DOCSLIB.ORG

Prosecutor V. Simba, Case No. ICTR-01-76-T, Judgment and Sentence

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Prosecutor V. Simba, Case No. ICTR-01-76-T, Judgment and Sentence International Criminal Tribunal for Rwanda Tribunal pénal international pour le Rwanda ORIGINAL: ENGLISH TRIAL CHAMBER I Before: Judge Erik Møse, presiding Judge Sergei Alekseevich Egorov Judge Dennis C. M. Byron Registrar: Adama Dieng Date: 13 December 2005 THE PROSECUTOR v. Aloys SIMBA Case No. ICTR-01-76-T JUDGEMENT AND SENTENCE Office of the Prosecutor: Richard Karegyesa Ignacio Tredici Didace Nyirinkwaya Counsel for the Defence Sadikou Ayo Alao Beth Lyons The Prosecution v. Aloys Simba, Case No. ICTR-2001-76-T TABLE OF CONTENTS CHAPTER I: INTRODUCTION........................................................................................1 1. The Tribunal and Its Jurisdiction..........................................................................1 2. Indictment ................................................................................................................1 3. Summary of Procedural History ............................................................................1 4. Overview of the Case...............................................................................................1 CHAPTER II: Factual Findings...........................................................................................3 1. Preliminary Matters ................................................................................................3 1.1 Introduction................................................................................................................3 1.2 Notice.........................................................................................................................3 1.3 Alleged Witness Intimidation..................................................................................10 2. Aloys Simba ............................................................................................................14 3. Incitement of Kibeho Parish Massacre, 9 April 1994.........................................16 3.1 Indictment ................................................................................................................16 3.2 Evidence...................................................................................................................16 3.3 Deliberations ............................................................................................................19 4. Massacre at Murambi Technical School, 21 April 1994 ....................................22 4.1 Indictment ................................................................................................................22 4.2 Evidence...................................................................................................................23 4.3 Deliberations ............................................................................................................27 5. Massacre at Cyanika Parish, 21 April 1994 ........................................................31 5.1 Indictment ................................................................................................................31 5.2 Evidence...................................................................................................................31 5.3 Deliberations ............................................................................................................33 6. Massacre at Kaduha Parish, 21 April 1994.........................................................35 6.1 Indictment ................................................................................................................35 6.2 Evidence...................................................................................................................36 6.3 Deliberations ............................................................................................................40 7. Massacre in Ruhashya Commune, 29 April 1994...............................................45 7.1 Indictment ................................................................................................................45 7.2 Evidence...................................................................................................................45 7.3 Deliberations ............................................................................................................49 Judgement and Sentence i 13 December 2005 The Prosecution v. Aloys Simba, Case No. ICTR-2001-76-T 8. Further Evidence of Common Criminal Purpose...............................................52 8.1 Distribution of Weapons, Rukondo Commune Office, March 1994 .......................52 8.1.1 Indictment ........................................................................................................52 8.1.2 Evidence...........................................................................................................52 8.1.3 Deliberations ....................................................................................................53 8.2 Solicitation of Funds for Weapons, Rukondo Commune, March 1994...................54 8.2.1 Indictment ........................................................................................................54 8.2.2 Evidence...........................................................................................................54 8.2.3 Deliberations ....................................................................................................56 8.3 Public Meeting, Nyamagabe Commune Office, 10 April 1994...............................57 8.3.1 Indictment ........................................................................................................57 8.3.2 Evidence...........................................................................................................57 8.3.3 Deliberations ....................................................................................................59 8.4 Incitement in Nzega Trading Centre, Nyamagabe Commune, 10 April 1994.........59 8.4.1 Indictment ........................................................................................................59 8.4.2 Evidence...........................................................................................................60 8.4.3 Deliberations ....................................................................................................60 8.5 Distribution of Weapons, Kinyamakara Commune Office, Mid-April 1994 ..........61 8.5.1 Indictment ........................................................................................................61 8.5.2 Evidence...........................................................................................................61 8.5.3 Deliberations ....................................................................................................62 8.6 Meeting at CIPEP, 26 April 1994 ............................................................................63 8.6.1 Indictment ........................................................................................................63 8.6.2 Evidence...........................................................................................................63 8.6.3 Deliberations ....................................................................................................65 8.7 Public Meeting, Ntyazo Commune, Butare Prefecture, 22 May 1994 ....................68 8.7.1 Indictment ........................................................................................................68 8.7.2 Evidence...........................................................................................................68 8.7.3 Deliberations ....................................................................................................70 9. Alibi.........................................................................................................................72 9.1 Introduction..............................................................................................................72 9.2 Kigali and Gitarama Town, 6 to 13 April ................................................................73 9.2.1 Evidence...........................................................................................................73 9.2.2 Deliberations ....................................................................................................80 Judgement and Sentence ii 13 December 2005 The Prosecution v. Aloys Simba, Case No. ICTR-2001-76-T 9.3 Gitarama and Gikongoro, 14 to 24 April .................................................................82 9.3.1 Evidence...........................................................................................................82 9.3.2 Deliberations ....................................................................................................87 CHAPTER III: LEGAL FINDINGS ...............................................................................90 1. Criminal Responsibility.........................................................................................90 1.1 Elements of Joint Criminal Enterprise.....................................................................90 1.2 Notice.......................................................................................................................91 1.3 Application...............................................................................................................93 2. Genocide .................................................................................................................96 3. Crimes against Humanity (Extermination) .........................................................98
Load more

Recommended publications
  • The International Response to Conflict and Genocide:Lessom from the Rwanda Experience
    The International Response to Conflict and Genocide: Lessons from the Rwanda Experience March 1996 Published by: Steering Committee of the Joint Evaluation of Emergency Assistance to Rwanda Editor: David Millwood Cover illustrations: Kiure F. Msangi Graphic design: Designgrafik, Copenhagen Prepress: Dansk Klich‚, Copenhagen Printing: Strandberg Grafisk, Odense ISBN: 87-7265-335-3 (Synthesis Report) ISBN: 87-7265-331-0 (1. Historical Perspective: Some Explanatory Factors) ISBN: 87-7265-332-9 (2. Early Warning and Conflict Management) ISBN: 87-7265-333-7 (3. Humanitarian Aid and Effects) ISBN: 87-7265-334-5 (4. Rebuilding Post-War Rwanda) This publication may be reproduced for free distribution and may be quoted provided the source - Joint Evaluation of Emergency Assistance to Rwanda - is mentioned. The report is printed on G-print Matt, a wood-free, medium-coated paper. G-print is manufactured without the use of chlorine and marked with the Nordic Swan, licence-no. 304 022. 2 The International Response to Conflict and Genocide: Lessons from the Rwanda Experience Study 2 Early Warning and Conflict Management by Howard Adelman York University Toronto, Canada Astri Suhrke Chr. Michelsen Institute Bergen, Norway with contributions by Bruce Jones London School of Economics, U.K. Joint Evaluation of Emergency Assistance to Rwanda 3 Contents Preface 5 Executive Summary 8 Acknowledgements 11 Introduction 12 Chapter 1: The Festering Refugee Problem 17 Chapter 2: Civil War, Civil Violence and International Response 20 (1 October 1990 - 4 August
    [Show full text]
  • The Western Media and the Portrayal of the Rwandan Genocide
    History in the Making Volume 3 Article 5 2010 The Western Media and the Portrayal of the Rwandan Genocide Cherice Joyann Estes CSUSB Follow this and additional works at: https://scholarworks.lib.csusb.edu/history-in-the-making Part of the African History Commons, and the Mass Communication Commons Recommended Citation Estes, Cherice Joyann (2010) "The Western Media and the Portrayal of the Rwandan Genocide," History in the Making: Vol. 3 , Article 5. Available at: https://scholarworks.lib.csusb.edu/history-in-the-making/vol3/iss1/5 This Article is brought to you for free and open access by the Arthur E. Nelson University Archives at CSUSB ScholarWorks. It has been accepted for inclusion in History in the Making by an authorized editor of CSUSB ScholarWorks. For more information, please contact [email protected]. Cherice Joyann Estes The Western Media and the Portrayal of the Rwandan Genocide BY CHERICE JOYANN ESTES ABSTRACT: On December 9, 1948, the United Nations established its Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of the Crime of Genocide. Genocides, however, have continued to occur, affecting millions of people around the globe. The 1994 genocide in Rwanda resulted in an estimated 800,000 deaths. Global leaders were well aware of the atrocities, but failed to intervene. At the same time, the Western media's reports on Rwanda tended to understate the magnitude of the crisis. This paper explores the Western media's failure to accurately interpret and describe the Rwandan Genocide. Recognizing the outside media’s role in mischaracterizations of the Rwanda situation is particularly useful when attempting to understand why western governments were ineffective in their response to the atrocity.
