” words that can son’s version of the instrument had come and should be used to more accurately down to us unchanged. Those who knew On Teaching by Gavin Black 11 Reviewers John M. Bullard describe various approaches to an ob- it personally (conversations with Fred In the wind . by John Bishop 13 John L. Speller Gale Kramer ject, particularly an organ. The com- Swann and Ed Wallace come to mind) REVIEWS Robert August monest is Rebuilding, which indeed im- recall being in the presence of some- plies changes, enlargement, and other thing extraordinary. Music for Voices and Organ 15 John Collins Leon Nelson alterations, both tonally and mechani- Several of Mr. Carter’s assertions, Book Reviews 16 cally. Some parts of the original will however, don’t have legs. First, surely New Recordings 16 remain after a rebuild, and if advisable, William Self was responsible for key ele- New Organ Music 17 added and altered parts can be later re- ments of the St. Thomas scheme, much THE DIAPASON (ISSN 0012-2378) is published monthly New Handbell Music 18 by Scranton Gillette Communications, Inc., 3030 W. Salt moved and some attempt made to put as one would credit Virgil Fox or Nor- Creek Lane, Suite 201, Arlington Heights, IL 60005-5025. an organ back in something resembling man Coke-Jephcott at Riverside Church NEW ORGANS 28 Phone 847/391-1045. Fax 847/390-0408. Telex: 206041 MSG RLY. E-mail: <[email protected]>. its original state, but this is Reconstruc- or the Cathedral of St. John the Divine. CALENDAR 29 Subscriptions: 1 yr. $35; 2 yr. $55; 3 yr. $70 (Unit- tion, not Restoration. Finally, there is Mr. Harrison’s penchant for orthodoxy ed States and U.S. Possessions). Foreign subscrip- Replication, which is simply the copy- was doubtless closer to Self’s, but several ORGAN RECITALS 32 tions: 1 yr. $45; 2 yr. $65; 3 yr. $85. Single copies $6 (U.S.A.); $8 (foreign). ing, as closely as possible, of another key design features are hard to imagine CLASSIFIED ADVERTISING 34 Back issues over one year old are available only from existing object. The splendid new organ Harrison himself proposing. The Organ Historical Society, Inc., P.O. Box 26811, Rich- in Rochester, mentioned in Mr. Carter’s Second, it is certainly provocative to mond, VA 23261, which can supply information on avail- Cover: Johannes Klais Orgelbau, Bonn, Ger- abilities and prices. letter (The Diapason, October 2011, compare the Craighead-Saunders organ many; First Church Congregational, Fair- Periodical postage paid at Rochelle, IL and additional page 3), is an excellent example of this. at Christ Church Rochester—a $2.8 mil- fi eld, Connecticut 26 mailing offices. POSTMASTER: Send address changes to THE DIAPASON, 3030 W. Salt Creek Lane, Suite 201, Ar- Since every inch of it is entirely new, lion recreation of a 28-stop 1776 Cas- lington Heights, IL 60005-5025. it can hardly be called a Restoration— parini organ in Vilnius, Lithuania—to the Routine items for publication must be received six although a hundred years from now it notion of recreating a 1956 rebuild of an www.TheDiapason.com weeks in advance of the month of issue. For advertising copy, the closing date is the 1st. Prospective contributors may be ready for Restoration, provided already much-altered organ from 1913, of articles should request a style sheet. Unsolicited re- it was not radically altered by Rebuild- itself now radically changed. Even I, ar- views cannot be accepted. This journal is indexed in the The Music Index, an- ing in the meantime. dent fan of Skinner and Aeolian-Skinner, Send subscriptions, inquiries, and ad- notated in Music Article Guide, and abstracted in RILM Among some of the veteran Boston couldn’t endorse such a plan. First of all, Abstracts. organ technicians, I have heard the ex- many 1950s Aeolian-Skinner rebuilds did dress changes to THE DIAPASON, Copyright ©2011. Printed in the U.S.A. 3030 W. Salt Creek Lane, Suite 201, pression, “Three rebuilds equals a fi re.” not equal the mechanical fi nish of their Arlington Heights, IL 60005. THE DIAPASON accepts no responsibility or liability This doesn’t mean that the thrice-rebuilt brand-new instruments. Factory compo- for the validity of information supplied by contributors, organ will disappear in a cloud of smoke, nents and pipework were still executed vendors, advertisers or advertising agencies. but rather that its original concept and at a high level, but when it came time character has, rebuild by rebuild, been to marry new and old on site, corners No portion of the contents of this issue may be reproduced in any form without the specifi c written permission irrevocably lost, usually both tonally were too often cut. Of this syndrome, of the Editor, except that libraries are authorized to make photocopies of the material contained herein for the purpose of course reserve reading at the rate of one copy for every fi fteen students. Such copies may be reused for and mechanically, and often visually as St. Thomas was an acute example. When other courses or for the same course offered subsequently. well. It may still be a good organ, but it the contract was signed in 1955, all in- is not the organ that its original builder volved were keen for the rebuilt organ to put the fi nishing touches on many years be unveiled at the AGO national conven- before. Unfortunately the organ in St. tion in June 1956. The postwar economy Thomas Church Fifth Avenue has been was booming, but Aeolian-Skinner’s fi - Editor’s Notebook through more than three rebuilds, some nances were hardly profi table, and the quite substantial. It still has a lot of orig- company was often behind. Since the inal pipes, but even some of these have end of World War II, clients had been In this issue Newsletters been revoiced. Other ranks of pipes waiting as long as three and a half years Among the offerings in this issue of We send two e-mail newsletters each have been added and/or substituted. between contract-signing and delivery; The Diapason is Calvert Johnson’s month: classifi ed ads on the second It doesn’t even have its original wind- for St. Thomas, Mr. Harrison was prom- report on the Holy Land Mission Tour Tuesday of the month, and general news chests, and only the console shell can be ising less than eighteen months. that the Chancel Choir of the First Pres- on the fourth Tuesday of the month. The called original. Philip Steinhaus did the A decade later, the former Aeolian- byterian Church of Marietta, Georgia newsletters are free to Diapason sub- honest and respectful thing by remov- Skinner voicer Gilbert Adams sweep- took last June.