    [Show full text]
  • Assumpta -And-Benjamin 010Ed
    WP 010 | May 2018 WoP Ar king P E R Singing the Struggle: The Rwandan Patriotic Front’s ideology through its songs of liberation Assumpta Mugiraneza and Benjamin Chemouni About the authors Abstract Benjamin Chemouni is a LSE Fellow in the Department of This article studies the Rwandan Patriotic International Development at the London School of Eco- Front’s (RPF) ideology as articulated nomics. His research analyses post-conflict state building before the genocide. To do so, it identi- trajectory in the African Great Lakes’ Region, focusing fied, transcribed, translated and analysed especially on Burundi and Rwanda. He explores in partic- 20 songs of RPF members and supporters ular elite dynamics, rebel movements and their ideology, and state/society interface. He has published in World composed before or around 1994 to under- Development, the Journal of Eastern African Studies, and stand how, before reaching power, the Third World Thematics. RPF made sense of its environment and Assumpta Mugiraneza is the co-founder and director of the issues it faced, how it envisioned the the IRIBA Centre for Rwanda’s multimedia heritage. She proper order of society, and how such is an educationalist, a psychologist and a political scien- order was to be achieved. Analysis focus- tist. For 20 years, she has worked on the topics of extreme es on four main themes: national unity, the violence and genocide, focusing particularly on the role of RPF’s depiction of itself, the depiction of language and communication, for example comparing the its enemy, and its relation to the interna- Nazi and Hutu power discourses.
    [Show full text]
  • Why the U.S. Government Failed to Anticipate the Rwandan Genocide of 1994: Lessons for Early Warning and Prevention
    Genocide Studies and Prevention: An International Journal Volume 9 Issue 3 Article 6 2-2016 Why the U.S. Government Failed to Anticipate the Rwandan Genocide of 1994: Lessons for Early Warning and Prevention Matthew Levinger George Washington University Follow this and additional works at: https://scholarcommons.usf.edu/gsp Recommended Citation Levinger, Matthew (2016) "Why the U.S. Government Failed to Anticipate the Rwandan Genocide of 1994: Lessons for Early Warning and Prevention," Genocide Studies and Prevention: An International Journal: Vol. 9: Iss. 3: 33-58. DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.5038/1911-9933.9.3.1362 Available at: https://scholarcommons.usf.edu/gsp/vol9/iss3/6 This Article is brought to you for free and open access by the Open Access Journals at Scholar Commons. It has been accepted for inclusion in Genocide Studies and Prevention: An International Journal by an authorized editor of Scholar Commons. For more information, please contact [email protected]. Why the U.S. Government Failed to Anticipate the Rwandan Genocide of 1994: Lessons for Early Warning and Prevention Matthew Levinger George Washington University Washington, DC, USA Abstract: During the months leading up to the Rwandan genocide of 1994, cognitive biases obstructed the capacity of U.S. government analysts and policymakers to anticipate mass violence against the country’s Tutsi minority. Drawing on declassified U.S. government documents and on interviews with key current and former officials, this essay shows that most U.S. government reporting on Rwanda before April 1994 utilized a faulty cognitive frame that failed to differentiate between threats of civil war and genocide.
    [Show full text]
  • The Capture of Power and the Path to Hegemony
    Cambridge University Press 978-1-107-04355-8 - Political Governance in Post-Genocide Rwanda Filip Reyntjens Excerpt More information 1 The Capture of Power and the Path to Hegemony seeking hegemony When taking power, the RPF inherited a country it hardly knew. Being an “outsider” coming from abroad, it had a poor understanding of the social and political relations, and it was probably genuinely disappointed by the lukewarm way in which it was welcomed by most Rwandans. The years in exile and the guerrilla experience pushed it toward self-reliance and dis- trust toward anything outside its known environment, and therefore toward a strong degree of isolationism. Establishing control and only counting on those who can be trusted (i.e., the core of the movement) was a logical, even essential course of action, and this is what the RPF set out to do from day one. The war between the Forces armées rwandaises (FAR) and the Rwanda Patriotic Army (RPA), the military wing of the RPF, which had resumed on April 7, 1994, ended with the fall of Gisenyi (northwest) on July 18. The RPA controlled the country’s territory, with the temporary exception of the “safe humanitarian zone” created in the southwest by the French operation Turquoise. On the next day, a new government was inaugurated in Kigali. Although its composition appeared at first sight to obey the spirit if not the letter of the Arusha peace accord signed in August 1993, the departures were considerable, and they all aimed at establishing hegemony. According to Article 2 of the Declaration of the RPF Concerning the Putting into Place of the Institutions made on July 17, from being purely ceremonial, the presidency became executive and even dominant.
    [Show full text]
  • Annexe 51 : Les Assassinats Des Opposants Et Des Témoins Des Crimes Du FPR. Questions Sur Les Libertés Civiques Au Rwanda 1. S
    Annexe 51 : Les assassinats des opposants et des témoins des crimes du FPR. Questions sur les libertés civiques au Rwanda 1. Seth Sendashonga ou le prix du reniement du serment au FPR………………………..4 1.1 André Guichaoua, Le problème de la réinstallation et du rapatriement des réfugiés rwandais dans le contexte politique rwandais en mars-avril 1995, Banque mondiale, Washington, avril 1995………………………………………………………………………..7 1.2 To the Vice President and Minister of Defence, Enemy Internal Activity, Monthly Report, document remis par Seth Sendashonga en mars 1995………………………………………..15 1.3 La lettre de démission de Seth Sendashonga, ministre de l’Intérieur et du Développement communal, du 28 août 1995…………………………………………………………………..17 1.4 André Guichaoua, Seth Sendashonga, un fidèle militant du FPR, inédit, août 2005…….19 1.5. L’assassinat de Seth Sendashonga……………………………………………………….34 2. La mort de Monseigneur André Sibomana, un assassinat par refus de soins.…….…40 2.1. Le « testament politique » d’André Sibomana rédigé le 4 mars 1998 (copie de l’original) ……………………………………………………………………………………..41 2.2. Transcription du testament de Mgr André Sibomana…………………………….…….. 45 2.3. André Guichaoua, Préface, in Hervé Deguine, Enquête sur la mort d’André Sibomana, Paris, Reporters sans frontière, 1998, p. 5-10……………………………….………………..46 2.4. Extraits de Hervé Deguine, Enquête sur la mort d’André Sibomana, Paris, Reporters sans frontières, 1998, 140 p………………….…..……………….………………………………..50 2.4.1. L’assassinat par un militaire de l’APR du père Curic Vjecko, économe général du diocèse de Kabgayi, in Hervé Deguine, Enquête sur la mort d’André Sibomana, Paris, Reporters sans frontières, 1998, p. 17-28…………………………………………………....52 2.4.2.
    [Show full text]
  • Re-Imagining Rwanda Conflict, Survival and Disinformation in the Late Twentieth Century
    This page intentionally left blank Re-imagining Rwanda Conflict, Survival and Disinformation in the Late Twentieth Century The tragic conflict in Rwanda and the Great Lakes in 1994 to 1996 attracted the horrified attention of the world’s media. Journalists, diplomats and aid workers struggled to find a way to make sense of the bloodshed. Johan Pottier’s troubling study shows that the post-genocide regime in Rwanda was able to impose a simple yet persuasive account of Central Africa’s crises upon international commentators new to the region, and he explains the ideological underpinnings of this official narrative. He also provides a sobering analysis of the way in which this simple, persuasive, but fatally misleading analysis of the situation on the ground led to policy errors that exacerbated the original crisis. Professor Pottier has extensive field experience in the region, from before and after the genocide. JOHAN POTTIER is Professor of Social Anthropology at the School of Oriental and African Studies, University of London. His previous publica- tions include ‘Anthropology of Food: The Social Dynamics of Food Security’ (1999) and ‘Migrants No More: Settlement and Survival in Mambwe Villages, Zambia’ (1988). African Studies Series 102 Editorial Board Dr David Anderson, Department of History, School of Oriental and African Studies, University of London Professor Carolyn Brown, Department of History, Rutgers University, New Jersey Professor Christopher Clapham, Department of Politics and International Relations, Lancaster University Professor Michael Gomez, Department of History, New York University Professor Patrick Manning, Department of History, Northeastern University, Boston Professor David Robinson, Department of History, Michigan State University Professor Leo Villalon, Department of Political Science, University of Kansas Published in collaboration with THE AFRICAN STUDIES CENTRE, CAMBRIDGE A list of books in this series can be found at the end of this volume.
    [Show full text]
  • Annotated Bibliography Primary Sources Articles Meierhenrich, Jens, Et Al
    Annotated Bibliography Primary Sources Articles Meierhenrich, Jens, et al. “Murambi.” Through a Glass Darkly: Genocide Memorials in Rwanda ​ 1994-Present, Harvard Education, 2010, maps.cga.harvard.edu/rwanda/murambi.html ​ This website is part of a research project lead by Harvard that compiled data, photographs and interviews concerning the 1994 Rwandan Genocide to create digital memorials. The Murambi memorial, which this page focuses on, was the site of slaughter for 50,000 Tutsis and today graphically displays the remains of these victims. This page contains 77 original photographs of the memorial as well as interviews from survivors. The source was vital to our research be it revealed the sheer horror of the genocide. ---. “Ntarama.” Through a Glass Darkly: Genocide Memorials in Rwanda 1994-Present, ​ ​ Harvard Education, 2010, http://maps.cga.harvard.edu/rwanda/project.html. “Through a Glass Darkly” is a research project that archived materials from the Rwandan Genocide and made them available to the public digitally. This page focuses on the memorial site at Ntarama. Located in a church, this memorial reveals the brutality of genocide in relation to religion. Churches, thought to be a safe haven were a primary location of massacre during the 100 days. This source led us to investigate the role of the Church in Rwanda’s tragedy. ---. “Nyamata.” Through a Glass Darkly: Genocide Memorials in Rwanda 1994-Present, ​ ​ Harvard Education, 2010, maps.cga.harvard.edu/rwanda/nyamata.html. This source is another piece of the Through a Glass Darkly series which focuses on ​ ​ archiving powerful testaments to genocide on a digital platform. This specific page outlines the massacre at Nyamata, a church located in a region occupied by many Tutsis who had been expelled from prominent cities after the 1959 revolution.
    [Show full text]
  • Consensual Democracy in the Post -Genocide Rwanda: Evaluating the March 2001 District Elections
    "CONSENSUAL DEMOCRACY" IN POST-GENOCIDE RWANDA EVALUATING THE MARCH 2001 DISTRICT ELECTIONS 9 October 2001 Africa report N°34 Nairobi/Brussels TABLE OF CONTENTS EXECUTIVE SUMMARY AND RECOMMENDATIONS.....................................................................i I. INTRODUCTION..............................................................................................................................5 II. CONFLICTING ELECTION OBJECTIVES: DECENTRALISATION AND CONSOLIDATION OF RPF POWER............................................................................................3 A. RPF POLITICAL PHILOSOPHY: TEACHING DEMOCRACY AND NATIONAL UNITY AND IDENTIFYING THE “WISE MEN”.............................................................................................................................................3 B. BREAKING THE GENOCIDAL MACHINERY.................................................................................................5 C. PREPARING FOR THE 2003 NATIONAL ELECTIONS AND BEYOND .............................................................6 III. EXTERNAL AND INTERNAL CONSTRAINTS..........................................................................8 A. THE REGIONAL INSECURITY TRAP ............................................................................................................8 B. INTERNAL POLITICAL TENSIONS...............................................................................................................9 C. THE CHALLENGE OF LIMITED RESOURCES................................................................................................9
    [Show full text]
  • Rwandan Rebel Chief Says Ethnicity Not the Issue
    Rwandan rebel chief says ethnicity not the issue Hartley, Aidan Reuters, April 13, 1994 MULINDI, Rwanda, April 13 (Reuter) - Alexis Kanyarengwe, Hutu chairman of the rebel Rwanda Patriotic Front (RPF), says he wants to end dictatorship and tribal bloodshed in his country racked by civil war. “I am a Hutu – but this is not an ethnic war. It is a war against dictatorship,” Kanyarengwe, 57, told Reuters in his headquarters at Mulindi in the northern hills of the central African country gripped by ethnic bloodshed that has killed tens of thousands of people. Kanyarengwe, whose Tutsi-dominated RPF invaded in 1990 from neighbou- ring Uganda, may soon have a chance to show the world whether he can stop the tribal carnage. His troops have advanced swiftly on Kigali, plunged into chaos when Hutu President Juvenal Habyarimana was killed in a rocket attack on his plane last week, and are engaged in close combat with seemingly demoralised government troops. Kanyarengwe, 57, is an oddity even among his own rebels. He comes from the majority Hutu people while most of the RPF’s 20,000-strong fighters are drawn from the minority Tutsi tribe. “He is soft spoken and doesn’t like confrontation,” said one RPF official of Kanyarengwe, a stocky man with a strong handshake who likes to wear a sporting jockey cap. He is the political leader of a guerrilla movement which has fought on the battlefield and around the negotiating table for RPF aims. These included the overthrow of Habyarimana and the right of tens of thou- sands of refugees exiled by four decades of tribal killing to return home.
    [Show full text]
  • The Arusha Accords and the Failure of International Intervention in Rwanda
    8 The Arusha Accords and the Failure of International Intervention in Rwanda Joel Stettenheim Overview HE PERIOD FOLLOWING an agreement on ending internal conflict can often Tbe even bloodier and more dangerous than the period before the agreement. The Arusha Peace Accords, which ostensibly ended the ongoing conflict in Rwanda between an exiled Tutsi guerrilla group (the Rwandese Patriotic Front) and the Hutu government of President Juvenal Habyarimana, are a tragic ex- ample of a negotiated agreement failing miserably in its implementation.Almost immediately following the signature of the Arusha Accords, Hutu extremists who felt left out of the process and threatened by the results organized a horrific massacre of Tutsi and Hutu moderates. Between 800,000 and one million peo- ple died between April and July 1994. Rather than focusing on the period of the massacre, this chapter examines how the mediation of the Arusha Accords set the stage for what many have de- scribed as genocide. The chapter also highlights the unsuccessful mediation at- tempts leading up to the Arusha Accords;the successful mediation of the Arusha Accords by a highly skilled Tanzanian diplomat, Ami Mpungwe; and the vio- lence following the breakdown of the Accords after the suspicious death of Pres- ident Habyarimana. The role of regional organizations and other international actors in the pre-Arusha mediations and the Arusha process itself is analyzed. The skill of the mediator in pacing the negotiations, focusing the substance of the negotiations, and using connections
    [Show full text]
  • Genocide in Rwanda April-May 1994
    May 1994 Vol. 6, No. 4 GENOCIDE IN RWANDA APRIL-MAY 1994 CONTENTS SYSTEMATIC SLAUGHTER ............................................................................................ 2 THE WORST, BUT NOT THE FIRST MASSACRE....................................................... 3 THE SLAUGHTER BEGINS IMMEDIATELY AFTER THE CRASH........................ 3 THE WAR RESUMES......................................................................................................... 4 THE SELF-PROCLAIMED GOVERNMENT................................................................. 4 EXTENDING THE MASSACRES..................................................................................... 4 NETTOYAGE - CLEANING UP THOSE WHO ARE LEFT........................................ 5 CENTRAL DIRECTION..................................................................................................... 6 RESISTANCE TO THE MASSACRES............................................................................. 6 THOSE WHO CAN HALT THE VIOLENCE................................................................ 6 ABUSES BY THE RWANDAN PATRIOTIC FRONT .................................................. 7 THE SUFFERINGS OF THE DISPLACED...................................................................... 8 RESPONSE OF THE INTERNATIONAL COMMUNITY........................................... 8 The United Nations ............................................................................................... 9 The Diplomatic Community in Kigali .............................................................
    [Show full text]